Constant-pH molecular dynamics simulations: a test case of succinic acid

Constant pH replica exchange molecular dynamics in biomolecules using a discrete protonation model

A constant pH replica exchange molecular dynamics (REMD) method is proposed and implemented to improve coupled protonation and conformational state sampling. By mixing conformational sampling at constant pH (with discrete protonation states) with a temperature ladder, this method avoids conformational trapping. Our method was tested and applied to seven different biological systems. The constant pH REMD not only predicted pKa correctly for small, model compounds but also converged faster than constant pH molecular dynamics (MD). We further tested our constant pH REMD on a heptapeptide from ovomucoid third domain (OMTKY3). Although constant pH REMD and MD produced very close pKa values, the constant pH REMD showed its advantage in the efficiency of conformational and protonation state samplings.

Coupling Constant pH Molecular Dynamics with Accelerated Molecular Dynamics

An extension of the constant pH method originally implemented by Mongan et al. (J. Comput. Chem.2004, 25, 2038−2048) is proposed in this study. This adapted version of the method couples the constant pH methodology with the enhanced sampling technique of accelerated molecular dynamics, in an attempt to overcome the sampling issues encountered with current standard constant pH molecular dynamics methods. Although good results were reported by Mongan et al. on application of the standard method to the hen egg-white lysozyme (HEWL) system, residues which possess strong interactions with neighboring groups tend to converge slowly, resulting in the reported inconsistencies for predicted pK_a values, as highlighted by the authors. The application of the coupled method described in this study to the HEWL system displays improvements over the standard version of the method, with the improved sampling leading to faster convergence and producing pK_a values in closer agreement to those obtained experimentally for the more slowly converging residues.

MCCE2: improving protein pKa calculations with extensive side chain rotamer sampling

Multiconformation continuum electrostatics (MCCE) explores different conformational degrees of freedom in Monte Carlo calculations of protein residue and ligand pK(a)s. Explicit changes in side chain conformations throughout a titration create a position dependent, heterogeneous dielectric response giving a more accurate picture of coupled ionization and position changes. The MCCE2 methods for choosing a group of input heavy atom and proton positions are described. The pK(a)s calculated with different isosteric conformers, heavy atom rotamers and proton positions, with different degrees of optimization are tested against a curated group of 305 experimental pK(a)s in 33 proteins. QUICK calculations, with rotation around Asn and Gln termini, sampling His tautomers and torsion minimum hydroxyls yield an RMSD of 1.34 with 84% of the errors being <1.5 pH units. FULL calculations adding heavy atom rotamers and side chain optimization yield an RMSD of 0.90 with 90% of the errors <1.5 pH unit. Good results are also found for pK(a)s in the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin. The inclusion of extra side chain positions distorts the dielectric boundary and also biases the calculated pK(a)s by creating more neutral than ionized conformers. Methods for correcting these errors are introduced. Calculations are compared with multiple X-ray and NMR derived structures in 36 soluble proteins. Calculations with X-ray structures give significantly better pK(a)s. Results with the default protein dielectric constant of 4 are as good as those using a value of 8. The MCCE2 program can be downloaded from http://www.sci.ccny.cuny.edu/~mcce.

Backbone relaxation coupled to the ionization of internal groups in proteins: a self-guided Langevin dynamics study

