Delayed graft function of more than six days strongly decreases long-term survival of transplanted kidneys

BACKGROUND

We reviewed 843 first cadaver kidney transplants carried out consecutively at our center to examine the effect on long-term graft survival of the duration of delayed graft function (DGF), defined as the time taken for the kidney to attain the threshold of a Cockcroft calculated creatinine clearance (cCCr) > or = 10 ml/min.

METHODS

Using a multivariate Cox survival analysis we evaluated the consequences of DGF on allograft survival, and then by regression analysis identified the factors contributing to the occurrence of DGF. Finally, using a Kaplan Meier analysis we compared the profiles of graft failure according to the duration of DGF.

RESULTS

Defining DGF in terms of cCCr rather than necessity for dialysis after transplantation allowed better prediction of long-term graft loss. Indeed, patients with a Cockcroft-based DGF > six days who did not require dialysis (12%) had a significantly poorer long-term graft outcome than those with a DGF < or = six days. Furthermore, we showed that a DGF of six days could be taken as a cut-off point that marked a significant difference in the long-term graft survival rate (P < 0.0001). Surprisingly, further extension of the duration of DGF > six days was not associated with further worsening of graft survival (except in DGF > 30 days).

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest a threshold effect in the lesions that ultimately results in long-term functional deficiency. In addition, we show that the need for dialysis is not an adequate criterium for DGF in terms of long-term outcome prediction.

Efficacy Endpoints Conference on Acute Rejection in Kidney Transplantation: review of the conference questionnaire

Basic differences in the diagnosis and management of acute rejection in renal transplant can be found between centers. A questionnaire was developed to ascertain the profile of these variables. Sixteen fundamental questions were presented to the program directors of 17 transplant groups from around the world. The questions were brief and designed to identify clinical practice and behaviors related to the definition of acute and steroid-resistant rejection, successful response to therapy, use of histological diagnosis, estimated frequency of rejection, and frequency of mild, moderate, or severe acute rejections. Clinicians were presented with case studies and asked to respond to specific questions regarding the rejection management described in these cases to determine similarities in management practices. Results indicated that clinicians relied on clinical symptoms only rarely. Biopsy findings were used by 53% of clinicians, and 94% of clinicians indicated that rejection was suspected if creatinine increased. Successful response was defined as a return to prerejection creatinine level by 77% of clinicians and that steroid-resistant rejection is evident by 5 days. Biopsy was used by 80% of centers to diagnose first acute rejection episode, and only 18% of rejection episodes are expected to be severe. This report was then used to develop a more detailed questionnaire to be used in profiling acute rejection in consecutive transplant recipients.

Comparing outcomes in renal replacement therapy: how should we correct for case mix?

The need to evaluate the effectiveness of clinical practice to justify expensive therapy in the face of financial constraints in all areas of health care delivery makes it necessary to identify groups of patients who are likely to benefit most from treatment. Various risk stratification methods have been used for analyzing survival probabilities for patients receiving renal replacement therapy. Complicated risk stratification methods produce large numbers of risk groups of small sizes, which makes comparison between individual centers difficult. We compared three simple methods of risk stratification, that divided patients into low-, medium-, and high-risk groups, in a cohort of 1,407 patients who commenced renal replacement therapy in five European countries during a 7-year period. Method 1 considered age (>55 years) and diabetes alone; method 2 used a higher age limit (>70 years) and comorbid illnesses, including those other than diabetes; and method 3 used only the number of comorbidities (none, 1, or > or =2) for stratification. Kaplan-Meier survival curves were constructed for comparison between risk groups and Cox's regression model used to assess strength of relationship with mortality. Although patient survival was significantly different between the low-, medium-, and high-risk groups using all three methods, Cox's regression analysis showed that method 2 provided the greatest discrimination between risk groups. In predicting mortality, method 2 (based on comorbidities and age) showed the highest sensitivity and specificity (84% and 80%, respectively) compared with method 1 (80% and 74%) and method 3 (64% and 82%). Validation of this approach in other populations in a prospective study is required before this method, which takes into account the influences of both age and comorbidity for risk stratification, can be used for comparing survival data and for presenting results of renal replacement therapy.

