Comparison of colonic stenting and open surgery for malignant large bowel obstruction

BACKGROUND

Colonic stents potentially offer effective palliation for those with bowel obstruction attributable to incurable malignancy, and a "bridge to surgery" for those in whom emergency surgery would necessitate a stoma. The current study compared the outcomes of stents and open surgery in the management of malignant large bowel obstruction.

METHODS

A literature search of the Medline, Ovid, Embase and Cochrane databases was performed to identify comparative studies reporting outcomes on colonic stenting and surgery for large bowel obstruction. Random effects meta-analytical techniques were applied to identify differences in outcomes between the two groups. Sensitivity analysis of high quality studies, those reporting on more than 35 patients, those solely concerning colorectal cancer and studies performing intention to treat analysis was undertaken to evaluate the study heterogeneity.

RESULTS

A total of 10 studies satisfied the criteria for inclusion, with outcomes reported for 451 patients. Stent insertion was attempted for 244 patients (54.1%), and proved successful for 226 (92.6%). The length of hospital stay was shorter by 7.72 days in the stent group (p < 0.001), which also had lower mortality (p = 0.03) and fewer medical complications (p < 0.001). Stoma formation at any point during management was significantly lower than in the stent group (odds ratio, 0.02; p < 0.001), and "bridging to surgery" did not adversely influence survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Colonic stenting offers effective palliation for malignant bowel obstruction, with short lengths of hospital stay and a low rate for stoma formation, but data on quality of life and economic evaluation are limited. There is no evidence of differences in long-term survival between those who have stents followed by subsequent resection and those undergoing emergency bowel resection.

[Congenital anatomic gastrointestinal obstruction: prenatal diagnosis, morbidity and mortality]

OBJECTIVES

To describe the morbidity and mortality associated with congenital gastrointestinal obstruction, assess the usefulness of prenatal diagnosis, and analyze the results in relation to the site of obstruction.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We performed a retrospective case series study of 148 patients in a 13-year period (1990-2003). Sites of obstruction was classified into three groups: I) gastric, duodenal or jejunal; II) ileal or colonic; III) anorectal.

RESULTS

There were 65 patients in group I, 38 in group II and 45 in group III. Surgery was performed in 137 patients. Trisomy was diagnosed in 15 patients, polymalformation syndrome in 16 patients, and cystic fibrosis in seven patients. More than one site of intestinal obstruction was found in 22 patients (15 %). Morbidity consisted of nosocomial sepsis in 32 %, necrotizing enterocolitis in 7 %, and short gut in 3.4 %. Prematurity (48 %) was associated with higher morbidity and mortality. Overall mortality was 14.2 %, mainly associated with other malformations and extraintestinal problems. When patients with other extraintestinal malformations were excluded, the highest mortality was found in group II (OR: 12.19; CI: 2.4-76.2). The overall sensitivity of prenatal diagnosis was 0.44 and the mean gestational age at diagnosis was 31.6 weeks (SD 5.2). According to the site of obstruction, sensitivity was 0.77 in group I, 0.39 in group II and 0.04 in group III. Prenatal diagnosis did not alter prognosis.

CONCLUSIONS

Morbidity and mortality were strongly influenced by extraintestinal problems. The most severe intestinal complications were midgut volvulus and necrotizing enterocolitis. Prenatal diagnosis was late and showed good sensitivity only in group I.

Obstruction of the small intestine by a trichobezoar in cattle: 15 cases (1992-2002)

OBJECTIVE

To determine historical and clinical findings, treatment, and outcome for cattle with small intestinal obstruction caused by a trichobezoar.

DESIGN

Retrospective case series.

ANIMALS

15 cattle.

PROCEDURES

Medical records of cattle with a diagnosis of small intestinal obstruction by a trichobezoar from 1992 to 2002 were reviewed. Information pertaining to various aspects of diagnosis, treatment, and outcome was collected from records.

