In situ localization of C3 synthesis in experimental acute renal allograft rejection

Hemolytic uremic syndrome: a fatal outcome after kidney and liver transplantation performed to correct factor h gene mutation

Factor H-associated hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS) is a genetic form of thrombotic microangiopathy characterized by deficient factor H (HF-1) levels/activity and uncontrolled complement activation. The disorder mostly leads to end-stage renal disease and often recurs after kidney transplantation. We previously demonstrated that in a child with HF-1-associated HUS a simultaneous kidney and liver transplantation restored the defective HF-1 with no recurrence of the disease in the transplanted kidney. Here we describe a second childhood case of HF-1-associated HUS treated by combined kidney and liver transplant and complicated by a fatal, primary non-function of the liver graft. Graft hypoperfusion during surgery triggered ischemia/reperfusion changes and complement activation. Conceivably, as a result of defective complement regulatory potential, massive shedding of vascular heparan sulfates was documented in the transplanted liver. This might have impaired the physiological thromboresistance of vascular endothelium ending with widespread microvascular thrombosis and infarction. This case indicates that more fundamental research is needed before combined liver and kidney transplant is considered an option for children with HF-1-associated HUS.

Delayed graft function in kidney transplantation

Delayed graft function is a form of acute renal failure resulting in post-transplantation oliguria, increased allograft immunogenicity and risk of acute rejection episodes, and decreased long-term survival. Factors related to the donor and prerenal, renal, or postrenal transplant factors related to the recipient can contribute to this condition. From experimental studies, we have learnt that both ischaemia and reinstitution of blood flow in ischaemically damaged kidneys after hypothermic preservation activate a complex sequence of events that sustain renal injury and play a pivotal part in the development of delayed graft function. Elucidation of the pathophysiology of renal ischaemia and reperfusion injury has contributed to the development of strategies to decrease the rate of delayed graft function, focusing on donor management, organ procurement and preservation techniques, recipient fluid management, and pharmacological agents (vasodilators, antioxidants, anti-inflammatory agents). Several new drugs show promise in animal studies in preventing or ameliorating ischaemia-reperfusion injury and possibly delayed graft function, but definitive clinical trials are lacking. The goal of monotherapy for the prevention or treatment of is perhaps unattainable, and multidrug approaches or single drug targeting multiple signals will be the next step to reduce post-transplantation injury and delayed graft function.

Banff 2003 meeting report: new diagnostic insights and standards

The Seventh Banff Conference on Allograft Pathology was held June 14-18, 2003 in Aberdeen, Scotland representing the latest iteration of the international consensus meeting, which develops worldwide standards for interpretation of allograft biopsies. The meeting is an important force behind standardized slide interpretation to strengthen endpoints in international clinical trials. Of participants polled 87% reported that they would alter clinical practice as a direct consequence of the meeting and its content. Advances were made in many areas including tubulitis mechanisms, real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) gene analysis and microarrays in rejection diagnosis, tolerance/accommodation/immunomodulation, the role of monocytes and macrophages in rejection and C4d as a marker for antibody-mediated rejection. A provisional scoring system for peritubular capillary inflammatory cell accumulation in antibody-mediated rejection was presented for testing, as well as plans for a nephrectomy study to determine specificity of vascular lesions of rejection. Future meetings are planned for 2005 (Edmonton), 2007 and 2009, with active ongoing Internet discussion between meetings.

The membrane attack complex, C5b-9, up regulates collagen gene expression in renal tubular epithelial cells

