Crystallographic structures of the M and N intermediates of bacteriorhodopsin: assembly of a hydrogen-bonded chain of water molecules between Asp-96 and the retinal Schiff base

Molecular dynamics free energy calculations to assess the possibility of water existence in protein nonpolar cavities

Are protein nonpolar cavities filled with water molecules? Although many experimental and theoretical investigations have been done, particularly for the nonpolar cavity of IL-1 beta, the results are still conflicting. To study this problem from the thermodynamic point of view, we calculated hydration free energies of four protein nonpolar cavities by means of the molecular dynamics thermodynamic integration method. In addition to the IL-1 beta cavity (69 A(3)), we selected the three largest nonpolar cavities of AvrPphB (81 A(3)), Trp repressor (87 A(3)), and hemoglobin (108 A(3)) from the structural database, in view of the simulation result from another study that showed larger nonpolar cavities are more likely to be hydrated. The calculations were performed with flexible and rigid protein models. The calculated free energy changes were all positive; hydration of the nonpolar cavities was energetically unfavorable for all four cases. Because hydration of smaller cavities should happen more rarely, we conclude that existing protein nonpolar cavities are not likely to be hydrated. Although a possibility remains for much larger nonpolar cavities, such cases are not found experimentally. We present a hypothesis to explain this: hydrated nonpolar cavities are quite unstable and the conformation could not be maintained.

Time-resolved structural studies of protein reaction dynamics: a smorgasbord of X-ray approaches

Time-resolved structural studies of proteins have undergone several significant developments during the last decade. Recent developments using time-resolved X-ray methods, such as time-resolved Laue diffraction, low-temperature intermediate trapping, time-resolved wide-angle X-ray scattering and time-resolved X-ray absorption spectroscopy, are reviewed.

Proteins undergo conformational changes during their biological function. As such, a high-resolution structure of a protein’s resting conformation provides a starting point for elucidating its reaction mechanism, but provides no direct information concerning the protein’s conformational dynamics. Several X-ray methods have been developed to elucidate those conformational changes that occur during a protein’s reaction, including time-resolved Laue diffraction and intermediate trapping studies on three-dimensional protein crystals, and time-resolved wide-angle X-ray scattering and X-ray absorption studies on proteins in the solution phase. This review emphasizes the scope and limitations of these complementary experimental approaches when seeking to understand protein conformational dynamics. These methods are illustrated using a limited set of examples including myoglobin and haemoglobin in complex with carbon monoxide, the simple light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin, and the superoxide scavenger superoxide reductase. In conclusion, likely future developments of these methods at synchrotron X-ray sources and the potential impact of emerging X-ray free-electron laser facilities are speculated upon.

Overcoming merohedral twinning in crystals of bacteriorhodopsin grown in lipidic mesophase

Twinning is one of the most common crystal-growth defects in protein crystallography. There are neither efficient rational approaches for the growth of nontwinned protein crystals nor are there examples of systematic studies of the dependence of the twinning-ratio distribution on crystallization conditions. The description of the twinning phenomenon has been covered even less for membrane-protein crystals and is non-existent for crystals grown using lipidic phases (in meso). In the present work, possibilities for overcoming merohedral twinning are investigated for crystals of the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR) grown in meso. It is shown that traditional crystallization additives are not effective in the case of the in meso crystallization of bR. The twinning ratio was determined for 310 crystals grown under different crystallization conditions. A correlation of the twinning ratio with the growth rate of the crystals was observed. Slow growth indicated that crystals had a noticeable chance of avoiding twinning. Model calculations were performed in order to rationalize this observation. The calculations confirmed the experimental observation that most crystals consist of two twin domains and showed that under this condition small changes in the probability of twin-domain formation lead to dramatic changes in the number of nontwinned crystals, which explains why slow crystal growth results in a considerable number of nontwinned crystals.

Crystal structures of different substrates of bacteriorhodopsin's M intermediate at various pH levels

The hexagonal P622 crystal of bacteriorhodopsin, which is made up of stacked membranes, is stable provided that the precipitant concentration in the soaking solution is higher than a critical value (i.e., 1.5 M ammonium sulfate). Diffraction data showed that the crystal lattice shrank linearly with increasing precipitant concentration, due primarily to narrowing of intermembrane spaces. Although the crystal shrinkage did not affect the rate of formation of the photoreaction M intermediate, its lifetime increased exponentially with the precipitant concentration. It was suggested that the energetic barrier of the M-to-N transition becomes higher when the motional freedom of the EF loop is reduced by crystal lattice force. As a result of this property, the M state accumulated predominantly when the crystal that was soaked at a high precipitant concentration was illuminated at room temperature. Structural data obtained at various pH levels showed that the overall structure of M is not strongly dependent on pH, except that Glu194 and Glu204 in the proton release complex are more separated at pH 7 than at pH 4.4. This result suggests that light-induced disruption of the paired structure of Glu194 and Glu204 is incomplete when external pH is lower than the pK(a) value of the proton release group in the M state.

