Regulation of Lck activity by CD4 and CD28 in the immunological synapse

Although the Src family tyrosine kinase Lck is essential for T cell receptor (TCR) signaling, whether or how Lck is activated is unknown. Using a phosphospecific antiserum to Lck, we show here that Lck becomes autophosphorylated when T cells are stimulated by antigen-presenting cells (APCs). We found that TCR cross-linking alone could not stimulate Lck autophosphorylation and CD45 was not required for this process. Instead, the T cell accessory molecules CD4 and CD28 cooperated to induce autophosphorylation of Lck. CD4 recruited Lck to the T cell--APC interface, whereas CD28 sustained Lck activation. These data show how the multiple interactions afforded by the immunological synapse drive efficient and highly specific signaling.

T cell receptor signaling precedes immunological synapse formation

The area of contact between a T cell and an antigen-presenting cell (APC) is known as the immunological synapse. Although its exact function is unknown, one model suggests that it allows for T cell receptor (TCR) clustering and for sustained signaling in T cells for many hours. Here we demonstrate that TCR-mediated tyrosine kinase signaling in naïve T cells occurred primarily at the periphery of the synapse and was largely abated before mature immunological synapses had formed. These data suggest that many hours of TCR signaling are not required for T cell activation. These observations challenge current ideas about the role of immunological synapses in T cell activation.

Facility of accommodation in myopia

PURPOSE

Myopes have been shown to have abnormal accommodative characteristics. This study investigated the characteristics of accommodation facility in myopic and emmetropic students.

METHODS

Distance and near positive and negative accommodation response time components of facility were measured over a 1 min period using a -2.00 D/zero lens pair for distance responses and a +/-2.00 D lens pair for near responses. 79 students (37 myopes and 42 emmetropes) aged 18-27 years acted as subjects. Subjects were masked, and the results were analysed in a masked fashion.

RESULTS

Mean distance facility was significantly lower (9.7 cycles per minute (cpm)) in the myopic group compared with the mean distance facility in the emmetropic group (15.6 cpm; p < 0.005). There was no significant difference in the near facilities of the two groups (11.5 cpm in myopes vs 12.9 cpm in emmetropes). Positive accommodation response time for distance vision was greater than 4 s in 45% of myopes and in 9% of emmetropes.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings confirm that myopes tend to have abnormal accommodation responses to blur. Distance facility, but not near facility of accommodation is more frequently reduced in myopes than in emmetropes.

The immunological synapse

The adaptive immune response is initiated by the interaction of T cell antigen receptors with major histocompatibility complex molecule-peptide complexes in the nanometer scale gap between a T cell and an antigen-presenting cell, referred to as an immunological synapse. In this review we focus on the concept of immunological synapse formation as it relates to membrane structure, T cell polarity, signaling pathways, and the antigen-presenting cell. Membrane domains provide an organizational principle for compartmentalization within the immunological synapse. T cell polarization by chemokines increases T cell sensitivity to antigen. The current model is that signaling and formation of the immunological synapse are tightly interwoven in mature T cells. We also extend this model to natural killer cell activation, where the inhibitory NK synapse provides a striking example in which inhibition of signaling leaves the synapse in its nascent, inverted state. The APC may also play an active role in immunological synapse formation, particularly for activation of naïve T cells.

Essential role of neutrophils in the initiation and progression of a murine model of rheumatoid arthritis

Neutrophils are prominent participants in the joint inflammation of human rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients, but the extent of their role in the inductive phase of joint inflammation is unknown. In the K/BxN mouse RA model, transfer of autoreactive Ig from the K/BxN mouse into mice induces a rapid and profound joint-specific inflammatory response reminiscent of human RA. We observed that after K/BxN serum transfer, the earliest clinical signs of inflammation in the ankle joint correlated with the presence of neutrophils in the synovial regions of recipient mouse ankle joints. In this study, we investigated the role of neutrophils in the early inflammatory response to transferred arthritogenic serum from the K/BxN transgenic mouse. Mice were treated with a neutrophil-depleting mAb before and following transfer of arthritogenic serum and scored for clinical indications of inflammation and severity of swelling in ankle joints and front paws. In the absence of neutrophils, mice were completely resistant to the inflammatory effects of K/BxN serum. Importantly, depletion of neutrophils in diseased recipient mice up to 5 days after serum transfer reversed the inflammatory reaction in the joints. Transfer of serum into mice deficient in the generation of nitrogen or oxygen radicals (inducible NO synthase 2 or gp91(phox) genes, respectively) gave normal inflammatory responses, indicating that neither pathway is essential for disease induction. These studies have identified a critical role for neutrophils in initiating and maintaining inflammatory processes in the joint.

Kissing cousins: immunological and neurological synapses

Immunological synapse formation is essential for T cell activation. A recent paper in Science reports that immunological and neurological synapses utilize a common molecule, agrin.

Environmental control of immunological synapse formation and duration

The coordination of T-cell migration and antigen recognition is crucial for an effective immune response. We have proposed that this coordination is achieved by formation of an immunological synapse between the T cell and the antigen-presenting cell (APC). Our view contrasts with the serial encounter model also proposed in this issue of Trends in Immunology, which is based on transient T cell-APC interactions when surrounded by collagen. Here, we propose a model that reconciles immunological synapse formation and serial encounters based on environmental control of immunological synapse formation.

Two MHC surface amino acid differences distinguish foreign peptide recognition from autoantigen specificity

KRN T cells can recognize two self MHC alleles with differing biological consequences. They respond to the foreign peptide RN(42--56) bound to I-A(k) or alternatively initiate autoimmune arthritis by interacting with a self Ag, GPI(282--294), on I-A(g7). Five surface amino acid differences between the two MHC molecules collectively alter which peptide side chains are recognized by the KRN TCR. In this study, it is shown that mutation of only two of these residues, alpha 65 and beta 78, in I-A(k) to their I-A(g7) counterparts is sufficient to allow recognition of the TCR contacts from GPI(282--294). To provide a detailed mechanism for the specificity change, the distinct contributions of each of these two mutations to the global effect on peptide specificity were analyzed. The alpha65 mutation is shown to broaden the spectrum of amino acids permissible at P8 of the peptide. In contrast, the beta 78 mutation alone blocks KRN TCR interaction with I-A(k) and requires the simultaneous presence of the alpha 65 mutation to preserve recognition. In the presence of the alpha 65 mutation, the beta 78 residue broadens peptide recognition at P3 and prevents recognition of the P8 L in RN(42--56), thus producing the observed specificity shift. These results localize the functionally relevant differences between the surfaces of two self-restricted MHC molecules to two residues that have counterbalanced positive and negative contributions to interaction with a single TCR. They highlight how subtle structural distinctions attributable to single amino acids can stand at the interface between foreign Ag responsiveness and pathogenic autoreactivity.

