Prozone phenomenon in pretransplant testing: An interesting conundrum involving solid-phase and cell-based assays

BACKGROUND

Human leukocyte antigen (HLA) is a major determinant in deciding upon solid organ histocompatibility. Donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies (Donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies (DSAs)) are always a contraindication for solid organ transplantation, and identification of DSA becomes very crucial before transplantation to provide long-term graft survival. For identification of DSA, usually, either cell-based or HLA bead-based assay is being used in laboratories. However, both cell-based and bead-based assays have certain limitations. One such common limitation is "prozone effect," which can give false-negative results. Here, we would like to present a small pilot study to analyze the effect of the prozone phenomenon in the cell-based and HLA bead-based assays and its utility in histocompatibility testing.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In a series of four experiments, cell-based assay, flow cytometric cross-match (FCXM), and HLA bead-based flow cytometric panel reactive antibodies (PRAs) were performed. Single-antigen bead (SAB) testing was conducted as a first experiment on four known positives samples for anti-HLA antibody-antibodies. In the second experiment, these four samples were pooled together (called pooled sera in the text) and tested for FCXM and PRA. In the third experiment, known commercially available positive control sera were mixed with pooled positive sera (positive control sera + pooled sera) to prepare, what we have called "positive concoction" in the text. In the fourth experiment, the positive concoction was diluted serially (1:2, 1:4, 1:8, and 1:16) and FCXM and PRA were performed again to analyze and compare the prozone effect.

RESULTS

Pooled sera did not have the expected median fluorescence intensity (MFI) values in FCXM assay, whereas the PRA was showing >90% positivity. In positive concoction, the MFI of FCXM assay was observed to be declining; however, PRA values remained almost constant. Dilutions of the pooled sera showed that MFI values of FCXM assays were increased suddenly after dilution. The highest MFI values were observed in 1:4 dilution of the sera, and then, it declined gradually, but the PRA values remained almost constant even after serial dilutions.

CONCLUSION

In our experimental findings, it was clear that cell-based assay (FCXM) was more severely affected by the prozone, whereas solid-phase (flow PRA) assay remained resistant to prozone.

Association of end-stage renal disease with HLA phenotypes and panel reactive antibodies in patients awaiting renal transplantation in Hunan Province

Objectives

To explore the immune‐related genetic susceptibility of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) alleles and their correlation with panel reactive antibody (PRA) generation during end‐stage renal disease (ESRD) progression.

Materials and methods

Data of the expression patterns of HLA‐A, ‐B, and ‐DR alleles and PRAs of 347 ESRD patients awaiting renal transplantation in Hunan Province from 2015 to 2019 were retrospectively studied. The polymerase chain reaction with sequence‐specific primers was used for HLA genotyping and the enzyme‐linked immunosorbent assay for PRA detection. SPSS 21.0 software was used for all allele frequency and statistical analyses.

Results

Thirteen HLA‐A, 25 HLA‐B, and 13 HLA‐DR alleles were expressed. The allele frequencies of HLA‐A2, ‐B48, ‐B52, and ‐B55 were significantly higher in the case group than in the control group (p < 0.05), whereas that of HLA‐B60 was significantly higher in the control group (p < 0.05). The frequency of HLA alleles in the PRA‐positive group was significantly higher in females than in males (p < 0.05). The allele frequencies of HLA‐A2, ‐B38, and ‐B46 were significantly higher in the PRA‐positive group than in the PRA‐negative one (p < 0.05), whereas that of HLA‐60 was significantly higher in the PRA‐negative group (p < 0.05).

Conclusion

HLA‐A2, ‐B48, ‐B52, and ‐B55 may be the ESRD susceptibility alleles in Han Chinese patients in Hunan Province, whereas HLA‐B60 may be the protective allele. Patients carrying HLA‐A2, ‐B38, and ‐B46 are more likely to develop PRA positivity, whereas the opposite is true for those with HLA‐B60.

