Fish otolith mass asymmetry: morphometry and influence on acoustic functionality

The role of the fish otolith mass asymmetry in acoustic functionality is studied. The saccular, lagenar and utricular otoliths are weighted in two species of the Black Sea rays, 15 species of the Black Sea teleost fish and guppy fish. The dimensionless otolith mass asymmetry chi is calculated as ratio of the difference between masses of the right and left paired otoliths to average otolith mass. In the most fish studied the otolith mass asymmetry is within the range of -0.2 < chi < +0.2 (< 20%). We do not find specific fish species with extremely large or extremely small otolith asymmetry. The large otoliths do not belong solely to any particular side, left or right. The heavier otoliths of different otolithic organs can be located in different labyrinths. No relationship has been found between the magnitude of the otolith mass asymmetry and the length (mass, age) of the animal. The suggested fluctuation model of the otolith growth can interpret these results. The model supposes that the otolith growth rate varies slightly hither and thither during lifetime of the individual fish. Therefore, the sign of the relative otolith mass asymmetry can change several times in the process of the individual fish growth but within the range outlined above. Mathematical modeling shows that acoustic functionality (sensitivity, temporal processing, sound localization) of the fish can be disturbed by the otolith mass asymmetry. But this is valid only for the fish with largest otolith masses, characteristic of the bottom and littoral fish, and with highest otolith asymmetry. For most fish the values of otolith mass asymmetry is well below critical values. Thus, the most fish get around the troubles related to the otolith mass asymmetry. We suggest that a specific physicochemical mechanism of the paired otolith growth that maintains the otolith mass asymmetry at the lowest possible level should exist. However, the principle and details of this mechanism are still far from being understood.

Structural variation in the inner ears of four deep-sea elopomorph fishes

Deep-sea fishes have evolved in dark or dimly lit environments devoid of the visual cues available to shallow-water species. Because of the limited opportunity for visual scene analysis by deep-sea fishes, it is reasonable to hypothesize that the inner ears of at least some such species may have evolved structural adaptations to enhance hearing capabilities in lieu of vision. As an initial test of this hypothesis, scanning electron microscopy was used to examine the structure of the inner ears of four deep-sea elopomorph species inhabiting different depths: Synaphobranchus kaupii, Synaphobranchus bathybius, Polyacanthonotus challengeri, and Halosauropsis macrochir. The shape of the sensory epithelia and hair cell ciliary bundle orientation of the saccule, lagena, and utricle, the three otolithic organs associated with audition and vestibular function, are described. The saccules of all four species have a common, alternating ciliary bundle orientation pattern. In contrast, the lagena exhibits more interspecific diversity in shape and ciliary bundle orientation, suggesting that it has special adaptations in these species. The macula neglecta, a sensory epithelium of unknown function, is present in all four species.

Localization of calbindin D-28K in the otoconia of lizard Podarcis sicula

The membranous labyrinth of lizard Podarcis sicula contains calcite and aragonite crystals. Saccule, utricle and lagena contain calcite crystals while aragonite crystals are present only in the saccule where they are very abundant. We have recently demonstrated the presence of calbindin D-28K in the organic matrix of lizard P. sicula otoconia. In order to define its localization, since calbindin modulates cellular Ca2+ level, otoconia from utricle and lagena were collected separately from those from saccule and then otoconial proteins were extracted. Immunoblot assay on proteins extracted from the otoconia and confocal laser scanning microscope analyses of otoconia using monoclonal anti-calbindin D-28K antibodies indicated that calbindin D-28K is a protein typical of aragonite crystals.

Endolymphatic calcium supply for fish otolith growth takes place via the proximal portion of the otocyst

The presence of calcium within the utricle of larval cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus was analysed by means of energy-filtering transmission electron microscopy. Electron-spectroscopic imaging and electron energy loss spectra revealed discrete calcium precipitations that were more numerous in the proximal endolymph than in the distal endolymph, clearly indicating a decreasing proximo-distal gradient. This decreasing proximo-distal gradient was also present within the proximal endolymph between the sensory epithelium and the otolith. Further calcium particles covered the peripheral proteinaceous layer of the otolith. They were especially pronounced at the proximal surface of the otolith indicating that otolithic calcium incorporation takes place here. Other calcium precipitates accumulated at the macular junctions clearly supporting an earlier assumption according to which the endolymph is supplied with calcium via a paracellular pathway. The present results clearly show that the apical region of the macular epithelium is involved in the release of calcium and that the calcium supply of the otoliths takes place via the proximal endolymph.

