Plant root development: is the classical theory for auxin-regulated root growth false?

One of the longest standing theories and, therein-based, regulation-model of plant root development, posits the inhibitory action of auxin (IAA, indolylacetic acid) on elongation growth of root cells. This effect, as induced by exogenously supplied IAA, served as the foundation stone for root growth regulation. For decades, auxin ruled the day and only allowed hormonal side players to be somehow involved, or in some way affected. However, this copiously reiterated, apparent cardinal role of auxin only applies in roots immersed in solutions; it vanishes as soon as IAA-supplied roots are not surrounded by liquid. When roots grow in humid air, exogenous IAA has no inhibitory effect on elongation growth of maize roots, regardless of whether it is applied basipetally from the top of the root or to the entire residual seedling immersed in IAA solution. Nevertheless, such treatment leads to pronounced root-borne ethylene emission and lateral rooting, illustrating and confirming thereby induced auxin presence and its effect on the root - yet, not on root cell elongation. Based on these findings, a new root growth regulatory model is proposed. In this model, it is not IAA, but IAA-triggered ethylene which plays the cardinal regulatory role - taking effect, or not - depending on the external circumstances. In this model, in water- or solution-incubated roots, IAA-dependent ethylene acts due to its accumulation within the root proper by inhibited/restrained diffusion into the liquid phase. In roots exposed to moist air or gas, there is no effect on cell elongation, since IAA-triggered ethylene diffuses out of the root without an impact on growth.

Root cap-mediated evaluation of soil resistance towards graviresponding roots of maize (Zea mays L.) and the relevance of ethylene

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Besides biological and chemical impacts, mechanical resistance represents an important obstacle that growing roots face. Graviresponding roots must assess the mechanical resistance of the substrate and take decisions on whether they change growth direction and grow around obstacles or tolerate growth conditions impaired to varying degrees. To test the significance of the root cap, we measured pressure and growth behaviour of single intact, as well as decapped, roots encountering diverse mechanical obstacles. We examined ethylene emission in intact roots as well as roots without a root cap, thereby lacking the capacity to deviate.

METHODS

Roots of fixed seedlings were grown vertically onto diverse mechanical obstacles. Developing pressure profiles of vertically growing roots encountering horizontal mechanical obstacles were measured employing electronic milligram scales, with and without root caps in given local environmental conditions. The evolution of root-borne ethylene was measured in intact roots and roots without the root cap.

KEY RESULTS

In contrast to decapped roots, intact roots develop a tentative, short-lasting pressure profile, the resolution of which is characterized by a definite change of growth direction. Similarly, pressure profiles and strengths of roots facing gradually differing surface resistances differ significantly between the two. This correlates in the short term with root cap-dependent ethylene emission which is lacking in roots without caps.

CONCLUSIONS

The way gravistimulated and graviresponding roots cope with exogenous stimuli depends on whether and how they adapt to these impacts. With respect to mechanical hindrances, roots without caps do not seem to be able to evaluate soil strengths in order to respond adequately. On encountering resistance, roots with intact caps emit ethylene, which is not observed in decapped roots. It therefore appears that it is the root cap which specifically orchestrates the resistance needed to overcome mechanical resistance by specifically inducing ethylene.

The root cap determines ethylene-dependent growth and development in maize roots

Besides providing protection against mechanical damage to the root tip, the root cap is involved in the perception and processing of diverse external and internal stimuli resulting in altered growth and development. The transduction of these stimuli includes hormonal signaling pathways such as those of auxin, ethylene and cytokinin. Here, we show that the root cap is essential for the ethylene-induced regulation of elongation growth and root hair formation in maize. Exogenously applied ethylene is no longer able to inhibit elongation growth when the root cap has been surgically removed prior to hormone treatment. Reconstitution of the cap positively correlates with the developing capacity of the roots to respond to ethylene again. In contrast, the removal of the root cap does not per se affect growth inhibition controlled by auxin and cytokinin. Furthermore, our semi-quantitative RT-PCR results support earlier findings that the maize root cap is a site of high gene expression activity with respect to sensing and responding to hormones such as ethylene. From these data, we propose a novel function of the root cap which is the establishment of competence to respond to ethylene in the distal zones of the root.

