X-ray studies on the interaction of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S with microbial lipid extracts: evidence for cubic phase formation

Tuning curvature and stability of monoolein bilayers by designer lipid-like peptide surfactants

This study reports the effect of loading four different charged designer lipid-like short anionic and cationic peptide surfactants on the fully hydrated monoolein (MO)-based Pn3m phase (Q(224)). The studied peptide surfactants comprise seven amino acid residues, namely A(6)D, DA(6), A(6)K, and KA(6). D (aspartic acid) bears two negative charges, K (lysine) bears one positive charge, and A (alanine) constitutes the hydrophobic tail. To elucidate the impact of these peptide surfactants, the ternary MO/peptide/water system has been investigated using small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), within a certain range of peptide concentrations (R Collapse

Key Words Collapse

MESH Headings

• Anions
• Lipid Bilayers
• Lipids/chemistry
• Models, Molecular
• Peptides/chemistry
• Scattering, Radiation
• Surface-Active Agents/chemistry
• Temperature

Collapse

Grants Collapse

Affiliation(s)

Anan Yaghmur Institute of Biophysics and Nanosystems Research (IBN), Austrian Academy of Sciences, Graz, Austria.
Peter Laggner
Shuguang Zhang
Michael Rappolt

Collapse

Structural rearrangement of model membranes by the peptide antibiotic NK-2

We have developed a novel alpha-helical peptide antibiotic termed NK-2. It efficiently kills bacteria, but not human cells, by membrane destruction. This selectivity could be attributed to the different membrane lipid compositions of the target cells. To understand the mechanisms of selectivity and membrane destruction, we investigated the influence of NK-2 on the supramolecular aggregate structure, the phase transition behavior, the acyl chain fluidity, and the surface charges of phospholipids representative for the bacterial and the human cell cytoplasmic membranes. The cationic NK-2 binds to anionic phosphatidylglycerol liposomes, causing a thinning of the membrane and an increase in the phase transition temperature. However, this interaction is not solely of electrostatic but also of hydrophobic nature, indicated by an overcompensation of the Zeta potential. Whereas NK-2 has no effect on phosphatidylcholine liposomes, it enhances the fluidity of phosphatidylethanolamine acyl chains and lowers the phase transition enthalpy of the gel to liquid cristalline transition. The most dramatic effect, however, was observed for the lamellar/inverted hexagonal transition of phosphatidylethanolamine which was reduced by more than 10 degrees C. Thus, NK-2 promotes a negative membrane curvature which can lead to the collapse of the phosphatidylethanolamine-rich bacterial cytoplasmic membrane.

Structure-activity relationships of diastereomeric lysine ring size analogs of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S: mechanism of action and discrimination between bacterial and animal cell membranes

Structure-activity relationships were examined in seven gramicidin S analogs in which the ring-expanded analog GS14 [cyclo-(VKLKVdYPLKVKLdYP)] is modified by enantiomeric inversions of its lysine residues. The conformation, amphiphilicity, and self-association propensity of these peptides were investigated by circular dichroism spectroscopy and reversed phase high performance liquid chromatography. (31)P nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopic and dye leakage experiments were performed to evaluate the capacity of these peptides to induce inverse nonlamellar phases in, and to permeabilize phospholipid bilayers; their growth inhibitory activity against the cell wall-less mollicute Acholeplasma laidlawii B was also examined. The amount and stability of beta-sheet structure, effective hydrophobicity, propensity for self-association in water, ability to disrupt the organization of phospholipid bilayers, and ability to inhibit A. laidlawii B growth are strongly correlated with the facial amphiphilicity of these GS14 analogs. Also, the magnitude of the parameters segregate these peptides into three groups, consisting of GS14, the four single inversion analogs, and the two multiple inversion analogs. The capacity of these peptides to differentiate between bacterial and animal cell membranes exhibits a biphasic relationship with peptide amphiphilicity, suggesting that there may only be a narrow range of peptide amphiphilicity within which it is possible to achieve the dual therapeutic requirements of high antibiotic effectiveness and low hemolytic activity. These results were rationalized by considering how the physiochemical properties of these GS14 analogs are likely to be reflected in their partitioning into lipid bilayer membranes.

