Neuropsychological speed tests and blood phenylalanine levels in patients with phenylketonuria: A meta-analysis

Executive functioning in context: Relevance for treatment and monitoring of phenylketonuria

This paper presents findings from studies of EF in individuals with early-treated PKU within the context of recent advances in neuropsychological theory and research. It focuses on means of assessment, contexts of assessment, and the best way to define and investigate EF. Several conclusions can be drawn based on the findings presented here. The first conclusion is that there is clear evidence for phenylalanine-related EF-deficits in early-treated PKU, particularly with respect to prepotent response inhibition and the manipulation or monitoring component of working memory. An important note, however, is that measurement of EF in PKU has become too fragmented, as different researchers and clinicians use different definitions of EF, and subsequently, different instruments to measure EF. This appears to be one of the most important causes of mixed results. A second conclusion is that there appears to be a need to incorporate at least one specific, relatively new taxonomy of EF in PKU-research, i.e. the taxonomy that distinguishes hot and cool EFs, where hot EF is associated with regulation of affect/emotions and motivation, or regulatory functions when the context contains such elements, while cool EF concerns decontextualized regulatory abilities. PKU in adults is increasingly associated with different mental health problems, despite supposedly good treatment standards and adherence throughout childhood and adolescence. Since hot EF is strongly associated with such mental health problems, it is recommended that the hot-cool taxonomy will feature more prominently in future PKU-studies.

Processing speed and executive abilities in children with phenylketonuria

OBJECTIVE

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is a hereditary metabolic disorder that often results in neuropsychological impairment, even in individuals treated early and continuously. This study was conducted to examine processing speed, variability in processing speed, and the relationship between processing speed variables and executive abilities in children with early and continuously treated PKU.

METHOD

Participants were 42 children with PKU and 81 typically developing children from 7 to 18 years of age. Children completed 3 computerized reaction time (RT) tasks (simple RT, go/no-go, stimulus-response compatibility) and 7 tasks assessing executive abilities (working memory, inhibitory control, strategic processing).

RESULTS

Performance of children with PKU was significantly slower and more variable than that of controls across the 3 tasks administered. When age was considered, it was shown that processing speed improved with age to a comparable degree for both groups. Variability in processing speed, however, decreased more with age for the PKU than control group, reflecting the fact that variability in younger, but not older, children with PKU was greater than that of controls. With regard to executive abilities, processing speed and variability contributed to performance on most, but not all, executive tasks; and after controlling for processing speed and variability, executive impairments were still identified in working memory and inhibitory control (not strategic processing).

CONCLUSIONS

These findings indicate that information processing is slower and less efficient in children with PKU. In addition, processing speed and variability contribute to some, but not all, of the impairments in executive abilities observed in children with PKU.

Commentary: What degree of hyperphenylalaninaemia requires treatment?

Despite some 50 years' experience in the treatment of phenylketonuria and numerous scientific publications on the subject there is no clear consensus as to what degree of hyperphenylalaninaemia will result in intellectual impairment. Studies of three main types, on untreated cases of moderate hyperphenylalaninaemia, on treated cases of phenylketonuria, and on the effects of current blood phenylalanine concentration on executive function, have lead to different conclusions. Overall, there appears to be a fairly strong case for limiting dietary treatment to individuals whose blood phenylalanine levels would otherwise exceed 600 μmol/L. This is now policy in some European countries but a formal large-scale study of long-term outcomes to validate the approach is urgently required.

Recommendations for the use of sapropterin in phenylketonuria

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is an inherited disorder of phenylalanine (Phe) metabolism. Until recently, the only treatment for PKU was a Phe-restricted diet. Increasing evidence of suboptimal outcomes in diet-treated individuals, inconsistent PKU management practices, and the recent availability of tetrahydrobiopterin (BH(4)) therapy have fueled the need for new management and treatment recommendations for this metabolic disorder. BH(4), now available as sapropterin dihydrochloride (sapropterin), may offer the potential for improved metabolic control as well as enhanced dietary Phe tolerance in some PKU patients. A group of metabolic dietitians from North America convened in June 2011 to draft recommendations for the use of sapropterin therapy in PKU. Physicians with extensive experience in PKU management were invited at a later date to contribute to the development of these recommendations. Based on extensive clinical experience and current evidence, the present recommendations provide guidance from patient selection and determination of sapropterin response to the long-term management of patients on sapropterin therapy. Target Phe levels, nutritional adequacy, neurocognitive screening and adherence to treatment are addressed to optimize patient outcomes.