Gravitropic plant growth regulation and ethylene: an unsought cardinal coordinate for a disused model

According to the Cholodny-Went hypothesis, gravitropic differential growth is brought about by the redistribution of auxin (indolyl-3-acetic acid, IAA). We reinvestigated the relevance of different auxins and studied the role of ethylene in hypocotyls of sunflower and shoots and roots of rye and maize seedlings. Incubation of coleoptiles and of sunflower hypocotyls in solutions of IAA and dichlorophenoxyacetic acid as well as naphthylacetic acid resulted in a two- to threefold length increase compared to water controls. In spite of this pronounced general effect on elongation growth, gravi-curvature was similar to water controls. In contrast to this, inhibition of ethylene synthesis by aminoethoxyvinylglycine prevented differential growth of both hypocotyls and coleoptiles and of roots of maize. In horizontally stimulated maize roots growing on surfaces, inhibition of ethylene perception by methylcyclopropene inhibited roots to adapt growth to the surface, resulting in a lasting vertical orientation of the root tips. This effect is accompanied by up- and down-regulation of a number of proteins as detected by two-dimensional matrix-assisted laser desorption-ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Together the data query the regulatory relevance of IAA redistribution for gravitropic differential growth. They corroborate the crucial regulatory role of ethylene for gravitropic differential growth, both in roots and coleoptiles of maize as well as in hypocotyls.

Physiological and biochemical characterization of ethylene-generated gravicompetence in primary shoots of coleoptile-less gravi-incompetent rye seedlings

A recent study demonstrated that gravi-incompetent coleoptile-less seedlings of rye exhibit gravi-competence after exogenous application of ethylene. Treatments and conditions which induce and interfere with this phenomenon were analysed in more detail. Aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) as a precursor of ethylene has similar gravicompetence-inducing effects and also appropriate conditions of light, which strongly enhances ethylene synthesis. Both effects can be inhibited by the ethylene-perception blocking agent methylcyclopropene (MCP) or inhibitors of ethylene synthesis such as aminovinylglycine (AVG), indicating that light exerts its gravicompetence-generating effect via induced/enhanced ethylene synthesis. Gain in gravicompetence is accompanied by the induced/enhanced occurrence of calreticulin and lipoxygenase as detected by 2D-gels and Q-TOFF-analyses. Previously gravicompetent, light-grown coleoptile-less seedlings are characterized by gravi-incompetent growth during subsequent horizontal gravistimulation when perception of ethylene is inhibited by MCP. The results demonstrate that continuous perception of ethylene is an indispensable step, permanently required for the regulation of gravitropic growth in germinating primary shoots of rye, either within the process of graviperception and/or of the transduction of the gravi-signal.

Ethylene perception generates gravicompetence in gravi-incompetent leaves of rye seedlings

The elongating leaves of young rye seedlings do not show a gravitropic response when placed horizontally. However, after treatment with ethylene, either supplied exogenously via ethephon or by application of its precursor 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC), gravicompetence is seen. The inhibition of ethylene perception by 1-methylcyclopropene (MCP) prevents gravicompetence. Young rye leaves provide a useful model system in which to identify the components of the gravity sensing or response systems, the presence of which govern gravicompetence.

The gravitropic setpoint angle of dark-grown rye seedlings and the role of ethylene

The orientation growth of coleoptiles of dark-grown seedlings of rye (Secale cereale L. cv. Marder II), when grown under various conditions, was analysed with respect to the gravivector ('gravitropic setpoint angle', GSA). Coleoptiles growing through moist vermiculite attain and maintain a GSA with an average of about 180 degrees, i.e. a vertical orientation. Seedlings growing uncovered either on the surface of vermiculite or positionally fixed on filter paper attain and maintain a GSA of 140-150 degrees (i.e. deviating from the vertical by an average of 30-40 degrees ). Changing the position of the embryo relative to the horizontally fixed seed kernel or of the angle of the seed with respect to gravity during germination (+/-40 degrees relative to the horizontal) had no significant effect on the subsequent GSA of both covered and uncovered seedlings. The GSA of uncovered coleoptiles could be restored close to 180 degrees by treatment of the seedlings with ethylene, either applied via ethephon or 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) as well as by fruit-released ethylene. The results are discussed with respect to the mechanism of the regulation of gravitropic growth of grass seedlings.

