Clinical Interventions for Hyperacusis in Adults: A Scoping Review to Assess the Current Position and Determine Priorities for Research

BACKGROUND

There is no universally accepted definition for hyperacusis, but in general it is characterised by decreased sound tolerance to ordinary environmental sounds. Despite hyperacusis being prevalent and having significant clinical implications, much remains unknown about current management strategies.

PURPOSE

To establish the current position of research on hyperacusis and identify research gaps to direct future research.

DESIGN AND SAMPLE

Using an established methodological framework, electronic and manual searches of databases and journals identified 43 records that met our inclusion criteria. Incorporating content and thematic analysis approaches, the definitions of hyperacusis, management strategies, and outcome measures were catalogued.

RESULTS

Only 67% of the studies provided a definition of hyperacusis, such as "reduced tolerance" or "oversensitivity to sound." Assessments and outcome measures included Loudness Discomfort Levels, the Hyperacusis Questionnaire, and Tinnitus Retraining Therapy (TRT) interview. Management strategies reported were Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, TRT, devices, pharmacological therapy, and surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Management strategies were typically evaluated in patients reporting hyperacusis as a secondary complaint or as part of a symptom set. As such the outcomes reported only provided an indication of their effectiveness for hyperacusis. Randomised Controlled Trials are needed to evaluate the effectiveness of management strategies for patients experiencing hyperacusis.

Simultaneous, unilateral plugging of superior and posterior semicircular canal dehiscences to treat debilitating hyperacusis

OBJECTIVE

To describe a case of bilateral superior and posterior semicircular canal dehiscences, and the use of a unilateral transmastoid approach to address both right-sided defects simultaneously.

CASE REPORT

In a patient with right-sided hyperacusis, bilateral dehiscence of both the superior and the posterior semicircular canals was identified, located adjacent to the common crus, together with a right-sided, anterosuperiorly positioned sigmoid sinus and a high-riding jugular bulb. Results for audiography and cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potential testing were consistent with right-sided semicircular canal dehiscence. At surgery, a right-sided transmastoid approach provided access to plug both defects simultaneously, following posterior mobilisation of the sigmoid sinus. The patient's hyperacusis was completely resolved, with a 10-30 dB improvement in his right ear air conduction hearing, without decrement in bone conduction.

CONCLUSION

In properly selected patients, a transmastoid approach can be used to effectively manage superior semicircular canal dehiscence and posterior semicircular canal dehiscence simultaneously. Pre-operative computed tomography is recommended to evaluate the dehiscence sites and to identify complicating vascular anatomy.

15th Yahya Cohen Memorial Lecture - the relationship between the air-bone gap and the size of superior semicircular canal dehiscence

INTRODUCTION

This study aimed to examine the relationship between the air-bone gap (ABG) and the size of the superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SSCD) as measured on a computed tomography (CT) scan.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study design was a case series with chart review. Twenty-three patients (28 ears) from a tertiary referral centre were diagnosed with SSCD. The size of the dehiscence on CT scans and the ABG on pure-tone audiometry were recorded.

RESULTS

The size of the dehiscence ranged from 1.0 to 6.0 mm (mean, 3.5 ± 1.6 mm). Six ears with a dehiscence measuring less than 3.0 mm did not have an ABG (0 dB). The remaining 18 ears showed an average ABG at 500, 1000, and 2000 Hz (AvABG(500-2000)) ranging from 3.3 to 27.0 dB (mean, 11.6 ± 5.7 dB). The analysis of the relationship between the dehiscence size and AvABG(500-2000) revealed a correlation of R(2) = 0.828 (P <0.001, quadratic fit) and R(2) = 0.780 (P <0.001, linear fi t). Therefore, the larger the dehiscence, the larger the ABG at lower frequencies on pure-tone audiometry.

CONCLUSION

In SSCD patients, an ABG is consistently shown at the low frequency when the dehiscence is larger than 3 mm. The size of the average ABG correlates with the size of the dehiscence. These findings highlight the effect of the dehiscence size on conductive hearing loss in SSCD and contribute to a better understanding of the symptomatology of patients with SSCD.

Acoustic injury and TRPV1 expression in the cochlear spiral ganglion

Acoustic trauma not only produces temporary and permanent hearing loss but is a common cause of chronic tinnitus. Recent work indicated a possible role for the transient receptor potential channel vanilloid subfamily type 1 (TRPV1) in modulating the effects of cochlear injury. In our research, we investigated the effects of acoustic damage on TRPV1 expression in spiral ganglion neurons of adult rats. After exposing them unilaterally to noise, we extracted cochleas and processed the spiral ganglion for TRPV1 expression at four posttrauma intervals (2 hours, 24 hours, 12 days, and 16.9 months). We measured TRPV1 immunodensity in the apical, middle, and basal turns of the cochlea. We found a significant interaction (p = .039) between posttrauma interval and regional cochlear receptor expression: For survival intervals between 24 hours and 2 weeks, TRPV1 density increased in all cochlear regions; at the longest survival interval (16.9 months), TRPV1 density was dramatically reduced in the basal region. We also psychophysically tested the long-survival subjects, which showed evidence of 20-kHz tonal tinnitus. These results suggest that TRPV1 may participate after cochlear injury in a signal cascade that is responsible for the neuroplastic events leading to tinnitus and hyperacusis.

