META Score: An International Consensus Scoring System on Mesh-Tissue Adhesions

BACKGROUND

Currently, the lack of consensus on postoperative mesh-tissue adhesion scoring leads to incomparable scientific results. The aim of this study was to develop an adhesion score recognized by experts in the field of hernia surgery.

METHODS

Authors of three or more previously published articles on both mesh-tissue adhesion scores and postoperative adhesions were marked as experts. They were queried on seven items using a modified Delphi method. The items concerned the utility of adhesion scoring models, the appropriateness of macroscopic and microscopic variables, the range and use of composite scores or subscores, adhesion-related complications and follow-up length. This study comprised two questionnaire-based rounds and one consensus meeting.

RESULTS

The first round was completed by 23 experts (82%), the second round by 18 experts (64%). Of those 18 experts, ten were able to participate in the final consensus meeting and all approved the final proposal. From a total of 158 items, consensus was reached on 90 items. The amount of mesh surface covered with adhesions, tenacity and thickness of adhesions and organ involvement was concluded to be a minimal set of variables to be communicated separately in each future study on mesh adhesions.

CONCLUSION

The MEsh Tissue Adhesion scoring system is the first consensus-based scoring system with a wide backing of renowned experts and can be used to assess mesh-related adhesions. By including this minimal set of variables in future research interstudy comparability and objectivity can be increased and eventually linked to clinically relevant outcomes.

Comparing the behavior of different polypropylene meshes (heavy and lightweight) in an experimental model of ventral hernia repair

New generation prosthetic biomaterials for abdominal wall repair have been designed to be less dense, by having larger pores than that of the standard polypropylene meshes, to improve abdominal wall compliance. The aim of the present study was to analyze the functional and morphologic properties of these new meshes. For this purpose, 7 x 5 cm(2) defects were created in the anterior abdominal wall of 36 male New Zealand White rabbits and repaired using different polypropylene meshes: a heavyweight mesh (HW), Surgipro, and two lightweight meshes (LW), Parietene and Optilene. Six animals each implanted with biomaterial were sacrificed on postoperative days 14 and 90. Histological and morphometric analysis, adhesion assessment, and biomechanical resistance tests were performed. Similar behavior was shown by the LW and HW meshes in terms of the adhesions and macrophage response induced. After 14 days, the tensile strength of Optilene was greater than the strengths recorded for the other two biomaterials, probably because of its high elasticity. By 90 days, however, the tensile strengths of the three biomaterials were comparable. In conclusion, despite an initial tensile strength advantage shown by the mesh with larger pores, at 90 days postimplant, tensile strengths were similar. Compared with HW, LW prostheses have the benefit that less foreign material was implanted, preserving the elasticity of the recipient host tissue.

TGF-beta1 overexpression in the transversalis fascia of patients with direct inguinal hernia

BACKGROUND

The aetiology of inguinal hernia includes changes in collagen turnover and metalloproteinase (MMP) expression, and direct hernia has been linked to increased MMP-2 expression. Since transforming growth factor beta1 (TGFbeta1) plays a role in tissue remodelling, this growth factor could directly affect metalloproteinase secretion and thus the proteolytic activity of these enzymes. We hypothesized that TGFbeta1 expression could also be altered in direct inguinal hernias.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Tissue specimens were obtained from the transversalis fascia (TF) of organ donors (controls; n = 10) and patients with inguinal hernia (indirect; n = 20/direct; n = 20), who were also divided into two groups according to age (20-40/41-60 years). Tissue sections were immunohistochemically labelled using anti-LAP TGFbeta1 (latent form) and anti-TGFbeta1 (active form) antibodies, and fragments of tissue were subjected to Western blot analysis.

RESULTS

No significant differences in LAP-TGFbeta1 expression were detected between specimens from control and hernia patients. However, significantly higher levels of active TGFbeta1 were detected in the TF of patients with direct hernia (P < 0.05). Age affected the expression of the growth factor in its active form, and significant differences emerged between direct hernias and controls/indirect hernias only in the younger age groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings indicate overexpression of the active form of TGFbeta1 in the TF of young patients with direct hernia. This overexpression reflects an attempt to counterbalance the enhanced matrix degradation process observed in these patients, identifying a subset of patients requiring the use of a prosthetic material for primary hernia repair.

