Combined petrosal approach: a systematic review and meta-analysis of surgical complications

Transpetrosal approaches are known to be associated with a significant risk of complications, including CSF leak, facial palsy, hearing impairment, venous injury, and/or temporal lobe injury. We aimed to evaluate the morbidity of the standard combined petrosal approach (CPA), defined as a combination of the posterior (retrolabyrinthine) and the anterior petrosal approach. We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of articles reporting on clinical series of patients operated on for petroclival meningiomas through CPA. Studies that used the terminology "combined petrosal approach" without matching the aforementioned definition were excluded as well as clinical series that included less than 5 patients. A total of 8 studies were included involving 160 patients. The pooled complication rates were 3% (95% CI, 0.5-5.6) for CSF leak, 8.6% (95% CI, 4.1-13.2%) for facial palsy, 8.2% (95% CI, 3.9-12.6%) for hearing impairment, 2.8% (95% CI, 0.9-6.5%) for venous complications, and finally 4.8% (95%, 1.2-8.4%) for temporal lobe injury. Contrary to the general belief, CPA is associated with an acceptable rate of complications, especially when compared to alternative approaches to the petroclival area. In view of the major advantages like shorter trajectory, multiple angles of surgical attack, and early tumor devascularization, CPA remains an important tool in the armamentarium of the skull base surgeon.

The Transpetrosal-Ridge Approach: A Modification of the Combined Transpetrosal Approach

Background

Petroclival tumors are formidable challenges for skull base surgeons. Obtaining adequate surgical access is a paramount consideration. Although the combined transpetrosal approach provides a wide surgical corridor, it is technically challenging and, to a degree, morbid. This article describes the transpetrosal-ridge approach, which is a modification of the combined transpetrosal approach with improvements with regards to ease of execution and reduced surgical morbidity.

Methods

The key elements of the transpetrosal-ridge approach are outlined, followed by a detailed description of the steps. The head is placed in the lateral position. After skin incision and muscle elevation, a temporo-suboccipital craniotomy is performed. Middle fossa dura is elevated to the petrous ridge. A limited mastoidectomy is performed with preservation of the semicircular canals. The remaining petrous ridge is then resected and the posterior fossa dura is opened, with the opening extending through the trigeminal dural ring.

Results

Steps of the combined transpetrosal approach that do not contribute to the final surgical corridor are omitted. Extensive mastoid and petrous apex resection is avoided. Posterior fossa dural opening extending through the trigeminal dural ring is a critical step, as it detaches the superior petrosal sinus and sigmoid sinus from the petrous bone. With the retraction of the temporal lobe and the cerebellum and sigmoid sinus, a wide surgical corridor is obtained.

Conclusions

The transpetrosal-ridge approach is a modification of the combined transpetrosal approach with optimization of the operative steps while continuing to provide a wide surgical corridor to the petroclival region.

Intradural Combined Transpetrosal Approach for Primary Pontine Hemorrhage

OBJECTIVE

The standard combined transpetrosal approach (CTPA) is fundamentally an epidural approach that has been quite successfully practiced for many decades. However, it has some disadvantages, such as cosmetic problems, difficulties with custom-tailored petrosectomy, and cerebrospinal fluid leakage, as it is a complicated epidural procedure. We describe here a case of primary pontine hemorrhage via intradural CTPA (iCTPA), which is a modified technique of CTPA and includes intradural anterior petrosectomy and partial posterior petrosectomy without mastoidectomy and skeletonization of the sigmoid sinus.

METHODS

A 63-year-old woman with primary pontine hemorrhage underwent surgery via iCTPA to improve postoperative functional outcomes. After the temporal craniotomy without mastoidectomy and skeletonization of the sigmoid sinus, Kawase's triangle and Trautmann's triangle were identified from the intradural space. Resection of Kawase's triangle and partial resection of Trautmann's triangle were performed to approach the frontotemporal surface of the pons. The hematoma was irrigated and totally removed after corticotomy on the pons.

RESULTS

The postoperative symptoms of the patient improved within 2 weeks without surgical complication.

CONCLUSIONS

The intradural approach allows for custom-tailored petrosectomy and is more straightforward than the epidural route, although it can injure the vein of Labbé. Moreover, it can also reduce cosmetic problems and cerebrospinal fluid leakage. iCTPA could provide enough working space for the frontolateral surface of pontine and petroclival lesions without the need for mastoidectomy and skeletonization of the sigmoid sinus.