Effects of single D-amino acid substitutions on disruption of beta-sheet structure and hydrophobicity in cyclic 14-residue antimicrobial peptide analogs related to gramicidin S

Gramicidin S (GS) is a 10-residue cyclic beta-sheet peptide with lytic activity against the membranes of both microbial and human cells, i.e. it possesses little to no biologic specificity for either cell type. Structure-activity studies of de novo-designed 14-residue cyclic peptides based on GS have previously shown that higher specificity against microbial membranes, i.e. a high therapeutic index (TI), can be achieved by the replacement of a single L-amino acid with its corresponding D-enantiomer [Kondejewski, L.H. et al. (1999) J. Biol. Chem. 274, 13181]. The diastereomer with a D-Lys substituted at position 4 caused the greatest improvement in specificity vs. other L to D substitutions within the cyclic 14-residue peptide GS14, through a combination of decreased peptide amphipathicity and disrupted beta-sheet structure in aqueous conditions [McInnes, C. et al. (2000) J. Biol. Chem. 275, 14287]. Based on this information, we have created a series of peptide diastereomers substituted only at position 4 by a D- or L-amino acid (Leu, Phe, Tyr, Asn, Lys, and achiral Gly). The amino acids chosen in this study represent a range of hydrophobicities/hydrophilicities as a subset of the 20 naturally occurring amino acids. While the D- and L-substitutions of Leu, Phe, and Tyr all resulted in strong hemolytic activity, the substitutions of hydrophilic D-amino acids D-Lys and D-Asn in GS14 at position 4 resulted in weaker hemolytic activity than in the L-diastereomers, which demonstrated strong hemolysis. All of the L-substitutions also resulted in poor antimicrobial activity and an extremely low TI, while the antimicrobial activity of the D-substituted peptides tended to improve based on the hydrophilicity of the residue. D-Lys was the most polar and most efficacious substitution, resulting in the highest TI. Interestingly, the hydrophobic D-amino acid substitutions had superior antimicrobial activity vs. the L-enantiomers although substitution of a hydrophobic D-amino acid increases the nonpolar face hydrophobicity. These results further support the role of hydrophobicity of the nonpolar face as a major influence on microbial specificity, but also highlights the importance of a disrupted beta-sheet structure on antimicrobial activity.

The cyclic antimicrobial peptide RTD-1 induces stabilized lipid-peptide domains more efficiently than its open-chain analogue

The effects of a mammalian cyclic antimicrobial peptide, rhesus theta defensin 1 (RTD-1) and its open chain analogue (oRTD-1), on the phase behaviour and structure of model membrane systems (dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine, DPPC and dipalmitoyl phosphatidylglycerol, DPPG) were studied. The increased selectivity of RTD-1 for anionic DPPG over zwitterionic DPPC was shown by differential scanning calorimetry. RTD-1, at a molar peptide-lipid ratio of 1:100, induced considerable changes in the phase behaviour of DPPG, but not of DPPC. The main transition temperature, Tm, was unchanged, but additional phase transitions appeared above Tm. oRTD-1 induced similar effects. However, the effects were not observable below a peptide:lipid molar ratio of 1:50, which correlates with the weaker biological activity of oRTD-1. Small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering revealed for DPPG the appearance of additional structural features induced by RTD-1 above Tm, which were interpreted as correlated lamellar structures, with increased order of the fatty acyl side chains of the lipid. It is proposed that after initial electrostatic interaction of the cationic rim of the peptide with the anionic DPPG headgroups, leading to stabilized lipid-peptide clusters, the hydrophobic face of the peptide assists in its interaction with the fatty acyl side chains eventually leading to membrane disruption.

Structure-activity relationships of de novo designed cyclic antimicrobial peptides based on gramicidin S

The cyclic beta-sheet structure possessed by the 10-residue antibiotic peptide gramicidin S was taken as the structural framework for the de novo design of biologically active peptides with membrane-active properties. We have shown from previous studies that gramicidin S is a broad-spectrum antibiotic effective against Gram-positive bacteria, Gram-negative bacteria, and fungi, but is toxic to human red blood cells. We tested the effect of ring size on antimicrobial activity and hemolytic activity on peptides varying from 4 to 16 residues. Interestingly, we were able to dissociate hemolytic activity and antimicrobial activity by increasing the ring size of the peptide to 14 residues (peptide GS14). Furthermore, we increased specificity for microbial membranes while decreasing toxicity to red blood cells by substituting enantiomers (D-amino acids for L-amino acids and vice versa) into the GS14 sequence. The enantiomeric substitutions all disrupted beta-sheet structure in benign medium and decreased peptide amphipathicity. The least amphipathic peptide, produced by substituting a D-Lys at position 4 of GS14 (peptide GS14K4), also had the highest therapeutic index, i.e., highest degree of specificity for microbial cells over human cells. Solution structures of GS14 analogs solved by NMR spectroscopy showed that the D-amino acid side chain was located on the nonpolar face of GS14K4. Another analog, a beta-sheet peptide with reduced amphipathicity (peptide GS14 K3L4), also had a lysine (lysine 3) on the nonpolar face as determined by the NMR structure. Both GS14K4 and GS14 K3L4 had reduced amphipathicity relative to GS14 and much higher therapeutic indices. Finally, the alteration of the nonpolar face hydrophobicity of GS14K4 analogs provided a range of activities and specificities, where the peptides with the intermediate hydrophobicities among the series had the highest therapeutic indices. The optimal peptide hydrophobicities varied depending on the microorganism being tested, with higher hydrophobicity requirements against Gram-positive bacteria and yeast compared with Gram-negative microorganisms. The net result of these studies suggests that it is possible to rationally design a cyclic membrane-active antimicrobial peptide with high specificity towards prokaryotic (bacterial and fungal) membranes and minimal toxicity to eukaryotic (e.g., mammalian) membranes.