Effect of long-term immunosuppression in kidney-graft recipients on cancer incidence: randomised comparison of two cyclosporin regimens

BACKGROUND

Long-term administration of cyclosporin carries a risk of renal toxicity, and immunosuppressants are associated with an increased rate of malignant disorders. We undertook an open randomised study of the risks and benefits of two long-term maintenance regimens of cyclosporin in kidney-allograft recipients. The primary endpoint was graft function; secondary endpoints were survival and occurrence of cancer and rejection.

METHODS

231 recipients of a first allograft with at most one previous rejection episode were randomised 1 year after transplantation. Most were receiving cyclosporin and azathioprine. One group received cyclosporin doses adjusted to yield trough blood concentrations of 75-125 ng/mL (low-dose group); the second received doses that yielded trough concentrations of 150-250 ng/mL (normal-dose group). Analysis was by intention to treat.

FINDINGS

At 66 months' follow-up, the low-dose and normal-dose groups were similar in mean serum creatinine (182 [SD 160] vs 184 [157] micromol/L; p=0.9) and mean creatinine clearance (47.5 [25.1] vs 45.3 (22.5] mL/min; p=0.6). Nine of 116 patients in the low-dose group and one of 115 in the normal-dose group had symptoms of rejection (p<0.02). There was no difference between the low-dose and normal-dose groups in survival (95 vs 92%; p=0.7) or graft survival (89 vs 82%; p=0.17) at 6 years. 60 patients developed cancers, 37 in the normal-dose group and 23 in the low-dose group (p<0.034); 66% were skin cancers (26 vs 17; p<0.05).

INTERPRETATION

We found no evidence that halving of trough blood cyclosporin concentrations significantly changes graft function or graft survival. The low-dose regimen was associated with fewer malignant disorders but more frequent rejection. The design of long-term maintenance protocols for transplant recipients based on powerful immunosuppressant combinations should take these potential risks into account.

Disposition of basiliximab, an interleukin-2 receptor monoclonal antibody, in recipients of mismatched cadaver renal allografts

BACKGROUND

Basiliximab is an interleukin-2 receptor (IL-2R; CD25) chimeric monoclonal antibody for immunoprophylaxis against acute rejection in renal transplantation. Its pharmacokinetics were characterized in a multicenter open-label, prospective dose-escalation study to identify a single-dose regimen providing IL-2R-saturating serum concentrations in the critical first posttransplant month.

METHODS

Thirty-two recipients of primary, mismatched cadaver kidneys were enrolled: 20 men and 12 women, who were 47+/-11 years old and weighed 65+/-12 kg. The immunosuppression regimen consisted of steroids and azathioprine from day 0 and cyclosporine from day 10. Basiliximab was infused over 30 min as a single dose preoperatively.

RESULTS

Thirty patients were evaluable for basiliximab pharmacokinetics: 24 received 40 mg and 6 received 60 mg. Basiliximab was well tolerated without evidence of cytokine-release syndrome, hypersensitivity reactions, or anti-idiotype antibody response. Peak concentration and area under the concentration curve increased proportionally with dose. Postinfusion concentrations declined in a biphasic manner with a terminal half-life of 6.5+/-2.1 days. Weak, widely dispersed correlations were noted between body weight versus distribution volume (r=0.29) and versus clearance (r=0.45), suggesting no clinical relevance for weight-adjusted dosing. There were no apparent gender-related differences in basiliximab disposition. Previous phase II data indicated that serum concentrations in excess of 0.2 microg/ml are sufficient to saturate IL-2R epitopes on circulating T lymphocytes. Concentrations were above this threshold for 26+/-8 days (range 16 to 46) at the 40-mg dose level and for 32+/-11 days (range 22 to 51) at the 60-mg dose level.

CONCLUSIONS

Total basiliximab doses of 40-60 mg were well tolerated, nonimmunogenic, and estimated to provide immunoprophylaxis to cover the first posttransplant month.

