Organization of the cerebellum in the pigeon (Columba livia): II. Projections of the cerebellar nuclei

The evolution of the dorsal thalamus of jawed vertebrates, including mammals: cladistic analysis and a new hypothesis

The evolution of the dorsal thalamus in various vertebrate lineages of jawed vertebrates has been an enigma, partly due to two prevalent misconceptions: the belief that the multitude of nuclei in the dorsal thalamus of mammals could be meaningfully compared neither with the relatively few nuclei in the dorsal thalamus of anamniotes nor with the intermediate number of dorsal thalamic nuclei of other amniotes and a definition of the dorsal thalamus that too narrowly focused on the features of the dorsal thalamus of mammals. The cladistic analysis carried out here allows us to recognize which features are plesiomorphic and which apomorphic for the dorsal thalamus of jawed vertebrates and to then reconstruct the major changes that have occurred in the dorsal thalamus over evolution. Embryological data examined in the context of Von Baerian theory (embryos of later-descendant species resemble the embryos of earlier-descendant species to the point of their divergence) supports a new 'Dual Elaboration Hypothesis' of dorsal thalamic evolution generated from this cladistic analysis. From the morphotype for an early stage in the embryological development of the dorsal thalamus of jawed vertebrates, the divergent, sequential stages of the development of the dorsal thalamus are derived for each major radiation and compared. The new hypothesis holds that the dorsal thalamus comprises two basic divisions--the collothalamus and the lemnothalamus--that receive their predominant input from the midbrain roof and (plesiomorphically) from lemniscal pathways, including the optic tract, respectively. Where present, the collothalamic, midbrain-sensory relay nuclei are homologous to each other in all vertebrate radiations as discrete nuclei. Within the lemnothalamus, the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus of mammals and the dorsal lateral optic nucleus of non-synapsid amniotes (diapsid reptiles, birds and turtles) are homologous as discrete nuclei; most or all of the ventral nuclear group of mammals is homologous as a field to the lemniscal somatosensory relay and motor feedback nuclei of non-synapsid amniotes; the anterior, intralaminar and medial nuclear groups of mammals are collectively homologous as a field to both the dorsomedial and dorsolateral (including perirotundal) nuclei of non-synapsid amniotes; the anterior, intralaminar, medial and ventral nuclear groups and the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus of mammals are collectively homologous as a field to the nucleus anterior of anamniotes, as are their homologues in non-synapsid amniotes. In the captorhinomorph ancestors of extant land vertebrates, both divisions of the dorsal thalamus were elaborated to some extent due to an increase in proliferation and lateral migration of neurons during development.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The evolution of the dorsal pallium in the telencephalon of amniotes: cladistic analysis and a new hypothesis

The large body of evidence that supports the hypothesis that the dorsal cortex and dorsal ventricular ridge of non-mammalian (non-synapsid) amniotes form the dorsal pallium and are homologous as a set of specified populations of cells to respective sets of cells in mammalian isocortex is reviewed. Several recently taken positions that oppose this hypothesis are examined and found to lack a solid foundation. A cladistic analysis of multiple features of the dorsal pallium in amniotes was carried out in order to obtain a morphotype for the common ancestral stock of all living amniotes, i.e., a captorhinomorph amniote. A previous cladistic analysis of the dorsal thalamus (Butler, A.B., The evolution of the dorsal thalamus of jawed vertebrates, including mammals: cladistic analysis and a new hypothesis, Brain Res. Rev., 19 (1994) 29-65; this issue, previous article) found that two fundamental divisions of the dorsal thalamus can be recognized--termed the lemnothalamus in reference to predominant lemniscal sensory input and the collothalamus in reference to predominant input from the midbrain roof. These two divisions are both elaborated in amniotes in that their volume is increased and their nuclei are laterally migrated in comparison with anamniotes. The present cladistic analysis found that two corresponding, fundamental divisions of the dorsal pallium were present in captorhinomorph amniotes and were expanded relative to their condition in anamniotes. Both the lemnothalamic medial pallial division and the collothalamic lateral pallial division were subsequently further markedly expanded in the synapsid line leading to mammals, along with correlated expansions of the lemnothalamus and collothalamus. Only the collothalamic lateral pallial division--along with the collothalamus--was subsequently further markedly expanded in the non-synapsid amniote line that gave rise to diapsid reptiles, birds and turtles. In the synapsid line leading to mammals, an increase in the degree of radial organization of both divisions of the dorsal pallium also occurred, resulting in an 'outside-in' migration pattern during development. The lemnothalamic medial division of the dorsal pallium has two parts. The medial part forms the subicular, cingulate, prefrontal, sensorimotor, and related cortices in mammals and the medial part of the dorsal cortex in non-synapsid amniotes. The lateral part forms striate cortex in mammals and the lateral part of dorsal cortex (or pallial thickening or visual Wulst) in non-synapsid amniotes. Specific fields within the collothalamic lateral division of the dorsal pallium form the extrastriate, auditory, secondary somatosensory, and related cortices in mammals and the visual, auditory, somatosensory, and related areas of the dorsal ventricular ridge in non-synapsid amniotes.