Influence of the structure of new generation prostheses on shrinkage after implant in the abdominal wall

When a biomaterial is used to repair an abdominal wall defect, wound contraction can cause the prosthesis to shrink, and the tension generated can provoke recurrence of the defect. This study was designed to determine whether the structure of a prosthesis can directly influence prosthetic shrinkage. Abdominal wall defects (7 x 5 cm) in rabbits were repaired using the laminar prosthesis DualMesh (DM), the composites Sepramesh (Se) and Vypro II (Vy), and the reticular prosthesis Surgipro (PP). The animals were sacrificed 14 and 90 days after surgery, at which time implant specimens were morphologically and immunohistochemically examined to establish the presence of myofibroblasts and macrophages. The size of each prosthesis was measured at the end of the study through image analysis. Morphometric measurements revealed greatest prosthesis shrinkage for Se, PP, and Vy (16.05% +/- 5.08%; 13.75% +/- 4.22%; 16.16% +/- 6.34%), while the DM prostheses only showed a 7.57% +/- 0.62% decrease in size (p < 0.05). In the DM implants, the macrophage response and myofibroblast labeling were reduced. Both biomaterial structure and the macrophage reaction induced at the implant site modulate prosthetic shrinkage, laminar prostheses of the ePTFE type undergoing less shrinkage than reticular meshes. Reduced DM shrinkage was linked to decreased myofibroblast numbers 2 weeks postimplant.

Muscle-derived stem cells in tissue engineering: defining cell properties suitable for construct design

The terms construct or tissue equivalent refer to neotissue produced by tissue engineering techniques. The elements forming the construct are scaffolds on which cells are "recreated" to form an engineered-tissue sensitive to certain cell signals. The ability of the cells to expand and differentiate on the scaffold is determined by properties such as fixation, adhesion, proliferation and migration. Among the cell types that seem to be most promising for designing constructs are tissue-residing, or adult, stem cells, which show two main features: a capacity to differentiate into many cell lineages and the power of self-renewal. These features make them good candidates for cell replacement therapies. Here, we report the identification, isolation and culture of muscle stem cells aimed at establishing the ideal culture in terms of defining when the cultured cell population would show optimal characteristics for transfer to the scaffold to obtain a particular construct. Stem cells harvested from the dorsal muscle of white New Zealand rabbits were cultured in vitro and characterized 5 to 14 days after the start of culture. Fibroblasts obtained from the same experimental animal served as controls. The stem cells were examined by light and scanning electron microscopy. For stem cell identification, we used the antibodies anti-m-cadherin, anti-CD34 and anti-Myf-5. The markers of muscle differentiation used were: anti-vimentin, anti-alpha-actin, anti-desmin and anti-myosin. The expression profiles of the different markers of muscle differentiation and TGFbeta1 in the cell cultures were confirmed by Western blotting. Proliferation rates were determined by monitoring tritiated thymidine incorporation. The thymidine incorporation rate was substantially higher for the population of undifferentiated cells than for control fibroblasts obtained from the same animal. During the first five days of culture, most cells were negative for all the markers examined, with the exception of m-cadherin, CD34 and Myf-5, although discrete signs of vimentin expression started to emerge. After 14 days of culture, the adult stem cells showed vimentin (94.2%) and desmin (33.8%) expression yet scarce labeling for myosin (16.2%) and alpha-actin (8.3%). Control fibroblasts showed intense labeling for vimentin (99.3%) and alpha-actin (62.2%), while less than 2% of the population expressed myosin (0.9%) and desmin (1.6%). After two weeks of culture, muscle-derived stem cells show good proliferative and adhesion properties as they initiate differentiation. These conditions seem ideal for obtaining the desired construct.