RESULTS

Trichobezoars were more common in young cattle, and affected cattle did not deteriorate clinically as rapidly as cattle with other types of intestinal obstruction. The most common initial owner complaints included decreased or absent fecal output, inappetance, abdominal distension, and signs of abdominal pain. Common clinical findings were dehydration, decreased or absent rumen motility, signs of depression, splashing sounds during succussion of the abdomen, and a pinging sound on percussion of the abdomen. The jejunum was obstructed in 10 cattle. Hypochloremic metabolic alkalosis and chronic inflammation were common laboratory findings. All 4 cattle that underwent abdominocentesis had peritonitis. The obstructing trichobezoar was removed surgically in 9 cattle, of which 7 survived and 2 died. The 6 cattle treated medically died or were euthanized.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Obstruction of the small intestine by a trichobezoar is uncommon, but it should be considered as a differential diagnosis in cattle with signs of intestinal obstruction, particularly if they are younger than 4 years of age and have a history of nonacute signs of intestinal obstruction. Surgical removal appears to be a favorable method of treatment and should be considered when this condition is suspected.

Obstruction in patients with colorectal cancer increases morbidity and mortality in association with altered nutritional status

Intestinal obstruction aggravates the prognosis of colorectal cancer (CRC) patients. The aim of this study was to carry out a comparative analysis of nutritional status and inflammatory response in CRC patients with or without intestinal obstruction. The study was carried out on 43 patients with CRC. Twenty-three of these patients had intestinal obstruction. Anthropometric measurements, serum protein content, acute phase reactants, and diagnostic and risk nutritional indices were analyzed. The presence of intestinal obstruction reduced albumin (31 +/- 5.2 vs. 36 +/- 4.2 g/l; P = 0.0025) and prealbumin (0.13 +/- 0.047 vs. 0.21 +/- 0.042 g/l; P = 0.0001) and increased C-reactive protein (49 +/- 43.8 vs. 14 +/- 16.7 mg/l; P = 0.006) and alpha1-antitrypsin (189 +/- 34.7 vs. 148 +/- 35.4 mg/dl; P = 0.0011). Intestinal obstruction was related to malnutrition (86% vs. 33%; P = 0.019) and Mullen's prognostic nutritional index (48 +/- 21.7 vs. 31 +/- 17.9; P = 0.038) in CRC patients. Mullen's nutritional risk index was inversely correlated to total cholesterol (r = -0.51; P = 0.0002) and albumin (r = -0.81; P = 0.0001). No correlation was found between Duke's tumor stages and acute phase response, inflammatory parameters, and malnutrition. In conclusion, intestinal obstruction occurred more frequently in CRC patients with malnutrition. The increased morbidity and mortality of CRC patients was also associated with acute phase response, inflammation, and low serum cholesterol and triglyceride concentration.

Fatal sand impaction of the spiral colon in a 1-month-old alpaca

A 1-month-old cria (Lama pacos) was presented because of depression, anorexia, and diarrhea for 3 days. Although treated for enteritis (intravenous fluids and antibiotics), the cria's condition deteriorated. An abdominal radiograph revealed radiodense materials in the 3rd compartment and intestines. The cria died due to sand impaction of the spiral colon.

[Small bowel obstruction caused by postoperative adhesions: personal experience and review of the literature]

Small bowel obstruction due to postoperative adhesions still remains an important matter in terms of frequency, diagnostic and therapeutic commitment and costs. The Authors report on a series observed over 14 years consisting of 63 patients (71 cumulative hospital admissions). Surgery was required in 42 cases (59.2%), 23 cases were treated in emergency and 19 cases after failure of conservative treatment. In 29 cases (69%) the surgical procedure was limited to adhesiolysis, whereas in 13 cases (31%) an intestinal resection was performed. During operation the mechanisms responsible for obstruction were: strangulation by an adhesive band (39.4%), angulation (34%), bowel loops and volvulus glued together (13.2% in each case). The operative mortality was 4.7% (2 cases). In 29 cases (40.8%), after medical treatment, the obstruction was completely resolved within a mean period of 4.15 days (range: 2-8). The results lead to the conclusion that diagnostic accuracy in cases of obstruction due to postoperative adhesions is still uncertain. The main aspects of treatment and surgical timing are left to the surgeon's personal experience. Medical treatment, however, should be the first therapeutic option and, in case of doubt, further diagnostic investigations are necessary (mainly CT) to identify those cases amenable to surgical treatment.

