Size-dependent studies of macromolecular crowding on the thermodynamic stability, structure and functional activity of proteins: in vitro and in silico approaches

Interactions Under Crowding Milieu: Chemical-Induced Denaturation of Myoglobin is Determined by the Extent of Heme Dissociation on Interaction with Crowders

Generally, in vivo function and structural changes are studied by probing proteins in a dilute solution under in vitro conditions, which is believed to be mimicking proteins in intracellular milieu. Earlier, thermal-induced denaturation of myoglobin, in the milieu of crowder molecule showed destabilization of the metal protein. Destabilization of protein by thermal-induced denaturation involves a large extrapolation, so, the reliability is questionable. This led us to measure the effects of macromolecular crowding on its stability by chemical-induced denaturation of the protein using probes like circular dichroism and absorption spectroscopy in the presence of dextran 70 and ficoll 70 at various pHs (acidic: 6.0, almost neutral: 7.0 and basic: 8.0). Observations showed that the degree of destabilization of myoglobin was greater due to ficoll 70 as compared to that of dextran 70 so it can be understood that the nature of the crowder or the shape of the crowder has an important role towards the stability of proteins. Additionally, the degree of destabilization was observed as pH dependent, however the pH dependence is different for different crowders. Furthermore, isothermal titration calorimetry and molecular docking studies confirmed that both the crowders (ficoll and dextran) bind to heme moiety of myoglobin and a single binding site was observed for each.

Formation of molten globule state in horse heart cytochrome c under physiological conditions: Importance of soft interactions and spectroscopic approach in crowded milieu

To understand protein folding problem under physiological condition, usually taken as dilute aqueous buffer at pH 7.0 and 25 °C, knowledge of properties of folding intermediates is important, such as molten globule (MG). We observed that polyethylene glycol 400 Da (PEG 400) induces molten globule state conformation in cytochrome c at pH 7.0 and 25 °C. This PEG-induced MG state has: (i) native tertiary structure partially perturbed, (ii) unperturbed native secondary structure, (iii) newly exposed hydrophobic patches, and (iv) has 1.58 times more hydrodynamic volume than that of the native protein. Isothermal titration calorimetry and docking studies showed specific binding between PEG 400 and cytochrome c. The study delineates that PEG-protein interactions are more complex than the excluded-volume. The soft interactions need to be seriously studied in crowding milieu that leads to destabilization of protein and overcome stabilizing exclusion volume effect. This study not only can help in unraveling the mystery of steps involved in the proper folding of proteins to solve the massively complicated problems of protein folding but also provides novel insights towards importance of structural change in proteins inside cell where intermediate states of protein import-export easily via membranes rather than native form of proteins.

More than a Confinement: “Soft” and “Hard” Enzyme Entrapment Modulates Biological Catalyst Function

Catalysis makes chemical and biochemical reactions kinetically accessible. From a technological point of view, organic, inorganic, and biochemical catalysis is relevant for several applications, from industrial synthesis to biomedical, material, and food sciences. A heterogeneous catalyst, i.e., a catalyst confined in a different phase with respect to the reagents’ phase, requires either its physical confinement in an immobilization matrix or its physical adsorption on a surface. In this review, we will focus on the immobilization of biological catalysts, i.e., enzymes, by comparing hard and soft immobilization matrices and their effect on the modulation of the catalysts’ function. Indeed, unlike smaller molecules, the catalytic activity of protein catalysts depends on their structure, conformation, local environment, and dynamics, properties that can be strongly affected by the immobilization matrices, which, therefore, not only provide physical confinement, but also modulate catalysis.

Crowder-Induced Conformational Ensemble Shift in Escherichia coli Prolyl-tRNA Synthetase

