Quality assurance in corneal transplants: Donor cornea assessment and oversight

The cornea is the most frequently transplanted human tissue, and corneal transplantation represents the most successful allogeneic transplant worldwide. In order to obtain good surgical outcome and visual rehabilitation and to ensure the safety of the recipient, accurate screening of donors and donor tissues is necessary throughout the process. This mitigates the risks of transmission to the recipient, including infectious diseases and environmental contaminants, and ensures high optical and functional quality of the tissues. The process can be divided into 3 stages: (1) donor evaluation and selection before tissue harvest performed by the retrieval team, (2) tissue analysis during the storage phase conducted by the eye bank technicians after the retrieval, and, (3) tissue quality checks undertaken by the surgeons in the operating room before transplantation. Although process improvements over the years have greatly enhanced safety, quality, and outcome of the corneal transplants, a lack of standardization between centers during certain phases of the process still remains, and may impact on the quality and number of transplanted corneas. Here we detail the donor screening process for the retrieval teams, eye bank operators. and ophthalmic surgeons and examine the limitations associated with each of these stages.

Gram stain and addition of amphotericin B to improve the microbial safety of human donor corneas

To determine the effectiveness of two methods to improve the microbial safety of human corneas preserved in organ culture. We compared the number of positive preservation solutions of corneas in organ culture in which the initial short-term hypothermic corneal maintenance solution was supplemented with amphotericin B 2.5 µg/mL and the historical data of microbial test results (2015-2019). In addition, we appraised the efficacy of Gram stain to detect bacterial or fungal contamination in the organ culture solutions of corneas from at-risk donors compared to the culture tests of corneas from not-at-risk donors. Statistical analysis was performed using STATA and statistical significance set at p < 0.05. The number of positive culture tests after preservation was 15 (0.5%) in 2020 compared to a mean of 37 (1.2%) in the period 2015-2019 (p < 0.01), with 10 (1.0%) positive samples in the cohort of 998 corneas from at-risk donors and 5 (0.2%) in the 2046 corneas from not-at-risk donors (p < 0.01). All corneas from at-risk donors tested positive at Gram stain and the results were available 1-3 days before those of the conventional culture tests. Amphotericin B supplementation in the short-term maintenance solution markedly reduced the number of positive microbial tests after organ culture and the early detection of contaminants, including slow-growing microorganisms, by Gram stain before the standard culture results. This meant fewer corneas being discarded and a greater likelihood of preventing post-graft infections.

Safety and efficacy of corneal tissue harvested from organophosphorous deceased patients

Purpose:

To analyze the quality of tissues and outcome of corneal transplants from tissues harvested from the donors of organophosphorus poisoning victims.

Methods:

A retrospective study was carried out on corneas harvested from organophosphorus poisoning victims between January 2016 and December 2018. Details of quality of tissues and outcome following keratoplasty were collected from the eye bank and outpatient records, respectively.

Results:

Four hundred and seventy-eight donor corneas were collected from the victims of organophosphorus poisoning during the study period. The mean age of the donor was 38.8 ± 16.5 years. The mean donor-to-preservation time was 6.2 ± 3.2 hours. The mean endothelial cell density on specular microscopy was 2986.5 ± 369.0 cells/mm². Four hundred and twenty-two (88.2%) donor corneas were utilized. Of the 121 corneas utilized at our institute for transplantation, 73 and 48 corneas were for optical and therapeutic/tectonic indications, respectively. Of the 73 optical grafts, 25 patients were lost-to-follow-up and 58.3% (28/48) who came for one-year follow-up were found to be clear.

Conclusion:

Donor corneas retrieved from organophosphorus poisoning are safe for transplantation. The postoperative outcome of the tissue utilized from these donors is satisfactory.

