Comparison of outcomes of surgical and other invasive treatment modalities for malignant pleural effusion in patients with pleural carcinomatosis

Background

Treatment modalities for malignant pleural effusion (MPE) are diverse. The objectives were to analyze actual clinical data from patients with MPE and pleural carcinomatosis and to compare the outcomes of different treatment modalities with regard to effectiveness, survival, morbidity, and mortality as well as the duration of hospitalization.

Methods

Patients with pathologically proven pleural carcinomatosis or MPE from 2018 to 2020 were included in this retrospective-observational study with additional questionnaires. We identified four treatment modalities: (I) video-assisted thoracic surgery with pleurodesis (VATS, mechanical/chemical); (II) VATS with pleurodesis combined with indwelling pleural catheter (IPC) placement; (III) VATS (without pleurodesis) combined with IPC placement; and (IV) management with IPC placement alone.

Results

We enrolled 91 patients aged 38-90 years who were treated by either VATS-pleurodesis (N=22), VATS-IPC placement (N=21), a combination of VATS with pleurodesis and IPC placement (N=22), or IPC placement alone (N=26). The mean survival time was 138.3 days. No significant differences were detected among treatment groups regarding the outcome of pleurodesis failure, either initially or later. Patients in the VATS-pleurodesis with IPC group experienced significantly more complications than those in the other treatment modality groups [odds ratio (OR): 3.288, P=0.026]. However, no statistically significant differences were observed regarding the type of adverse event and survival. Hypoalbuminemia, systemic therapy, and successful pleurodesis (P=0.008; P=0.011; P=0.044, respectively) were significantly correlated with survival. In multiple linear regression, hypoalbuminemia persisted as an independent predictor of survival (P=0.031). The type of intervention showed significant differences regarding the duration of hospitalization (P=0.017). IPC placement alone shortened the mean total hospitalization time by 7.9, 5.9, and 7.0 days compared to VATS-pleurodesis (P≤0.001), VATS-IPC placement (P=0.004), and VATS-pleurodesis with IPC placement (P≤0.001), respectively.

Conclusions

The survival time was very short, and each treatment group had pros and cons. Therefore, decisions should be made on a case-by-case basis. The use of an IPC, even if the lung is not trapped, can significantly reduce the length of hospital stay. VATS is needed when histology is needed. The ideal method for treating recurrent MPE should be simple, effective, and inexpensive, with minimal disturbance to the patient.

Malignant pleural effusion: current understanding and therapeutic approach

Malignant pleural effusion (MPE) is a common complication of thoracic and extrathoracic malignancies and is associated with high mortality and elevated costs to healthcare systems. Over the last decades the understanding of pathophysiology mechanisms, diagnostic techniques and optimal treatment intervention in MPE have been greatly advanced by recent high-quality research, leading to an ever less invasive diagnostic approach and more personalized management. Despite a number of management options, including talc pleurodesis, indwelling pleural catheters and combinations of the two, treatment for MPE remains symptom directed and centered around drainage strategy. In the next future, because of a better understanding of underlying tumor biology together with more sensitive molecular diagnostic techniques, it is likely that combined diagnostic and therapeutic procedures allowing near total outpatient management of MPE will become popular. This article provides a review of the current advances, new discoveries and future directions in the pathophysiology, diagnosis and management of MPE.

The role of angiogenesis in malignant pleural effusion: from basic research to clinical application

Malignant pleural effusion (MPE) is associated with advanced stages of various malignant diseases, especially lung cancer, and is a poor prognostic indicator in these patients. However, the management of MPE remains palliative. A better understanding of the pathogenesis of MPE may lead to the development of new and more effective therapeutic options. Here, we shed light on recent advances in the mechanisms of MPE formation and provide an overview of current targeted therapies for the vascular endothelial growth factor pathway. We also retrospectively enrolled 19 patients with lung adenocarcinoma from the West China Hospital to analyze the efficacy of bevacizumab for MPE using different routes of administration.

