Knowledge gaps and research priorities in the prevention and control of hepatitis E virus infection

Hepatitis E virus (HEV), family Hepeviridae, is a main cause of epidemic hepatitis in developing countries and sporadic and cluster cases of hepatitis in industrialized countries. There are an increasing number of reported cases in humans especially in industrialized countries, and there is a high potential for transboundary spread of zoonotic genotypes of the virus through the transport of pigs, pig products and by-products. Bloodborne transmission of the virus has been reported with a significant medical concern. To better coordinate HEV research and design better control measures of HEV infections in animals, a group of HEV experts reviewed the current knowledge on the disease and considered the existing disease control tools. It was concluded that there is a lack of in-depth information about the spread of the virus from pigs to humans. The role of animals other than pigs in the zoonotic transmission of the virus to humans and the extent of foodborne transmission are poorly understood. Factors involved in development of clinical disease such as infectious dose, susceptibility and virulence of virus strains need to be studied more extensively. However, such studies are greatly hindered by the absence of a broadly applicable, efficient and sensitive in vitro cell culture system for HEV. Diagnostic tools for HEV are available but need to be further validated, harmonized and standardized. Commercially available HEV vaccines for the control of HEV infection in animal populations are needed as such vaccines can minimize the zoonotic risk for humans. Anti-HEV drugs for treatment of HEV-infected patients need to be studied more extensively. The detailed expert review can be downloaded from the project website at http://www.discontools.eu/.

Molecular detection of hepatitis E virus in wild boar population in eastern Romania

In industrialized countries, Hepatitis E is a recognized zoonosis, with wild boar and swine representing the main reservoirs for zoonotic genotype HEV-3 in Europe. Data related to HEV infection in wild boar population in Romania are restricted to serological surveys. Therefore, our main goal was to determine the HEV prevalence in wild boar population and to characterize HEV strains circulating in Romania. Using TaqMan real-time RT-PCR assay, we analyzed the presence of RNA HEV in 45 liver samples and five spleen samples collected from 50 wild boars. Samples were collected during the 2013-2015 hunting seasons. Nine samples of 50 were tested positive for HEV RNA, resulting an overall prevalence of 18%. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that the isolates clustered in different HEV-3 monophyletic groups, depending on the sampling county. This is the first study signalling, based on molecular analysis, the presence of HEV in wild boar population from Romania. Also, in this study, we report the detection of HEV in splenic tissue from wild boar.

Susceptibility of Pigs to Zoonotic Hepatitis E Virus Genotype 3 Isolated from a Wild Boar

In Europe, zoonotic hepatitis E virus (HEV) genotype 3 strains mainly circulate in humans, swine and wild boar. The aim of this study was to investigate the potential transmission of a wild boar originating HEV strain (WbHEV) to swine by intravenous or oral inoculation and to study the consequences of infection of a WbHEV strain, a WbHEV strain previously passaged in a pig and a swine HEV strain after oral inoculation. Firstly, an intravenous infection was performed for which five piglets were divided into two groups with three pigs inoculated with a WbHEV field strain and two pigs inoculated with a HEV-negative swine liver homogenate. All pigs were necropsied 8, 9 and 10 days post-inoculation. Secondly, an oral infection of 56 days was performed on 12 piglets divided into four groups inoculated with a WbHEV strain, a WbHEV strain previously passaged in swine, a swine HEV strain or a HEV-negative swine liver homogenate. After intravenous inoculation, HEV RNA was detected in serum, bile, liver, spleen, duodenum, jejunum, colon, lung, gastro-hepatic lymph nodes and faeces in all infected piglets. After oral inoculation, HEV RNA was detected in serum, bile, liver, gastro-hepatic lymph nodes and faeces. Most of HEV-inoculated pigs became seropositive at day 15. This study provides experimental evidence of early viral spread throughout the organism after intravenous infection with a WbHEV strain and supports the notion that such a zoonotic strain could be transmitted via the natural faecal-oral route of infection between wild boar and pigs but also between pigs.

