Review of current ECG consumer electronics (pros and cons)

BACKGROUND

Several wearable, medical-grade consumer ECG devices are now available and integrated into consumer electronics like multi sensor fitness watches and scales. Specific consumer ECGs can also come in the form of patches or thin sensor plates in credit card or other shapes. Watches with ECG capabilities are often multi vital sign sensor devices. The majority of these devices are usually connected to a mobile smartphone. However, there are pros and cons to their use.

METHODS

We review here an exemplary selection of modern consumer ECG devices based on device type, recording method and the number of standard ECG channels derived.

RESULTS

Single-channel consumer ECG devices such as Smart Watches can be useful for detecting and monitoring atrial fibrillation and flutter and other arrhythmias, as well as ectopic complexes. However, they are currently limited with respect to recording duration and information content (a single-channel or limb‑lead ECG having less diagnostic information than a 12‑lead ECG). While some non watch-based consumer ECG devices can now record all 6 limb leads to yield increased information, no consumer ECG devices can currently reliably detect ST-segment deviations, potentially indicating myocardial infarction or ischemic episodes. Moreover, barriers to use still exist for at-risk elderly people. Finally, there currently is no universal data exchange format.

CONCLUSION

Consumer ECG devices, whether in fitness or fashionable design, allow for reliable detection of atrial fibrillation. Timely detection of atrial fibrillation and subsequent treatment might protect against stroke, especially in high-risk groups, yet prospective evidence is still lacking. Six-channel consumer ECG and longer data collection capabilities extend potential functionality, including for the monitoring of ST-segments and QT intervals. However, no currently available devices are sufficiently suitable for the detection of myocardial infarction or ischemia, which is why portable 12-channel technologies are desirable. For the reliable detection of a myocardial infarction, the determination of specific myocardial infarction blood markers and evaluation of patient medical history still is indispensable in addition to the 12 lead ECG.

Analysis and postprocessing of ECG or heart rate data from wearable devices beyond the proprietary cloud and app infrastructure of the vendors

Background

The impact of medical-grade wearable electrocardiographic (ECG) recording technology is increasing rapidly. A wide range of different portable smartphone-connected ECG and heart rate trackers is available on the market. Smart ECG devices are especially valuable to monitor either supraventricular arrhythmias or prolonged QT intervals to avoid drug-induced life-threatening arrhythmias. However, frequent false alarms or false-positive arrhythmia results from wearable devices are unwanted. Therefore, for clinical evaluation, it should be possible to measure and evaluate the biosignals of the wearables independent of the manufacturer.

Objective

Unlike radiological devices that do support the universal digital imaging and communications in medicine standard, these medical-grade devices do not yet support a secure standardized exchange pathway between sensors, smartphones/smartwatches, and end services such as cloud storage or universal Web-based application programming interface (API) access. Consequently, postprocessing of recorded ECGs or heart rate interval data requires a whole toolbox of customized software technologies.

Methods/Results

Various methods for measuring and analyzing nonstandardized ECG and heart rate data are proposed, including online measurement of ECG waveforms within a PDF, access to data using manufacturer-specific software development kits, and access to biosignals using modern Web APIs.

Conclusion

With the appropriate workaround, modern software technologies such as JavaScript and PHP allow health care providers and researchers to easily and instantly access necessary and important signal measurements on demand.