The antibiotic activity of cationic linear amphipathic peptides: lessons from the action of leucine/lysine copolymers on bacteria of the class Mollicutes

Peptides composed of leucyl and lysyl residues ('LK peptides') with different compositions and sequences were compared for their antibacterial activities using cell wall-less bacteria of the class Mollicutes (acholeplasmas, mycoplasmas and spiroplasmas) as targets. The antibacterial activity of the amphipathic alpha-helical peptides varied with their size, 15 residues being the optimal length, independent of the membrane hydrophobic core thickness and the amount of cholesterol. The 15-residue ideally amphipathic alpha helix with a +5 positive net charge (KLLKLLLKLLLKLLK) had the strongest antibacterial activity, similar to that of melittin. In contrast, scrambled peptides devoid of amphipathy and the less hydrophobic beta-sheeted peptides [(LK)nK], even those 15-residue long, were far less potent than the helical ones. Furthermore, the growth inhibitory activity of the peptides was correlated with their ability to abolish membrane potential. These data are fully consistent with a predominantly flat orientation of LK peptides at the lipid/water interface and strongly supports that these peptides and probably the linear polycationic amphipathic defence peptides act on bacterial membranes in four main steps according to the 'carpet' model: (a) interfacial partitioning with accumulation of monomers on the target membrane (limiting step); (b) peptide structural changes (conformation, aggregation, and orientation) induced by interactions with the lipid bilayer (as already shown with liposomes and erythrocytes); (c) plasma membrane permeabilization/depolarization via a detergent-like effect; and (d) rapid bacterial cell death if the extent of depolarization is maintained above a critical threshold.

Mechanism of the lamellar/inverse hexagonal phase transition examined by high resolution x-ray diffraction

For the first time the electron density of the lamellar liquid crystalline as well as of the inverted hexagonal phase could be retrieved at the transition temperature. A reliable decomposition of the d-spacings into hydrophobic and hydrophilic structure elements could be performed owing to the presence of a sufficient number of reflections. While the hydrocarbon chain length, d(C), in the lamellar phase with a value of 14.5 A lies within the extreme limits of the estimated chain length of the inverse hexagonal phase 10 A < d(C) < 16 A, the changes in the hydrophilic region vary strongly. During the lamellar-to-inverse hexagonal phase transition the area per lipid molecule reduces by approximately 25%, and the number of water molecules per lipid increases from 14 to 18. On the basis of the analysis of the structural components of each phase, the interface between the coexisting mesophases between 66 and 84 degrees C has been examined in detail, and a model for the formation of the first rods in the matrix of the lamellar phospholipid stack is discussed. Judging from the structural relations between the inverse hexagonal and the lamellar phase, we suggest a cooperative chain reaction of rod formation at the transition midpoint, which is mainly driven by minimizing the interstitial region.

The effects of ring-size analogs of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S on phospholipid bilayer model membranes and on the growth of Acholeplasma laidlawii B