Pathways of structural relaxation triggered by ionization of internal groups in staphylococcal nuclease (SNase) were studied through multiple self-guided Langevin dynamics (SGLD) simulations. Circular dichroism, steady-state Trp fluorescence, and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy have shown previously that variants of SNase with internal Glu, Asp, and Lys at positions 66 or 92, and Arg at position 66, exhibit local reorganization or global unfolding when the internal ionizable group is charged. Except for Arg-66, these internal ionizable groups have unusual pKa values and are neutral at physiological pH. The structural trends observed in the simulations are in general agreement with experimental observations. The I92D variant, which unfolds globally upon ionization of Asp-92, in simulations often exhibits extensive hydration of the protein core, and sometimes also significant perturbations of the beta-barrel. In the crystal structure of the V66R variant, the beta1 strand from the beta-barrel is domain-swapped; in the simulations, the beta1 strand is sometimes partially released. The V66K variant, which in solutions shows reorganization of six residues at the C-terminus of helix alpha1 and perturbations in the beta-barrel structure, exhibits fraying of three residues of helix alpha1 in one simulation, and perturbations and partial unfolding of three beta-strands in a few other simulations. In sharp contrast, very small structural changes were observed in simulations of the wild-type protein. The simulations indicate that charging of internal groups frequently triggers penetration of water into the protein interior. The pKa values of Asp-92 and Arg-66 calculated with continuum methods on SGLD-relaxed structures reached the normal values in most simulations. Detailed analysis of accuracy and performance of SGLD demonstrates that SGLD outperforms LD in sampling of alternative protein conformations without loss of the accuracy and level of detail characteristic of regular LD.

FAMBE-pH: a fast and accurate method to compute the total solvation free energies of proteins

A fast and accurate method to compute the total solvation free energies of proteins as a function of pH is presented. The method makes use of a combination of approaches, some of which have already appeared in the literature; (i) the Poisson equation is solved with an optimized fast adaptive multigrid boundary element (FAMBE) method; (ii) the electrostatic free energies of the ionizable sites are calculated for their neutral and charged states by using a detailed model of atomic charges; (iii) a set of optimal atomic radii is used to define a precise dielectric surface interface; (iv) a multilevel adaptive tessellation of this dielectric surface interface is achieved by using multisized boundary elements; and (v) 1:1 salt effects are included. The equilibrium proton binding/release is calculated with the Tanford-Schellman integral if the proteins contain more than approximately 20-25 ionizable groups; for a smaller number of ionizable groups, the ionization partition function is calculated directly. The FAMBE method is tested as a function of pH (FAMBE-pH) with three proteins, namely, bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor (BPTI), hen egg white lysozyme (HEWL), and bovine pancreatic ribonuclease A (RNaseA). The results are (a) the FAMBE-pH method reproduces the observed pK a's of the ionizable groups of these proteins within an average absolute value of 0.4 p K units and a maximum error of 1.2 p K units and (b) comparison of the calculated total pH-dependent solvation free energy for BPTI, between the exact calculation of the ionization partition function and the Tanford-Schellman integral method, shows agreement within 1.2 kcal/mol. These results indicate that calculation of total solvation free energies with the FAMBE-pH method can provide an accurate prediction of protein conformational stability at a given fixed pH and, if coupled with molecular mechanics or molecular dynamics methods, can also be used for more realistic studies of protein folding, unfolding, and dynamics, as a function of pH.

CHARMM-GUI: a web-based graphical user interface for CHARMM

CHARMM is an academic research program used widely for macromolecular mechanics and dynamics with versatile analysis and manipulation tools of atomic coordinates and dynamics trajectories. CHARMM-GUI, http://www.charmm-gui.org, has been developed to provide a web-based graphical user interface to generate various input files and molecular systems to facilitate and standardize the usage of common and advanced simulation techniques in CHARMM. The web environment provides an ideal platform to build and validate a molecular model system in an interactive fashion such that, if a problem is found through visual inspection, one can go back to the previous setup and regenerate the whole system again. In this article, we describe the currently available functional modules of CHARMM-GUI Input Generator that form a basis for the advanced simulation techniques. Future directions of the CHARMM-GUI development project are also discussed briefly together with other features in the CHARMM-GUI website, such as Archive and Movie Gallery.

Recent advances in implicit solvent-based methods for biomolecular simulations

Implicit solvent-based methods play an increasingly important role in molecular modeling of biomolecular structure and dynamics. Recent methodological developments have mainly focused on the extension of the generalized Born (GB) formalism for variable dielectric environments and accurate treatment of nonpolar solvation. Extensive efforts in parameterization of GB models and implicit solvent force fields have enabled ab initio simulation of protein folding to native or near-native structures. Another exciting area that has benefited from the advances in implicit solvent models is the development of constant pH molecular dynamics methods, which have recently been applied to the calculations of protein pK(a) values and the studies of pH-dependent peptide and protein folding.

