Bystander signaling between glioma cells and fibroblasts targeted with counted particles

Dilution of irradiated cell conditioned medium and the bystander effect

While nontargeted and low-dose effects such as the bystander effect are now accepted, the mechanisms underlying the response have yet to be elucidated. It has been shown that the transfer of irradiated cell conditioned medium (ICCM) can kill cells that are not directly irradiated; however, to date the effect of ICCM concentration on cell killing has not been reported. The occurrence of a bystander effect was determined by measuring cell survival after exposure to various ICCM dilutions, using the colony-forming assay, in cells of six human cell lines with varied bystander responses and tumor/ p53 status. Autologous ICCM transfer for these cell lines induced a bystander effect as reported previously. ICCM from these cell lines was transferred to cells of a common reporter cell line (HPV-G) to investigate whether the lack of an induced bystander effect was due to their inability to generate or to respond to a bystander signal(s). ICCM from cells of four cell lines induced a bystander effect in HPV-G reporter cells, confirming that signal production is a critical factor. A saturation response was observed when ICCM was diluted. Survival was found to increase linearly until a plateau was reached and the bystander effect was abolished at 2x dilution. The effect of ICCM from the different cell lines reached a plateau at different dilutions, which were found to correlate with the cell line's radiosensitivity.

Low dose radiation and intercellular induction of apoptosis: potential implications for the control of oncogenesis

PURPOSE

This review is focused on the potential impact of low dose radiation effects on intercellular induction of apoptosis and the underlying reactive-oxygen species (ROS)-mediated signaling pathways.

RESULTS

Transformed cells are subject to ROS-mediated apoptosis induction by non-transformed cells ('intercellular induction of apoptosis') and by ROS-mediated autocrine self-destruction. Sensitivity to intercellular induction of apoptosis and autocrine self-destruction are strictly correlated to the expression of the transformed state. Extracellular superoxide anions generated by transformed target cells drive the selectivity and sensitivity of this signaling system which is based on four different signaling pathways. Low dose irradiation of non-transformed cells enhances intercellular induction of apoptosis in transformed cells. This process is controlled by TGF-beta and seems to depend on the induction of peroxidase release. In addition, low dose radiation enhances superoxide anion generation of transformed target cells.

CONCLUSIONS

Low dose radiation-triggered enhancement of intercellular induction of apoptosis and autocrine self-destruction might represent a potential control system during carcinogenesis. It might be the underlying mechanism for the well-known inhibitory effect of low dose radiation on detectable transformation events. However, modifications of the complex intercellular ROS-based signaling system may also lead to configurations in which low dose radiation attenuates ROS-mediated apoptosis induction.

Signaling factors for irradiated glioma cells induced bystander responses in fibroblasts

The aim of this study was to investigate the signaling factor and its pathway involved in the targeted irradiation-induced bystander response from glioblastoma cells to primary fibroblasts. After co-culturing with a glioblastoma T98G population where a fraction of cells had been individually irradiated with a precise number of helium particles, additional micronucleus (MN) were induced in the non-irradiated human fibroblasts AG01522 cells and its yield was independent of irradiation dose. This bystander MN induction was eliminated by treating the cells with either aminoguanidine (AG), an iNOS inhibitor, or anti-transforming growth factor-beta1 (anti-TGF-beta1). In addition, TGF-beta1 could be released from irradiated T98G cells but this release was inhibited by AG. In consistent, TGF-beta1 could also be induced from T98G cells treated with diethylamine nitric oxide (DEANO), a donor of nitric oxide (NO). Moreover, the effect of TGF-beta1 on bystander AG01522 cells was investigated. It was found that reactive oxygen species (ROS) and MN were induced in AG01522 cells after TGF-beta1 treatment. Our results indicate that, downstream of NO, TGF-beta1 plays an important role in the targeted T98G cells induced bystander response to AG0 cells by further causing DNA damage in vicinal fibroblasts through a ROS related pathway. This study may have implications for properly evaluating the secondary effects of radiotherapy.

