Anergic T cells inhibit the antigen-presenting function of dendritic cells

The phenomena of infectious tolerance and linked-suppression are well established, but the mechanisms involved are incompletely defined. Anergic T cells can inhibit responsive T cells in vitro and prolong skin allograft survival in vivo. In this study the mechanisms underlying these events were explored. Allospecific mouse T cell clones rendered unresponsive in vitro inhibited proliferation by responsive T cells specific for the same alloantigens. The inhibition required the presence of APC, in that the response to coimmobilized anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 Abs was not inhibited. Coculture of anergic T cells with bone marrow-derived dendritic cells (DC) led to profound inhibition of the ability of the DC to stimulate T cells with the same or a different specificity. After coculture with anergic T cells expression of MHC class II, CD80 and CD86 by DC were down-regulated. These effects did not appear to be due to a soluble factor in that inhibition was not seen in Transwell experiments, and was not reversed by addition of neutralizing anti-IL-4, anti-IL-10, and anti-TGF-beta Abs. Taken together, these data suggest that anergic T cells function as suppressor cells by inhibiting Ag presentation by DC via a cell contact-dependent mechanism.

Critical role of costimulation in the activation of naive antigen-specific TCR transgenic CD8+ T cells in vitro

The influence of costimulation on the activation of naive CD8+ T cells and thymocytes was studied in vitro using H-Y-specific TCR-transgenic mice and H-Y antigenic peptide. Using a variety of physiological APC types, the activation of naive CD8+ T cells depended strictly on costimulation, which could not be substituted by high epitope density. T cell activation is known to be regulated by the interactions between CD86/CD80 and CD28/CD152, although it remains unclear whether the B7 isoforms have distinct roles. Addition of soluble anti-CD86 Ab led to profound inhibition of T cell reactivity, further confirming the importance of costimulation in naive CD8+ T cell activation. Finally, TCR engagement in the absence of costimulation had no effect on the subsequent reactivity of peripheral naive transgenic CD8+ T cells, but induced nonresponsiveness in mature CD8+ transgenic thymocytes. Collectively, these results demonstrate the importance of costimulation for naive CD8+ T cell activation, suggest that CD80 and CD86 can mediate opposing effects, possibly due to differential interaction with CD152 and CD28, and indicate differences in the sensitivity of immature vs mature CD8+ T cells to the induction of nonresponsiveness following costimulation-deficient Ag presentation.

Anergic T cells act as suppressor cells in vitro and in vivo

The potential suppressive effects of allospecific anergic T cells were investigated both in vitro and in vivo. Allospecific T cells were rendered unresponsive in vitro using immobilized anti-CD3 mAb. These anergic T cells profoundly inhibited proliferation of responsive T cells in an antigen-specific manner. The observed inhibition did not appear to be due to the release of inhibitory cytokines in that secretion of IL-2, IFN-gamma, IL-4, IL-10 and TGF-beta was greatly reduced following the induction of anergy, and neutralizing mAb specific for IL-4, IL-10 and TGF-beta failed to reverse the inhibition. Furthermore, the suppression mediated by anergic T cells required cell to cell contact. In vivo, adoptive transfer of anergic T cells into recipients of allogeneic skin grafts led to prolonged skin graft survival. Consistent with the lack of inhibitory cytokine production by the anergic cells, prolongation of skin allograft rejection was not influenced by the simultaneous administration of a neutralizing anti-IL-4 antibody. These results indicate that anergic T cells can function as antigen-specific suppressor cells both in vitro and in vivo.

T:T antigen presentation by activated murine CD8+ T cells induces anergy and apoptosis

Using an IL-2-secreting, noncytolytic, H-Y-specific, CD8+ T cell clone, the functional consequences of Ag presentation by T cells to T cells were investigated. Incubation of the T cells with H-Y-soluble peptide led to nonresponsiveness to Ag rechallenge. This was due to the simultaneous induction of apoptosis, involving approximately 40% of the T cells, and of anergy in the surviving cells. These effects were strictly dependent upon bidirectional T:T presentation, in that exposure of C6 cells to peptide-pulsed T cells from the same clone induced proliferation but not apoptosis or anergy. The inhibitory effects of T:T presentation were not due to a lack of costimulation, since the T cells expressed levels of CD80 and CD86 higher than those detected on cultured dendritic cells and equipped them to function as efficient APCs for primary CD8+ T cell responses. Following incubation with soluble peptide, CD80 expression increased, and high levels of CTLA-4 (CD152) expression were induced. Although addition of anti-CTLA-4 Ab augmented proliferation in response to soluble peptide, no protection from apoptosis or anergy was observed. Neither Fas nor TNF-alpha was expressed/produced by the C6 cells, and coligation of MHC class I molecules and TCR failed to reproduce the effects of T:T presentation. Taken together, these data suggest that T:T Ag presentation induces anergy and apoptosis in murine CD8+ T cells and may reflect the regulatory consequences of T:T interactions in the course of clonal expansion in vivo.