Molecular simulation with variable protonation states at constant pH

A new method is presented for performing molecular simulations at constant pH. The method is a Monte Carlo procedure where trial moves consist of relatively short molecular dynamics trajectories, using a time-dependent potential energy that interpolates between the old and new protonation states. Conformations and protonation states are sampled from the correct statistical ensemble independent of the trial-move trajectory length, which may be adjusted to optimize efficiency. Because moves are not instantaneous, the method does not require the use of a continuum solvation model. It should also be useful in describing buried titratable groups that are not directly exposed to solvent, but have strong interactions with neighboring hydrogen bond partners. The feasibility of the method is demonstrated for a simple test case: constant-pH simulations of acetic acid in aqueous solution with an explicit representation of water molecules.

Effects of solute-solvent proton exchange on polypeptide chain dynamics: a constant-pH molecular dynamics study

A method for performing implicit-solvent molecular dynamics simulations at constant pH was applied to a pentapeptide acetyl-Ala-Asp-Ala-Lys-Ala-amide at pH 4. As a reference, molecular dynamics simulations were done for the same peptide with two variants of its fixed protonation patterns expected to dominate at pH 4, i.e., with a protonated and a deprotonated side chain of the Asp residue and the protonated Lys residue in both cases. The dynamic trajectories of the peptide were used to discuss the problem of the significance of the solute-solvent proton exchange phenomena for the dynamics and structural distributions of the polypeptide chain. The Asp-Lys distance was used as a probe of the overall molecular structure of the investigated pentapeptide. To characterize the dynamics, distributions of the "waiting" times for a transition from a "short" distance conformation to a "long" distance conformation were constructed, based on the generated molecular dynamics trajectories. We show that the relaxation time for the transitions, derived from the constant-pH simulations, is very close to the relaxation time characterizing a permanently protonated molecule, although the average protonation probability of the short-distance conformation is close to zero. However, the distribution of the Asp-Lys distances obtained from constant-pH simulations cannot be reproduced as a linear combination of the distributions resulting from the simulations with fixed protonation states.

The pH-dependent conformational states of kyotorphin: a constant-pH molecular dynamics study

An extensive conformational study of the analgesic dipeptide kyotorphin (L-Tyr-L-Arg) at different pH values was performed using a constant-pH molecular dynamics method. This dipeptide showed a remarkable pH-dependent conformational variety. The protonation of the N-terminal amine was identified as a key element in the transition between the more extended and the more packed conformational states, as monitored by the dihedral angle defined by the atoms 1Cbeta-1Calpha-2Calpha-2Cbeta. The principal-component analysis of kyotorphin identified two major conformational populations (the extended trans and the packed cis) together with conformations that occur exclusively at extreme pH values. Other, less stable conformations were also identified, which help us to understand the transitions between the predominant populations. The fitting of kyotorphin's conformational space to the structure of morphine resulted in a set of conformers that were able to fulfill most of the constraints for the mu-receptor. These results suggest that there may be strong similarities between the kyotorphin receptor and the structural family of opioid receptors.

Factors influencing the energetics of electron and proton transfers in proteins. What can be learned from calculations

A protein structure should provide the information needed to understand its observed properties. Significant progress has been made in developing accurate calculations of acid/base and oxidation/reduction reactions in proteins. Current methods and their strengths and weaknesses are discussed. The distribution and calculated ionization states in a survey of proteins is described, showing that a significant minority of acidic and basic residues are buried in the protein and that most of these remain ionized. The electrochemistry of heme and quinones are considered. Proton transfers in bacteriorhodopsin and coupled electron and proton transfers in photosynthetic reaction centers, 5-coordinate heme binding proteins and cytochrome c oxidase are highlighted as systems where calculations have provided insight into the reaction mechanism.