The efficacy of Endostar combined with platinum pleural infusion for malignant pleural effusion in tumor patients is significantly better than that of monotherapy, but the economy is lower: a systematic review, network meta-analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis

Background

Endostar and platinum were widely used in the treatment of malignant pleural effusion (MPE), but there was no unified conclusion on which scheme is the best. The aim of this study was to systematically evaluate the efficacy and cost-effectiveness of Endostar, cisplatin, lobaplatin, Endostar combined with cisplatin, and Endostar combined with lobaplatin in the treatment of MPE so as to provide a reference for clinical treatment.

Methods

A comprehensive literature search was performed of sources on PubMed, Web of Science, and other databases published up to and including November 23, 2021, and screened out randomized controlled trial (RCT) concerning the efficacy of 5 interventions of pleural perfusion for MPE. The Cochrane Collaboration tool was used for assessing the risk of bias, and a network meta-analysis was performed with Addis software based on the Bayesian framework. A decision tree model was used to complete a cost-effectiveness analysis that was based on the direct medical costs and the probabilities were determined from the network meta-analysis. The one-way sensitivity analysis was presented with a tornado chart. In the probabilistic sensitivity analysis, the cost-effectiveness acceptability curve was obtained after Monte Carlo simulation.

Results

A total of 55 studies were included, comprising 3,379 total patients, excluding the unclear part, we evaluated as low risk of bias. According to the network meta-analysis, Endostar combined with lobaplatin had the highest effectiveness, followed by Endostar combined with cisplatin, Endostar, cisplatin, and lobaplatin. In the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) analysis, lobaplatin and Endostar were excluded as inferior schemes. With cisplatin as the comparison, the ICER of Endostar combined with cisplatin was yuan renminbi ¥22,648.31. With Endostar combined with cisplatin as the comparison, the ICER of Endostar combined with lobaplatin was ¥236,502.67. The results of sensitivity analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis were basically consistent.

Conclusions

Endostar combined with lobaplatin had the highest effectiveness, but its ICER was relatively too high to be acceptable. Therefore, cisplatin alone and Endostar combined with cisplatin were more cost-effective, and clinicians can choose the optimal treatment scheme based on the willingness to pay (WTP) of different patients with comprehensive consideration of effectiveness and economy.

Pleural effusions associated with squamous cell lung carcinoma have a low diagnostic yield and a poor prognosis

Background

Malignant pleural effusion (MPE) portends a poor prognosis in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). However, the yield of pleural fluid cytology as well as survival of patients with MPE associated with squamous cell carcinoma versus adenocarcinoma is not well understood. We conducted this study to assess the diagnostic yield of pleural cytology and survival of patients with NSCLC related MPE.

Methods

We performed a single-center, retrospective analysis of patients with NSCLC related MPE between 2010 and 2017. Kaplan-Meier method was used to compare survival and Cox proportional hazards analysis to assess if squamous cell cytopathology was associated with mortality.

Results

We identified 277 patients, 29 with squamous cell and 248 with adenocarcinoma MPE. Pleural fluid cytology from initial thoracentesis was diagnostic in 13.8% (4/29) patients with squamous cell and 80.2% (199/248) with adenocarcinoma (P<0.001). Cytology from second thoracentesis was diagnostic in 13.3% (2/15) patients with squamous cell carcinoma, compared to 37.5% (12/32) with adenocarcinoma (P=0.17). There was no statistically significant difference in the pleural biopsy yield from medical pleuroscopy or video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) in the two groups. The median survival of patients with squamous cell MPE was 112 [interquartile range (IQR): 44-220] days versus 194 (IQR: 54-523) days in adenocarcinoma (Log-rank test P=0.04). Multivariate Cox proportional hazards analysis showed that squamous cell cytopathology was independent predictor of mortality (hazard ratio for death of 1.73, 95% CI: 1.1-2.6; P=0.01).

Conclusions

Pleural fluid cytology has a low diagnostic yield in squamous cell carcinoma MPE, and these patients have a poor survival compared to lung adenocarcinoma.

