Stakeholder Engagement in the Development of Public Health Economic Models: An Application to Modelling of Minimum Unit Pricing of Alcohol in South Africa

BACKGROUND

Health economic models aim to provide decision makers with information that is contextually relevant, understandable and credible. This requires ongoing engagement throughout the research project between the modeller and end-users.

OBJECTIVES

We aim to reflect on how a public health economic model of minimum unit pricing of alcohol in South Africa benefited from, and was shaped by, stakeholders. We outline how engagement activities were used during the development, validation and communication phases of the research with input gathered at each stage to inform future priorities.

METHODS

A stakeholder mapping exercise was completed to identify stakeholders with the required knowledge, for example academics with expertise in modelling alcohol harm in South Africa, members of civil society organisations with lived experience of informal alcohol outlets, and policy professionals working at the forefront of alcohol policy development in South Africa. The stakeholder engagement consisted of four phases: developing a detailed understanding of the local policy context; co-producing model focus and structure; scrutinising model development and communication planning; and communicating research evidence to end-users. The first phase utilised 12 individual semi-structured interviews. Phases two to four centred around face-to-face workshops (two online) with both individual and group-based exercises employed to achieve required outputs.

RESULTS

Phase one provided key learning on policy context and initiated working relationships. Phases two to four provided a conceptualisation of the problem of alcohol harm in South Africa and the choice of policy to model. Stakeholders chose population subgroups of interest and advised on both economic and health outcomes. They provided input on critical assumptions, data sources, priorities for future work, and communication strategies. The final workshop provided a platform to communicate the results of the model to a largely policy audience. These activities led to the production of highly contextualised research methods and findings that were able to be communicated widely beyond academia.

CONCLUSIONS

Our programme of stakeholder engagement was fully integrated into the research programme. It resulted in a number of benefits including creating positive working relationships, guiding modelling decisions, tailoring the research to the context, and providing ongoing opportunities for communication.

Whole-body UVB (TL-01) or UVA-1 irradiation does not alter the levels of immunomodulatory cytokines in the serum of human volunteers

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Ultraviolet (UV) exposure of mammalian skin induces local and systemic immunosuppression. In mice it has been proposed that systemic immunosuppression is mediated by an UV-induced cytokine cascade involving systemic interleukin (IL)-4 and IL-10 and a reduction in IL-12 activity. To investigate whether there was a parallel mechanism in humans we examined the effect of whole-body narrowband ultraviolet B (UVB) (311-313 nm; TL-01) and ultraviolet A (UVA)-1 (340-400 nm) on serum cytokine levels.

METHODS/RESULTS

In a first study, five male psoriatic subjects were whole-body irradiated with three sessions of a standard UVB (TL-01) phototherapy regimen previously shown to cause downregulation of natural killer cell activity and T helper 1 (Th1) and Th2 cytokine production by peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Enzyme-linked immunoabsorbent assay (ELISA) of sera taken before and after the third session showed no effect of phototherapy on IL-10 and tumour necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha). In a second study, five healthy subjects received three whole-body exposures of UVB (TL-01) and five other healthy subjects received three exposures of UVA-1 on alternate days (total 22 J/cm(2)). Blood samples were taken before the first irradiation and at 0, 4, 8, 12, 14, 24 and 48 h after the third irradiation. The sera were subsequently analysed for IL-10, IL-12, IL-8, IL-1beta and TNF-alpha, by ELISA. The levels of IL-1beta and TNF-alpha were below detection limits (<5 pg/ml), while no significant change in the levels of IL-10, IL-12 or IL-8 was detected as a result of either TL-01 or UVA-1.

CONCLUSIONS

It seems unlikely that a modulation in these circulating cytokines assessed in this study accounts for systemic UV-induced immunosuppression in human subjects.

A review of studies on the effects of ultraviolet irradiation on the resistance to infections: evidence from rodent infection models and verification by experimental and observational human studies

Recent studies on the immunosuppressive effects of ultraviolet radiation (UVR) and the related resistance to infections in rodents and humans are presented. The waveband dependency of trans-to-cis isomerisation of urocanic acid in the stratum corneum and the role of DNA damage in UVR-induced erythema and immunosuppression were investigated to further elucidate the underlying mechanisms. Furthermore, human experimental studies on UVR-induced immunomodulation were performed. It appeared that the doses needed to suppress various immune parameters in humans (e.g. NK activity, contact hypersensitivity) were higher than those needed in experiments in rodents. Still, extrapolation of experimental animal data to the human situation showed that UVR may impair the resistance to different systemic infections at relevant outdoor doses. In observational human studies we aimed to substantiate the relevance of UVR for infections in humans. It was shown that sunny season was associated with a slightly retarded but clinically non-relevant antibody response to hepatitis B vaccination. Furthermore, sunny season appeared to be associated with a small decline in the number of CD4+ T-helper cells in a cohort of HIV-infected persons and a higher recurrence of herpes simplex and herpes zoster in a cohort of renal transplant recipients. However, in a study among young children a higher exposure to solar UVR was associated with a lower occurrence of upper respiratory tract symptoms. As disentangling the effects of UVR from other relevant factors is often impossible in observational studies, concise quantitative risk estimations for the human situation cannot be given at present.