The effect of molecular crowding on the structure and function of Escherichia coli prolyl-transfer RNA synthetase (Ec ProRS), a member of the aminoacyl-transfer RNA synthetase family, has been investigated using a combined experimental and theoretical method. Ec ProRS is a multidomain enzyme; coupled-domain dynamics are essential for efficient catalysis. To gain insight into the mechanistic detail of the crowding effect, kinetic studies were conducted with varying concentrations and sizes of crowders. In parallel, spectroscopic and quantum chemical studies were employed to probe the "soft interactions" between crowders and protein side chains. Finally, the dynamics of the dimeric protein was examined in the presence of crowders using a long-duration (70 ns) classical molecular dynamic simulations. The results of the simulations revealed a shift in the conformational ensemble, which is consistent with the preferential exclusion of cosolutes. The "soft interactions" model of the crowding effect also explained the alteration in kinetic parameters. In summary, the study found that the effects of molecular crowding on both conformational dynamics and catalytic function are correlated in the multidomain Ec ProRS, an enzyme that is central to protein synthesis in all living cells. This study affirmed that large and small cosolutes have considerable impacts on the structure, dynamics, and function of modular proteins and therefore must be considered for stabilizing protein-based pharmaceuticals and industrial enzymes.

Molecular Insights into Dipole Relaxation Processes in Water-Lysine Mixtures

Dielectric spectroscopy is a robust method to investigate relaxations of molecular dipoles. It is particularly useful for studies of biological solutions because of the potential of this method to cover a broad range of dynamical time scales typical for such systems. However, this technique does not provide any information about the nature of the molecular motions, which leads to a certain underemployment of dielectric spectroscopy for gaining microscopic understanding of material properties. For such detailed understanding, computer simulations are valuable tools because they can provide information about the nature of molecular motions observed by, for example, dielectric spectroscopy and to further complement them with structural information. In this work, we acquire information about the nature of dipole relaxation, in n-lysine solutions by means of molecular dynamics simulations. Our results indicate that the experimentally observed main relaxation process of n-lysine has different origins for the single monomer and the polypeptide chains. The relaxation of 1-lysine is due to the motions of whole molecules, whereas the experimentally observed relaxation of 3-lysine and 4-lysine is due to the motions of the residues, which, in turn, are promoted by water relaxation. Furthermore, we propose a new structural model of the lysine amino acids, which can quantitatively account for the experimental dielectric relaxation data. Hydrogen bonding and the structure of water are also discussed in terms of their influence on relaxation processes.

Effect of Macromolecular Crowding on the FMN-Heme Intraprotein Electron Transfer in Inducible NO Synthase

Previous biochemical studies of nitric oxide synthase enzymes (NOSs) were conducted in diluted solutions. However, the intracellular milieu where the proteins perform their biological functions is crowded with macromolecules. The effect of crowding on the electron transfer kinetics of multidomain proteins is much less understood. Herein, we investigated the effect of macromolecular crowding on the FMN-heme intraprotein interdomain electron transfer (IET), an obligatory step in NOS catalysis. A noticeable increase in the IET rate in the bidomain oxygenase/FMN (oxyFMN) and the holoprotein of human inducible NOS (iNOS) was observed upon addition of Ficoll 70 in a nonsaturable manner. Additionally, the magnitude of IET enhancement for the holoenzyme is much higher than that that of the oxyFMN construct. The crowding effect is also evident at different ionic strengths. Importantly, the enhancing extent is similar for the iNOS oxyFMN protein with added Ficoll 70 and Dextran 70 that give the same solution viscosity, showing that specific interactions do not exist between the NOS protein and the crowder. Moreover, the population of the docked FMN-heme state is significantly increased upon addition of Ficoll 70 and the fluorescence lifetime values do not correspond to those in the absence of Ficoll 70. The steady-state cytochrome c reduction by the holoenzyme is noticeably enhanced by the crowder, while the ferricyanide reduction is unchanged. The NO production activity of the iNOS holoenzyme is stimulated by Ficoll 70. The effect of macromolecular crowding on the kinetics can be rationalized on the basis of the excluded volume effect, with an entropic origin. The intraprotein electron transfer kinetics, fluorescence lifetime, and steady-state enzymatic activity results indicate that macromolecular crowding modulates the NOS electron transfer through multiple pathways. Such a mechanism should be applicable to electron transfer in other multidomain redox proteins.

