An evolutionary divergent thermodynamic brake in ZAP-70 fine-tunes the kinetic proofreading in T cells

T cell signaling starts with assembling several tyrosine kinases and adaptor proteins to the T cell receptor (TCR), following the antigen-binding to the TCR. The stability of the TCR-antigen complex and the delay between the recruitment and activation of each kinase determines the T cell response. Integration of such delays constitutes a kinetic proofreading mechanism to regulate T cell response to the antigen binding. However, the mechanism of these delays is not fully understood. Combining biochemical experiments and kinetic modelling, here we report a thermodynamic brake in the regulatory module of the tyrosine kinase ZAP-70, which determines the ligand selectivity, and may delay the ZAP-70 activation upon antigen binding to TCR. The regulatory module of ZAP-70 comprises of a tandem SH2 (tSH2) domain that binds to its ligand, doubly-phosphorylated ITAM peptide (ITAM-Y2P), in two kinetic steps: a fast step and a slow step. We show the initial encounter complex formation between the ITAM-Y2P and tSH2 domain follows a fast-kinetic step, whereas the conformational transition to the holo-state follows a slow-kinetic step. We further observed a thermodynamic penalty imposed during the second phosphate-binding event reduces the rate of structural transition to the holo-state. Phylogenetic analysis revealed the evolution of the thermodynamic brake coincides with the divergence of the adaptive immune system to the cell-mediated and humoral responses. In addition, the paralogous kinase Syk expressed in B cells does not possess such a functional thermodynamic brake, which may explain the higher basal activation and lack of ligand selectivity in Syk.

Differences in the dynamics of the tandem-SH2 modules of the Syk and ZAP-70 tyrosine kinases

The catalytic activity of Syk-family tyrosine kinases is regulated by a tandem Src homology 2 module (tSH2 module). In the autoinhibited state, this module adopts a conformation that stabilizes an inactive conformation of the kinase domain. The binding of the tSH2 module to phosphorylated immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motifs necessitates a conformational change, thereby relieving kinase inhibition and promoting activation. We determined the crystal structure of the isolated tSH2 module of Syk and find, in contrast to ZAP-70, that its conformation more closely resembles that of the peptide-bound state, rather than the autoinhibited state. Hydrogen-deuterium exchange by mass spectrometry, as well as molecular dynamics simulations, reveal that the dynamics of the tSH2 modules of Syk and ZAP-70 differ, with most of these differences occurring in the C-terminal SH2 domain. Our data suggest that the conformational landscapes of the tSH2 modules in Syk and ZAP-70 have been tuned differently, such that the autoinhibited conformation of the Syk tSH2 module is less stable. This feature of Syk likely contributes to its ability to more readily escape autoinhibition when compared to ZAP-70, consistent with tighter control of downstream signaling pathways in T cells.

ZAP70 activation is an early event of T cell immunity that involved in the anti-bacterial adaptive immune response of Nile tilapia

ZAP70 is essential for initiating the early events of T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) signaling cascade to ensure proper T cell activation and function. However, whether this molecule takes part in the T cell immune response of early vertebrates remains unclear. In the present study, using a teleost model Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus), we investigated the potential involvement of ZAP70 in the T cell activation and adaptive immunity of fish species. Both primary and tertiary structures of O. niloticus ZAP70 (On-ZAP70) are highly conserved with those from other vertebrates. On-ZAP70 protein was widely expressed in lymphoid tissues, and with the highest level in thymus. Once Nile tilapia was infected by Aeromonas hydrophila, mRNA of On-ZAP70 in spleen lymphocytes was induced on day 5 and 8 after infection; meanwhile, phosphorylation of On-ZAP70 was also enhanced, suggesting that On-ZAP70 potentially participated in primary adaptive immune response of Nile tilapia. Furthermore, the frequency of ZAP70 positive lymphocytes was increased during the anti-bacterial adaptive immune response. More importantly, when spleen lymphocytes were activated by T cell specific mitogen PHA, a dramatical augment of On-ZAP70 could be observed at transcription, phosphorylation and cellular level, indicating the involvement of this molecule in T cells activation of Nile tilapia. Altogether, our results demonstrated that ZAP70 activation is an early event of T cell immunity that involved in the anti-bacterial adaptive immune response of Nile tilapia, and thus provided a new evidence to understand the evolution of the lymphocyte-mediated adaptive immunity.