Time course of skin photosensitivity following trimethylpsoralen bath PUVA

One aspect of bath photochemotherapy (PUVA) that requires clarification is the duration of psoralen-induced cutaneous photosensitisation under conditions simulating clinical use. Using a half back comparison study technique, we investigated the persistence of trimethylpsoralen (TMP)-induced photosensitivity in skin irradiated to simulate a first PUVA exposure compared with un-irradiated skin. Baseline UVA minimal erythema dose and minimal phototoxic dose (MPD) were determined in 13 healthy volunteers. After readings at 72 h, subjects were bathed in TMP bath water for 15 min and one half of the back was immediately exposed to 40% of the MPD. Test sites (1.5 cm2) on both halves of the back were then irradiated with a UVA dose series at 15 min, 5, 10, 24, 34, 48 and 72 h after the bath. MPD readings were recorded visually at 72 h after each UVA exposure. The UVA MED was >25 J/cm2 in all the subjects. At each time point, a phototoxic index (PI) was calculated as UVA MED/MPD. In un-irradiated skin, photosensitivity returned to normal (PI=1) within 24 h after the TMP bath. In contrast, skin pre-irradiated to simulate the first PUVA treatment was still significantly photosensitive (PI=2.3; P=0.002) at 48 h. Contrary to previous recommendations, these data suggest that patients should be advised to avoid ambient or artificial sources of UVA throughout their course of TMP bath PUVA to reduce the risk of phototoxic erythema.

The phototumorigenic fluoroquinolone, lomefloxacin, photosensitises p53 accumulation and transcriptional activity in human skin cells

The fluoroquinolone antibiotic, lomefloxacin, is phototoxic in human skin exposed to UVA radiation, photosensitises DNA strand breaks and pyrimidine dimers in human keratinocytes in vitro, and is phototumorigenic in mouse skin. The p53 tumour suppressor protein is activated by a variety of cellular insults including UV radiation, to become a transcription factor for downstream markers such as the cyclin-kinase inhibitor p21CIP1/WAF1 or cause caspase transactivation which cleaves poly ADP ribose polymerase (PARP) as an early step in apoptosis. We have investigated these molecular defence responses in human skin cells treated with lomefloxacin and UVA radiation in vitro. Western blots revealed that lomefloxacin photosensitised the stabilisation of p53 protein in human fibroblasts. Lomefloxacin also photosensitised p53 transcriptional activity in amelanotic melanoma cells expressing wild-type p53 and stably transfected with a construct containing a beta-galactosidase reporter gene downstream from a p53 consensus binding sequence. Neither photosensitised production of H2O2 nor the resultant DNA strand breaks, appeared to be involved in this effect. Interestingly, p21CIP1/WAFI protein was upregulated by lomefloxacin in the dark by a p53-independent mechanism. Lomefloxacin also photosensitised the degradation of nuclear PARP, suggestive of caspase mediated, early apoptotic events.

Synergistic activation of p53-dependent transcription by two cooperating damage recognition pathways

High level activation of p53-dependent transcription occurs following cellular exposure to genotoxic damaging agents such as UV-C, while ionizing radiation damage does not induce a similarly potent induction of p53-dependent gene expression. Reasoning that one of the major differences between UV-C and ionizing radiation damage is that the latter does not inhibit general transcription, we attempted to reconstitute p53-dependent gene expression in ionizing irradiated cells by co-treatment with selected transcription inhibitors that alone do not activate p53. p53-dependent transcription can be dramatically enhanced by the treatment of ionizing irradiated cells with low doses of DRB, which on its own does not induce p53 activity. The mechanism of ionizing radiation-dependent activation of p53-dependent transcription using DRB is more likely due to inhibition of gene transcription rather than prolonged DNA damage, as the non-genotoxic and general transcription inhibitor Roscovitine also synergistically activates p53 function in ionizing irradiated cells. These results identify two distinct signal transduction pathways that cooperate to fully activate p53-dependent gene expression: one responding to lesions induced by ionizing radiation and the second being a kinase pathway that regulates general RNA Polymerase II activity.

