New reactions of the ribosomal RNA precursor of Tetrahymena and the mechanism of self-splicing

Deletion of P9 and stem-loop structures downstream from the catalytic core affects both 5' and 3' splicing activities in a group-I intron

The P9 stem-loop is one of the conserved structural elements found in all group-I introns. Using two deletion mutants in this region of the Tetrahymena thermophilia large ribosomal subunit intron, we show that removal of the P9 element, either alone, or together with the non-conserved downstream P9.1 and P9.2 elements, results in an intron incapable of the first step of the splicing reaction at a low concentration of Mg2+. The mutant introns also require high concentrations of Mg2+ for the second step in splicing, as well as hydrolysis reactions, suggesting that P9, as well as P9.1 and P9.2, are important structural elements in the final folded form of the intron. In addition, RNase-T1-mediated-structure-probing experiments demonstrated that the loss of P9, P9.1 and P9.2 changes the structural context of the region binding the 5' splice site. The deletions lead to less efficient recognition of the 3' splice site and an accumulation of unligated exons. These observations support the view that the P9, P9.1 and P9.2 stem-loops play an important role in the binding of the 3' splice site.

Evolutionary optimization of the catalytic properties of a DNA-cleaving ribozyme

In a previous study [Beaudry, A. A., & Joyce, G. F. (1992) Science 257, 635-641], an in vitro evolution procedure was used to obtain variants of the Tetrahymena ribozyme with 100-fold improved ability to cleave a target single-stranded DNA under physiologic conditions. Here we report continuation of the in vitro evolution process to achieve 10(5)-fold overall improvement in DNA-cleavage activity. In addition, we demonstrate that, by appropriate manipulation of the selection constraints, one can optimize specific catalytic properties of the evolved ribozymes. We first reduced the concentration of the DNA substrate 50-fold to favor ribozymes with improved substrate binding affinity. We then reduced the reaction time 12-fold to favor ribozymes with improved catalytic rate. In both cases, the evolving population responded as expected, first improving substrate binding 25-fold, and then improving catalytic rate about 50-fold. The population of ribozymes has undergone 27 successive generations of in vitro evolution, resulting in, on average, 17 mutations relative to the wild type that are responsible for the improved DNA-cleavage activity.

A tertiary interaction in the Tetrahymena intron contributes to selection of the 5' splice site

The utilization of cryptic splice sites has been observed in a number of RNA splicing reactions. In the self-splicing group I intron of Tetrahymena thermophila, point mutations of either A57 or A95 promote cleavage at two sites other than the normal 5' splice site, suggesting that these nucleotides are involved in a common tertiary interaction. These results are unusual since A57 and A95 are neither at nor near the 5' splice site in the sequence or secondary structure. Cleavage at the alternative sites appears to occur by intron cyclization, a reaction with well-established structural and mechanistic similarities to the first step of RNA self-splicing. Alternative docking of P1 (the helix containing the 5' splice site paired to the internal guide sequence of the intron) into the catalytic core accounts for cleavage at the cryptic reaction sites. We propose that the A57/A95 interaction, along with an element implicated previously (J1/2), provide structural connectivity from the reaction site in P1 to the catalytic core of the Tetrahymena intron. It seems likely that RNA splicing in general will require such tertiary interactions to position RNA helices.

Synthesis of circular RNA in bacteria and yeast using RNA cyclase ribozymes derived from a group I intron of phage T4

Studies on the function of circular RNA and RNA topology in vivo have been limited by the difficulty in expressing circular RNA of desired sequence. To overcome this, the group I intron from the phage T4 td gene was split in a peripheral loop (L6a) and rearranged so that the 3' half intron and 3' splice site are upstream and a 5' splice site and 5' half intron are downstream of a single exon. The group I splicing reactions excise the internal exon RNA as a circle (RNA cyclase ribozyme activity). We show that foreign sequences can be placed in the exon and made circular in vitro. Expression of such constructs (RNA cyclase ribozymes) in Escherichia coli and yeast results in the accumulation of circular RNA in these organisms. In yeast, RNA cyclase ribozymes can be expressed from a regulated promoter like an mRNA, containing 5' leader and 3' trailer regions, and a nuclear pre-mRNA intron. RNA cyclase ribozymes have broad application to questions of RNA structure and function including end requirements for RNA transport or function, RNA topology, efficacy of antisense or ribozyme gene control elements, and the biosynthesis of extremely long polypeptides.

Footprinting the sites of interaction of antibiotics with catalytic group I intron RNA

Aminoglycoside inhibitors of translation have been shown previously to inhibit in vitro self-splicing by group I introns. Chemical probing of the phage T4-derived sunY intron shows that neomycin, streptomycin, and related antibiotics protected the N-7 position of G96, a universally conserved guanine in the binding site for the guanosine cofactor in the splicing reaction. The antibiotics also disrupted structural contacts that have been proposed to bring the 5' cleavage site of the intron into proximity to the catalytic core. In contrast, the strictly competitive inhibitors deoxyguanosine and arginine protected only the N-7 position of G96. Parallels between these results and previously observed protection of 16S ribosomal RNA by aminoglycosides raise the possibility that group I intron splicing and transfer RNA selection by ribosomes involve similar RNA structural motifs.

Evidence for an essential non-Watson-Crick interaction between the first and last nucleotides of a nuclear pre-mRNA intron

Nuclear pre-messenger RNA splicing requires the action of five small nuclear (sn) RNAs, U1, U2, U4, U5 and U6, and more than 50 proteins. The mechanistic similarity of nuclear pre-mRNA splicing and group II self-splicing suggests that many of the central processes of nuclear pre-mRNA splicing are based on RNA-RNA interaction. To understand the mechanism of pre-mRNA splicing, the interactions, and their temporal relationships, that occur between the snRNAs and the pre-mRNA during splicing must be identified. Several snRNA-snRNA and snRNA-intron interactions have been demonstrated but the putative RNA-based interactions that recognize the AG dinucleotide at the 3' splice site during 3' cleavage and exon ligation are unknown. We report here the reciprocal suppression between 5' and 3' splice site mutations in the yeast actin intron, and propose that the 3' splice site is positioned for 3' cleavage and exon ligation, at least in part, through a non-Watson-Crick interaction between the guanosines at the 5' and 3' splice sites.