Hepatitis E Virus and Related Viruses in Animals

Hepatitis E is an acute human liver disease in healthy individuals which may eventually become chronic. It is caused by the hepatitis E virus (HEV) and can have a zoonotic origin. Nearly 57,000 people die yearly from hepatitis E-related conditions. The disease is endemic in both developing and developed countries with distinct epidemiologic profiles. In developing countries, the disease is associated with inadequate water treatment, while in developed countries, transmission is associated with animal contact and the ingestion of raw or uncooked meat, especially liver. All human HEV are grouped into at least four genotypes, while HEV or HEV-related viruses have been identified in an increasing number of domestic and wild animal species. Despite a high genetic diversity, only one single HEV serotype has been described to date for HEV genotypes 1-4. The discovery of new HEV or HEV-related viruses leads to a continuing increase in the number of genotypes. In addition, the genome organization of all these viruses is variable with overlapping open reading frames (ORF) and differences in the location of ORF3. In spite of the role of some domestic and wild animals as reservoir, the origin of HEV and HEV-related viruses in humans and animals is still unclear. This review discusses aspects of the detection, molecular virology, zoonotic transmission and origin of HEV and HEV-related viruses in the context of 'One Health' and establishes a link between the previous and the new taxonomy of this growing virus family.

Development and validation of a genotype 3 recombinant protein-based immunoassay for hepatitis E virus serology in swine

Hepatitis E virus (HEV) is classified within the family Hepeviridae, genus Hepevirus. HEV genotype 3 (Gt3) infections are endemic in pigs in Western Europe and in North and South America and cause zoonotic infections in humans. Several serological assays to detect HEV antibodies in pigs have been developed, at first mainly based on HEV genotype 1 (Gt1) antigens. To develop a sensitive HEV Gt3 ELISA, a recombinant baculovirus expression product of HEV Gt3 open reading frame-2 was produced and coated onto polystyrene ELISA plates. After incubation of porcine sera, bound HEV antibodies were detected with anti-porcine anti-IgG and anti-IgM conjugates. For primary estimation of sensitivity and specificity of the assay, sets of sera were used from pigs experimentally infected with HEV Gt3. For further validation of the assay and to set the cutoff value, a batch of 1100 pig sera was used. All pig sera were tested using the developed HEV Gt3 assay and two other serologic assays based on HEV Gt1 antigens. Since there is no gold standard available for HEV antibody testing, further validation and a definite setting of the cutoff of the developed HEV Gt3 assay were performed using a statistical approach based on Bayes' theorem. The developed and validated HEV antibody assay showed effective detection of HEV-specific antibodies. This assay can contribute to an improved detection of HEV antibodies and enable more reliable estimates of the prevalence of HEV Gt3 in swine in different regions.

[How to investigate and diagnose autochthonous hepatitis E?]

In developed countries, HEV infection was still recently considered as rare, and as an imported disease from endemic areas by travellers. Hepatitis E virus is now recognized mainly as an autochthonous disease in these countries. Although the source and the route of contamination remain uncertain, several cases of food-borne (zoonotic transmission) and blood-borne transmission have been recently reported. The mortality rates in industrialized countries seems to be higher than in endemic areas, since the infection occurs more frequently in elderly people with underlying chronic liver disease (mortality rate approaching 70% in this subgroup of patients). By contrast, whereas mortality rate rises by 20% during pregnancy in developing countries, no death in pregnant woman from developed countries secondary to an autochthonous case has been reported so far. Lastly, HEV infection may be a cause of chronic hepatitis in immunocompromised patients (mostly in solid organ-transplant recipients) which can evolve to cirrhosis.

A national survey of acute hepatitis E in France

BACKGROUND

Few data are available on the incidence, risk factors and contamination pathways involved in acute indigenous hepatitis E in developed countries.

AIMS

To draw up an overall picture of hepatitis E cases, to confirm whether or not the majority of the cases were indigenous and to attempt to identify the risk factors and contamination pathways involved in hepatitis E.

METHODS

This study was performed in the framework of a national network (ANGH) including 96 participating centres. The 19 centres with at least one case of acute HEV reported a total number of 53 cases.

RESULTS

A decreasing South-to-North geographic gradient was observed. A nonspecific clinical profile was observed in many cases. Acute hepatitis E was of indigenous origin in 90% of the patients. The most relevant and/or frequent possible risk factors among the 47 indigenous metropolitan cases were water consumption from a personal water supply, uncooked shellfish consumption and the recent acquisition of a pet pig.