Video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery pleurectomy: a suitable alternative for treating malignant pleural effusions

Background

Malignant pleural effusions (MPEs) are common manifestations of metastatic cancers and are associated with a dismal prognosis. Talc pleurodesis has been proven to be effective in the management of MPEs, however, class-action lawsuits linking talc to ovarian adenocarcinoma have rendered it unavailable at many institutions. As a result, surgeons have resorted to less effective chemical pleurodesis as an alternative to indwelling pleural drainage catheters. Given the absence of talc, we explored the effectiveness of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) partial pleurectomy (VPP) for treating MPEs.

Methods

We performed a retrospective review of patients with MPEs managed after talc became unavailable at our institution. Between 2016 and 2018, we identified five patients who refused pleural drainage catheters and underwent VPP. Symptoms at presentation included fatigue, dyspnea, and pleuritic chest pain. All had unilateral MPEs (left n=3, right n=2). VPP included removal of parietal surfaces of the pleura other than the pleura overlying the subclavian vessels, the mediastinum, and the lung viscera.

Results

There were no significant perioperative adverse events and post-operative pain was well controlled. Chest tubes were removed between post-operative day (POD) 3 and 7. Follow-up time ranged from four to 36 weeks. All patients had symptomatic relief and radiographic evidence of improved MPEs. No patients required re-interventions. One patient expired six months after surgery while the remaining four were alive at last follow-up.

Conclusions

VPP offers an effective alternative to chemical pleurodesis for managing MPEs in patients who prefer to avoid pleural drainage catheters.

Intrathoracic infusion therapy with Lentinan and chemical irritants for malignant pleural effusion: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 65 randomized controlled trials

BACKGROUND

Aderivative of Shiitake mushrooms, Lentinan is used to control malignant pleural effusion (MPE) through intrathoracic infusion.

PURPOSE

To determine the clinical response, survival and safety of Lentinan plus chemical irritants, and the optimal combinations with chemical irritants, indication, threshold and optimal regimen for achieving the desired responses.

STUDY DESIGN

We performed a new systematic review and meta-analysis following the PRISMA guidelines.

METHODS

We collected all randomized controlled trials (RCTs) regarding Lentinan plus chemical irritants from Chinese and English electronic databases (from inception until March 2019). We evaluated their bias risk, synthesized data using meta-analysis, and summarized evidence quality following the Grades of Recommendation Assessment, Development and Evaluation approach.

RESULTS

We included 65 RCTs involving 4,080 patients and nine chemical irritants. Most trials had unclear bias risk. Lentinan with cisplatin significantly improved complete response [Risk ratio (RR) = 1.68, 95% confidence intervals (CI) (1.51 to 1.87), p < 0.00001, Fig.3a] and quality of life [RR = 1.51 95% CI (1.41 to 1.62), p < 0.00001, Fig.4], and decreased the risk of treatment failure, myelosuppression, gastrointestinal reaction, and chest pain. For patients with moderate to large volume of the pleural effusion, primary treatment, KPS score ≥ 50-60, or anticipated survival time ≥ 3months, Lentinan (3-4 mg/time, once a week for three to four times) withcisplatin (30-40 mg/m2 or 50-60 mg/m2) significantly improved complete response and decreased failure. Most results were robust and moderate quality.

CONCLUSION

The results suggest that Lentinan with chemical irritants, especially cisplatin is beneficial to the patient with MPE, and provide evidence for the indication, threshold, and optimal regimen that may achieve success and decrease failure.

Manometry performed at indwelling pleural catheter insertion to predict unexpandable lung

Background

The finding of unexpandable lung (UL) at an early timepoint is of increasing importance in guiding treatment decisions in patients with malignant pleural effusion (MPE). Pleural manometry is the most common technique to delineate UL, however it has never been measured via an indwelling pleural catheter (IPC). To further the evidence base we analysed all patients in the IPC-PLUS study who had manometry performed during IPC insertion for the ability to predict substantial UL using manometry.

Methods

All patients enrolled in IPC-PLUS who had manometry performed at IPC insertion and radiographic assessment of UL at day 10 were included. Elastance curves were visually inspected for each patient. Initial pleural pressure, closing pleural pressure, and terminal elastance were analysed for their differences and predictive ability in those with substantial UL, defined as ≥25% entrapment on chest radiography.