Mutations at the guanosine-binding site of the Tetrahymena ribozyme also affect site-specific hydrolysis

Self-splicing group I introns use guanosine as a nucleophile to cleave the 5' splice site. The guanosine-binding site has been localized to the G264-C311 base pair of the Tetrahymena intron on the basis of analysis of mutations that change the specificity of the nucleophile from G (guanosine) to 2AP (2-aminopurine ribonucleoside) (F. Michel et al. (1989) Nature 342, 391-395). We studied the effect of these mutations (G-U, A-C and A-U replacing G264-C311) in the L-21 ScaI version of the Tetrahymena ribozyme. In this enzymatic system (kcat/Km)G monitors the cleavage step. This kinetic parameter decreased by at least 5 x 10(3) when the G264-C311 base pair was mutated to an A-U pair, while (kcat/Km)2AP increased at least 40-fold. This amounted to an overall switch in specificity of at least 2 x 10(5). The nucleophile specificity (G > 2AP for the G-C and G-U pairs, 2AP > G for the A-U and A-C pairs) was consistent with the proposed hydrogen bond between the nucleotide at position 264 and N1 of the nucleophile. Unexpectedly, the A-U and A-C mutants showed a decrease of an order of magnitude in the rate of ribozyme-catalyzed hydrolysis of RNA, in which H2O or OH- replaces G as the nucleophile, whereas the G-U mutant showed a decrease of only 2-fold. The low hydrolysis rates were not restored by raising the Mg2+ concentration or lowering the temperature. In addition, the mutant ribozymes exhibited a pattern of cleavage by Fe(II)-EDTA indistinguishable from that of the wild type, and the [Mg2+]1/2 for folding of the A-U mutant ribozyme was the same as that of the wild type. Therefore the guanosine-binding site mutations do not appear to have a major effect on RNA folding or stability. Because changing G264 affects the hydrolysis reaction without perturbing the global folding of the RNA, we conclude that the catalytic role of this conserved nucleotide is not limited to guanosine binding.

A phosphorothioate at the 3' splice-site inhibits the second splicing step in a group I intron

RNA polymerases can synthesize RNA containing phosphorothioate linkages in which a sulfur replaces one of the nonbridging oxygens. Only the Rp isomer is generated during transcription. A Rp phosphorothioate at the 5' splice-site of the Tetrahymena group I intron does not inhibit splicing (McSwiggen, J.A. and Cech, T.R. (1989) Science 244, 679). Transcription of mutants in which the first base of the 3' exon, U+1, was mutated to C or G, in the presence, respectively, of either cytosine or guanosine thiotriphosphate, introduced a phosphorothioate at the 3' splice-site. In both cases exon ligation was blocked. In the phosphorothioate substituted U+1G mutant, a new 3' splice-site was selected one base downstream of the correct site; despite the fact that the correct site was selected with very high fidelity in unsubstituted RNA. In contrast, the exon ligation reaction was successfully performed in reverse using unsubstituted intron RNA and ligated exons containing an Rp phosphorothioate at the exon junction site. Chirality was reversed during transesterification as in 5' splice-site cleavage (vide supra). This suggests that one non-bridging oxygen is particularly crucial for both splicing reactions.

Analysis of the role of phosphate oxygens in the group I intron from Tetrahymena

We have developed a quantitative substitution interference technique to examine the role of Pro-Rp oxygens in the phosphodiester backbone of RNA, using phosphorothioates as a structural probe. This approach is generally applicable to any reaction involving RNA in which the precursor and reaction products can be separated. We have applied the technique to identity structural requirements in the group I intron from Tetrahymena thermophila for catalysis of hydrolysis at the 3' splice site; 44 phosphate oxygens are important in 3' splice site hydrolysis. These include four or five oxygens previously observed to be important in exon ligation. Although phosphate oxygens having a functional significance can be found throughout the intron, the strongest phosphorothioate effects are closely associated with positions in the highly conserved intron core, which are likely to be involved in tertiary interactions, substrate recognition and catalysis.

A region of group I introns that contains universally conserved residues but is not essential for self-splicing

The catalytic core of the self-splicing group I intron RNAs is composed of six paired regions together with their connecting sequences; these are thought to form two elongated domains, with paired regions P5, P4, and P6 aligned along one axis and P8, P3, and P7 along the other. Most of the very highly conserved residues of the group I introns lie in or near P7, but two occur in L4, the internal loop connecting P4 and P5. It is generally believed that such bases are conserved because they are essential for splicing. Mutants were created in a member of each of the two major subclasses of group I introns, in which P5, L4, and the distal portion of P4 were deleted. Splicing activity was still detected in these mutants, albeit substantially weakened; splicing was accurate and occurred by the normal group I mechanism, with addition of a guanosine molecule to the intron. Thus the deleted region, containing two universally conserved bases, is not essential but facilitates splicing. Another reaction characteristic of group I introns, hydrolysis of the 3' splice site, was less severely affected by the deletions. The results are discussed in terms of the prevailing three-dimensional model for the core structure of the group I introns.

