Affinity analysis of non-steady-state data obtained under mass transport limited conditions using BIAcore technology

Sequence Recognition in the Minor Groove of DNA by Covalently Linked Formamido Imidazole−Pyrrole−Imidazole Polyamides: Effect of H-Pin Linkage and Linker Length on Selectivity and Affinity

The polyamide N-formamido imidazole-pyrrole-imidazole (f-ImPyIm) binds with an exceptionally high affinity for its cognate site 5'-ACGCGT-3' as a stacked, staggered, and noncovalent cooperative dimer. Investigations are presented into its sequence specificity and binding affinity when linked covalently as an H-pin "dimer". Five f-ImPyIm cross-linked analogues with six to nine methylene linkers and an eight-linked ethylene glycol linker were examined to investigate the effect of linkage and linker length on DNA binding. Thermal denaturation studies on short DNA hairpins showed preferential binding by both f-ImPyIm (DeltaTm = 7.8 degrees C) and its cross-linked derivatives (DeltaTm > 30 degrees C) at 5'-ACGCGT-3', indicating sequence specificity was retained on linkage. DNase I footprinting confirmed strict cognate site selectivity and demonstrated that affinity increased with linker length (f-ImPyIm-9 = f-ImPyIm-8 = f-ImPyIm-EG-8 > f-ImPyIm-7 > f-ImPyIm-6). The eight- and nine-linked derivatives bound at 100-fold lower concentrations at the cognate site relative to f-ImPyIm-6, and with 10-fold higher affinity than unlinked f-ImPyIm. Use of an ethylene glycol linkage in f-ImPyIm-EG-8 to improve solubility slightly increased the cognate site affinity relative to those of f-ImPyIm-8 and f-ImPyIm-9, although some selectivity was lost at high ligand concentration. CD demonstrated that cognate site binding by eight and nine-linked compounds occurred in the minor groove. SPR analysis gave a binding affinity (K) for f-ImPyIm-EG-8 at the cognate site of 2 x 10(10) M-1, representing a 100-fold increase relative to that of f-ImPyIm. This study demonstrates that the high-affinity cooperative binding of f-ImPyIm can be enhanced significantly by suitable covalent linkage, while maintaining its strict cognate site selectivity.

Binding between the integrin alphaXbeta2 (CD11c/CD18) and heparin

The interactions between cell surface receptors and sulfated glucosamineglycans serve ubiquitous roles in cell adhesion and receptor signaling. Heparin, a highly sulfated polymer of uronic acids and glucosamine, binds strongly to the integrin receptor alphaXbeta2 (p150,95, CD11c/CD18). Here, we analyze the structural motifs within heparin that constitute high affinity binding sites for the I domain of integrin alphaXbeta2. Heparin oligomers with chain lengths of 10 saccharide residues or higher provide strong inhibition of the binding by the alphaX I domain to the complement fragment iC3b. By contrast, smaller oligomers or the synthetic heparinoid fondaparinux were not able to block the binding. Semipurified heparin oligomers with 12 saccharide residues identified the fully sulfated species as the most potent antagonist of iC3b, with a 1.3 microM affinity for the alphaX I domain. In studies of direct binding by the alphaX I domain to immobilized heparin, we found that the interaction is conformationally regulated and requires Mg2+. Furthermore, the fully sulfated heparin fragment induced conformational change in the ectodomain of the alphaXbeta2 receptor, also demonstrating allosteric linkage between heparin binding and integrin conformation.

Correlation between binding rate constants and individual information of E. coli Fis binding sites

Individual protein binding sites on DNA can be measured in bits of information. This information is related to the free energy of binding by the second law of thermodynamics, but binding kinetics appear to be inaccessible from sequence information since the relative contributions of the on- and off-rates to the binding constant, and hence the free energy, are unknown. However, the on-rate could be independent of the sequence since a protein is likely to bind once it is near a site. To test this, we used surface plasmon resonance and electromobility shift assays to determine the kinetics for binding of the Fis protein to a range of naturally occurring binding sites. We observed that the logarithm of the off-rate is indeed proportional to the individual information of the binding sites, as predicted. However, the on-rate is also related to the information, but to a lesser degree. We suggest that the on-rate is mostly determined by DNA bending, which in turn is determined by the sequence information. Finally, we observed a break in the binding curve around zero bits of information. The break is expected from information theory because it represents the coding demarcation between specific and nonspecific binding.