CONCLUSIONS

This national survey confirmed that acute indigenous hepatitis E is an emerging disease in developed countries such as France, and suggests that various risk factors are responsible for acute indigenous hepatitis E contamination in non-endemic countries.

[Hepatitis E as a zoonosis]

Hepatitis E virus (HEV) is responsible for large waterborne epidemics of acute hepatitis in endemic regions and for autochthonous sporadic cases in non endemic regions. In contrast to endemic regions where the water vector has been well characterised, very little is known about the way of contamination in non endemic regions. Unlike the other hepatitis viruses, HEV has an animal reservoir. Several lines of evidence, such as phylogenic analysis and direct contamination through infected food products, suggest that animal to human transmissions occur. Despite these observations, all origins of possible human contamination in non endemic areas remain unknown and need to be investi- gated. The high genetic variability of HEV might also be an important risk factor for human contamination and need further survey.

Poliovirus persistence in human cells in vitro

Poliovirus (PV) can persist in vivo in the intestine of immunocompromised hosts for years. Moreover, immunocompetent individuals who have survived paralytic poliomyelitis sometimes develop the post-poliomyelitis syndrome (PPS), consisting of a variety of symptoms including new muscular atrophies. PPS may be due to PV persistence. We have developed models of PV persistence in neural cells and epidermoid cells. Cell determinants are of crucial importance for the establishment of persistent infections in human neuronal cells, whereas viral determinants play the primary role in human epidermoid HEp-2 cells. The results obtained with these in vitro models show the capacity of PV to persist and reveal a virus and cell co-evolution involving PV-receptor interactions. In addition, they suggest that several mechanisms are used by PV to establish and maintain persistent infections.

Expression of mutated poliovirus receptors in human neuroblastoma cells persistently infected with poliovirus

Poliovirus (PV) is able to establish persistent infections in human neuroblastoma IMR-32 cells [Colbère-Garapin et al. (1989) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86, 7590]. During persistent infection, PV mutants are selected that display substitutions of residues in regions of the capsid known to interact with the PV receptor (PVR), a glycoprotein of the immunoglobulin superfamily. The mechanism of persistent infection in IMR-32 cells may therefore involve the selection of mutant PVRs. To test this hypothesis, the sequences of the PVR mRNAs in uninfected IMR-32 cells and in two independent IMR-32 cell cultures persistently infected with the Mahoney strain of PV type 1 (PV1/Mahoney) were determined. The PVR mRNA population of uninfected cells was homogeneous, and no mutation was repeatedly found, whereas that of persistently infected cells displayed missense mutations. Particular mutations were repeatedly detected, and all of them mapped to the N-terminal domain of PVR (domain 1), which interacts directly with PV. These mutations generated several types of PVR variants with the following substitutions: Ala67-->Thr alone, Ala67-->Thr associated with Gly39-->Ser, and Arg104-->Gln. Functional analysis of PVR in murine LM cells, stably expressing each of the PVR forms, showed that the PVR forms selected during persistent infection conferred on LM cells partial resistance to PV1/Mahoney-induced lysis. Although adsorption onto PVR seemed to be independent of the PVR form, an analysis of the conformational changes of the capsid during the early steps of the PV cycle provided evidence that the Ser39/Thr67 and Gln104 substitutions almost halved the conversion of 160S infectious particles into 135S A particles associated with the PV-PVR interaction. Altogether, these findings indicate that during persistent infection, specific mutations were selected in the domain 1 of PVR and that these mutations increased the resistance of cells to PV-induced lysis. These results are discussed in view of the position of the mutations on PVR.

Molecular mechanisms of poliovirus persistence: key role of capsid determinants during the establishment phase

As viral persistence is of major medical importance, well-characterized, simple models are needed to improve our understanding of persistent infections. We have chosen to study the molecular mechanisms of viral persistence with the poliovirus (PV), because this picornavirus is one of the best characterized animal viruses, it infects the central nervous system which is a target organ for viral persistence, and it belongs to the Picornaviridae family of viruses, which includes several naturally persisting viruses. We have developed models of PV persistence in neuronal and epidermoid cells, and the present review will focus on the latter one because both lytic and persistent PV strains can be used to study the PV-HEp-2 cell interactions. The viral determinants of persistence have been investigated with this model, and PV determinants have proven to be of crucial importance for the establishment of persistence in HEp-2 cells. Precise determinants of PV persistence have been identified for PV serotypes 1 and 3, in capsid proteins VP1 and VP2. These determinants modify the early steps of the PV cycle, and in particular, the conformational modifications of the capsid following virus adsorption onto its receptor. These results permit us to propose several hypotheses concerning PV persistence and the early steps of the PV cycle.

