Expert review: preeclampsia Type I and Type II

Pregnancy involves an interplay between maternal and fetal factors affecting changes to maternal anatomy and physiology to support the developing fetus and ensure the well-being of both the mother and offspring. A century of research has provided evidence of the imperative role of the placenta in the development of preeclampsia. Recently, a growing body of evidence has supported the adaptations of the maternal cardiovascular system during normal pregnancy and its maladaptation in preeclampsia. Debate surrounds the roles of the placenta vs the maternal cardiovascular system in the pathophysiology of preeclampsia. We proposed an integrated model of the maternal cardiac-placental-fetal array and the development of preeclampsia, which reconciles the disease phenotypes and their proposed origins, whether placenta-dominant or maternal cardiovascular system-dominant. These phenotypes are sufficiently diverse to define 2 distinct types: preeclampsia Type I and Type II. Type I preeclampsia may present earlier, characterized by placental dysfunction or malperfusion, shallow trophoblast invasion, inadequate spiral artery conversion, profound syncytiotrophoblast stress, elevated soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase-1 levels, reduced placental growth factor levels, high peripheral vascular resistance, and low cardiac output. Type I is more often accompanied by fetal growth restriction, and low placental growth factor levels have a measurable impact on maternal cardiac remodeling and function. Type II preeclampsia typically occurs in the later stages of pregnancy and entails an evolving maternal cardiovascular intolerance to the demands of pregnancy, with a moderately dysfunctional placenta and inadequate blood supply. The soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase-1-placental growth factor ratio may be normal or slightly disturbed, peripheral vascular resistance is low, and cardiac output is high, but these adaptations still fail to meet demand. Emergent placental dysfunction, coupled with an increasing inability to meet demand, more often appears with fetal macrosomia, multiple pregnancies, or prolonged pregnancy. Support for the notion of 2 types of preeclampsia observable on the molecular level is provided by single-cell transcriptomic survey of gene expression patterns across different cell classes. This revealed widespread dysregulation of gene expression across all cell types, and significant imbalance in fms-like tyrosine kinase-1 (FLT1) and placental growth factor, particularly marked in the syncytium of early preeclampsia cases. Classification of preeclampsia into Type I and Type II can inform future research to develop targeted screening, prevention, and treatment approaches.

Proteomic profile of extracellular vesicles in maternal plasma of women with fetal death

OBJECTIVES

Fetal death is a complication of pregnancy caused by multiple etiologies rather than being the end-result of a single disease process. Many soluble analytes in the maternal circulation, such as hormones and cytokines, have been implicated in its pathophysiology. However, changes in the protein content of extracellular vesicles (EVs), which could provide additional insight into the disease pathways of this obstetrical syndrome, have not been examined. This study aimed to characterize the proteomic profile of EVs in the plasma of pregnant women who experienced fetal death and to evaluate whether such a profile reflected the pathophysiological mechanisms of this obstetrical complication. Moreover, the proteomic results were compared to and integrated with those obtained from the soluble fraction of maternal plasma.

METHODS

This retrospective case-control study included 47 women who experienced fetal death and 94 matched, healthy, pregnant controls. Proteomic analysis of 82 proteins in the EVs and the soluble fractions of maternal plasma samples was conducted by using a bead-based, multiplexed immunoassay platform. Quantile regression analysis and random forest models were implemented to assess differences in the concentration of proteins in the EV and soluble fractions and to evaluate their combined discriminatory power between clinical groups. Hierarchical cluster analysis was applied to identify subgroups of fetal death cases with similar proteomic profiles. A p-value of <.05 was used to infer significance, unless multiple testing was involved, with the false discovery rate controlled at the 10% level (q < 0.1). All statistical analyses were performed by using the R statistical language and environment-and specialized packages.

RESULTS

Nineteen proteins (placental growth factor, macrophage migration inhibitory factor, endoglin, regulated upon activation normal T cell expressed and presumably secreted (RANTES), interleukin (IL)-6, macrophage inflammatory protein 1-alpha, urokinase plasminogen activator surface receptor, tissue factor pathway inhibitor, IL-8, E-Selectin, vascular endothelial growth factor receptor 2, pentraxin 3, IL-16, galectin-1, monocyte chemotactic protein 1, disintegrin and metalloproteinase domain-containing protein 12, insulin-like growth factor-binding protein 1, matrix metalloproteinase-1(MMP1), and CD163) were found to have different plasma concentrations (of an EV or a soluble fraction) in women with fetal death compared to controls. There was a similar pattern of change for the dysregulated proteins in the EV and soluble fractions and a positive correlation between the log₂-fold changes of proteins significant in either the EV or the soluble fraction (ρ = 0.89, p < .001). The combination of EV and soluble fraction proteins resulted in a good discriminatory model (area under the ROC curve, 82%; sensitivity, 57.5% at a 10% false-positive rate). Unsupervised clustering based on the proteins differentially expressed in either the EV or the soluble fraction of patients with fetal death relative to controls revealed three major clusters of patients.

