Anergic T cells actively suppress T cell responses via the antigen-presenting cell

We here show that anergic T cells are active mediators of T cell suppression. In co-culture experiments, we found that anergic T cells, derived from established rat T cell clones and rendered anergic via T cell presentation of the specific antigen (Ag), were active inhibitors of T cell responses. Anergic T cells inhibited not only the responses of T cells with the same Ag specificity as the anergic T cells, but were also capable of efficiently inhibiting polyclonal T cell responses directed to other epitopes. This suppression required close cell-cell contact between antigen-presenting cells (APC), anergic T cells and responder T cells, and only occurred when the epitope recognized by the anergic T cell was present. The suppression was not caused by passive competition for ligands on the APC surface, IL-2 consumption, or cytolysis, and was not mediated by soluble factors derived from anergic T cells that were stimulated with their specific Ag. When responder T cells were added 24 h after co-culturing anergic cells in the presence of Ag and APC, T cell responses were still suppressed, indicating that the suppressive effect was persistently present. However, anergic T cells were not able to suppress responder T cells that had already received a full activation signal. We propose that suppression by anergic T cells is mediated via the APC, either through modulation of the T cell-activating capacity of the APC (APC/T cell interaction), or by inhibition of T cells recognizing their ligand in close proximity on the same APC (T/T cell interaction).

Specific tolerance induction and organ transplantation

Induction of tolerance to histocompatibility antigens of an organ donor would eliminate the need for long-term administration of nonspecific immunosuppressive drugs associated with an increased risk of infection and malignancies. Recently, we established a murine model in which recipient mice were treated with a single dose of anti-CD3, anti-CD4, low dose of total body irradiation (TBI) and allogeneic bone marrow cells. Our results clearly demonstrate that stable multilineage mixed chimerism, immunocompetence and permanent donor-specific skin graft tolerance across full major histocompatibility (MHC) barriers can be successfully achieved in this way. The observations that the preparative regimen and skin transplantation can be performed on the same day, and that a significant reduction in irradiation dose is sufficient in haploidentical donor-recipient combinations (MHC-sharing effect), bring our protocol closer to clinical use.

Haematopoietic stem cells can induce specific skin graft acceptance across full MHC barriers

Previously, we and others have demonstrated in several animal models that the establishment of stable haematopoietic chimerism through allogeneic bone marrow transfusion provides an effective means for the development of specific transplantation tolerance. However, a major limitation to the clinical application of allogeneic bone marrow transfusion in immunosuppressed recipients for induction of tolerance to solid grafts, is the risk of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Therefore, it is important to identify the cell population needed for the induction of mixed chimerism and tolerance. Haematopoietic stem cells have the capacity of self-renewal and multilineage differentiation, and have been shown to reduce the risk of GVHD. We studied transfusion of two rich sources of stem cells, namely allogeneic fetal liver cells and a subset of purified bone marrow-derived progenitor cells (c-kit+) into anti-T cell monoclonal antibody-treated, low-dose irradiated recipient mice. Our data revealed that stable multilineage mixed chimerism and permanent donor-specific tolerance for skin, even when transplanted directly following conditioning, can be successfully achieved in this way, with no signs of GVHD.

Specific tolerance induction and transplantation: a single-day protocol

Bone marrow transfusion is a well-established method for induction of mixed hematopoietic chimerism and donor-specific tolerance in animal models. This procedure, however, is inapplicable in clinical transplantation using cadaveric donors due to the interval (1 week to 7 months) between tolerance induction and organ transplantation. For clinical use, it is essential that allografts be placed at the time of bone marrow transfusion. In the present study, we performed skin transplantation within 1 hour after a nonlethal conditioning regimen. Recipient mice were treated with anti-CD3, anti-CD4, low-dose total body irradiation (3 to 6 Gy TBI) and fully mismatched or haploidentical donor bone marrow cells. Stable multilineage chimerism and specific T-cell nonresponsiveness developed. Donor skin grafts were permanently accepted. These results suggest that this single day protocol has clear potential for application in both cadaveric and living-related organ transplantation.

A substantial level of mixed chimerism is required for the induction of permanent transplantation tolerance

The induction of donor-specific transplantation tolerance is a major goal in organ transplantation, in order to eliminate the requirement for lifelong immunosuppressive therapy. Previously, we have developed a murine bone marrow transplantation model in which recipient mice were treated with a single dose of anti-CD3 and low dose whole body irradiation (WBI). Transfusion of donor bone marrow cells across a full H-2 disparity resulted in induction of high levels of stable mixed chimerism, specific T cell non-responsiveness and indefinite skin allograft survival. The present study has focused on manipulation of the level of chimerism in this model by varying the number of infused bone marrow cells, varying the dose of WBI and addition of syngeneic bone marrow cells. Our results indicate that a substantial level of chimerism is needed for induction of transplantation tolerance. In addition, in the semi-allogeneic donor-recipient combination an even lower dose of WBI was sufficient of engraftment of bone marrow cells and subsequent tolerance induction. We suggest that sharing of MHC antigens between donor and recipient might play an important role in facilitating the development of chimerism and tolerance in organ transplantation.

Anti-CD3 treatment facilitates engraftment of full H-2-disparate donor bone marrow cells and subsequent skin allograft tolerance

The aim of the present study was to induce engraftment of full H-2-disparate donor bone marrow cells and the development of subsequent transplantation tolerance. To this end, recipient H-2b mice were treated with anti-CD3 and on the same day received 6 Gy whole body irradiation as well as donor bone marrow cells (H-2d). Anti-CD3 treatment was chosen because it results in suppression of T cell function and in the release of CSF associated with enhancement of donor bone marrow engraftment. Stable, long-term chimerism measured in peripheral blood and mesenteric lymph nodes was obtained using this preparative regimen. In contrast, the use of anti-CD3 F(ab')2 fragments failed to induce donor bone marrow cell engraftment, suggesting indeed an important role of anti-CD3-mediated growth factor production in marrow engraftment. To overcome the side effects of anti-CD3 treatment (cytokine release syndrome), anti-CD4 was given 1 day before the treatment protocol. Omission of anti-CD3 resulted in failure of donor bone marrow engraftment, indicating the essential role of anti-CD3 treatment in marrow engraftment. Skin transplantation performed 2 and 6 months after this well-tolerated conditioning regimen showed indefinite survival of first and second grafts, respectively. In addition, specific CTL nonresponsiveness developed, demonstrating the presence of classical transplantation tolerance across a full H-2 barrier.