Process evaluation of a university residence-based SARS-CoV-2 testing programme in the UK

Background

Regular testing for SARS-CoV-2 is an important strategy for controlling virus outbreaks on university campuses during the COVID-19 pandemic but testing participation can be low. The Residence-Based Testing Participation Pilot (RB-TPP) was a novel 4-week intervention implemented at two student residences on a UK university campus, aiming to increase asymptomatic testing frequency and normalise university life through relaxed social restrictions onsite.

Methods

Mixed-methods process evaluation determined whether RB-TPP was implemented as planned and identified implementation barriers and facilitators. Data were collected from meeting records, university students (online survey: n = 152; focus groups: n = 30), and staff (interviews, n = 13). Barriers and facilitators to implementation were mapped to the ‘Capability, Opportunity, Motivation-Behaviour’ (COM-B) behaviour change framework.

Results

Uptake was high (n = 464 students opted-in; 98% of those living onsite). Implementation was broadly as planned, with adjustments due to national escalation of the COVID-19 Delta variant. Majority engaged in testing (88%); 46% (52% of testers) were fully compliant with pre-determined testing frequency. Most felt positively towards relaxed social distancing (97.9%). Implementation was facilitated by convenience and efficiency of testing and reduced negative impacts of isolation through opportunities for students to socialise. Barriers to implementation were mixed-messages about the rules, ambivalent attitudes, and lack of adherence to COVID-19 protective measures in the minority.

Conclusions

This is the first process evaluation of the implementation of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 testing in university residences. Testing participation increased and student mental wellbeing improved. Rapid adaptions to the changing pandemic context generated complexity and challenge. Findings have global relevance for outbreak prevention and management strategies in higher education settings.

Key messages

• Delivery of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 testing and relaxation of social distancing within residences led to high rates of testing participation and benefits for student mental wellbeing.

• This is the first process evaluation of the implementation of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 testing in university residences with global relevance for outbreak prevention in higher education settings.

Mixed-methods process evaluation of a residence-based SARS-CoV-2 testing participation pilot on a UK university campus during the COVID-19 pandemic

BACKGROUND

Regular testing for Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) is an important strategy for controlling virus outbreaks on university campuses during the COVID-19 pandemic but testing participation rates can be low. The Residence-Based Testing Participation Pilot (RB-TPP) was a novel intervention implemented at two student residences on a large UK university campus over 4 weeks. The aim of the pilot was to increase the frequency of asymptomatic SARS-CoV-2 saliva testing onsite. This process evaluation aimed to determine whether RB-TPP was implemented as planned and identify implementation barriers and facilitators.

METHODS

A mixed-methods process evaluation was conducted alongside the RB-TPP. Evaluation participants were students (opting in, or out of RB-TPP) and staff with a role in service provision or student support. Monitoring data were collected from the intervention delivery team and meeting records. Data were collected from students via online survey (n = 152) and seven focus groups (n = 30), and from staff via individual interviews (n = 13). Quantitative data were analysed descriptively and qualitative data thematically. Barriers and facilitators to implementation were mapped to the 'Capability, Opportunity, Motivation-Behaviour' (COM-B) behaviour change framework.

RESULTS

Four hundred sixty-four students opted to participate in RB-TPP (98% of students living onsite). RB-TPP was implemented broadly as planned but relaxed social distancing was terminated early due to concerns relating to national escalation of the COVID-19 Delta variant, albeit testing continued. Most students (97.9%) perceived the period of relaxed social distancing within residences positively. The majority engaged in asymptomatic testing (88%); 46% (52% of testers) were fully compliant with pre-determined testing frequency. Implementation was facilitated by convenience and efficiency of testing, and reduction in the negative impacts of isolation through opportunities for students to socialise. Main barriers to implementation were perceived mixed-messages about the rules, ambivalent attitudes, and lack of adherence to COVID-19 protective measures in the minority.

CONCLUSIONS

This process evaluation identifies factors that help or hinder the success of university residence-based outbreak prevention and management strategies. RB-TPP led to increased rates of SARS-CoV-2 testing participation among students in university residences. Perceived normalisation of university life significantly enhanced student mental wellbeing. The complexity and challenge generated by multiple lines of communication and rapid adaptions to a changing pandemic context was evident.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

UKAS 307727-02-01; Pre-results.

CLINICALTRIALS

gov Identifier: NCT05045989 ; post-results (first posted, 16/09/21).

ETHICAL APPROVAL

Faculty of Medicine & Health Sciences Research Ethics Committee, University of Nottingham (Ref: FMHS 96-0920).

