Analysis of Factors and Medical Errors Involved in Patient Complaints in a European Emergency Department

Introduction

Patients' complaints from Emergency Departments (ED) are frequent and can be used as a quality assurance indicator.

Objective

Factors contributing to patients' complaints (PCs) in the emergency department were analyzed.

Methods

It was a retrospective cohort study, the qualitative variables of patients' complaints visiting ED of a university hospital were compared with Chi-Square and t test tests.

Results

Eighty-five PC were analyzed. The factors contributing to PC were: communication (n=26), length of stay (LOS) (n=24), diagnostic errors (n=21), comfort and privacy issues (n=7), pain management (n=6), inappropriate treatment (n=6), delay of care and billing issues (n=3). PCs were more frequent when patients were managed by residents, during night shifts, weekends, Saturdays, Mondays, January and June. Moreover, the factors contributing to diagnostic errors were due to poor communication, non-adherence to guidelines and lack of systematic proofreading of X-rays. In 98% of cases, disputes were resolved by apology and explanation and three cases resulted in financial compensation.

Conclusion

Poor communication, LOS and medical errors are factors contributing to PCs. Improving communication, resolving issues leading to slow health care provision, adequate staffing and supervision of trainees may reduce PCs.

Analysis of Factors and Medical Errors Involved in Patient Complaints in a European Emergency Department

INTRODUCTION

Patients' complaints from Emergency Departments (ED) are frequent and can be used as a quality assurance indicator.

OBJECTIVE

Factors contributing to patients' complaints (PCs) in the emergency department were analyzed.

METHODS

It was a retrospective cohort study, the qualitative variables of patients' complaints visiting ED of a university hospital were compared with Chi-Square and t test tests.

RESULTS

Eighty-five PC were analyzed. The factors contributing to PC were: communication (n=26), length of stay (LOS) (n=24), diagnostic errors (n=21), comfort and privacy issues (n=7), pain management (n=6), inappropriate treatment (n=6), delay of care and billing issues (n=3). PCs were more frequent when patients were managed by residents, during night shifts, weekends, Saturdays, Mondays, January and June. Moreover, the factors contributing to diagnostic errors were due to poor communication, non-adherence to guidelines and lack of systematic proofreading of X-rays. In 98% of cases, disputes were resolved by apology and explanation and three cases resulted in financial compensation.

CONCLUSION

Poor communication, LOS and medical errors are factors contributing to PCs. Improving communication, resolving issues leading to slow health care provision, adequate staffing and supervision of trainees may reduce PCs.