Structural and functional consequences of altering a peptide MHC anchor residue

To better understand TCR discrimination of multiple ligands, we have analyzed the crystal structures of two Hb peptide/I-E(k) complexes that differ by only a single amino acid substitution at the P6 anchor position within the peptide (E73D). Detailed comparison of multiple independently determined structures at 1.9 A resolution reveals that removal of a single buried methylene group can alter a critical portion of the TCR recognition surface. Significant variance was observed in the peptide P5-P8 main chain as well as a rotamer difference at LeuP8, approximately 10 A distal from the substitution. No significant variations were observed in the conformation of the two MHC class II molecules. The ligand alteration results in two peptide/MHC complexes that generate bulk T cell responses that are distinct and essentially nonoverlapping. For the Hb-specific T cell 3.L2, substitution reduces the potency of the ligand 1000-fold. Soluble 3.L2 TCR binds the two peptide/MHC complexes with similar affinity, although with faster kinetics. These results highlight the role of subtle variations in MHC Ag presentation on T cell activation and signaling.

Eradication of established tumors by CD8+ T cell adoptive immunotherapy

We generated the DUC18 T cell receptor transgenic mouse expressing an H-2Kd -restricted transgenic T cell receptor specific for the syngeneic CMS5 fibrosarcoma rejection antigen mutated ERK2(136-144). DUC18 mice were capable of specifically eliminating lethal CMS5 tumor challenges, and transfer of DUC18 splenocytes to naive nontransgenic recipients conferred protection from subsequent and established CMS5 tumor burdens. Eradication of established tumor burdens by adoptive transfer of DUC18 splenocytes was dose and time dependent. Transferred tumor-specific T cells remained functional in vivo and capable of rejecting small tumors even in the presence of large, established tumor burdens. These findings highlight the kinetic battle between tumor growth and the production of a tumor-specific response and have critical implications for effective adoptive immunotherapy.

Genetically separable determinants of hair keratin gene expression

The nude locus encodes Whn, a transcription factor of the forkhead/winged-helix class. Mutations in Whn cause failure of differentiation of thymic epithelium with a corresponding lack of intrathymic T-cell development; in the skin, differentiation of follicular keratinocytes is disturbed resulting, in the formation of fragile hair shafts. Here, we describe the identification and characterization of a novel nude allele, nu(StL). nu(StL) encodes a truncated Whn transcription factor protein, designated Whn(StL), lacking the activation domain but retaining the characteristic DNA binding domain. In contrast, the previously described Whn(nu) mutant protein lacks both domains. nu(StL)/nu(StL) mice show an alymphoid thymic rudiment and lack of peripheral T cells, similar to nu/nu mice. In the skin, impaired expression of hair keratin genes mHa1, mHa2, mHa3 and mHa4, mHb3, mHb4, mHb5, and mHb6 is observed in a pattern that parallels that of nu/nu mice: both mutant alleles behave as hypomorphs with respect to the expression of these hair keratin genes. However, a significant difference between these two alleles exists for mHa5 expression, which is reduced in nu(StL)/nu(StL) but not in nu/nu mice. We show that the mutant Whn protein in nu/nu mice cannot enter the nucleus, whereas the mutant Whn protein in nu(StL)/nu(StL) mice is present in the nucleus. The antimorphic characteristic of the activation-deficient Whn(StL) protein with respect to mHa5 expression is therefore most likely caused by its non-productive interaction with other proteins at cis-regulatory regions of the mHa5 gene. Our results indicate that the molecular consequences of mutations of the Whn gene can be different and demonstrate an unexpected complexity of transcriptional control mechanisms of hair keratin genes.

Ligand-specific selection of MHC class II-restricted thymocytes in fetal thymic organ culture

Positive and negative selection of thymocytes is determined by the specificity of the TCR and signaling through its associated molecules. We have studied selection of thymocytes bearing a MHC class II-restricted TCR using fetal thymic organ culture. This system allows the addition of peptides to the already diverse panoply of endogenous peptide ligands and is useful for analyzing ligand-specific negative selection of CD4 single positive (CD4SP) thymocytes. The data reveal that the ability of a given ligand to mediate negative selection is related to its dissociation rate from the TCR. We find that negative selection is very sensitive, and only the weakest ligand that we can identify fails to induce negative selection. None of the numerous peptides tested were able to induce an increase in CD4SP thymocytes. In addition, the ligands that induce negative selection of CD4SP thymocytes also cause an increase in numbers of CD8SP thymocytes bearing high levels of the class II-restricted TCR. Although these cells have a cell surface phenotype consistent with positive selection, they most likely represent cells in the process of negative selection. Further analysis reveals that these cells are not induced by these ligands in intact adult animals and that their induction is probably only revealed in the organ culture system.

Molecular basis for recognition of an arthritic peptide and a foreign epitope on distinct MHC molecules by a single TCR

KRN TCR transgenic T cells recognize two self-MHC molecules: a foreign peptide, bovine RNase 42-56, on I-Ak and an autoantigen, glucose-6-phosphate isomerase 282-294, on I-Ag7. Because the latter recognition event initiates a disease closely resembling human rheumatoid arthritis, we investigated the structural basis of this pathogenic TCR's dual specificity. While peptide recognition is altered to a minor degree between the MHC molecules, we show that the receptor's cross-reactivity critically depends upon a TCR contact residue completely conserved in the foreign and self peptides. Further, the altered recognition of peptide derives from discrete differences on the MHC recognition surfaces and not the disparate binding grooves. This work provides a detailed structural comparison of an autoreactive TCR's interactions with naturally occurring peptides on distinct MHC molecules. The capacity to interact with multiple self-MHCs in this manner increases the number of potentially pathogenic self-interactions available to a T cell.