The effect of whole-body sunbed ultraviolet A exposure on the pharmacokinetics of the photolabile drug nifedipine

The calcium antagonist nifedipine absorbs ultraviolet A (UVA) radiation and readily photodegrades in vitro to a toxic nitroso-pyridine photoproduct. We examined whether whole body exposure of normal subjects to sunbed UVA radiation would affect the pharmacokinetics of nifedipine. Eight healthy, male, Caucasian volunteers (phototypes I-III) participated in this ethically approved, randomised, cross-over study. Each subject attended on 2 occasions, one week apart, and on each occasion was given a single oral dose (10 mg) of nifedipine following which blood samples were collected at 0, 0.5, 1. 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 3.5, 4, 5, 6 and 7 h. During one of the visits, 15 min after nifedipine ingestion, a whole-body UVA (sunbed comprising Philips R-UVA lamps) dose of 70% of the individual's predetermined minimal phototoxic dose was delivered over a period of 17-36 min. Plasma nifedipine levels were measured using a standard reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatography method. The area under the plasma concentration-time curve (AUC) of nifedipine during the UVA irradiation session (median 206 ng x ml(-1) x h(-1)) was significantly higher than during the non-irradiation control session (median 174.5 ng x ml(-1) x h(-1)) (P=0.03; 95% C.I. for difference in medians 9.9 to 55.9 ng x ml(-1) x h(-1)). UVA irradiation did not significantly affect any of the other measured pharmacokinetic parameters (Cmax, t 1/2, tmax). We demonstrate that sunbed UVA irradiation does not lead to in vivo photodegradation of nifedipine in healthy humans after a single dose. The apparent increase in AUC during UVA irradiation may be due to slightly slower metabolism of nifedipine in the presence of toxic photoproduct(s) or due to blood distribution changes affecting liver blood flow.

Comparison of an in vitro cellular phototoxicity model against controlled clinical trials of fluoroquinolone skin phototoxicity

Many therapeutic drugs induce phototoxic skin responses following exposure to solar or artificial ultraviolet radiation sources. Several in vitro model systems have been developed to predict drug phototoxicity but none have been conducted in parallel with controlled clinical phototoxicity studies on systemically administered pharmaceuticals. The in vitro phototoxicity of eight fluoroquinolone (FQ) antibiotics (ciprofloxacin, grepafloxacin, lomefloxacin, norfloxacin, ofloxacin, trovafloxacin, BAYy3118, moxifloxacin) was determined by exposing Chinese hamster fibroblasts to UVA radiation. Cell damage was quantified with standard MTT or neutral red assays and an in vitro phototoxic index calculated (PI(vit)=% cell viability with UVA alone /% cell viability with UVA+FQ) for each endpoint. Clinical photosensitizing ability of the eight systemically administered FQ was investigated using double-blind, placebo and positive controlled, clinical skin phototesting of normal subjects. Minimal erythema doses at 365+/-30nm were determined before and after 6-7 days of FQ ingestion and PI(clin) (minimal erythema dose without FQ/minimal erythema dose with FQ) calculated. Linear regression analysis of PI(vit) vs PI(clin) gave correlations of up to 0.893. Principal components analysis of PI(vit), daily dose, plasma levels and photophysical (absorption) properties of the eight FQ showed that phototoxic (arbitrarily defined as PI(clin)> or =2) and non-phototoxic (PI(clin)<2) FQ could be completely discriminated using these parameters, and that the in vitro models were able to rank the relative phototoxic potential of the eight FQ.

Transcriptional activation of tyrosinase and TRP-1 by p53 links UV irradiation to the protective tanning response

We are exposed constantly to potentially harmful compounds and radiations. Complex adaptive protective responses have evolved to prevent such agents causing cellular damage, including potentially oncogenic mutation. The p53 tumour suppressor appears to have a role in co-ordinating such responses: it is activated by diverse insults and it acts as a transcriptional regulator of downstream genes that facilitate cellular adaptation. Ultraviolet (UV) light is a particularly potent inducer of p53 expression. In addition, UV light induces the production of melanin as a protection against further irradiation-induced damage. This study shows that the promoters of the genes coding for the enzymes crucial in melanin biosynthesis, namely tyrosinase and tyrosinase-related protein-1 (TRP-1), are activated by wild-type p53. Both promoters have p53-responsive elements and are activated in vivo in a dose-dependent manner by wild-type p53, as well as by the p53 homologues p73alpha and p63alpha.