Group I permuted intron-exon (PIE) sequences self-splice to produce circular exons

Circularly permuted group I intron precursor RNAs, containing end-to-end fused exons which interrupt half-intron sequences, were generated and tested for self-splicing activity. An autocatalytic RNA can form when the primary order of essential intron sequence elements, splice sites, and exons are permuted in this manner. Covalent attachment of guanosine to the 5' half-intron product, and accurate exon ligation indicated that the mechanism and specificity of splicing were not altered. However, because the exons were fused and the order of the splice sites reversed, splicing released the fused-exon as a circle. With this arrangement of splice sites, circular exon production was a prediction of the group I splicing mechanism. Circular RNAs have properties that would make them attractive for certain studies of RNA structure and function. Reversal of splice site sequences in a context that allows splicing, such as those generated by circularly permuted group I introns, could be used to generate short defined sequences of circular RNA in vitro and perhaps in vivo.

Exon sequences distant from the splice junction are required for efficient self-splicing of the Tetrahymena IVS

The presence of a natural rRNA secondary structure element immediately preceding the 5' splice site of the Tetrahymena IVS can inhibit self-splicing by competing with base pairing between the 5' exon and the guide sequence of the IVS (P1). Formation of this alternative hairpin is preferred in short precursor RNAs, and results in loss of G-addition to the 5' splice site. Pre-rRNAs which contain longer exons of ribosomal sequence, however, splice rapidly. As many as 146 nucleotides of the 5' exon and 86 nucleotides of the 3' exon are required for efficient self-splicing of Tetrahymena precursors. The presence of nucleotides distant from the 5' splice site apparently alters the equilibrium between the alternative hairpins, and promotes formation of active precursors. This effect is dependent on the specific sequences of the ribosomal pre-RNA, since point mutations within this region reduce the rate of splicing as much as 50-fold. This system provides an opportunity to study the way in which long-range interactions can influence splice site selection in a highly structured RNA.

Activation of the catalytic core of a group I intron by a remote 3' splice junction

Over 1000 nucleotides may separate the ribozyme core of some group I introns from their 3' splice junctions. Using the sunY intron of bacteriophage T4 as a model system, we have investigated the mechanisms by which proximal splicing events are suppressed in vitro, as well as in vivo. Exon ligation as well as cleavage at the 5' splice site are shown to require long-range pairing between one of the peripheral components of the ribozyme core and some of the nucleotides preceding the authentic 3' splice junction. Consistent with our three-dimensional modeling of the entire sunY ribozyme, we propose that this novel interaction is necessary to drive 5' exon-core transcripts into an active conformation. A requirement for additional stabilizing interactions, either RNA-based or mediated by proteins, appears to be a general feature of group I self-splicing. A role for these interactions in mediating putative alternative splicing events is discussed.

Directed evolution of an RNA enzyme

An in vitro evolution procedure was used to obtain RNA enzymes with a particular catalytic function. A population of 10(13) variants of the Tetrahymena ribozyme, a group I ribozyme that catalyzes sequence-specific cleavage of RNA via a phosphoester transfer mechanism, was generated. This enzyme has a limited ability to cleave DNA under conditions of high temperature or high MgCl2 concentration, or both. A selection constraint was imposed on the population of ribozyme variants such that only those individuals that carried out DNA cleavage under physiologic conditions were amplified to produce "progeny" ribozymes. Mutations were introduced during amplification to maintain heterogeneity in the population. This process was repeated for ten successive generations, resulting in enhanced (100 times) DNA cleavage activity.

Co-optimization of ribozyme substrate stacking and L-arginine binding

A model of the Tetrahymena catalytic site predicts that nucleotide 262 (nt262) caps an RNA pocket in which nucleoside substrates and arginine-like competitive inhibitors reside. Here we show that substituted RNAs behave as if nt262 stacks on nucleoside substrates, supporting the model. The more frequent an nt262 is in natural sequences, the more reactive the corresponding Tetrahymena RNA is for both cognate and non-cognate nucleoside substrates. These more reactive RNAs with the majority nt262 also bind arginine more strongly, stereoselect more strongly in favor of L-arginine, and make a greater distinction between the somewhat similar side-chains of L-arginine and L-lysine. These parallel changes in interaction with nucleosides and arginine analogs seem best explained by stacking of the arginine's guanidino group under the nt262 base. One consequence is that selection for improved Tetrahymena catalysis with nucleosides should also yield an improved arginine site.

In vivo characterization of tus gene expression in Escherichia coli

The tus gene encodes a DNA-binding protein (Tus) that inhibits replication forks at specific block-sites within the terminus region of the Escherichia coli chromosome. One of these block-sites, TerB, is adjacent to the tus gene. Using primer extension and a promoter fusion to characterize in vivo expression, we have demonstrated that the tus transcription start site is within TerB, and that Tus protein autoregulates expression at this weak promoter. We have also demonstrated that a minority of tus transcripts are initiated from an upstream region that contains two additional open reading frames. This readthrough transcription into tus is reduced in the presence of Tus protein.

Mutational evidence for competition between the P1 and the P10 helices of a mitochondrial group I intron

A guanosine to cytosine transversion at position 2 of the fifth intron of the mitochondrial gene COB blocks the ligation step of splicing. This mutation prevents the formation of a base pair within the P1 helix of this group I intron--the RNA duplex formed between the 3' end of the upstream exon and the internal guide sequence. The mutation also reduces the rate of the first step of splicing (guanosine addition at the 5' splice junction) while stimulating hydrolysis at the 3' intron-exon boundary. Consequently, the ligation of exons is blocked because the 3' exon is removed prior to cleavage at the 5' splice junction. The lesion can be suppressed by second-site mutations that preserve the potential for base-pairing at this position. Because the P1 duplex and the P10 duplex (between the guide sequence and the 3' exon) overlap at the affected pairings represent alternative structures that do not, indeed cannot, form simultaneously.

