Response of engineered cartilage tissue to biochemical agents as studied by proton magnetic resonance microscopy

Microengineering neocartilage scaffolds

Advances in micropatterning methodologies have made it possible to create structures with precise architecture on the surface of cell culture substrata. We applied these techniques to fabricate microfeatures (15-65 microm wide; 40 microm deep) on the surface of a flexible, biocompatible polysaccharide gel. The micropatterned polymer gels were subsequently applied as scaffolds for chondrocyte culture and proved effective in maintaining key aspects of the chondrogenic phenotype. These were rounded cell morphology and a positive and statistically significant (p < 0.0001) immunofluorescence assay for the production of type II collagen throughout the maximum culture time of 10 days after cell seeding. Further, cells housed within individual surface features were observed to proliferate, while serial application of chondrocytes resulted in the formation of cellular aggregates. These methods represent a novel approach to the problem of engineering reparative cartilage in vitro.

Cartilage calcification studied by proton nuclear magnetic resonance microscopy

A three-dimensional (3D) mineralizing culture system using hollow fiber bioreactors has been developed to study the early stages of endochondral ossification by proton nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) microscopy. Chondrocytes harvested from the cephalic half of the sterna from 17-day-old chick embryos were terminally differentiated with 33 nM of retinoic acid for 1 week and mineralization was initiated by the addition of 1% beta-glycerophosphate to the culture medium. Histological sections taken after 6 weeks of development in culture confirmed calcification of the cartilage matrix formed in bioreactors. Calcium to phosphorus ratios (1.62-1.68) from X-ray microanalysis supported electron diffraction of thin tissue sections showing the presence of a poorly crystalline hydroxyapatite mineral phase in the cultures. After 4 weeks of culture, quantitative proton NMR images showed water proton magnetization transfer rate constants (km) were higher in premineralized cartilage compared with uncalcified cartilage, a result suggesting collagen enrichment of the matrix. Notably after 5 weeks mineral deposits formed in bioreactors principally in the collagen-enriched zones of the cartilage with increased km values. This caused marked reductions in water proton longitudinal (T1) and transverse (T2) relaxation times and water diffusion coefficients (D). These results support the hypothesis that mineralization proceeds in association with a collagen template. After 6 weeks of culture development, the water proton T2 values decreased by 13% and D increased by 7% in uncalcified areas, compared with the same regions of tissue examined 1 week earlier. These changes could be attributed to the formation of small mineral inclusions in the cartilage, possibly mediated by matrix vesicles, which may play an important role in cartilage calcification. In summary, NMR images acquired before and after the onset of mineralization of the same tissue provide unique insights into the matrix events leading to endochondral mineral formation.

Water magnetic relaxation dispersion in biological systems: the contribution of proton exchange and implications for the noninvasive detection of cartilage degradation

Magnetic relaxation has been used extensively to study and characterize biological tissues. In particular, spin-lattice relaxation in the rotating frame (T(1rho)) of water in protein solutions has been demonstrated to be sensitive to macromolecular weight and composition. However, the nature of the contribution from low frequency processes to water relaxation remains unclear. We have examined this problem by studying the water T(1rho) dispersion in peptide solutions ((14)N- and (15)N-labeled), glycosaminoglycan solutions, and samples of bovine articular cartilage before and after proteoglycan degradation. We find in model systems and tissue that hydrogen exchange from NH and OH groups to water dominates the low frequency water T(1rho) dispersion, in the context of the model used to interpret the relaxation data. Further, low frequency dispersion changes are correlated with loss of proteoglycan from the extra-cellular matrix of articular cartilage. This finding has significance for the noninvasive detection of matrix degradation.

EPR oxygen mapping (EPROM) of engineered cartilage grown in a hollow-fiber bioreactor

A novel electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR)-based oxygen mapping procedure (EPROM) is applied to cartilage grown in a single-, hollow-fiber bioreactor (HFBR) system. Chondrocytes harvested from the sterna of 17-day-old chick embryos were inoculated into an HFBR and produced hyaline cartilage over a period of 4 weeks. Tissue oxygen maps were generated according to the EPROM technique (Velan et al., Magn Reson Med 2000;43:804-809) by making use of the line-broadening effects of oxygen on the signal generated from nitroxide spin probes. In addition, the effect on oxygen consumption of the addition of cyanide to the tissue was investigated. Cyanide is a potent inhibitor of oxidative phosphorylation, and accordingly, given the constant provision of oxygen to the tissue, it would be expected to increase oxygen levels within the HFBR. The EPROM measurements showed a significant increase in oxygen concentration in the cartilage after the addition of cyanide. In contrast to other methods for studying oxygen in cartilage, EPROM can provide direct, noninvasive visualization of local concentrations in three dimensions.