CONCLUSION

Pregnant women with fetal death have different concentrations of 19 proteins in the EV and soluble fractions compared to controls, and the direction of changes in concentration was similar between fractions. The combination of EV and soluble protein concentrations revealed three different clusters of fetal death cases with distinct clinical and placental histopathological characteristics.

The great obstetrical syndromes and the placenta

Although historically pre-eclampsia, preterm birth, abruption, fetal growth restriction and stillbirth have been viewed as clinically distinct entities, a growing body of literature has demonstrated that the placenta and its development is the root cause of many cases of these conditions. This has led to the term 'the great obstetrical syndromes' being coined to reflect this common origin. Although these conditions mostly manifest in the second half of pregnancy, a failure to complete deep placentation (the transition from histiotrophic placentation to haemochorial placenta at 10-18 weeks of gestation via a second wave of extravillous trophoblast invasion), is understood to be key to the pathogenesis of the great obstetrical syndromes. While the reasons that the placenta fails to achieve deep placentation remain active areas of investigation, maternal inflammation and thrombosis have been clearly implicated. From a clinical standpoint these mechanisms provide a biological explanation of how low-dose aspirin, which affects the COX-1 receptor (thrombosis) and the COX-2 receptor (inflammation), prevents not just pre-eclampsia but all the components of the great obstetrical syndromes if initiated early in pregnancy. The optimal dose of low-dose aspirin that is maximally effective in pregnancy remains a question open for further research. Additionally, other candidate medications have been identified that may also prevent pre-eclampsia, and further study of them may offer therapeutic options beyond low-dose aspirin. Interestingly, three of the eight identified compounds (hydroxychloroquine, metformin and pravastatin) are known to decrease inflammation.

Molecular subclasses of preeclampsia characterized by a longitudinal maternal proteomics study: distinct biomarkers, disease pathways and options for prevention

OBJECTIVES

The heterogeneous nature of preeclampsia is a major obstacle to early screening and prevention, and a molecular taxonomy of disease is needed. We have previously identified four subclasses of preeclampsia based on first-trimester plasma proteomic profiles. Herein, we expanded this approach by using a more comprehensive panel of proteins profiled in longitudinal samples.

METHODS

Proteomic data collected longitudinally from plasma samples of women who developed preeclampsia (n=109) and of controls (n=90) were available from our previous report on 1,125 proteins. Consensus clustering was performed to identify subgroups of patients with preeclampsia based on data from five gestational-age intervals by using select interval-specific features. Demographic, clinical, and proteomic differences among clusters were determined. Differentially abundant proteins were used to identify cluster-specific perturbed KEGG pathways.

RESULTS

Four molecular clusters with different clinical phenotypes were discovered by longitudinal proteomic profiling. Cluster 1 involves metabolic and prothrombotic changes with high rates of early-onset preeclampsia and small-for-gestational-age neonates; Cluster 2 includes maternal anti-fetal rejection mechanisms and recurrent preeclampsia cases; Cluster 3 is associated with extracellular matrix regulation and comprises cases of mostly mild, late-onset preeclampsia; and Cluster 4 is characterized by angiogenic imbalance and a high prevalence of early-onset disease.

CONCLUSIONS

This study is an independent validation and further refining of molecular subclasses of preeclampsia identified by a different proteomic platform and study population. The results lay the groundwork for novel diagnostic and personalized tools of prevention.