Detection of CD40 on human thyroid follicular cells: analysis of expression and function

Thyroid follicular cells (TFC) are a common target of autoimmune attack, but the role they play in inciting and maintaining this attack is unclear. TFC express cytokines, adhesion molecules, and class I and II major histocompatibility complex molecules, but without additional signals that costimulate T cells, they may down-regulate, rather than stimulate, T cell function. In this report, we have investigated whether TFC can express the CD40 molecule, which plays a crucial role in the reciprocal two-way communication between T and B cells. We have shown by immunohistochemistry and flow cytometry that CD40 is expressed by TFC in vivo and in vitro in both autoimmune and nonautoimmune glands. CD40 expression was up-regulated by interleukin-1alpha and interferon-gamma, but not by TSH. Although there was no significant effect of CD40 ligation on cAMP synthesis or [3H]thymidine incorporation, there was a significant increase in interleukin-6 release by TFC. Thus, although TFC do not express members of the B7 family of T cell costimulators, they do express CD40, indicating the possibility of mutually stimulatory T cell-TFC interaction. This has important implications, both for TFC synthesis of immunological mediators and for the biasing of T cell behavior toward a T helper 2-type phenotype.

Interferon-gamma-treated renal tubular epithelial cells induce allospecific tolerance

Following organ transplantation, tissue parenchymal cells commonly express major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules as a result of local cytokine release, and thus acquire the capacity to present donor MHC alloantigens to alloreactive CD4+ T cells. The consequences of such a presentation are likely to be relevant in the induction of tolerance to the transplanted tissues, and this has been reported in animal models of transplantation and in humans. In this study, the consequences of antigen presentation by interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma)-treated human renal tubular epithelial cells (RTEC) to resting and activated CD4+ T cells were investigated. Allogeneic RTEC were unable to stimulate proliferation by peripheral blood CD45 RA+ or RO+ CD4+ T cells from three HLA-mismatched responders. The response to RTEC was partially reconstituted by the addition of murine L cell transfectants expressing human B7.1 (DAP.3-B7), suggesting that the failure of RTEC to stimulate a primary alloresponse was due, at least in part, to a lack of costimulation. T cell clones dependent on B7-mediated co-stimulation also did not respond to peptide presented by RTEC. Most importantly, this lack of reactivity was accompanied by the induction of nonresponsiveness. Incubation with allogeneic, DR-expressing RTEC induced allospecific hyporesponsiveness in both CD45RA+ and RO+ cells. Similarly, overnight incubation with antigen-pulsed RTEC induced nonresponsiveness in the B7-dependent T cell clones. These results suggest that MHC class II expression on RTEC may contribute to the induction of an allospecific nonresponsiveness following organ transplantation.

Mechanisms of peripheral T-cell tolerance

It is becoming increasingly clear that the control of self-reactivity involves peripheral mechanisms that supplement thymic negative selection. It is now generally accepted that T-cell activation depends upon both T-cell receptor engagement and the delivery of B7-mediated costimulation by specialized antigen presenting cells (APC). In contrast, failure to deliver B7-mediated costimulation can result in the induction of antigen-specific non-responsiveness. In physiological terms, costimulation-deficient antigen presentation is the prerogative of those cells that do not express B7 molecules, even during inflammatory conditions, such as tissue parenchymal cells. The consequences of such costimulation-deficient antigen presentation are illustrated by the allospecific tolerance that is observed in animal models of transplantation following the depletion of bone marrow-derived APC from an allograft. In this paper the possible role of antigen presentation by tissue parenchymal cells in the induction and maintenance of peripheral tolerance is discussed, with particular attention to the important contribution that the liver may make to these events.