The phototumorigenic fluoroquinolone lomefloxacin photosensitizes pyrimidine dimer formation in human keratinocytes in vitro

The fluoroquinolone antibiotic lomefloxacin is phototoxic, photogenotoxic, photomutagenic and photosensitizes tumorigenesis in mouse skin. We have used T4 endonuclease V to demonstrate that lomefloxacin photosensitizes pyrimidine dimer formation in a human keratinocyte line (HaCaT). A possible mechanism for this effect would be triplet-triplet energy transfer. However, there is indirect evidence that the lomefloxacin triplet yield is very low, making this reaction less likely. The finding that lomefloxacin photosensitizes production of highly mutagenic pyrimidine dimers correlates with its ability to initiate skin tumor formation in mice. Until the potential of other fluoroquinolones to photosensitize dimer formation is explored it may be unadvisable to prescribe these antibiotics to patients with defective DNA repair capacity (e.g. xeroderma pigmentosum).

Estimation of the effect of increasing UVB exposure on the human immune system and related resistance to infectious diseases and tumours

Exposure to UV light has, besides some beneficial effects (vitamin D production), many harmful effects on human health. UVB irradiation has been shown to suppress both systemic and local immune responses to a variety of antigens, including some microorganisms. However, it is still not known whether such immunomodulating effects may lead to an increase in the number and severity of certain tumours and/or infections in humans. We report herein the data provided by a project that was funded by the European Union (Programme Environment), and that was aimed at the estimation of the risk associated with increased UVB exposure due to ozone depletion regarding the deleterious effects on the immune system and related resistance to tumours and infections in humans. The data, obtained by the different research groups involved, were assembled and used to calculate for the first time a risk assessment for increased environmental exposure to UVB in human subjects.

Photogenotoxicity of skin phototumorigenic fluoroquinolone antibiotics detected using the comet assay

The fluoroquinolone (FQ) antibiotics photosensitize human skin to solar UV radiation and are reported to photosensitize tumor formation in mouse skin. As tumor initiation will not occur without genotoxic insult, we examined the potential of ciprofloxacin, lomefloxacin, fleroxacin, BAYy3118 (a recently developed monofluorinated quinolone) and a nalidixic acid to photosensitize DNA damage in V79 hamster fibroblasts in vitro. Cells were exposed to 37.5 kJ/m2 UVA (320-400 nm; glass filtered Sylvania psoralen + UVA (PUVA) tubes; calibrated Waldmann radiometer) at 4 degrees C in the presence of FQ and immediately afterwards embedded in agarose, lysed and placed in an electrophoretic field at pH 12. Under these denaturing conditions, the presence of DNA single-strand breaks (SSB), alkali-labile sites (ALS) and double-strand breaks (DSB) can be visualized as DNA migrating away from the nucleus (characteristic "comet" appearance) after staining with a specific fluorochrome. At FQ concentrations that induced minimal loss of cell viability (neutral red uptake assay) the compounds tested induced comets with a rank order of BAYy3118 > norfloxacin > ciprofloxacin > lomefloxacin > fleroxacin > nalidixic acid. If cells were incubated after treatment for 1 h at 37 degrees C, the comet score decreased, suggesting efficient removal of SSB/ALS/DSB. Addition of the DNA polymerase(alpha) inhibitor, aphidicolin, to cells treated with either ciprofloxacin alone or ciprofloxacin + UVA resulted in an accumulation of SSB due to the endo/exonuclease steps of excision repair. We have demonstrated that the FQ are photogenotoxic in mammalian cells but the FQ-photosensitized SSB are efficiently repaired. Preliminary evidence that ciprofloxacin photosensitizes the formation of DNA lesions warranting excision repair may indicate production of more mutagenic lesions.

Quercetin prevents UV-induced local immunosuppression, but does not affect UV-induced tumor growth in SKH-1 hairless mice

Ultraviolet is thought to induce skin tumors by its dual activity as a mutagenic agent and a suppressor of cell-mediated immunity. In the present study the effects of quercetin, a flavonoid-containing compound, on carcinogenesis and immunosuppression were studied in SKH hairless mice exposed to suberythemal doses of UV for up to 17 weeks. It was found that quercetin did not affect the onset or growth of non-melanoma skin tumors resulting from UV exposure. In contrast, it prevented the suppression in contact hypersensitivity (CHS) to picryl chloride induced by UV. The mechanism of this prevention might be explained by the observation that the decreased number of epidermal Langerhans' cells is partly prevented by the quercetin. Quercetin did not alter the effects of UV in increasing numbers of spleen and lymph node cells, only partly in decreasing the CD8-positive cells in spleen cell populations and decreasing the lymphoproliferative response of spleen cells to the mitogens concanavalin A and phytohemagglutinin. Thus oral quercetin did not prevent UV-induced carcinogenesis although it restored the skin-associated CHS response probably by protecting the antigen-presenting cells in the skin.

