SLC6A8 creatine transporter deficiency can be detected by plasma creatine and creatinine concentrations

Creatine transporter deficiency has been described with normal or uninformative levels of creatine and creatinine in plasma, while urine has been the preferred specimen type for biochemical diagnosis. We report a cohort of untreated patients with creatine transporter deficiency and abnormal plasma creatine panel results, characterized mainly by markedly decreased plasma creatinine. We conclude that plasma should be considered a viable specimen type for the biochemical diagnosis of this disorder, and abnormal results should be followed up with further confirmatory testing.

Dodecyl creatine ester therapy: from promise to reality

Pathogenic variants in SLC6A8, the gene which encodes creatine transporter SLC6A8, prevent creatine uptake in the brain and result in a variable degree of intellectual disability, behavioral disorders (e.g., autism spectrum disorder), epilepsy, and severe speech and language delay. There are no treatments to improve neurodevelopmental outcomes for creatine transporter deficiency (CTD). In this spotlight, we summarize recent advances in innovative molecules to treat CTD, with a focus on dodecyl creatine ester, the most promising drug candidate.

Elevated amyloid beta peptides and total tau in cerebrospinal fluid in individuals with Creatine transporter deficiency

Background

Creatine transporter deficiency (CTD) is a rare X-linked disorder of creatine transport caused by pathogenic variants in SLC6A8 (Xq28). The disorder is marked by developmental delay, especially speech delay. The biomarkers Aβ40, Aβ42 and total tau are abnormal in Alzheimer disease (AD), a common neurodegenerative disorder pathologically characterized by Aβ peptide containing amyloid plaques and tau neurofibrillary tangles. Although CTD results in neuronal energy deficiency, the pathological processes underlying the CTD phenotype are not fully characterized.

Methods

Cerebral spinal fluid (CSF) was collected as an optional part of a natural history study of CTD. Aβ40, Aβ42 and total tau levels were quantified in CSF from individuals with CTD and from age-appropriate comparison samples. Neuro3-Plex enzyme-linked immunoassay was performed on a Quanterix SR-X instrument. The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale, 3rd Edition was used to determine an overall Adaptive Behavior Composite (ABC) standard score.

Results

CSF from 12 individuals with CTD and 23 age appropriate non-CTD comparison samples were analyzed. We found that levels of total tau [t(32) = 4.05, p = 0.0003], Aβ40 [t(31) = 6.11, p < 0.0001], and Aβ42 [t(32) = 3.20, p = 0.003] were elevated in the participants with CTD relative to the comparison group. Additionally, except for one individual that we considered an outlier, all three biomarkers correlated inversely with the adaptive behavior score (total tau: ρ = -0.60 [-0.88, 0.005]; Aβ40: ρ = -0.67 [-0.91, -0.12]; Aβ42: ρ = -0.62 [-0.89, -0.02]).

Conclusion

We describe here the novel finding of elevated protein biomarkers in the CSF of individuals with CTD. Aβ40, Aβ42 and total tau are markedly elevated in individuals with CTD compared to comparison samples, and increased levels of these biomarkers inversely correlated with ABC scores. We hypothesize that elevated CSF levels of Aβ40 and Aβ42 are due to cellular energy deficiency. Elevated CSF total tau levels may indicate ongoing neuronal damage. The observed inverse correlation of Vineland ABC scores with increased biomarker levels needs to be confirmed in a larger CTD cohort; however, our observation of increased Aβ40, Aβ42 and total tau levels in CSF from individuals with CTD may provide insight into pathological mechanisms contributing to the CTD phenotype and may prove useful as supportive data in future therapeutic trials.

X-linked creatine transporter (SLC6A8) deficiency in females: Difficult to recognize, but a potentially treatable disease

Creatine transporter deficiency (CTD), caused by pathogenic variants in SLC6A8, is the second most common cause of X-linked intellectual disability. Symptoms include intellectual disability, epilepsy, and behavioral disorders and are caused by reduced cerebral creatine levels. Targeted treatment with oral supplementation is available, however the treatment efficacy is still being investigated. There are clinical and theoretical indications that heterozygous females with CTD respond better to supplementation treatment than hemizygous males. Unfortunately, heterozygous females with CTD often have more subtle and uncharacteristic clinical and biochemical phenotypes, rendering diagnosis more difficult. We report a new female case who presented with learning disabilities and seizures. After determining the diagnosis with molecular genetic testing confirmed by proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (1H-MRS), the patient was treated with supplementation treatment including creatine, arginine, and glycine. After 28 months of treatment, the patient showed prominent clinical improvement and increased creatine levels in the brain. Furthermore, we provide a review of the 32 female cases reported in the current literature including a description of phenotypes, genotypes, diagnostic approaches, and effects of supplementation treatment. Based on this, we find that supplementation treatment should be tested in heterozygous female patients with CTD, and a prospective treatment underlines the importance of diagnosing these patients. The diagnosis should be suspected in a broad clinical spectrum of female patients and can only be made by molecular genetic testing. 1H-MRS of cerebral creatine levels is essential for establishing the diagnosis in females, and especially valuable when assessing variants of unknown significance.