Effect of dose rate on the radiation-induced bystander response

Radiation-induced biological bystander effects have become a well-established phenomenon associated with the interaction of radiation with cells. These so-called bystander effects have been seen across a variety of end points for both high and low linear energy transfer (LET) radiations, utilizing a variety of dose rates and radiation sources. In this study, the effect of dose rate and different low LET sources on the bystander cell survival fraction (SF) was examined. The cell line investigated was the human keratinocyte HPV-G. The bystander response was measured via clonogenic assay after medium transfer protocol. Cells were irradiated using (60)Co gamma-rays and 20 MeV electrons at doses of 0.5, 5 and 10 Gy with varying dose rates. Both gamma and electron irradiation decreased recipient SF at 0.5 Gy and 5 Gy, respectively. Subsequent recovery of the SF to control levels for 10 Gy was observed. There was no dose rate dependence for (60)Co irradiation. A significant difference in the survival fraction was observed for electron irradiation at 10 Gy and a high dose rate. Furthermore, survival fractions were compared between (60)Co and 20 MeV electron irradiations. This showed a significant increase in the survival fraction 'recovery' at 10 Gy for a (60)Co dose rate of 1.1 Gy min(-1) compared to 20 MeV electrons at 1.0 Gy min(-1). No such difference was observed when comparing at higher dose rates. Lastly, increases in survival fraction at 10 Gy were abolished and the SF decreased by the plating of increased numbers of recipient cells. Such evidence may help gain insight into the nature and mechanism(s) surrounding bystander signal production, how these phenomena are tested and their eventual application in a clinical setting.

Elevated sodium chloride concentrations enhance the bystander effects induced by low dose alpha-particle irradiation

Previous studies have shown that high NaCl can be genotoxic, either alone or combined with irradiation. However, little is known about the relationship between environmental NaCl at elevated conditions and radiation-induced bystander effects (RIBE). RIBE, which has been considered as non-targeted bystander responses, has been demonstrated to occur widely in various cell lines. In the present study, RIBE under the elevated NaCl culture condition was assessed in AG 1522 cells by both the induction of gamma-H2AX, a reliable marker of DNA double-strand break (DSB) for the early process (<1h post irradiation), and the generation of micronuclei (MN), a sensitive marker for relative long process of RIBE. Our results showed that in the absence of irradiation, NaCl at elevated concentration such as 8.0, 9.0 and 10.0g/L did not significantly increase the frequency of gamma-H2AX foci-positive cells and the number of foci per positive cell comparing with that NaCl at a normal concentration (6.8g/L). However, with 0.2cGy alpha-particle irradiation, the induced fraction of gamma-H2AX foci-positive cells and the number of induced gamma-H2AX foci per positive cell were significantly increased in both irradiated and adjacent non-irradiated regions. Similarly, the induction of MN by 0.2cGy alpha-particle irradiation also increased with the elevated NaCl concentrations. With N(G)-methyl-l-arginine, an inhibitor of nitric oxide synthase, the induced fraction of foci-positive cells was effectively inhibited both in 0.2cGy alpha-particle irradiated and adjacent non-irradiated regions under either normal or elevated NaCl conditions. These results suggested that the cultures with elevated NaCl medium magnified the damage effects induced by the low dose alpha-particle irradiation and nitric oxide generated by irradiation was also very important in this process.

Bystander effects of ionizing radiation can be modulated by signaling amines

Actual risk and risk management of exposure to ionizing radiation are among the most controversial areas in environmental health protection. Recent developments in radiobiology especially characterization of bystander effects have called into question established dogmas and are thought to cast doubt on the scientific basis of the risk assessment framework, leading to uncertainty for regulators and concern among affected populations. In this paper we test the hypothesis that small signaling molecules widely used throughout the animal kingdom for signaling stress or environmental change, such as 5-Hydroxytryptamine (5-HT, serotonin), l-DOPA, glycine or nicotine are involved in bystander signaling processes following ionizing radiation exposure. We report data which suggest that nano to micromolar concentrations of these agents can modulate bystander-induced cell death. Depletion of 5-HT present in tissue culture medium, occurred following irradiation of cells. This suggested that 5-HT might be bound by membrane receptors after irradiation. Expression of 5-HT type 3 receptors which are Ca(2+) ion channels was confirmed in the cells using immunocytochemistry and receptor expression could be increased using radiation or 5-HT exposure. Zofran and Kitryl, inhibitors of 5-HT type 3 receptors, and reserpine a generic serotonin antagonist block the bystander effect induced by radiation or by serotonin. The results may be important for the mechanistic understanding of how low doses of radiation interact with cells to produce biological effects.