Effects of phototherapy on the production of cytokines by peripheral blood mononuclear cells and on systemic antibody responses in patients with psoriasis

Exposure to ultraviolet B (UVB) radiation results in the suppression of many cell-mediated immune responses, and recent studies mice and murine cells in vitro suggest a shift from a T-helper 1 (Th1) to a Th2 type of response on irradiation. Active psoriasis is considered to be a Th1-type disorder, chiefly on the basis of the cytokines produced by inflammatory cells in psoriatic lesions. We investigated the effect of phototherapy in patients with psoriasis on the cytokine profile of mitogen-stimulated mononuclear cells from peripheral blood and the concentration of IgG subclasses and IgE in the plasma. Eight patients were irradiated with a broad-band UV source (Sylvania UV6; 280-400 nm) three times a week and another eight with a narrow-band UVB source (Philips TL-01; 311-313 nm). Peripheral blood was collected before therapy started and after 1-4 weeks of therapy. Peripheral blood mononuclear cells were stimulated in vitro with phytohemagglutinin; proliferation was measured by incorporation of tritiated thymidine and culture supernatants assayed for interleukin (IL)-2, -4 and -10 and gamma-interferon (IFN) by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays. Lymphoproliferation was not consistently affected by 4 weeks of UV6 therapy, and there was also no consistent change in the production of IL-2, IL-10 or gamma-IFN. In contrast, 4 weeks of TL-01 therapy significantly suppressed lymphoproliferative responses. In addition the production of IL-2, IL-10 and gamma-IFN was lowered after 1 week of TL-01 therapy, and this was even more apparent after the treatment had been extended to 4 weeks. IL-4 concentrations were below detectable levels in all the samples throughout the study. The amounts of IgG1, -2, -3 and -4 and IgE in the plasma of the patients did not vary with either of the two phototherapies. Thus, although no evidence was obtained to indicate that UV6 exposures affected T-helper subsets in psoriasis, TL-01 inhibited the activity of both Th1 and Th2 subsets while not altering plasma antibody concentrations.

Investigating the red shift between in vitro and in vivo urocanic acid photoisomerization action spectra

Trans-urocanic acid (UCA) is found in the upper layer of the skin and UV irradiation induces its photoisomerization to cis-UCA. Cis-UCA mimics some of the immunosuppressive properties of UV exposure. The wavelength dependence for in vitro photoisomerization of trans-UCA (15 microM) over the spectral range 250 nm-340 nm (10 nm intervals) was determined. The action spectrum revealed that maximal cis-UCA production occurred at 280 nm, which is red-shifted by 10-12 nm from its absorption peak at 268 nm and differs markedly from the reported action spectra for cis-UCA production in mouse skin in vivo, which peaks at 300-310 nm. The reasons for the red shift between the in vitro and in vivo action spectra are not clear. There is limited evidence suggesting that the UV absorption maximum of trans-UCA red shifts from 268 nm in vitro to 310 nm on interaction with stratum corneum proteins in vivo. This phenomenon was investigated by applying trans-UCA (2.5 mg/cm2) in an oil emulsion to isolated human stratum corneum. After incubation at 37 degrees C for 1 h, the absorption spectra of stratum corneum with UCA and with oil only were compared using a Xe arc source and a spectroradiometer. A moderate red shift in trans-UCA absorption from approximately 268 nm to 280 nm was observed. In summary, we suggest that the 10-12 nm red shift between the UCA absorption spectrum peak and the action spectrum peak in vitro may be accounted for by the wavelength dependence of quantum yields reported over the 254-313 nm range. The red shift between the in vitro and in vivo photoisomerization action spectra may result from the 10 to 12 nm red shift in the absorption of UCA in association with stratum corneum proteins, combined with increasing quantum yields over the 254-313 nm range.

The role of urocanic acid in UV-induced immunosuppression: recent advances (1992-1994)

Cis-urocanic acid (UCA), formed in the epidermis by UV irradiation of trans-UCA, has been implicated as a mediator of the immunosuppression induced by UV exposure of the skin. This review covers recent work in which the wavelength dependence of cis-UCA formation, the interaction of UCA isomers with DNA, the effects of UCA isomers on the immune system and their interaction with histamine are examined. Results are frequently conflicting, particularly when considering the possible mode of action of cis-UCA but, overall, a multifaceted role for UCA in immunomodulation by UV radiation is substantiated.