Hb(64-76) epitope binds in different registers and lengths to I-Ek and I-Ak

The nature of peptide binding to MHC molecules is intrinsically degenerate, in what, one given MHC molecule can accommodate numerous peptides which are structurally diverse, and one given peptide can bind to different alleles. The structure of the MHC class II molecules allows peptides to extend out of the binding groove at both ends and these residues can potentially influence the stability and persistence of peptide/class II complexes. We have previously shown that both I-E(k) and I-A(k)-restricted T cell hybridomas could be generated against the Hb(64-76) epitope. In this study, we characterized the binding register of the Hb(64-76) epitope to I-A(k), and showed that it was shifted by one residue in comparison to its binding to I-E(k), and did not use a dominant anchor residue at P1. This conclusion was further supported by the modeling of the Hb(64-76) epitope bound to I-A(k), which revealed that all of its putative anchor residues fit into their corresponding pockets. We identified the naturally processed Hb epitopes presented by both I-E(k) and I-A(k), and found that they consisted of different species. Those associated with I-A(k) being 20-22 residues long, whereas, those found to I-E(k) contained 14-16 residues. These findings suggested that the lack of a dominant P1 anchor could be compensated by the selection of longer peptides. Overall, these studies revealed the Hb(64-76) epitope bound to I-E(k) and I-A(k) in distinct registers and lengths, demonstrating the plasticity MHC molecules have in generating distinct TCR ligands from the same amino acid sequence.

Partially phosphorylated T cell receptor zeta molecules can inhibit T cell activation

The T cell receptor complex (TCR) zeta chain is constitutively tyrosine phosphorylated specifically at two of the six zeta immunoreceptor tyrosine-based activation motif (ITAM) tyrosine residues in resting peripheral T cells. Further phosphorylation of zeta is induced by both agonist and antagonist ligands of the TCR, with agonists inducing complete phosphorylation of the zeta ITAM tyrosines. After antagonist stimulation, zeta phosphorylation is incomplete and generates discrete forms of partially phosphorylated ITAMs. Here, we mutate specific tyrosines in chimeric human CD8-zeta molecules to reflect phosphorylation in resting T cells as well as phosphorylation induced by agonist and antagonist ligands. We demonstrate that such partially phosphorylated TCR-zeta species can inhibit IL-2 production in T cell hybridomas and proliferation in T cell clones. This reveals a previously unrecognized, inhibitory function of partially phosphorylated ITAMs. These findings support the concept that TCR antagonism can arise through the generation of an inhibitory signal within the TCR complex and that constitutive zeta phosphorylation in resting T cells is an inhibitory signaling environment.

Differential requirements for CD4 in TCR-ligand interactions

The coreceptor molecule, CD4, plays an integral part in T cell activation; it is involved in both extracellular Ag recognition and intracellular signaling. We wanted to examine the functional role of CD4 in the recognition of agonist and altered peptide ligands (APLs). We generated two CD4-deficient T cell lines expressing well-characterized TCRs specific for Hb(64-76)/I-Ek. Although the responsiveness of the T cell lines to the agonist peptide was differently affected by the loss of CD4 expression, the recognition of APLs was in both cases dramatically reduced. Nearly full responsiveness to the agonist peptide was achieved by expression of a CD4 variant that did not associate with p56lck; however, the stimulation by APLs was only partially restored. Importantly, the expression of a CD4 variant in which domains interacting with MHC class II molecules have been mutated failed to restore the reactivity to all ligands. CD4-deficient T cells were able to be antagonized by APLs, indicating that CD4 was not required for antagonism. Overall, these findings support the concepts that CD4 is an integral part of the initial formation of the immunological synapse, and that the requirement for different CD4 functions in T cell activation varies depending upon the potency of the ligand.

Differential Requirements for CD4 in TCR-Ligand Interactions

The coreceptor molecule, CD4, plays an integral part in T cell activation; it is involved in both extracellular Ag recognition and intracellular signaling. We wanted to examine the functional role of CD4 in the recognition of agonist and altered peptide ligands (APLs). We generated two CD4-deficient T cell lines expressing well-characterized TCRs specific for Hb(64–76)/I-Ek. Although the responsiveness of the T cell lines to the agonist peptide was differently affected by the loss of CD4 expression, the recognition of APLs was in both cases dramatically reduced. Nearly full responsiveness to the agonist peptide was achieved by expression of a CD4 variant that did not associate with p56lck; however, the stimulation by APLs was only partially restored. Importantly, the expression of a CD4 variant in which domains interacting with MHC class II molecules have been mutated failed to restore the reactivity to all ligands. CD4-deficient T cells were able to be antagonized by APLs, indicating that CD4 was not required for antagonism. Overall, these findings support the concepts that CD4 is an integral part of the initial formation of the immunological synapse, and that the requirement for different CD4 functions in T cell activation varies depending upon the potency of the ligand.

Proline residues in CD28 and the Src homology (SH)3 domain of Lck are required for T cell costimulation

The Src family tyrosine kinases Lck and Fyn are critical for signaling via the T cell receptor. However, the exact mechanism of their activation is unknown. Recent crystal structures of Src kinases suggest that an important mechanism of kinase activation is via engagement of the Src homology (SH)3 domain by proline-containing sequences. To test this hypothesis, we identified several T cell membrane proteins that contain potential SH3 ligands. Here we demonstrate that Lck and Fyn can be activated by proline motifs in the CD28 and CD2 proteins, respectively. Supporting a role for Lck in CD28 signaling, we demonstrate that CD28 signaling in both transformed and primary T cells requires Lck as well as proline residues in CD28. These data suggest that Lck plays an essential role in CD28 costimulation.

The immunological synapse: a molecular machine controlling T cell activation

The specialized junction between a T lymphocyte and an antigen-presenting cell, the immunological synapse, consists of a central cluster of T cell receptors surrounded by a ring of adhesion molecules. Immunological synapse formation is now shown to be an active and dynamic mechanism that allows T cells to distinguish potential antigenic ligands. Initially, T cell receptor ligands were engaged in an outermost ring of the nascent synapse. Transport of these complexes into the central cluster was dependent on T cell receptor-ligand interaction kinetics. Finally, formation of a stable central cluster at the heart of the synapse was a determinative event for T cell proliferation.