Biosensor-surface plasmon resonance: Quantitative analysis of small molecule–nucleic acid interactions

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR)-biosensor techniques directly provide essential information for the study and characterization of small molecule-nucleic acid interactions, and the use of these methods is steadily increasing. The method is label-free and monitors the interactions in real time. Both dynamic and steady-state information can be obtained for a wide range of reaction rates and binding affinities. This article presents the basics of the SPR technique, provides suggestions for experimental design, and illustrates data processing and analysis of results. A specific example of the interaction of a well-known minor groove binding agent, netropsin, with DNA is evaluated by both kinetic and steady-state SPR methods. Three different experiments are used to illustrate different approaches and analysis methods. The three sets of results show the reproducibility of the binding constants and agreement from both steady-state and kinetic analyses. These experiments also show that reliable kinetic information can be obtained, even with difficult systems, if the experimental conditions are optimized to minimize mass transport effects. Limitations of the biosensor-SPR technique are also discussed to provide an awareness of the care needed to conduct a successful experiment.

Unusually strong binding to the DNA minor groove by a highly twisted benzimidazole diphenylether: induced fit and bound water

RT29 is a dicationic diamidine derivative that does not obey the classical "rules" for shape and functional group placement that are expected to result in strong binding and specific recognition of the DNA minor groove. The compound contains a benzimidazole diphenyl ether core that is flanked by the amidine cations. The diphenyl ether is highly twisted and gives the entire compound too much curvature to fit well to the shape of the minor groove. DNase I footprinting, fluorescence intercalator displacement studies, and circular dichroism spectra, however, indicate that the compound is an AT specific minor groove binding agent. Even more surprisingly, quantitative biosensor-surface plasmon resonance and isothermal titration calorimetric results indicate that the compound binds with exceptional strength to certain AT sequences in DNA with a large negative enthalpy of binding. Crystallographic results for the DNA complex of RT29 compared to calculated results for the free compound show that the compound undergoes significant conformational changes to enhance its minor groove interactions. In addition, a water molecule is incorporated directly into the complex to complete the compound-DNA interface, and it forms an essential link between the compound and base pair edges at the floor of the minor groove. The calculated DeltaCp value for complex formation is substantially less than the experimentally observed value, which supports the idea of water being an intrinsic part of the complex with a major contribution to the DeltaCp value. Both the induced fit conformational changes of the compound and the bound water are essential for strong binding to DNA by RT29.

Biosensor-based characterization of serum antibodies during development of an anti-IgE immunotherapeutic against allergy and asthma

Antibody responses, induced in Cynomolgus monkey by recombinant IgE-derived immunotherapeutic protein against atopic allergies and asthma, were characterized using label-free, real-time protein interaction analysis. The effects of two different immunotherapeutic proteins were compared. Active concentrations of specific anti-IgE antibodies formed were determined in sera sampled at multiple time points, using conditions of total mass transport limitation that were proved to exist on the sensor surface. These concentrations varied from about 0.4 to 35 microg/ml among the monkeys and throughout the immunization period. Based on these concentrations, the rate and affinity constants for the binding of antibody populations to the antigen could be determined. The apparent equilibrium dissociation constant decreased during the immunization period, for all the monkeys, by a factor between 6 and 50, ending at values from approximately 2 x 10(-9) to approximately 2 x 10(-11) M among the animals. This affinity maturation was attributable to the changes in both rate constants, although the magnitude of the contribution of each constant depended partly on specimen, but primarily on the immunotherapeutic used. The immunotherapeutic proteins examined showed excellent immunogenic properties, providing the basis for a new and effective treatment for allergy and asthma.

Quantification of Small Molecule-Receptor Affinities and Kinetics by Acoustic Profiling

The label-free RAPid 4 system that exploits resonant acoustic profiling (RAP) from Akubio (Cambridge, UK) was used to determine the affinity and kinetics for several different small molecule-receptor interactions. This was achieved by attaching the target receptor to the surface of quartz crystal resonators through a variety of specific coupling chemistries, followed by application of a small-molecular-weight ligand to the receptor via a microfluidic flow-based delivery system. Rank order of binding was determined for very weak interactions such as cofactor binding to glucose dehydrogenase. Moderate interaction affinities and binding kinetics could be determined for biotin binding to a specific antibody, and also for several low-molecular-weight sulfonamide analogues binding to human carbonic anhydrase isoform II. The equilibrium binding constants were in general agreement with the values obtained by kinetic analysis of the data, as well as with previously published values obtained using surface plasmon resonance, stopped flow fluorescence, and isothermal titration calorimetry.