Solubilized ubiquinol for preserving corneal function

Defective cellular metabolism, impaired mitochondrial function, and increased cell death are major problems that adversely affect donor tissues during hypothermic preservation prior to transplantation. These problems are thought to arise from accumulated reactive oxygen species (ROS) inside cells. Oxidative stress acting on the cells of organs and tissues preserved in hypothermic conditions before surgery, as is the case for cornea transplantation, is thought to be a major reason behind cell death prior to surgery and decreased graft survival after transplantation. We have recently discovered that ubiquinol - the reduced and active form of coenzyme Q10 and a powerful antioxidant - significantly enhances mitochondrial function and reduces apoptosis in human donor corneal endothelial cells. However, ubiquinol is highly lipophilic, underscoring the need for an aqueous-based formulation of this molecule. Herein, we report a highly dispersible and stable formulation comprising a complex of ubiquinol and gamma cyclodextrin (γ-CD) for use in aqueous-phase ophthalmic products. Docking studies showed that γ-CD has the strongest binding affinity with ubiquinol compared to α- or β-CD. Complexed ubiquinol showed significantly higher stability compared to free ubiquinol in different aqueous ophthalmic products including Optisol-GS® corneal storage medium, balanced salt solution for intraocular irrigation, and topical Refresh® artificial tear eye drops. Greater ROS scavenging activity was noted in a cell model with high basal metabolism and ROS generation (A549) and in HCEC-B4G12 human corneal endothelial cells after treatment with ubiquinol/γ-CD compared to free ubiquinol. Furthermore, complexed ubiquinol was more effective at lowering ROS, and at far lower concentrations, compared to free ubiquinol. Complexed ubiquinol inhibited lipid peroxidation and protected HCEC-B4G12 cells against erastin-induced ferroptosis. No evidence of cellular toxicity was detected in HCEC-B4G12 cells after treatment with complexed ubiquinol. Using a vertical diffusion system, a topically applied inclusion complex of γ-CD and a lipophilic dye (coumarin-6) demonstrated transcorneal penetrance in porcine corneas and the capacity for the γ-CD vehicle to deliver drug to the corneal endothelium. Using the same model, topically applied ubiquinol/γ-CD complex penetrated the entire thickness of human donor corneas with markedly greater ubiquinol retention in the endothelium compared to free ubiquinol. Lastly, the penetrance of ubiquinol/γ-CD complex was assayed using human donor corneas preserved for 7 days in Optisol-GS® per standard industry practices, and demonstrated higher amounts of ubiquinol retained in the corneal endothelium compared to free ubiquinol. In summary, ubiquinol complexed with γ-CD is a highly stable composition that can be incorporated into a variety of aqueous-phase products for ophthalmic use including donor corneal storage media and topical eye drops to scavenge ROS and protect corneal endothelial cells against oxidative damage.

Seropositivity of blood samples of 31,355 cornea donors from a tertiary care network of eye banks

PURPOSE

To evaluate the seropositivity of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), hepatitis B virus (HBV), hepatitis C virus (HCV) and syphilis from blood samples of cornea donors and assess correlation between seropositivity for HIV and syphilis.

METHODS

Retrospective analysis of blood samples of 31,355 cornea donors for HIV, HBV, HCV, and syphilis was performed. Postmortem blood samples were analyzed by a rapid screening test for anti-HIV envelope antibodies against HIV 1 and 2, HBV surface antigen, antibody to HCV and anti-cardiolipin antibodies for syphilis by rapid plasma reagin test.

RESULTS

The overall seropositivity rate was 4.28% (1343/31,355 donors). All positive donors were reactive for a single serological test. The seropositivity rate for HIV was 0.93% (95% CI 0.83-1.04%), for HBsAg was 1.56% (95% CI 1.43-1.7%), for HCV was 1.19% (95% CI 1.08-1.33%) and for syphilis was 0.59% (95% CI 0.52-0.69%). The trends in seropositivity rates showed a decline for three viral markers: HIV (2010, 1.17% to 2018, 0.72%, p = 0.02), HBsAg (2010, 1.98% to 2018, 1.05%, p = 0.0006) and HCV (2010, 1.32% to 2018, 0.43%, p < 0.0001). The seropositivity rates for syphilis showed a progressive increase when compared to baseline (2010, 0.14% to 2018, 1.14%, p < 0.0001). There was no relationship between seropositivity for HIV and syphilis (p = 0.18).

CONCLUSIONS

The overall seropositivity for HIV, HBV, HCV and syphilis was 4.28%. Seropositivity was highest for HBV. The study did not find correlation between seropositivity of HIV and syphilis.