A kinetic threshold between negative and positive selection based on the longevity of the T cell receptor-ligand complex

We have developed a unique in vivo system to determine the relationship between endogenous altered peptide ligands and the development of major histocompatibility complex class II- restricted T cells. Our studies use the 3.L2 T cell receptor (TCR) transgenic mouse, in which T cells are specific for Hb(64-76)/I-Ek and positively selected on I-Ek plus self-peptides. To this endogenous peptide repertoire, we have individually added one of six well-characterized 3.L2 ligands. This transgenic approach expands rather than constrains the repertoire of self-peptides. We find that a broad range of ligands produce negative selection of thymocytes in vivo. When compared with the in vitro TCR-ligand binding kinetics, we find that these negatively selecting ligands all have a half-life of 2 s or greater. Additionally, one of two ligands examined with no detectable binding to the 3.L2 TCR and no activity on mature 3.L2 T cells (Q72) enhances the positive selection of transgenic thymocytes in vivo. Together, these data establish a kinetic threshold between negative and positive selection based on the longevity of TCR-ligand complexes.

Cutting Edge: The Tyrosine Phosphatase SHP-1 Regulates Thymocyte Positive Selection

The binding kinetics of the TCR for its interacting ligand and the nature of the resulting signal transduction event determine the fate of a developing thymocyte. The intracellular tyrosine phosphatase SHP-1 is a potential regulator of the TCR signal transduction cascade and may affect thymocyte development. To assess the role of SHP-1 in thymocyte development, we generated T cell-transgenic mice that express a putative dominant negative form of SHP-1, in which a critical cysteine is mutated to serine (SHP-1 C453S). SHP-1 C453S mice that express the 3.L2 TCR transgene are increased in CD4 single positive cells in the thymus and are increased in cells that express the clonotypic TCR. These data suggest that the expression of SHP-1 C453S results in increased positive selection in 3.L2 TCR-transgenic mice and support a role for SHP-1 thymocyte development.

Cutting edge: the tyrosine phosphatase SHP-1 regulates thymocyte positive selection

The binding kinetics of the TCR for its interacting ligand and the nature of the resulting signal transduction event determine the fate of a developing thymocyte. The intracellular tyrosine phosphatase SHP-1 is a potential regulator of the TCR signal transduction cascade and may affect thymocyte development. To assess the role of SHP-1 in thymocyte development, we generated T cell-transgenic mice that express a putative dominant negative form of SHP-1, in which a critical cysteine is mutated to serine (SHP-1 C453S). SHP-1 C453S mice that express the 3.L2 TCR transgene are increased in CD4 single positive cells in the thymus and are increased in cells that express the clonotypic TCR. These data suggest that the expression of SHP-1 C453S results in increased positive selection in 3.L2 TCR-transgenic mice and support a role for SHP-1 thymocyte development.

Characterization of the fibronectin binding motif for a unique mycobacterial fibronectin attachment protein, FAP

Studies were performed to define the fibronectin binding motif of the previously identified Mycobacterium avium fibronectin attachment protein (FAP-A). Using synthetic peptides of a previously identified fibronectin binding region (amino acids 269-292), the minimal binding sequence was determined to be 12 amino acids, 269-280 (FAP-A-(269-280)). Synthetic peptides were prepared in which each amino acid in the 269-280 sequence was substituted with Ala. Assessment of the effect of Ala substitution on fibronectin binding showed that the presence of Ala at amino acids 273-276 (RWFV) completely abrogated fibronectin binding activity. Furthermore, the ability to inhibit the attachment of viable Mycobacterium bovis BCG to fibronectin was abrogated by Ala substitution at the RWFV sites. To validate the function of RWFV, further studies were performed with recombinant FAP-A in which single Ala mutations were generated for the RWFV sites and as controls at amino acids 269 and 280. Mutant FAP-A containing single Ala substitutions at the RWFV sites (amino acids 273, 274, 275, or 276) showed significant abrogation of fibronectin binding function. Recombinant FAP-A with Ala substitutions at either 269 or 280 showed wild type activity. When the four essential amino acids (RWFV) were either substituted en bloc with Ala or were all deleted, complete loss of fibronectin binding function was observed. Control recombinant proteins with en bloc Ala substitutions or deletions at four positions outside the fibronectin binding region (amino acids 255-257) retained functional activity. These data show that the RWFV sequence is necessary for fibronectin binding function of FAP-A. Furthermore, the data suggest that mycobacterial FAP proteins, all of which share the RWFV binding motif, constitute a family of highly homologous proteins that bind fibronectin in a unique manner.

TCR-independent pathways mediate the effects of antigen dose and altered peptide ligands on Th cell polarization

We examined the role of the peptide/MHC ligand in CD4+ T cell differentiation into Th1 or Th2 cells using a TCR alphabeta transgenic mouse specific for hemoglobin (Hb)(64-76)/I-Ek. We identified two altered peptide ligands of Hb(64-76) that retain strong agonist activity but, at a given dose, induce cytokine patterns distinct from the Hb(64-76) peptide. The ability of these peptides to produce distinct cytokine patterns at identical doses is not due to an intrinsic qualitative property. Each peptide can induce Th2 cytokines at low concentrations and Th1 cytokines at high concentrations and has a unique range of concentrations at which these distinct effects occur. The pattern of cytokines produced from limiting dilution of naive T cells demonstrated that the potential to develop an individual Th1 or Th2 cell is stochastic, independent of Ag dose. We propose that the basis for the observed effects on the Th1/Th2 balance shown by the altered peptide ligands and the amount of Ag dose involves the modification of soluble factors in bulk cultures that are the driving force that polarize the population to either a Th1 or Th2 phenotype.

TCR-Independent Pathways Mediate the Effects of Antigen Dose and Altered Peptide Ligands on Th Cell Polarization

We examined the role of the peptide/MHC ligand in CD4+ T cell differentiation into Th1 or Th2 cells using a TCR αβ transgenic mouse specific for hemoglobin (Hb)(64-76)/I-Ek. We identified two altered peptide ligands of Hb(64-76) that retain strong agonist activity but, at a given dose, induce cytokine patterns distinct from the Hb(64-76) peptide. The ability of these peptides to produce distinct cytokine patterns at identical doses is not due to an intrinsic qualitative property. Each peptide can induce Th2 cytokines at low concentrations and Th1 cytokines at high concentrations and has a unique range of concentrations at which these distinct effects occur. The pattern of cytokines produced from limiting dilution of naive T cells demonstrated that the potential to develop an individual Th1 or Th2 cell is stochastic, independent of Ag dose. We propose that the basis for the observed effects on the Th1/Th2 balance shown by the altered peptide ligands and the amount of Ag dose involves the modification of soluble factors in bulk cultures that are the driving force that polarize the population to either a Th1 or Th2 phenotype.