Structural basis for polypyrimidine tract recognition by the essential pre-mRNA splicing factor U2AF65

The essential pre-mRNA splicing factor, U2AF(65), guides the early stages of splice site choice by recognizing a polypyrimidine (Py) tract consensus sequence near the 3' splice site. Since Py tracts are relatively poorly conserved in higher eukaryotes, U2AF(65) is faced with the problem of specifying uridine-rich sequences, yet tolerating a variety of nucleotide substitutions found in natural Py tracts. To better understand these apparently contradictory RNA binding characteristics, the X-ray structure of the U2AF(65) RNA binding domain bound to a Py tract composed of seven uridines has been determined at 2.5 A resolution. Specific hydrogen bonds between U2AF(65) and the uracil bases provide an explanation for polyuridine recognition. Flexible side chains and bound water molecules form the majority of the base contacts and potentially could rearrange when the U2AF(65) structure adapts to different Py tract sequences. The energetic importance of conserved residues for Py tract binding is established by analysis of site-directed mutant U2AF(65) proteins using surface plasmon resonance.

Binding of netropsin and 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole to an A2T2 DNA hairpin: a comparison of biophysical techniques

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and biosensor-surface plasmon resonance (SPR) are evaluated for their accuracy in determining equilibrium constants, ease of use, and range of application. Systems chosen for comparison of the three techniques were the formation of complexes between two minor groove binding compounds, netropsin and 4,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole (DAPI), and a DNA hairpin having the sequence 5'-d(CGAATTCGTCTCCGAATTCG)-3'. These systems were chosen for their structural differences, simplicity (1:1 binding), and binding affinity in the range of interest (K approximately 10(8) M(-1)). The binding affinities determined from all three techniques were in excellent agreement; for example, netropsin/DNA formation constants were determined to be K = 1.7x10(8) M(-1) (ITC), K = 2.4x10(8) M(-1) (DSC), and K = 2.9x10(8) M(-1) (SPR). DSC and SPR techniques have an advantage over ITC in studies of ligands that bind with affinities greater than 10(8) M(-1). The ITC technique has the advantage of determining a full set of thermodynamic parameters, including deltaH, TdeltaS, and deltaC(p) in addition to deltaG (or K). The ITC data revealed complex binding behavior in these minor groove binding systems not detected in the other methods. All three techniques provide accurate estimates of binding affinity, and each has unique benefits for drug binding studies.

Convection, diffusion and reaction in a surface-based biosensor: Modeling of cooperativity and binding site competition on the surface and in the hydrogel

We study theoretically the transport and kinetic processes underlying the operation of a biosensor (particularly the surface plasmon sensor "Biacore") used to study the surface binding kinetics of biomolecules in solution to immobilized receptors. Unlike previous studies, we concentrate mainly on the modeling of system-specific phenomena rather than on the influence of mass transport limitations on the intrinsic kinetic rate constants determined from binding data. In the first problem, the case of two-site binding where each receptor unit on the surface can accommodate two analyte molecules on two different sites is considered. One analyte molecule always binds first to a specific site. Subsequently, the second analyte molecule can bind to the adjacent unoccupied site. In the second problem, two different analytes compete for one binding site on the same surface receptor. Finally, the third problem considers the case of positive cooperativity among bound molecules in the hydrogel using a simple mean-field approach. The transport in both the flow channel and the hydrogel phases of the biosensor is taken into account in this case (with few exceptions, most previous studies assume a simpler model in which the hydrogel is treated as a planar surface with the receptors). We consider simultaneously diffusion and convection through the flow channel together with diffusion and cooperativity binding on the surface and in the hydrogel. In each case, typical results for the concentration contours of the free and bound molecules in the flow channel and hydrogel regions are presented together with the time-dependent association/dissociation curves and reaction rates. For binding site competition, the analysis predicts overshoot phenomena.

Kinetic mechanism of deoxyadenosine kinase from Mycoplasma determined by surface plasmon resonance technology

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR) detection technology was employed to investigate the kinetic mechanism of deoxyadenosine kinase from Mycoplasma mycoides ssp. mycoides SC. In our experimental approach, the enzyme was attached to the sensor surface, the reactants were injected in the mobile phase, and the product-enzyme complex formation was measured using the fact that the rate of product formation exceeds that of its dissociation. The pre-steady-state analysis of deoxyguanosine phosphorylation showed the presence of a burst phase, which is consistent with product dissociation being a rate-limiting step. High activity of the immobilized enzyme was demonstrated by analyzing the reaction mixture eluted from the chip and by determining the Michaelis-Menten constants for several phosphate acceptors (e.g., deoxyadenosine) and phosphate donors (e.g., ATP) using SPR detection. These values were in good agreement with those reported previously [Wang, L. et al. (2001) Mol. Microbiol. 42, 1065-1073]. The bisubstrate initial rate pattern obtained was characteristic of a sequential kinetic mechanism. Because in the method applied here it is the mass change on the surface that is monitored, a new mathematical approach to interpreting product inhibition experiments was proposed. According to that approach, product inhibition studies, supported by product binding experiments, indicated that the reaction mechanism was of Bi Bi sequential ordered type, involving the formation of a ternary complex, in which ATP and deoxyadenosine bound sequentially, followed by a transfer of the phosphate group, and an ordered release of products with ADP dissociating before dAMP.