Self-splicing of a mitochondrial group I intron from the cytochrome b gene of the ascomycete Podospora anserina

We have shown that the second intron of the Podospora mitochondrial gene coding for cytochrome b (Cytb 12) splices autocatalytically, using in vitro transcripts generated from the T7 promoter. The reaction takes place at 37 degrees C in the presence of 50 mM TRIS-HCl pH 7.5, 60 mM MgCl2 and 1 mM GTP but shows a low efficiency even at high KCl concentrations of up to 1.2 M. Under these conditions, intron bI2 follows the conventional pathway of group I splicing, and all characteristic products, with regard to both transesterification and hydrolysis, could be identified. Moreover, the intron is capable of undergoing cyclization, thereby releasing the noncoded G and one additional nucleotide (U) from the 5' end. The 5' cleavage site is preceded by the same two nucleotides, indicating a base-pairing at the same site of the internal guide sequence (IGS) for both splicing and cyclization ("one-binding-site model"). In addition, products resulting from site-specific hydrolysis 138 nucleotides downstream of the 5' splice site were detected. Unusually, the shortened intron is also able to form a circular RNA and an alternative sequence that aligns the cyclization site to the catalytic core of the intron must be assumed.

Circle reopening in the Tetrahymena ribozyme resembles site-specific hydrolysis at the 3' splice site

The Tetrahymena intron, after splicing from its flanking exons, can mediate its own circularization. This is followed by site-specific hydrolysis of the phosphodiester bond formed during the circularization reaction. The structural components involved in recognition of this bond for hydrolysis have not been established. We have made base substitutions to the P9.0 pairing and at the 3'-terminal guanosine residue (G414) of the intron to investigate their effects on circle formation and reopening. We have found that disruption of either P9.0 pairing or binding of the terminal nucleotide result in the formation of a large circle, C-413:5E23 from precursor RNA molecules that have undergone hydrolysis at the 3' splice site. This circle is formed at the phosphodiester bond of the 5'-terminal guanosine residue of the upstream exon via nucleophilic attack by the 3'-terminal nucleotide of the intron. The large circle is novel since it can reopen eight bases downstream from the original circularization junction at a site resembling the normal 3' splice site, restoring a guanosine to the 3' terminus and re-establishing P9.0 pairing. The new 3' terminus of the intron is capable of recircularization at any of the three normal wild-type sites. We conclude that both P9.0 and the 3'-terminal guanosine residue are required for the selection of the phosphodiester bond hydrolysed during circle reopening.

Folding of group I introns from bacteriophage T4 involves internalization of the catalytic core

Fe(II)-EDTA, a solvent-based cleavage reagent that distinguishes between the inside and outside surfaces of a folded RNA molecule, has revealed some of the higher-order folding of the group IB intron from Tetrahymena thermophila pre-rRNA. This reagent has now been used to analyze the bacteriophage T4 sunY and td introns, both of which are members of the group IA subclass. Significant portions of the phylogenetically conserved secondary structure are protected from Fe(II)-EDTA cleavage. However, the P4 secondary structure element, which is substantially protected in the Tetrahymena intron, is available for cleavage in the two T4 introns. We conclude that a family of catalytic RNAs (ribozymes) that possess similar secondary structures and have similar activities fold into similar but nonidentical tertiary structures that nevertheless serve to internalize portions of the catalytic center. Furthermore, comparison of cleavage patterns of the sunY and td intron RNAs indicates that conserved nucleotides outside as well as within the catalytic core participate in the tertiary structure.

In vitro self-splicing reactions of the chloroplast group I intron Cr.LSU from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii and in vivo manipulation via gene-replacement

The group I intron from the chloroplast rRNA large subunit of Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (Cr.LSU) undergoes autocatalytic splicing in vitro. Cr.LSU displays a range of reactions typical of other group I introns. Under optimal conditions, the 5' cleavage step proceeds rapidly, but the exon-ligation step is relatively slow, and no pH dependent hydrolysis of the 3' splice site occurs. A requirement for high temperature and high [Mg2+] suggests involvement of additional splicing factors in vivo. The positions of three cyclization sites of the free intron have been mapped; two of these sites represent reactions analogous to 5'-splice site cleavage, whereas the third is an example of G-exchange. Cr.LSU contains an open reading frame (ORF) potentially encoding an 163 amino acid polypeptide. ORF function has been investigated by using chloroplast gene replacement via particle bombardment. We have shown that the ORF can be deleted from Cr.LSU without affecting splicing in vivo and it thus does not encode an essential splicing factor.

Evolution of compensatory substitutions through G.U intermediate state in Drosophila rRNA

It has often been suggested that the frequently observed Watson-Crick base-pair compensatory substitutions in RNA helical structures occur mainly through a slightly deleterious G.U intermediate state. We have scored base substitutions in a set of 82 related Drosophila species for the D1 and D2 variable domains of the large rRNA subunit. In all locations where a G-C in equilibrium with A-U compensatory base change occurred, a G.U pair has been observed in one or several species. As this dominant process implies two transitions, their rate was far higher in paired regions (92%) than in unpaired regions (47%). The other types of compensation were rarer and no intermediate states were observed. Most of the G.U base pairs observed in a species are not slightly deleterious. The rate of evolution of compensatory substitution is close to that predicted by a simple model of compensatory substitution through slightly deleterious or slightly advantageous G.U pairs, although some exceptions are presented.

A self-splicing group I intron in the nuclear pre-rRNA of the green alga, Ankistrodesmus stipitatus

The nuclear small subunit ribosomal RNA gene of the unicellular green alga Ankistrodesmus stipitatus contains a group I intron, the first of its kind to be found in the nucleus of a member of the plant kingdom. The intron RNA closely resembles the group I intron found in the large subunit rRNA precursor of Tetrahymena thermophila, differing by only eight nucleotides of 48 in the catalytic core and having the same peripheral secondary structure elements. The Ankistrodesmus RNA self-splices in vitro, yielding the typical group I intron splicing intermediates and products. Unlike the Tetrahymena intron, however, splicing is accelerated by high concentrations of monovalent cations and is rate-limited by the exon ligation step. This system provides an opportunity to understand how limited changes in intron sequence and structure alter the properties of an RNA catalytic center.