Pre-attentive processing in children with early and continuously-treated PKU. Effects of concurrent Phe level and lifetime dietary control

Sixty-four children, aged 7 to 14 years, with early-treated PKU, were compared with control children on visual evoked potential (VEP) amplitudes and latencies and auditory mismatch negativity (MMN) amplitudes. It was further investigated whether indices of dietary control would be associated with these evoked potentials parameters. There were no significant differences between controls and children with PKU in VEP- and MMN-indices. However, higher lifetime Phe levels were, in varying degree and stronger than concurrent Phe level, related to increased N75 amplitudes, suggesting abnormalities in attention, and longer P110 latencies, indicating a reduction in speed of neural processing, possibly due to deficits in myelination or reduced dopamine levels in brain and retina. Similarly, higher lifetime Phe levels and Index of Dietary Control (IDC) were associated with decreased MMN amplitudes, suggesting a reduced ability to respond to stimulus change and poorer triggering of the frontally mediated attention switch. In summary, the present study in children with PKU investigated bottom-up information processing, i.e., triggered by external events, a fundamental prerequisite for the individual's responsiveness to the outside world. Results provide evidence that quality of dietary control may affect the optimal development of these pre-attentive processes, and suggest the existence of windows of vulnerability to Phe exposure.

Outcomes of phenylketonuria with relevance to follow-up

Currently, there is no international consensus on how patients with phenylketonuria (PKU) (or milder forms of hyperphenylalaninaemia) should be followed in clinical practice. Guidelines concerning the frequency and type of assessments that should be made according to age usually focus on blood phenylalanine concentrations. A need exists for improved guidelines on how to do the follow-up of individuals with PKU/milder forms of hyperphenylalaninaemia. An interdisciplinary approach for monitoring patients is required, involving relevant clinical investigations and regular contact with a clinician and dietician/nutritionist as well as contact with social health worker, psychologist and neurologist, at least at request. This chapter presents a scheme for follow-up. However, by no means this scheme aims to present the one for all time follow-up programme. The scheme for follow-up may rather serve as a start for further discussion in larger groups of professionals in collaboration with patients and their parents. A number of questions remain unanswered, and further research is still needed to fine-tune the management of PKU at different ages.

Sapropterin hydrochloride: enzyme enhancement therapy for phenylketonuria

Phenylketonuria (PKU) is an inherited disorder of amino acid metabolism caused by deficiency of the enzyme phenylalanine hydroxylase (PAH). Historically PKU was a common genetic cause of severe learning difficulties and developmental delay, but with the introduction of newborn screening and early dietary management, it has become a treatable disease and people born with PKU should now have IQs and achievements similar to their peers. Dietary treatment, however, involves lifestyle changes that pervade most aspects of daily life for an individual and their family. A simple pharmacological treatment for PKU would have a great appeal. Sapropterin hydrochloride is a synthetic form of tetrahydrobiopterin, the cofactor for PAH. A proportion of mutant PAH enzymes show enhanced activity in the presence of pharmacological doses of sapropterin and, for some patients with milder forms of PKU, sapropterin can effectively lower plasma phenylalanine levels. This article discusses the potential place for sapropterin in the management of PKU and how this expensive orphan drug is being integrated into patient care in different healthcare systems.

Retrospective, observational data collection of the treatment of phenylketonuria in the UK, and associated clinical and health outcomes

OBJECTIVE

To determine the percentage of phenylketonuria (PKU) subjects using current treatment strategies whose phenylalanine (Phe) concentrations diverge from the UK target guidelines for PKU.

RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS

This retrospective, observational, chart review was conducted between 2004 and 2008 at three specialist PKU treatment centres in the UK, and included 125 eligible subjects: 20 adults (18+ years, with ≥4 Phe concentrations measured per year) and 105 children (up to age 17, with ≥6 Phe concentrations measured per year).

RESULTS

The mean percentage of subjects with at least 70% of Phe concentrations within the target range for 0-5-year olds, 6-10 year olds and 11-17 year olds was similar across the period 2004-2008 (57.0%, 56.5% and 57.1%, respectively) and lower (39.4%) in the 18+ year age group. For all ages, across the period the mean was 54.4%. Further analysis of the adult population showed that some subjects were very good at complying with treatment and reporting Phe concentrations. Overall, the percentage of 100% compliance was 15.7% in females and 13.7% in males. The mean duration that subjects were 'out of range' of target Phe concentrations over the study period was approximately 1 year and 3 months and the mean duration for 'significantly out of range' values was approximately 9 months. The most common type of contact made with subjects was by telephone, with a mean number of 16 calls per subject per year.