Unexpected involvement of a second rodent species makes impacts of introduced rats more difficult to detect

Rodent predators are implicated in declines of seabird populations, and removing introduced rats, often, but not always, results in the expected conservation gains. Here we investigated the relationship between small mammal (Norway rat, wood mouse and pygmy shrew) abundance and Manx shearwater breeding success on the island of Rum, Scotland, and tested whether localised rodenticide treatments (to control introduced Norway rats) increased Manx shearwater breeding success. We found that Manx shearwater breeding success was negatively correlated with late summer indices of abundance for rats and mice, but not shrews. On its own, rat activity was a poor predictor of Manx shearwater breeding success. Rat activity increased during the shearwater breeding season in untreated areas but was supressed in areas treated with rodenticides. Levels of mouse (and shrew) activity increased in areas treated with rodenticides (likely in response to lower levels of rat activity) and Manx shearwater breeding success was unchanged in treated areas (p < 0.1). The results suggest that, unexpectedly, negative effects from wood mice can substitute those of Norway rats and that both species contributed to negative impacts on Manx shearwaters. Impacts were intermittent however, and further research is needed to characterise rodent population trends and assess the long-term risks to this seabird colony. The results have implications for conservation practitioners planning rat control programmes on islands where multiple rodent species are present.

Making the case for a 'fifth wave' in public health

This paper will argue that the UK has seen several phases of public health improvement since the Industrial Revolution, and that each of these can be linked to major shifts in thinking about the nature of society and health itself. The authors are not, however, attempting to delineate firm sequences of events (or imply causality) as this would require a level of analysis of the relationship between economy, society and culture which is beyond the scope of this paper. Rather, it is suggested that each phase of health improvement can be thought of in metaphorical terms as a 'wave'. The first wave is associated with great public works and other developments arising from social responses to the profound disruptions which followed the Industrial Revolution. The second wave saw the emergence of medicine as science. The third wave involved the redesign of our social institutions during the 20th Century and gave birth to the welfare state. The fourth wave has been dominated by efforts to combat disease risk factors and the emergence of systems thinking. Although a trough of public health activity continues from each wave, none exerts the same impact as when it first emerged. This paper will discuss the complex challenges of obesity, inequality and loss of wellbeing, together with the broader problems of exponential growth in population, money creation and energy usage. As exponential growth is unsustainable on a finite planet, inevitable change looms. Taken together, these analyses suggest that a fifth wave of public health development is now needed; one which will need to differ radically from its forerunners. The authors invite others to join them in envisioning its nature and in furthering the debate about future public health.

'When the talking starts': a framework for analysing tutorials

The drive towards learner-centred learning which will equip doctors for the next century has encouraged the exploration of alternative ways of learning. A fundamental assumption is that a new learning strategy will either fit into existing patterns or trigger changes in the way that teachers and learners talk together. Despite the use of videotaped tutorials within re-accreditation visits in parts of the UK, the literature reveals no currently existing frameworks to analyse these teaching/learning interactions in the general practice setting. In this qualitative study of tutorials in general practice vocational training, a new grounded theory was developed. This study was innovative in its use of audiotaped tutorials as opposed to espoused theories of interaction. The new theoretical framework of Trainer/GP Registrar interactions consists of five categories: 'gaps to be filled', 'listening in', 'quick fix', 'problem solving' and 'talk on'. Each category illustrates whose agenda was met, who triggers the learning issue, time factors, the educational philosophy and the degree of reflection encouraged. The key principle underpinning this framework is that for learning to be effective a range of educational transactions may need to occur. If educational transactions occur exclusively around one point on the framework, the quality of training and opportunities for critical reflection may suffer. This framework may have implications for the analysis by Trainers of their teaching dialogues in the same way that consultation analysis has informed the development of consultation styles in general practice.

Schistosoma mansoni: evaluation of selected preparative procedures for transmission and scanning electron microscopy

Evaluation of numerous procedures for collection and preparation of Schistosoma mansoni for scanning (SEM) and transmission microscopy (TEM) revealed that some commonly used methods result in introduction of osmotic or mechanical damage. Modification and selection of appropriate procedures allowed elimination of these artifacts. Not eliminated by these procedures, however, were several kinds of spheres and blebs that were either external to the apical plasma membrane of the tegument or budding from it. After careful examination of all procedures, we concluded that these spheres appear to some extent on all schistosomes prepared for either SEM or TEM and may represent either a normal component of the schistosome surface, a constant host contaminant, or an artifact not eliminated by any of the multiple modifications of technique examined.

Schistosoma mansoni: morphologic changes induced by maintenance in vitro

Adults of Schistosoma mansoni were incubated in several culture media at various time intervals ranging from 2 to 96 hr. The morphologic changes induced by the incubation were documented using both scanning and transmission electron microscopy. These included changes in the tegument, esophageal cells, and cecum. Variability was noted among worms within experimental groups and the surface changes on single worms were frequently observed to have patchy distribution. Based on morphologic changes observed, culture media were ranked as adequate, mediocre, or inadequate. RPMI-1640 + 50% fetal calf serum, Eagle's MEM with Earle's salts (no serum), and McCoy's 5A Medium + serum were judged adequate. Basal Eagle's Medium, Triple Eagle Medium, NCTC-135, and Earle's Balanced Salt Solution (all with or without serum) were judged mediocre. Hanks' Basal Salt Solution (with or without serum) was judged as severely inadequate. All media tested gave better results in the presence of serum. These factors point to the necessity for the use of carefully selected culture media, as well as adequate controls and sampling techniques in the interpretation of in vitro experiments with S. mansoni.