Arteriovenous Fistula Nonmaturation: What's the Immune System Got to Do with It?

Background

Arteriovenous fistula (AVF) nonmaturation is a persistent problem, particularly among female and Black patients. Increasingly, the immune system has been recognized as an important contributor to vascular disease, but few studies have examined immune factors relative to AVF maturation outcomes. This study evaluated the association of serum panel reactive antibodies (PRA), a measure of immune system reactivity assessed in patients undergoing kidney transplant evaluation, with AVF nonmaturation.

Methods

We identified 132 patients at our institution who underwent surgical AVF placement between 2010-2019 and had PRA testing within 1 year of AVF creation. Multivariable logistic regression was used to determine the association of patient demographic and clinical factors, class I and class II PRA levels, and preoperative arterial and venous diameters with AVF maturation outcomes.

Results

AVF nonmaturation was more likely in females than males (44% versus 20%, P=0.003) and in Black than white patients (40% versus 13%, P=0.001). Class II PRA was higher in females than males (12%±23% versus 4%±13%, P=0.02). In the multivariable model, AVF nonmaturation was associated with class II PRA (adjusted odds ratio [aOR], 1.34 per 10% increase; 95% confidence interval [95% CI], 1.04 to 1.82, P=0.02) and Black race (aOR, 3.34; 95% CI, 1.02 to 10.89, P=0.03), but not with patient sex or preoperative arterial or venous diameters.

Conclusions

The association of elevated class II PRA with AVF nonmaturation suggests the immune system may play a role in AVF maturation outcomes, especially among female patients.

Epidemiological and Immunological Characteristics of HIV-Infected Patients on the Cadaveric Kidney Donor Waiting List at the Johannesburg Renal Transplant Program

HIV infection was previously considered an exclusion criterion for renal dialysis and transplant. Recent research has prompted policy changes, allowing for transplantation in this subgroup of patients. Theoretical risks with transplantation include the immune dysregulation associated with post-transplantation immunosuppression and immune activation with possible organ rejection. Assessments for eligibility to renal transplantation rely on a point system, which allocates points based on a patient's age, previous transplants, and time on the waiting list as well as panel reactive antibodies among other parameters. This study aimed at quantifying and defining the clinically relevant characteristics of HIV-infected patients on the cadaveric donor waiting list on the Johannesburg renal transplant program. Clinical records for patients on the transplant list from November 2016 to October 2017 were accessed from existing databases and clinical records. A total of 248 patients were analyzed during the study period. There were a total of 215 HIV-uninfected patients, and 33 HIV-infected patients were on the waiting list. The median age for patients at listing was 39 years (interquartile range 29-47). There were no significant differences in the median age of listing between the HIV-infected and HIV-uninfected groups (p = .7). Hypertension was the most common cause of renal failure in both study groups. The study did not show any significant differences in age or immunological characteristics between the HIV-infected and HIV-uninfected groups. This suggests that for immunological risk stratification purposes, these two groups of patients could be considered equivalent. A possible explanation for this could be that antiretroviral therapy has a significant role in mitigating the effect of the virus on the immune system. Further studies looking at a larger study population are required to corroborate these findings. These data do provide reassurance that HIV-infected patients are suitable candidates for transplantation.

False negative single antigen bead assay: Is it always an effect of prozone?

BACKGROUND

Bead based flow cytometry and Luminex play a major role in identification of alloantibodies in renal transplant work-up. Strong sensitization events may lead to prozone phenomenon that can affect single antigen bead (SAB) assay and result in false negativity. However, this can also be due to high titer of other blocking antibodies. While methods like, heat inactivation, C1 inhibitor, Ethylene diamine tetra-acetic-acid and Dithio threitol treatment can remove interfering antibodies of complement and IgM, these methods are not optimal if false negativity is due to prozone effect, which is high titer of antibodies alone.

