Two approaches to discovering and developing new drugs for Chagas disease

This review will focus on two general approaches carried out at the Sandler Center, University of California, San Francisco, to address the challenge of developing new drugs for the treatment of Chagas disease. The first approach is target-based drug discovery, and two specific targets, cytochrome P450 CYP51 and cruzain (aka cruzipain), are discussed. A 'proof of concept' molecule, the vinyl sulfone inhibitor K777, is now a clinical candidate. The preclinical assessment compliance for filing as an Investigational New Drug with the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is presented, and an outline of potential clinical trials is given. The second approach to identifying new drug leads is parasite phenotypic screens in culture. The development of an assay allowing high throughput screening of Trypanosoma cruzi amastigotes in skeletal muscle cells is presented. This screen has the advantage of not requiring specific strains of parasites, so it could be used with field isolates, drug resistant strains or laboratory strains. It is optimized for robotic liquid handling and has been validated through a screen of a library of FDA-approved drugs identifying 65 hits.

Substrate recognition sites in 14alpha-sterol demethylase from comparative analysis of amino acid sequences and X-ray structure of Mycobacterium tuberculosis CYP51

The crystal structure of 14alpha-sterol demethylase from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTCYP51) [Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 98 (2001) 3068-3073] provides a template for analysis of eukaryotic orthologs which constitute the CYP51 family of cytochrome P450 proteins. Putative substrate recognition sites (SRSs) were identified in MTCYP51 based on the X-ray structures and have been compared with SRSs predicted based on Gotoh's analysis [J. Biol. Chem. 267 (1992) 83-90]. While Gotoh's SRS-4, 5, and 6 contribute in formation of the putative MTCYP51 substrate binding site, SRS-2 and 3 likely do not exist in MTCYP51. SRS-1, as part of the open BC loop, in the conformation found in the crystal can provide only limited contacts with the sterol. However, its role in substrate binding might dramatically increase if the loop closes in response to substrate binding. Thus, while the notion of SRSs has been very useful in leading to our current understanding of P450 structure and function, their identification by sequence alignment between distant P450 families will not necessarily be a good predictor of residues associated with substrate binding. Localization of CYP51 mutation hotspots in Candida albicans azole resistant isolates was analyzed with respect to SRSs. These mutations are found to be outside of the putative substrate interacting sites indicating the preservation of the protein active site under the pressure of azole treatment. Since the mutations residing outside the putative CYP51 active side can profoundly influence ligand binding within the active site, perhaps they provide insight into the basis of evolutionary changes which have occurred leading to different P450s.

Folding Requirements Are Different between Sterol 14α-Demethylase (CYP51) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Human or Fungal Orthologs

Upon sequence alignment of CYP51 sterol 14alpha-demethylase from animals, plants, fungi, and bacteria, arginine corresponding to Arg-448 of CYP51 in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MT) is conserved near the C terminus of all family members. In MTCYP51 Arg-448 forms a salt bridge with Asp-287, connecting beta-strand 3-2 with helix J. Deletion of the three C-terminal residues of MTCYP51 has little effect on expression of P450 in Escherichia coli. However, truncation of the fourth amino acid (Arg-448) completely abolishes P450 expression. We have investigated whether Arg-448 has other structural or functional roles in addition to folding and whether its conservation reflects conservation of a common folding pathway in the CYP51 family. Characterization of wild type protein and three mutants, R448K, R448I, and R448A, including examination of catalytic activity, secondary and tertiary structure analysis by circular dichroism and tryptophan fluorescence, and studies of both equilibrium and temporal MTCYP51 unfolding behavior, shows that Arg-448 does not play any role in P450 function or maintenance of the native structure. C-terminal truncation of Candida albicans and human CYP51 orthologs reveals that, despite conservation in sequence, the requirement for arginine at the homologous C-terminal position in folding in E. coli is not conserved. Thus, despite similar spatial folds, functionally related but evolutionarily distinct P450s can follow different folding pathways.