High- and low-potency ligands with similar affinities for the TCR: the importance of kinetics in TCR signaling

We have examined binding characteristics for a single TCR interacting with five of its different peptide/MHC ligands using surface plasmon resonance. We find that very small structural changes produce ligands with similar equilibrium binding affinities (K(D)) for the TCR, but vastly different potencies for T cell activation. Ligands with similar K(D)s induce similar amounts of total phospho-zeta but distinct patterns of zeta phosphorylation. Lower potency ligands induce only incomplete phosphorylation of TCR zeta and generally have faster off-rates. Therefore, the potency of TCR ligands is primarily determined by the half-life of the TCR-ligand complex and the consequent ability to induce complete phosphorylation of zeta.

In vivo antagonism of a T cell response by an endogenously expressed ligand

3.L2 T cell receptor transgenic T cells are activated by the 64-76 peptide of the mouse hemoglobin d beta chain [Hb(64-76)], and their response is antagonized by the position 72 alanine substitution of this peptide (A72). To test the effect of this altered peptide ligand (APL) on 3.L2 T cell function in vivo, a transgene expressing A72 in major histocompatibility complex II positive cells (A72tg) has been introduced into mice. We demonstrate that 3.L2 T cells, when transferred to A72tg+ mice show a dramatically reduced proliferative response to Hb(64-76). Identical decreased responses were observed using T cells that developed in either A72tg+ or A72tg- hosts. This affect was not attributable to diminished precursor frequency, anergy, or competition for binding to I-Ek molecules. These results unequivocally demonstrate in vivo antagonism by an endogenous APL and characterize a class of self-peptides that, although inefficient in causing deletion in the thymus, effectively modulate T cell responses in the periphery.

The study of self-tolerance using murine haemoglobin as a model self antigen

T cell tolerance to self proteins involves both thymic and peripheral mechanisms. We have used allotypic differences in murine haemoglobin (Hb) to study the development of tolerance to the abundantly expressed self-protein. In Hb beta s/H-2k mice, the response to Hb beta d is directed against Hb beta d (64-76) presented by I-Ek molecules. Using T cell hybridomas and clones specific for this epitope, we have demonstrated that Hb(64-76)/I-Ek complexes and present on antigen-presenting cells in all lymphoid organs including dendritic cells, B cells and macrophages. In the thymus, the presence of these complexes results in negative selection of transgenic T cells with high levels of Hb(64-76)/I-Ek-specific receptor. However, cells with intermediate levels of specific receptor escape negative selection and can be found in the periphery. Under normal circumstances these cells remain tolerant, but can be activated by mechanisms which increase the number of Hb(64-76)/I-Ek complexes.

A novel adaptor protein orchestrates receptor patterning and cytoskeletal polarity in T-cell contacts

Recognition of antigen by T cells requires the formation of a specialized junction between the T cell and the antigen-presenting cell. This junction is generated by the recruitment and the exclusion of specific proteins from the contact area. The mechanisms that regulate these events are unknown. Here we demonstrate that ligand engagement of the adhesion molecule, CD2, initiates a process of protein segregation, CD2 clustering, and cytoskeletal polarization. Although protein segregation was not dependent on the cytoplasmic domain of CD2, CD2 clustering and cytoskeletal polarization required an interaction of the CD2 cytoplasmic domain with a novel SH3-containing protein. This novel protein, called CD2AP, is likely to facilitate receptor patterning in the contact area by linking specific adhesion receptors to the cytoskeleton.

14-3-3 proteins are required for maintenance of Raf-1 phosphorylation and kinase activity

By binding to serine-phosphorylated proteins, 14-3-3 proteins function as effectors of serine phosphorylation. The exact mechanism of their action is, however, still largely unknown. Here we demonstrate a requirement for 14-3-3 for Raf-1 kinase activity and phosphorylation. Expression of dominant negative forms of 14-3-3 resulted in the loss of a critical Raf-1 phosphorylation, while overexpression of 14-3-3 resulted in enhanced phosphorylation of this site. 14-3-3 levels, therefore, regulate the stoichiometry of Raf-1 phosphorylation and its potential activity in the cell. Phosphorylation of Raf-1, however, was insufficient by itself for kinase activity. Removal of 14-3-3 from phosphorylated Raf abrogated kinase activity, whereas addition of 14-3-3 restored it. This supports a paradigm in which the effects of phosphorylation on serine as well as tyrosine residues are mediated by inducible protein-protein interactions.

Fidelity of T cell activation through multistep T cell receptor zeta phosphorylation

The T cell receptor (TCR) alphabeta heterodimer interacts with its ligands with high specificity, but surprisingly low affinity. The role of the zeta component of the murine TCR in contributing to the fidelity of antigen recognition was examined. With sequence-specific phosphotyrosine antibodies, it was found that zeta undergoes a series of ordered phosphorylation events upon TCR engagement. Completion of phosphorylation steps is dependent on the nature of the TCR ligand. Thus, the phosphorylation steps establish thresholds for T cell activation. This study documents the sophisticated molecular events that follow the engagement of a low-affinity receptor.

TCR Transgenic Mice in Which Usage of Transgenic α- and β-Chains Is Highly Dependent on the Level of Selecting Ligand

We have produced a TCR transgenic mouse that uses a TCR derived from a Th1 clone that is specific for residues 64 to 76 of the d allele of murine hemoglobin presented by I-Ek. Examination of these TCR transgenic mice on an H-2k/k background that expressed the nonstimulatory s allele of murine hemoglobin revealed that these mice express many endogenous TCR chains from both α and β loci. We found that this transgenic TCR is also very inefficient at mediating β selection, thereby showing a direct linkage between β selection and allelic exclusion of TCR β. We have also examined these mice on MHC backgrounds that have reduced levels of I-Ek and found that positive selection of cells with high levels of the transgenic TCR depends greatly on the ligand density. Decreasing the selecting ligand density is a means of reducing the number of available selecting niches, and the data reveal that the 3.L2 TCR is used sparingly for positive selection under conditions where the number of niches becomes limiting. The results, therefore, show a way that T cells may get to the periphery with two self-restricted TCRs: one that efficiently mediates positive selection, and another that is inefficient at positive selection with the available niches.