Role of TGF-beta1 and nitric oxide in the bystander response of irradiated glioma cells

The radiation-induced bystander effect (RIBE) increases the probability of cellular response and therefore has important implications for cancer risk assessment following low-dose irradiation and for the likelihood of secondary cancers after radiotherapy. However, our knowledge of bystander signaling factors, especially those having long half-lives, is still limited. The present study found that, when a fraction of cells within a glioblastoma population were individually irradiated with helium ions from a particle microbeam, the yield of micronuclei (MN) in the nontargeted cells was increased, but these bystander MN were eliminated by treating the cells with either aminoguanidine (an inhibitor of inducible nitric oxide (NO) synthase) or anti-transforming growth factor beta1 (anti-TGF-beta1), indicating that NO and TGF-beta1 are involved in the RIBE. Intracellular NO was detected in the bystander cells, and additional TGF-beta1 was detected in the medium from irradiated T98G cells, but it was diminished by aminoguanidine. Consistent with this, an NO donor, diethylamine nitric oxide (DEANO), induced TGF-beta1 generation in T98G cells. Conversely, treatment of cells with recombinant TGF-beta1 could also induce NO and MN in T98G cells. Treatment of T98G cells with anti-TGF-beta1 inhibited the NO production when only 1% of cells were targeted, but not when 100% of cells were targeted. Our results indicate that, downstream of radiation-induced NO, TGF-beta1 can be released from targeted T98G cells and plays a key role as a signaling factor in the RIBE by further inducing free radicals and DNA damage in the nontargeted bystander cells.

Bystander killing of breast cancer MCF-7 cells by MDA-MB-231 cells exposed to 5-fluorouracil is mediated via Fas

The major drawback with cancer therapy is the development of resistant cells within tumors due to their heterogeneous nature and due to inadequate drug delivery during chemotherapy. Therefore, the propagation of injury ("bystander effect" (BE)) from directly damaged cells to other cells may have great implications in cancer chemotherapy. The general advantage of the bystander cell killing phenomenon is the large therapeutic index that can be achieved. Experiments suggest that this phenomenon is detected in radiation therapy as well as in gene therapy in conjunction with chemotherapy. In the present study, we developed an original in vitro model dedicated to the exploration of bystander cytotoxicity induced during breast carcinoma chemotherapy. In brief, we investigated this perpetuation of injury on untreated bystander MCF-7 breast cancer cells which were coplated with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU)-treated MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells. To achieve this goal, a specific in vitro coculture model which involved mixing of aggressive MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells with enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) expressing stable clone of non-metastatic MCF-7 breast cancer cells (MCF-EGFP), was used. A bystander killing effect was observed in MCF-EGFP cells cocultured with MDA-MB-231 cells pretreated with 5-FU. The striking decrease in MCF-EGFP cells, as detected by assaying for total GFP intensity, is mediated by activation of Fas/FasL system. The implication of Fas in MCF-EGFP cell death was confirmed by using antagonistic anti-FasL antibody that reverses bystander cell death by blocking FasL on MDA-MB-231 cells. In addition, inhibition of CD95/Fas receptor on the cell surface of MCF-EGFP cells by treatment with Pifithrin-alpha, a p53 specific transactivation inhibitor, partially abrogated the sensitivity of bystander MCF-EGFP cells. Our data, therefore, demonstrates that the Fas/FasL system could be considered as a new determinant for chemotherapy-induced bystander cell death in breast cancers.

