MR Imaging Safety Considerations of Gadolinium-Based Contrast Agents: Gadolinium Retention and Nephrogenic Systemic Fibrosis

Gadolinium (Gd)-based contrast agents (GBCAs) have revolutionized of MR imaging, enabling physicians to obtain life-saving medical information that often cannot be obtained with unenhanced MR imaging or other imaging modalities. Since regulatory approval in 1988, more than 450 million intravenous GBCA doses have been administered worldwide, with an extremely favorable pharmacologic safety profile. Recent evidence has demonstrated, however, that a small fraction of Gd is retained in human tissues. No direct correlation between Gd retention and clinical effects has been confirmed; however, a subset of patients have attributed various symptoms to GBCA exposure. This review details current knowledge regarding GBCA safety.

An initial investigation of serum cytokine levels in patients with gadolinium retention

Objective

To determine whether individuals with proposed gadolinium deposition disease (GDD) have elevated serum levels of pro-inflammatory and pro-fibrotic cytokines, and whether specific cytokines are correlated with certain symptoms.

Materials and Methods

Twenty-four participants recruited between May 2016 and June 2017 met GDD diagnostic criteria. The 64 control subjects provided serum samples before prophylactic flu vaccination. Serum cytokine levels were obtained with Luminex serum cytokine assay using eBiosciences/Affymetrix human 62-plex kits. Wilcoxon rank-sum tests were performed to assess the difference between the median fluorescence intensity values for the participants and the control group. Generalized linear models were built to evaluate the association between each cytokine of interest and selected participant symptoms.

Results

Serum levels of 14 cytokines, including nine pro-inflammatory cytokines, were statistically significantly elevated compared to controls (p ≤ 0.05). Hypotheses regarding pro-fibrotic cytokines and cytokine links to specific symptoms' intensity were not confirmed.

Conclusion

The statistically significantly elevated cytokines may be markers of susceptibility to GDD or agents of symptom induction. These findings suggest that individuals developing symptoms characteristic of GDD after a contrast-assisted magnetic resonance imaging should be studied to investigate whether gadolinium retention and elevated cytokines may be related to their symptoms.

MRI demonstration of gadolinium deposition in bone after monthly triple-dose gadopentetate dimeglumine and correlation with frequency of hypophosphatemia

OBJECTIVES

We retrospectively analyzed data of the BECOME trial to investigate whether serial administration of triple-dose (3-dose) gadopentetate dimeglumine would result in the development of T1 signal-to-noise (S/N) changes in the cranial diploic space and whether S/N changes correlated with on-study hypophosphatemia.

METHODS

Signal intensity analysis was performed on the first year's data of the BECOME trial using 3-dose Gd (14 months, maximum number of doses, 39, mean: 36). Routine blood and urine tests were obtained each month for safety monitoring. Linear mixed regression modeling with random intercept was used to analyze monthly signal-to-noise ratio (S/N = Bone/Air) using an ROI of the diploic space created from T2W images and overlaid on T1FS (T1 fat-saturated) images. Incidence of phosphate abnormalities was analyzed using the general estimation equation; correlation of phosphate and S/N change was achieved with type 3 test of fixed effects.

RESULTS

Cranial diploic space T1FS S/N increased over 14 months: S/N = 0.039 mean monthly increase (S.E. 0.008; p < 0.0001). Subjects with consistently normal phosphate levels (n = 32) experienced more of a S/N increase than patients with at least one episode of hypophosphatemia (n = 35) (0.057 vs. 0.023, respectively, p = 0.037). Those with moderate hypophosphatemia demonstrated no significant S/N increase.

CONCLUSION

Monthly administration of 3-dose gadopentetate dimeglumine is associated with development of increased S/N on T1FS imaging in the cranial diploic space, suggesting Gd retention in bone. Our data suggests MRI could be used as a noninvasive method of tracking Gd retention in bone, which was more pronounced in patients with normal phosphate levels.

Gadolinium Aspiration Following Inadvertent Endotracheal Tube Cuff Injection in a Pediatric Patient

INTRODUCTION

Gadolinium-based contrast agents (GBCA) are frequently used for MRI contrast studies. We report a case of pulmonary aspiration secondary to inadvertent GBCA injection.

CASE REPORT

A 12-year-old female with a past medical history significant for mitochondrial disorder, bronchial asthma, autism, recurrent urinary tract infection, epilepsy, developmental delay, dysautonomia, and thrombocytopenia was scheduled for a contrast-enhanced MRI study using gadoterate meglumine for urinary incontinence. The patient was sedated and intubated in preparation for the study, during which 10 mL of gadoterate meglumine was inadvertently injected into the endotracheal tube cuff pilot line instead of intravenously. The patient remained intubated and was admitted to the intensive care unit with continuous monitoring for signs of pulmonary injury or gadolinium toxicity. She was successfully extubated approximately 24 hours later without complication.