An analysis of surgical versus chemotherapeutic intervention for the management of intestinal obstruction in advanced ovarian cancer

The objective of this study was to compare the treatment outcomes of surgical versus chemotherapeutic interventions for the management of intestinal obstruction secondary to metastatic epithelial ovarian cancer. A retrospective analysis of 39 patients with epithelial ovarian cancer who had 98 events of intestinal obstruction was performed. A medical records review of patients treated for advanced ovarian cancer from 1973 to 2003 was conducted. Time from treatment to obstruction, complications, and predictors of outcome were analyzed. Mean time from diagnosis of cancer to first obstruction was 38 months (range, 7-234 months). Of 39 patients with obstruction, 5% were stage I, 2% stage II, 85% stage III, and 8% stage IV. Prior to first obstruction, the median number of prior surgeries was 2 and chemotherapy regimens 3. Sites of the 98 events of obstruction were small intestine, 79 (81%); large intestine, 8 (8%); and combined small and large intestines, 11 (11%). The mean time to re-obstruction was 6.4 months (0-24) for chemotherapy, 5.1 months (0-40) for surgery, and 1.9 months (0-15) for supportive care. The mean hospital stays were 7 days (2-10) for chemotherapy, 18 days (3-50) for surgery, and 7 days (0-20) for supportive care. There were 4 major complications in the chemotherapy patients, 11 in the surgical patients, and 2 in the supportive only patients. The only significant factor predictive of > or =6 month obstruction-free period was prior response to platinum-based chemotherapy. Of the 13 patients with a response to chemotherapeutic or surgical treatment, 46% had an initial response to platinum-based chemotherapy, while 27% of 22 patients who re-obstructed in <6 months were platinum sensitive. In this retrospective analysis of selected patients, surgery and chemotherapy were found to have similar outcomes. The surgical approach had higher morbidity. The best predictor of either treatment's effectiveness is tumor sensitivity to platinum-based chemotherapeutic agents (P= 0.168).

[Considerations about neoplastic intestinal occlusion]

Neoplastic intestinal occlusion represent a Frequently Surgical emergency. The present study deals with 96 cases of neoplastic intestinal occlusion from a group of 480 patients admitted and operated with diagnosis of intestinal occlusions in our clinic between 1998-2002. The patients had clinical evidence of intestinal occlusions confirmed by imaging and endoscopical examination. Median age was 50 years, females (59,40%), urban (53,12%), rectosigmoid localization (60%) advised evaluative stages was predominance. Emergency operations were performed in all cases after a short period of equilibration, 54 operations with radical intention, in 29 cases we have used a orthograde colic lavage witch help us to make a good anastomosis, 20 Hartman type, 10 colostomy, 15 exploration laparatomy. Postoperative major complications was observed in 54,48% and postoperative mortality rate was of 6,22 %.

The impact of blood loss, obstruction and perforation on survival in patients undergoing curative resection for colon cancer

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have drawn attention to the high postoperative mortality and poor survival of patients who present as an emergency with colon cancer. However, these patients are a heterogeneous group. The aim of the present study was to establish, having adjusted for case mix, the size of the differences in postoperative mortality and 5-year survival between patients presenting as an emergency with evidence of blood loss, obstruction and perforation.

METHODS

The study included 2068 patients who presented with colon cancer between 1991 and 1994 in Scotland. Five-year survival rates and the adjusted hazard ratios were calculated.

RESULTS

Thirty-day postoperative mortality following potentially curative resection was consistently higher in patients who presented with evidence of blood loss, obstruction or perforation (all P < 0.005) than in elective patients. Following potentially curative surgery, cancer-specific survival at 5 years was 74.6 per cent compared with 60.9, 51.6 and 46.5 per cent in those who presented with blood loss, obstruction and perforation respectively (all P < 0.001). The corresponding adjusted hazard ratios (95 per cent confidence interval) for cancer-specific survival, relative to elective patients, were 1.62 (1.22 to 2.15), 2.22 (1.78 to 2.75) and 2.93 (1.82 to 4.70) for patients presenting with evidence of blood loss, obstruction or perforation (all P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Compared with patients who undergo elective surgery for colon cancer, those who present as an emergency with evidence of blood loss, obstruction or perforation have higher postoperative mortality rates and poorer cancer-specific survival.

Role of home parenteral nutrition in chronic radiation enteritis

OBJECTIVES

The management of chronic radiation enteritis (CRE) is difficult and often controversial. The aim of the study was to compare long-term outcome of patients with radiation-induced intestinal obstruction treated either surgically or with intestinal rest and home parenteral nutrition (HPN).