High-throughput affinity ranking of antibodies using surface plasmon resonance microarrays

A method was developed to rapidly identify high-affinity human antibodies from phage display library selection outputs. It combines high-throughput Fab fragment expression and purification with surface plasmon resonance (SPR) microarrays to determine kinetic constants (kon and koff) for 96 different Fab fragments in a single experiment. Fabs against human tissue kallikrein 1 (hK1, KLK1 gene product) were discovered by phage display, expressed in Escherichia coli in batches of 96, and purified using protein A PhyTip columns. Kinetic constants were obtained for 191 unique anti-hK1 Fabs using the Flexchip SPR microarray device. The highest affinity Fabs discovered had dissociation constants of less than 1 nM. The described SPR method was also used to categorize Fabs according to their ability to recognize an apparent active site epitope. The ability to rapidly determine the affinities of hundreds of antibodies significantly accelerates the discovery of high-affinity antibody leads.

Analyzing a kinetic titration series using affinity biosensors

The classical method of measuring binding constants with affinity-based biosensors involves testing several analyte concentrations over the same ligand surface and regenerating the surface between binding cycles. Here we describe an alternative approach to collecting kinetic binding data, which we call "kinetic titration." This method involves sequentially injecting an analyte concentration series without any regeneration steps. Through a combination of simulation and experimentation, we show that this method can be as robust as the classical method of analysis. In addition, kinetic titrations can be more efficient than the conventional data collection method and allow us to fully characterize analyte binding to ligand surfaces that are difficult to regenerate.

Out-of-Shape DNA Minor Groove Binders: Induced Fit Interactions of Heterocyclic Dications with the DNA Minor Groove

DB921 and DB911 are benzimidazole-biphenyl isomers with terminal charged amidines. DB911 has a central meta-substituted phenyl that gives it a shape similar to those of known minor groove binding compounds. DB921 has a central para-substituted phenyl with a linear conformation that lacks the appropriate radius of curvature to match the groove shape. It is thus expected that DB911, but not DB921, should be an effective minor groove binder, but we find that DB921 not only binds in the groove but also has an unusually high binding constant in SPR experiments (2.9 x 10(8) M(-)(1), vs 2.1 x 10(7) M(-)(1) for DB911). ITC thermodynamic analysis with an AATT sequence shows that the stronger binding of DB921 is due to a more favorable binding enthalpy relative to that of DB911. CD results support minor groove binding for both compounds but do not provide an explanation for the binding of DB921. X-ray crystallographic analysis of DB921 bound to AATT shows that an induced fit structural change in DB921 reduces the twist of the biphenyl to complement the groove, and places the functional groups in position to interact with bases at the floor of the groove. The phenylamidine of DB921 forms indirect contacts with the bases through a bound water. The DB921-water pair forms a curved binding module that matches the shape of the minor groove and provides a number of strong interactions that are not possible with DB911. This result suggests that traditional views of compound curvature required for minor groove complex formation should be reevaluated.

Kinetic determinations of molecular interactions using Biacore—minimum data requirements for efficient experimental design

Reliable kinetic estimates can be obtained from significantly less data than is commonly used today, particularly in the characterization of 1:1 interactions involving low molecular weight compounds and proteins. We have designed a rational and cost-effective strategy to determine kinetic constants using Biacore's surface plasmon resonance-based biosensors and show that the number of measurements necessary for accurate kinetic determinations can be greatly reduced, increasing sample throughput and saving sample material. Simulated and measured data for a range of possible 1:1 interactants were studied to find the minimum requirements of a data set for kinetic analysis. The results showed that kinetic constants in the region 10(4) < k(a) < 10(7) M(-1) s(-1) (association) and 10(-4) < k(d) < 10(-1) s(-1) (dissociation) could easily be determined in a 1:1 interaction model. Owing to the information-dense nature of Biacore data, only two sample concentrations were necessary to reliably determine the kinetics. A standard sample concentration series consisting of 10-fold dilutions between approximately 10 microM and approximately 1 nM consistently provided at least two concentrations with sufficient information about the interaction in this region. Determinations of the constants became increasingly unreliable outside this region. If the rate constants prove to be outside the specified region or the data fits poorly to the 1:1-MTL model, more experiments are required. General recommendations for the design of a cost-effective assay to deliver reliable kinetic measurements are provided.