Constant-pH Molecular Dynamics with Ionic Strength Effects: Protonation−Conformation Coupling in Decalysine

A new implementation of the stochastic titration method for constant-pH molecular dynamics is presented, which introduces ionic strength effects in the simulations. In addition, the new implementation uses a faster molecular dynamics algorithm and an improved treatment of protonation events and of their effect on force field parameters. This new methodology is applied to a decalysine peptide, yielding very good quantitative agreement with experiments, both in terms of titration and helix-coil transition. The results show a significant dependence on ionic strength, illustrating the importance of including this parameter in constant-pH molecular dynamics simulations. Overall, the method seems to properly capture the protonation-conformation coupling and its dependence on ionic strength.

Constant pH molecular dynamics with proton tautomerism

The current article describes a new two-dimensional lambda-dynamics method to include proton tautomerism in continuous constant pH molecular dynamics (CPHMD) simulations. The two-dimensional lambda-dynamics framework is used to devise a tautomeric state titration model for the CPHMD simulations involving carboxyl and histidine residues. Combined with the GBSW implicit solvent model, the new method is tested on titration simulations of blocked histidine and aspartic acid as well as two benchmark proteins, turkey ovomucoid third domain (OMTKY3) and ribonuclease A (RNase A). A detailed analysis of the errors inherent to the CPHMD methodology as well as those due to the underlying solvation model is given. The average absolute error for the computed pKa values in OMTKY3 is 1.0 pK unit. In RNase A the average absolute errors for the carboxyl and histidine residues are 1.6 and 0.6 pK units, respectively. In contrast to the previous work, the new model predicts the correct sign for all the pKa shifts, but one, in the benchmark proteins. The predictions of the tautomeric states of His12 and His48 and the conformational states of His48 and His119 are in agreement with experiment. Based on the simulations of OMTKY3 and RNase A, the current work has demonstrated the capability of the CPHMD technique in revealing pH-coupled conformational dynamics of protein side chains.

Proton binding to proteins: a free-energy component analysis using a dielectric continuum model

Proton binding plays a critical role in protein structure and function. We report pK(a) calculations for three aspartates in two proteins, using a linear response approach, as well as a "standard" Poisson-Boltzmann approach. Averaging over conformations from the two endpoints of the proton-binding reaction, the protein's atomic degrees of freedom are explicitly modeled. Treating macroscopically the protein's electronic polarizability and the solvent, a meaningful model is obtained, without adjustable parameters. It reproduces qualitatively the electrostatic potentials, proton-binding free energies, Marcus reorganization free energies, and pK(a) shifts from explicit solvent molecular dynamics simulations, and the pK(a) shifts from experiment. For thioredoxin Asp-26, which has a large pK(a) upshift, we correctly capture the balance between unfavorable carboxylate desolvation and favorable interactions with a nearby lysine; similarly for RNase A Asp-14, which has a large pK(a) downshift. For the unshifted thioredoxin Asp-20, desolvation by the protein cavity is overestimated by 2.9 pK(a) units; several effects could explain this. "Standard" Poisson-Boltzmann methods sidestep this problem by using a large, ad hoc protein dielectric; but protein charge-charge interactions are then incorrectly downscaled, giving an unbalanced description of the reaction and a large error for the shifted pK(a) values of Asp-26 and Asp-14.

Peptide and protein folding and conformational equilibria: theoretical treatment of electrostatics and hydrogen bonding with implicit solvent models

Since biomolecules exist in aqueous and membrane environments, the accurate modeling of solvation, and hydrogen bonding interactions in particular, is essential for the exploration of structure and function in theoretical and computational studies. In this chapter, we focus on alternatives to explicit solvent models and discuss recent advances in generalized Born (GB) implicit solvent theories. We present a brief review of the successes and shortcomings of the application of these theories to biomolecular problems that are strongly linked to backbone H-bonding and electrostatics. This discussion naturally leads us to explore existing areas for improvement in current GB theories and our approach towards addressing a number of the key issues that remain in the refinement of these models. Specifically, the critical importance of balancing solvation forces and intramolecular forces in GB models is illustrated by examining the influence of backbone hydrogen bond strength and backbone dihedral energetics on conformational equilibria of small peptids.