A hammerhead ribozyme allows synthesis of a new form of the Tetrahymena ribozyme homogeneous in length with a 3' end blocked for transesterification

The L-21 Scal form of the Tetrahymena ribozyme acts as a sequence-specific endonuclease. This ribozyme has a homogeneous 5' end but a somewhat heterogeneous 3' end, as is typical of RNA synthesized by transcription in vitro. To produce a more homogeneous ribozyme for both structural and enzymological studies, a hammerhead ribozyme was inserted at the 3' end of the Tetrahymena ribozyme. During transcription the hammerhead moiety self-cleaves to produce the L-21 A Tetrahymena ribozyme, which ends at A410 with a 2',3'-cyclic phosphate terminus. The new ribozyme has endoribonuclease activity equivalent to that of L-21 Scal under conditions where binding of substrate is rate-limiting, as well as under conditions where chemical cleavage by guanosine is rate-limiting. However, the L-21 A has lost activity in oligo(C) disproportionation (e.g., 2 pC5----pC4 + pC6), consistent with the previous proposal that this reaction occurs predominantly through a covalent ribozyme-substrate intermediate involving the 3'-terminal hydroxyl group of the ribozyme. Formation of such an intermediate would be prevented by the 2',3'-cyclic phosphate terminus. Thus the L-21 A ribozyme has simplified enzymatic activity, being fully active as an endonuclease but blocked for disproportionation.

Group I intron self-splicing with adenosine: evidence for a single nucleoside-binding site

For self-splicing of Tetrahymena ribosomal RNA precursor, guanosine binding is required for 5' splice-site cleavage and exon ligation. Whether these two reactions use the same or different guanosine-binding sites has been debated. A double mutation in a previously identified guanosine-binding site within the intron resulted in preference for adenosine (or adenosine triphosphate) as the substrate for cleavage at the 5' splice site. However, splicing was blocked in the exon ligation step. Blockage was reversed by a change from guanine to adenine at the 3' splice site. These results indicate that a single determinant specifies nucleoside binding for both steps of splicing. Furthermore, it suggests that RNA could form an active site specific for adenosine triphosphate.

Effects of mutations of the bulged nucleotide in the conserved P7 pairing element of the phage T4 td intron on ribozyme function

The P7 element of group I introns contains a semiconserved "bulged" nucleotide, a C in group IA introns (nt 870 in the td intron) and an A in group IB introns [Cech, T.R. (1988) Gene 73, 259-271]. Variants U870, G870, and A870, isolated by a combination of in vitro and in vivo genetic strategies, indicate that C and A at position 870 are consistent with splicing whereas U and G are not. Although mutants G870 and U870 could be activated in vitro by increasing the Mg2+ concentration, their Km for GTP at pH 7 was 20-100-fold elevated, and they were unable to undergo site-specific hydrolysis. The dependence of the mutants on high guanosine concentrations could be substantially overcome by an increase in pH, suggesting that a tautomeric change, which makes U and G mimic C and A, is responsible for restoring function. In contrast to the striking Km effect, Vmax for the mutants differed by less than a factor of 2 from the wild type. Furthermore, streptomycin, an aminoglycoside antibiotic that competes with guanosine for its binding site, inhibited splicing of the U870 and G870 constructs at least as well as of the C870 and A870 variants, indicating that the guanosine-binding site of the mutants is proficient at interacting with a guanidino group. While our experiments argue against a hydrogen-bonding interaction between the C6-O of the cofactor and C4-NH2 of the bulged nucleotide, they are consistent with other models in which the C4-NH2 and/or N3 groups of the bulged C are involved in establishing an active ribozyme.

Selection of small molecules by the Tetrahymena catalytic center

The catalytic center in group I RNAs contains a selective binding site that accommodates both guanosine and L-arginine. In order to understand the specificity of the RNA for small molecules, we analyzed 6 RNAs that vary in this region. Specificity for nucleotides resides substantially in G264 rather than its paired nucleotide C311, and is expressed substantially in Km, with comparatively little variation in kcat. kcat is not notably perturbed even for RNAs with mispairs in the active-site helix. For 5 of 6 sequences, effects of RNA substitutions on arginine binding and GTP reactivity are proportional, confirming that arginine contacts a subset of the groups occupied by G. As a result of particular mutations, reaction with GTP is decreased, and reaction with the natural nucleotides UTP and ATP is enhanced. Molecular modeling of these effects suggests that exceptionally flexible placement of reactants may be an essential quality of RNA-catalyzed splicing. The specificity of the intron can be rationalized by a type of binding model not previously considered, in which the G/arginine site includes adjacent nucleotides (an 'axial' site), rather than a single nucleotide, G264.

Alternative secondary structures in the 5' exon affect both forward and reverse self-splicing of the Tetrahymena intervening sequence RNA

The natural splice junction of the Tetrahymena large ribosomal RNA is flanked by hairpins that are phylogenetically conserved. The stem immediately preceding the splice junction involves nucleotides that also base pair with the internal guide sequence of the intervening sequence during splicing. Thus, precursors which contain wild-type exons can form two alternative helices. We have constructed a series of RNAs where the stem-loop in the 5' exon is more or less stable than in the wild-type precursor, and tested them in both forward and reverse self-splicing reactions. The presence of a stable hairpin in ligated exon substrates interferes with the ability of the intervening sequence to integrate at the splice junction. Similarly, the presence of the wild-type hairpin in the 5' exon reduces the rate of splicing 20-fold in short precursors. The data are consistent with a competition between unproductive formation of a hairpin in the 5' exon and productive pairing of the 5' exon with the internal guide sequence. The reduction of splicing by a hairpin that is a normal feature of rRNA structure is surprising; we propose that this attenuation is relieved in the natural splicing environment.

