Comparative effectiveness of influenza vaccines among U.S. Medicare beneficiaries ages 65 years and older during the 2019-20 season

BACKGROUND

Around 50,000 influenza-associated deaths occur annually in the U.S., overwhelmingly among individuals ages >65 years. Although vaccination is the primary prevention tool, investigations have shown low vaccine effectiveness (VE) in recent years, particularly among the elderly. We analyzed the relative VE (RVE) of all influenza vaccines among Medicare beneficiaries ages >65 years to prevent influenza hospital encounters during the 2019-20 season.

METHODS

Retrospective cohort study using Poisson regression and inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW). Exposures included egg-based high-dose trivalent (HD-IIV3), egg-based adjuvanted trivalent (aIIV3), egg-based standard dose (SD) quadrivalent (IIV4), cell-based SD quadrivalent (cIIV4), and recombinant quadrivalent (RIV4) influenza vaccines.

RESULTS

We studied 12.7 million vaccinated beneficiaries. Following IPTW, cohorts were well balanced for all covariates and health-seeking behavior indicators. In the adjusted analysis, RIV4 (RVE 13.3%, 95% CI 7.4%, 18.9%), aIIV3 (RVE 8.2%, 95% CI 4.2%, 12.0%), and HD-IIV3 (RVE 6.8%, 95% CI 3.3%, 10.1%) were significantly more effective in preventing hospital encounters than the reference egg-based SD IIV4, while cIIV4 was not significantly more effective than IIV4 (RVE 2.8%, 95% CI -2.8%, 8.2%). Our results were consistent across all analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

In this influenza B-Victoria and A(H1N1)-dominated season, RIV4 was moderately more effective than other vaccines, while the HD-IIV3 and aIIV3 were more effective than the IIV4 vaccines, highlighting the contributions of antigen amount and adjuvant use to VE. Egg adaptation likely did not substantially affect our RVE evaluation. Our findings, specific to the 2019-20 season, should be evaluated in other studies using virological case confirmation.