CONCLUSION

The results support current literature showing that a proportion of subjects with PKU, in particular older subjects, are not fully compliant with their treatment and subsequently have Phe concentrations that depart from national recommendations. However, definitive conclusions may not be drawn due to the retrospective nature of the study and the small number of observed subjects.

Dietary treatment of phenylketonuria: the effect of phenylalanine on reaction time

There is no evidence that high phenylalanine (Phe) levels have irreversible effects on the adult brain. Many adults with phenylketonuria (PKU) no longer follow a protein-restricted diet. Neuropsychological studies have shown that reaction time in adults with PKU is slower than controls. There are no data to show that this is directly related to Phe levels. Another way to assess reaction time is to measure saccadic latency. We have used a portable, head-mounted saccadometer to measure latency in the outpatient setting. Patients with PKU were split into three groups: off-diet (Phe >1,200 μmol/l), on-diet (Phe < 800 μmol/l) and maternal diet (Phe 100-400 μmol/l ). Reciprocal median latency (RML) was compared between groups. Latency was significantly slower in patients who were off-diet than in patients on-diet, on a maternal diet or in normal controls. Reaction times in both diet-treated groups were not significantly different from normal controls. In 16 women planning pregnancy we obtained values before and after they commenced the maternal diet. Stricter control of Phe levels resulted in a significant improvement in reaction times. We conclude that saccadometry is useful in monitoring PKU patients. Adult patients with PKU not on a protein-restricted diet have significantly slower reaction times than controls. In addition, off-diet patients have significantly slower reaction times than on-diet. Paired data show that effects of Phe levels on reaction time are reversible.

High phenylalanine levels directly affect mood and sustained attention in adults with phenylketonuria: a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover trial

The main debate in the treatment of Phenylketonuria (PKU) is whether adult patients need the strict phenylalanine (Phe)-restricted diet. Physicians and patients lack evidence-based guidelines to help them make well-informed choices. We have carried out the first randomised double-blind placebo-controlled trial into the effects of short-term elevation of Phe levels on neuropsychological functions and mood of adults with PKU. Nine continuously treated adults with PKU underwent two 4-week supplementation periods: one with Phe, mimicking normal dietary intake, and one with placebo in randomly allocated order via a randomisation coding list in a double-blind cross-over design. A set of neuropsychological tests (Amsterdam Neuropsychological Tasks) was administered at the end of each study period. In addition, patients and for each patient a friend or relative, completed weekly Profile of Mood States (POMS) questionnaires, evaluating the patients' mood. Phe levels were measured twice weekly. Mean plasma Phe levels were significantly higher during Phe supplementation compared with placebo (p = 0.008). Neuropsychological tests demonstrated an impairment in sustained attention during Phe supplementation (p = 0.029). Both patients and their friend or relative reported lower scores on the POMS questionnaires during Phe supplementation (p = 0.017 and p = 0.040, respectively). High plasma Phe levels have a direct negative effect on both sustained attention and on mood in adult patients with PKU. A Phe-restricted "diet for life" might be an advisable option for many.

Serum vitamin B12 concentrations within reference values do not exclude functional vitamin B12 deficiency in PKU patients of various ages

Homocysteine (Hcy) and in particular methylmalonic acid (MMA) are considered reliable parameters for vitamin B(12) status in healthy individuals. Phenylketonuria (PKU) patients are at risk for functional vitamin B(12) deficiency based on their diet.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to investigate the prevalence of functional vitamin B(12) deficiency in continuously treated PKU patients and the association of parameters of vitamin B(12) and metabolic control.

METHODS

In 75 continuously treated PKU patients of 1-37 years of age, serum vitamin B(12) concentrations, plasma Hcy, MMA, and phenylalanine concentrations were studied.

RESULTS

Eight patients had vitamin B(12) concentrations below normal. Out of these eight patients, two had elevated MMA and/or Hcy concentrations. Ten other patients with normal vitamin B(12) concentrations had elevated concentrations of MMA and/or Hcy.

