Biomechanical Comparison of Dart-Throw Motions after Partial Wrist Fusions

Background  Multiple partial wrist fusions exist for the management of arthritic disease. Limited information is available on their effect on wrist range of motion in the dart-throwing direction of wrist motion, even though it is used in most activities of daily living. Purpose  The purpose of this study was to measure the retained motion for different orientations of dart-throwing motion for seven different partial wrist fusions and proximal row carpectomy (PRC). Methods  Eight fresh frozen right cadavers were tested with the wrist intact and followed simulated fusions. Fusions were performed using an external fixation technique and included scaphocapitate, scapholunate (SL), capitolunate, radiolunate, radioscapholunate, scaphotrapeziotrapezoid, 4 corner fusion, and PRC. Results  In the intact wrist, the average arc of wrist motion with the wrist oriented at 20 degrees away from the flexion-extension axis was significantly larger than at any other orientation of motion. All partial wrist fusions and the PRC had significantly smaller average dart-throw arc of motion compared with intact at an orientation 20 and 25 degrees away from flexion-extension. The SL fusion provided a significantly larger arc of motion than most of the other fusions at most orientations. Conclusion/Clinical Relevance  This study provides a comprehensive compilation of the range of motion in a functional plane, "the dart-throw motion," for limited wrist fusions and PRC. These data provide the clinician with important information that can be used to educate patients regarding expectations after surgery.

Analysis of a New Artificial Muscle Type Dynamic Orthosis for Wrist Joint Disease Using a Three-dimensional Motion Analyzer

Objectives:

Recently, the dart-throwing motion (DTM) has attracted attention as a functional direction of wrist joint motion. Consequently, we devised a new artificial muscle-type dynamic orthosis (Dynamic Traction Splint by Artificial Muscle, DTSaM) to reproduce DTM. This study analyzed the automatic motion of the wrist joint using a three-dimensional motion analysis system to assess how closely the DTSaM replicates DTM.

Methods:

The DTSaM orthosis incorporates two McKibben-type rubber artificial muscles, and measurements were performed using image analysis software and a three-dimensional motion analysis system. The wrist radial angle (WRA) was defined as the angle between the line connecting the head of the index finger metacarpal to the radial styloid process and the line connecting the radial styloid process to the lateral epicondyle of the humerus. WRAs were investigated from 60° of palmar flexion to 60° of dorsiflexion.

Results:

For dorsiflexion, comparisons of radial deviation and wrist ulnar angle (WUA) between the motion obtained using the DTSaM orthosis and active DTM showed a significant difference (P <0.05) at 30° and 60°, respectively. For palmar flexion, the same comparison showed a significant difference for both the ulnar and radial deviations (30°, P <0.05; and 60°, P <0.01, respectively). Furthermore, WUA showed a significant difference at 50° (P <0.05). Intraclass correlation coefficient analyses yielded good reliability with an average value of ≥0.8.

Conclusion:

The DTSaM orthosis produces a motion similar to the DTM. It is hoped that the use of the DTSaM orthosis will help to shorten the treatment period for patients with wrist disease.

There is motion between the scaphoid and the lunate during the dart-throwing motion

Scaphoid and lunate mobility has been suggested to be minimal during the dart-throwing motion in studies based on serial computed tomography (CT) scans and cadaver studies. This study analyzes the direct motion between the scaphoid and the lunate during the dart-throwing motion in vivo. We examined nine individuals with standard CT scans of the wrist in radial extension and ulnar flexion. The paired CT scans were analyzed with a volume registration technique. The lunate was registered as fixed and the scaphoid as the mobile element. The motion of the scaphoid relative the lunate between the positions of radial extension and ulnar flexion was measured. There was considerable motion between the scaphoid and the lunate with both a distal to proximal translation and rotation during the dart-throwing motion, regardless of whether the scapholunate ligament was intact or not. These results suggest that aggressive dart-throwing exercises should not be implemented early on during rehabilitation following scapholunate repair.

Biomechanical Effects of Radioscapholunate Fusion With Distal Scaphoidectomy and Triquetrum Excision on Dart-Throwing and Wrist Circumduction Motions

PURPOSE

Distal scaphoid and triquetrum excisions can improve the range of wrist motion after radioscapholunate (RSL) fusion, but little is known about the kinematics of dart-throwing and global circumduction motions. We hypothesized that these excisions could increase the range of motion without causing midcarpal instability.

METHODS

Seven fresh-frozen cadaver upper extremities were mounted on a testing apparatus after isolation and preloading of the tendons of the flexor carpi radialis, flexor carpi ulnaris, extensor carpi radialis, and extensor carpi ulnaris. Sequential loadings of the flexor carpi ulnaris and extensor carpi radialis simulated active dart-throwing motion. Passive circumferential loading produced the wrist circumduction motion. We measured the range of wrist motions with an electromagnetic tracking system in 4 experiments: intact, simulated RSL fusion, RSL fusion with distal scaphoid excision, and RSL fusion with distal scaphoid and total triquetrum excisions. To evaluate midcarpal stability, we conducted passive mobility testing of the distal carpal row in the radial, volar, ulnar, and dorsal directions.