A biophysical characterisation of factors controlling dimerisation and selectivity in the NF-kappaB and NFAT families

The Rel/NF-kappaB family of eukaryotic transcription factors bind DNA with high specificity and affinity as homo- or heterodimers to mediate a diverse range of biological processes. By comparison, the nuclear factor of activated T-cells (NFAT) family has been recognised as Rel homologues due to structural similarities between the DNA-binding domains, yet they bind DNA as lower-affinity monomers. The structural and functional overlap between the NF-kappaB and NFAT families suggests that they may be evolutionarily divergent from a common, monomeric ancestor but have evolved different mechanisms to achieve high-affinity binding to their target DNA sequences. In order to understand the origin of these mechanistic differences, we constructed two chimeric proteins, based on molecular modelling, comprising the DNA-binding domain of NFAT and the dimerisation domain of NF-kappaB p50, differing only in the position of the splice site. Biophysical characterisation of the wild-type and chimeric proteins revealed that one of the chimeras bound DNA as a high-affinity, NF-kappaB-like cooperative dimer, whilst the other bound as a lower-affinity, NFAT-like monomer, demonstrating the importance of the interdomain linker in controlling the intrinsic ability of NFATc to form dimers. In addition, we have studied the rate of exchange of monomers between preformed NF-kappaB dimers and have determined, for the first time, the intrinsic homodimerisation constant for NF-kappaB p50. These data support a model in which NF-kappaB proteins bind DNA both in vitro and in vivo as high-affinity preformed homo- or heterodimers, which in an unbound form can still exchange monomer units on a physiologically relevant timescale in vivo.

Analysis of the pH-dependencies of the association and dissociation kinetics of HIV-1 protease inhibitors

The kinetic constants for the interactions between HIV-1 protease and a selection of inhibitors were determined at different pH-values using a biosensor based interaction assay. Since this technique does not involve a substrate, it was possible to determine the pH-dependencies of the association and dissociation rates of an inhibitor, without the complication of a pH-dependent enzyme-substrate/product equilibrium. The importance of these interactions was evaluated by correlating the free energy changes upon association and dissociation of inhibitors with the predicted change in electrostatic properties of the interacting groups as a result of altered pH. It was found that the kinetic parameters varied with pH in a unique manner for all inhibitors, demonstrating that the kinetic features were associated with the specific structure of each inhibitor. Association and dissociation had different pH-profiles, indicating that the two processes proceeded by different pathways/mechanisms. The energy barrier for dissociation of the enzyme-indinavir complex increased with pH from 4.1 to 7.4, while it was generally reduced for the other inhibitors as the pH was increased from 5.1 to 7.4. The pH-dependent interactions involved in the recognition/binding of inhibitors and in the stabilization of the complex were identified by analysing three-dimensional structures of enzyme-inhibitor complexes. The interaction between the pyridine nitrogen of indinavir with Arg-8 was hypothesized to be responsible for the unique pH-dependency of indinavir. The analysis revealed features of interactions that are significant for understanding enzyme function and for optimization of new drug leads. It also highlighted the importance of environmental conditions on interactions.

Elucidation of HIV-1 protease resistance by characterization of interaction kinetics between inhibitors and enzyme variants

The kinetics of the interaction between drug-resistant variants of HIV-1 protease (G48V, V82A, L90M, I84V/L90M, and G48V/V82A/I84V/L90M) and clinically used inhibitors (amprenavir, indinavir, nelfinavir, ritonavir, and saquinavir) were determined using biosensor technology. The enzyme variants were immobilized on a biosensor chip and the association and dissociation rate constants (k(on) and k(off)) and affinities (K(D)) for interactions with inhibitors were determined. A unique interaction kinetic profile was observed for each variant/inhibitor combination. Substitution of single amino acids in the protease primarily resulted in reduced affinity through increased k(off) for the inhibitors. For inhibitors characterized by fast association rates to wild-type protease (ritonavir, amprenavir, and indinavir), additional substitutions resulted in a further reduction of affinity by a combination of decreased k(on) and increased k(off). For inhibitors characterized by slow dissociation rates to wild-type enzyme (saquinavir and nelfinavir), the decrease of affinity conferred by additional mutations was attributed to increased k(off) values. Development of resistance thus appears to be associated with a change of the distinctive kinetic parameter contributing to high affinity. Further inhibitor design should focus on improving the "weak point" of the lead compound, that being either k(on) or k(off).