Fetal exposure to maternal hyperbilirubinemia. Neonatal course and outcome

A case of prolonged fetal exposure to hyperbilirubinemia occurred in a mother with end-stage liver disease during the second and third trimester of pregnancy. At birth, the infant had elevated levels of both conjugated and unconjugated serum bilirubin that required multiple-exchange transfusions during the first three days of life. The infant exhibited abnormal neurologic findings at birth that resolved during the neonatal period. The results of subsequent developmental and neurologic evaluation were normal at 14 months of follow-up. Prolonged fetal exposure to elevated serum bilirubin levels may not necessarily result in developmental or neurologic handicap.

Separation and detection of lipoproteins in human serum by use of size-exclusion liquid chromatography: a preliminary report

Components of human serum can be separated on the basis of differences in relative molecular mass by using size-exclusion "high-performance" liquid chromatography. Lipoproteins in fractions of the eluate can be quantitated by conventional chemical and enzymatic methods. Alternatively, if lipoproteins in the serum are selectively prestained with diformazan dye, the column effluent can be monitored spectrophotometrically at 580 nm, so that only the lipoprotein components of serum are detected. Samples of purified low-density lipoproteins, so stained and analyzed, provide peak-area values that are proportional to their concentration as evaluated by chemical methods. With this technique, the various lipoprotein classes can be quickly separated and their concentration estimated. These techniques should prove useful in clinical and research laboratories.

Separation and detection of lipoproteins in human serum by use of size-exclusion liquid chromatography: a preliminary report

Components of human serum can be separated on the basis of differences in relative molecular mass by using size-exclusion "high-performance" liquid chromatography. Lipoproteins in fractions of the eluate can be quantitated by conventional chemical and enzymatic methods. Alternatively, if lipoproteins in the serum are selectively prestained with diformazan dye, the column effluent can be monitored spectrophotometrically at 580 nm, so that only the lipoprotein components of serum are detected. Samples of purified low-density lipoproteins, so stained and analyzed, provide peak-area values that are proportional to their concentration as evaluated by chemical methods. With this technique, the various lipoprotein classes can be quickly separated and their concentration estimated. These techniques should prove useful in clinical and research laboratories.

Evidence for two insulin receptor populations on human erythrocytes

Human erythrocytes specifically bind 125I-insulin in a manner similar to cells in which insulin exerts a physiological response. In addition, erythrocytes are of practical value for correlating in vitro insulin binding with in vivo carbohydrate intolerance. The competitive binding of labelled and unlabelled insulin to erythrocyte receptor3 is typically curvilinear when plotted according to Scatchard. The curvilinear nature of the Scatchard plot describing insulin binding to membrane receptors, although originally attributed to heterogeneous sites, has been more recently interpreted as negative cooperativity between homogenous sites. Evidence reported here, however, suggests that there are two populations of insulin receptors on erythrocytes. Specific concentrations of concanavalin A (Con A), a lectin which mimics insulin activity, are shown here to inhibit one population of receptors leaving another population unaffected.

Effects of parasympathominetics on porcine stillbirth

To study the effect of 2 parasympathomimetic drugs in reduction of incidence of stillborn pigs, 84 sows and gilts were randomly allotted to 3 treatment groups. Single 1-ml injections of isotonic saline solution, carbachol (2 mg/ml), or neostigmine bromide (5 mg/ml) were subcutaneously administered to pigs of groups A, B, and C, respectively. Injections were given midway through parturition in an attempt to hasten the delivery of the last pigs in the litter, where the corresponding incidence of stillbirth is greatest. The mean time of injection was after the birth of 3.5 pigs. Total stillbirths/litter for carbachol-treated (0.23) and neostigmine-treated (0.21) pies were significantly different (P greater than 0.0001) from those for control pigs (0.88). Before injection, stillbirths/litter for control pigs (0.23) were not significantly different from those for carbachol-treated (0.18) or neostigmine-treated (0.12) pigs. After treatment, stillbirths/litter for carbachol-treated (0.06) and neostigmine-treated (0.09) pigs were both significantly different (P greater than 0.0001) from those for saline solution-treated control pigs (0.65). When injected midway through parturition, carbachol and neostigmine reduced stillbirth rate by reducing stillbirths which occur late in farrowing.

Bi-frontal stereotactic tractotomy. A follow-up study of its effects on 210 patients

Since 1955 there has been a steady decline in the number of leucotomy operations, particularly of the open standard type introduced into this country in 1941. It has been considered by most authors that the undesirable side-effects caused this decline but no doubt the introduction of ataractic drugs also played its part (Pippard, 1962). Sykes and Tredgold (1964) discussed in detail the literature up to that time and it was felt unnecessary to repeat that survey here. Suffice it to say that from about 1949 various modifications of the standard operation were devised in the hope of diminishing or eliminating undesirable sequelae. Following the publication of a paper on the late social results of pre-frontal leucotomy by Ström-Olsen and Tow (1949) the late Alexander Kennedy (1949) wrote in the correspondence column of theLancet—‘The future of this kind of operation (i.e. standard leucotomy) lies in limited and accurately localized sections. The correlation of these with their clinical and neuropathological effects offers a field of study which will occupy us for many years to come’.