CONCLUSIONS

A vitamin B(12) concentration within the reference range does not automatically imply a sufficient vitamin B(12) status. We recommend measuring serum MMA, or alternatively plasma Hcy, yearly in all PKU patients to diagnose functional vitamin B(12) deficiency.

Follow up of phenylketonuria patients

In recent years our understanding of the follow up policies for PKU has increased substantially. In particular, we now understand the importance of maintaining control of blood phenylalanine (phe) concentrations life-long to achieve the best long-term neuropsychological outcomes. The concordance with the follow up strategy remains a key challenge for the future, especially with respect to adolescents and young adults. The recent therapies could ease the burden of the dietary phe restriction for PKU patients and their families. The time may be right for revisiting the guidelines for follow up of PKU in order to address a number of important issues related to PKU management: promotion of breastfeeding to complementary feeding up to 2 years of age for prevention of early growth retardation and later overweight development, treatment advancements for metabolic control, blood phe and tyr variability, routine screening measures for nutritional biomarkers, neurocognitive and psychological assessments, bone pathology, understanding the challenges of compliance and transitioning into adulthood as an individual with PKU and addressing unmet needs in this population.

Adult phenylketonuria outcome and management

The problem to evaluate treatment outcome in adult PKU (phenylketonuric) patients lies in the heterogeneity of the adult PKU population. This heterogeneity is not only based on the different treatment history of every individual patient but also on the different severity of the underlying defect of the enzyme phenylalanine hydroxylase. Recent, partly double blind studies in adult PKU patients further support recommendation for lifelong treatment. However, it has become evident that dietary treatment is suboptimal and continuation to adulthood often not accepted. Late detected PKU patients (up to 4-6 years of age) benefit from strict dietary treatment and are able to catch up in intellectual performance. Untreated, severely retarded patients with behavioral changes may benefit from introduction of dietary treatment. However, individual decision is necessary and based on the personal situation of the patient. In early and well treated patients a number of studies have demonstrated that cognitive and neurosychologic tests are different from controls. In addition there is evidence that patients with higher blood phenylalanine (phe) levels demonstrate more often psychiatric symptoms like depression and anxiety. Medical problems are more often observed: there are certain risks as impaired growth, decreased bone mineral density and nutrional deficits probably caused by dietary treatment with an artificial protein substitute and/or missing compliance with an unpleasant diet. The long term risk of a strict dietary treatment must be balanced with the risk of higher blood phe (mean blood phenylalanine >600-900 μmol/L) on cognitive and neuropsychological functions and psychiatric symptoms. Further studies should consider the role of blood phe exposure for brain development in childhood and for brain function in all ages. Besides mean blood phe, fluctuation of blood phe over time is important. Fluctuation of blood phe is decreased by sapropterin treatment in responsive patients which would on the long term may have positive effects on cognitive outcome. Further studies also should include adult PKU patients.

Cognitive, neurophysiological, neurological and psychosocial outcomes in early-treated PKU-patients: a start toward standardized outcome measurement across development

The aim of this paper is to provide a concise summary of findings from outcome studies in early-treated phenylketonuria (PKU). The paper should not be considered as an extensive review of the many different outcome measures that have been used in PKU-research, but as an attempt to integrate such findings so that they will be of additional value for day to day monitoring of PKU-patients and may direct future research to fill the present gaps of knowledge. Neurological, neuropsychological, neurophysiological, neuroimaging, quality of life, and psychosocial findings will be discussed in the context of their potential contributions to lifelong follow-up and treatment of PKU-patients being summarized in statements.

Phenylketonuria

Phenylketonuria is the most prevalent disorder caused by an inborn error in aminoacid metabolism. It results from mutations in the phenylalanine hydroxylase gene. Phenotypes can vary from a very mild increase in blood phenylalanine concentrations to a severe classic phenotype with pronounced hyperphenylalaninaemia, which, if untreated, results in profound and irreversible mental disability. Neonatal screening programmes identify individuals with phenylketonuria. The initiation of a phenylalanine-restricted diet very soon after birth prevents most of the neuropsychological complications. However, the diet is difficult to maintain and compliance is often poor, especially in adolescents, young adults, and pregnant women. Tetrahydrobiopterin stimulates phenylalanine hydroxylase activity in about 20% of patients, and in those patients serves as a useful adjunct to the phenylalanine-restricted diet because it increases phenylalanine tolerance and allows some dietary freedom. Possible future treatments include enzyme substitution with phenylalanine ammonia lyase, which degrades phenylalanine, and gene therapy to restore phenylalanine hydroxylase activity.