DISCUSSION

A variety of adverse effects attributable to parenteral GBCA exposure have been reported ranging from mild irritation to life-threatening anaphylaxis. Gadolinium deposition and storage have been implicated in a number of those adverse effects and multiple treatments modalities have been suggested, but no scientifically guided management exists.

CONCLUSION

This case of pulmonary aspiration secondary to inadvertent GBCA injection in a pediatric patient demonstrated no acute  side effects or complications within the first 24 hours. With the wide range of adverse effects attributed to gadolinium use in the medical literature, it is difficult to predict potential future adverse effects.

Evaluating the Patient with Reported Gadolinium-Associated Illness

INTRODUCTION

Gadolinium-based contrast agents (GBCAs) have been increasingly used in clinical practice since their introduction in the 1980s. Recently, increased public attention has been given to patients who report new symptoms following GBCA exposure. This review details the current knowledge surrounding GBCAs, with a focus on the known and proposed disease states that may be associated with GBCAs. Recommendations for the appropriate clinical workup of a patient suspected of having symptoms attributable to gadolinium exposure are included.

DISCUSSION

GBCAs are known to precipitate the disease state nephrogenic systemic fibrosis (NSF), a syndrome characterized by skin thickening in patients with preexisting renal disease. An additional syndrome, termed gadolinium deposition disease, has been proposed to describe patients with normal renal function who develop an array of symptoms following GBCA exposure. While there is a potential physiologic basis for the development of this condition, there is no conclusive evidence to support a causal relationship between GBCA administration and the reported symptoms yet. Clinical evaluation revolves around focused history-taking and physical examination, given the absence of a reliable link between patient symptoms and measured gadolinium levels. There are no recommended treatments for suspected gadolinium deposition disease. Chelation therapy, which is not approved for this indication, carries undue risk without documented efficacy.

CONCLUSIONS

The extent to which GBCAs contribute to clinically relevant adverse effects remains an important and evolving field of study. NSF remains the only proven disease state associated with GBCA exposure. Additional data are required to evaluate whether other symptoms should be attributed to GBCAs.

Gadolinium Deposition and Chronic Toxicity

Clinicians, radiologists, and patients should be aware of the most up-to-date data on the risks of gadolinium-based contrast agent (GBCA) administration. In this review, we discuss in vivo gadolinium retention, particularly brain tissue retention, and potential toxic effects. GBCA pharmacokinetics and biodistribution are reviewed briefly. Based on the more recent published literature and society guidelines, general safety recommendations for clinical practice are provided.

Gadolinium Retention and Toxicity-An Update

Until 2006, the main considerations regarding safety for all gadolinium-based contrast agents (GBCAs) were related to short-term adverse reactions. However, the administration of certain "high-risk" GBCAs to patients with renal failure resulted in multiple reported cases of nephrogenic systemic fibrosis. Findings have been reported regarding gadolinium deposition within the body and various reports of patients who report suffering from acute and chronic symptoms secondary to GBCA's exposure. At the present state of knowledge, it has been proved that gadolinium deposits also occur in the brain, irrespective of renal function and GBCAs stability class. To date, no definitive clinical findings are associated with gadolinium deposition in brain tissue. Gadolinium deposition disease is a newly described and probably infrequent entity. Patients presenting with gadolinium deposition disease may show signs and symptoms that somewhat follows a pattern similar but not identical, and also less severe, to those observed in nephrogenic systemic fibrosis. In this review, we will address gadolinium toxicity focusing on these 2 recently described concerns.

Gadolinium toxicity and treatment

Gadolinium based contrast agents (GBCAs) play an important role in the diagnostic evaluation of many patients. The safety of these agents has been once again questioned after gadolinium deposits were observed and measured in brain and bone of patients with normal renal function. This retention of gadolinium in the human body has been termed "gadolinium storage condition". The long-term and cumulative effects of retained gadolinium in the brain and elsewhere are not as yet understood. Recently, patients who report that they suffer from chronic symptoms secondary to gadolinium exposure and retention created gadolinium-toxicity on-line support groups. Their self-reported symptoms have recently been published. Bone and joint complaints, and skin changes were two of the most common complaints. This condition has been termed "gadolinium deposition disease". In this review we will address gadolinium toxicity disorders, from acute adverse reactions to GBCAs to gadolinium deposition disease, with special emphasis on the latter, as it is the most recently described and least known.

Summary of special issue on gadolinium bioeffects and toxicity with a look to the future

This summary attempts to provide forward-looking concepts regarding gadolinium related toxicity, as discussed in further detail in this issue.