Lateral redistribution of auxin is not the means for gravitropic differential growth of coleoptiles: A new model

Gravicurvature in water- and auxin (IAA)-incubated coleoptiles of rye (Secale cereale L.) is similar, despite a general strongly enhancing effect of exogenous IAA on the overall (cell) elongation of these organs. Longitudinally split coleoptiles or isolated longitudinally halved coleoptiles (horizontally positioned as upper or lower halves) respond gravitropically in the same way as water-incubated intact coleoptiles, irrespective of whether the halves are incubated in distilled water or IAA. A new model for the principal mechanism of regulation of gravitropic growth is proposed which depends on, yet does not involve, the redistribution of IAA as the means for gravistimulated differential growth, as postulated by the Cholodny-Went hypothesis (CWH). It is based on a gravimediated temporarily restrained infiltration of IAA-induced wall-loosening factors into the growth-limiting outer epidermal walls of the concave organ flank.

Latrunculin B-induced plant dwarfism: Plant cell elongation is F-actin-dependent

Marine macrolides latrunculins are highly specific toxins which effectively depolymerize actin filaments (generally F-actin) in all eukaryotic cells. We show that latrunculin B is effective on diverse cell types in higher plants and describe the use of this drug in probing F-actin-dependent growth and in plant development-related processes. In contrast to other eukaryotic organisms, cell divisions occurs in plant cells devoid of all actin filaments. However, the alignment of the division planes is often distorted. In addition to cell division, postembryonic development and morphogenesis also continue in the absence of F-actin. These experimental data suggest that F-actin is of little importance in the morphogenesis of higher plants, and that plants can develop more or less normally without F-actin. In contrast, F-actin turns out to be essential for cell elongation. When latrunculin B was added during germination, morphologically normal Arabidopsis and rye seedlings developed but, as a result of the absence of cell elongation, these were stunted, resembling either genetic dwarfs or environmental bonsai plants. In conclusion, F-actin is essential for the plant cell elongation, while this F-actin-dependent cell elongation is not an essential feature of plant-specific developmental programs.

Auxin-dependent cell wall depositions in the epidermal periplasmic space of graviresponding nodes of Tradescantia fluminensis

Differential growth of the nodal regions of graviresponding Tradescantia fluminensis (Wandering Jew) was analysed with special respect to the extension-restricting epidermal cells of the opposite growing and growth-inhibited organ flanks. Gravicurvature of horizontally gravistimulated isolated nodes depends on auxin (indolyl-3-acetic acid, IAA) and shows a node-specific profile in which the third node below the tip showed the greatest response. Exogenously supplied gibberellic acid induced no gravitropic growth. Vertically oriented isolated nodes supplied with exogenous IAA showed, on an electron microscopical level, conspicuous membrane invaginations with adjacent wall depositions restricted to the outer tangential epidermal cell walls. Their number was more than doubled by exogenously supplied Ca2+, which inhibited IAA-induced growth. No such changes could be detected in water-incubated segments or inner tissues of IAA-supplied segments. Gravistimulated differential growth of nodes of intact shoots and of nodal segments was characterized by changes similar to the ones induced by exogenous IAA, with greatly increased numbers of wall depositions within the epidermal cells of the growth-inhibited upper organ flank. Similar to the gravistimulated wall depositions, an asymmetric distribution pattern of Ca2+ was detected in the epidermal cell walls employing x-ray energy spectrum analysis (EDX). The results indicate that growth of nodes of Tradescantia fluminensis is regulated via IAA-induced secretion and subsequent infiltration of wall components enabling wall extension. The data support the hypothesis that temporary differential growth during gravicurvature of Tradescantia fluminensis is mediated by the antagonistic effect of Ca(2+)-ions on the infiltration of IAA-induced wall-loosening components into the outer, extension-restricting epidermal walls thereby inhibiting growth.