We have examined the effects of three ring-size analogs of the cyclic beta-sheet antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S (GS) on the thermotropic phase behavior and permeability of phospholipid model membranes and on the growth of the cell wall-less Gram-positive bacteria Acholeplasma laidlawii B. These three analogs have ring sizes of 10 (GS10), 12 (GS12) or 14 (GS14) amino acids, respectively. Our high-sensitivity differential scanning calorimetric studies indicate that all three of these GS analogs perturb the gel/liquid-crystalline phase transition of zwitterionic phosphatidylcholine (PtdCho) vesicles to a greater extent than of zwitterionic phosphatidylethanolamine (PtdEtn) or of anionic phosphatidylglycerol (PtdGro) vesicles, in contrast to GS itself, which interacts more strongly with PtdGro than with PtdCho and PtdEtn bilayers. However, the relative potency of the perturbation of phospholipid phase behavior varies markedly between the three peptides, generally decreasing in the order GS14 > GS10 > GS12. Similarly, these three GS ring-size analogs also differ considerably in their ability to cause fluorescence dye leakage from phospholipid vesicles, with the potency of permeabilization also generally decreasing in the order GS14 > GS10 > GS12. Finally, these GS ring-size analogs also differentially inhibit the growth of A. laidlawii with growth inhibition also decreasing in the order GS14 > GS10 > GS12. These results indicate that the relative potencies of GS and its ring-size analogs in perturbing the organization and increasing the permeability of phospholipid bilayer model membranes, and of inhibiting the growth of A. laidlawii B cells, are at least qualitatively correlated, and provide further support for the hypothesis that the primary target of these antimicrobial peptides is the lipid bilayer of the bacterial membrane. The very high antimicrobial activity of GS14 against the cell wall-less bacteria A. laidlawii as compared to various conventional bacteria confirms our earlier suggestion that the avid binding of this peptide to the bacterial cell wall is primarily responsible for its reduced antimicrobial activity against such organisms. The relative magnitude of the effects of GS itself, and of the three ring-size GS analogs, on phospholipid bilayer organization and cell growth correlate relatively well with the effective hydrophobicities and amphiphilicities of these peptides but less well with their relative charge density, intrinsic hydrophobicities or conformational flexibilities. Nevertheless, all of these parameters, as well as others, may influence the antimicrobial potency and hemolytic activity of GS analogs.

Conformation and interaction of the cyclic cationic antimicrobial peptides in lipid bilayers

To investigate the role of peptide-membrane interactions in the biological activity of cyclic cationic peptides, the conformations and interactions of four membrane-active antimicrobial peptides [based on Gramicidin S (GS)] were examined in neutral and negatively charged micelles and phospholipid vesicles, using CD and fluorescence spectroscopy and ultracentrifugation techniques. Moreover, the effects of these peptides on the release of entrapped fluorescent dye from unilamellar vesicles of phosphatidylcholine (PC) and phosphatidylethanolamine/phosphatidylglycerol (PE/PG) were studied. The cyclic peptides include GS10 [Cyclo(VKLdYP)2], GS12 [Cyclo(VKLKdYPKVKLdYP)], GS14 [Cyclo(VKLKVdYPLKVKLdYP)] and [d-Lys]4GS14 [Cyclo(VKLdKVdYPLKVKLdYP)] (underlined residues are d-amino acids), were different in their ring size, structure and amphipathicity, and covered a broad spectrum of hemolytic and antimicrobial activities. Interaction of the peptides with the zwitterionic PC and negatively charged PE/PG vesicles were distinct from each other. The hydrophobic interaction seems to be the dominant factor in the hemolytic activity of the peptides, as well as their interaction with the PC vesicles. A combination of electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions of the peptides induces aggregation and fusion in PE/PG vesicles with different propensities in the order: [d-Lys]4GS14 > GS14 > GS12 > GS10. GS10 and GS14 are apparently located in the deeper levels of the membrane interfaces and closer to the hydrophobic core of the bilayers, whereas GS12 and [d-Lys]4GS14 reside closer to the outer boundary of the interface. Because of differing modes of interaction of the cyclic cationic peptides with lipid bilayers, the mechanism of their biological activity (and its relation to peptide-lipid interaction) proved to be versatile and complex, and dependent on the biophysical properties of both the peptides and membranes.

Effects of lipid composition on membrane permeabilization by sticholysin I and II, two cytolysins of the sea anemone Stichodactyla helianthus