Crystal structure of cytochrome P450 14alpha -sterol demethylase (CYP51) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis in complex with azole inhibitors

Cytochrome P450 14alpha-sterol demethylases (CYP51) are essential enzymes in sterol biosynthesis in eukaryotes. CYP51 removes the 14alpha-methyl group from sterol precursors such as lanosterol, obtusifoliol, dihydrolanosterol, and 24(28)-methylene-24,25-dihydrolanosterol. Inhibitors of CYP51 include triazole antifungal agents fluconazole and itraconazole, drugs used in treatment of topical and systemic mycoses. The 2.1- and 2.2-A crystal structures reported here for 4-phenylimidazole- and fluconazole-bound CYP51 from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTCYP51) are the first structures of an authentic P450 drug target. MTCYP51 exhibits the P450 fold with the exception of two striking differences-a bent I helix and an open conformation of BC loop-that define an active site-access channel running along the heme plane perpendicular to the direction observed for the substrate entry in P450BM3. Although a channel analogous to that in P450BM3 is evident also in MTCYP51, it is not open at the surface. The presence of two different channels, with one being open to the surface, suggests the possibility of conformationally regulated substrate-in/product-out openings in CYP51. Mapping mutations identified in Candida albicans azole-resistant isolates indicates that azole resistance in fungi develops in protein regions involved in orchestrating passage of CYP51 through different conformational stages along the catalytic cycle rather than in residues directly contacting fluconazole. These new structures provide a basis for rational design of new, more efficacious antifungal agents as well as insight into the molecular mechanism of P450 catalysis.

Crystal structure of the CCAAT box/enhancer-binding protein beta activating transcription factor-4 basic leucine zipper heterodimer in the absence of DNA

The crystal structure of the heterodimer formed by the basic leucine zipper (bZIP) domains of activating transcription factor-4 (ATF4) and CCAAT box/enhancer-binding protein beta (C/EBP beta), from two different bZIP transcription factor families, has been determined and refined to 2.6 A. The structure shows that the heterodimer forms an asymmetric coiled-coil. Even in the absence of DNA, the basic region of ATF4 forms a continuous alpha-helix, but the basic region of C/EBP beta is disordered. Proteolysis, electrophoretic mobility shift assay, circular dichroism, and NMR analyses indicated that (i) the bZIP domain of ATF4 is a disordered monomer and forms a homodimer upon binding to the DNA target; (ii) the bZIP domain of ATF4 forms a heterodimer with the bZIP domain of C/EBP beta that binds the cAMP response element, but not CCAAT box DNA, with high affinity; and (iii) the basic region of ATF4 has a higher alpha-helical propensity than that of C/EBP beta. These results suggest that the degree of ordering of the basic region and the fork and the dimerization properties of the leucine zipper combine to distinguish the structurally similar bZIP domains of ATF4 and C/EBP beta with respect to DNA target sequence. This study provides insight into the mechanism by which dimeric bZIP transcription factors discriminate between closely related but distinct DNA targets.

Tyrosine 114 is essential for the trimeric structure and the functional activities of human proliferating cell nuclear antigen

In order to study the effect of trimerization of proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) on its interaction with DNA polymerase (pol) delta and its loading onto DNA by replication factor C (RF-C) we have mutated a single tyrosine residue located at the subunit interface (Tyr114) to alanine. This mutation (Y114A) had a profound effect on PCNA, since it completely abolished trimer formation as seen by glycerol gradient sedimentation and native gel electrophoresis. Furthermore, the mutant protein was unable to stimulate DNA synthesis by pol delta and did not compete effectively with wild-type PCNA for pol delta, although it was able to oligomerize and could to some extent interact with subunits of functionally active PCNA. We thus conclude that PCNA molecules that are not part of a circular trimeric complex cannot interact with the pol delta core. furthermore, the mutant protein could not be loaded onto DNA by RF-C and did not compete with wild-type PCNA for loading onto DNA, indicating that PCNA trimerization may also be a prerequisite for its recognition by RF-C. The adverse effects caused by this single mutation suggest that trimerization of PCNA is essential for the monomers to keep their overall structure and that the structural changes imposed by trimerization are important for interaction with other proteins.