An integrated model of preeclampsia: a multifaceted syndrome of the maternal cardiovascular-placental-fetal array

Maternal tolerance of the semiallogenic fetus necessitates conciliation of competing interests. Viviparity evolved with a placenta to mediate the needs of the fetus and maternal adaptation to the demands of pregnancy and to ensure optimal survival for both entities. The maternal-fetal interface is imagined as a 2-dimensional porous barrier between the mother and fetus, when in fact it is an intricate multidimensional array of tissues and resident and circulating factors at play, encompassing the developing fetus, the growing placenta, the changing decidua, and the dynamic maternal cardiovascular system. Pregnancy triggers dramatic changes to maternal hemodynamics to meet the growing demands of the developing fetus. Nearly a century of extensive research into the development and function of the placenta has revealed the role of placental dysfunction in the great obstetrical syndromes, among them preeclampsia. Recently, a debate has arisen questioning the primacy of the placenta in the etiology of preeclampsia, asserting that the maternal cardiovascular system is the instigator of the disorder. It was the clinical observation of the high rate of preeclampsia in hydatidiform mole that initiated the focus on the placenta in the etiology of the disease. Over many years of research, shallow trophoblast invasion with deficient remodeling of the maternal spiral arteries into vessels of higher capacitance and lower resistance has been recognized as hallmarks of the preeclamptic milieu. The lack of the normal decrease in uterine artery resistance is likewise predictive of preeclampsia. In abdominal pregnancies, however, an extrauterine pregnancy develops without remodeling of the spiral arteries, yet there is reduced resistance in the uterine arteries and distant vessels, such as the maternal ophthalmic arteries. Proponents of the maternal cardiovascular model of preeclampsia point to the observed maternal hemodynamic adaptations to pregnancy and maladaptation in gestational hypertension and preeclampsia and how the latter resembles the changes associated with cardiac disease states. Recognition of the importance of the angiogenic-antiangiogenic balance between placental-derived growth factor and its receptor soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase-1 and disturbance in this balance by an excess of a circulating isoform, soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase-1, which competes for and disrupts the proangiogenic receptor binding of the vascular endothelial growth factor and placental-derived growth factor, opened new avenues of research into the pathways to normal adaptation of the maternal cardiovascular and other systems to pregnancy and maladaptation in preeclampsia. The significance of the "placenta vs heart" debate goes beyond the academic: understanding the mutuality of placental and maternal cardiac etiologies of preeclampsia has far-reaching clinical implications for designing prevention strategies, such as aspirin therapy, prediction and surveillance through maternal hemodynamic studies or serum placental-derived growth factor and soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase-1 testing, and possible treatments to attenuate the effects of insipient preeclampsia on women and their fetuses, such as RNAi therapy to counteract excess soluble fms-like tyrosine kinase-1 produced by the placenta. In this review, we will present an integrated model of the maternal-placental-fetal array that delineates the commensality among the constituent parts, showing how a disruption in any component or nexus may lead to the multifaceted syndrome of preeclampsia.

Preeclampsia and eclampsia: the conceptual evolution of a syndrome

Preeclampsia, one of the most enigmatic complications of pregnancy, is considered a pregnancy-specific disorder caused by the placenta and cured only by delivery. This article traces the condition from its origins-once thought to be a disease of the central nervous system, recognized by the occurrence of seizures (ie, eclampsia)-to the present time when preeclampsia is conceptualized primarily as a vascular disorder. We review the epidemiologic data that led to the recommendation to use diastolic hypertension and proteinuria as diagnostic criteria, as their combined presence was associated with an increased risk of fetal death and the birth of small-for-gestational-age neonates. However, preeclampsia is a multisystemic disorder with protean manifestations, and the condition can be present even in the absence of hypertension and proteinuria. Toxins gaining access to the maternal circulation have been proposed to mediate the clinical manifestations-hence, the term "toxemia of pregnancy," which was used for several decades. The search for putative toxins has challenged investigators for more than a century, and a growing body of evidence suggests that products of an ischemic or a stressed placenta are responsible for the vascular changes that characterize this syndrome. The discovery that the placenta can produce antiangiogenic factors, which regulate endothelial cell function and induce intravascular inflammation, has been a major step forward in the understanding of preeclampsia. We view the release of antiangiogenic factors by the placenta as an adaptive response to improve uterine perfusion by modulating endothelial function and maternal cardiovascular performance. However, this homeostatic response can become maladaptive and lead to damage of target organs during pregnancy or the postpartum period. Early-onset preeclampsia has many features in common with atherosclerosis, whereas late-onset preeclampsia seems to result from a mismatch of fetal demands and maternal supply, that is, a metabolic crisis. Preeclampsia, as it is understood today, is essentially vascular dysfunction unmasked or caused by pregnancy. A subset of patients diagnosed with preeclampsia are at greater risk of the subsequent development of hypertension, ischemic heart disease, heart failure, vascular dementia, and end-stage renal disease. However, these adverse events may be the result of a preexisting vascular pathologic process; it is not known if the occurrence of preeclampsia increases the baseline risk. Therefore, the understanding, prediction, prevention, and treatment of preeclampsia are healthcare priorities.