Anergic T cells effect linked suppression

Although the phenomenon of T cell-mediated suppression is well established, particularly in experimental models of transplantation, the mechanisms involved in this form of immunoregulation remain controversial. We have recently demonstrated, using an in vitro system, that anergic T cells can act as suppressor cells by competing for the membrane of the antigen-presenting cell (APC) and for locally produced interleukin-2. In the experiments described here we have explored the ability of anergic T cells to effect linked suppression in antigen-specific and allospecific responses. We observed that anergic antigen-specific CD4+ T cells can inhibit T cells restricted by a different major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecule provided that both restriction elements are expressed by the same APC. In addition, anergic allospecific clones could also effect linked suppression since they could regulate not only T cells specific for the same alloantigen but also responder T cells with direct allospecificity for a second allogeneic MHC molecule or with indirect, self MHC-restricted allospecificity for a processed MHC class I alloantigen. Furthermore, the regulatory effect of the anergic T cells was dependent on cell contact, was not dependent upon irradiation, and was maintained during in vitro culture. These data demonstrate that linked suppression can be effected by anergic T cells in vitro. In the clinical context this raises the possibility that induction of tolerance to a single alloantigen could serve to regulate the immune response to an allograft carrying several MHC and minor antigen differences.

Measurement of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor frequencies reveals cryptic HLA class I mismatches in the context of unrelated donor bone marrow transplantation

BACKGROUND

In this large, two-center study, 260 cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursor (CTLp) frequency assays, performed to assess patient-donor compatibility, were analyzed in relation to the degree of HLA matching.

METHODS

While the tissue-typing techniques used at the Royal Postgraduate Medical School (RPMS) and Anthony Nolan Bone Marrow Trust (ANBMT) differ, the results of the analyses on the two sites are analogous, with high CTLp frequencies (>1:100,000) in 42% and 41% of recipient-donor pairs, respectively.

RESULTS

Recipient-donor combinations with class I mismatches and class II identity were associated with high CTLp frequencies (collectively 83% vs. 17% low CTLp). This correlation was not as strong in pairs where class II mismatches were demonstrated (61% high vs. 39% low). Despite using different matching procedures, the RPMS and ANBMT both show that 32% of the "perfectly" matched pairs (i.e., where no mismatch was detected by any of the techniques used here) had high frequencies of recipient-specific CTLp.

CONCLUSIONS

The failure of conventional methods to identify such a level of histoincompatibilities indicates that the CTLp assay has an important role in the selection of unrelated donors for bone marrow transplantation.

In the absence of the invariant chain, HLA-DR molecules display a distinct array of peptides which is influenced by the presence or absence of HLA-DM

The independent influences of invariant chain (Ii) and HLA-DM molecules on the array of naturally processed peptides displayed by HLA-DR molecules were studied using transfected cell lines. The absence of Ii led to an altered set of HLA-DR-bound peptides as judged by the discriminating responses of alloreactive T cell clones. While most T cell clones raised against DR+Ii+DM+ peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) failed to respond to DR+Ii-DM- cells, T cell clones raised against DR+Ii-DM- transfectants were not stimulated by DR+Ii+DM+ cells. Furthermore, coexpression of HLA-DM with HLA-DR1 in the absence of Ii augmented responses of anti-PBMC T cell clones but inhibited allorecognition by T cell clones raised against DR+Ii-DM- transfectants. The conformational integrity of the class II molecules, as judged by serology, suggests that the patterns of reactivity of the T cell clones reflect specificity for different alloantigen-bound peptides. Hence, discordant regulation of expression of major histocompatibility complex class II, Ii, and HLA-DM molecules in vivo may lead to the display of novel self-peptides and possible interruption of self-tolerance.

Allele-specific variation in the degeneracy of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) restriction

The role of peptides in determining immune responses for both allorecognition and antigen-specific recognition has been clearly documented. The importance of different regions of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecule in contributing to recognition has been demonstrated by studies involving site-directed mutagenesis and exon shuffling. These studies have indicated that the N-terminal region of the MHC class II molecule has a role to play in contributing to the T-cell receptor (TCR)-MHC-peptide interaction. Variation in the importance of different regions of the MHC class II molecule may be dependent on different aspects of this interaction, such as restriction specificity and affinity of the responding T-cell clone, and the nature of the bound peptide. We demonstrate here that the degree of T-cell degeneracy may be allele dependent. Thus, a series of exon-shuffled molecules were generated by shuffling the first and second variable region of a particular DR beta 1 molecule with the third variable region of a different DR beta 1 molecule. A panel of transfectants, which expressed these hybrid molecules, was then generated and used as antigen-presenting cells (APCs). A panel of peptide-specific T-cell clones was generated using the native HLA-DR molecules as the restricting elements. For the majority of restricting alleles, HLA-DRB5*0101, HLA-DRB1*1101, and HLA-DRB1*0701, all three variable regions were required for recognition. The exception to this observation was HLA-DRB1*0401, which was degenerate. Such degeneracy may facilitate the breakdown of self-tolerance through the cross-reactive recognition of other alleles in DR4/DR"x" heterozygotes. Such an observation as this may contribute to our understanding of the etiopathology of rheumatoid arthritis, an autoimmune disease strongly associated with HLA-DRB1*0401.