Results

A total of 89 patients had manometry performed at IPC insertion with subsequent radiographic assessment of UL and interpretable elastance curves. Those with substantial UL had a significantly lower median closing pleural pressure (-15.00 vs. 0.00 cmH₂O, P=0.012) and higher terminal elastance (12.03 vs. 8.59 cmH₂O/L, P=0.021) compared to a combined group with no or partial UL. However, the predictive ability of these factors to discriminate substantial UL was poor, with areas under the receiver operating characteristic curves of 0.695 and 0.680 for closing pleural pressure and elastance respectively.

Conclusions

Our results suggest that manometry is not useful in accurately predicting substantial UL when used via an IPC at the time of insertion.

Multimodal approach to the management of malignant pleural effusions: role of thoracoscopy with pleurodesis and tunneled indwelling pleural catheters

Malignant pleural effusion (MPE) is associated with a median survival of 3–6 months and causes significant symptoms affecting the overall quality of life in patients with advanced malignancies. Despite the high incidence of recurrent MPE, less than 25% of patients undergo a definitive pleural intervention as recommended by guidelines. In this review, we summarize the latest guidelines for management of MPE by various societies and discuss a multimodal approach in these patients using thoracoscopy with pleurodesis using talc insufflation and placement of tunneled indwelling pleural catheters (TIPC). We also address the role of diagnostic thoracoscopy for histologic and molecular diagnosis and outline our approach to patients with known or suspected MPE.

Differential diagnosis between lymphoma-associated malignant pleural effusion and tuberculous pleural effusion

Background

Lymphoma-associated malignant pleural effusions (L-MPE) can mimic tuberculous pleural effusion (TPE) characterized by lymphocytic exudate with high adenosine deaminase (ADA) levels. Furthermore, the low cytological yield of L-MPE makes differentiation between L-MPE and TPE more challenging. However, there are few data regarding differential diagnosis of L-MPE and TPE.

Methods

All consecutive patients diagnosed with L-MPE or TPE between January 2011 and December 2016 were retrospectively recruited using the Electronic Medical Record database. Clinical symptoms and laboratory and pleural fluid data [including serum lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), C-reactive protein, and pleural fluid ADA levels] were compared between L-MPE and TPE. Useful variables in the differential diagnosis of L-MPE and TPE were evaluated by multivariate logistic regression analysis.

Results

Seventeen patients with L-MPE and 216 patients with TPE were included in this study. In the multivariate analysis, fever was negatively associated with L-MPE [odds ratio (OR): 0.175, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.033-0.941, P=0.042], while serum LDH levels were positively associated with L-MPE (OR: 1.005, 95% CI: 1.003-1.007, P<0.001). Serum LDH >460 U/L provided a sensitivity of 76% and a specificity of 81% to distinguish L-MPE and TPE. In contrast, serum C-reactive protein and pleural fluid ADA levels were not significantly different between the groups.

Conclusions

Patients with L-MPE and TPE present very similar clinical, laboratory, and pleural fluid characteristics. Fever and serum LDH levels may be helpful in guiding the differential diagnosis of L-MPE and TPE. Lymphoma should be kept in mind in the differential diagnosis in patients with lymphocytic pleural effusion and high ADA levels.

Making cold malignant pleural effusions hot: driving novel immunotherapies

Malignant pleural effusions, arising from either primary mesotheliomas or secondary malignancies, heralds advanced disease and poor prognosis. Current treatments, including therapeutic thoracentesis and tube thoracostomy, are largely palliative. The immunosuppressive environment within the pleural cavity includes myeloid derived suppressor cells, T-regulatory cells, and dysfunctional T cells. The advent of effective immunotherapy with checkpoint inhibitors and adoptive cell therapies for lung cancer and other malignancies suggests a renewed examination of local and systemic therapies for this malady. Prior strategies reporting remarkable success, including instillation of the cytokine interleukin-2, perhaps coupled with checkpoint inhibitors, should be further evaluated in the modern era.