Physiological evidence for the accumulation of restrained wall loosening potential on the growth-inhibited side of graviresponding rye coleoptiles

Subsequent to inversion, horizontally pre-gravistimulated coleoptiles exhibit an increased gravicurvature capacity as compared to vertically pre-gravistimulated and subsequently horizontally gravistimulated coleoptiles. This indicates that gravistimulated inhibition of growth of the upper organ flank during gravicurvature is mediated via the retention of wall loosening potential. After inversion, this potential contributes to enhanced cell extension on the then physiologically lower side.

Gravistimulated asymmetries in the outer epidermal cell walls of graviresponding coleoptiles

Gravitropic plant growth is due to gravistimulated asymmetric extension rates of the affected flanks of the graviresponding organ. Differential growth of the upper and lower flanks (UFs, LFs) of graviresponding plant organs may in principle be achieved by various biochemical and/or biophysical asymmetries. The gravistimulated mechanism(s) by which the different growth rates are determined is still unresolved, as is the mechanism of IAA-regulated growth. The purpose of this brief review is to summarize and critically evaluate data concerning gravistimulated asymmetries, especially with respect to the interface of the plasma membranes and of the extension-restricting, load-bearing epidermal cell walls (Masuda and Yamamoto 1972 Physiol Plant 27:109-115). In addition, recent results obtained by the author in experiments with rye coleoptiles will be presented and discussed in the context of a tentative model of gravistimulated wall asymmetries temporarily causing differential growth.

Coleoptiles are gravi-guiding systems vital for gravi-insensitive shoots of germinating grass seedlings

Surgical removal of the coleoptiles from germinating seedlings of Secale cereale L., Avena sativa L., and Zea mays L. leads to a total loss of gravitropic response of the shoot without affecting growth. The principal function of coleoptiles is therefore to guide the gravi-insensitive shoot to the soil surface.

Unequal distribution of osmiophilic particles in the epidermal periplasmic space of upper and lower flanks of gravi-responding rye coleoptiles

In various studies, auxin (IAA)-induced coleoptile growth has been reported to be closely correlated with an increased occurrence of osmiophilic particles (OPs) at the inner surface of the outer, growth-limiting epidermal cell wall, indicating a possible function related to the mechanism of IAA-induced wall loosening. In order to test whether changes in cell elongation rates of upper and lower flanks (UFs, LFs, respectively) during graviresponsive growth are reflected in appropriate changes in the occurrence of OPs, rye (Secale cereale L.) coleoptiles either as segments or as part of intact seedlings, were gravitropically stimulated by positioning them horizontally for 2 h. Ultrastructural analyses within the UFs and LFs of the upward-bending coleoptiles revealed a distinct imbalance in the occurrence of OPs. The number of OPs per transverse epidermal cell section of the elongation-inhibited UF on average amounted to twice the number of OPs counted in epidermal cell sections of the faster-growing LF. As a hypothesis, the results lead us to suggest that OPs are involved in the mechanism of wall loosening and that temporary growth inhibition of epidermal cells of the UF during upward bending is mediated by inhibition of OP entry into the cell walls. Thereby, more OPs accumulate near the inner surface of the outer wall of epidermal cells of the UF compared with the LF.

Effect of cellulose synthesis inhibition on growth and the integration of xyloglucan into pea internode cell walls

2,6-Dichlorobenzonitrile (DCB, 100 mum) inhibited by 80 to 85% the incorporation of [(3)H]glucose into cellulose in stem segments of etiolated pea (Pisum sativum) seedlings. The inhibition lasted for at least 24 h. In the period 1 to 4 h after the excision of the segments, DCB did not influence elongation in the presence or absence of 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid (2,4-D). However, during the period 1 to 24 h after excision, DCB enhanced endogenous and 2,4-D-stimulated elongation by 65 and 34%, respectively. DCB did not affect the incorporation of (3)H from [(3)H]arabinose into xyloglucan, and did not change the ability of the [(3)H]xyloglucan formed in vivo to bind strongly to the cell wall. Therefore, at least 80 to 85% of newly synthesized cellulose was excess to the requirements for tight wall binding of newly synthesized xyloglucan. This conflicts with the hypothesis that xyloglucan is held in the cell wall solely by direct hydrogen bonding to the surfaces of cellulosic microfibrils.