Towards Cooperative Patient Management Through Organizational and Medical Ontologies

Within knowledge and data engineering a new research paradigm is emerging based on the Multi-Agent System (MAS) architectural framework, allowing human and software agents to interoperate and thus cooperate within common application areas. In such a framework, knowledgeable agents of heterogeneous nature, that possess diverse but at least partially compatible or inter-translatable conceptual views, or ontologies, modeling both their own expertise and the external environment, make somehow available their information resources or problem-solving abilities for cooperative processes addressing the construction of a new agent or the achievement of some common goal through a correlated execution of tasks.

In this paper, we restrict our analysis to the case of an organization of cognitive agents, illustrated with examples from a prototypical healthcare MAS, that is, a so-called Distributed Healthcare Information System (D-HIS). The prototype makes use of an ontological library written in the standard language Ontolingua. An ongoing application of the methodology to the main problem of Clinical Practice Guidelines (GLs) computer-based dissemination and enforcement is described.

The beneficial effects of combining pharmacological and psychosocial treatment on remission and functional outcome in outpatients with schizophrenia

OBJECTIVE

The effects of pharmacological and psychosocial treatment on remission and the functional outcome in outpatients with schizophrenia were evaluated. Remission was assessed according to the criteria proposed by the Remission in Schizophrenia Working group and psychosocial functioning according to the Global Assessment of Functioning with a score > 60. Functional outcome was the result of these two variables.

METHOD

One hundred fifty two patients were randomized to receive either, antipsychotic treatment as usual (TAU) or social skills training and family psychoeducation in addition to TAU. A final sample of 119 patients: n = 68 in the social skills training group, and n = 51 in the TAU group completed the study protocol. Patients were assessed at baseline and at 6-month follow-up.

RESULTS

At the end of the study, 80% of the patients fulfilled the criteria for symptomatic remission: 62 patients (91.2%) in the social skills training group in contrast to 34 patients (66.7%) in the TAU group. Functional improvement criteria were accomplished by 41 patients (34.5%) at the endpoint of the study. Forty of these patients (58.8%) belonged to social skills training and one patient to customary treatment (χ(2) = 41.7, df 1, p < 0.001) and when criteria for symptomatic remission and functional improvement were combined, 39 patients (97.5%) of the social skills training group and one patient (1.9%) of the customary treatment group achieved functional outcome.

CONCLUSION

The results emphasize the need for psychosocial interventions as conjoint to pharmacological treatment to improve functional outcome in schizophrenia patients.

[Development and psychometric properties of a brief instrument to measure the stigma of aggressiveness in schizophrenia]

INTRODUCTION

Schizophrenia has been object of stigmatization throughout history. A critical component of stigma in schizophrenia is the perception that patients are extremely dangerous. The assessment of this concept in general population by the use of reliable and valid instruments will allow the development of programs aimed to reduce it.

OBJECTIVE

To develop an assessment instrument of the public conception of aggressiveness in schizophrenia and to determine its reliability and validity in a community sample of Mexico City.

METHOD

A total of 258 subjects completed the Public Conception of Aggressiveness Questionnaire (CAQ) which is made up of a brief clinical vignette and specific questions that assess subjective conceptions about aggressiveness and mental disorders in patients with schizophrenia.

RESULTS

More than 40.0% of the sample considered that the patient with schizophrenia is aggressive and dangerous. The CAQ had an adequate internal consistency (alpha=0.74). The results of the factorial analysis showed that the two factors that explained 61.0% of the variance.

DISCUSSION

The items of CAQ showed two major areas that evaluate: a) perception of presentation of aggressive behaviors and, b) mental illness recognition and social aspects of the stigma of dangerousness. The CAQ is an instrument with adequate psychometric properties that could be useful to evaluate the perception of aggressiveness in schizophrenia among general population.

Towards cooperative patient management through organizational and medical ontologies

Within knowledge and data engineering a new research paradigm is emerging based on the Multi-Agent System (MAS) architectural framework, allowing human and software agents to interoperate and thus cooperate within common application areas. In such a framework, knowledgeable agents of heterogeneous nature, that possess diverse but at least partially compatible or inter-translatable conceptual views, or ontologies, modeling both their own expertise and the external environment, make somehow available their information resources or problem-solving abilities for cooperative processes addressing the construction of a new agent or the achievement of some common goal through a correlated execution of tasks. In this paper, we restrict our analysis to the case of an organization of cognitive agents, illustrated with examples from a prototypical healthcare MAS, that is, a so-called Distributed Healthcare Information System (D-HIS). The prototype makes use of an ontological library written in the standard language Ontolingua. An ongoing application of the methodology to the main problem of Clinical Practice Guidelines (GLs) computer-based dissemination and enforcement is described.