Histomorphometry of the embryonic avian growth plate by proton nuclear magnetic resonance microscopy

Quantitative nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) microscopy was used to characterize the biochemical and morphological properties of the different zones within the growth plate of an embryonic chick femur. For precalcified tissue, water proton transverse relaxation times (T2) and magnetization transfer values (MT) were directly and inversely dependent, respectively, on tissue cellularity, defined as the intracellular area per unit area on histological sections. T2 values extrapolated for intra- and extracellular water were 96 ms and 46 ms, respectively. The extracellular T2 was comparable with that measured for mature cartilage. The MT values extrapolated for intra- and extracellular compartments were 0.32 and 0.85, respectively. These values were comparable with those values reported in the literature for cell pellets and for mature cartilage tissue. Thus, cellularity dominated the NMR properties of this immature cartilage tissue. Mineral deposits within calcified cartilage and periosteal bone invoked NMR relaxation processes that were dependent on the inorganic mineral phase. Additionally, collagen molecules present in mineralized zones gave rise to a significant MT effect. These results show the utility of water proton NMR microscopy for assessing both the organic and inorganic phases within mineralized tissues.

Imaging of collagen and proteoglycan in cartilage sections using Fourier transform infrared spectral imaging

OBJECTIVE

To test the hypothesis that Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectral imaging, coupled with multivariate data processing techniques, can image the spatial distribution of matrix constituents in native and engineered cartilage samples.

METHODS

Tissue sections from native and trypsin-digested bovine nasal cartilage (BNC) and from engineered cartilage, generated by chick sternal chondrocytes grown in a hollow fiber bioreactor, were placed either on calcium fluoride windows for FTIR analysis or gelatinized microscope slides for histologic analysis. Based on the assumption that cartilage is predominantly chondroitin sulfate (CS) and type II collagen, chemical images were extracted from FTIR spectral imaging data sets using 2 multivariate methods: the Euclidean distance algorithm and a least-squares approach.

RESULTS

Least-squares analysis of the FTIR data of native BNC yielded a collagen content of 54 +/- 13% and a CS content of 37 +/- 16% (mean +/- SD). Euclidean distance analysis of measurements made on trypsin-digested BNC demonstrated only trace amounts of CS. For engineered cartilage, the CS content was significantly lower (15 +/- 5%), while the collagen content (73 +/- 6%) was significantly higher than biochemically determined values (CS 34%, collagen 5%, protein 61%). These differences are due to the fact that the dimethylmethylene blue assay overestimated the CS content of the tissue because it is not specific for CS, while the FTIR spectral imaging technique overestimated the collagen content because it lacks specificity for different proteins.

CONCLUSION

FTIR spectral imaging combines histology-like spatial localization with the quantitative capability of bulk chemical analysis. For molecules with a unique spectral signature, such as CS, the FTIR technique coupled with multivariate analysis can define a unique spatial distribution. However, for some applications, the lack of specificity of this technique for different types of proteins may be a limitation.

31P NMR spectroscopy of developing cartilage produced from chick chondrocytes in a hollow-fiber bioreactor

31P NMR was used to measure the concentrations and spin-lattice relaxation times of phosphorus-containing metabolites in neocartilage developing in an NMR-compatible hollow-fiber bioreactor over four weeks. Separate studies were performed for tissue developing from chondrocytes taken from the proximal and the distal sternum of the chick embryo. The metabolite ratio beta-ATP/Pi did not change significantly with development (proximal: beta-ATP/Pi = 0.38+/- 0.12 at one week, beta-ATP/Pi = 0.44+/-0.07 at four weeks, P< 0.63; distal: beta-ATP/Pi = 0.39+/-0.05 at one week, beta-ATP/Pi = 0.66+/- 0.26 at four weeks, P<0.28). ATP spin-lattice relaxation times were found to be comparable to those in muscle and brain tissue (proximal: T(1)(beta-ATP) = 0.5+/-0.06 sec at one week, T(1)(beta-ATP) = 0.4+/- 0.01 sec at four weeks; distal: T(1)(beta-ATP) = 0.3+/-0.12 sec at one week, T(1)(beta-ATP) = 0.4+/-0.04 sec at four weeks). A large increase in the spin-lattice relaxation time of inorganic phosphate, from 1.2+/-0.13 sec to 3.8+/-0.04 sec (P<0.0001) over four weeks of growth, was observed in tissue developing from chondrocytes harvested from the proximal sternum. No comparable increase in T(1)(Pi) was found in tissue developing from chondrocytes harvested from the distal portion of the sternum, which ossifies later in vivo.