Intestinal epithelial cell dysfunction is mediated by an endothelial-specific radiation-induced bystander effect

The response of endothelial cells (EC) to high radiation doses leads to damage of normal tissue or tumor. The precise mechanisms of the endothelial-tissue linkage are still largely unknown. We investigated the possible involvement of a bystander effect, secondary to endothelial damage, in tissue response to radiation. Proliferating human intestinal epithelial T84 cells were grown in a non-contact co-culture with confluent primary human microvascular EC (HMVEC-L). The bystander response in unirradiated T84 cells co-cultured with irradiated EC was studied by evaluating cell growth, cell death and epithelial morphology. Twenty-four hours after exposure of EC to 15 Gy, unirradiated T84 cells showed a decreased cell number (29%) and percentage in mitosis (66%) as well as increased apoptosis (1.5-fold) and cell surface area (1.5-fold), highlighting the involvement of bystander effects on T84 cells after irradiation of EC. Furthermore, the responses of T84 cells were amplified when EC and T84 cells were irradiated together, indicating that the bystander response in T84 cells adds further to direct radiation damage. As opposed to direct irradiation, the T84 cell bystander response did not involve the cell cycle-related protein p21(Waf1) (CDKN1A) and pro-apoptosis protein BAX. The bystander effect was specific to EC since the irradiation of human colon fibroblasts did not induce bystander responses in unirradiated T84 cells. These results strengthen previous in vivo evidence of the role of EC in tissue damage by radiation. In addition, this study provides a suitable and useful model to identify soluble factors involved in bystander effects secondary to endothelial damage. Modulating such factors may have important clinical implications.

Bystander effects induced by serum from survivors of the Chernobyl accident

OBJECTIVE

To examine blood samples from survivors of the Chernobyl accident for evidence of persistent bystander factors or clastogenic factors and to look at the ability of melanin and melatonin, which are radioprotective agents capable of preventing bystander effects in cell culture to prevent toxic effects.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Serum was extracted from blood samples of control and test groups and added to human immortalized reporter cells, used in our laboratories for identification of bystander effects. These were then analyzed for evidence of micronucleus formation and viability.

RESULTS

Micronuclei were significantly elevated in cells exposed to serum samples from Chernobyl liquidators and from workers in Gomel. Viability of cells treated with these sera was correspondingly reduced.

CONCLUSION

Twenty years after the accident at the Chernobyl Plant, these is still evidence of the presence of clastogenic or bystander factors in the serum of populations exposed to radiation from the reactor.

Intercellular and intracellular signaling pathways mediating ionizing radiation-induced bystander effects

A rapidly growing body of experimental evidence indicates that ionizing radiation induces biological effects in non-irradiated bystander cells that have received signals from adjacent or distant irradiated cells. This phenomenon, which has been termed the ionizing radiation-induced bystander effect, challenges the long-standing paradigm that radiation traversal through the nucleus of a cell is a prerequisite to elicit genetic damage or a biological response. Bystander effects have been observed in a number of experimental systems, and cells whose nucleus or cytoplasm is irradiated exert bystander responses. Bystander cells manifest a multitude of biological consequences, such as genetic and epigenetic changes, alterations in gene expression, activation of signal transduction pathways, and delayed effects in their progeny. Several mediating mechanisms have been proposed. These involve gap junction-mediated intercellular communication, secreted soluble factors, oxidative metabolism, plasma membrane-bound lipid rafts, and calcium fluxes. This paper reviews briefly the current knowledge of the bystander effect with a focus on proposed mechanisms. The potential benefit of bystander effects to cancer radiotherapy will also be discussed.

Multiple stressor effects of radiation and metals in salmon (Salmo salar)

These experiments were designed to look at the cellular effects in key organs in Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) after exposure in vivo to radiation and subtoxic levels of aluminum (Al) and cadmium (Cd), alone or in combination. Salmon (25g) were exposed to a single 0.5Gy dose of gamma-irradiation in water containing Cd, Al or Cd+Al. Three fish per group were sacrificed after 1h and the liver, pronephros, fin and gill of each was dissected. Small explants of each tissue were set up. After 2 days, the culture medium was harvested and filtered then placed on a reporter cell line for determination of stress signal activity (bystander effects). Radiation in combination with Cd and/or Al, caused bystander effects in tissues harvested from in vivo exposed salmon. The effects vary between different organs and are not consistently additive or synergistic for a given treatment. Tissue type appears to be critical. Liver cultures produce a toxic factor which is lethal to reporter cells, and therefore no liver data could be obtained. It is hoped that this stress signal response will prove to be a useful indicator of environmental stress in species inhabiting aquatic ecosystems.