A specific interaction between the NBD of the ABC-transporter HlyB and a C-terminal fragment of its transport substrate haemolysin A

A member of the family of RTX toxins, Escherichia coli haemolysin A, is secreted from Gram-negative bacteria. It carries a C-terminal secretion signal of approximately 50 residues, targeting the protein to the secretion or translocation complex, in which the ABC-transporter HlyB is a central element. We have purified the nucleotide-binding domain of HlyB (HlyB-NBD) and a C-terminal 23kDa fragment of HlyA plus the His-tag (HlyA1), which contains the secretion sequence. Employing surface plasmon resonance, we were able to demonstrate that the HlyB-NBD and HlyA1 interact with a K(D) of approximately 4 microM. No interaction was detected between the HlyA fragment and unrelated NBDs, OpuAA, involved in import of osmoprotectants, and human TAP1-NBD, involved in the export of antigenic peptides. Moreover, a truncated version of HlyA1, lacking the secretion signal, failed to interact with the HlyB-NBD. In addition, we showed that ATP accelerated the dissociation of the HlyB-NBD/HlyA1 complex. Taking these results together, we propose a model for an early stage of initiation of secretion in vivo, in which the NBD of HlyB, specifically recognizes the C terminus of the transport substrate, HlyA, and where secretion is initiated by subsequent displacement of HlyA from HlyB by ATP.

Kinetic and mechanistic analysis of the association and dissociation of inhibitors interacting with secreted aspartic acid proteases 1 and 2 from Candida albicans

In order to elucidate the characteristics of different aspartic proteases (Sap) secreted by Candida albicans, the kinetics of the interaction (k(on), k(off)) between Sap1 and Sap2 with acetyl-pepstatin and pepstatin A was determined at different pH by biosensor technology. The enzymes were biotinylated and coupled to a streptavidin-coated sensor chip, whereupon acetyl-pepstatin or pepstatin A was injected and the interaction was measured in real time. Sap2 showed a faster k(on) and a higher affinity for acetyl-pepstatin than Sap1, regardless of pH. The values for both k(on) and k(off) decreased with increased pH from 3.8 to 5.0, except for the k(off) for Sap1, which was only influenced by the pH change from 3.8 to 4.4. Binding of acetyl-pepstatin to Sap1 or Sap2 obviously proceeds by a different mechanism than dissociation of the inhibitor. Association appears to be coupled to protonation of a catalytic aspartic acid residue, consistent with reduced k(on) values at higher pH. In contrast, the stability of the complex is reduced at lower pH due to reduced hydrogen bonding capacity of aspartic acid residues acting as hydrogen bond acceptors. Differences in the number and distribution of charged nonactive site residues in Sap1 and Sap2 evidently result in different electrostatic properties of the binding sites, primarily influencing the association step.

Relationships between structure and interaction kinetics for HIV-1 protease inhibitors

The interaction between HIV-1 protease and 58 structurally diverse transition-state analogue inhibitors has been analyzed by a surface plasmon resonance based biosensor. Association and dissociation rate constants and affinities were determined and displayed as k(on)-k(off)-K(D) maps. It was shown that different classes of inhibitors fall into distinct clusters in these maps. Significant changes in association and dissociation rates were found as a result of modifying the P1/P1' or P2/P2' side chains of a linear lead compound. Similarly, cyclic urea and cyclic sulfamide inhibitors displayed different kinetic features and the affinities of both classes of cyclic compounds were limited by fast dissociation rates. These results confirm that association and dissociation rates are important features of drug-target interactions and indicate that optimization of inhibitor efficacy may be guided by aiming for high association and low dissociation rates rather than high affinity alone. The present approach thus provides a new tool for structure-interaction kinetic analysis and drug discovery.

Biospecific interaction analysis: a tool for drug discovery and development

The recent development of surface plasmon resonance (SPR)-based biosensor technologies for biospecific interaction analysis (BIA) enables the monitoring of a variety of molecular reactions in real-time. The biomolecular interactions occur at the surface of a flow cell of a sensor chip between a ligand immobilized on the surface and an injected analyte. SPR-based BIA offers many advantages over most of the other methodologies available for the study of biomolecular interactions, including full automation, no requirement for labeling, and the availability of a large variety of activated sensor chips that allow immobilization of DNA, RNA, proteins, peptides and cells. The assay is rapid and requires only small quantitities of both ligand and analyte in order to obtain informative results. In addition, the sensor chip can be re-used many times, leading to low running costs. Aside from the analysis of all possible combinations of peptide, protein, DNA and RNA interactions, this technology can also be used for screening of monoclonal antibodies and epitope mapping, analysis of interactions between low molecular weight compounds and proteins or nucleic acids, interactions between cells and ligands, and real-time monitoring of gene expression. Applications of SPR-based BIA in medicine include the molecular diagnosis of viral infections and genetic diseases caused by point mutations. Future perspectives include the combinations of SPR-based BIA with mass spectrometry, the use of biosensors in proteomics, and the application of this technology to design and develop efficient drug delivery systems.