TCR transgenic mice in which usage of transgenic alpha- and beta-chains is highly dependent on the level of selecting ligand

We have produced a TCR transgenic mouse that uses a TCR derived from a Th1 clone that is specific for residues 64 to 76 of the d allele of murine hemoglobin presented by I-Ek. Examination of these TCR transgenic mice on an H-2(k/k) background that expressed the nonstimulatory s allele of murine hemoglobin revealed that these mice express many endogenous TCR chains from both alpha and beta loci. We found that this transgenic TCR is also very inefficient at mediating beta selection, thereby showing a direct linkage between beta selection and allelic exclusion of TCR beta. We have also examined these mice on MHC backgrounds that have reduced levels of I-Ek and found that positive selection of cells with high levels of the transgenic TCR depends greatly on the ligand density. Decreasing the selecting ligand density is a means of reducing the number of available selecting niches, and the data reveal that the 3.L2 TCR is used sparingly for positive selection under conditions where the number of niches becomes limiting. The results, therefore, show a way that T cells may get to the periphery with two self-restricted TCRs: one that efficiently mediates positive selection, and another that is inefficient at positive selection with the available niches.

Molecular basis for the lack of T cell proliferation induced by an altered peptide ligand

In this report, we explore the mechanisms underlying cell cycle progression in T cells stimulated with an altered peptide ligand (APL) versus wild-type peptide. APL stimulation did not induce proliferation compared to wild-type peptide stimulation. To determine the point at which cell cycle progression is blocked, we have examined molecules responsible for regulating the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor gene product, pRb, which in its active state prevents G1/S progression. The majority of cells stimulated with an APL did not progress beyond G1; however, a small population did make the G1/S transition. These few cells passed the late G1 restriction point, divided and subsequently arrested at the next G1 phase. The lack of sustained signaling events following stimulation with an APL failed to induce cyclin E:cdk2 activity, a regulator which hyper-phosphorylates and inactivates pRb. Exogenous IL-2 addition did not compensate for the lack of proliferation following APL stimulation. Furthermore, the inability of the cells to enter S phase during partial T cell activation cannot be accounted for by p27Kip1 inhibition of cyclin E:cdk2 complexes. Upon APL stimulation, an increase in association of p27Kip1 with cyclin E:cdk2 complex was not observed, suggesting that instead, decreased cyclin E:cdk complex formation might contribute to the failure to progress from G1/S. Therefore, while for a majority of cells, wild-type stimulation results in cell cycle progression, APL stimulation is not sufficient to drive cells beyond G1.

In vivo expression of a TCR antagonist: T cells escape central tolerance but are antagonized in the periphery

Transgenic 3.L2 T cells are stimulated by Hb(64-76)/I-Ek and are positively selected on I-Ek plus self-peptides. To this pool of self-peptides we have added a single, well-defined 3.L2 TCR antagonist (A72) in vivo. We find that mice expressing both the 3.L2 TCR and A72 have a minimal loss of T cells expressing the clonotypic TCR in the thymus and spleen. Importantly, the proliferative response of 3.L2 x A72 splenocytes is significantly reduced compared with splenocytes from 3.L2 mice. This reduced response can be attributed to peripheral antagonism. Thus we have identified a new class of self-ligands whose predominant effect is constitutive peripheral antagonism rather than negative selection. The net effect of these ligands is to avoid potential self-reactivity while maintaining as large a repertoire as possible.

In Vivo Expression of a TCR Antagonist: T Cells Escape Central Tolerance But Are Antagonized in the Periphery

Transgenic 3.L2 T cells are stimulated by Hb(64–76)/I-Ek and are positively selected on I-Ek plus self-peptides. To this pool of self-peptides we have added a single, well-defined 3.L2 TCR antagonist (A72) in vivo. We find that mice expressing both the 3.L2 TCR and A72 have a minimal loss of T cells expressing the clonotypic TCR in the thymus and spleen. Importantly, the proliferative response of 3.L2 × A72 splenocytes is significantly reduced compared with splenocytes from 3.L2 mice. This reduced response can be attributed to peripheral antagonism. Thus we have identified a new class of self-ligands whose predominant effect is constitutive peripheral antagonism rather than negative selection. The net effect of these ligands is to avoid potential self-reactivity while maintaining as large a repertoire as possible.

A basis for alloreactivity: MHC helical residues broaden peptide recognition by the TCR

The high frequency of alloreactive T cells is a major hindrance for transplantation; however, the molecular basis for alloreactivity remains elusive. We examined the I-Ep alloreactivity of a well-characterized Hb(64-76)/I-Ek-specific murine T cell. Using a combinatorial peptide library approach, we identified a highly stimulatory alloepitope mimic and observed that the recognition of the central TCR contact residues (P3 and P5) was much more flexible than that seen with Hb(64-76)/I-Ek, but still specific. Therefore, alloreactive T cells can recognize a self-peptide/MHC surface; however, the allogeneic MHC molecule changes the recognition requirements for the central region of the peptide, allowing a more diverse repertoire of ligands to be recognized.

Inhibition of an in vitro CD4+ T cell alloresponse using altered peptide ligands

In this study, we explore the potential of altered peptide ligands (APLs) to modulate the alloresponse of CD4+ T cells using elements of the murine hemoglobin (Hb) Ag model. We first demonstrated that the T cell 2.102, specific for the Hb(64-76)/I-Ek complex, was alloreactive against splenocytes of the H-2p haplotype. Using Ab-blocking and transfection experiments, we further showed that this alloreactivity was restricted to the class II molecule I-Ep. We tested a panel of APLs previously shown to antagonize the Hb response of 2.102 and found that these peptides could also effectively inhibit the alloresponse to I-Ep. Importantly, these peptides were able to antagonize the alloresponse of naive T cells derived from mice transgenic for the 2.102 TCR, as well as Th1 and Th2 cell lines. The antagonism required the presence of both I-Ep and I-Ek on the same APC. Our study demonstrates the effectiveness of APLs to antagonize the primary alloresponse of specific T cells and provides a basis for the development of immunotherapeutics for use in transplantation and immune-mediated diseases.

Inhibition of an In Vitro CD4+ T Cell Alloresponse Using Altered Peptide Ligands

In this study, we explore the potential of altered peptide ligands (APLs) to modulate the alloresponse of CD4+ T cells using elements of the murine hemoglobin (Hb) Ag model. We first demonstrated that the T cell 2.102, specific for the Hb(64-76)/I-Ek complex, was alloreactive against splenocytes of the H-2p haplotype. Using Ab-blocking and transfection experiments, we further showed that this alloreactivity was restricted to the class II molecule I-Ep. We tested a panel of APLs previously shown to antagonize the Hb response of 2.102 and found that these peptides could also effectively inhibit the alloresponse to I-Ep. Importantly, these peptides were able to antagonize the alloresponse of naive T cells derived from mice transgenic for the 2.102 TCR, as well as Th1 and Th2 cell lines. The antagonism required the presence of both I-Ep and I-Ek on the same APC. Our study demonstrates the effectiveness of APLs to antagonize the primary alloresponse of specific T cells and provides a basis for the development of immunotherapeutics for use in transplantation and immune-mediated diseases.