Radiation-induced bystander effects in malignant trophoblast cells are independent from gap junctional communication

It is controversially discussed that irradiation induces bystander effects via gap junction channels and/or diffusible cellular factors such as nitric oxide or cytokines excreted from the cells into the environment. But up to now the molecular mechanism leading to a bystander response is not well understood. To discriminate between both mechanisms of bystander response, (i) mediated by gap junctional communication and/or (ii) mediated by diffusible molecules, we used non-communicating Jeg3 malignant trophoblast cells transfected with inducible gap junction proteins, connexin43 and connexin26, respectively, based on the Tet-On system. We co-cultivated X-ray irradiated and non-irradiated bystander Jeg3 cells for 4 h, separated both cell populations by flow cytometry and evaluated the expression of activated p53 by Western blot analysis. The experimental design was proven with communicating versus non-communicating Jeg3 cells. Interestingly, our results revealed a bystander effect which was independent from gap junctional communication properties and the connexin isoform expressed. Therefore, it seems more likely that the bystander effect is not mediated via gap junction channels but rather by paracrine mechanisms via excreted molecules in Jeg3 cells.

Radiation-induced bystander effects and adaptive response in murine lymphocytes

PURPOSE

To study the bystander effects of gamma-radiation in murine lymphocytes using irradiated conditioned medium (ICM) generated from irradiated lymphocytes.

METHODS

Proliferation response of unirradiated lymphocytes to mitogen concanavalin A (con A) in presence of ICM, collected from gamma-irradiated lymphocytes (60Co source; 0.35 Gy/min; 0.1-1 Gy), was studied by 3H-thymidine incorporation and also by dye dilution using carboxyfluorescein succinimidyl ester (CFSE). Expression of proliferation markers, interleukin 2 receptor alpha chain (CD25) and cyclin D in ICM treated lymphocytes was analyzed by labeling with specific antibodies. Intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS) and apoptosis were estimated by flow cytometry using dichlorodihydrofluorescein diacetate (H2DCFDA) and propidium iodide, respectively. Nitric oxide (NO) was measured using Griess reagent.

RESULTS

Proliferation response to con A in unirradiated lymphocytes was enhanced in the presence of ICM with maximum enhancement observed in the presence of 0.5 Gy ICM. Augmentation of proliferation in the presence of ICM was accompanied by an increase in CD25 and cyclin D expression, enhanced ROS and NO generation. ICM pretreated lymphocytes showed adaptive response to radiation which was not abrogated by wortmannin, a phosphatidyl inositol 3-kinase (PI3K) inhibitor.

CONCLUSION

Soluble factors released from irradiated lymphocytes initiate a signaling cascade in unirradiated lymphocytes resulting in increased response to mitogen and radioresistance which may have an important role in radiation-induced immunomodulation.

Communication of radiation-induced stress or bystander signals between fish in vivo

We report data in this paper suggesting that fish irradiated to 0.5 Gy total body dose can release factors into the water that signal other unexposed fish and cause induction of bystander effects expressed as increased cell death in a reporter system. Radiation-induced bystander effects, resulting in the appearance of radiation damage or induction of typical radiation responses in unirradiated cells and tissues are now an established consequence of exposure to low doses of ionizing radiation, however little work has been done in vivo or in species other than humans or mice. In these experiments rainbow trout were irradiated and then paired with unirradiated fish for two hours. Additionally, unirradiated fish were placed in water which had previously been used to hold irradiated fish for 2 h. Sham-irradiated fish and absolute control fish were also examined all using blind protocols. Following a two h incubation period, at these various exposure regimes, the fish were killed by a blow to the head and dissected. Five organs were removed from each fish and tissue explants were cultured using an established technique. After 2 days, the culture medium was harvested and used in a reporter assay to determine whether a bystander effect had been induced. The explants were cultured on in Clonetics growth medium for a further 14 days then fixed for assay of radiation response proteins. The responses varied according to the cell type in the original explants, with the gill and fin showing the most pronounced response. The results suggest that communication signals leading to a typical radiation response can be passed between fish and seem to involve secretion of a chemical messenger into the water.