The rate and specificity of a group I ribozyme are inversely affected by choice of monovalent salt

The fifth intron of the COB gene of yeast mitochondria splices autocatalytically. The rate of splicing is increased by high concentrations of monovalent salts, but the choice of both cation and anion is significant: The smaller the cation in solution, the faster the reaction (the rate in K+ greater than NH4+ greater than Na+ greater than Li+). Chloride, bromide, iodide and acetate salts enhance autocatalytic processing, but sulfate salts do not and fluoride salts are inhibitory. The choice of monovalent salt affects the KM of the intron for guanosine nucleotide, implying an alteration in the affinity of the RNA for that substrate. Under optimal conditions (1M KCl, 50 mM MgCl2) the catalytic efficiency of this intron exceeds that reported for the ribosomal intron from Tetrahymena, but several side reactions occur, including guanosine-addition within the downstream exon. The site of addition resembles the 5' splice junction, but selection of this site does not involve the internal guide sequence of the intron.

Reconstitution of a group I intron self-splicing reaction with an activator RNA

The self-splicing rRNA intron of Tetrahymena thermophila belongs to a subgroup of group I introns that contain a conserved extra stem-loop structure termed P5abc. A Tetrahymena mutant precursor RNA lacking this P5abc is splicing-defective under standard conditions (5 mM MgCl2/200 mM NH4Cl, pH 7.5) in vitro. However, the mutant precursor RNA by itself is capable of performing the self-splicing reaction without P5abc under different conditions (15 mM MgCl2/2 mM spermidine, pH 7.5). We have investigated the functional role of the P5abc in the mechanism of the self-splicing reaction. When an RNA consisting of the P5abc but lacking the rest of the Tetrahymena intron is incubated with the mutant precursor, the self-splicing reaction proceeds highly efficiently under standard conditions (5 mM MgCl2/200 mM NH4Cl, pH 7.5). Two steps of the bimolecular self-splicing reaction can be performed accurately by a shortened precursor RNA containing all essential components required in the self-splicing reaction and an activator RNA consisting of the P5abc. Gel-mobility-shift assays suggest that two molecules associate by a direct RNA-RNA interaction during the splicing reaction. The results imply that there might exist other small RNAs whose role is to activate ribozymes.

Modelling of the three-dimensional architecture of group I catalytic introns based on comparative sequence analysis

Alignment of the 87 available sequences of group I self-splicing introns reveals numerous instances of covariation between distant sites. Some of these covariations cannot be ascribed to historical coincidences or the known secondary structure of group I introns, and are, therefore, best explained as reflecting tertiary contacts. With the help of stereochemical modelling, we have taken advantage of these novel interactions to derive a three-dimensional model of the conserved core of group I introns. Two noteworthy features of that model are its extreme compactness and the fact that all of the most evolutionarily conserved residues happen to converge around the two helices that constitute the substrate of the core ribozyme and the site that binds the guanosine cofactor necessary for self-splicing. Specific functional implications are discussed, both with regard to the way the substrate helices are recognized by the core and possible rearrangements of the introns during the self-splicing process. Concerning potential long-range interactions, emphasis is put on the possible recognition of two consecutive purines in the minor groove of a helix by a GAAA or related terminal loop.

Splicing of COB intron 5 requires pairing between the internal guide sequence and both flanking exons

Group I introns are characterized by a set of conserved sequence elements and secondary structures. Evidence supporting the pairing of certain of these sequences has come from the comparison of intron sequences and from the analysis of mutations that disrupt splicing by interfering with pairing. One of the structures proposed for all group I introns is an internal guide sequence that base pairs with the upstream and the downstream exons, bringing them into alignment for ligation. We made specific mutations in the internal guide sequence and the flanking exons of the fifth intron in the yeast mitochondrial gene for apocytochrome b (COB). Mutations that disrupted the pairing between the internal guide sequence and the upstream exon (the P1 pairing) blocked addition of guanosine to the 5' end of the intron during autocatalytic reactions and prevented formation of the full-length circular intron. In contrast, transcripts containing mutations that disrupted the pairing between the guide sequence and the downstream exon (the P10 helix) initiated splicing but failed to ligate exons. Compensatory mutations that restored helices of normal stability mitigated the effects of the original mutations. These data provide direct evidence for the importance of the base pairing between the internal guide sequence and the downstream exon in the splicing of a wild-type group I intron.

Is there a special function for U.G basepairs in ribosomal RNA?

U.G basepairs are well-established elements of RNA structure. The geometry of this pair is different, however, from classical Watson-Crick basepairs. This leads to an unusual stacking of the basepair: overlap with the basepair at the 5' side of the U (and the 3' side of the G) is strong (stacked) while it is weak with the basepair on the other side (destacked). The closure of an RNA helix by a U.G pair will be energetically unfavourable when the U residue occupies the 5' end. In transfer RNA there is a strong selection against a 'destacked' U.G pair at helix ends. In the 16S rRNA model of Escherichia coli there are 72 U.G pairs of which 36 or 22 occupy a helix end, depending on how such an end is defined. There is a slight preference for 'stacked' U.G's in these positions. It is remarkable, however, that of 13 very conserved U.G pairs in the 16S (-like) rRNA, 7 occur at helix ends and that 5 of these have the 'destacked' configuration. It is suggested that these pairs, if they exist at all in a hydrogen-bounded form, are stabilized by co-axial stacking with other helices or by interaction with a protein.