Identification of epitopes of fibronectin attachment protein (FAP-A) of Mycobacterium avium which stimulate strong T-cell responses in mice

The T-cell response to fibronectin attachment protein (FAP-A) in BALB/c and B10.BR mice was examined. Both strains developed strong T-cell responses to FAP-A, directed to single, unique epitopes. T cells from mice infected with Mycobacterium avium responded to FAP-A, suggesting a possible role in a protective immune response.

Selective loss of the calcium ion signaling pathway in T cells maturing toward a T helper 2 phenotype

In the CD4+ T cell lineage, two well-defined differentiated populations are the Th1 and Th2 cells, which stem from a common naive T helper precursor (Thp). In this study, we begin to dissect the signaling pathways selectively used by Th1 or Th2 cells as they mature from a common naive precursor in vitro. We show that the maturing Th1 cells mount a vigorous and specific Ca2+ transient upon contact with immunogenic ligand, which is enhanced over that of the naive progenitor cells. As the cells differentiate toward a Th2 phenotype, they quickly lose the ability to engage this pathway, indicating a developmental segregation of intracellular signaling utilization. Moreover, altered peptide ligand stimulation of the Th1 line stimulates a similar Ca2+ transient as native ligand stimulation of the naive precursors, consistent with a quantitative difference in intracellular signaling by these two peptides. These data provide a direct and sequential assessment of a signaling pathway utilization in peripheral T cells as they differentiate to their final functional states.

Selective loss of the calcium ion signaling pathway in T cells maturing toward a T helper 2 phenotype

In the CD4+ T cell lineage, two well-defined differentiated populations are the Th1 and Th2 cells, which stem from a common naive T helper precursor (Thp). In this study, we begin to dissect the signaling pathways selectively used by Th1 or Th2 cells as they mature from a common naive precursor in vitro. We show that the maturing Th1 cells mount a vigorous and specific Ca2+ transient upon contact with immunogenic ligand, which is enhanced over that of the naive progenitor cells. As the cells differentiate toward a Th2 phenotype, they quickly lose the ability to engage this pathway, indicating a developmental segregation of intracellular signaling utilization. Moreover, altered peptide ligand stimulation of the Th1 line stimulates a similar Ca2+ transient as native ligand stimulation of the naive precursors, consistent with a quantitative difference in intracellular signaling by these two peptides. These data provide a direct and sequential assessment of a signaling pathway utilization in peripheral T cells as they differentiate to their final functional states.

Costimulation of T cell activation by integrin-associated protein (CD47) is an adhesion-dependent, CD28-independent signaling pathway

The integrin-associated protein (IAP, CD47) is a 50-kD plasma membrane protein with a single extracellular immunoglobulin variable (IgV)-like domain, a multiply membrane-spanning segment, and alternatively spliced short cytoplasmic tails. On neutrophils, IAP has been shown to function in a signaling complex with beta 3 integrins. However, the function of IAP on T cells, which express little or no beta 3 integrin, is not yet defined. Here, we show that mAbs recognizing IAP can enhance proliferation of primary human T cells in the presence of low levels of anti-CD3, but have no effect on T cell proliferation on their own. Together with suboptimal concentrations of anti-CD3, engagement of IAP also enhances IL-2 production in Jurkat cells, an apparently integrin-independent function of IAP. Nonetheless, costimulation by IAP ligation requires cell adhesion. IAP costimulation does not require CD28. Furthermore, anti-IAP, but not anti-CD28, synergizes with suboptimal anti-CD3 to enhance tyrosine phosphorylation of the CD3 zeta chain and the T cell-specific tyrosine kinase Zap70. Ligation of human IAP transfected into the hemoglobin-specific 3.L2 murine T cell hybridoma costimulates activation for IL-2 secretion both with anti-CD3 and with antigenic peptides on antigen-presenting cells (APCs). Moreover, ligation of IAP but not CD28 can convert antagonist peptides into agonists in 3.L2 cells. Using costimulation by IAP ligation as an assay to analyze the structure-function relationships in IAP signaling, we find that both the extracellular and multiply membrane-spanning domains of IAP are necessary for synergy with the antigen receptor, but the alternatively spliced cytoplasmic tails are not. These data demonstrate that IAP ligation initiates an adhesion-dependent costimulatory pathway distinct from CD28. We hypothesize that anti-IAP generates the costimulatory signal because it modulates interactions of the IgV domain with other plasma membrane molecules; this in turn activates effector functions of the multiply membrane-spanning domain of IAP. This model may have general significance for how IAP functions in cell activation.

Processing and presentation of an antigen of Mycobacterium avium require access to an acidified compartment with active proteases

We have generated a murine T-cell hybridoma, 1C9, which recognizes an antigen expressed by a virulent clinical isolate of Mycobacterium avium. Both peritoneal exudate macrophages and bone marrow-derived macrophages infected in vitro with M. avium process and present the antigen to the T-cell hybridoma. Gel filtration chromatography of a sonicate of M. avium followed by T-cell Western blotting (immunoblotting) demonstrated that the antigen recognized by hybridoma 1C9 is approximately 50 kDa. In addition, treatment of macrophages with the lysosomotropic agent chloroquine or with inhibitors of acid proteases inhibits processing and presentation of the antigen. These results indicate that the antigen must encounter an acidic compartment with active proteases for processing and presentation to occur. Our results are discussed in the context of our current understanding of how mycobacterial antigens are processed and presented by infected macrophages to T cells.