Detection of refractive photokeratectomy traces during eye banking: impossible with organ culture but possible with an active storage machine: case report

The detection of corneas operated on for refractive surgery [LASIK or photorefractive keratectomy (PRK)] will become a major concern for eye banks in the coming years because this surgery is often forgotten during the interview with the deceased's relatives. We present here 2 corneas operated on with PKR and stored successively in organ culture (OC) and in the active storage machine (ASM) that restores intraocular pressure, restores the cornea to its original shape, respects transparency and incorporates non-invasive controls. The 2 corneas of a 49-year-old donor operated 17 years earlier by PRK for -2 and -3 diopters myopia were stored in OC for 14 days and then placed in ASM for 48 h. Thickness map and OCT topography were performed under the 2 storage conditions, histology and electron microscopy were then performed. Traces of PRK remained unnoticed in OC while they were evident in ASM with central epithelial anomaly, central thinning and flattening of central keratometry shown by OCT. Histology and ultrastructure confirmed the absence of Bowman's membrane in the center. By placing the cornea under physiological conditions, and in particular by triggering its deswelling and by restoring its natural curvature, the ASM allows effective detection of subtle refractive surgery traces like those present after PRK.

Gender medicine in corneal transplantation: influence of sex mismatch on rejection episodes and graft survival in a prospective cohort of patients

To evaluate the effect of donor-to-recipient sex mismatched (male donor corneas to female recipients) on the incidence of rejection episodes and failures up to 1 year after corneal transplantation. Prospective observational cohort study, with donor corneas randomly assigned and surgeons blind to the sex of donor. A unique eye bank retrieved and selected the donor corneas transplanted in 4 ophthalmic units in patients with clinical indication for primary or repeated keratoplasty for optical reasons, perforating or lamellar, either anterior or posterior. Rejection episode defined as any reversible or irreversible endothelial, epithelial or stromal sign, with or without development of corneal edema, and graft failure as a permanently cloudy graft or a regraft for any reason detected or acknowledged during a postoperative ophthalmic visit at any time up to 1 year after surgery were recorded.156 (28.6%) patients resulted donor-to-recipient gender mismatched for H-Y antigen (male donor to female recipient). During the 12 months follow-up, 83 (14.7%, 95% CI 12.0-17.9) grafts showed at least 1 rejection episode and 17 (3.2%, 95% CI 2.0-5.0) failed after immune rejection, among 54 (9.6%, 95% CI 7.4-12.3) grafts failed for all causes. No significant differences between matched and mismatched patients were found for cumulative incidence of both rejection episodes (15.2% and 13.5%) and graft failures following rejection (3.2% and 2.6%), respectively. Multivariable analyses showed that H-Y matching either is not a predictive factor for rejection or graft failure nor seems to influence incidence of failures on respect to patient's risk category. The lack of influence of donor-to-recipient mismatched on the rate of rejections and graft failures resulting from this study do not support the adoption of donor-recipient matching in the allocation of corneas for transplantation.

Banking of corneal stromal lenticules: a risk-analysis assessment with the EuroGTP II interactive tool

We evaluated the feasibility and performed a risk-benefit analysis of the storage and widespread distribution of stromal lenticules for clinical application using a new systematic tool (European Good Tissue and cells Practices II-EuroGTP II tool), specifically designed for assessing the risk, safety and efficacy of substances of human origin. Three types of potential tissue preparations for human stromal lenticules were evaluated: cryopreserved, dehydrated and decellularized. The tool helps to identify an overall risk score (0-2: negligible; 2-6: low; 6-22: moderate; > 22: high) and suggests risk reduction strategies. For all the three types of products, we found the level of risk to be as "moderate". A process validation, pre-clinical in vitro and in vivo evaluations and a clinical study limited to a restricted number of patients should therefore be performed in order to mitigate the risks. Our study allowed to establish critical points and steps necessary to implement a new process for safe stromal lenticule preparation by the eye banks to be used in additive keratoplasty. Moreover, it shows that the EuroGTP II tool is useful to assess and identify risk reduction strategies for introduction of new Tissue and Cellular Therapies and Products into the clinical practice.

Thirty years of eye bank experience at a single centre in India

PURPOSE

The global survey of eye banking and corneal transplantation reveals differences in eye banking trajectories in various countries. There is a need to encourage and lay down foundations of successful eye banking practices in many nations across the world map. The study evaluates demographics, trends in donor cornea retrieval, utilization and eye banking practices in over 30 years at a single eye bank in India.