Immunomodulation at the initiation of phototherapy and photochemotherapy

The numbers and function of circulating lymphocyte subsets are within normal ranges in patients with psoriasis and are not affected by 4 weeks of ultraviolet (UV) therapy, except for a suppression in natural killer (NK) cell activity. However, it is possible that immunomodulation might occur at the initiation of phototherapy with a return to control values on more prolonged UV exposure. Thus, in this study the responses of 15 patients with chronic plaque psoriasis undergoing broad-band UVB therapy, 10 narrow-band (311-313 nm) UVB therapy and 10 PUVA therapy were compared. In each case, samples were taken immediately before starting treatment and 1 week later. Broad-band UVB and PUVA therapy had no effect on NK activity, but a significant reduction was found in the group receiving narrow-band UVB. In vitro lymphoproliferative responses to mitogens and to herpes simplex virus antigens did not alter with therapy, except there was a significant increase in mitogen responses (at optimal mitogen concentrations only) in the narrow-band UVB group. Generally no alterations in overall percentages of circulating mononuclear cells were found in any group. Samples were taken from the epidermis of the forearm and back of the patients receiving narrow-band UVB for the quantification of urocanic acid (UCA) isomers. The total UCA concentration remained unchanged after 1 week of therapy, while the percentage of cis-UCA increased significantly at both sites in the majority of patients. However, this rise did not correlate with the decrease in NK cell activity and the two parameters may not be related causally.

The phototumorigenic potential of broad-band (270-350 nm) and narrow-band (311-313 nm) phototherapy sources cannot be predicted by their edematogenic potential in hairless mouse skin

The new Philips TL01 narrow-band (311-313 nm) and conventional broad-band (e.g., Philips TL12; 270-350 nm) sources are effective for psoriasis phototherapy, for which treatment regimens are based on a predetermined minimal erythema dose. TL01 phototherapy treatment times are approximately half those with TL12 for psoriasis, whereas the cumulative exposure doses at clearing are similar. We compared the phototumorigenic potential of TL01 and TL12 radiation in mouse skin. Groups of albino Skh-1 hairless mice were exposed for 5 d/week at three dose levels. At each dose level, TL12 and TL01 doses were equally edematogenic. At each dose level, TL01 radiation was significantly more effective at producing first tumors of 1 mm in diameter and multiple tumors. At the lower two dose levels, TL01 radiation produced a significantly greater proportion of squamous cell carcinomas. This study demonstrates that TL01 radiation is more phototumorigenic than TL12 radiation at equally edematogenically weighted doses. This is in contrast with previous reports that edema production by polychromatic sources is predictive of their phototumorigenic effect in Skh-1 mice. The absolute cumulative TL12 dose needed to induce tumors was much less than that for TL01 radiation. The possibility of increased tumor risk with TL01 phototherapy should be considered but must be balanced against the high phototherapeutic efficacy of this source, short treatment times, and the low cumulative doses necessary for clearing of psoriasis.

A comparison of narrow band phototherapy (TL-01) and photochemotherapy (PUVA) in the management of polymorphic light eruption

Twenty-five patients suffering from severe polymorphic light eruption (PLE) were randomized to either photochemotherapy (PUVA) or narrow-band phototherapy (TL-01 UVB) treatment in early spring; patients receiving UVB were given placebo tablets to achieve a matching therapy procedure. During the 4 months following treatment, patient exposure to solar UVB was monitored with polysulphone badges. PLE occurrence, severity, and restriction of outdoor activity were recorded, using weekly diary-sheets. Analysis of covariance on this data, using the logarithm of UVB exposure as the explanatory variable, showed no significant differences between the treatments. TL-01 UVB is an effective alternative to PUVA in the management of PLE.

Comparative potency of broad-band and narrow-band phototherapy sources to induce edema, sunburn cells and urocanic acid photoisomerization in hairless mouse skin

The Philips TL01 narrow-band (311-313 nm) fluorescent lamp provides effective phototherapy for psoriasis and atopic eczema while emitting less erythemogenic radiation than conventional broad-band (e.g. Philips TL12; 270-350 nm) sources. We studied the potency of TL01 and TL12 radiation to induce edema and sunburn cells (SBC) and to photoisomerize naturally occurring trans-urocanic acid (UCA) to cis-UCA in hairless mouse skin. Cis-UCA has immunosuppressive properties and is a putative mediator of UV-induced suppression of immune responses. For each source, there was UV dose dependence for all three responses. Within the dose ranges used, the potency ratio of TL12:TL01 radiation to induce equivalent edema and SBC was about 6:1. However, the potency ratio to induce cis-UCA was less than 2.3:1. Therefore, at a given level of edema or SBC induction, TL01 was more efficient than TL12 at UCA photoisomerization. The TL01 induction of immunomodulating cis-UCA, while causing minimal skin injury, may relate to the therapeutic efficacy of this source in skin conditions with an immunological component.