Selective activation of the calcium signaling pathway by altered peptide ligands

We previously demonstrated that altered peptide ligands (APL) can partially activate T cells, resulting in multiple distinct functional phenotypes, including the induction of anergy. Such APL stimulate a unique pattern of T cell receptor (TCR) phospho-zeta species, and lack associated ZAP-70 kinase activity. While these data suggested that selective signaling pathways downstream of the TCR/CD3 molecules are activated upon APL stimulation, they did not directly demonstrate this. Thus, we pursued intracellular signaling events successfully stimulated by APL. Because our previous studies showed that cyclosporin A (CsA) completely inhibited anergy induction, we assessed whether TCR ligation by APL cause a rise in cytosolic calcium (Ca+2). Our results show that these ligands can induce Ca+2 transients, in contrast to data generated using analogue peptides in other antigen systems. These opposing results may reflect differences in the intracellular signaling pathways utilized by different APL, or may be due to the exquisite sensitivity of the assay used here. Importantly, the APL-stimulated Ca+2 induction is both initiated and sustained at lower levels than that stimulated by a strong agonist signal, but resembles that stimulated by a weaker agonist stimulus. Alone, the less than optimal Ca+2 induction does not cause anergy, because ionomycin treatment together with the APL does not result in a proliferative signal. Instead, we propose that a combination of this and other signaling pathways induces T cell anergy. Overall, these data support the concept of differential signaling in T cells, as a direct consequence of the phosphotyrosine status of the TCR/CD3 molecules.

Structural basis for T cell recognition of altered peptide ligands: a single T cell receptor can productively recognize a large continuum of related ligands

T cells recognize short linear peptides bound to major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-encoded molecules. Subtle molecular changes in peptide antigens produce altered peptide ligands (APLs), which induce different T cell responses from those induced by the antigenic ligand. A molecular basis for how these slight molecular variations lead to such different consequences for the T cell has not been described. To address this issue, we have made amino acid substitutions at the primary T cell receptor (TCR) contact residue of the murine hemoglobin determinant, Hb(64-76)/I-Ek and produced 12 peptides that interact with the TCR of the T cell clone 3.L2. The 3.L2 T cell responds to these peptides, which vary 1 million-fold in their activity, and enables them to be ranked according to their relative ability to signal through the 3.L2 TCR. Such a ranking reveals that the ability of the 3.L2 T cell to respond to these peptides depends on how well the structure of the side chain at the primary TCR contact site mimics that of the Asn residue present in the antigenic ligand. The reactivity of the 3.L2 T cell also depends on an MHC contact residue that is next to the primary TCR contact residue, suggesting that conformation of the Asn side chain is also important. By using nonnatural amino acids at a TCR contact residue, we have demonstrated that APLs can be rationally designed based on structure. These data are consistent with a model in which the affinity of a peptide-MHC complex for the TCR determines how the T cell will respond.

TCR recognition of the Hb(64-76)/I-Ek determinant: single conservative amino acid changes in the complementarity-determining region 3 dramatically alter antigen fine specificity

To identify the structural basis of Ag fine specificity, TCR sequences from a panel of Hb(64-76)/I-Ek-specific T cells were compared and found to be restricted in variable (V) gene usage, predominantly using BV1 or BV15 and AV4 or AV10 genes. TCRA and TCRB junctional sequences were extremely diverse. No conservation of length or position was found, which distinguishes this response from others, but correlates with the range of fine specificities that these T cells display. A remarkable subtlety in the recognition of Hb(64-76) was revealed from the study of the response to the D73 variant of Hb(64-76), which contains a conservative change in an MHC anchor residue not affecting the binding affinity to I-Ek. To one group of T cells this determinant was non-cross-reacting with Hb(64-76), whereas another recognized both Ags. Interesting, they all used a different constellation of TCRBV genes than that found in Hb(64-76) recognition. To limit the variability in the anti-Hb(64-76) TCR repertoire, transgenic mice expressing a fixed TCRB rearrangement from a Hb(64-76)-specific T cell were used. In Hb(64-76)-specific TCR from these mice, the endogenous alpha-chains pairing with the transgenic beta-chain were highly restricted in their AV gene usage. A comparison of two pairs of closely related T cells of these endogenous TCR variants, one differing by a single, conservative substitution in the complementarity-determining region 3 and the other containing a positional switch of two amino acids, revealed dramatically different fine specificities. Overall, these findings highlight the exquisite sensitivity of the TCR- peptide/MHC interaction to subtle alterations in any of the components.

TCR recognition of the Hb(64-76)/I-Ek determinant: single conservative amino acid changes in the complementarity-determining region 3 dramatically alter antigen fine specificity

To identify the structural basis of Ag fine specificity, TCR sequences from a panel of Hb(64-76)/I-Ek-specific T cells were compared and found to be restricted in variable (V) gene usage, predominantly using BV1 or BV15 and AV4 or AV10 genes. TCRA and TCRB junctional sequences were extremely diverse. No conservation of length or position was found, which distinguishes this response from others, but correlates with the range of fine specificities that these T cells display. A remarkable subtlety in the recognition of Hb(64-76) was revealed from the study of the response to the D73 variant of Hb(64-76), which contains a conservative change in an MHC anchor residue not affecting the binding affinity to I-Ek. To one group of T cells this determinant was non-cross-reacting with Hb(64-76), whereas another recognized both Ags. Interesting, they all used a different constellation of TCRBV genes than that found in Hb(64-76) recognition. To limit the variability in the anti-Hb(64-76) TCR repertoire, transgenic mice expressing a fixed TCRB rearrangement from a Hb(64-76)-specific T cell were used. In Hb(64-76)-specific TCR from these mice, the endogenous alpha-chains pairing with the transgenic beta-chain were highly restricted in their AV gene usage. A comparison of two pairs of closely related T cells of these endogenous TCR variants, one differing by a single, conservative substitution in the complementarity-determining region 3 and the other containing a positional switch of two amino acids, revealed dramatically different fine specificities. Overall, these findings highlight the exquisite sensitivity of the TCR- peptide/MHC interaction to subtle alterations in any of the components.

Altered T cell receptor ligands trigger a subset of early T cell signals

TCR ligands are complexes of peptides and MHC proteins on the surfaces of APCs. Some of these ligands cause T cell proliferation (agonists), while others block it (antagonists). We compared the acid release, calcium flux, and proliferation response of helper T cells to a variety of ligands. We found that all agonist ligands but not most antagonist ligands trigger acid release, a general indicator of early cellular activation. Only a subset of ligands triggering acid release cause sustained calcium flux, and only a subset of these ligands cause T cell proliferation. Antagonist ligands and anti-CD4 antibodies both effectively block T cell proliferation. However, significantly greater antagonist ligand or antibody concentrations are required to block acid release and initial calcium influx. These data demonstrate a hierarchy of early T cell signaling steps and show that altered TCR ligands can initiate some steps while blocking the completion of others.