Minimum secondary structure requirements for catalytic activity of a self-splicing group I intron

We have completed a comprehensive deletion analysis of the Tetrahymena ribozyme in order to define the minimum secondary structure requirements for phosphoester transfer activity of a self-splicing group I intron. A total of 299 nucleotides were removed in a piecewise fashion, leaving a catalytic core of 114 nucleotides that form 7 base-paired structural elements. Among the various deletion mutants are a 300-nucleotide single-deletion mutant and a 281-nucleotide double-deletion mutant whose activity exceeds that of the wild type when tested under physiologic conditions. Consideration of those structural elements that are essential for catalytic activity leads to a simplified secondary structure model of the catalytic core of a group I intron.

Nobel lecture. Self-splicing and enzymatic activity of an intervening sequence RNA from Tetrahymena

A living cell requires thousands of different chemical reactions to utilize energy, move, grow, respond to external stimuli and reproduce itself. While these reactions take place spontaneously, they rarely proceed at a rate fast enough for life. Enzymes, biological catalysts found in all cells, greatly accelerate the rates of these chemical reactions and impart on them extraordinary specificity. In 1926, James B. Summer crystallized the enzyme urease and found that it was a protein. Skeptics argued that the enzymatic activity might reside in a trace component of the preparation rather than in the protein (Haldane, 1930), and it took another decade for the generality of Summer's finding to be established. As more and more examples of protein enzymes were found, it began to appear that biological catalysis would be exclusively the realm of proteins. In 1981 and 1982, my research group and I found a case in which RNA, a form of genetic material, was able to cleave and rejoin its own nucleotide linkages. This self-splicing RNA provided the first example of a catalytic active site formed of ribonucleic acid. This lecture gives a personal view of the events that led to our realization of RNA self-splicing and the catalytic potential of RNA. It provides yet another illustration of the circuitous path by which scientific inquiry often proceeds. The decision to expand so many words describing the early experiments means that much of our current knowledge about the system will not be mentioned. For a more comprehensive view of the mechanism and structure of the Tetrahymena self-splicing RNA and RNA catalysis in general, the reader is directed to a number of recent reviews (Cech & Bass, 1986: Cech, 1987, 1988a, 1990; Burke, 1988; Altman, 1989). Possible medical and pharmaceutical implications of RNA catalysis have also been described recently (Cech, 1988b).

Mechanism of 3' splice site selection by the catalytic core of the sunY intron of bacteriophage T4: the role of a novel base-pairing interaction in group I introns

The catalytic core of the sunY intron of bacteriophage T4 is separated from its 3' exon by 837 nucleotides, most of which are part of an open reading frame (ORF). Here, we report that transcripts truncated within the sunY ORF self-splice in vitro to a variety of sites in the segment immediately 3' of the core. Recognition of these proximal splice sites is shown to depend on (1) the presence on the intron side of a terminal G, which must not be part of a secondary structure; and (2) the ability of the penultimate intron nucleotide to base-pair with a 3' splice site-binding sequence (3'SSBS) located within the core. The counterpart of the 3'SSBS can be identified in most group I introns. The possible significance of such alternative splicing events for in vivo expression of intron-encoded proteins is discussed.

Selection in vitro of an RNA enzyme that specifically cleaves single-stranded DNA

The discovery of RNA enzymes has, for the first time, provided a single molecule that has both genetic and catalytic properties. We have devised techniques for the mutation, selection and amplification of catalytic RNA, all of which can be performed rapidly in vitro. Here we describe how these techniques can be integrated and performed repeatedly within a single reaction vessel. This allows evolution experiments to be carried out in response to artificially imposed selection constraints. We worked with the Tetrahymena ribozyme, a self-splicing group I intron derived from the large ribosomal RNA precursor of Tetrahymena thermophila that catalyses sequence-specific phosphoester transfer reactions involving RNA substrates. It consists of 413 nucleotides, and assumes a well-defined secondary and tertiary structure responsible for its catalytic activity. We selected for variant forms of the enzyme that could best react with a DNA substrate. This led to the recovery of a mutant form of the enzyme that cleaves DNA more efficiently than the wild-type enzyme. The selected molecule represents the discovery of the first RNA enzyme known to cleave single-stranded DNA specifically.

The guanosine binding site of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

The self-splicing Group I introns have a highly specific binding site for the substrate guanosine. Mutant versions of the Tetrahymena ribozyme have been used in combination with guanosine analogues to identify the nucleotide in the ribozyme that is primarily responsible for recognition of the guanine base.

The conserved U.G pair in the 5' splice site duplex of a group I intron is required in the first but not the second step of self-splicing

Group I self-splicing introns have a 5' splice site duplex (P1) that contains a single conserved base pair (U.G). The U is the last nucleotide of the 5' exon, and the G is part of the internal guide sequence within the intron. Using site-specific mutagenesis and analysis of the rate and accuracy of splicing of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron, we found that both the U and the G of the U.G pair are important for the first step of self-splicing (attack of GTP at the 5' splice site). Mutation of the U to a purine activated cryptic 5' splice sites in which a U.G pair was restored; this result emphasizes the preference for a U.G at the splice site. Nevertheless, some splicing persisted at the normal site after introduction of a purine, suggesting that position within the P1 helix is another determinant of 5' splice site choice. When the U was changed to a C, the accuracy of splicing was not affected, but the Km for GTP was increased by a factor of 15 and the catalytic rate constant was decreased by a factor of 7. Substitution of U.A, U.U, G.G, or A.G for the conserved U.G decreased the rate of splicing by an even greater amount. In contrast, mutation of the conserved G enhanced the second step of splicing, as evidenced by a trans-splicing assay. Furthermore, a free 5' exon ending in A or C instead of the conserved U underwent efficient ligation. Thus, unlike the remainder of the P1 helix, which functions in both the first and second steps of self-splicing, the conserved U.G appears to be important only for the first step.