Development of a method for direct quantification of cytomegalovirus antigenemia by flow cytometry

Cytomegalovirus (CMV) antigenemia was directly detected in polymorphonuclear leukocytes (PMNLs) from transplant recipients by using flow cytometry (FC). Two fixation and permeabilization methods and seven anti-CMV monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) were evaluated. 1C3, SL20, and NEA-9221 MAbs were more efficacious. The antigenemia detection threshold of FC was 0.05% positive PMNLs, and percentages correlated well with DNA viral load and the appearance of clinical symptoms.

Usefulness of DNA viral load quantification for cytomegalovirus disease monitoring in renal and pancreas/renal transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

The purpose of this prospective study was to evaluate the usefulness of quantifying DNA-cytomegalovirus (CMV) load for the diagnosis and monitoring of CMV disease among renal and pancreas transplant patients under immunosuppressive drugs.

METHODS

A longitudinal study was conducted among 34 consecutive, unselected renal and pancreas/renal transplanted patients in our unit. During the first 3 posttransplant months, weekly monitoring of CMV infection and CMV disease was done, involving the determination of viremia by the shell vial assay, qualitative DNAemia by semi-nested polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and quantitative DNAemia by the hybrid capture system (HCS), a new and original hybridization method (337 samples were collected for each test). Qualitative and quantitative DNAemia results were blinded to physicians and three grades of disease were defined according to CMV related symptom occurrence.

RESULTS

PCR was the most sensitive (100%) but the least specific (78%) method for the diagnosis of CMV disease. HCS was specific for CMV genome detection, sensitive and reproducible. Blood DNA levels above 60 pg/ml were predictive of severe or moderate CMV disease (sensitivity, 92%; specificity, 100%). A significant decrease in viral load was observed after ganciclovir administration, and a positive PCR or HCS result at the end of the antiviral treatment was associated with relapse of CMV infection or disease.

CONCLUSIONS

It is concluded that quantitative DNAemia detection, with this new commercially available method, can predict disease and may be useful for a rational evaluation of ganciclovir preemptive therapy in such patients.

Successful quantification of cytomegalovirus DNA by competitive PCR and detection with capillary electrophoresis

Human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) is responsible for severe infections in immunocompromised patients. Viral load has recently been identified as one of the major risk factors for subsequent development of HCMV disease. In this context, we developed a protocol allowing rapid, sensitive and precise quantification of HCMV DNA using competitive PCR run to saturation. Long primers were used for amplification, and internal DNA standard was constructed by PCR, with a primer inducing formation of a loop on the target sequence. The obtained fragment differed from the wild one (142 bp) by 6 bp. Quantitative analysis of PCR-amplified HCMV DNA was carried out using an original system combining capillary gel electrophoresis and u.v. detection. This procedure was evaluated on renal transplant recipients, and the results of quantitative PCR were compared with those of viraemia, qualitative DNAemia and HCMV-related symptoms. High levels of HCMV DNA were associated with HCMV-related symptoms, and in all cases a significant decrease of viral load was observed following DHPG treatment. Competitive PCR with capillary electrophoresis detection appears to provide a sensitive quantification method for HCMV DNA in leukocytes and is easily adaptable to routine laboratory use.

Anti-CD4 MoAb therapy in kidney transplantation--a pilot study in early prophylaxis of rejection

B-F5, a mouse IgG1 anti-CD4 MoAb, was used in recipients of a first cadaveric kidney allograft. Eighteen patients received 30 mg/day MoAb with a quadruple sequential therapy. All but one kidney were functioning at 6 months, with a mean serum creatinine of 153 micromol/L. However, 50% of the patients had an acute rejection episode within the first three months, and most of the early episodes (i.e., < 1 month) occurred in patients with low levels of circulating MoAb. The biological analysis showed a strong depleting effect on the CD4+ cell counts, a saturation by the MoAb of the remaining circulating CD4+ cells, and no detectable immunization against B-F5. Although the biological parameters indicate an action of B-F5 in vivo, the clinical data associated with poor MoAb bioavailability suggest the need for an improved pharmacokinetic behavior of the MoAb to determine its use for prophylaxis of early rejection.