Spectroscopic and mechanistic analysis of the interaction between Jack bean urease and polypseudorotaxane fabricated with bis-thiolated poly(ethylene glycol) and α-cyclodextrin

Self-assembled polypseudorotaxanes (PPRXs) fabricated with α-cyclodextrin and poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) or its thiolated derivatives were candidate functional materials for enzyme soft-immobilization, encapsulation and controlled-release. The study of their interaction with Jack bean urease (JBU) indicated that they inconspicuously influenced the activity and stability of JBU during long storage, up to 30 days. The macro-species were inaccessible to JBU's active site and the steric effect might play a significant role in the stabilization of JBU, when compared with the small-molecular sulfhydryl inhibitor thioglycolic acid. Circular dichroism and fluorescence spectra analyses revealed that thiolated PEG₄₀₀-(SH)₂ and its assembly PPRX₄₀₀(SH) brought in perturbations to certain α-helical or β-sheet domains of JBU, making JBU's conformation more flexible. The resulting partial unfolding of domains exposed several hydrophobic clusters and varied JBU's surface hydrophobicity. It also rendered the chromophores more hydrophilic and more bared to the polar environment, leading to the typical bathochromic-shift and quenching in intrinsic and synchronous fluorescence spectra. Moreover, the surface hydrophobicity profile of JBU was depicted by fluorescent probe monitoring and the unique "hydrophobic cave" motif was proposed by analyzing JBU's structural data from the Protein Data Bank. It should be pointed out that conformational variations mainly occurred at the surface region of JBU, while the buried active bi-nickel center was not markedly influenced by the macro-species. The results demonstrated that the PPRXs might act as a proper carrier for JBU encapsulation or soft-immobilization.

Mixture of Macromolecular Crowding Agents Has a Non-additive Effect on the Stability of Proteins

The folding and unfolding of proteins inside a cell take place in the presence of macromolecules of various shapes and sizes. Such crowded conditions can significantly affect folding, stability, and biophysical properties of proteins. Thus, to logically mimic the intracellular environment, the thermodynamic stability of two different proteins (lysozyme and α-lactalbumin) was investigated in the presence of mixtures of three crowding agents (ficoll 70, dextran 70, and dextran 40) at different pH values. These crowders possess different shapes and sizes. It was observed that the stabilizing effect of mixtures of crowders is more than the sum effects of the individual crowder, i.e., the stabilizing effect is non-additive in nature. Moreover, dextran 40 (in the mixture) has been found to exhibit the greatest stabilization when compared with other crowders in the mixture. In other words, the small size of the crowder has been observed to be a dominant factor in stabilization of the proteins. Graphical Abstract.

Intrinsically disordered proteins in crowded milieu: when chaos prevails within the cellular gumbo

Effects of macromolecular crowding on structural and functional properties of ordered proteins, their folding, interactability, and aggregation are well documented. Much less is known about how macromolecular crowding might affect structural and functional behaviour of intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) or intrinsically disordered protein regions (IDPRs). To fill this gap, this review represents a systematic analysis of the available literature data on the behaviour of IDPs/IDPRs in crowded environment. Although it was hypothesized that, due to the excluded-volume effects present in crowded environments, IDPs/IDPRs would invariantly fold in the presence of high concentrations of crowding agents or in the crowded cellular environment, accumulated data indicate that, based on their response to the presence of crowders, IDPs/IDPRs can be grouped into three major categories, foldable, non-foldable, and unfoldable. This is because natural cellular environment is not simply characterized by the presence of high concentration of "inert" macromolecules, but represents an active milieu, components of which are engaged in direct physical interactions and soft interactions with target proteins. Some of these interactions with cellular components can cause (local) unfolding of query proteins. In other words, since crowding can cause both folding and unfolding of an IDP or its regions, the outputs of the placing of a query protein to the crowded environment would depend on the balance between these two processes. As a result, and because of the spatio-temporal heterogeneity in structural organization of IDPs, macromolecular crowding can differently affect structures of different IDPs. Recent studies indicate that some IDPs are able to undergo liquid-liquid-phase transitions leading to the formation of various proteinaceous membrane-less organelles (PMLOs). Although interiors of such PMLOs are self-crowded, being characterized by locally increased concentrations of phase-separating IDPs, these IDPs are minimally foldable or even non-foldable at all (at least within the physiologically safe time-frame of normal PMLO existence).