Long-Term Consequences of Placental Vascular Pathology on the Maternal and Offspring Cardiovascular Systems

Over the last thirty years, evidence has been accumulating that Hypertensive Disorders of Pregnancy (HDP) and, specifically, Preeclampsia (PE) produce not only long-term effects on the pregnant woman, but have also lasting consequences for the fetus. At the core of these consequences is the phenomenon known as defective deep placentation, being present in virtually every major obstetrical syndrome. The profound placental vascular lesions characteristic of this pathology can induce long-term adverse consequences for the pregnant woman’s entire arterial system. In addition, placental growth restriction and function can, in turn, cause a decreased blood supply to the fetus, with long-lasting effects. Women with a history of HDP have an increased risk of Cardiovascular Diseases (CVD) compared with women with normal pregnancies. Specifically, these subjects are at a future higher risk of: Hypertension; Coronary artery disease; Heart failure; Peripheral vascular disease; Cerebrovascular accidents (Stroke); CVD-related mortality. Vascular pathology in pregnancy and CVD may share a common etiology and may have common risk factors, which are unmasked by the “stress” of pregnancy. It is also possible that the future occurrence of a CVD may be the consequence of endothelial dysfunction generated by pregnancy-induced hypertension that persists after delivery. Although biochemical and biophysical markers of PE abound, information on markers for a comparative evaluation in the various groups is still lacking. Long-term consequences for the fetus are an integral part of the theory of a fetal origin of a number of adult diseases, known as the Barker hypothesis. Indeed, intrauterine malnutrition and fetal growth restriction represent significant risk factors for the development of chronic hypertension, diabetes, stroke and death from coronary artery disease in adults. Other factors will also influence the development later in life of hypertension, coronary and myocardial disease; they include parental genetic disposition, epigenetic modifications, endothelial dysfunction, concurrent intrauterine exposures, and the lifestyle of the affected individual.

Killer-cell immunoglobulin-like receptor/human leukocyte antigen-C combination and 'great obstetrical syndromes' (Review)

Recurrent pregnancy loss (RPL), pre-eclampsia (PE), fetal growth restriction (FGR), and preterm delivery are examples of ‘great obstetrical syndromes’ (GOS). Placental dysfunction is the most common pathogenesis of GOS. In human pregnancies, the effects of uterine natural killer cells involve angiogenesis, promoting the remodeling of uterine spiral artery, and improving the invasion of trophoblast cells. The uNK cells supply killer immunoglobulin-like receptors (KIRs), which come into contact with human leukocyte antigen-C (HLA-C) ligands expressed by extravillous trophoblast cells (EVTs). Numerous studies have investigated the association between GOS and KIR/HLA-C combination. However, the outcomes have not been conclusive. The present review aimed to reveal the association between GOS and KIR/HLA-C combination to screen out high-risk pregnancies, strengthen the treatment of pregnancy complications, and reduce the frequency of adverse maternal and fetal outcomes. It has been reported that a female with a KIR AA genotype and a neonate with a paternal HLA-C2 molecule is more prone to develop GOS and have a small fetus since less cytokines were secreted by uNK cells. Conversely, the combination of KIR BB haplotype (including the activating KIR2DS1) and HLA-C2 can induce the production of cytokines and increase trophoblast invasion, leading to the birth of a large fetus. KIR/HLA-C combinations may be applicable in selecting third-party gametes or surrogates. Detection of maternal KIR genes and HLA-C molecules from the couple could serve as useful markers for predicting and diagnosing GOS.

Antibiotic administration reduces the rate of intraamniotic inflammation in preterm prelabor rupture of the membranes

BACKGROUND

Preterm prelabor rupture of the membranes (PPROM) is frequently complicated by intraamniotic inflammatory processes such as intraamniotic infection and sterile intraamniotic inflammation. Antibiotic therapy is recommended to patients with PPROM to prolong the interval between this complication and delivery (latency period), reduce the risk of clinical chorioamnionitis, and improve neonatal outcome. However, there is a lack of information regarding whether the administration of antibiotics can reduce the intensity of the intraamniotic inflammatory response or eradicate microorganisms in patients with PPROM.