Quantitative analysis of stereociliary arrays on vestibular hair cells

We have developed a method for quantifying the number, spacing, and distribution of stereocilia on the apical surface of hair cells using spatial autocorrelation analysis and statistics for directional data. Here, we illustrate the method using idealized hair bundles, and we apply it to scanning micrographs of turtle hair cells from the utricle and posterior canal, and to freeze-fracture preparations of bullfrog saccule. The analysis suggests three common features of stereociliary bundles. First, bundle geometries form a continuum from 'loose' to 'tight' rather than two distinct groups. Second, interciliary spacing along the three hexagon axes is not equal; spacing is usually widest along the hexagon axis closest to the bundle's axis of bilateral symmetry (the presumptive excitatory axis). Third, spacing between stereocilia changes with distance from the kinocilium. All three features will influence predictions of the tip link tensions that accompany bundle deflection.

Morphometry of otoconia in the utricle and saccule of developing Japanese quail

The development of otoconia in the utricular and saccular maculae from initial embryonic formation to adult stages was examined in Japanese quails. Both the morphology and size of the otoconia were quantified at different developmental stages. It was observed that the otoconia were initially formed on embryologic stage E5 in the saccule and E6 in the utricle. Otolith mass areas increased in a sigmoidal growth pattern, with saccular otolith areas being smaller than the utricular mass areas. Saccular otolith masses reached adult values at embryonic stage E12 and utricular areas reached adult values at post-hatch day 7. Mature individual otoconia were characterized by a barrel shape with two trihedral faceted ends. However, initial formation of otoconia at E5 (saccular) and E6 (utricular) maculae was characterized by a double fluted morphology that consisted of an hourglass shape with extended fins forming trihedral angles of 120 degrees. Double fluted otoconia rapidly filled, so that by embryonic day 8 mature otoconia dominated the maculae for the remainder of development through adulthood. Thus, a progression from double fluted to mature forms was noted. Mature utricular otoconia in adult quails averaged 11 microm in length and 5 microm in width, with length/width ratios of approximately 2.5:1, for all size ranges. Saccular otoconia were smaller, having about 70% the size of utricular otoconia in both length and width. During development, the average size and range of individual otoconia increased nearly linearly for both otolith organs. In the utricular macula, large otoconia were concentrated in the lateral regions of the epithelium. In contrast, otoconia of various sizes were distributed uniformly across the surface of the saccular macula.

Efficacy of an ototoxic aminoglycoside (gentamicin) on the differentiation of the inner ear of cichlid fish

Previous investigations revealed that the growth of fish inner ear otoliths depends on the amplitude and the direction of gravity, thus suggesting the existence of a (negative) feedback mechanism. In the course of these experiments, it was shown that altered gravity both affected otolith size (and thus the provision of the proteinacious matrix) as well as the incorporation of calcium. It is hitherto unknown, as of whether sensory hair cells are involved either in the regulation of otolith growth or in the provision of otolithic material (such as protein or inorganic components) or even both. The ototoxic aminoglycoside gentamicin (GM) damages hair cells in many vertebrates (and is therefore used for the treatment of Meniere's disease in humans). The present study was thus designed to determine as of whether vestibular sensory cells are needed for otolith growth by applying GM in order to induce a (functionally relevant) loss of these cells. Developing cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus were therefore immersed in 120 mg/l GM for 10 or 21 days. At the beginning and at the end of the experimental periods, the fish were incubated in the calcium-tracer alizarin complexone (AC). After the experiment, otoliths were dissected and the area grown during GM-exposure (i.e., the area enclosed by the two AC labellings) was determined planimetrically. The results showed that incubating the animals in a GM-solution had no effect on otolith growth, but the development of otolith asymmetry was affected. Ultrastructural examinations of the sensory hair cells revealed that they had obviously not been affected by GM-treatment (no degenerative morphological features observed). Overall, the present results suggest that hair cells are not affected by GM concerning their possible role in (general) otolith growth, but that these cells indeed might have transitionally been impaired by GM resulting in a decreased capacity of regulating otolith symmetry.

Extremely elongated mitochondria in ionocytes of the saccular epithelium of a teleost, Oreochromis mossambicus (Cichlidae)

Unusually large mitochondria are a rather scarce feature in normal biological tissue and string-like giant mitochondria have hitherto not been reported in animals. Investigating the role of inner ear ionocytes for otolith growth, large ionocytes of the saccular epithelium of the cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus were analyzed by imaging of thick sections with energy-filtering transmission electron microscopy. We report here that ionocytes do not contain numerous small-sized mitochondria as has been suggested earlier but rather few, extremely elongated megamitochondria. Since the particular mitochondrial structure is important for normal cell function, such megamitochondria possibly reflect a functional advantage in the context of the presumed role of teleostean ionocytes in regulating the composition of the endolymphatic fluid.