Action spectra for the trans to cis photoisomerisation of urocanic acid in vitro and in mouse skin

Urocanic acid (UCA) is a major UV chromophore in the upper layers of the skin where it is found predominantly as the trans isomer. UV irradiation induces photoisomerisation of trans-UCA to cis-UCA which has been shown to mimic some of the immunosuppressive properties of UV exposure. We examined the wavelength dependence for trans-UCA to cis-UCA photoisomerisation in vitro and in mouse skin in vivo over the spectral range 270-340 nm. The resulting action spectra were very similar with maximal effectiveness at 300-315 nm and equal activity at 270 nm and 325-330 nm, demonstrating that UVA-II radiation (320-340 nm) is efficient at UCA photoisomerisation. These action spectra differed markedly from the trans-UCA absorption spectrum in vitro and also the reported action spectrum for UV suppression of contact hypersensitivity in mice. These findings suggest that the relationship between cis-UCA formation in skin and UV-induced immunosuppression may be complex.

In vitro phototoxicity of nifedipine: sequential induction of toxic and non-toxic photoproducts with UVA radiation

Anecdotal reports suggest that the dihydropyridine calcium antagonist, nifedipine (NIF), may be phototoxic in human skin. We have studied NIF phototoxicity in vitro using UVA fluorescent tubes (Sylvania PUVA). NIF was phototoxic to Candida albicans and induced photohaemolysis both with NIF present during irradiation and with pre-irradiated drug. In V79 hamster fibroblasts, NIF (10 micrograms ml-1) was phototoxic MTT assay) 24 h after irradiation (0-112 kJ m-2); at 7.5 kJ m-2, about 70% of cells were damaged whilst at 37.5 kJ m-2, only about 45% of cells were damaged. A similar pattern was seen with pre-irradiated NIF. Absorption spectroscopy showed that the NIF absorption maximum (Amax approximately 340 nm) blue-shifted to 314 nm at low UVA doses (7.5 kJ m-2 or less) and red-shifted to 345 nm at higher doses (isosbestic point, 325 nm). Thin layer chromatography of irradiated NIF showed a single photoproduct (PP1; Amax approximately 314 nm) formed at 7.5 kJ m-2 or less which disappeared at higher UVA doses to give further photoproducts. PP1 was highly dark toxic to V79 cells (50% damage at about 5 micrograms ml-1) but PP1 pre-irradiated with UVA was non-toxic. Preliminary gas chromatography-mass spectroscopy studies suggest that PP1 is the nitroso derivative of NIF. These results indicate that NIF phototoxicity in vitro is partially mediated by initial formation of a toxic photoproduct (PP1) but, paradoxically, subsequent UVA irradiation may reduce phototoxicity. The NIF concentrations required to induce in vitro phototoxicity are much greater than therapeutic plasma levels. Unless there is skin accumulation of NIF or PP1, our in vitro results suggest that NIF may not be an important skin-photosensitizing agent in vivo.

Action spectra and chromophores for lethal photosensitization of Candida albicans by DNA monoadducts formed by 8-methoxypsoralen and monofunctional furocoumarins

The red-shift of furocoumarin action spectra, compared with their absorption spectra, has been investigated. An action spectrum for 8-methoxypsoralen (8-MOP) monoadduct formation in the yeast Candida albicans has been determined. The yeast cells were initially exposed to sublethal doses of monochromatic UVA at different wavelengths. Monoadduct formation was monitored by growth inhibition induced, after washing out any unbound 8-MOP, by re-irradiation with a constant second (non-lethal) dose of 330 nm radiation. A comparison between this action spectrum and the absorption spectrum of the dark complex of 8-MOP and DNA was made. In addition, the action spectra of monoadduct formation of five monofunctional compounds including a coumarin derivative have been determined. These action spectra were compared with their respective DNA dark complex absorption spectra. In general, the peaks of the furocoumarin DNA dark complexes show a red-shift when compared with the free furocoumarin molecule and the action spectra show peaks which correspond with the peaks of the dark complexes. Such data indicate that the DNA dark complex is the chromophore for growth inhibition in yeast rather than the free furocoumarin. The similarity of the 8-MOP monoadduct formation action spectrum and 8-MOP action spectra suggests that spectral dependence for the photobiological effects (including the red-shift) is dependent on monoadduct formation rather than, as previously suggested by several authors, crosslink formation. The action spectrum for the coumarin derivative 4-methyl N-ethylpyrrolo (3,2-g) coumarin (PCNEt) correlated well with the free molecule absorption spectrum rather than DNA dark complex indicating that the free molecule is the chromophore.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effects of butylated hydroxytoluene upon PUVA-tumorigenesis and induction of ornithine decarboxylase activity in the mouse