OBJECTIVE

The first aim of the study was to determine whether antimicrobial agents can reduce the magnitude of the intraamniotic inflammatory response in patients with PPROM by assessing the concentrations of interleukin-6 in amniotic fluid before and after antibiotic treatment. The second aim was to determine whether treatment with intravenous clarithromycin changes the microbial load of Ureaplasma spp DNA in amniotic fluid.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective cohort study included patients who had (1) a singleton gestation, (2) PPROM between 24+0 and 33+6 weeks, (3) a transabdominal amniocentesis at the time of admission, and (4) intravenous antibiotic treatment (clarithromycin for patients with intraamniotic inflammation and benzylpenicillin/clindamycin in the cases of allergy in patients without intraamniotic inflammation) for 7 days. Follow-up amniocenteses (7^th day after admission) were performed in the subset of patients with a latency period lasting longer than 7 days. Concentrations of interleukin-6 were measured in the samples of amniotic fluid with a bedside test, and the presence of microbial invasion of the amniotic cavity was assessed with culture and molecular microbiological methods. Intraamniotic inflammation was defined as a bedside interleukin-6 concentration ≥745 pg/mL in the samples of amniotic fluid. Intraamniotic infection was defined as the presence of both microbial invasion of the amniotic cavity and intraamniotic inflammation; sterile intraamniotic inflammation was defined as the presence of intraamniotic inflammation without microbial invasion of the amniotic cavity.

RESULTS

A total of 270 patients with PPROM were included in this study: 207 patients delivered within 7 days and 63 patients delivered after 7 days of admission. Of the 63 patients who delivered after 7 days following the initial amniocentesis, 40 underwent a follow-up amniocentesis. Patients with intraamniotic infection (n = 7) and sterile intraamniotic inflammation (n = 7) were treated with intravenous clarithromycin. Patients without either microbial invasion of the amniotic cavity or intraamniotic inflammation (n = 26) were treated with benzylpenicillin or clindamycin. Treatment with clarithromycin decreased the interleukin-6 concentration in amniotic fluid at the follow-up amniocentesis compared to the initial amniocentesis in patients with intraamniotic infection (follow-up: median, 295 pg/mL, interquartile range [IQR], 72-673 vs initial: median, 2973 pg/mL, IQR, 1750-6296; P = .02) and in those with sterile intraamniotic inflammation (follow-up: median, 221 pg/mL, IQR 118-366 pg/mL vs initial: median, 1446 pg/mL, IQR, 1300-2941; P = .02). Samples of amniotic fluid with Ureaplasma spp DNA had a lower microbial load at the time of follow-up amniocentesis compared to the initial amniocentesis (follow-up: median, 1.8 × 10⁴ copies DNA/mL, 2.9 × 10⁴ to 6.7 × 10⁸ vs initial: median, 4.7 × 10⁷ copies DNA/mL, interquartile range, 2.9 × 10³ to 3.6 × 10⁷; P = .03).

CONCLUSION

Intravenous therapy with clarithromycin was associated with a reduction in the intensity of the intraamniotic inflammatory response in patients with PPROM with either intraamniotic infection or sterile intraamniotic inflammation. Moreover, treatment with clarithromycin was related to a reduction in the load of Ureaplasma spp DNA in the amniotic fluid of patients with PPROM <34 weeks of gestation.

Gestational diabetes as one of the "great obstetrical syndromes"--the maternal, placental, and fetal dialog

Gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM)-associated fetal and neonatal adverse outcome results from the metabolic milieu projected on the fetus via the placental interface. Therefore, it can be considered to be one of the great obstetrical syndromes. Placentas from GDM pregnancies differ from nondiabetic pregnancies by an increased placental to fetal ratio and by histological findings such as villous fibrinoid necrosis, villous immaturity, chorangiosis, and ischemic changes. While early onset diabetes is more associated with marked structural changes of the placenta, GDM that rises at late gestation is associated more with placental functional changes. These placental changes, causing increased intervillous diffusion distance of immature villi and placental size to perfusion mismatch, may predispose the fetus to chronic and acute changes in gas and nutrient exchange thus turning the placenta from being a "fetus protector" to a potential source of adverse outcome. Understanding placental changes and how they affect outcome is necessary in order to develop effective screening, prevention, and management approaches.