Evidence suggesting a direct role for proteinuria in the pathogenesis of renal tubulointerstitial fibrosis is accumulating. However the mechanism by which proteinuria leads to injury is unknown. In proteinuric states complement proteins are filtered through the glomerulus and could contribute to the tubular damage. The aim of this study was to investigate the role of complement activation in the progression of interstitial fibrosis. To determine whether complement activation may be responsible for the pro-fibrotic response that occurs in the tubulointerstitial compartment we stimulated primary cultures of proximal tubular epithelial cells with membrane attack complex, C5b-9. This led to increased mRNA concentrations of both collagen type IV and its intracellular chaperone, Heat Shock Protein 47 (HSP47). To determine whether this occurred in vivo Adriamycin was used to induce proteinuria in female Balb/c mice. The expression of collagen type IV and HSP47 was increased in proteinuric mice compared to control mice. In proteinuric mouse kidney, C3 was deposited at sites of tubulointerstitial injury and there was a relationship between C3 deposition and immunochemical staining for collagen type IV and HSP47. In situ hybridization suggested that the renal tubular epithelium was actively expressing HSP47 mRNA and, by implication, excess collagen. These observations support the hypothesis that complement activation on tubular epithelial cells can directly increase the pro-fibrotic process associated with tubulointerstitial damage.

Nontransgenic hyperexpression of a complement regulator in donor kidney modulates transplant ischemia/reperfusion damage, acute rejection, and chronic nephropathy

Complement activation during ischemia and reperfusion contributes to the development of tissue injury with severe negative impact on outcomes in transplantation. To counter the effect of complement, we present a strategy to deliver a novel complement regulator stabilized on cell surfaces within donor organs. The membrane-bound complement regulator is able to inhibit complement activation when the donor organ is revascularized and exposed to host-circulating complement. Application of this construct to donor kidneys protected transplanted tissues from ischemia/reperfusion injury and reduced the deposition of activated complement and histological signs of damage under conditions in which a nontargeted control construct was ineffective. Treatment of donor organs in this way improved graft performance in the short and long term. An analysis of the immune response in allograft recipients showed that reducing graft damage at the time of transplantation through complement regulation also modulated the alloresponse. Additionally, the results of perfusion studies with human kidneys demonstrated the feasibility of targeting endothelial and epithelial surfaces with this construct, to allow investigation in clinical transplantation.

Locally produced complement and its role in renal allograft rejection

The role of innate immunity in allograft injury is just beginning to become clear, and complement is probably one of a number of factors that are activated very early in the course of transplantation. Kidney transplantation into complement-inhibited rats reduces subsequent inflammation of the graft, probably as a result of reduction of ischemia reperfusion damage as well as diminution of immune mediated damage. Closer analysis of the role of locally synthesised components in mice has suggested that regional synthesis of complement proteins, in particular by the renal tubule, may play a more important role than circulating components. A marked effect on the antidonor T cell response may be explained by the triggering of complement receptors present on antigen presenting cells or T cells infiltrating the graft, or by a more direct effect of complement on the liaison between proximal tubule cells and T cells. Therapeutic control is likely to require a shift to a more targeted approach, directed at complement components produced in the extravascular tissue compartment.

C3D deposition in peritubular capillaries indicates a variant of acute renal allograft rejection characterized by a worse clinical outcome

BACKGROUND

C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries (PTCs) is a sign of humoral renal allograft rejection and an independent predictor of graft survival. Few investigators have focused on the meaning of capillary C3 deposition in rejecting grafts. Because C3 production can result from both classic and alternative pathway activation of the complement cascade, it is not clear whether C3 deposition indicates a distinct entity of acute rejection (AR) or merely represents a separate form of C4d-positive AR.

METHODS

We examined the deposition of C3d in the PTCs of recipients with AR in the first year posttransplantation (n=30). Clinical outcome variables and histology were compared with C3d-negative control patients (n=82).

RESULTS

C3d-positive patients demonstrated more frequent preexisting T-cell antibodies (57%) and more re-transplants (37%), and they received more blood transfusions (mean 10.3 units). C3d-positive patients experienced more frequent multiple AR episodes (57%) and delayed graft function (36.7%). All nine C3d-positive recipients screened for posttransplantation donor-specific human leukocyte antigen antibodies demonstrated positive results. Graft failure occurred in 23% of C3d-positive recipients (7.3% in the control group) (P=0.03). C3d-positive biopsies showed significantly less tubulitis (P=0.03), whereas congestive PTCs with intraluminal accumulation of polymorphonuclear leukocytes were conspicuous. Thrombi, fibrinoid necrosis, and acute tubular necrosis were not more pronounced. In 19% of rejection biopsies, C3d deposition in PTCs was present without C4d deposition. In the remaining biopsies, C3d and C4d deposition was found simultaneously.