Cell-specific vulnerability to metabolic failure: the crucial role of parvalbumin expressing neurons in creatine transporter deficiency

Mutations in the solute carrier family 6-member 8 (Slc6a8) gene, encoding the protein responsible for cellular creatine (Cr) uptake, cause Creatine Transporter Deficiency (CTD), an X-linked neurometabolic disorder presenting with intellectual disability, autistic-like features, and epilepsy. The pathological determinants of CTD are still poorly understood, hindering the development of therapies. In this study, we generated an extensive transcriptomic profile of CTD showing that Cr deficiency causes perturbations of gene expression in excitatory neurons, inhibitory cells, and oligodendrocytes which result in remodeling of circuit excitability and synaptic wiring. We also identified specific alterations of parvalbumin-expressing (PV⁺) interneurons, exhibiting a reduction in cellular and synaptic density, and a hypofunctional electrophysiological phenotype. Mice lacking Slc6a8 only in PV⁺ interneurons recapitulated numerous CTD features, including cognitive deterioration, impaired cortical processing and hyperexcitability of brain circuits, demonstrating that Cr deficit in PV⁺ interneurons is sufficient to determine the neurological phenotype of CTD. Moreover, a pharmacological treatment targeted to restore the efficiency of PV⁺ synapses significantly improved cortical activity in Slc6a8 knock-out animals. Altogether, these data demonstrate that Slc6a8 is critical for the normal function of PV⁺ interneurons and that impairment of these cells is central in the disease pathogenesis, suggesting a novel therapeutic venue for CTD.

Use of an animal model of disease for toxicology enables identification of a juvenile no observed adverse effect level for cyclocreatine in creatine transporter deficiency

In standard general toxicology studies in two species to support clinical development, cyclocreatine, a creatine analog for the treatment of creatine transporter deficiency, caused deaths, convulsions, and/or multi-organ pathology. The potential translatability of these findings to patients was evaluated by comparing toxicity of cyclocreatine in wild-type mice to creatine transporter-deficient mice, a model of the human disease. A biodistribution study indicated greater accumulation of cyclocreatine in the brains of wild-type mice, consistent with its ability to be transported by the creatine transporter. Subsequent toxicology studies confirmed greater sensitivity of wild-type mice to cyclocreatine-induced toxicity. Exposure at the no observed adverse effect level in creatine transporter-deficient (554 μg*hr/ml) mice exceeded exposure at the maximum tolerated dose in wild-type (248 μg*hr/ml) mice. When dosed at 300 mg/kg/day for 3 months, cyclocreatine-related mortality, convulsions, and multi-organ pathology were observed in wild-type mice whereas there were no adverse findings in creatine transporter-deficient mice. Brain vacuolation was common to both strains. Although transporter-deficient mice appeared to be more sensitive, the finding had no functional correlates in this strain. The results highlight the importance of considering models of disease for toxicology in cases where they may be relevant to assessing safety in the intended patient population.

Treatment experience in two adults with creatinfe transporter deficiency

Background

Creatine transporter deficiency (CTD) is an X-linked form of intellectual disability (ID) caused by SCL6A8 mutations. Limited information exists on the adult course of CTD, and there are no treatment studies in adults.

Methods

We report two half-brothers with CTD, 36 and 31 years at intervention start. Their clinical phenotypes were consistent with CTD, and intervention was indicated because of progressive disease course, with increased difficulties speaking, walking and eating, resulting in fatigue, and malnutrition. We therefore performed treatment trials with arginine, glycine and a proprietary product containing creatine and betaine, and then a trial supplementing with betaine alone.

Results

In the older patient, glycine and arginine were accompanied by adverse effects, while betaine containing proprietary product gave improved balance, speech and feeding. When supplementation stopped, his condition deteriorated, and improved again after starting betaine supplement. Betaine supplementation was also beneficial in the younger patient, reducing his exhaustion, feeding difficulties and weight loss, making him able to resume his protected work.