METHODS

A longitudinal descriptive analysis of eye banking practices from 1989 to 2018 at Ramayamma International Eye Bank, Hyderabad, India, was performed. Data on eye donations, practice patterns and various types of keratoplasty were collected. Data were analysed focusing on practices and historical development of the eye bank.

RESULTS

Over the years, the eye bank has made use of several advances in its practice patterns and evolved to a stage of self-sustainability. With the fulfilment of internal demand for corneal transplantation, 50% of retrieved corneas could be distributed for community needs outside the institute. Number of transplants increased from 20 in 1987 to 4738 in 2018. Total number of transplants touched 27,746 in 2018 which might be the highest numbers for a single centre anywhere in the world.

CONCLUSIONS

The study reveals a dynamic development of the eye bank over the last 30 years and emphasizes the importance of an active quality management in coping with the challenges of modern eye banking. The increasing trend of cornea collection and transplantation is a reflection of the needs and efforts towards treating and eliminating corneal blindness.

Microbiological contamination in donor corneas preserved for medium-term

To evaluate the characteristics of microbiological contamination in donor corneas preserved for medium-term. A total of 82 donated corneas from June 1, 2014 to November 30, 2014 were retrospectively analyzed. The corneas were preserved in cornea chambers medium-term solution at 4-8 °C for keratoplasty. After removal of the central corneas for transplantation, the corneoscleral rims were put back into the medium for 1 month at room temperature (20-25 °C). The suspicious contaminated storage solutions indicated with transparency or color change were examined with bacteria and fungi cultivation for strain identification. The data collected included gender, age, procurement site and causes of death of donors, and follow-up of recipients. Statistical analysis was performed using Microsoft Excel and SPSS 24.0. Significance level was set at a P value < 0.05. The overall pathogen positive rate was 9.8% (n = 8), including 7 (87.5%) fungi and 1 (12.5%) bacteria. They were 2 (2.44%) Fusarium, 2 (2.44%) Chromomycosis, 1 (1.22%) Candida albicans, 1 (1.22%) Aspergillus versicolor, 1 (1.22%) Acremonium species, and 1 (1.22%) Enterococcus. 5 contaminated corneas were used for penetrating keratoplasty; although four out of five (80%) had not been given antifungal drugs during more than 6 months following-up period, none of the recipients was infected with a graft. Donor age (P = 0.839), gender (P = 0.062), procurement sites (P = 0.713) and cause of death (P = 0.711) had no statistically significant influence on the contamination rate. All donor corneas have a possibility of microbiological contamination. Strict tissue preservation protocol but not antifungal drugs following keratoplasty seems necessary to prevent graft infection.

A two-centre validation study of sterility test of corneal storage media with elimination of interfering antimicrobials in compliance with the European Pharmacopoeia

The purpose of this study was to validate the sterility test of corneal culture and deswelling/transport media using a device for removal of antimicrobials before incubation in BACTEC™ automated system in two Italian Eye Banks. Corneal culture medium, TISSUE-C, and deswelling/transport medium, CARRY-C, were inoculated with 10-100 cfu of six European Pharmacopoeia (EP) reference strains and either treated with medical device RESEP for removal of antimicrobials (RESEP+ group) or left untreated (RESEP- group) before injection into the BACTEC Plus bottles. The same steps were repeated in the absence of inocula with tryptone soy broth samples as negative controls, and the inocula were also directly injected in the BACTEC™ bottles as growth controls. All the samples were incubated in BACTEC™ automated system for 7 days, and the time to detection of microbial growth was recorded automatically. At both the Eye Banks, in the RESEP+ groups, microbial growth was detected in 100% of samples. In the RESEP- group, the method sensitivity ranged from 66.7 ± 21.1 to 88.9 ± 6.4% for TISSUE-C samples while for CARRY-C samples the method sensitivity ranged from 94.5 ± 5.1 to 100%. The method specificity corresponded to 100% for all the groups at both Eye Banks. This two-centre validation study showed that the use of RESEP increased the sensitivity of sterility test using BACTEC™ automated system up to 100% and, consequently, allowed validation of the method for sterility testing of corneal storage and deswelling/transport media according to the EP requirements. The test could not be validated without the use of RESEP.