[Economic contribution of mofetil mycofenolate as preventive immunosuppressive treatment after renal transplantation from cadaver]

OBJECTIVES

The economic impact resulting from the clinical consequences of immunosuppressive strategy using mycophenolate mofetil in new renal transplant recipients was conducted considering the viewpoint of the health insurance system.

METHODS

The analysis was based on the results of three controlled randomized double-blind clinical trials comparing mycophenolate mofetil with placebo or azathioprine in 1003 out of 1493 included patients respectively. Health care costs associated with each event were determined by 7 French experts in renal transplantation working in six different hospitals. Direct cumulative costs for each strategy were compared.

RESULTS

The studies demonstrated a difference in the incidence of acute rejection and treatment failures whatever the cause. The three trials showed that, compared with current strategies, use of mycophynolate mofetil in the immunosuppression protocol generated a 19 to 38% cost reduction during the 6 months after transplantation. Cost reduction resulted from lower incidence of acute rejection and the subsequent nephrectomics and dialysis sessions. The sensitivity analysis on the most important cost factors-cost of hospitalization per day and number of hospitalization days-confirmed strength of the results.

CONCLUSION

Use of mycophenolate mofetil in the immunosuppressive prophylaxis protocol after renal transplantation allows a reduction in the direct costs during the 6 months following transplantation.

Survival on renal replacement therapy in Europe: is there a 'centre effect'?

OBJECTIVE

Survival is the ultimate outcome measure in renal replacement therapy (RRT) and may be used to compare performance among centres. Such comparison, however, is meaningless if the influences of comorbidity, age and early deaths are not considered. We therefore studied survival rates on RRT in seven centres in Europe after taking into account the influence of age, early deaths, primary renal diagnoses, and comorbidity.

DESIGN

A retrospective survival analysis was carried out on 1407 patients who commenced RRT in seven centres across five European countries during a 7-year period. Patients were stratified into low-, medium- and high-risk groups based mainly on comorbidity and to a lesser extent on age at commencement of RRT. Kaplan-Meier survival and Cox's proportional hazards model were used to compare survival.

RESULTS

Before risk stratification overall 2-year survival across the seven centres ranged from 60.2 to 85.3% (69.3-89.9%) after excluding early deaths) masking a range of survivals of 27.4% for the high-risk group with the worst survival to 100% in the low-risk group with the best survival. After excluding early deaths 2-year survival in the low risk groups (n=622) was greater than 90% in all centres. Multivariate analysis showed that the mortality risk increased four fold from low- to medium- and a further 1.6-fold from medium- to high-risk group. However, despite this adjustment for comorbidity and age there still remained a significant difference in survival among some centres, i.e. a 'centre effect' which ranked the centres.

CONCLUSION

Risk stratification diminishes the variance in survival between centres but a centre effect remains despite adjusting for age and comorbidity. Multicentre prospective studies are urgently required to identify the reasons for this apparent centre effect.

Single-center analysis of 468 first cadaveric kidney allografts with a uniform ATG-CsA sequential therapy

Progress in clinical management and sophistication of immunological treatment of kidney allografts depend upon continuous reassessment of the risk factors related to pre- and post-graft information according to the therapeutical strategies used. We studied predictive factors of long-term graft survival (up to 9 years) and of kidney graft function at one year after surgery in a single-center population of 468 first cadaveric kidney recipients treated with a uniform immunosuppression induction regimen of anti-thymocyte globulin, followed by cyclosporine A. The statistical analysis showed that long-term graft survival was highly correlated with the occurrence of one or more acute cellular rejections and with the timing of these episodes. In addition, this uniformly treated series of patients confirmed the potential importance of gender matching. The magnitude of anti-HLA immunization and delayed graft function were also strongly linked to low graft survival rates. We found no significant influence of HLA matching, with serological HLA typing, on graft loss. The quality of graft function at one year was found to be a strong prognostic factor of long-term graft survival. In addition, the impact of pre- and post-graft parameters were studied in terms of prediction of one-year graft function. A stepwise multivariate analysis showed that graft function at one year was a multivariate phenomenon strongly correlated with a history of acute rejection episodes and with donor and recipient age. However, these 3 factors could account for only 15% of the graft function deterioration, the remaining 85% might be explained in part by chronic cyclosporine toxicity and/or chronic rejection.