Clinical xenotransplantation of solid organs

A possible solution to the chronic shortage of allografts is xenotransplantation, the use of tissue from an animal donor. Most experts believe that the pig will provide the most suitable solid organs for use in human beings. Although porcine organs are rapidly rejected by a process called hyperacute rejection (HAR), there is hope that several novel therapeutic strategies, already tested in animal models, will overcome this hurdle in patients. Successful clinical trials of these strategies, expected within the next few years, may herald the era of clinical xenotransplantation. However, there is increasing evidence that other barriers, both immune and non-immune, might exist to limit the survival of xenografts beyond the HAR phase. New strategies to overcome these barriers will be needed if long-term xenograft survival equivalent to, or better than, that of allografts is ever to be achieved.

Antigen presentation by interferon-gamma-treated thyroid follicular cells inhibits interleukin-2 (IL-2) and supports IL-4 production by B7-dependent human T cells

The consequence of recognition of antigen on antigen-presenting cells that are induced to express major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules following an inflammatory process is still not clear. In this study, we have investigated the outcome of antigen presentation by epithelial cells and we have used as a model thyroid follicular cells (TFC) that are known to express MHC class II molecules in autoimmune thyroid diseases and acquire the capacity to present autoantigens to T cells infiltrating the thyroid gland. The result show that MHC class II-expressing TFC were unable to stimulate a primary T cell alloresponse, using CD4+ T cells from three HLA-mismatched responders. Phenotypic analysis showed that TFC, after incubation with interferon-gamma, do not express the costimulatory molecules B7-1 (CD80) and -2 (CD86). Addition of murine DAP.3 cells expressing human B7-1 (DAP.3-B7) to cultures containing peripheral blood CD4+ T cells and DR1-expressing TFC led to a proliferative response, suggesting that the failure of TFC to stimulate a primary alloresponse was due to a lack of co-stimulation. Similarly, HLA-DR-restricted, influenza-specific T cell clones dependent on B7 for co-stimulation did not respond to peptide presented by TFC; again the lack of response could be overcome by co-culture of TFC with DAP.3-B7. Furthermore, recognition of antigen on TFC inhibited interleukin-2 (IL-2) production in the B7-dependent T cells. In contrast, in T helper type 0 (Th0) T cells, IL-4 release was not affected by TFC presentation. In addition, antigen presentation by TFC favored IL-4 production relative to IL-2 production by B7-independent Th0 clones. These results suggest that antigen presentation by MHC class II+ TFC may induce tolerance in autoreactive Th1 cells but may simultaneously favors a Th2 response in uncommitted T cells, and thereby support autoantibody production.

The TAP complex influences allorecognition of class II MHC molecules

The influence of the TAP complex on T-cell allorecognition of MHC class II molecules was examined using human B-cell lines that have mutations in the TAP 1 or 2 genes. The TAP mutations led to the loss of allorecognition for two of 28 anti- HLA-DR T-cell clones. Restoration of TAP expression by transfection of a TAP 2 cDNA clone led to recovery of the alloresponse for both clones. These results could be explained in two ways. First, TAP dependence could reflect specificity for a peptide derived from an MHC class I molecule that is less efficiently generated by the endocytic pathway in the TAP-deficient stimulator cells owing to reduction in surface class I expression. The proliferative responses of these clones to the TAP-deficient stimulator cells was not restored by rescue of cell-surface expression of class I molecules by low temperature culture or by the addition of class I-binding peptides. These data therefore favor the alternative explanation that class II loading by some peptides is TAP dependent. Circumstances that lead to the amplification of this minority pathway of endogenous presentation by class II MHC molecules may have the potential to interrupt self-tolerance.