T cell receptor-dependent S-acylation of ZAP-70 controls activation of T cells

ZAP-70 is a tyrosine kinase essential for T cell immune responses. Upon engagement of the T cell receptor (TCR), ZAP-70 is recruited to the specialized plasma membrane domains, becomes activated, and is released to phosphorylate its laterally segregated targets. A shift in ZAP-70 distribution at the plasma membrane is recognized as a critical step in TCR signal transduction and amplification. However, the molecular mechanism supporting stimulation-dependent plasma membrane compartmentalization of ZAP-70 remains poorly understood. In this study, we identified previously uncharacterized lipidation (S-acylation) of ZAP-70 using Acyl-Biotin Exchange assay, a technique that selectively captures S-acylated proteins. We found that this posttranslational modification of ZAP-70 is dispensable for its enzymatic activity. However, the lipidation-deficient mutant of ZAP-70 failed to propagate the TCR pathway suggesting that S-acylation is essential for ZAP-70 interaction with its protein substrates. The kinetics of ZAP-70 S-acylation were consistent with TCR signaling events indicating that agonist-induced S-acylation is a part of the signaling mechanism controlling T cell activation and function. Taken together, our results suggest that TCR-induced S-acylation of ZAP-70 can serve as a critical regulator of T cell-mediated immunity.

An improved flow cytometric method using FACS Lysing Solution for measurement of ZAP-70 expression in B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia

BACKGROUND

B-cell expression of ZAP-70, normally expressed in T and NK cells, correlates with poor prognosis in B-CLL. Poor discrimination between ZAP-70 positive and negative cells hampers routine application of flow cytometry. We examined the usefulness of FACS Lysing Solution.

METHODS

ZAP-70 expression in 65 healthy volunteers was measured by four-color flow cytometry, comparing FACS Lysing Solution for fixation and permeabilization with the Fix & Perm kit. Separation between ZAP-70 positive T cells and negative B cells was based on a ratio of median ZAP-70 staining of T cells to B cells. In 25 B-CLL patients, ZAP-70 expression was estimated using the lower limit of the fluorescence range corresponding with 98% of ZAP-70 positive T cells as threshold marker as well as a ratio of B-CLL cell to internal T-cell median ZAP-70 staining.

RESULTS

Use of FACS Lysing Solution resulted in approximately fourfold increased separation between ZAP-70 positive T cells and negative B cells, when compared with the Fix & Perm kit. In B-CLL samples, ZAP-70 negative and positive B-cell expression could be clearly discerned.

CONCLUSIONS

FACS Lysing Solution is a simple procedure that markedly improves discrimination between ZAP-70 positive and negative cells.

Structural basis for the inhibition of tyrosine kinase activity of ZAP-70

ZAP-70, a cytoplasmic tyrosine kinase required for T cell antigen receptor signaling, is controlled by a regulatory segment that includes a tandem SH2 unit responsible for binding to immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motifs (ITAMs). The crystal structure of autoinhibited ZAP-70 reveals that the inactive kinase domain adopts a conformation similar to that of cyclin-dependent kinases and Src kinases. The autoinhibitory mechanism of ZAP-70 is, however, distinct and involves interactions between the regulatory segment and the hinge region of the kinase domain that reduce its flexibility. Two tyrosine residues in the SH2-kinase linker that activate ZAP-70 when phosphorylated are involved in aromatic-aromatic interactions that connect the linker to the kinase domain. These interactions are inconsistent with ITAM binding, suggesting that destabilization of this autoinhibited ZAP-70 conformation is the first step in kinase activation.

ZAP70 in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia

The protein tyrosine kinase zeta-chain associated protein kinase (ZAP70), normally expressed in T cells and a subset of B cells, is solely expressed in poor prognosis chronic lymphocytic leukaemia and implicated in enhanced B cell receptor signalling. As a result, the expression of this protein provides an ideal prognostic marker for the disease. A previous study has shown differential CpG methylation of a 5' region of ZAP70 in leukaemic lymphoid cells, although no further epigenetic studies have been reported. Further investigation into the expression of ZAP70 may therefore provide targets for therapies.