METHODS

Thirty patients, with mechanical bowel obstruction due to CRE, were retrospectively included in the study and divided in two groups according to the first treatment approach. Seventeen patients underwent surgery (S group) and 13 patients were supported with HPN (HPN group). Survival, nutrition autonomy, number of surgeries, related complications and persistence of symptoms were evaluated in the two groups. Associations between factors and treatment group were assessed by means of the Wilcoxon rank sum test for continuous variables and the Fisher exact test for categorical variables. Overall survival was calculated using the Kaplan-Meier method.

RESULTS

The two groups were similar in terms of age, dose of radiation therapy, time of occurrence and degree of signs and symptoms. 7/13 patients in the HPN group resolved the obstruction without surgery. 10/17 patients of the S group developed intestinal failure which required HPN. Nutrition autonomy was achieved in 100% and 58.8% of HPN and S group respectively (p = 0.01). The overall five-year survival was 90.0% and 68.4% respectively in the HPN and S group (p = 0.0231).

CONCLUSIONS

Both HPN and surgery are often necessary in patients with chronic radiation-induced intestinal obstruction. However, the long term nutrition autonomy and survival seem to be better in patients initially treated with intestinal rest and HPN.

[Diagnosis and treatment of acute intestinal obstruction due to gall-stone]

Results of treatment of 43 patients with acute intestinal obstruction due to gall-stones are analyzed. Forty patients were operated, 3 patients were not because of extremely severe state. Enterolythotomy was performed in 27 cases, incision of intestinal wall was carried out directly above the stones (14 cases, group 1), above or below it (13 cases, group 2). Insufficiency of enteral suture was seen in 4 patients of group 1 that required repeated surgery. Lethality in group 1 was 21.4%, in group 2-7.1%. Intestinal resection was performed in 12 patients of group 3, there were no cases of suture insufficiency, and lethality was 8.3%. It is concluded that enterotomy should be performed above or below strangulated stone. Intestinal resection should be performed when concrement is immovable or in cases of intestinal necrosis.

Nonsurgical treatment of the primary tumor in four consecutive cases of metastasized colorectal carcinoma

BACKGROUND AND STUDY AIMS

Surgical resection of the primary tumor is standard treatment in stage IV colorectal cancer, but palliative surgery is associated with high morbidity and mortality and with uncertain benefit. The wisdom of surgical resection of asymptomatic or oligosymptomatic primary tumors is therefore questionable. By studying a small series of such patients, we aimed to assess whether endoscopic techniques can offer an effective alternative form of nonsurgical palliative treatment for the prevention of local complications caused by a primary colorectal tumor.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We treated four consecutive patients who had stage IV colorectal cancer by endoscopic tumor debulking, either using a standard polypectomy snare technique alone or by argon plasma coagulation ablation followed by snare debulking of the primary tumor.

RESULTS

Palliation was achieved in all patients, demonstrated by regression of the primary tumor and absence of symptoms related to the colonic tumor during the observation period of up to 24 months. No procedure-associated complications were observed and it was possible to commence systemic chemotherapy immediately after the endoscopic treatment in all four patients.

CONCLUSIONS

We believe that surgical resection of the primary tumor is not appropriate in all patients with stage IV colorectal cancer, and that this form of treatment should be reserved for patients with signs of complete obstruction in whom local ablative procedures are not possible. Simple endoscopic techniques for treatment of the primary tumor, in conjunction with systemic chemotherapy, may be the most suitable form of management for patients with stage IV colorectal tumors.

Complicated diverticulitis: is it time to rethink the rules?

INTRODUCTION

Much of our knowledge and treatment of complicated diverticulitis (CD) are based on outdated literature reporting mortality rates of 10%. Practice parameters recommend elective resection after 2 episodes of diverticulitis to reduce morbidity and mortality. The aim of this study is to update our understanding of the morbidity, mortality, characteristics, and outcomes of CD.

METHODS

Three hundred thirty-seven patients hospitalized for CD were retrospectively analyzed. Characteristics and outcomes were determined using chi-squared and Fisher exact tests.

