Factors affecting the activity of phenolic disinfectants

Low challenge phenol coefficient and high challenge use-dilution tests were made on a neutral cocoanut oil soap emulsion of o-phenylphenol and aqueous solutions of sodium o-phenylphenate prepared in the laboratory from the phenol using a stoichiometric amount of NaOH as well as with increasing amounts of excess NaOH. The phenol had considerably greater activity in both test methods when emulsified with the neutral soap than when converted to the phenate and dissolved in water. Use dilution test results against Salmonella choleraesuis with both the phenol and the phenate were within the range which would have been predicted from the Salmonella typhosa coefficient results employing the conventional conversion multiple of 20 to determine the maximal number of parts of water to which one part of germicide could be added. With the emulsified phenol this was also true where Staphylococcus aureus was employed in both procedures. With the aqueous solution of the phenate the maximal safe use-dilution by the phenol coefficient found for S. aureus and the same conventional conversion procedure was roughly five times higher than the maximal safe use-dilution found by the use-dilution method. Results with aqueous solutions of the phenate to which increasing amounts of excess NaOH were added showed no significant differences in the phenol coefficient method with either S. typhosa or S. aureus. In the use-dilution method, significant decreases in activity were found as the excess NaOH was increased to 4% with both S. choleraesuis and S. aureus. Although the pH values of aqueous solutions of the phenate were raised as the amount of free NaOH was increased, the decreases in pH observed as the dilution with water was increased were such that only small differences existed at the high critical killing dilutions found in the low challenge phenol coefficient method, whereas rather large differences existed at the lower critical killing dilutions in the high challenge use-dilution method.