Effect of an Intrinsically Disordered Plant Stress Protein on the Properties of Water

Dehydrins are plant proteins that are able to protect plants from various forms of dehydrative stress such as drought, cold, and high salinity. Dehydrins can prevent enzymes from losing activity after freeze/thaw treatments. Previous studies had suggested that the dehydrins function by a molecular shield effect, essentially preventing a denatured enzyme from aggregating with another enzyme. Therefore, the larger the dehydrin, the larger the shield and theoretically the more effective the protection. Although this relationship holds for smaller dehydrins, it fails to explain why larger dehydrins are less efficient than would be predicted from their size. Using solvatochromic dyes to probe the solvent features of water, we first confirm that the dehydrins do not bind the dyes, which would interfere with interpretation of the data. We then show that the dehydrins have an effect on three solvent properties of water (dipolarity/polarizability, hydrogen-bond donor acidity and hydrogen-bond acceptor basicity), which can contribute to the protective mechanism of these proteins. Interpretation of these data suggests that although polyethylene glycol and dehydrins have similar protective effects, dehydrins may more efficiently modify the hydrogen-bonding ability of bulk water to prevent enzyme denaturation. This possibly explains why dehydrins recover slightly more enzyme activity than polyethylene glycol.

Elastin-like Peptide in Confinement: FT-IR and NMR T 1 Relaxation Data

We employed FT-IR and NMR experiments to investigate the influence of a cell-mimicking crowding environment on the structure and dynamics of an elastin-like peptide (ELP) with the sequence GVG(VPGVG)3, which – due to a high number of hydrophobic amino acid side chains – exhibits an inverse temperature transition (ITT). As simplified crowding agent, we used 30 wt% Ficoll. The FT-IR data revealed the well-known broad ITT above ~25°C, as observed by the decrease of the relative population of random coil structures and the concomitant increase of type II β-turns. Interestingly, the addition of Ficoll leads to a destabilizing effect of type II β-turn structures. This is in contrast to the expected excluded-volume effect of the macromolecular crowder, but can be explained by weak interactions of the peptide with the polysaccharide chains of the crowding agent. Further, the crowding agent leads to the onset of a reversal of the folding transition at high temperatures. The full assignment of the ELP allowed for a residue-specific investigation of the dynamic behavior of ELP by NMR. Due to a strong change of microscopic viscosity between native/buffered conditions and crowded conditions, relaxation data remain inconclusive with respect to the observation of an ITT. Hence, no quantitative details in terms of internal conformational changes can be obtained. However, temperature dependent differences in the 13C relaxation behavior between core and terminal parts of the peptide indicate temperature induced changes in the internal dynamics with generally higher internal mobility at chain ends: This is in full agreement with FT-IR data. In harmony with the FT-IR analysis, macromolecular crowding does not lead to significant changes in the relaxation behavior.

Toward an understanding of biochemical equilibria within living cells

Four types of environmental effects that can affect macromolecular reactions in a living cell are defined: nonspecific intermolecular interactions, side reactions, partitioning between microenvironments, and surface interactions. Methods for investigating these interactions and their influence on target reactions in vitro are reviewed. Methods employed to characterize conformational and association equilibria in vivo are reviewed and difficulties in their interpretation cataloged. It is concluded that, in order to be amenable to unambiguous interpretation, in vivo studies must be complemented by in vitro studies carried out in well-characterized and controllable media designed to contain key elements of selected intracellular microenvironments.

Properties of Hydrogen-Bonded Liquids at Interfaces

Effects of interfaces on hydrogen-bonded liquids play major roles in nature and technology. Despite their importance, a fundamental understanding of these effects is still lacking. In large parts, this shortcoming is due to the high complexity of these systems, leading to an interference of various interactions and effects. Therefore, it is advisable to take gradual approaches, which start from well designed and defined model systems and systematically increase the level of intricacy towards more complex mimetics. Moreover, it is necessary to combine insights from a multitude of methods, in particular, to link novel preparation strategies and comprehensive experimental characterization with inventive computational and theoretical modeling. Such concerted approach was taken by a group of preparative, experimentally, and theoretically working scientists in the framework of Research Unit FOR 1583 funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (German Research Foundation). This special issue summarizes the outcome of this collaborative research. In this introductory article, we give an overview of the covered topics and the main results of the whole consortium. The following contributions are review articles or original works of individual research projects.