Late acute failure of well-HLA-matched renal allografts with capillary congestion and arteriolar thrombi

Seventeen cases of a histologically and clinically unusual renal acute dysfunction in kidney recipients, individualized among a population of 1378, are reported. The basic histological lesion was a huge capillary congestion, associated with capillary and arteriolar thromboses or parenchymal necrosis in most patients, and contrasting with the absence of the classical features of acute cellular rejection, i.e., tubulitis, glomerulitis, edema, and infiltrate. The corresponding clinical history was characterized by its early timing in the course of transplantation (< 3 months), its sudden occurrence in patients usually having good transplant function, leading to end-stage renal failure in a few days, and its resolution under rejection treatment. The occurrence of this syndrome was significantly linked with a good HLA matching: 13 of the 17 recipients were HLA-DR matched (P < 0.0001). The etiology of this syndrome remains unknown. There was no evidence for graft vessel thrombosis. Because of some histological similarities, the usual causes of the hemolytic uremic syndrome, including bacterial and viral infections or cyclosporine arteriolopathy, were discussed. Acute vascular rejection was suspected, but the cross-match was negative on T lymphocytes in all cases and anti-HLA class I and II antibodies were not found to develop at the time of transplant dysfunction, except in 1 patient, in whom the detected anti-DR antibodies were not directed at the kidney donor. Anti-human umbilical vein endothelial cell antibodies, detected in an antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity assay, were present in 6 patients (of the 14 tested) at the onset of renal failure, but they were either absent (n = 3) or already present at the time of transplantation (n = 5) in the other 8 patients. Therefore, reliable arguments are lacking to conclude that this acute transplant dysfunction is an acute vascular rejection and its strong association with HLA matching has, as yet, no satisfactory explanation.

Graft-infiltrating T helper cells, CD45RC phenotype, and Th1/Th2-related cytokines in donor-specific transfusion-induced tolerance in adult rats

Specific tolerance to LEW.1W (RT1u) heart allografts can be induced in adult LEW.1A (RT1a) rats by donor-specific blood transfusion (DST). We have previously shown that both rejected and tolerated grafts are heavily infiltrated by T lymphocytes, and that in both cases these T cells are capable of developing similar cytotoxic responses against donor cells in vitro; tolerance is therefore not due to the deletion of alloreactive T cells. At the same time, we found that the accumulation of IL-2 and IFN-gamma mRNA was decreased in tolerated grafts compared with rejected grafts. These results suggested that the induction of allograft tolerance in DST-treated animals could be mediated by anergy or suppression of graft-infiltrating Th1 cells. Although Th1 and Th2 clones have not yet been characterized in the rat, peripheral CD4+ rat T cells can be divided into two populations, based on their expression of the isoform RC of the CD45 molecule. Upon activation, CD45RChigh CD4+ T cells produce IL-2 and IFN-gamma and responsible for the induction of the graft-versus-host reaction, whereas CD45RClow CD4+ T cells produce IL-4 in vitro and provide B cell help. In the present study, we show that heart allografts from both DST-treated and untreated rats were infiltrated by equivalent numbers of leukocytes, of which CD4+ T cells also made up similar percentages. Among these CD4+ T cells, we observed that in allografts from DST-treated recipients the CD45RChigh population on day 5 was very significantly smaller (P = 0.004) than in the untreated group, while CD45RClow populations remained comparable. Moreover, using a new quantitative RT-PCR method, we found a dramatic reduction in the accumulation of IL-2, IFN-gamma, IL-10, IL-4, and IL-13 mRNA in hearts from DST-treated recipients compared with those of untreated recipients during the week following transplantation. These results show that in heart allografts from DST-treated recipients, despite phenotypic changes suggesting Th1 inhibition by Th2 imbalance, T helper function was inhibited as a whole, and that in vivo the phenotype CD4+ CD45RClow does not always correlate with Th2-related cytokine-producing cells.