Psoralen photochemotherapy (PUVA) is widely used in the treatment of psoriasis. Some therapy regimen have been associated with increased risk of skin cancer. Free radical species are thought to play a role in psoralen phototoxicity and photocarcinogenesis. It has been reported that the antioxidant butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) inhibits acute phototoxicity by PUVA but does not reduce therapeutic efficacy. It has also been shown that BHT inhibits UVB-induced erythema, tumorigenesis and induction of ornithine decarboxylase (ODC) activity--ODC activity is thought by some to be associated with tumor promotion. Therefore, we have investigated the effect of BHT on psoralen tumorigenesis and PUVA-induced epidermal ODC activity. SKH-Hr-1 hairless albino mice were treated with topically applied 8-MOP and exposed to UVA (3X weekly) for 31 weeks with and without BHT administered either in the diet or topically. Induction of ODC activity was determined in similar experimental groups 24 h after a single exposure to UVA. Neither route of BHT administration had any effect on 8-MOP phototumorigenesis. However, BHT when administered in the diet reduced induction of ODC activity by 40% (p less than 0.05). These data indicate different mechanisms for UVB- and PUVA-induced carcinogenesis and again bring into question the relationship between induction of ODC activity and photocarcinogenesis.

Photophysical, photochemical and photobiological properties of pyrrolocoumarins; a new class of photoactive compounds

With the aim of finding new photoactive compounds that may reduce the side effects of 8-methoxypsoralen photochemotherapy we report on some photophysical, photochemical and photobiological properties of recently synthesized pyrrolocoumarins, in particular 4-methyl-N-ethyl-pyrrolo[3,2-g]coumarin (PCNEt) which has an absorption maximum in the UV-A (320-400 nm). Laser (347 nm) flash photolysis studies showed triplet transients that were quenched by O2 and by ground state PCNEt. Singlet minus triplet spectra were broad (350-550 nm) and, at 700 nm, indicated solvated electron and radical production. PCNEt complexes with DNA in the dark and photobinds to thymine but does not form DNA cross-links. PCNEt was phototoxic in yeast with an action spectrum similar to its absorption spectrum. PCNEt showed photohaemolytic activity but was not phototoxic on guinea pig skin. These data suggest that PCNEt may photosensitize via several mechanisms: direct DNA photobinding, photodynamic action, or photoproduction of radicals.

An adaptation of the Candida albicans phototoxicity test to demonstrate photosensitizer action spectra

The Candida albicans assay is widely used for the testing of potential photosensitizers, especially furocoumarins. A novel adaptation of this assay is described which provides a rapid, inexpensive and easy-to-perform method of producing action spectra. The use of filter paper rectangles with central apertures instead of the usual discs, and monochromatic irradiation with a liquid light guide reduces some of the problems associated with the standard assay. Action spectra for 8-methoxypsoralen and a new pyrrolocoumarin derivative are presented as illustrative examples.

Modification of 5-methoxypsoralen phototumorigenesis by UVB sunscreens: a statistical and histologic study in the hairless albino mouse

Sunscreen preparations containing 5-methoxypsoralen at 25 micrograms/ml and 50 micrograms/ml, and the appropriate vehicle only, sunscreen only, and 5-methoxypsoralen only controls, were assessed for tumorigenic potential in hairless albino mice exposed to solar simulated radiation for a period of 44-46 weeks. Some animals were observed for a 15 week post-irradiation period. A wide range of statistical analyses has shown that, during the course of irradiation, the inclusion of sunscreens eliminates the enhancement of phototumorigenesis and malignancy that is normally observed with 5-methoxypsoralen. There was, however, some indication of increased risk at the end of the postirradiation follow-up period. Possible reasons for the protective effect of the sunscreens and the relevance of these data to the assessment of human risk are discussed.

A strain of hairless mouse susceptible to tumorigenesis by TPA alone: studies with 8-methoxypsoralen and solar simulated radiation

Hairless albino mice were painted with 8-methoxypsoralen (8-MOP) and exposed to solar simulated radiation (SSR) for 0, 3 or 6 weeks and subsequently treated with the promoter 12-O-tetradecanoylphorbol-13-acetate (TPA). TPA was highly tumourigenic in non-pretreated mice. Pretreatment with 8-MOP + SSR did not increase this level of tumorigenesis. It is proposed that 8-MOP + SSR tumour induction was the result of promotion of innate initiated cells and that this mouse strain might be useful as a promoter testing model.

Personal solar UVR exposure: a method of increasing the reliability of measurements made with film badge dosimeters

Polysulphone film, mounted in single aperture badges, has been used extensively to monitor personal solar UVB (280-315 nm) exposure. The reliability of individual badge measurements after exposure to solar simulated radiation was calculated using a 2-way analysis of variance. A new badge mount has been designed with 4 circular apertures. This badge had a 30% greater reliability of measurement than the older badge. The new badges are equally acceptable to clinical trial participants and are more robust in structure. It is suggested that the 4-aperture badge might be a useful successor to the single aperture badge in future studies of this nature.