A presentation of culture-positive corneal donors and the effect on clinical outcomes

PURPOSE

Donor-to-host transmission of infectious agents is a rare but well-recognised complication of corneal transplantation and may carry a grave visual prognosis. In this case series, we describe the clinical features and risk factors of using culture-positive donor corneas for transplantation.

METHODS

Retrospective chart review of a series of patients who underwent either penetrating keratoplasty (PK) or Descemet's stripping automated endothelial keratoplasty (DSAEK) with positive microbiology cultivation during routine assessment of donor corneal tissue obtained at the time of surgery. Donor and recipient characteristics, tissue preparation and surgical parameters, clinical signs and outcomes were registered.

RESULTS

Eleven patients who received culture-positive corneal grafts were identified: six with Candida, three with Gram-positive bacteria and two with Gram-negative bacteria. Three patients developed clinical keratitis after routine DSAEK using corneas contaminated with Candida species. The median death-to-preservation time (DPT) of these three donor corneas was 18.08 (range 18.08 to 20.90) h, while in the remaining eight donors, it was 12.27 (range 9.32 to 20.47) h. Despite the initiation of antifungal treatment, all three cases required explantation of the graft and a subsequent re-DSAEK.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of donor corneas that are culture-positive for Candida carries a risk for developing postoperative keratitis and the risk may be higher in DSAEK. Unlike the cold storage technique employed for donor corneas described in this case series, organ culture technique requires microbiological screening and supplementation of an antifungal agent which may reduce the risk of donor-to-host transmission of fungal infection.

Pre-banking microbial contamination of donor conjunctiva and storage medium for penetrating keratoplasty

PURPOSE

The aims of this study were to investigate the incidence of positive donor tissue cultures before transfer to preservation medium (Optisol™-GS) for penetrating keratoplasty, to verify the efficacy of antibiotics contained in Optisol™-GS by examining the drug susceptibility and to assess the relationship between the results of our microbial assessments as well as donor factors and the incidence of contamination.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective, cross-sectional study using Juntendo Eye Bank records for all corneal transplantations. Two hundred donor conjunctiva harvestings and storage medium (EP-II^®) cultures were performed between July 2008 and June 2011. We analyzed the associations between donor factors (age, gender, history of cataract surgery, death-to-preservation interval, cause of death) and contamination rates using multivariate analysis by the generalized estimating equation model.

RESULTS

We obtained positive bacterial cultures from 154 of the 200 eyes (77.0%). The isolated bacteria were indigenous, such as coagulase-negative Staphylococci, Corynebacterium sp., and methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA). There was significant resistance to levofloxacin (18 eyes, 9.0%) and gentamicin (12 eyes, 6.0%), and no vancomycin-resistant bacteria were detected. The donor factors did not correlate with the prevalence of bacterial contamination in our criteria.

CONCLUSIONS

Pre-banking microbial assessment allows for microbial detection, bacterial susceptibility and resistance testing. This is useful for developing preservation mediums containing effective spectrum antibiotic agents for high quality control of corneal banking.

Precut cornea for Descemet's stripping endothelial keratoplasty: experience at a single eye bank

The aim of the study is to describe the experience with precut facility for endothelial keratoplasty at a single eye bank affiliated to a tertiary eye care center in India. Data on precut tissues from Nov 2012 to Dec 2014 were retrospectively reviewed from the electronic database of the eye bank of a tertiary eye care center in South India. Donor characteristic data including donor age, precut and postcut endothelial cell density (ECD), recipient age, and thickness of graft were collected. The number of precuts increased from 42 in 2012 (Nov and Dec) and 422 in 2013 to 584 in 2014. Of the total of 1048 precuts, seven (0.67 %) were miscut and could not be utilized for transplants. The donor age ranged from 2 to 89 years. A mean change of 43.6 ± 325.2 cells/mm² in ECD was noted after cut, proportional increase in mean being 1.9 %. The change in ECD after cut was negatively correlated with ECD before cut. The recipient age ranged from 1 to 89 years. The median thickness of donor lenticule after cut was 148 µm (interquartile range 131-166 µm). Analysis of precut donor corneas from a single eye bank shows that the ECD of the processed tissues was excellent for transplantation. The tissue wastage in the hands of eye bank personal was minimal.