452
|
Anderson JL, Horne BD, Stevens SM, Woller SC, Samuelson KM, Mansfield JW, Robinson M, Barton S, Brunisholz K, Mower CP, Huntinghouse JA, Rollo JS, Siler D, Bair TL, Knight S, Muhlestein JB, Carlquist JF. A Randomized and Clinical Effectiveness Trial Comparing Two Pharmacogenetic Algorithms and Standard Care for Individualizing Warfarin Dosing (CoumaGen-II). Circulation 2012; 125:1997-2005. [DOI: 10.1161/circulationaha.111.070920] [Citation(s) in RCA: 188] [Impact Index Per Article: 15.7] [Reference Citation Analysis] [Abstract] [Track Full Text] [Journal Information] [Submit a Manuscript] [Subscribe] [Scholar Register] [Indexed: 11/16/2022]
Abstract
Background—
Warfarin is characterized by marked variations in individual dose requirements and a narrow therapeutic window. Pharmacogenetics (PG) could improve dosing efficiency and safety, but clinical trials evidence is meager.
Methods and Results—
A Randomized and Clinical Effectiveness Trial Comparing Two Pharmacogenetic Algorithms and Standard Care for Individualizing Warfarin Dosing (CoumaGen-II) comprised 2 comparisons: (1) a blinded, randomized comparison of a modified 1-step (PG-1) with a 3-step algorithm (PG-2) (N=504), and (2) a clinical effectiveness comparison of PG guidance with use of either algorithm with standard dosing in a parallel control group (N=1866). A rapid method provided same-day
CYP2C9
and
VKORC1
genotyping. Primary outcomes were percentage of out-of-range international normalized ratios at 1 and 3 months and percentage of time in therapeutic range. Primary analysis was modified intention to treat. In the randomized comparison, PG-2 was noninferior but not superior to PG-1 for percentage of out-of-range international normalized ratios at 1 month and 3 months and for percentage of time in therapeutic range at 3 months. However, the combined PG cohort was superior to the parallel controls (percentage of out-of-range international normalized ratios 31% versus 42% at 1 month; 30% versus 42% at 3 months; percentage of time in therapeutic range 69% versus 58%, 71% versus 59%, respectively, all
P
<0.001). Differences persisted after adjustment for age, sex, and clinical indication. There were fewer percentage international normalized ratios ≥4 and ≤1.5 and serious adverse events at 3 months (4.5% versus 9.4% of patients,
P
<0.001) with PG guidance.
Conclusions—
These findings suggest that PG dosing should be considered for broader clinical application, a proposal that is being tested further in 3 major randomized trials. The simpler 1-step PG algorithm provided equivalent results and may be preferable for clinical application.
Clinical Trial Registration—
URL:
http://www.clinicaltrials.gov
. Unique identifier: NCT00927862.
Collapse
Affiliation(s)
- Jeffrey L. Anderson
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Benjamin D. Horne
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Scott M. Stevens
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Scott C. Woller
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Kent M. Samuelson
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Justin W. Mansfield
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Michelle Robinson
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Stephanie Barton
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Kim Brunisholz
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Chrissa P. Mower
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - John A. Huntinghouse
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Jeffrey S. Rollo
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Dustin Siler
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Tami L. Bair
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Stacey Knight
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - Joseph B. Muhlestein
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| | - John F. Carlquist
- From the Intermountain Healthcare (Intermountain Medical Center and LDS and McKay-Dee Hospitals), Murray, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., J.W.M., M.R., S.B., K.B., C.P.M., J.A.H., J.S.R., D.S., T.L.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.); and University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT (J.L.A., B.D.H., S.M.S., S.C.W., K.M.S., S.B., K.B., S.K., J.B.M., J.F.C.)
| |
Collapse
|