Mechanism of inhibition of proliferating cell nuclear antigen-dependent DNA synthesis by the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor p21

It is known that the direct binding of the cyclin-dependent kinase (Cdk) inhibitor p21, also called Cdk-interacting protein 1 (p21), to proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) results in the inhibition of PCNA-dependent DNA synthesis. We provide evidence that p21 first inhibits the replication factor C-catalyzed loading of PCNA onto DNA and second prevents the binding of DNA polymerase delta core to the PCNA clamp assembled on DNA. The second effect contributes most to the inhibition of pol delta holoenzyme activity. p21 primarily inhibited the DNA synthesis resulting from multiple reassembly of DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme. On the other hand, an ability of the PCNA clamp to translocate along double-stranded DNA was not affected by p21. These data were confirmed with a mutant of p21 that is unable to bind PCNA and therefore neither inhibited clamp assembly nor prevented the loading of DNA polymerase delta core onto DNA. Our data suggest that p21 does not discriminate in vitro "repair" and "replication" DNA synthesis based on template length but does act preferentially on polymerization which encounters obstacles to progress.

Mammalian DNA polymerase auxiliary proteins: analysis of replication factor C-catalyzed proliferating cell nuclear antigen loading onto circular double-stranded DNA

To understand the mechanism of action of the two eukaryotic replication auxiliary proteins proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) and replication factor C (RF-C), we constructed a plasmid for producing PCNA which could be 32P labelled in vitro. This allowed us to analyze the assembly of the auxiliary proteins directly on DNA and to examine this process in the absence of DNA synthesis. By using closed circular double-stranded DNA or gapped circular DNA for protein-DNA complex formation, the following results were obtained, (i) RF-C can load PCNA in an ATP-dependent manner directly on double-stranded DNA, and no 3'-OH ends are required for this reaction; (ii) the RF-C-PCNA complex assembled on closed circular DNA differs from those assembled on gapped or nicked circular DNA; (iii) the stable RF-C-PCNA complex can be assembled on circular but not on linear DNA; and (iv) only gapped DNA can partially retain the assembled RF-C-PCNA complex upon the linearization of the template. We propose that RF-C first binds unspecifically to double-stranded DNA in the presence of ATP and then loads PCNA onto DNA to yield a protein complex able to track along DNA. The RF-C-PCNA complex could slide along the template until it encounters a 3'-OH primer-template junction, where it is likely transformed into a competent clamp. The latter complex, finally, might still be able to slide along double-stranded DNA.

DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme: action on single-stranded DNA and on double-stranded DNA in the presence of replicative DNA helicases

DNA polymerase delta requires proliferating cell nuclear antigen and replication factor C to form a holoenzyme efficient in DNA synthesis. We have analyzed three different aspects of calf thymus DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme: (i) analysis of pausing during DNA synthesis, (ii) replication of double-stranded DNA in the absence of additional factors, and (iii) replication of double-stranded DNA in the presence of the two known replicative DNA helicases from simian virus 40 and bovine papilloma virus. DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme replicated primed single-stranded DNA at a rate of 100-300 nucleotides/min, partially overcoming multiple pause sites on DNA. While Escherichia coli single-strand DNA binding protein helped DNA polymerase delta pass through pause sites, the DNA polymerase delta itself appeared to dissociate from the template in the absence of synthesis or when encountering pause sites. Proliferating cell nuclear antigen likely remained on the template. DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme could perform limited strand displacement synthesis on double-stranded gapped circular DNA, and this reaction was not stimulated either by replication protein A or by E. coli single-strand DNA binding protein. DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme could efficiently cooperate with replicative DNA helicases from simian virus 40 (large T antigen) and bovine papilloma virus 1 (protein E1) in replication through double-stranded DNA in a reaction that required replication protein A or E. coli single-strand DNA binding protein.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Assembly of DNA polymerase delta and epsilon holoenzymes depends on the geometry of the DNA template