No correlation between multilamellar bodies in the inner ear and further organs of mutant (backstroke, bks) and wildtype zebrafish embryos

The origin of the proteinacious matrix of the inner ear stones (otoliths) of vertebrates has not yet been clarified. Using the backstroke mutant (bks) of the zebrafish Danio rerio, which is characterized by a complete lack of otoliths, we searched for possibly missing or aberrant structural components within the macular epithelia of the inner ears of embryos on the ultrastructural level. Numerous multilamellar bodies (MLBs) were found. The MLBs were, however, not restricted to the inner ears of mutants but were also found in wildtype individuals and in further organs such as brain and liver. MLBs have hitherto never been described from the inner ear of fish and are generally estimated to be rare structures. Their occurrence in fish liver can, however, be induced by using particular chemical substances, which seem to effect adaptive compensatory processes on the cellular level. Such a chemical treatment also affects the ultrastructure of further organelles. Since the occurrence of MLBs in the liver of zebrafish was not accompanied by an alteration of the morphology of other organelles, their occurrence seems not to be due to environmental stress. The findings indicate that the MLBs cannot be correlated with bks-inherent features as well as with missing otolith development/growth. Since the occurrence of MLBs was independent from the developmental stage of a specimen and its overall tissue preservation, it can moreover be excluded that these MLBs merely represent fixation artifacts. Their presence more likely indicates cellular remodelling processes of hitherto unknown significance.

Form and function in the unique inner ear of a teleost: The silver perch (Bairdiella chrysoura)

Members of the teleost family Sciaenidae show significant variation in inner ear and swim bladder morphology as well as in the relationship between the swim bladder and the inner ear. In the silver perch (Bairdiella chrysoura), a Stellifer-group sciaenid, both the saccular and utricular otoliths are enlarged relative to those in other teleosts. Additionally, its swim bladder is two-chambered, and the anterior chamber surrounds the otic capsule and terminates lateral to the saccules. Structure and function of the auditory system of the silver perch were explored by using gross dissections, scanning electron microscopy, CT scan reconstruction, and auditory brainstem response approach. Several morphological specializations of the auditory system of the silver perch were found, including expansion of the utricular and lagenar otoliths, close proximity between the saccules and the utricles, deeply grooved sulci on the saccular otoliths, two-planar saccular sensory epithelia, and a unique orientation pattern of sensory hair cell ciliary bundles on the saccular sensory epithelium. It was determined that the silver perch can detect up to 4 kHz, with lowest auditory thresholds between 600 Hz and 1 kHz. Audition in the silver perch is comparable to that in the goldfish (Carassius auratus), a hearing "specialist." The morphological specializations of the inner ear and swim bladder of the silver perch may be linked to its enhanced hearing capabilities. The findings of this study support the proposal that sciaenids are excellent model species for investigating structure-function relations in the teleost auditory system.

Calcium gradients in the fish inner ear sensory epithelium and otolithic membrane visualized by energy filtering transmission electron microscopy (EFTEM)

Inner ear otolith formation in fish is supposed to be performed by the molecular release of proteinacious precursor material from the sensory epithelia, followed by an undirected and diffuse precipitation of calcium carbonate (which is mainly responsible for the functionally important weight of otoliths). The pathway of calcium into the endolymph, however, still remains obscure. Therefore, the presence of calcium within the utricle of larval cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus was analyzed by means of energy filtering transmission electron microscopy (EFTEM). Electron spectroscopic imaging (ESI) and electron energy loss spectra (EELS) revealed discrete calcium precipitations, which were especially numerous in the proximal endolymph as compared to the distal endolymph. A decreasing proximo-distal gradient was also present within the proximal endolymph between the sensory epithelium and the otolith. Further calcium particles covered the peripheral proteinacious layer of the otolith. They were especially pronounced at the proximal surface of the otolith. Other calcium precipitates were found to be accumulated at the macular junctions. These results strongly suggest that the apical region of the macular epithelium is involved in the release of calcium and that calcium supply of the otoliths takes place in the proximal endolymph.