Catalytic activity is retained in the Tetrahymena group I intron despite removal of the large extension of element P5

We have made sizeable internal deletions within the self-splicing group I intron of Tetrahymena thermophila. Deletions were made in a piecewise manner in order to remove secondary structural elements thought to be extraneous to the catalytic center of the molecule. The resulting deletion mutants retain self-splicing activity, albeit under modified reaction conditions that enhance duplex stability. Considering those portions of the molecule that can be deleted without a loss of catalytic activity, one is left with a catalytic center of approximately 130 nucleotides that is solely responsible for the molecule's activity.

The conserved U.G pair in the 5' splice site duplex of a group I intron is required in the first but not the second step of self-splicing

Group I self-splicing introns have a 5' splice site duplex (P1) that contains a single conserved base pair (U.G). The U is the last nucleotide of the 5' exon, and the G is part of the internal guide sequence within the intron. Using site-specific mutagenesis and analysis of the rate and accuracy of splicing of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron, we found that both the U and the G of the U.G pair are important for the first step of self-splicing (attack of GTP at the 5' splice site). Mutation of the U to a purine activated cryptic 5' splice sites in which a U.G pair was restored; this result emphasizes the preference for a U.G at the splice site. Nevertheless, some splicing persisted at the normal site after introduction of a purine, suggesting that position within the P1 helix is another determinant of 5' splice site choice. When the U was changed to a C, the accuracy of splicing was not affected, but the Km for GTP was increased by a factor of 15 and the catalytic rate constant was decreased by a factor of 7. Substitution of U.A, U.U, G.G, or A.G for the conserved U.G decreased the rate of splicing by an even greater amount. In contrast, mutation of the conserved G enhanced the second step of splicing, as evidenced by a trans-splicing assay. Furthermore, a free 5' exon ending in A or C instead of the conserved U underwent efficient ligation. Thus, unlike the remainder of the P1 helix, which functions in both the first and second steps of self-splicing, the conserved U.G appears to be important only for the first step.

Reverse self-splicing of the tetrahymena group I intron: implication for the directionality of splicing and for intron transposition

Using short oligoribonucleotides as ligated exon substrates, we show that splicing of the Tetrahymena rRNA group I intron is fully reversible in vitro. Incubation of ligated exon RNA with linear intron produces a molecule in which the splice site sequences of the precursor are reformed. Reversal of self-splicing is favored by high RNA concentration, high magnesium and temperature, and the absence of guanosine. 5' exon sequences that can pair with the internal guide sequence of the intron are required, whereas 3' exon sequences are not essential. Integration of the intron into ligated exon substrates that have the ability to form stem-loop structures is reduced at least one order of magnitude over short, unstructured substrates. We propose that the formation of these structures helps drive splicing in the forward direction. We also show that the Tetrahymena intron can integrate into a beta-globin transcript. This has implications for transposition of group I introns.

Effects of substrate structure on the kinetics of circle opening reactions of the self-splicing intervening sequence from Tetrahymena thermophila: evidence for substrate and Mg2+ binding interactions

The self-splicing intervening sequence from the precursor rRNA of Tetrahymena thermophila cyclizes to form a covalently closed circle. This circle can be reopened by reaction with oligonucleotides or water. The kinetics of circle opening as a function of substrate and Mg2+ concentrations have been measured for dCrU, rCdU, dCdT, and H2O addition. Comparisons with previous results for rCrU suggest: (1) the 2' OH of the 5' sugar of a dinucleoside phosphate is involved in substrate binding, and (2) the 2' OH of the 3' sugar of a dimer substrate is involved in Mg2+ binding. Evidently, the binding site for a required Mg2+ ion is dependent on both the ribozyme and the dimer substrate. The apparent activation energy and entropy for circle opening by hydrolysis are 31 kcal/mol and 50 eu, respectively. The large, positive activation entropy suggests a partial unfolding of the ribozyme is required for reaction.

Molecular genetics of group I introns: RNA structures and protein factors required for splicing--a review

In vivo and in vitro genetic techniques have been widely used to investigate the structure-function relationships and requirements for splicing of group-I introns. Analyses of group-I introns from extremely diverse genetic systems, including fungal mitochondria, protozoan nuclei, and bacteriophages, have yielded results which are complementary and highly consistent. In vivo genetic studies of fungal mitochondrial systems have served to identify cis-acting sequences within mitochondrial introns, and trans-acting protein products of mitochondrial and nuclear genes which are important for splicing, and to show that some mitochondrial introns are mobile genetic elements. In vitro genetic studies of the self-splicing intron within the Tetrahymena thermophila nuclear large ribosomal RNA precursor (Tetrahymena LSU intron) have been used to examine essential and nonessential RNA sequences and structures in RNA-catalyzed splicing. In vivo and in vitro genetic analysis of the intron within the bacteriophage T4 td gene has permitted the detailed examination of mutant phenotypes by analyzing splicing in vivo and self-splicing in vitro. The genetic studies combined with phylogenetic analysis of intron structure based on comparative nucleotide sequence data [Cech 73 (1988) 259-271] and with biochemical data obtained from in vitro splicing experiments have resulted in significant advances in understanding the biology and chemistry of group-I introns.

Conserved sequences and structures of group I introns: building an active site for RNA catalysis--a review

Group I introns fold to form an active site to mediate their own RNA splicing. Sequence elements conserved among the available set of 66 group I introns are compiled. Comparative sequence analysis leads to the prediction of some conserved structural features that have not been widely appreciated. The possible significance of conserved nucleotides within base-paired duplexes is discussed; they might be involved in base triplets or alternate pairing interactions.