Antigen presentation by T cells inhibits IL-2 production and induces IL-4 release due to altered cognate signals

Conflicting results of the effects of Ag presentation by MHC class II-expressing T cells have been described. In some studies class II-expressing T cells have been shown to act as effective APCs, while others have reported that the recognition of Ag on the surface of another T cell inactivates IL-2 production. In this study we have investigated the mechanisms involved in Ag presentation by T cells. The results obtained suggest that 1) lack of costimulation is not responsible for the inhibitory effects of T cell Ag presentation on IL-2 production; the provision of costimulation by immobilized anti-CD28 Ab or by the addition of accessory cells failed to reverse the effects of T cell Ag presentation, but restored the response to immobilized anti-CD3; 2) T cell Ag presentation induced a minimal increase in intracellular Ca2+ compared with that induced by antigen-pulsed B cells; this difference in the calcium response is not explained by quantitative differences in ligand density between B cells and T cells; and 3) despite the weak calcium signal, T cell presentation supported IL-4 release in the absence of IL-2 production. Taken together these data suggest that T cell Ag presentation leads to altered TCR/CD3-transduced signals, which biases the T cell towards a Th2 phenotype.

Antigen presentation by T cells inhibits IL-2 production and induces IL-4 release due to altered cognate signals

Conflicting results of the effects of Ag presentation by MHC class II-expressing T cells have been described. In some studies class II-expressing T cells have been shown to act as effective APCs, while others have reported that the recognition of Ag on the surface of another T cell inactivates IL-2 production. In this study we have investigated the mechanisms involved in Ag presentation by T cells. The results obtained suggest that 1) lack of costimulation is not responsible for the inhibitory effects of T cell Ag presentation on IL-2 production; the provision of costimulation by immobilized anti-CD28 Ab or by the addition of accessory cells failed to reverse the effects of T cell Ag presentation, but restored the response to immobilized anti-CD3; 2) T cell Ag presentation induced a minimal increase in intracellular Ca2+ compared with that induced by antigen-pulsed B cells; this difference in the calcium response is not explained by quantitative differences in ligand density between B cells and T cells; and 3) despite the weak calcium signal, T cell presentation supported IL-4 release in the absence of IL-2 production. Taken together these data suggest that T cell Ag presentation leads to altered TCR/CD3-transduced signals, which biases the T cell towards a Th2 phenotype.

Ligation of either CD2 or CD28 rescues CD4+ T cells from HIV-gp120-induced apoptosis

Temporal or quantitative imbalance in signals delivered to T cells via T cell antigen receptor (TCR), the CD4 co-receptor, and accessory molecules can lead to anergy, apoptosis, or both. This has been observed following ligation of CD4 by HIV gp120 prior to TCR occupancy. The ability of molecules such as CD2 and CD28, interacting with their ligands LFA-3 and B7, to provide signals that protect T cells from the induction of anergy, has been reported. Here, we demonstrate that ligation of CD2 and CD28 in conjunction with TCR occupancy rescue T cells that have been programmed for apoptotic death by prior CD4 ligation to gp120. This appears to be the result of augmented interleukin-2 and interleukin-4 release by the T cells following these molecular interactions. In conclusion, our results suggest that an impairment of antigen-presenting accessory cell functions could favor gp120-mediated apoptosis in HIV-uninfected cells.

The primary alloresponse of human CD4+ T cells is dependent on B7 (CD80), augmented by CD58, but relatively uninfluenced by CD54 expression

Conflicting data have been reported regarding the relative abilities of B7, ICAM-1 and LFA-3 to provide co-stimulation for the induction of a primary T cell alloproliferative response. A series of naturally HLA-DR-expressing cell lines and panels of human and murine transfectants expressing DR alloantigens in conjunction with combinations of mouse or human B7.1, human LFA-3 and human ICAM-1 were used to analyse the contributions of these molecules to primary alloproliferative responses by adult and cord blood CD4+ T cells. The results demonstrated that B7 expression is required, and may be sufficient for the induction of a primary alloresponse. The allostimulation observed in response to DR-expressing murine DAP.3 cells, that constitutively express B7.1, was inhibited by the presence of the murine cytolytic T lymphocyte-associated antigen 4-human Fc gamma 11 fusion protein, suggesting that mouse B7.1 provides sufficient costimulation for a primary human alloproliferative response. Expression of supranormal levels of human B7.1 on the allostimulator cells led to a reduction in the proliferative response, suggesting that an optimal level of B7 exists which, if exceeded, leads to inhibition. Co-expression of LFA-3 with B7.1 by the allostimulator cells caused a marked increase in the proliferative response. Expression of ICAM-1a had relatively little effect. No differences were seen in the co-stimulatory requirements of naive cord blood versus CD45RO adult T cells. There results highlight the key molecular interactions that govern immunogenicity with relevance to inhibiting unwanted immune response to transplanted tissues and provoking anti-tumour immunity.