CONCLUSIONS

The deposition of complement factor C3d in PTCs indicates a variant type of AR characterized by a worse clinical outcome.

The effect of locally synthesised complement on acute renal allograft rejection

The complement system of components and receptors is one of the earliest forms of defence. Excessive or inappropriate activation can result in tissue damage, classically illustrated in immune-mediated nephritis. In addition, complement forms a bridge between innate and adaptive immunity, helping to prepare and focus T and B lymphocyte responses. More recent research in renal allograft models has shown that complement-inhibited and complement-deficient animals have reduced inflammatory injury and lowered antidonor immune responses. Furthermore, it is known that the transplanted kidney is a significant site of local synthesis of C3, although until recently the relative contribution of locally produced C3 to transplant injury was unknown. Current evidence indicates that defective local synthesis of C3 both reduces tissue injury and lowers the antidonor T cell response, substantially increasing graft survival. Among various possible explanations to account for these findings, the data favours a direct effect of complement on alloreactive T cell stimulation. Study of complement gene regulation by common immunosuppressive agents suggests that they do not influence local complement synthesis. Alternative approaches are therefore required to control the local effect of complement in the extravascular tissue compartment of the graft.

C5a is important in the tubulointerstitial component of experimental immune complex glomerulonephritis

Interstitial injury is the hallmark of glomerulonephritis which is progressing to end-stage renal disease (ESRD). In humans and experimental animals, we have shown that interstitial disease is accompanied by up-regulation of complement components in tubular epithelial cells. Glomerulonephritis was induced in mice by the intraperitoneal injection of horse spleen apoferritin (HSA) and lipopolysaccharide (LPS). In addition to wild-type C57/B6 mice, animals in which the C5a receptor had been deleted (C5aR KO) were used. Animals were killed after 3 or 6 weeks, and kidneys harvested. At three weeks, both groups had evidence of mild mesangial matrix expansion and increased cellularity; there were no crescents, sclerotic lesions, or interstitial disease. At six weeks, glomerular lesions were advanced, but identical in the two groups. Both groups had evidence of an identical pattern of C3 gene expression in the tubular epithelium by in situ hybridization. There was a marked difference, however, in the extent of interstitial injury. Wild-type animals had significantly greater numbers of infiltrating interstitial cells, greater expansion of the peritubular space, more tubular atrophy, and more apoptotic tubular cells than did C5aR KOs. The anaphylotoxic fragment of C5, C5a, is not likely to be important in the glomerular component of this model of progressive glomerulonephritis. On the other hand, the interstitial component is markedly attenuated in knockout animals. These data support a role for complement in the interstitial component of this glomerulonephritis model. They are consistent with our hypotheses of a role for complement in the progression of some forms of glomerulonephritis to ESRD.

Membrane attack complex contributes to destruction of vascular integrity in acute lung allograft rejection

The lung is known to be particularly susceptible to complement-mediated injury. Both C5a and the membrane attack complex (MAC), which is formed by the terminal components of complement (C5b-C9), can cause acute pulmonary distress in nontransplanted lungs. We used C6-deficient rats to investigate whether MAC causes injury to lung allografts. PVG.R8 lungs were transplanted orthotopically to MHC class I-incompatible PVG.1U recipients. Allografts from C6-sufficient (C6(+)) donors to C6(+) recipients were rejected with an intense vascular infiltration and diffuse alveolar hemorrhage 7 days after transplantation (n = 5). Ab and complement (C3d) deposition was accompanied by extensive vascular endothelial injury and intravascular release of von Willebrand factor. In contrast, lung allografts from C6-deficient (C6(-)) donors to C6(-) recipients survived 13-17 days (n = 5). In the absence of C6, perivascular mononuclear infiltrates of ED1(+) macrophages and CD8(+) T lymphocytes were present 7 days after transplantation, but vascular endothelial cells were quiescent, with minimal von Willebrand factor release and no evidence of alveolar hemorrhage or edema. Lung allografts were performed from C6(-) donors to C6(+) recipients (n = 5) and from C6(+) donors to C6(-) recipients (n = 5) to separate the effects of systemic and local C6 production. Lungs transplanted from C6(+) donors to C6(-) recipients had increased alveolar macrophages and capillary injury. C6 production by lung allografts was demonstrated at the mRNA and protein levels. These results demonstrate that MAC causes vascular injury in lung allografts and that the location of injury is dependent on the source of C6.