Diagnostic benefits of the combined use of liquid-based cytology, cell block, and carcinoembryonic antigen immunocytochemistry in malignant pleural effusion

Background

Malignant pleural effusion (MPE) is a common complication of cancer cell metastasis to the pleura. Discrimination between MPE and benign pleural effusion is necessary to design treatment strategies. Cytology is important for the diagnosis of MPE. Carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) is an epithelial biomarker with a strong staining pattern in adenocarcinomas. Here, the diagnostic performances of liquid-based cytology (LBC), cell block (CB) preparation, and CEA immunostaining for the detection of malignancy in effusion cytology were compared in a large case series.

Methods

In a single institution, 1,014 cytology samples from 862 patients were retrospectively collected and reviewed between January 2013 and November 2015. Ethanol-fixed, paraffin embedded CB of pleural effusions was analyzed by CEA immunostaining. Diagnostic values were compared among LBC, CB, CEA immunostaining, and the combination of two methods.

Results

The sensitivity and specificity of the CB preparation were 94.3% and 98.7%, respectively, compared with 81.3% and 99.4% for LBC preparations, respectively. Combination of LBC and CB increased sensitivity by 98.3%. Although the accuracy of CEA staining itself was moderate (sensitivity, 89.8%), the combined use of CB and CEA tumor marker increased the detection rate of malignancy (sensitivity, 100%; specificity, 100%), compared with that of cytology (LBC or CB) alone.

Conclusions

The sensitivity and specificity for the diagnosis of MPE could be improved by integrating the CB and CEA staining into LBC in routine clinical practice to improve diagnostic accuracy.

Diagnosis and management of malignant pleural effusions: state of the art in 2017

Malignant pleural effusion (MPE) is a known complication of both thoracic and extra thoracic malignancies. The presence of MPE regardless of the primary site translates into advanced stage disease. Diagnosis and management of MPE with the goals of palliation and improving quality of life poses a challenge for chest physicians. Recently, multiple studies have made attempts to answer questions regarding optimal management in various clinical scenarios. We will review the current evidence and available options for the management of MPE.

Patient evaluation for rapid pleurodesis of malignant pleural effusions

BACKGROUND

Malignant pleural effusions (MPEs) represent advanced stage disease with potentially significant patient discomfort due to dyspnea. Palliative management options include repetitive thoracenteses, placement of a tunneled pleural catheter (TPC), chemical pleurodesis, or some combination of these procedures. The rapid pleurodesis procedure combines thoracoscopic talc pleurodesis and insertion of a TPC at the same time with the goals of reducing both the length of hospitalization and the duration of catheter use. The rapid pleurodesis procedure has previously been described to achieve both of these goals in a pilot study of 30 patients with fully expandable lungs. Both symptoms of dyspnea and quality of life improved with few complications. Additional data on procedural effectiveness is needed to optimize patient selection for this procedure.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of patients who had undergone rapid pleurodesis protocol at two academic institutions over a 40-month period. Data was collected and analyzed on time to removal of the TPC, chemotherapy, malignancy type, complications, age, and catheter occlusion.

RESULTS

A total of 29 patients underwent the rapid pleurodesis protocol with a median hospital length of stay of 2 days. Total length of hospitalization was not significantly different between patients with and without primary lung cancer. Median duration of the indwelling TPC was 10 days. Patients with primary lung cancer and those actively or recently undergoing chemotherapy maintained the catheter longer than their counterparts.

CONCLUSIONS

The rapid pleurodesis protocol should be considered a viable treatment option for select patients with symptomatic recurrent MPEs undergoing chemical pleurodesis.

Malignant pleural effusion and algorithm management

Involvement of the pleura in lung cancer is a common manifestation accompanying with reduced life expectancy. Symptoms relief and improvement of the quality of life are the primary goals of the management of malignant pleural effusion (MPE). Histological confirmation is essential for optimal patient management. Lung cancer patients, with life expectancy more than 3 months, resistant to chemotherapy should be treated with thoracentesis, intercoastal tube drainage and installation of a sclerosant agent or pleurodesis through thoracospopic procedures or placement of an indwelling pleura catheter. Talc pleurodesis (sterile asbestos-free graded, particle size >15 μm), as "poudrage" or "slurry" still remains the treatment of choice in patients with MPE resistant to chemotherapy.