To study in details the assembly of DNA polymerases delta and epsilon holoenzymes a circular double-stranded DNA template containing a gap of 45 nucleotides was constructed. Both replication factor C and proliferating cell nuclear antigen were absolutely required and sufficient for assembly of DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme complex on DNA. On such a circular DNA substrate replication protein A (or E. coli single-strand DNA binding protein) was neither required for assembly of DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme complex nor for the gap-filling reaction. A circular structure of the DNA substrate was found to be absolutely critical for the ability of auxiliary proteins to interact with DNA polymerases. The linearization of the circular DNA template resulted in three dramatic effects: (i) DNA synthesis by DNA polymerase delta holoenzyme was abolished, (ii) the inhibition effect of replication factor C and proliferating cell nuclear antigen on DNA polymerase alpha was relieved and (iii) DNA polymerase epsilon could not form any longer a holoenzyme with replication factor C and proliferating cell nuclear antigen. The comparison of the effect of replication factor C and proliferating cell nuclear antigen on DNA polymerases alpha, delta and epsilon indicated that the auxiliary proteins appear to form a mobile clamp, which can easily slide along double-stranded DNA.

[Structure of a single-stranded DNA target as a factor influencing the effectiveness of its modification with a complementary reagent]

Site directed alkylation of three oligonucleotide targets: 41-mer (hairpin structure), 22-mer (loop part of this hairpin) and 10-mer (part of the loop) with 5'-p-(N-2-chloroethyl-N-methylamino)benzylamides of oligonucleotides complementary to the loop region was studied. Thermodynamic parameters of the interaction were estimated using the dependence of the limit modification extent on the reagent concentration at different temperatures. The stability of the complex increases much in the set: 302-mer carrying the above hairpin, 41-mer, 22-mer; data on 22-mer and 10-mer being almost identical. This indicates significant influence of the loop supporting structure on the interaction with antisense reagents.

The influence of the target structure on the efficiency of alkylation of single-stranded DNA with the reactive derivatives of antisense oligonucleotides

Site-directed alkylation of three oligonucleotide targets: 41-mer (hairpin structure), 22-mer (loop part of this hairpin) and 10-mer (part of the loop) with 5'-p-(N-2-chloroethyl-N-methylamino)benzylamides of oligonucleotides complementary to the loop region was studied. Thermodynamic parameters of the interaction were estimated using the dependence of the limit modification extent on the reagent concentration at several temperatures. The stability of the complex increases significantly in the set: 302-mer carrying above hairpin, 41-mer, 22-mer, the data for 22-mer and 10-mer being nearly identical. This indicates significant influence of the loop supporting structure on the interaction with antisense reagents.

[Sequence specificity modification of double-stranded DNA with an alkylating derivative of oligodeoxyribonucleotide pT(CT)6]

It is shown that in slightly acidic solution (pH approximately 5.3) reagent CIRCH2NHpT(CT)6 (RCl = -C6H4-N(CH3)CH2CH2Cl) modifies a double-stranded DNA fragment (120 b. p.) containing A(GA)6.T(CT)6 sequence at a single nucleotide residue, viz. G29 located near to this sequence in the DNA chain. The location of this modification point suggests formation of a triple-stranded reactive complex with parallel orientation of the pyrimidine oligonucleotide moiety of the reagent and pyrine sequence of the target DNA. Analysing the modification extent dependence of the reagent concentration the association constant Kx between the reagent and DNA was calculated (Kx = (0.95 +/- 0.03).10(5) M-1, 25 degrees C, pH = 5.3, [NaCl] = 0.1 M). The modification by the reagent ClRCH2NHpT(m5CT)6 has the same quantitative characteristics as in the case of ClRCH2NHpT(CT)6.