Analysis of the interaction between the aspartic peptidase inhibitor SQAPI and aspartic peptidases using surface plasmon resonance

Aspartic peptidase inhibitors, which are themselves proteins, are strong inhibitors (small inhibition constants) of some aspartic peptidases but not others. However, there have been no studies of the kinetics of the interaction between a proteinaceous aspartic peptidase inhibitor and aspartic peptidases. This paper describes an analysis of rate constants for the interaction between recombinant squash aspartic peptidase inhibitor (rSQAPI) and a panel of aspartic peptidases that have a range of inhibition constants for SQAPI. Purified rSQAPI completely inhibits pepsin at a 1:1 molar ratio of pepsin to rSQAPI monomer (inhibition constant 1 nM). The interaction of pepsin with immobilized rSQAPI, at pH values between 3.0 and 6.0, was monitored using surface plasmon resonance. Binding of pepsin to rSQAPI was slow (association rate constants ca 10(4)M (-1)s(-1)), but rSQAPI was an effective pepsin inhibitor because dissociation of the rSQAPI-pepsin complex was much slower (dissociation rate constants ca 10(-4)s(-1)), especially at low pH values. Similar results were obtained with a His-tagged rSQAPI. Strong inhibition (inhibition constant 3 nM) of one isoform (rSap4) of the family of Candida albicans-secreted aspartic peptidases was, as with pepsin, characterized by slow binding of rSap4 and slower dissociation of the rSap4-inhibitor complex. In contrast, weaker inhibition of the Glomerella cingulata-secreted aspartic peptidase (inhibition constant 7 nM) and the C. albicans rSap1 and Sap2 isoenzymes (inhibition constants 25 and 400 nM, respectively) was, in each case, characterized by a larger dissociation rate constant.

A thermodynamic characterization of the binding of thrombin inhibitors to human thrombin, combining biosensor technology, stopped-flow spectrophotometry, and microcalorimetry

The binding of a series of low-molecular-mass, active-site-directed thrombin inhibitors (399-575 Da) to human alpha-thrombin was investigated by surface plasmon resonance technology (BIACORE), stopped-flow spectrophotometry, and isothermal titration microcalorimetry (ITC). The equilibrium constants K(D) (nM to microM range) at 25 degrees C obtained from the BIACORE analysis correlated well with the inhibition constants K(i) in a chromogenic inhibition assay. The interactions between thrombin and three potent inhibitors, melagatran, inogatran, and CH-248, were further investigated at temperatures between 278 and 310K. A one-to-one binding stoichiometry found with ITC was supported by BIACORE data. K(i) and K(D) values increased with the temperature, mainly due to higher values for dissociation rate constants. The changes in enthalpy, DeltaH, and entropy, DeltaS, determined from the linear van't Hoff plots (R coefficient > 0.99), were linearly correlated by chemical compensation. Both techniques indicated clear differences in DeltaS for the three inhibitors, with a strong correlation to the number of rotational bonds. Immobilization of thrombin increased the binding stability at higher temperature and reduced the DeltaH by 20 kJ mol(-1). DeltaH values obtained from the inhibition kinetics and BIACORE were thus not identical, but correlated well with ITC data obtained at 37 degrees C. The two thermodynamic techniques allowed further differentiation between compounds of similar affinity; furthermore, kinetic analysis, hence analysis of the transition state, is complementary to ITC. A direct BIACORE binding assay might be a useful alternative to more elaborate inhibition studies.

Temperature differentially affects encounter and docking thermodynamics of antibody--antigen association

Using BIACORE SPR, we have examined the mechanism of temperature effects on the binding kinetics of two closely related antibody Fabs (H10 and H26) which recognize coincident epitopes on hen egg-white lysozyme (HEL), and whose association and dissociation kinetics are best described by the two-step conformational change model which we interpret as molecular encounter and docking. Time-course series data obtained at a series of six temperatures (6, 10, 15, 25, 30 and 37 degrees C) showed that temperature differentially affects the rate constants of the encounter and docking steps. Docking is more temperature-sensitive than the encounter step, and energetically less favorable at higher temperatures. At elevated temperatures, the time required for docking is longer and the apparent increase in off-rate reflects the greater proportion of the molecules failing to dock and remaining in the less stable encounter state. As a consequence, distribution of free energy change between the encounter and docking steps is altered. At physiological temperature (37 degrees C) the docking step of the H26 complex is energetically unfavorable and most complexes essentially do not dock. There is a significant decrease in total free energy change of the H26 complex at higher temperatures. Elevated temperature changes the rate-limiting step of H26--HEL association from the encounter to the docking step, but not that of H10--HEL. Our results indicate that the mechanism by which elevated temperature reduces the affinities of antigen--antibody complexes is to decrease the net docking rate, and/or stability of the docked complex; at higher temperatures, a smaller proportion of the complexes actually anneal to a more stable docked state. This mechanism may have broad applicability to other receptor--ligand complexes.

