Reducing Postoperative CT Imaging for Children With Complicated Appendicitis: A Pediatric Surgical Quality Collaborative Quality Improvement Project

BACKGROUND

Despite widespread initiatives to reduce ionizing radiation for appendicitis diagnosis, computed tomography (CT) scanning postoperatively remains common. The Pediatric Surgery Quality Collaborative (PSQC) aimed to identify differences between children's hospitals with high and low postoperative CT usage for complicated appendicitis.

METHODS

Using National Surgery Quality Improvement Program Pediatric data from PSQC children's hospitals, we compared postoperative CT imaging for complicated appendicitis (April 2020-March 2021). Key stakeholders from 11 hospitals (5 low CT utilization, 6 high CT utilization) participated in semi-structured interviews regarding postoperative imaging. Qualitative analysis of transcripts was performed deductively and inductively based on the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF).

RESULTS

Five of twelve TDF domains were most prominent in influencing CT use: skills, beliefs about capabilities, intentions/goals, memory and decision processes, and environment. Children's hospitals with lower rates of postoperative CT use tended to: trust and educate the ultrasound technicians; believe US strengths outweigh weaknesses; image no sooner than 7 days postoperatively; have access to sufficient quality improvement resources; maintain trusting relationships between specialties; and prioritize radiation stewardship.

CONCLUSION

Hospitals at extremes of postoperative CT use for complicated appendicitis reveal strategies for improvement, which include imaging protocol development and adherence, quality improvement resource availability, interdisciplinary collaboration, and promoting radiation stewardship.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level V.

A Magnetic Resonance Imaging Protocol for the Evaluation of Pediatric Postappendectomy Abscess: A Quality Improvement Project

INTRODUCTION

Computed tomography (CT) scans are often used when cross-sectional imaging is required for evaluation of postappendectomy abscess, exposing children to a source of ionizing radiation. Our aim was to decrease the use of CT scans in pediatric postappendectomy patients by 50% in 12 mo and to sustain those results for 1 y.

METHODS

A comprehensive magnetic resonance imaging protocol was introduced in 2018 at a tertiary children's hospital within a general health system to replace CT scans in suspected pediatric postappendectomy abscess. Diagnostic and clinical outcomes were compared preprotocol (2015-2017) and postprotocol (2018-2022) implementation using standard univariate statistics. P < 0.05 was considered significant. Quality improvement methodology was used to design and implement the protocol.

RESULTS

Sixty eight pediatric postappendectomy patients received cross-sectional imaging during the study period. Overall, CT scans were used exclusively (100%, n = 27) in the preimplementation period compared to 31.7% (n = 13) of cross-sectional imaging in the postimplementation period. However, in the first year of protocol implementation, CT scan use only decreased to 78% of cross-sectional studies performed. The majority of protocol deviations (54%) also occurred in this time period. With improved education and reinforcement, CT scan utilization decreased to approximately 24% of cross-sectional studies annually. Missed abscess rate, time to diagnosis, drainage procedure type, readmission, and reoperation were similar between preimplementation and postimplementation periods.

CONCLUSIONS

Implementation of a postappendectomy abscess magnetic resonance imaging protocol was associated with decreased CT utilization in the pediatric population, while maintaining comparable diagnostic evaluation and clinical outcomes. Adherence to quality improvement principles facilitated achieving goals and sustaining gains.

Sustaining the gains: Reducing unnecessary computed tomography scans in pediatric trauma patients

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

"Pan-scanning" pediatric blunt trauma patients leads to exposure to harmful radiation and increased healthcare costs without improving outcomes. We aimed to reduce computed tomography (CT) scans that are not indicated (NI) by imaging guidelines for injured children.

METHODS

In July 2017, our Pediatric Trauma Center prospectively implemented validated imaging guidelines to direct CT imaging for trauma activations and consultations for children younger than 16 years old with blunt traumatic injuries. Patients with suspected physical abuse, CT imaging prior to arrival, penetrating mechanism, and instability precluding CT imaging were excluded. We compared CT scanning rates for pre-implementation (01/2016-06/2017) and post-implementation (07/2017-08/2021) time periods. Guideline compliance was evaluated by chart review and sustained through iterative process improvement cycles.

RESULTS

During the pre-implementation era, 61 patients underwent 171 CT scans of which 87 (51%) scans were not indicated by guidelines. Post-implementation, 363 patients had 531 scans and only 134 (25%) CTs were not indicated. Total CTs performed declined after initiation of guidelines (2.80 vs 1.46 scans/patient, p<0.0001). Total NI CTs declined (1.41 vs 0.37 NI scans/patient, p<0.0001) reflected in significant reductions in all anatomic regions: head, cervical spine, chest, and abdomen/pelvis. Charges related to NI scans decreased from $1,490.31/patient to $408.21/patient, saving $218,000 in charges. Based on prior utilization, 146 children were spared excessive radiation with no clinically significant missed injuries since guideline implementation.

CONCLUSIONS

Quality improvement and implementation science methodologies to enhance compliance with imaging guidelines for children with blunt injuries can significantly reduce unnecessary CT scanning without compromising care. This practice reduces harmful radiation exposure in a sensitive patient population and may save healthcare systems money and resources.

Influence of symptom duration and WBC profile on the negative predictive value of a nondiagnostic ultrasound in children with suspected appendicitis

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to explore the combined negative predictive value (NPV) of symptom duration and WBC profile in children with a nondiagnostic ultrasound (US) for appendicitis.

METHODS

This was a retrospective analysis of children with suspected appendicitis at a single children's hospital from 1/2010 to 3/2018. NPVs based on WBC profile and symptom duration at presentation were calculated individually and combined for children with a nondiagnostic US.

RESULTS

2277 patients were included, of which 1018 (44.7%) had a nondiagnostic US. The NPV of a nondiagnostic US ranged from 83.7% with ≤24 h of symptoms to 94.5% with >72 h of symptoms (p < 0.01). NPV also differed significantly across WBC profiles, ranging from 76.8% when WBC profile was elevated to 97.3% to when WBC profile was normal (p < 0.01). The range of NPVs for a nondiagnostic US was even greater when combining symptom duration and WBC profile, ranging from 73.7% for patients with 24-48 h of symptoms and an elevated WBC profile to 100% for patients with >72 h of symptoms and a normal WBC profile.

CONCLUSIONS

Incorporation of symptom duration and WBC profile significantly improves the accuracy and clinical utility of the negative predictive value associated with a nondiagnostic ultrasound.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Study of diagnostic test level II: development of diagnostic criteria in a consecutive series of patients and a universally applied gold standard.