The Christmas Miracle of Emil von Behring

The foundation story of immunology is the Christmas miracle of Emil von Behring, whose diphtheria antitoxin was first used to save the life of a child on Christmas Day 1891. Modern scholarship has dismissed it as historically and scientifically implausible: Behring's lab did not have enough antitoxin serum for use in humans, and Ernst von Bergmann had prohibited its use at the Charité.But antitoxin was tried that December by their assistants, Erich Wernicke, who processed injected rams and horses and harvested the serum for Behring, and Heinrich Geissler, who was one of Bergmann's house physicians. Especially during the Christmas season, it is easy to imagine Wernicke and Geissler bypassing protocol and giving the serum a try as a last-ditch effort to save a dying child. Derek Linton, a Behring biographer, wrote:A harried nurse confronted by a dying infant belatedly remembers that a doctor with a promising remedy for diphtheria urged her to bring hopeless cases to his attention and has him roused from his slumber on the other side of Berlin in the middle of the night on December 20, 1891. The injection of his wonder serum then rapidly resuscitates the comatose infant. Five days later, the parents celebrate the most joyous Christmas of their lives with their fully recovered daughter.

[A Japanese in Marburg : Excerpts from the Memories - Jiden - of the Japanese Bacteriologist Taichi Kitashima (1870-1956)]

The heart of this article is the transmission of selected chapters from the Japanese bacteriologist Taichi Kitashima's (1870-1956) autobiographical memoirs (in Japanese, Jiden) published in 1955, in which Kitashima reports on his stay in Marburg in a very personal and subjective way. Like other Japanese physicians of his generation, Kitashima spent several years in Germany in order to work with the serum researcher Emil von Behring and continued his education there. The contact came through Kitashima's teacher Shibasaburô Kitasato, who had worked with Behring in Berlin on questions of immunology. The memoir gives insight into Behring's laboratory work and his relation to his "subordinates". The editors investigate to what extent Kitashima's assessment, made from a distance of fifty years, of his stay in Germany as "wasted time" was accurate, given the advantages that arose from having been part of a vibrant European scientific community, including encounters in the Pasteur Institute in Paris, and why he cultivated his contacts with Germany and the Behring family during National Socialism.