Differential allograft gene expression in acute cellular rejection and recurrence of hepatitis C after liver transplantation

Treatment of acute cellular rejection (ACR) is associated with increased viral load, more severe histologic recurrence, and diminished patient and graft survival after liver transplantation for hepatitis C virus (HCV). Recurrence of HCV may be difficult to distinguish histologically from ACR. Because the immunologic mechanisms of ACR and HCV recurrence are likely to differ, we hypothesized that ACR is associated with the expression of a specific subset of immune activation genes that may serve as a diagnostic indicator of ACR and provide mechanistic insight into the pathophysiology of ACR and recurrence of HCV. The goal of the study was to study intragraft gene expression patterns in ACR and during recurrence of HCV in HCV-infected recipients. High-density microarrays were used to determine relative intragraft gene expression in two groups of HCV-infected liver transplant recipients: four with steroid responsive ACR by Banff criteria and four age- and gender-matched HCV-infected recipients with similar necroinflammatory activity but without histological criteria for rejection (no cholangitis or endotheliitis). Immunosuppression was similar in both groups. Other etiologies of graft dysfunction were excluded by ultrasound, cholangiography, and cultures. High-quality total RNA was extracted from snap frozen liver biopsies, reverse transcribed, labeled with biotin, and fragmented according to established protocol. Twenty-five genes were relatively overexpressed, and 15 were relatively underexpressed by > or = twofold in the ACR when compared with the HCV group. ACR was most notably associated with the relative overexpression of genes associated with major histocompatibility complex I and II, insulin-like growth factor-1 expression, apoptosis induction, and T-cell activation. In HCV-infected liver transplant recipients, ACR is associated with an intragraft gene expression profile that is distinct from that seen during recurrence of HCV. These experiments provide evidence that alloimmunity, as indicated by expression of T-cell activation and apoptosis-inducing genes, is less important in recurrence of HCV than in ACR. Further studies are required to determine whether gene expression profiles, either intragraft or in serum, can be used for the diagnosis and differentiation of ACR from recurrence of HCV.

Local synthesis of complement component C3 regulates acute renal transplant rejection

Accumulating evidence suggests that innate immunity interacts with the adaptive immune system to identify potentially harmful antigens and eliminate them from the host. A central facet of innate immunity is complement, which for some time has been recognized as a contributor to inflammation in transplant rejection but without detailed analysis of its role in what is principally a T cell mediated process. Moreover, epithelial and vascular tissues at local sites of inflammation secrete complement components; however, the role of such local synthesis remains unclear. Here we show that the absence of locally synthesized complement component C3 is capable of modulating the rejection of renal allografts in vivo and regulating T-cell responses in vivo and in vitro. The results indicate that improved success in kidney transplantation could come from therapeutic manipulation of innate immunity in concert with T cell directed immunosuppression.

Intrarenal synthesis of complement

During the past decade, research has shown that the kidney has the capacity to synthesize most of the activation pathway components of the complement cascade. As well as implying physiological roles in local clearance of immune complexes and defense against invasive organisms, an increasing amount of evidence indicates that the intrarenal synthesis of complement makes an important contribution in the pathogenesis of renal injury. Here we review this evidence and present a case for more definitive investigation of these functions.