The history of Japanese lung transplantation: the unique pathway to establishing the program and its initial success

Japan is a unique country in terms of organ transplantation. Despite the impressive progress in transplant medicine achieved during the late 20th century in many Western countries, Japan was unable to implement a program for organ transplants from brain-dead donors due to persistent public distrust regarding the ethical understanding of "brain death as human death". In 1997, the Japanese Organ Transplant Law was enacted, and organ transplantation from brain-dead donors was finally legalized. However, this law was strongly opposed by religious leaders, philosophers, politicians, and even medical personnel who did not accept the idea that brain death is human death, so transplant physicians had to start performing transplants in the face of strong social resistance. The Japanese National Lung Transplant System was established based on the following three philosophies: (I) an institutional certification system based on strict standards; (II) a rigorous central monitoring system for transplant results; and (III) a third-party review system to determine eligibility for patient registration. The purpose of these policies was to avoid ethical issues at lung transplant institutes, and to achieve high-quality transplant results. The actual progress of Japanese lung transplantation has been quite unusual compared to other countries. The number of brain-dead organ donations was extremely limited at first, so more than 60% of lung transplants were performed as living-donor transplants during the first 9 years [1998-2006]. The number of brain-dead donations subsequently increased, particularly after the revision of the Organ Transplant Law in 2010 such that the majority of lung transplants are now performed as brain-dead transplantations. Regarding the results of lung transplants, the most recent national registry report indicated that a total of 668 lung transplants including 447 from brain-dead donors and 221 from living donors, had been performed as of 2018. The 5- and 10-year survival rates for brain-dead donor lung transplantation were 71.9% and 57.8%, respectively, with no significant difference between the living-donor and brain-dead-donor groups. These results are comparable with the outcome of preceding programs in the US and European countries.

Organ Donation in Croatia: The Importance of a National Champion, a Comprehensive Plan, and International Collaborations

The Republic of Croatia is a global leader in organ donation and transplantation despite having fewer resources and more modest healthcare expenditures than other countries in the European Union. The results of an extensive literature review were combined with expert input in an iterative multi-step data collection and evaluation process designed to assess trends in Croatian organ donation and transplantation and identify key elements, policy changes, and drivers of the system that have contributed to its success. Multiple sources of evidence were used in this study, including primary documents, national and international transplantation reports, and insights from critical informants and content experts. The results highlight several key organizational reforms that have substantially improved the performance of the Croatian transplant program. Our findings emphasize the importance of strong central governance led by an empowered national clinical leader acting under the direct auspices of the Ministry of Health and a comprehensive and progressive national plan. The Croatian transplant system is notable for its integrated approach and efficient manner of managing scarce health resources. Collectively, the results suggest that Croatia has become nearly self-sufficient due to its systematic implementation of the guiding principles for organ donation and transplantation.

A Conceptual Framework for Evaluating National Organ Donation and Transplantation Programs

Conceptual frameworks are valuable resources that can be used to guide the planning, evaluation, and development of healthcare services. However, there are currently no comprehensive frameworks focused on organ donation and transplantation that identify the critical factors underlying a successful national program. To address this knowledge gap, we developed a conceptual framework that takes into account all major domains of influence, including political and societal aspects as well as clinical implementation. The framework was initially constructed based on a targeted review of the relevant medical literature. Feedback provided by a panel of international experts was incorporated into the framework via an iterative process. The final framework features 16 essential domains that are critical for initiating and maintaining a successful program and improving the health of patients with organ failure. Of particular note, these domains are subject to three overarching health system principles: responsiveness, efficiency, and equity. This framework represents a first attempt to develop a whole-system view of the various factors that contribute to the success of a national program. These findings provide a useful tool that can be adapted to any jurisdiction and used to plan, evaluate, and improve organ donation and transplantation programs.

How to Structure a Successful Organ Donation and Transplantation System in Eight (Not So Easy) Steps: An Italian Case Study

Valuable information can be obtained from a systematic evaluation of a successful national transplant program. This paper provides an overview of Italy's solid organ transplantation program which is coordinated by the National Transplant Network (Rete Nazionale Trapianti) and The National Transplant Center (Centro Nazionale Trapianti). The analysis is based on a system-level conceptual framework and identifies components of the Italian system that have contributed to improving rates of organ donation and transplantation. A narrative literature review was conducted and the findings were validated iteratively with input from subject matter experts. The results were organized into eight critical steps, including 1) generating legal definitions of living and deceased donation, 2) taking steps to ensure that altruistic donation and transplantation become part of the national culture and a point of pride, 3) seeking out existing examples of successful programs, 4) creating a situation in which it is easy to become a donor, 5) learning from mistakes, 6) working to diminish risk factors that lead to the need for organ donation, 7) increasing the rate of donations and transplantations via innovative strategies and policies, and 8) planning for a system that supports growth.

The National Organ Donation and Transplantation Program in Greece: Gap Analysis and Recommendations for Change

Greece has fallen far behind many comparable European countries in the field of organ donation and transplantation and has made little progress over the past decade. Despite efforts to improve its organ donation and transplantation program, systemic problems persist. In 2019, the Onassis Foundation commissioned a report to be prepared by the London School of Economics and Political Science that focused on the state of the Greek organ donation and transplantation program and proposed recommendations for its improvement. In this paper, we present our analysis of the Greek organ donation and transplantation program together with an overview of our specific recommendations. The analysis of the Greek program was undertaken in an iterative manner using a conceptual framework of best practices developed specifically for this project. Our findings were further developed via an iterative process with information provided by key Greek stakeholders and comparisons with case studies that featured successful donation and transplantation programs in Croatia, Italy, Portugal, Spain, and the United Kingdom. Because of their overall complexity, we used a systems-level approach to generate comprehensive and far-reaching recommendations to address the difficulties currently experienced by the Greek organ donation and transplantation program.