Prolongation of allogeneic heart graft survival in rats by administration of a peptide (a.a. 75-84) from the alpha 1 helix of the first domain of HLA-B7 01

Allospecific T lymphocytes mediate graft rejection through specific, direct or indirect, recognition of processed determinants of foreign MHC class I molecules. Small synthetic peptides derived from highly conserved sequences of the alpha 1 helix of the first domain of certain MHC class I molecules have been shown to inhibit CTL responses in vitro and to prolong graft survival in rats when combined with subtherapeutic doses of cyclosporine. Here, we report that the survival of LEW.1W heart allografts was significantly prolonged when transplanted into congenic LEW.1A recipients treated only with a peptide corresponding to residues 75-84 of the human HLA-B7-01 molecule (B7.75-84) before transplantation. The experimental value for mean survival time (+/- SD) in untreated recipients was 13 +/- 6 days and in peptide-treated recipients was 42 +/- 27 days (P < 0.002). A total of 64% of treated recipients had a functioning graft at 30 days, while grafts were rejected in all rats belonging to the control group within this time. Within graft-infiltrating leukocytes (GIL) in B7.75-84-treated animals, the proportion of T cells was significantly lower and that of CD5-/TCR alpha beta-/CD16-/CD8+ and MHC class II+ cells concomitantly increased, as compared with nontreated animals. GIL from B7.75-84-treated animals also exhibited a dramatic decrease (approximately 70%) of allospecific and spontaneous (NK) cytotoxic activity, whereas their proliferation and IL-2 production were similar in both experimental groups. The IFN-gamma, IL-2, and IL-10 mRNA levels from GIL from peptide-treated recipients were similar to levels of controls, reflecting a state of activation of GIL. Perforin and granzyme A mRNA, the level of which may be modulated parallel to impaired cytotoxic functions, were at similar levels in both experimental groups. These data demonstrate that B7.75-84 significantly prolongs graft survival in LEW.1A rats when given as a single agent and suggests that a specifically decreased cytotoxic response (allospecific and spontaneous) plays a major role.

Decreased anti-donor major histocompatibility complex class I and increased class II alloantibody response in allograft tolerance in adult rats

Permanent tolerance to allografts can be induced in adult rats by donor-specific transfusions (DST) prior to transplantation. We have previously reported, in a model of heart allograft, the presence of a heavy leukocyte infiltrate, in the allograft which displayed a strong allospecific cytotoxicity when tested in vitro against donor cells, and a strong accumulation of mRNA for granzyme A and perforin in vivo. In contrast, there was a major decrease in the accumulation of mRNA for interleukin-2 and interferon-gamma. These results suggested that the DST-induced tolerance was associated with a decrease in type-1 T helper (Th1) cell function. The major role of preformed antibodies in xeno and allorejection is clearly established. Nevertheless, the consequences of alloantibody production in acute rejection and tolerance induction remains to be elucidated. We here analyze the alloantibody response in rejecting and DST-treated recipients. We show that, after transplantation, tolerant recipients, in contrast to rejecting ones, mount a low IgM alloresponse that switches to low IgG production. Detailed analysis of IgG alloantibodies in DST-treated recipients revealed that their production decrease was not equally distributed. Whereas rejecting animals mounted a strong anti-class I and II IgG alloantibody response, DST-treated recipients produced anti-class II and low titers of anti-class I IgG alloantibodies. Furthermore, among IgG subclasses, tolerant recipients predominantly produced IgG2a, a profile which, in the rat, is compatible with a Th2-controlled response. Finally, the passive transfer of immune serum from rejecting animals to DST-treated recipients could abrogate the tolerance. We suggest that the absence of anti-class I alloantibodies combined with preserved and/or increased anti-class II production plays a major role in graft tolerance in this model. These results reinforced the role of alloantibodies in rejection and in induction of tolerance.