Discussion & conclusion

We report for the first time that betaine supplement was well tolerated and efficient in adults with CTD, while arginine and/or glycine were accompanied by side effects. Thus, betaine is potentially a new useful treatment for CTD patients. We discuss possible underlying treatment mechanisms. Betaine has been reported to have antagonistic effect on NKCC1 channels, a mechanism shared with bumetanide, a medication with promising results in both in autism and epilepsy. Further studies of betaine's effects in well-designed studies are warranted.

Locus heterogeneity in two siblings presenting with developmental delay, intellectual disability and autism spectrum disorder

Correct diagnosis of children presenting with developmental delay and intellectual disability remains challenging due to the complex and heterogeneous etiology. High throughput sequencing technologies like exome sequencing have become more commonly available and are significantly improving genetic testing. We present two siblings - a 14-year old male and an 8-year old female patient - with a similar clinical phenotype that was characterized by combined developmental delay primarily affecting speech, mild to moderate intellectual disability, behavioral abnormalities, and autism spectrum disorder, but with no congenital anomalies. The sister showed additional muscular hypotonia and more pronounced dysmorphic features compared to her brother. Both parents had psychiatric disorders and mild to moderate intellectual disability. A common genetic etiology in the siblings was suspected. Metabolic, psychological and neuroradiological examinations were complemented by basic genetic testing including chromosome analysis and array comparative genomics hybridization analysis (CGH), followed by exome sequencing and combined data analysis of the family. Exome sequencing identified two different underlying genetic conditions: in the sister, a maternally inherited pathogenic variant c.1661C > T, p.Pro554Leu in SLC6A8 (NM_005629.4) was identified causing cerebral creatine deficiency syndrome 1 (MIM #300352) which was confirmed by MR spectroscopy and treated accordingly. In the brother, a paternally inherited 16p13.11 duplication was identified by exome sequencing and considered to be likely associated with his and possibly his father's phenotype. The 16p13.11 duplication had been previously identified in an array CGH but had not been prioritized due to the lack of segregation in the siblings. In conclusion, we report a case of intra-familial locus heterogeneity of developmental delay in two siblings. We advocate for the need of unbiased and comprehensive genetic testing to provide accurate diagnosis despite locus heterogeneity.

Treatment outcome of creatine transporter deficiency: international retrospective cohort study

To evaluate the outcome of current treatment for creatine transporter (CRTR) deficiency, we developed a clinical severity score and initiated an international treatment registry. An online questionnaire was completed by physicians following patients with CRTR deficiency on a treatment, including creatine and/or arginine, and/or glycine. Clinical severity score included 1) global developmental delay/intellectual disability; 2) seizures; 3) behavioural disorder. Phenotype scored 1-3 = mild; 4-6 = moderate; and 7-9 = severe. We applied the clinical severity score pre- and on-treatment. Seventeen patients, 14 males and 3 females, from 16 families were included. Four patients had severe, 6 patients had moderate, and 7 patients had a mild phenotype. The phenotype ranged from mild to severe in patients diagnosed at or before 2 years of age or older than 6 years of age. The phenotype ranged from mild to severe in patients with mildly elevated urine creatine to creatinine ratio. Fourteen patients were on the combined creatine, arginine and glycine therapy. On the combined treatment with creatine, arginine and glycine, none of the males showed either deterioration or improvements in their clinical severity score, whereas two females showed improvements in the clinical severity score. Creatine monotherapy resulted in deterioration of the clinical severity score in one male. There seems to be no correlation between phenotype and degree of elevation in urine creatine to creatinine ratio, genotype, or age at diagnosis. Combined creatine, arginine and glycine therapy might have stopped disease progression in males and improved phenotype in females.

Creatine transporter deficiency leads to increased whole body and cellular metabolism

Creatine (Cr) is a guanidino compound required for rapid replenishment of ATP in cells with a high-energy demand. In humans, mutations in the Cr transporter (CRT;SLC6A8) prevent Cr entry into tissue and result in a significant intellectual impairment, epilepsy, and aphasia. The lack of Cr on both the whole body and cellular metabolism was evaluated in Crt knockout (Crt (-/y) ) mice, a high-fidelity model of human CRT deficiency. Crt (-/y) mice have reduced body mass and, however, show a twofold increase in body fat. There was increased energy expenditure in a home cage environment and during treadmill running in Crt (-/y) mice. Consistent with the increases in the whole-body metabolic function, Crt (-/y) mice show increased cellular metabolism as well. Mitochondrial respiration increased in skeletal muscle fibers and hippocampal lysates from Crt (-/y) mice. In addition, Crt (-/y) mice had increased citrate synthase activity, suggesting a higher number of mitochondria instead of an increase in mitochondrial activity. To determine if the increase in respiration was due to increased mitochondrial numbers, we measured oxygen consumption in an equal number of mitochondria from Crt (+/y) and Crt (-/y) mice. There were no changes in mitochondrial respiration when normalized to mitochondrial number, suggesting that the increase in respiration observed could be to higher mitochondrial content in Crt (-/y) mice.