Control of crystal size and lattice formation by starmaker in otolith biomineralization

The stone-like otoliths from the ears of teleost fishes are involved in balance and hearing and consist of calcium carbonate crystallites embedded in a protein framework. We report that a previously unknown gene, starmaker, is required in zebrafish for otolith morphogenesis. Reduction of starmaker activity by injection of modified antisense oligonucleotides causes a change in the crystal lattice structure and thus a change in otolith morphology. The expression pattern of starmaker, along with the presence of the protein on the growing otolith, suggest that the expression levels of starmaker control the shape of the otoliths.

Developmental biology. Rocks that roll zebrafish

The vestibular organs of the inner ear of higher vertebrates control balance, and their counterparts in fish control both balance and hearing. Essential to the operation of these sensory organs are the biomineralized structures--otoconia in higher vertebrates or otoliths in fish--that deflect the sensory hair bundles situated beneath them. In her Perspective, Fekete explores the fascinating world of otolith biomineralization in zebrafish; revealing the importance of a protein called Starmaker for coordinating the shape and type of crystal in fish otoliths ( Söllner et al.).

Histological preparation of developing vestibular otoconia for scanning electron microscopy

The unique nature of vestibular otoconia as calcium carbonate biominerals makes them particularly susceptible to chemical deformation during histological processing. We fixed and stored otoconia from all three otolith endorgans of embryonic, hatchling and adult Japanese quail in glutaraldehyde containing either phosphate or non-phosphate buffers for varying lengths of time and processed them for scanning electron microscopy. Otoconia from all age groups and otolith endorgans processed in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 7.4) showed abnormal surface morphology when compared to acetone fixed controls. Otoconia processed in 0.1 M sodium cacodylate or HEPES buffered artificial endolymph (pH 7.4) showed normal morphology that was similar to controls. The degree of otoconial deformation was directly related to the time exposed to phosphate buffer. Short duration exposure produced particulate deformations while longer exposures resulted in fused otoconia that formed solid sheets. Otoconial surface deformation and fusing was independent of the glutaraldehyde component of the histological processing. These findings should help vestibular researchers to develop appropriate histological processing protocols in future studies of otoconia.

The otoliths of the antarctic teleost Trematomus bernacchii: scanning electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction studies

The authors studied the otoliths of the Nototheniid Trematomus bernacchii with scanning electron microscopy and X-ray diffraction analysis. Results obtained reveal that three otoliths are present: a large sagitta, a lapillus and a fragile asteriscus. Their sensorial faces appear finely decorated as shown by scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The sagitta and the lapillus are aragonitic while the asteriscus is vateritic, as demonstrated by X-ray diffraction.

First steps of otolith formation of the zebrafish: role of glycogen?

The first steps of otolith formation were studied by electron microscopy in zebrafish embryos at different postfertilization (PF) time intervals. Between 19 and 22 h PF, the otic cavity contains glycogen particles derived by an apocrine process from the apical portions of the epithelial cells of the inner ear. The particles are arranged in parallel arrays, then in pseudocrystalloid structures, and finally in concentric arrays to form dense clusters referred to as "spherules". At 23 h PF, a group of "globules", consisting of modified aggregated "spherules" surrounded by several free "spherules", forms the nascent otolith. At 30 h PF, fused globules form a roughly spherical otolith. Spherules undergoing their process of modification and aggregation, are located in its central part, and constitute the so-called "nucleus". At 50 h PF, the otolith is a flattened hemisphere. It is made up of fused globules surrounded by two concentric layers whose organization is similar to that observed in the otolith of the adult fish. At this stage, calcium may be detected in the otolith except in its nucleus. We suggest that glycogen molecules found in the nascent otolith might allow the insertion of molecules such as glycoproteins (collagens) which are known to fix calcium. As a result, glycogen might play a key role in initiating the formation of otoliths and possibly that of other calcified tissues.

The role of gravity in the phylogeny of structure and function in animal sensors of spatial orientation, and their predicted action in weightlessness

