Methylene blue dye versus combined dye-radioactive tracer technique for sentinel lymph node localisation in early breast cancer

AIM

The study compared the accuracy and success rate of two techniques, methylene blue alone versus combined methylene blue and radioactive colloid in sentinel lymph node localisation in the management early breast cancer.

METHODS

Three hundred and twenty-nine patients with tumours less than 2 cm on ultrasound assessment were prospectively evaluated. One hundred and seventy-three patients (Group A) underwent sentinel lymph node localisation using 1 ml of 1% methylene blue. A combined technique of both methylene blue and radioactive colloid was used in 156 patients (Group B). Application of both was subdermal and subareolar. Sentinel lymph nodes were examined by standard microscopy. Patients underwent breast conservation surgery or mastectomy and sentinel node guided four node axillary sampling+/-clearance.

RESULTS

In Group A, the sentinel lymph node identification rate was 96.5%. The negative predictive value was 96.3%, with false negative of 3.7% and accuracy of 87.4%. In group B the identification rate for sentinel lymph node was 98.7%, with false negative of 4.1%, negative predictive value of 96%, and accuracy of 83.8%.

CONCLUSION

Sentinel lymph node localisation using methylene blue or combined dye and radioactive tracer technique predicts the axillary lymph node status in early breast cancer with comparable success rates, accuracy and false negative rates. The combined technique facilitates quicker identification of sentinel lymph node; however the dye technique alone can be used successfully in centres without nuclear medicine facilities.

Radioimmunoscintigraphy with Tc-99m-labelled SM3 in differentiating malignant from benign adnexal masses

OBJECTIVE

Ultrasound scanning, serum CA125 and menopausal status have previously been combined in a risk of malignancy index for the differential diagnosis of adnexal masses. Although this approach has greater accuracy than either individual tests or clinical assessment, it has a significant false positive and false negative rate. Efforts have been directed at refining differential diagnosis and this study assessed the role of radioimmunoscintigraphy using the stripped mucin 3 (SM3) antibody that has a 17-fold greater uptake in malignant than benign ovarian tumours in vitro.

DESIGN

Prospective study of patients with a pelvic mass using radioimmunoscintigraphy.

SETTING

Department of Nuclear Medicine of St Bartholomew's Hospital in collaboration with Cancer Network.

POPULATION

A total of 93 patients with pelvic masses were recruited for this study of which 32 had ovarian cancer and 61 had benign lesions.

METHODS

Radioimmunoscintigraphy was performed with Tc-99m-labelled SM3 (600 MBq), anterior and posterior pelvis imaged at 10 minutes and at 4 and 24 hours and evaluated with change detection analysis and probability mapping.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Sensitivity and specificity of radioimmunoscintigraphy for ovarian cancer.

RESULTS

Radioimmunoscintigraphy had a sensitivity for ovarian cancer of 84% (27 true positive and 5 false negatives) and a specificity of 87% (53 true negatives and 8 false positives) giving a negative predictive value of 91%.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that radioimmunoscintigraphy could be used to reduce the number of false positive findings in a strategy to refine differential diagnosis of the pelvic mass.

Can the estimation of ejection fraction during gated single photon emission computed tomography at rest add information to the cardiac perfusion study?

Left ventricular function is an important prognostic indicator in patients with coronary artery disease. The electrocardiogram gated, myocardial, single photon emission tomography (SPECT) program is coming into wide use. This program permits measurement of end diastolic volume, end systolic volume, and ejection fraction. This study was designed to show whether the measurement of ejection fraction by using (99c)Tc tetrofosmin gated SPECT at rest could give additional information to the interpretation of perfusion. Exercise 99mTc tetrofosmin SPECT and gated (99c)Tc tetrofosmin SPECT at rest were performed in 33 patients with or suspected of having coronary artery disease. Left ventricular ejection fraction was calculated from reconstructed gated SPECT at rest with a software quantitative gated SPECT. The results showed a poor correlation between segmental ejection fraction and segmental perfusion in stress and rest. There was an increasing probability of reversibility as the ejection fraction increased, while there was a greater chance of a fixed defect as the ejection fraction decreased. It is concluded that gated SPECT using (99c)Tc tetrofosmin provides clinically satisfactory functional data that, in combination with the perfusion information, will improve diagnostic and prognostic accuracy without an increase in cost or radiation dose to patients.