Sequence-specific chemical modification of double-stranded DNA with alkylating oligodeoxyribonucleotide derivatives

Chemical modification of double-stranded (ds) DNA with alkylating oligodeoxynucleotide (oligo) derivatives, 5'-p(N-2-chloroethyl-N-methylamino) benzylamides of oligos, has been investigated. In contrast to relaxed plasmid DNAs, the superhelical molecules interact with the oligo derivatives and specific alkylation of the DNAs occurs at the regions complementary to the oligo reagents. Alkylating derivatives of oligocytidylates and pT(pCpT)6 react with corresponding homopyrimidine-homopurine tracts within ds DNA fragments due to triple helix formation.

Application of tris(2,2'-bipyridyl)ruthenium(III) for the investigation of DNA spatial structure by a chemical modification method

It was shown that the treatment of a DNA fragment and a hepta-decanucleotide having a hairpin structure by Ru(2,2'-bipyridyl)3(3+) complex at 15 degrees C in 1 M NaCl for 10-60 min, and subsequent hydrolysis in 1 M piperidine at 95 degrees C led to the specific cleavage of the polynucleotide chain at guanosine residues in the single-stranded regions. This method can be used for the studying of nucleic acids secondary structure.

Complementary addressed modification of double-stranded DNA within a ternary complex

Double-stranded DNA containing a d(pG)18.d(pC)18 sequence was shown to be selectively alkylated in the vicinity of this fragment using the 5'-p-(N-2-chloroethyl-N-methylamino)benzylamide of deoxyribooligocytidylate, CIRCH2NH(pdC)n (n = 9,15), in conditions favouring triple-stranded complex formation.

[Effectiveness of the modification of a single-stranded DNA fragment by alkylating derivatives of oligonucleotides]

Modification of a single-stranded DNA fragment 303 nucleotides long with addressed reagents d(pTGACCCTCTTCCC) A greater than CHRCl (I), d(pACCCTCTTCCC) A greater than CHRCl (II), d(CCTCTTCCC) A greater than CHRCl (III) and d(TCTTCCC) A greater than CHRCl (IV) complementary to the sequence 261-274 has been studied. It was shown that not only G258 residue, located near to the above sequence, but also G179 residue is modified. The latter can be explained by the vicinity of G179 and the alkylating group in the three-dimensional structure of the complex. Some modification of fragment 19-24 was observed due to non-complementary binding of the reagent. Association constants of the reagents (I)-(IV) with 261-274 sequence of the fragment were calculated using the dependence of the modification extent of G258 and G179 on the reagent concentration. The constants at 25 and 35 degrees C were found to be 260 and 31 (I), 0,5 and 2 (II), 0,46 and 0,13 (III), 0,0020 and 0,0023 (IV) microM-1.

[Affinity modification of Escherichia coli ribosomes with photoactivated analogs of mRNA]

Oligoribonucleotide derivatives containing the photoactivated arylazidogroup at 5'-end of the oligonucleotide fragment [2-(N-2,4-dinitro-5-azidophenyl) aminoethyl] phosphamides of the oligoribonucleotides, azido-NH (CH2)2NHpN (pN) n-1, were prepared. It was demonstrated that azido-NH(CH2)2NHpA(pA)4 and azido-NH (CH2)2NHpU (pU)3 stimulate the binding of the codonspecific aminoacyl-tRNA with ribosome. After irradiation of the ternary complex ribosome-azido-NH (CH2)2NHpU (pU) n-1 X tRNA with UV-light (lambda greater than 350 nm) covalent binding of the reagent to ribosome occurs. Up to 10% of the reagent, bound in the ternary complex with ribosome, is cross-linked with the ribosomal proteins of 30S and 50S subunits. The ribosomal RNA are not modified by azido-NH (CH2)2NHpU (pU) n-1. The proteins of 30S and 50S subunits, modified with azido-NH (CH2)2NHpU (pU) n-1 with n = 4,7 and 8, were identified. It is shown that proteins of 30S subunits S3, S4, S9, S11, S12, S14, S17, S19, S20 undergo modification. The proteins of 50S subunits L2, L13, L16, L27, L32, L33 are modified. The set of the modified proteins essentially depends on the length of the oligonucleotide part of the reagent and on occupancy of ribosome A-site by a molecule of tRNA.