The evolution of the structural, functional and cytochemical organization of the gravity receptor which determines a body position in the gravitational field of the earth by means of muscular regulation was traced both invertebrates and vertebrates, using electron microscopic and histochemical methods. In the course of evolution of vertebrates, the specialized gravity receptor-statocyst which, as a rule, consists of primary sensory cells and supplies otoliths, is formed. In vertebrates, there exists a vestibular apparatus made up of secondary sensory cells and also having otoliths. The receptor cells, both of statocysts and the vestibular apparatus, are supplied with special antennas (kinocilia and stereocilia). Deviation of the antennas stimulated by displacement of the otoliths resulting from locomotor activity of animals leads to excitation of the receptor cells. When exposed to a modified gravitational field (linear accelerations of 10 g, for 3 min), the receptor cells of the vestibular apparatus, in all classes of vertebrates, show progressive changes in RNA content and protein synthesis (increase followed by decrease) which return to normal only after 12 days. Thus, immediate transfer of animals and man from acceleration to weightlessness appears to be a reason for movement disease. The above consideration showed the need for an experiment in which an animal (with its vestibular apparatus) which had not undergone previous accelerations, would be exposed to weightlessness. Frog embryos, Rana temporaria, at the stage preceding the organogenesis, when the vestibular apparatus and other organs were lacking, were chosen as a suitable subject. Frog embryos at the stage of an early gastrula were placed in a special container Emkon aboard the Soyuz 10 spacecraft. After short accelerations, they were exposed to weightlessness for 44 hours. The embryos were allowed to continue to develop to the stage of early tail bud. The experimental embryos showed normally developed acoustic vesicles and vestibular ganglia. Clear differentiation of the receptor cells with antennas (kinocilia and stereocilia) was found in the acoustic vesicles. Thus, in weightlessness, vestibular apparatus develops just as well as in the gravitational field of the earth. However, only a much longer stay in weightlessness conditions will indicate whether there are any changes in the structural, cytochemical and functional organization of vestibular apparatus. The similarity in the structural, functional and cytochemical organization of the gravity receptor in vertebrates and invertebrates appears to allow the prediction of the behaviour of the gravity receptor as a whole, and of its receptor elements, both in normal and changed gravitational fields. The first attempts were carried out only on the vestibular apparatus of vertebrates.

High transmittance of X-rays in the utricular otolith of upside-down swimming catfish, Synodontis nigriventris

The upside-down swimming catfish (Synodontis nigriventris) has unique behavior, i.e., it frequently shows a stable upside-down posture during swimming and resting. To examine whether the unique postural control in S. nigriventris results from the characteristics of the vestibular organ, we observed the morphological aspects of the otolith and the orientation of sensory hair cells in the utricle. Soft X-ray densitometry analysis showed that the transmittance of soft X-rays in the otolith of S. nigriventris was higher than that in a closely related species (Synodontis multipunctatus) belonging to Synodontis family, goldfish (Carassius auratus) or miniature catfish (Corydoras paleatus) which shows upside-up swimming. The higher transmittance of soft X-rays suggests that the density of the otolith in S. nigriventris is lower than that in S. multipunctatus, C. auratus or C. paleatus. It is possible that the low density of the otolith may have a relation to the control of the unique upside-down posture of S. nigriventris. The hair cells in S. nigriventris were present at the ventral to ventro-lateral site of the utricular epithelium, forming a single hair cell layer as in the other 3 species of fish. The orientation of the sensory hair cells does not appear to cause the unique postural control.

Piezoelectric effects in otolith structure-function relationship

In the present report, the possible role of piezoelectric effects in the functioning of an otolith organ is discussed by comparison with effects in a man-made material, polymer composite films, in which the polymer (organic) matrix contains piezoelectric inclusions (usually, piezoceramics). The theoretical grounds of this consideration are: a piezoelectric model of gravireception proposed some time ago, and the description of otolith organ as a system with distributed parameters.

Vesicular bodies in fish maculae are artifacts not contributing to otolith growth

The presence, morphology and possible origin of vesicle-like bodies (VBs) within the inner ear macular otolithic membrane of developmental stages of cichlid fish Oreochromis mossambicus and neonate (i.e. functionally fully developed except the reproductive organs) swordtail fish Xiphophorus helleri were analyzed by means of transmission and scanning electron microscopy (TEM and SEM, respectively) employing various fixation procedures. Some authors believe that these VBs are involved in the formation of the organic phase of inner ear otoliths (or statoliths in birds and mammals). Decreasing the osmolarity of the fixation medium from a value rather close to that of native fresh water fish tissue (i.e. 250 mOsm and 290--300 mOsm, respectively) to a value of fixatives mostly employed in TEM studies (ca. 190 mOsm), the amount of VBs increased and the components of sensory inner ear tissue increasingly dilated. Whilst a conventional prefixation with aldehydes followed by osmium tetroxide postfixation yielded numerous VBs, only few of them were observed when the tissue was fixed with aldehydes and osmium tetroxide simultaneously. Therefore, the results demonstrate that inner ear sensory epithelia are extremely sensitive to altering fixation media. On this background it must be concluded that VBs are fixative (i.e. glutaraldehyde) induced artificial structures, so-called membrane blisters. Thus, the protein matrix of otoliths (and possibly that of statoliths in higher vertebrates) is rather provided by secretion processes than by the release of vesicles.