Suboptimal outcomes in patients with PKU treated early with diet alone: revisiting the evidence

BACKGROUND

The National Institute of Health (NIH) published a Consensus Statement on the screening and management of Phenylketonuria (PKU) in 2000. The panel involved in the development of this consensus statement acknowledged the lack of data regarding the potential for more subtle suboptimal outcomes and the need for further research into treatment options. In subsequent years, the approval of new treatment options for PKU and outcome data for patients treated from the newborn period by dietary therapy alone have become available. We hypothesized that a review of the PKU literature since 2000 would provide further evidence related to neurocognitive, psychosocial, and physical outcomes that could serve as a basis for reassessment of the 2000 NIH Consensus Statement.

METHODS

A systematic review of literature residing in PubMed, Scopus and PsychInfo was performed in order to assess the outcome data over the last decade in diet-alone early-treated PKU patients to assess the need for new recommendations and validity of older recommendations in light of new evidence.

RESULTS

The majority of publications (140/150) that contained primary outcome data presented at least one suboptimal outcome compared to control groups or standardized norms/reference values in at least one of the following areas: neurocognitive/psychosocial (N=60; 58 reporting suboptimal outcomes); quality of life (N=6; 4 reporting suboptimal outcomes); brain pathology (N=32; 30 reporting suboptimal outcomes); growth/nutrition (N=34; 29 reporting suboptimal outcomes); bone pathology (N=9; 9 reporting suboptimal outcomes); and/or maternal PKU (N=19; 19 reporting suboptimal outcomes).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the remarkable success of public health programs that have instituted newborn screening and early introduction of dietary therapy for PKU, there is a growing body of evidence that suggests that neurocognitive, psychosocial, quality of life, growth, nutrition, bone pathology and maternal PKU outcomes are suboptimal. The time may be right for revisiting the 2000 NIH Consensus Statement in order to address a number of important issues related to PKU management, including treatment advancements for metabolic control in PKU, blood Phe variability, neurocognitive and psychological assessments, routine screening measures for nutritional biomarkers, and bone pathology.

Phenylketonuria: a 21st century perspective

Phenylketonuria is the most prevalent inherited defect in amino acid metabolism. Owing to mutations in the gene encoding the enzyme phenylalanine hydroxylase, the essential amino acid phenylalanine cannot be hydroxylated to tyrosine and blood and tissue concentrations of phenylalanine increase. Untreated, phenylketonuria causes severe mental retardation, epilepsy and behavioral problems. The combined effect of neonatal screening and treatment has, however, meant that phenylketonuria is now a biochemical rather than a clinical diagnosis. Treatment consists of stringent dietary restriction of natural protein intake and supplementation of amino acids other than phenylalanine by a chemically manufactured protein substitute. Although clinical outcome on a phenylalanine-restricted diet is good, neuropsychological deficits are now known to exist in dietary-treated patients with phenylketonuria, and quality of life, nutritional condition and psychosocial outcome could probably also be improved. The need for new therapeutic approaches is being met by supplementation with tetrahydrobiopterin or large neutral amino acids, whilst development of the use of phenylalanine ammonia lyase, and, in the longer term, gene therapy and chaperone treatment holds promise. This Review provides an overview of the history of phenylketonuria, the challenges of treatment today and the treatment possibilities in the near future.

Challenges and pitfalls in the management of phenylketonuria

Despite recent advances in the management of phenylketonuria and hyperphenylalaninemia, important questions on the management of this disorder remain unanswered. Consensus exists on the need for neonatal screening and early treatment, yet disagreement persists over threshold levels of blood phenylalanine for starting treatment, target blood phenylalanine levels, and the management of older patient groups. The mainstay of treatment is a phenylalanine-restricted diet, but its application varies between and within countries. Beyond diet treatment, there is a lack of consensus on the use of newer treatments such as tetrahydrobiopterin. Although neonatal screening and early treatment has meant that most well-treated children grow up with near-normal IQ scores, the effect of relaxing metabolic control on cognitive and executive function later in life is still not fully understood. Although it is clear from the available literature that the active control of blood phenylalanine levels is of vital importance, there are other treatment-related factors that affect outcome. A uniform and firmly evidence-based approach to the management of phenylketonuria is required.