RESULTS

Mean age of patients was 65 years. Seventy percent had one or more comorbidities. A total of 46.6% had a history of at least one prior diverticulitis episode, whereas 53.4% presented with CD as their first episode. Overall mortality rate was 6.5% (86.4% associated with perforation, 9.5% anastomotic leak, 4.5% patient managed nonoperatively). A total of 89.5% of the perforation patients who died had no history of diverticulitis. Steroid use was significantly associated with perforation rates as well as mortality (P< 0.001 and P = 0.002). Comorbidities such as diabetes, collagen-vascular disease, and immune system compromise were also highly associated with death (P = 0.006, P = 0.009, and P = 0.003, respectively). Overall morbidity was 41.4%. Older age, gender, steroids, comorbidities, and perforation were significantly associated with morbidity.

CONCLUSION

Today, mortality from CD excluding perforation is reduced compared with past data. This, coupled with the fact that the majority of these patients presented with CD as their first episode, calls into question the current practice of elective resection as a stratagem for reducing mortality. Immunocompromised patients may benefit from early resection. New prospective data is needed to redefine target groups for prophylactic resection.

Presentation, treatment, and multivariate analysis of risk factors for obstructive and perforative colorectal carcinoma

BACKGROUND

It is known that emergency surgery for colorectal cancer is associated with high morbidity and mortality. The aim of this study was to assess the presentation, treatment, and outcome of patients with complicated colorectal cancer. Risk factors for morbidity and mortality were also evaluated.

METHODS

From 1991 to 2002, the medical records of 107 consecutive patients undergoing emergency surgery for obstructing or perforating colorectal carcinoma were retrospectively reviewed. Information regarding patient and tumor characteristics, treatment, and outcome was recorded. Risk factors were assessed by multivariate analysis.

RESULTS

Eighty-three patients (78%) had complete obstruction and 24 (22%) had perforation. Overall and major complications occurred in 70% and 34%, respectively. The mortality rate was 15%. Independent risk factors for major morbidity were perioperative blood transfusion and high American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) class, whereas those for mortality were older age and high Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation II (APACHE II) score.

CONCLUSIONS

Emergency surgery for complicated colorectal carcinoma carries high rates of morbidity and mortality. To achieve improvements in outcome, intensive treatment after surgery in patients with risk factors is recommended.

Atresia of the colon

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Colonic atresia (CA) is one of the rarest causes of neonatal intestinal obstructions, and no large series can be reported. Therefore, we did perform a retrospective clinical trial to delineate our CA cases and carry out a literature survey.

METHODS

We reviewed the charts of CA cases treated in our center between 1992 and 2002. We aimed to collect all reported cases in Medline, and personal communications with the authors of published series were used to reach the missing data.

RESULTS

The chart review revealed 9 newborns with CA treated in our center (6 cases of type III, 2 cases of type II, and 1 case of type IV). These accounted for 3.7% of all gastrointestinal atresias managed in our center. Of the CA cases, 3 were isolated and 6 had at least one or more associated congenital anomalies. The preferred surgical technique at the initial treatment of CA was performing a proximal stoma and distal mucous fistula in an average of postnatal 59.4 hours. The literature survey enabled us to reach 224 cases of CA, including our cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Because of the low incidence of CA, delay in diagnosis and treatment may occur. The mortality is statistically higher when the surgical management is performed after 72 hours of age. However, the prognosis of CA is satisfactory if diagnosis and surgical management could be made promptly and properly.

Comparison of surgical versus medical treatment of nephrosplenic entrapment of the large colon in horses: 19 cases (1992-2002)

OBJECTIVE

To compare the outcome of horses with nephrosplenic entrapment of the large colon (NSELC) treated surgically or medically by rolling, administration of phenylephrine hydrochloride (or both), and exercise.

DESIGN

Retrospective study.

ANIMALS

11 medically treated horses and 8 surgically treated horses with NSELC.

PROCEDURE

Medical records of horses with nephrosplenic entrapment between 1992 and 2002 were reviewed. Medically treated horses were included if diagnosis and outcome of treatment of nephrosplenic entrapment were confirmed via transrectal examination and ultrasonographic examination. Surgically treated horses were included if the diagnosis was confirmed by exploratory laparotomy. Horses in which the large colon was entrapped between the spleen and body wall were not included.