Drop attacks secondary to superior canal dehiscence syndrome

Two patients with unprovoked drop attacks were found to have dehiscence of the superior semicircular canal on CT of the temporal bone. Both had conductive hearing loss, preservation of stapedius reflex, and abnormal vestibular evoked myogenic potentials. Neither had sound- or pressure-induced nystagmus. Repair of the dehiscence in one case stopped the drop attacks, supporting a causal relationship between the dehiscence and the drop attacks.

Incapacitating hypersensitivity to one's own body sounds due to a dehiscence of bone overlying the superior semicircular canal. A case report

We present a case study of a 49-year-old patient with an 8-year history of hypersensitivity to sound produced by intrinsic but not extrinsic sources. Findings that indicated an organic problem were: a supranormal bone conduction threshold of -25 to -15 dB HL from 0.25 to 1 kHz with an air-bone gap of 15 to 45 dB HL, a lower threshold and larger amplitude for vestibular-evoked myogenic potentials, eye movement reactions to sound and trunk pitch sway in response to sound. Results of immitance audiometry and otoacoustic emission testing were within normal limits and indicative of intact middle ear conductance. A high-resolution CT scan of the temporal bone demonstrated a dehiscence of bone overlying the superior semicircular canal. These findings support previous research indicating that auditory energy reaches the cochleo-vestibular receptor systems more easily via transmission through cerebrospinal fluid than through bone. Therefore, a dehiscence of the bone overlying the superior semicircular canal may lead to hypersensitivity to intrinsic sound. We recommend that similar findings in other patients be followed up with an evaluation of middle ear function and the temporal bone with high-resolution CT scan.

Central hyperacusis with phonophobia in multiple sclerosis

Hearing disorders are a well-described symptom in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS). Unilateral or bilateral hyperacusis or deafness in patients with normal sound audiometry is often attributed to demyelinating lesions in the central auditory pathway. Less known in MS is a central phonophobia, whereby acoustic stimuli provoke unpleasant and painful paresthesia and lead to the corresponding avoidance behaviour. In our comparison collective, patient 1 described acute shooting pain attacks in his right cheek each time set off by the ringing of the telephone. Patient 2 complained of intensified, unbearable noise sensations when hearing nonlanguage acoustic stimuli. Patient 3 noticed hearing unpleasant echoes and disorders of the directional hearing. All patients had a clinical brainstem syndrome. ENT inspection, sound audiometry and stapedius reflex were normal. All three patients had pathologically changed auditory evoked potentials (AEPs) with indications of a brainstem lesion, and in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) demyelinating lesions in the ipsilateral pons and in the central auditory pathway. The origin we presume in case 1 is an abnormal impulse conduction from the leminiscus lateralis to the central trigeminus pathway and, in the other cases, a disturbance in the central sensory modulation. All patients developed in the further course a clinically definite MS. Having excluded peripheral causes for a hyperacusis, such as, e.g., an idiopathic facial nerve palsy or myasthenia gravis, one should always consider the possibility of MS in a case of central phonophobia. Therapeutic possibilities include the giving of serotonin reuptake inhibitors or acoustic lenses for clearly definable disturbing frequencies.

Temporal bone pathology in a case of Cogan's syndrome

Cogan's syndrome (CS) presents typical and atypical types. Typically, there are episodes of nonsyphilitic keratitis and audiovestibular dysfunction. Atypically, there are inflammatory changes in other eye structures and other organ systems, particularly the cardiovascular system. The temporal bone pathology in a case of CS shows changes that are similar to those observed in other autoimmune disorders associated with audiovestibular dysfunction. The following pathologic features characterize autoimmune inner ear disease: 1. acute labyrinthitis resulting in atrophy of inner ear tissues including the sense organs and their supporting structures; 2. endolymphatic hydrops; 3. focal and diffuse proliferation of fibrous tissue and bone; and 4. retrograde neuronal degeneration. These pathologic findings are consistent with an inflammatory (and possibly ischemic) attack on the membranous labyrinth.

Loudness recruitment in abrupt drop sensorineural hearing impairment

Monaural bifrequency loudness balance tests were performed on 11 adults with abrupt drop sensorineural hearing impairment. To study frequencies on the slope, 2-octave Bekesy threshold measurements were made beginning at a frequency exhibiting normal hearing nearest to initiation of the slope (F1). Loudness was matched (Test 1) between F1 and F2 (a frequency nearest to termination of the slope), (Test 2) between F1 and F1 + F2/2 (a frequency halfway between F1 and F2), and (Test 3) between F1 and 2F1 (a frequency an octave above F1). Our data indicated that a combination of asymptotic and straight-line recruitment was demonstrated in Test 1, pure asymptotic recruitment in Test 2, and straight-line recruitment in Test 3. It was speculated that diffuse hair cell lesions such as in frequency areas in the vicinity of 2F1 in abrupt drop sensorineural hearing impairment or endolymphatic hydrops may show straight-line recruitment, and discrete outer hair cell lesions such as frequency regions around F1 + F2/2 may demonstrate pure asymptotic recruitment. Our results were discussed in relation to histopathological findings of human and animal subjects with abrupt drop hearing loss reported by other investigators. Data appeared to show a relationship between the types of loudness recruitment and the hair cell damage.