In Aqua Veritas: The Indispensable yet Mostly Ignored Role of Water in Phase Separation and Membrane-less Organelles

Despite the common practice of presenting structures of biological molecules on an empty background and the assumption that interactions between biological macromolecules take place within the inert solvent, water represents an active component of various biological processes. This Perspective addresses indispensable, yet mostly ignored, roles of water in biological liquid-liquid phase transitions and in the biogenesis of various proteinaceous membrane-less organelles. We point out that changes in the structure of water reflected in the changes in its abilities to donate and/or accept hydrogen bonds and participate in dipole-dipole and dipole-induced dipole interactions in the presence of various solutes (ranging from small molecules to synthetic polymers and biological macromolecules) might represent a driving force for the liquid-liquid phase separation, define partitioning of various solutes in formed phases, and define the exceptional ability of intrinsically disordered proteins to be engaged in the formation of proteinaceous membrane-less organelles.

Impact of macromolecular crowding on RNA/spermine complex coacervation and oligonucleotide compartmentalization

We report the effect of neutral macromolecular crowders poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) (8 kDa) and Ficoll (70 kDa) on liquid-liquid phase separation in a polyuridylic acid (polyU)/spermine complex coacervate system. The addition of PEG decreased both the amount of spermine required for phase separation and the coacervation temperature (T_C). We interpret these effects on phase behavior as arising due to excluded volume and preferential interactions on both the secondary structure/condensation of spermine-associated polyU molecules and on the association of soluble polyU/spermine polyelectrolyte complexes to form coacervate droplets. Examination of coacervates formed in the presence of fluorescently-labeled PEG or Ficoll crowders indicated that Ficoll is accumulated while PEG is excluded from the coacervate phase, which provides further insight into the differences in phase behavior. Crowding agents impact distribution of a biomolecular solute: partitioning of a fluorescently-labeled U15 RNA oligomer into the polyU/spermine coacervates was increased approximately two-fold by 20 wt% Ficoll 70 kDa and by more than two orders of magnitude by 20 wt% PEG 8 kDa. The volume of the coacervate phase decreased in the presence of crowder relative to a dilute buffer solution. These findings indicate that potential impacts of macromolecular crowding on phase behavior and solute partitioning should be considered in model systems for intracellular membraneless organelles.

Biopreservation of Myoglobin in Crowded Environment: A Comparison between Gelatin and Trehalose Matrixes

Biopreservation by sugar and/or polymeric matrixes is a thoroughly studied research topic with wide technological relevance. Ternary amorphous systems containing both saccharides and proteins are extensively exploited to model the in vivo biopreservation process. With the aim of disentangling the effect of saccharides and polypeptidic crowders (such as gelatin) on the preservation of a model protein, we present here a combined differential scanning calorimetry and UV-vis spectrophotometry study on samples of myoglobin embedded in amorphous gelatin and trehalose + gelatin matrixes at different hydrations, and compare them with amorphous myoglobin-only and myoglobin-trehalose samples. The results point out the different effects of gelatin, which acts mainly as a crowding agent, and trehalose, which acts mainly by direct interaction. Gelatin is able to improve effectively the protein thermal stability at very low hydration; however, it has small effects at medium to high hydration. Consistently, gelatin appears to be more effective than trehalose against massive denaturation in the long time range, while the mixed trehalose + collagen matrix is most effective in preserving protein functionality, outdoing both gelatin-only and trehalose-only matrixes.

Crowding in Cellular Environments at an Atomistic Level from Computer Simulations

The effects of crowding in biological environments on biomolecular structure, dynamics, and function remain not well understood. Computer simulations of atomistic models of concentrated peptide and protein systems at different levels of complexity are beginning to provide new insights. Crowding, weak interactions with other macromolecules and metabolites, and altered solvent properties within cellular environments appear to remodel the energy landscape of peptides and proteins in significant ways including the possibility of native state destabilization. Crowding is also seen to affect dynamic properties, both conformational dynamics and diffusional properties of macromolecules. Recent simulations that address these questions are reviewed here and discussed in the context of relevant experiments.

Role of solvent properties of water in crowding effects induced by macromolecular agents and osmolytes

Dipolarity/polarizability of water in polymer mixtures may be additive, reduced or enhanced depending on the composition of the mixture.