A patient workflow management system built on guidelines

To provide high quality, shared, and distributed medical care, clinical and organizational issues need to be integrated. This work describes a methodology for developing a Patient Workflow Management System, based on a detailed model of both the medical work process and the organizational structure. We assume that the medical work process is represented through clinical practice guidelines, and that an ontological description of the organization is available. Thus, we developed tools 1) for acquiring the medical knowledge contained into a guideline, 2) to translate the derived formalized guideline into a computational formalism, precisely a Petri Net, 3) to maintain different representation levels. The high level representation guarantees that the Patient Workflow follows the guideline prescriptions, while the low level takes into account the specific organization characteristics and allow allocating resources for managing a specific patient in daily practice.

An ontology-based framework for guideline-driven medical practice

This paper describes a general framework for clinical practice guidelines development, dissemination and use. We propose an ontological description of the medical knowledge and of the organizational context, in order to produce clinical guidelines which, on one hand, can be widely shared between different institutions and, on the other, can be efficiently tailored to consider the peculiarities of each clinical context.

[Factors affecting recurrence after surgical treatment of Crohn disease]

Surgery does not cure Crohn's disease, but only its complications, as the recurrence rate that requires a new intervention is 6% per year. The resections performed by the surgeon should be as limited as possible, in order to avoid the consequent malabsorption. The identification of two forms of Crohn's disease, with different aggressiveness, has found that the stricturoplastic is an encouraging way of treatment for those forms with a prevalent stenotic component. A lot of studies have evaluated the relationships between recurrences and resections on margins microscopically free or affected by the disease. The aim of this study was a retrospective verification of the influence of any possible microscopical residue of the disease on the recurrence rate, evaluating whether the two different forms of aggressiveness of the disease (presence of stenosis or fistula) can influence the rate and precocity of the recurrence onset. In 37 patients operated for the first time of ileal or ileocolic resection, the overall recurrence rate was 18.9%; neither the presence of microscopically affected margins nor the presence of fistulas or stenosis has showed to have an influence on the onset of the recurrences. The only data that emerged is a greater precocity of the onset of recurrence in those patients whose disease was characterised by the presence of enteric fistulas. The forms in which fistulas and perforations were evident showed a recurrence rate not significantly higher than that of forms with stenosis only, but the period of time free from the disease was notably longer for the latter. In the end, patients in which typical granulomas were present showed a recurrence rate of just 9%, compared to 23% of patients in which granulomas were absent. MATERIALS AND METHODS. From 1980 through 1992, 61 patients affected by Crohn's disease were operated. There were 39 men and 22 women (mean age: 40.4 years). The mean length of the follow-up was 55.5 months. It was the first operation for 43 patients, while 9 had already undergone surgery in other hospitals; 9 patients showed anorectal complications. The operations performed on the patients for the first time have been ileal resection in the following localizations: duodenum-jejunum 4, jejunum and ileal 34, colic 5; the recurrences treated have been ileal-jejunum in 7 cases and colic in 2. In 2 cases of recurrence a stricturoplastic has been performed. RESULTS. The operative mortality was of 3 patients: 2 due to sepsis for anastomotic dehiscence and 1 to systemic mycosis. Four postoperative fistulas were observed. Recurrence of the disease occurred in 13 patients (26.5%), specifically in 21.4% of the patients operated for the first time and in 57.1% of those that were operated for recurrences. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS. In the treatment of Crohn's disease, it is important to identify any possible group with high risk of recurrence in order to undertake an appropriate medical prophylaxis. The results concerning the presence of microscopical disease on the resection margins are today still controversial. Some groups of authors prefer wide resection margins, some others are in favour of restricted resections. Our considerations let us assert that in those patients in which the resections have been performed on margins with microscopic presence of the disease, the interval before the recurrence occurs is not significantly shorter than that of patients with free margins. But the patients suffering from Crohn's disease with fistulae, probably need medical post-operative therapy to delay recurrences onset.

[Surgical treatment of rectal cancer: prognostic factors for long-term survival]

The aim of our retrospective study was to verify the results of surgical treatment of rectal cancer in a homogeneous case series, evaluating the various factors that can influence the prognosis and long-term results. The prognostic factors taken into consideration were: Duke's stage; grading; colloid component; location of tumour; type of surgical intervention; age; sex; duration of the symptoms; length of normal rectum below the lower border of the tumour correlated to stage and grading. One hundred and sixty-five patients were operated with a radical approach: 50 abdominoperineal resections (APR) and 115 sphincter-saving resections (SSR) were performed. There were 90 males and 75 females. The mean age was 63 years. Total survival was 61.7% after 5 years and 50% after 10 years. In our study neither the age nor the sex, duration of symptoms or location of the tumours proved to have an influence on survival; while Duke's state turned out to be decisive for survival; also the colloid tumour component proved to have a worse prognosis. The 5-10-year survival rate was respectively 53.6% and 49% in the APR and 65.7% and 50.9% in the SSR (p = n.s.). The data we have collected show that APR and SSR operations have analogous efficiency.