An approach to understanding the mechanisms of poliovirus persistence in infected cells of neural or non-neural origin

BACKGROUND

Poliovirus (PV) is the etiologic agent of paralytic poliomyelitis, which is sometimes followed, after decades of clinical stability, by new symptoms, including progressive muscular atrophy, collectively known as the post-polio syndrome. This raises the question of possible PV persistence in post polio patients.

OBJECTIVE

To test the capacity of PV to establish persistent infections in human cells, three models were developed.

STUDY DESIGN

This review focuses on the viral and cellular parameters involved in persistent PV infection.

RESULTS

Many PV strains, which are generally lytic in primate cell lines, are able to establish persistent infections in human neuroblastoma cells. During persistent infection, PV mutants (PVpi) are consistently selected, and several of their capsid substitutions occur at positions known to be involved in PV-PV receptor interactions. PVpi have a particular property: they can establish persistent infections in non-neural HEp-2 cells. PV can also persistently infect primary cultures of human fetal brain cells and the majority of cells which survive infection belong to the neuronal lineage.

CONCLUSIONS

The results obtained with the three models of persistent PV infection in human cells suggest that several mechanisms are used by PV to establish and maintain persistent infections in neural and non-neural cells. The interactions of the virus with its receptor seem to be a key-step in all cases. In the future, the elucidation of the etiology of the post-polio syndrome will require the characterization of PV sequences having persisted for decades in post-polio patients.

Molecular aspects of poliovirus biology with a special focus on the interactions with nerve cells

Poliovirus (PV), the pathogenic agent of paralytic poliomyelitis, is the prototype of the picornavirus family. Although paralytic poliomyelitis has been nearly totally eradicated in most industrialized countries, PV continues to be an important public health problem in many developing countries. Moreover, in industrialized countries, two current concerns are the occurrence, albeit at a very low frequency, of vaccine-associated paralytic poliomyelitis, due to the genetic instability of the attenuated oral PV strains in vaccines, and the emergence of a neuro-muscular pathology in many survivors of the acute disease, called the post-polio syndrome. PV has been targeted by the World Health Organization for world-wide eradication in the coming decade and continues to be the subject of intensive research. The advances made in the molecular biology of PV, taken together with the development of new animal and cell models, have permitted a new look at a key step in the pathogenesis of poliomyelitis, i.e. the interactions between PV and nerve cells. These aspects of PV biology are developed in this review according to three themes: (i) the PV host range; (ii) the molecular determinants of PV neurovirulence and attenuation; and (iii) the persistence of PV in nerve cells, which has proven to be an interesting new domain in the field of PV research.

Persistent poliovirus infection of human fetal brain cells

It has been suggested that poliovirus (PV), the causative agent of poliomyelitis, could persist in surviving patients. We have previously shown that PV can persistently infect some human cell lines in vitro, particularly neuroblastoma cell lines. We report here an ex vivo model in which PV can persistently infect primary cultures of human fetal brain cells. Two mutations involving capsid residues 142 of VP2 and 95 of VP1 were repeatedly selected during the persistent infections. These residues are located in capsid regions known to be involved in interactions between PV and its receptor. During the first week after infection, viral antigens were found in cells of both the neuronal and glial lineages. In contrast, 2 weeks after infection, viral antigens were detected almost exclusively in cells of the neuronal lineage. They were detected predominantly in cells expressing a marker of early commitment to the neuronal lineage, MAP-5, particularly in neuroblasts. Viral antigens were also found in immature progenitors expressing a neuroepithelium marker, nestin, and in cells expressing a marker of postmitotic neurons, MAP-2. The presence of viral antigens in postmitotic neurons suggests that PV can persist in neurons of patients who have survived poliomyelitis.