ATR-dependent radiation-induced γH2AX foci in bystander primary human astrocytes and glioma cells

Radiotherapy is an important treatment for patients suffering from high-grade malignant gliomas. Non-targeted (bystander) effects may influence these cells' response to radiation and the investigation of these effects may therefore provide new insights into mechanisms of radiosensitivity and responses to radiotherapy as well as define new targets for therapeutic approaches. Normal primary human astrocytes (NHA) and T98G glioma cells were irradiated with helium ions using the Gray Cancer Institute microbeam facility targeting individual cells. Irradiated NHA and T98G glioma cells generated signals that induced gammaH2AX foci in neighbouring non-targeted bystander cells up to 48 h after irradiation. gammaH2AX bystander foci were also observed in co-cultures targeting either NHA or T98G cells and in medium transfer experiments. Dimethyl sulphoxide, Filipin and anti-transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta 1 could suppress gammaH2AX foci in bystander cells, confirming that reactive oxygen species (ROS) and membrane-mediated signals are involved in the bystander signalling pathways. Also, TGF-beta 1 induced gammaH2AX in an ROS-dependent manner similar to bystander foci. ROS and membrane signalling-dependent differences in bystander foci induction between T98G glioma cells and normal human astrocytes have been observed. Inhibition of ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) protein and DNA-PK could not suppress the induction of bystander gammaH2AX foci whereas the mutation of ATM- and rad3-related (ATR) abrogated bystander foci induction. Furthermore, ATR-dependent bystander foci induction was restricted to S-phase cells. These observations may provide additional therapeutic targets for the exploitation of the bystander effect.

Gamma ray-induced bystander effect in tumour glioblastoma cells: a specific study on cell survival, cytokine release and cytokine receptors

Recent experimental evidence has challenged the paradigm according to which radiation traversal through the nucleus of a cell is a prerequisite for producing genetic changes or biological responses. Thus, unexposed cells in the vicinity of directly irradiated cells or recipient cells of medium from irradiated cultures can also be affected. The aim of the present study was to evaluate, by means of the medium transfer technique, whether interleukin-8 and its receptor (CXCR1) may play a role in the bystander effect after gamma irradiation of T98G cells in vitro. In fact the cell specificity in inducing the bystander effect and in receiving the secreted signals that has been described suggests that not only the ability to release the cytokines but also the receptor profiles are likely to modulate the cell responses and the final outcome. The dose and time dependence of the cytokine release into the medium, quantified using an enzyme linked immunosorbent assay, showed that radiation causes alteration in the release of interleukin-8 from exposed cells in a dose-independent but time-dependent manner. The relative receptor expression was also affected in exposed and bystander cells.

Modelling radiation-induced bystander effect and cellular communication

In the last 10 years evidence has accumulated on the so-called radiation-induced 'non-targeted effects' and in particular on bystander effects, consisting of damage induction in non-irradiated cells most likely following the release of soluble factors by the irradiated ones. These phenomena were observed for different biological endpoints, both lethal and non-lethal for the cell. Although the underlying mechanisms are largely unknown, it is now widely recognised that two types of cellular communication (i.e. via gap junctions and/or release of molecular messengers into the extracellular environment) play a pivotal role. Furthermore, the effects can be significantly modulated by parameters such as cell type and cell-cycle stage, cell density, time after irradiation etc. Theoretical models and simulation codes can be of help to improve our knowledge of the mechanisms, as well as to investigate the possible role of these effects in determining deviations from the linear relationship between dose and risk which is generally applied in radiation protection. In this paper three models, including an approach under development at the University of Pavia, will be presented in detail. The focus will be on the various adopted assumptions, together with their implications in terms of non-targeted radiobiological damage and, more generally, low-dose radiation risk. Comparisons with experimental data will also be discussed.