RESULTS

Significant differences in mean age, heart rate, and duration of colic prior to treatment were not detected between horses treated surgically or medically. Ten medically treated horses recovered without complications, and 1 died. In the surgically treated group, 6 of 8 horses recovered without complications and 2 died. Mortality rate did not differ between treatments. Duration of hospitalization for medically treated horses was significantly shorter and the cost significantly less than for surgically treated horses.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Results indicated that medical treatment of horses with NSELC via administration of phenylephrine hydro-chloride, rolling during general anesthesia, or both appears to be as effective as and less expensive than surgical treatment.

Chilaiditi's syndrome: what should every surgeon know?

Demetrius Chilaiditi first described an incidental radiological finding of hepatodiaphragmatic interposition of bowel in 1910. The condition could be mistaken for pneumoperitoneum. This radiographic entity, known as Chilaiditi's sign, is found in asymptomatic patients and must be distinguished from Chilaiditi's syndrome, which produces symptomatology associated with the bowel interposition. A review of the literature yielded 27 published cases of Chilaiditi's syndrome. These cases were compiled to evaluate various aspects of this rare but important entity.

Prise en charge du cancer colique en occlusion

INTRODUCTION

Management of obstructed colonic carcinomas is a surgical challenge because it happens more often in elderly patients. The aim of our study is to assess mortality and morbidity rates of procedures performed in emergency for this pathology.

PATIENTS AND METHOD

Between January 1st, 1998 and December 31st 2003, 22 patients underwent an emergency procedure for obstructive colonic obstruction due to an adenocarcinoma. Obstruction was defined as an emesis, distension on examination, no gas or stool since 24 hours and confirmatory plain radiograph film.

RESULTS

Twenty patients (91%) underwent surgical procedure and two others received a colonic stent. Eleven patients (50%) underwent left colonic resection and intraoperative colonic cleansing was undertaken in 3 of these patients. One patient underwent a lateral colostomy, three patients (14%) underwent a right colectomy. A Hartmann's procedure was performed in six cases (27%). Morbidity occurred in 23% (50% were from anastomotic complication). Mortality rate was 27% (44% if aged more than 75 years old) (one superior mesenteric ischemia, and five heart and respiratory failures). Two-year survival rate was 61% and five year survival rate was 47%. Median survival was 24 months.

CONCLUSION

Our study confirms that obstructed colonic cancer has a bad prognosis because it happens in elderly and not healthy patients. Priority must be given to the restoration of colonic permeability.

Comparison of one-stage resection and anastomosis of acute complete obstruction of left and right colon

BACKGROUND

Although acute obstruction of the right colon is usually handled by primary anastomosis following resection, many surgeons are reluctant to offer one-stage resection and anastomosis to patients with obstructive lesions of the left colon. The aim of the study is to compare the immediate result of one-stage resection and anastomosis for patients with acute complete obstruction of the right colon versus left colon.

METHODS

From January 1986 to December 2003, 214 cases of acute colonic obstruction were managed with one-stage resection and anastomosis by a single surgeon. Eighty patients were operated on for obstructive lesions of the right colon, 71 of them for carcinoma of the colon. Operative mortality was 10% (8/80); all except 2 patients died of respiratory failure. There were 2 cases (2.5%) of anastomotic leakage. One hundred thirty-four patients were operated on for obstructive lesions of the left colon, 127 of them for carcinomas of the colon and rectum. Operative mortality was 1.5% (2/134); both patients died of metastasis from the colorectal cancer following surgery. There were 3 cases (2.3%) of anastomotic leakage.

CONCLUSION

This experience suggests that an anastomosis can be performed as safely in patients with acute obstruction of the left colon as in those with acute obstruction of the right colon. Mortality following resection and anastomosis is actually lower in left than right colonic obstruction. Neither intraoperative irrigation nor routine subtotal colectomy was found to be necessary in patients with acute colonic obstruction. Intraoperative decompression should be considered in left and also right colonic obstruction prior to the anastomosis following colonic resection.

Bowel function following insertion of self-expanding metallic stents for palliation of colorectal cancer

OBJECTIVE

Self-expanding metallic stents (SEMS) are an important addition to the treatment of large bowel obstruction. The aim of this study was firstly to assess bowel function following SEMS placement and secondly to identify any potential factors which might aid in the prediction of technical failure of stent insertion.

METHODS

A review of all patients undergoing attempted SEMS placement for palliation of malignant left-sided colorectal obstruction over a four-year period (1st May 2000-30th April 2004) was performed.