Creatine transporter deficiency: Novel mutations and functional studies

X-linked cerebral creatine deficiency (MIM 300036) is caused by deficiency of the creatine transporter encoded by the SLC6A8 gene. Here we report three patients with this condition from Israel. These unrelated patients were evaluated for global developmental delays and language apraxia. Borderline microcephaly was noted in one of them. Diagnosis was prompted by brain magnetic resonance imaging and spectroscopy which revealed normal white matter distribution, but absence of the creatine peak in all three patients. Biochemical testing indicated normal plasma levels of creatine and guanidinoacetate, but an increased urine creatine/creatinine ratio. The diagnosis was confirmed by demonstrating absent ([14])C-creatine transport in fibroblasts. Molecular studies indicated that the first patient is hemizygous for a single nucleotide change substituting a single amino acid (c.619 C > T, p.R207W). Expression studies in HeLa cells confirmed the causative role of the R207W substitution. The second patient had a three base pair deletion in the SLC6A8 gene (c.1222_1224delTTC, p.F408del) as well as a single base change (c.1254 + 1G > A) at a splicing site in the intron-exon junction of exon 8, the latter occurring de novo. The third patient, had a three base pair deletion (c.1006_1008delAAC, p.N336del) previously reported in other patients with creatine transporter deficiency. These three patients are the first reported cases of creatine transporter deficiency in Israel.

Estimated carrier frequency of creatine transporter deficiency in females in the general population using functional characterization of novel missense variants in the SLC6A8 gene

Creatine transporter deficiency (CRTR-D) is an X-linked inherited disorder of creatine transport. All males and about 50% of females have intellectual disability or cognitive dysfunction. Creatine deficiency on brain proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy and elevated urinary creatine to creatinine ratio are important biomarkers. Mutations in the SLC6A8 gene occur de novo in 30% of males. Despite reports of high prevalence of CRTR-D in males with intellectual disability, there are no true prevalence studies in the general population. To determine carrier frequency of CRTR-D in the general population we studied the variants in the SLC6A8 gene reported in the Exome Variant Server database and performed functional characterization of missense variants. We also analyzed synonymous and intronic variants for their predicted pathogenicity using in silico analysis tools. Nine missense variants were functionally analyzed using transient transfection by site-directed mutagenesis with In-Fusion HD Cloning in HeLa cells. Creatine uptake was measured by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry for creatine measurement. The c.1654G>T (p.Val552Leu) variant showed low residual creatine uptake activity of 35% of wild type transfected HeLa cells and was classified as pathogenic. Three variants (c.808G>A; p.Val270Met, c.942C>G; p.Phe314Leu and c.952G>A; p.Ala318Thr) were predicted to be pathogenic based on in silico analysis, but proved to be non-pathogenic by our functional analysis. The estimated carrier frequency of CRTR-D was 0.024% in females in the general population. We recommend functional studies for all novel missense variants by transient transfection followed by creatine uptake measurement by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry as fast and cost effective method for the functional analysis of missense variants in the SLC6A8 gene.

Detection of a novel intragenic rearrangement in the creatine transporter gene by next generation sequencing

Deficiency caused by mutations in the creatine transporter gene (SLC6A8/CT1) is an X-linked form of intellectual disability. The presence of highly homologous pseudogenes and high GC content of SLC6A8 genomic sequence complicates the molecular diagnosis of this disorder. To minimize the pseudogene interference, exons 2 to 13 of SLC6A8 were amplified as a single PCR product using gene-specific long-range PCR (LR-PCR) primers. The GC-rich exon 1 and its flanking intronic sequences were amplified separately in a short fragment under GC-rich conditions and a touchdown PCR program. Traditional Sanger sequence analysis of all coding exons of SLC6A8 from a 3-year-old boy with creatine transporter deficiency did not detect deleterious mutations. The long-range PCR product was used as template followed by massively parallel sequencing (MPS) on HiSeq2000. We were able to detect a tandem duplication involving part of exons 11 and 12 in the SLC6A8 gene. The deduced c.1592_1639dup133 mutation was confirmed to be a hemizygous insertion by targeted genomic DNA and cDNA Sanger sequencing. Combination of deep sequencing technology with long-range PCR revealed a novel intragenic duplication in the SLC6A8 gene, providing a definitive molecular diagnosis of creatine transporter deficiency in a male patient.