Direct and indirect "cortico"-rubral and rubro-cerebellar cortical projections in the pigeon

In birds the red nucleus is the most rostral cell group in the brain having projections to all levels of the spinal cord (Cabot et al., Prog. Brain Res., 57:79-108, 1982), but its sources of afferents are incompletely known. In order to determine these, a series retrograde and anterograde tracing experiments was carried out, largely with cholera toxin B-chain conjugated to horseradish peroxidase. The results show that a sparse and diffuse projection to the red nucleus arises from deep regions of the hyperstriatum accessorium (HA) of the anterior Wulst, and that a much more dense projection arises from the caudal part of the nucleus principalis precommissuralis and the medial part of the medial spiriform nucleus (SpMm). These last two sources were themselves shown to receive a substantial projection from HA of the anterior Wulst. The red nucleus was also shown to project upon the cerebellar cortex of lobule VI, and SpM upon the cerebellar cortex of lobules VI through IX (Karten and Finger, Brain Res., 102:335-338, 1976; Clarke, J. Comp. Neurol., 174:535-552, 1977). Double retrograde labelling experiments with fluorescein and rhodamine labelled latex microspheres injected into the cerebellar cortex and spinal cord showed that the rubrocerebellar cortical neurons are a different population from, although intermixed with, the rubrospinal neurons.

Organization of the cerebellum in the pigeon (Columba livia): III. Corticovestibular connections with eye and neck premotor areas

The connections of the cerebellar cortex with vestibular premotor neurons of the oculomotor and collimotor systems in the pigeon were delineated in experiments using WGA-HRP as an anterograde and retrograde tracer. Putative premotor neuron pools were identified by injections into the oculomotor (mIII) and trochlear nuclei (mIV) and into the most rostral portion of the cervical neck motor nucleus, nucleus supraspinalis (SSp). The retrograde data indicate that ipsilateral projections upon oculomotor neurons arise from the medial portions of the superior (VeS) and tangential (Ta) nuclei. Contralateral projections originate from the infracerebellar nucleus, the interstitial vestibular region including the main (lateral) portion of the tangential nucleus, and from the descending and medial vestibular nuclei (VeD, VeM). These projections were confirmed in anterograde studies that also defined the connections of these vestibular premotor regions with specific subnuclear divisions of the pigeon's "oculomotor" nuclei (mIII, mIV, mVI). The organization of projections from the vestibular nuclei to the pigeon's extraocular motoneurons is similar to that reported in mammals. Projections upon neck premotor neurons arise primarily from neurons in the interstitial region of the vestibular nuclear complex. After injections in SSp, retrogradely labeled neurons were found, contralaterally, in the lateral part of the tangential and superior vestibular nuclei and in the dorsolateral vestibular nucleus (VDL). Ipsilateral labeling was seen in the medial interstitial region (VeM, VeD, and medial Ta). These projections were confirmed in anterograde experiments. With the exception of VDL, vestibular nuclei projecting to neck motoneurons also project to extraocular motoneurons. Thus the infracerebellar nucleus projects exclusively, and the superior vestibular nucleus predominantly, upon oculomotor (mIII, mIV) nuclei; VDL projects predominantly upon the neck motor nucleus, whereas the interstitial vestibular regions (medial Ta, rostral VeD, intermediate VeM) project upon both collimotor and oculomotor neurons. The pattern of retrograde labeling seen in the cerebellar cortex after injections into vestibular premotor nuclei was used to define the projections of specific cerebellar cortical zones upon vestibular eye and neck premotor neurons. Corticovestibular projections upon these regions arise from the auricle and lateral unfoliated cortex, the posterior lobe components of cortical zones B and E, and from the vestibulocerebellum. Each of these cortical zones projects upon components of the vestibular nuclear complex, which are premotor to either oculomotor nuclei or collimotor nuclei. The hodological findings are related to the functional organization of the oculomotor and collimotor systems in the pigeon and compared with the mammalian data.

Organization of the cerebellum in the pigeon (Columba livia): I. Corticonuclear and corticovestibular connections

The projections of the cerebellar cortex upon the cerebellar nuclei and the vestibular complex of the pigeon have been delineated using WGA-HRP as an anterograde and retrograde tracer. Injections into individual cortical lobules (II-IXa) produce a pattern of ipsilateral terminal labeling of both the cerebellar and vestibular nuclei. The pattern of corticonuclear projections indicates both a rostrocaudal and a mediolateral organization with respect to the lobules and is consistent with a division of the cerebellar nuclei into a medial (CbM) and a lateral (CbL) nucleus. The retrograde experiments indicate that these nuclei receive projections, respectively, from Purkinje cells within medial (A) and lateral (C) longitudinal zones, which alternate with longitudinal zones (B, E) projecting upon the vestibular complex. Purkinje cells in (vestibulocerebellar) lobules IXb-X show only limited projections upon the cerebellar nuclei, but do project extensively upon the cerebellovestibular process (PCV), as well as upon the medial, superior, and descending vestibular nuclei. As the injection site shifts from medial to lateral, there is a corresponding shift in focus of the projection within PCV from areas bordering CbM to those abutting CbL. The topographic organization of corticovestibular projections is less clear-cut than those of the corticonuclear projections. Lobules II-X project upon the lateral vestibular nucleus (anterior lobe) or the dorsolateral vestibular nucleus (posterior lobe). These projections originate from either side of the lateral (C) zone. Projections originating from the medialmost (B) zone are interrupted in lobules VI and VII. The anterior and posterior portions of the lateralmost (E) zone overlap along lobules VI and VII. In addition, the E zone of the anterior lobe is the source of projections upon the medial, the descending, and the superior vestibular nuclei. Projections from the auricle and adjacent lateral unfoliated cortex (F zone) focus upon the infracerebellar nucleus, the medial tangential nucleus, and the medial division of the superior vestibular nucleus. The data suggest that the cerebellar cortex of the pigeon, like that of mammals, may be subdivided into a mediolaterally oriented series of longitudinal zones, with Purkinje cells in each zone projecting ipsilaterally to specific cerebellar nuclei or vestibular regions. For cortical regions exclusive of the auricle and lateral unfoliated cortex, three such zones (A, B, and C) are defined that are comparable in their efferent targets with the A, B, and C zones of mammals. There does not appear to be a D zone in the pigeon. The results are discussed in relation to comparative data on amphibians, reptiles, and mammals.