RESULTS

Twenty-one patients (12 male) with a median age of 76 years (range 48-92 years) were included, 11 with metastatic disease and 10 severe comorbidity. SEMS insertion was technically successful in 16 (76%) of 21 cases. Contrast successfully passed through the obstructing lesion in all 16 cases where SEMS placement was technically successful. It only passed through 1 of 5 cases where stenting was not possible (P = 0.0008, Fisher's Exact test). Complications included colonic perforation (1 case), stent migration (1 case) and tumour ingrowth requiring a second stent (1 case). Median survival after SEMS was 12 months (range 1-30 months), and 9 patients died during follow-up. Median bowel frequency following SEMS was 3.5 times per day (range 1-7). Eight patients always passed a liquid stool, 3 others regularly required laxatives and one further patient with poor function after stenting requested a defunctioning stoma.

CONCLUSION

Failure of contrast to pass through the obstructing lesion may predict those cases where stenting will not be technically possible. Median survival following SEMS insertion is encouraging in this series, but bowel function is often poor. Expected bowel function should be discussed fully when consenting patients for a SEMS, particularly those with metastatic disease who are otherwise fit for resectional surgery.

Unreasonable expectations in emergency colorectal cancer surgery

OBJECTIVES

The recently published ACPGBI colorectal cancer (ACPGBI CRC) scoring system for predicting operative mortality has been suggested as an instrument to improve patient consent procedures and to compare results between centres. This study compares the results of a surgical unit against the standards set by the ACPGBI colorectal cancer model and for emergency surgery, against the p-POSSUM instrument.

METHODS

Data for the ACPGBI CRC model were collected prospectively through 2003 at the Leicester Royal Infirmary. Additional data needed for the p-POSSUM was retrospectively collected from case records. The actual mortality was compared with that predicted by the models.

RESULTS

Seventy-two colorectal cancer operations were performed during the study period. The observed operative mortality in elective cases was lower, and in emergency cases higher, than predicted by the ACPGBI CRC model. With emergency cases the predicted mortality using P-POSSUM was significantly higher than that using the ACPGBI CRC model, particularly in the presence of faecal contamination.

CONCLUSION

The ACPGBI CRC model may be accurate for elective cases, but appears to significantly underestimate predicted mortality in the emergency setting, both actual and predicted by p-POSSUM. This may be due to a failure to incorporate adequate weighting for faecal peritonitis and the associated systemic insult into the ACPGBI model.

Childhood intestinal obstruction in Northwestern Nigeria

BACKGROUND

Intestinal obstruction is a common cause of childhood surgical emergency in the tropics. The aim of this paper was to assess the pattern and the outcome of mangement of intestinal obstruction in Nigerian children.

STUDY DESIGN

The clinical reccords of all the cases of childhood intestinal obstructions managed at a teaching hospital in northwestern Nigeria between 1999 and 2003 were retrospectively reviewed.

RESULTS

There were 54 children, 44(81.5 %) were boys and 10 (8.5 %) were girls (m:f=4.4:1). Fifteen (27.8%) and 22 (46.2%) were neonates and infants, respectively. The causes of the intestinal obstruction were intussusception 16(29.6 %), Hirschprung's disease 14(25.9%), anorectal anomaly 12 (22.2%), external hernias 6(11.1%), atresia 5(9.3%) and congenital bands 1(1.9 %). The clinical features were consistent with those reported from other parts of the world, except that many patients with intussusception presented late with gangrenous intestines. The overall mortality was 6(11.1 %); the mortality in the neonates was 5(33.3 %).

CONCLUSION

Apart from the obvious absence of worm infestation, the aetiological pattern and the clinical presentation of childhood intestinal obstruction in this study agrees with those reported from other parts of the country. Their management is associated with high mortality in our environment, especially when there are associated anomalies or the presentation is late.