Sticholysin I and II (St I and St II), two basic cytolysins purified from the Caribbean sea anemone Stichodactyla helianthus, efficiently permeabilize lipid vesicles by forming pores in their membranes. A general characteristic of these toxins is their preference for membranes containing sphingomyelin (SM). As a consequence, vesicles formed by equimolar mixtures of SM with phosphatidylcholine (PC) are very good targets for St I and II. To better characterize the lipid dependence of the cytolysin-membrane interaction, we have now evaluated the effect of including different lipids in the composition of the vesicles. We observed that at low doses of either St I or St II vesicles composed of SM and phosphatidic acid (PA) were permeabilized faster and to a higher extent than vesicles of PC and SM. As in the case of PC/SM mixtures, permeabilization was optimal when the molar ratio of PA/SM was ~1. The preference for membranes containing PA was confirmed by inhibition experiments in which the hemolytic activity of St I was diminished by pre-incubation with vesicles of different composition. The inclusion of even small proportions of PA into PC/SM LUVs led to a marked increase in calcein release caused by both St I and St II, reaching maximal effect at ~5 mol % of PA. Inclusion of other negatively charged lipids (phosphatidylserine (PS), phosphatidylglycerol (PG), phosphatidylinositol (PI), or cardiolipin (CL)), all at 5 mol %, also elicited an increase in calcein release, the potency being in the order CL approximately PA >> PG approximately PI approximately PS. However, some boosting effect was also obtained, including the zwitterionic lipid phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) or even, albeit to a lesser extent, the positively charged lipid stearylamine (SA). This indicated that the effect was not mediated by electrostatic interactions between the cytolysin and the negative surface of the vesicles. In fact, increasing the ionic strength of the medium had only a small inhibitory effect on the interaction, but this was actually larger with uncharged vesicles than with negatively charged vesicles. A study of the fluidity of the different vesicles, probed by the environment-sensitive fluorescent dye diphenylhexatriene (DPH), showed that toxin activity was also not correlated to the average membrane fluidity. It is suggested that the insertion of the toxin channel could imply the formation in the bilayer of a nonlamellar structure, a toroidal lipid pore. In this case, the presence of lipids favoring a nonlamellar phase, in particular PA and CL, strong inducers of negative curvature in the bilayer, could help in the formation of the pore. This possibility is confirmed by the fact that the formation of toxin pores strongly promotes the rate of transbilayer movement of lipid molecules, which indicates local disruption of the lamellar structure.

Cholesterol attenuates the interaction of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S with phospholipid bilayer membranes

We have investigated the effect of the presence of 25 mol percent cholesterol on the interactions of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S (GS) with phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylethanolamine model membrane systems using a variety of methods. Our circular dichroism spectroscopic measurements indicate that the incorporation of cholesterol into egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles has no significant effect on the conformation of the GS molecule but that this peptide resides in a range of intermediate polarity as compared to aqueous solution or an organic solvent. Our Fourier transform infrared spectroscopic measurements confirm these findings and demonstrate that in both cholesterol-containing and cholesterol-free dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine liquid-crystalline bilayers, GS is located in a region of intermediate polarity at the polar--nonpolar interfacial region of the lipid bilayer. However, GS appears to be located in a more polar environment nearer the bilayer surface when cholesterol is present. Our (31)P-nuclear magnetic resonance studies demonstrate that the presence of cholesterol markedly reduces the tendency of GS to induce the formation of inverted nonlamellar phases in model membranes composed of an unsaturated phosphatidylethanolamine. Finally, fluorescence dye leakage experiments indicate that cholesterol inhibits the GS-induced permeabilization of phosphatidylcholine vesicles. Thus in all respects the presence of cholesterol attenuates but does not abolish the interactions of GS with, and the characteristic effects of GS on, phospholipid bilayers. These findings may explain why it is more potent at disrupting cholesterol-free bacterial than cholesterol-containing eukaryotic membranes while nevertheless disrupting the integrity of the latter at higher peptide concentrations. This additional example of the lipid specificity of GS may aid in the rational design of GS analogs with increased antibacterial but reduced hemolytic activities.

Interaction of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S with dimyristoyl--phosphatidylcholine bilayer membranes: a densitometry and sound velocimetry study

We determined changes in the volume and adiabatic compressibility of large multi- and unilamellar vesicles composed of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine containing various concentrations of the antimicrobial peptide gramicidin S (GS) by applying densitometry and sound velocimetry. Gramicidin S incorporation was found to progressively decrease the phase transition temperature of DMPC vesicles as well as to decrease the degree of cooperativity of the main phase transition and to increase the volume compressibility of the vesicles. GS probably enhanced thermal fluctuations at the region of main phase transition and provide more freedom of rotational movement for the phospholipid hydrocarbon chains. The ability of GS to increase the membrane compressibility and to decrease the phase transition temperature is evidence for regions of distorted membrane structure around incorporated gramicidin S molecules. At relatively high GS concentration (10 mol%), more significant changes of specific volume and compressibility appear. This might suggest changes in the integrity of the lipid bilayer upon interaction with high concentrations of GS.

Self-regulation of the lipid content of membranes by non-bilayer lipids: a hypothesis

Many biological membranes contain lipids that do not form a lamellar phase but the roles of these lipids are not well understood. An artificial membrane assembled from the main non-bilayer lipid and the major integral protein of pea thylakoids revealed that the protein spatially inhibits the formation of non-bilayer structures in the lamellae. Without this inhibition, excess lipids are secreted, creating lipid reservoirs for metabolism and/or later uptake. This determines the protein:lipid ratio in the membrane and hence the balance between structural flexibility and the stability of the key constituents that participate in cooperative interactions.