Determination of interaction kinetic constants for HIV-1 protease inhibitors using optical biosensor technology

The interaction between HIV-1 protease and inhibitors has been studied with optical biosensor technology. Optimized experimental procedures and mathematical analysis permitted determination of association and dissociation rate constants. A sensor surface with native enzyme was unstable and exhibited a drift that was influenced by the binding of inhibitor. This was hypothesized to be due to a specific mechanism involving autoproteolysis and/or dimer dissociation. The use of a mutant predicted to be less susceptible to autoproteolysis (Q7K) than wild-type enzyme resulted in a minor effect on surface stability, while a completely stable surface was obtained by treatment of the immobilized enzyme with N-ethyl-N'-(dimethylaminopropyl)-carbodiimide and N-hydroxysuccinimide; the most stable surface was achieved by chemically modifying the Q7K enzyme. The stabilized surface was enzymatically active and the interaction with inhibitors was similar to that for native enzyme. Several of the inhibitors had very high association rates, and estimation of kinetic constants was therefore performed with a binding equation accounting for limited mass transport. Of the clinical inhibitors studied, saquinavir had the highest affinity for the enzyme, a result of the lowest dissociation rate. Although the dissociation rate for ritonavir was sixfold faster, the affinity was only twofold lower than that for saquinavir since the association rate was threefold faster. Nelfinavir and indinavir exhibited lower affinities relative to the other inhibitors, a consequence of a slower association for nelfinavir and a relatively fast dissociation for indinavir. These results show that biosensor-based interaction studies can resolve affinity into association and dissociation rates, and that these are characteristic parameters for the interaction between enzymes and inhibitors.

Use of optical biosensors for the study of mechanistically concerted surface adsorption processes

The advent of commercial optical biosensors, such as the BIAcore from Pharmacia and IAsys from Affinity Sensors, has made available to the biochemist a powerful means to examine and characterize the interaction of biological macromolecules with a binding surface. By analysis of the kinetic and equilibrium aspects of the observed experimental adsorption isotherms, rate and affinity constants can be determined. This Review focuses on pertinent aspects of the technology and its use for the performance and quantitative characterization of some various types of mechanistically concerted adsorption behavior.

Reevaluation of stoichiometry and affinity/avidity in interactions between anti-hapten antibodies and mono- or multi-valent antigens

In order to obtain further information on the interaction between antigens (Ags) and B cell Ag receptors (BCR) for a better understanding of the relationship between signals resulting from Ag binding and B cell activation, effects of Ag valence and size on the apparent association constant, i.e. the avidity as well as the molecular stoichiometry of immune complexes in Ag-antibody (Ab) interactions were studied. Hapten conjugates using proteins of various molecular weights, such as hen egg lysozyme (HEL), ovalbumin (OVA), bovine serum albumin (BSA), and chicken gammaglobulin (CGG), were prepared for this purpose. Different ratios of the hapten, (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP), to the protein were used for conjugation, and interactions between anti-NP monoclonal Abs (mAbs) and the NP conjugates were evaluated by surface plasmon resonance. It was founded that the two binding sites of an Ab were able to simultaneously accommodate two NP(1)-HEL, resulting in a tri-molecular complex, Ag(2)Ab(1). However, NP conjugates of the higher-molecular-weight proteins, OVA and BSA, formed only Ag(1)Ab(1), irrespective of hapten valence. This was thought to be due to steric hindrance caused by the binding of the first Ag. These results suggested that the stoichiometry depended largely on the size of the Ag involved and that mAbs with a low affinity are more efficient at raising the binding strength through divalent interaction since the avidity of two mAbs in interactions with highly haptenated BSA was not significantly different in spite of a 10-fold difference in affinity to the monovalent NP(1)-HEL.

Survey of the 1999 surface plasmon resonance biosensor literature

The application of surface plasmon resonance biosensors in life sciences and pharmaceutical research continues to increase. This review provides a comprehensive list of the commercial 1999 SPR biosensor literature and highlights emerging applications that are of general interest to users of the technology. Given the variability in the quality of published biosensor data, we present some general guidelines to help increase confidence in the results reported from biosensor analyses.