Adrenal insufficiency in intestinal obstruction from carcinomatosis peritonei--a factor of potential importance in symptom palliation

Corticosteroids are used in the management of intestinal obstruction (IO) in carcinomatosis peritonei. There is considerable overlap in the symptoms experienced in IO and functional adrenal insufficiency (AI). The success of symptom palliation in IO may be related to the presence of AI. The aim of this preliminary study was to evaluate the incidence of functional adrenal insufficiency in patients with IO and its relation to clinical outcome and symptom control. Twenty-nine consecutive patients with IO and carcinomatosis peritonei from gastrointestinal cancers admitted to our inpatient service between January and October 2002 were analyzed. They were screened for AI using the short corticotropin stimulation test. Thirteen patients (45%) had functional AI. Differences in characteristics of patients with normal adrenal function (Group 1) and adrenal insufficiency (Group 2) were not statistically significant. Time taken to control symptoms in Group 2 was longer. Mean duration of hospitalization per month of survival was two times longer in Group 2 relative to Group 1 (7.9 versus 4.0 days, P=0.011). Functional AI may be caused by cytokines produced in advanced cancer mediating direct adrenal suppression. Prompt corticosteroid therapy in the presence of AI may facilitate IO symptom palliation.

Gastrointestinal bezoars: A retrospective analysis of 34 cases

AIM: Bezoars (BZ) are the most common foreign bodies of gastrointestinal tract. Clinical manifestations vary depending on the location of BZ from no symptoms to acute abdominal syndrome. When located in small bowel, they frequently cause small bowel obstruction (SBO). We aimed to present our experience by reviewing literature.

METHODS: Thirty-four patients with gastrointestinal BZ were presented. The data were collected from hospital records and analyzed retrospectively. Morbidity and mortality rates were statistically analyzed between the subgroups according to SBO and endoscopic or surgical treatment modalities.

RESULTS: The 34 patients had phytobezoars (PBZ). Two patients with mental retardation and trichotillomania had trichobezoars (TBZ). More than half of them (55.88%) had previous gastric surgery. Also most of them had small bowel bezoars resulting in obstruction. Surgical and endoscopic morbidity rates were 32.14% and 14.28% respectively. The total morbidity rate of this study was 29.41%. Four patients in surgically treated group died. There was no death in endoscopically treated group. The total and surgical mortality rates were 11.76% and 14.28% respectively. The differences in morbidity and mortality rates between the subgroups were not statistically significant.

CONCLUSION: BZ are commonly seen in stomach and small intestine. SBO is the most common complication. When uncomplicated, endoscopic or surgical removal can be applied easily.

Endoscopy or surgery for malignant GI outlet obstruction?

BACKGROUND

The treatment of gastroduodenal outflow obstruction (GOO) caused by malignant diseases represents a significant challenge. Open surgical gastrojejunostomy (GJ) has been the treatment of choice, but it has high morbidity and mortality rates. More recently, endoscopic placement of self-expanding metallic stents (SEMS) has been proposed and the results of small, preliminary studies are encouraging. This study compared technical and clinical success, morbidity, mortality, and hospital stay in patients undergoing endoscopic and surgical treatment of GOO.

METHODS

Medical records of 60 consecutive patients with GOO seen between April 1997 and November 2002 were retrospectively reviewed. Because of extremely short life expectancy, 13 patients were treated by insertion of a double-lumen nasogastric-jejunal tube. The remaining 47 patients (28 men, 19 women; mean age 73.5 years, range 48-92 years) with unresectable pancreatic (33), gastric (7), metastatic lymph nodal (4), papillary (2), and biliary (1) tumors were treated by placement of a SEMS (24) or open surgical GJ (23).

RESULTS

The technical success rates were similar, but clinical success was lower in the GJ group (92% vs. 56%, p = 0.0067). The SEMS group had a shorter length of hospital stay (3.0 [1.4] days vs. 24.1 [10.3], p < 0.001). Thirty-day mortality was 30% in the GJ group, and 0% in the SEMS group ( p = 0.004). Morbidity was higher in the GJ compared with the SEMS group (61% vs. 17%, p = 0.0021). Mean survival was longer in the SEMS group (96.1 [9.6] days vs. 70.2 [36.2] days, p = 0.0165 for a single test of hypothesis; Bonferroni correction for a multiple testing removes this significance), consequently, out-of-hospital survival was longer for the SEMS group (93.2 [9.3] days vs. 46.0 [31.5] days, p < 0.001). None of the endoscopic procedures required the assistance of an anesthesiologist or the use of an operating room.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this retrospective study suggest that SEMS insertion is better than surgical GJ for palliation of patients with GOO in terms of clinical success, morbidity, and mortality. Technical success rates were similar. SEMS placement should be proposed as the first-line treatment for relief of GOO. However, a randomized, comparative, prospective study of SEMS vs. laparoscopic GJ is needed.