RESULTS

Radioscapholunate fusion decreased the dart-throwing motion to a mean of 46% of the baseline value; distal scaphoid and triquetrum excisions increased the mean arc to 50% and 62%, respectively. Radioscapholunate fusion diminished the wrist circumduction to a mean of 43% of the baseline value, which increased to a mean of 58% and 74% after distal scaphoid and triquetrum excision, respectively. A significant increase in radial deviation was noted after distal scaphoid excision, and subsequent triquetrum excision significantly increased motion in the ulnar-palmar direction. Regarding midcarpal stability, dorsal translation significantly increased after distal scaphoid and triquetrum excisions.

CONCLUSIONS

Distal scaphoid and triquetrum excision after RSL fusion improved both dart-throwing and circumduction motions, but dorsal midcarpal instability occurred.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Subsequent carpal excisions may improve short-term outcome by increasing motions in a RSL-fused wrist; however, a potential risk of midcarpal instability should be considered.

Functional Dart-Throwing Motion: A Clinical Comparison of Four-Corner Fusion to Radioscapholunate Fusion Using Inertial Motion Capture

Background  Dart-throwing motion (DTM) is an important functional arc of the wrist from radial extension to ulna flexion. An aim of partial fusion surgery of the wrist is to maintain maximal functional motion while addressing the pathology. The radioscapholunate (RSL) fusion, accompanied with partial resection of the distal scaphoid, is thought to allow better DTM than other partial wrist fusions such as the four-corner fusion (4CF). Question  Does an RSL fusion allow better functional DTM than 4CF, and how does this range compare with healthy wrists and the patient's contralateral wrist? Patients and Methods  Patients who have undergone an RSL fusion or 4CF at our tertiary center were identified and invited to present to have their DTM arc measured. To accurately measure DTM, a previously validated inertial measurement device was used. Patient's functional DTM arc was measured in both unrestrained (elbow and shoulder free to move) and restrained (elbow and shoulder immobilized) fashions. This was compared with their contralateral wrist and a group of healthy control volunteers. Results  Overall five RSL fusions, 10 4CF and 24 control patients were enrolled in the study. There was no significant difference between functional DTM when 4CF and RSL fusion were compared. Both had significantly reduced functional DTM arc than control patients. There was no significant difference between the operated wrist compared with the patient's contralateral unoperated wrist. Conclusion  RSL fusion is not significantly better at maintaining functional DTM when compared with 4CF. Both surgeries result in decreased functional DTM arc when compared with control patients. This is a cohort study and reflects a level of evidence IV. Level of Evidence  This is a Leve IV, cohort study.

International Federation of Societies for Surgery of the Hand 2013 Committee's report on wrist dart-throwing motion

This report updates information on wrist dart-throwing (DT) motion, based on the most recent research published on the kinematics, kinetics, and clinical applications of DT motion. A wide range of DT planes exists. "Pure" DT motion is done along an oblique plane that intercepts the coronal and sagittal planes at the zero position, and occurs almost exclusively at the midcarpal joint with near zero scaphoid and lunate motion. "Functional" DT motion such as a hammering is done along an oblique plane that is almost parallel to the pure DT plane, but that has an offset toward the dorsal side. Functional DT rotation has greater scaphoid and lunate motion compared with pure DT motion. Midcarpal arthrodesis adversely affects DT motion compared with radiocarpal arthrodesis. During a DT motion, the mean and peak tendon forces of the flexor carpi ulnaris and the extensor carpi radialis longus were the greatest among wrist motors. By performing a task along the plane of DT motion, the scapholunate (SL) joint was stable and SL ligament elongation was minimal in healthy subjects. However, a more recent study of patients with SL dissociation revealed that DT exercises applied tensile forces on the SL ligament and induced an SL gap.

Dart-throwing motion in patients with scapholunate instability: a dynamic four-dimensional computed tomography study

When the normal wrist rotates along the 'dart-throwing' plane, the proximal row remains still, with most motion occurring at the midcarpal joint. Whether this behaviour is maintained when the scapholunate ligaments are torn is not known. If this is the case, patients having a scapholunate ligament repair could benefit from early dart-throwing exercises without the risk of pulling the sutures apart. Using dynamic computer tomography, we analysed the carpal behaviour of six normal wrists and six wrists with scapholunate instability during dart-throwing motion. In the normal wrists, the scaphoid and lunate did not flex or extend, but translated along the frontal plane an average 5.9 and 5.6 mm, respectively. When the scapholunate ligaments were torn, the scaphoid shifted towards the radial styloid considerably more than the lunate (12.8 mm versus 4.8 mm; p = 0.005), inducing a scapholunate gap. Based on these findings, we cannot recommend dart-throwing exercises after scapholunate ligament repair, unless the joint is stabilized with wires or screws.