METHODS

We hereby present a case of a highly sensitized renal transplant recipient with 64% panel reactive antibody positivity (PRA) and a subsequent negative SAB assay. This paradoxical finding hinted at SAB being a false negative result and serial dilutions were used to perform further tests.

RESULTS

Serum dilutions lead to positive flow based panel reactive antibody (PRA) and flow cytometry crossmatch (FCXM), with an increasing trend in FCXM.

CONCLUSIONS

In highly sensitized patients serial dilution should be considered during a transplant work-up to avoid missing any underlying antibodies. Serum dilution can be used as first option to circumvent prozone. Also, interference of other antibodies should not be labeled as prozone effect.

False-positive hepatitis C virus serology after placement of a ventricular assistance device

BACKGROUND

Ventricular assist devices (VADs) have been associated with immune activation and sensitization. We observed several cases of false-positive (FP) hepatitis C virus (HCV) antibody (Ab) tests in patients being evaluated for orthotopic heart transplant (OHT), prompting us to investigate this further.

METHODS

We reviewed all VAD and OHT cases at Johns Hopkins from 2005 to 2012. FP HCV serology was defined as an equivocal or low-positive HCV Ab, plus either (i) a negative recombinant immunoblot (RIBA) and/or HCV nucleic acid test (NAT), or (ii) an indeterminate RIBA and negative NAT.

RESULTS

In 53 patients with available HCV testing, nearly 40% of patients (21/53: 39.6%) developed FP HCV Ab tests after VAD placement: 4 patients had negative NAT, 12 had negative RIBA, and 5 had an indeterminate RIBA and negative NAT. All patients with indeterminate RIBA tests had isolated reactivity to the same HCV protein, c100p/5-1-1p (NS4b protein). In 3 of 4 VAD patients who had OHT and repeat HCV Ab testing after VAD removal, repeat HCV Ab was negative (699-947 days after OHT); in 1 case, FP HCV serology persisted (5 days after OHT). Thirteen patients had OHT alone and none developed a FP HCV Ab.

CONCLUSIONS

FP HCV Ab results following VAD placement are very common. Reversal of FP serology in several patients after VAD removal is suggestive of a possible association with the VAD hardware. Clinicians should be aware of this phenomenon, as it could lead to delays in determining eligibility for OHT and increased costs.

Complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) to detect Anti-HLA antibodies: old but gold

BACKGROUND

The criterion (gold) standard to detect anti-human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibodies is the complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) assay. Recently, more sensitive methods have been used for the same purpose.

METHODS

This study analyzed 70 serum samples of patients with end-stage renal disease using CDC, CDC with the addition of anti-human globulin (CDC-AHG), CDC with the addition of dithiothreitol (CDC-DTT), and the recent solid-phase immunoassay (SPI; Labscreen PRA) to detect anti-HLA antibodies.

RESULTS

Mean percent panel reactive antibodies (PRA) detected by SPI was 37.5% (±34.2) higher than the values detected by the other methods. Comparative analyses revealed significant difference between CDC and CDC-AHG, and between CDC and SPI (P < 0.0001), but not between CDC-AHG and SPI (P = 0.8026).

CONCLUSION

Although the CDC-AHG method is "old," its performance to detect anti-HLA antibodies in the samples analyzed was comparable to the SPI in the evaluation of percent class I PRA.

Challenges with sensitized recipients in pediatric heart transplantation

The sensitization of patients to human leukocyte antigens prior to heart transplantation is increasingly being recognized as an important challenge both before and after the transplant, and the effects of sensitization on clinical outcomes are just beginning to be understood. Many patients are listed with the requirement of a negative prospective or virtual crossmatch prior to accepting a donor organ. This strategy has been associated with both longer waitlist times and higher waitlist mortality. An alternative approach is to transplant across a potentially positive crossmatch while utilizing strategies to decrease the significance of the human leukocyte antigen antibodies. This review will examine the challenges and the impact of sensitization on pediatric patients prior to and following heart transplantation.