Structural snapshots of conformational changes in a seven-helix membrane protein: lessons from bacteriorhodopsin

Recent advances in crystallizing integral membrane proteins have led to atomic models for the structures of several seven-helix membrane proteins, including those in the G-protein-coupled receptor family. Further steps toward exploring structure-function relationships will undoubtedly involve determination of the structural changes that occur during the various stages of receptor activation and deactivation. We expect that these efforts will bear many parallels to the studies of conformational changes in bacteriorhodopsin, which still remains the best-studied seven-helix membrane protein. Here, we provide a brief review of some of the lessons learned, the challenges faced, and the controversies over the last decade with determining conformational changes in bacteriorhodopsin. Our hope is that this analysis will be instructive for similar structural studies, especially of other seven-helix membrane proteins, in the coming decade.

X-ray diffraction of bacteriorhodopsin photocycle intermediates (Review)

Recent advances in the crystallography of bacteriorhodopsin, the light-driven proton pump, have yielded structural models for all intermediates of the photochemical cycle. For seven of the species, X-ray diffraction data were collected from trapped photostationary states in crystals, and for the two remaining ones the structures of selected mutants are available. The changes of the retinal chromophore, protein and bound water describe, at an atomic level, how accommodation of the twisted photoisomerized retinal to its binding site causes de-protonation of the retinal Schiff base and initiates cascades of gradual conformational rearrangements of the protein. One cascade propagates in the extracellular direction and results in proton release, and the other in the cytoplasmic direction and results in side-chain and main-chain rearrangements, formation of a chain of hydrogen-bonded water, and proton uptake from the bulk. Such local-global conformational coupling, with gradual spreading of a local perturbation over the rest of the protein, might be the uniting principle of transporters and receptors.

Structural changes in the N and N' states of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

The bacteriorhodopsin transport cycle includes protonation of the retinal Schiff base by Asp96 (M-->N reaction) and reprotonation of Asp96 from the cytoplasmic surface (N-->N' reaction). We measured distance changes between pairs of spin-labeled structural elements of interest, and in general observed larger overall structural changes in the N state compared with the N' state. The distance between the C-D loop and E-F interhelical loops in A103R1/M163R1 increased approximately 6 A in the N state and approximately 3 A in the N' state. The opposite trend of distance changes in V101R1/A168R1 and L100R1/T170R1 supports counterclockwise rotation of helix F in the N but not the N' state. Small distance increases were observed in S169R1/S226R1, but little change was seen in G106R1/G155R1. Taking earlier published EPR data into account, we suggest that structural changes of the E-F loop occur first, and then helices F and G begin to move together in the late M state. These motions then reach their maximum amplitude in the N state, evidently to facilitate the release of a proton from Asp96 and the formation of a proton-conduction pathway from Asp96 to the Schiff base. The structural changes reverse their directions and decay in the N' state.

Protein conformational changes in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle: comparison of findings from electron and X-ray crystallographic analyses

Light-driven conformational changes in the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin have been studied extensively using X-ray and electron crystallography, resulting in the deposition of >30 sets of coordinates describing structural changes at various stages of proton transport. Using projection difference Fourier maps, we show that coordinates reported by different groups for the same photocycle intermediates vary considerably in the extent and nature of conformational changes. The different structures reported for the same intermediate cannot be reconciled in terms of differing extents of change on a single conformational trajectory. New measurements of image phases obtained by cryo-electron microscopy of the D96G/F171C/F219L triple mutant provide independent validation for the description of the large protein conformational change derived at 3.2 A resolution by electron crystallography of 2D crystals, but do not support atomic models for light-driven conformational changes derived using X-ray crystallography of 3D crystals. Our findings suggest that independent determination of phase information from 2D crystals can be an important tool for testing the accuracy of atomic models for membrane protein conformational changes.

Gold nanoparticles surface plasmon field effects on the proton pump process of the bacteriorhodopsin photosynthesis

The rate of the proton pump of bacteriorhodopsin photosynthetic system is examined in the presence of a gold nanorod plasmon field. It is found that while the rate of the proton dissociation from the protonated Schiff base is not affected, the rate of its reprotonation increases. These results are qualitatively discussed in terms of several possible mechanisms.

Infrared monitoring of interlayer water in stacks of purple membranes

The thermodynamic behavior of films of hydrated purple membranes from Halobacterium salinarum and the water confined in it was studied by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy in the 180-280 K range. Unlike bulk water, water in the thin layers sandwiched between the biological membranes does not freeze at 273 K but will be supercooled to approximately 256 K. The melting point is unaffected, leading to hysteresis between 250 and 273 K. In its heating branch, a gradually increasing light-scattering by ice is observed with rate-limiting kinetics of tens of minutes. Infrared (IR) spectra decomposition provided extinction coefficients for the confined water vibrational bands and their changes upon freezing. Because of the hysteresis, at any given temperature in the 255-270 K range, the interbilayer water could be either liquid or frozen, depending on thermal history. We find that this difference affects the dynamics of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle in the hysteresis range: the decay of the M and N states and the redistribution between them are different depending on whether or not the water was initially precooled to below the freezing point. However, freezing of interbilayer water does block the M to N transition. Unlike the water, the purple membrane lipids do not undergo any IR-detectable phase transition in the 180-280 K range.

How does a membrane protein achieve a vectorial proton transfer via water molecules?

We present a detailed mechanism for the proton transfer from a protein-bound protonated water cluster to the bulk water directed by protein side chains in the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin. We use a combined approach of time-resolved Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, molecular dynamics simulations, and X-ray structure analysis to elucidate the functional role of a hydrogen bond between Ser193 and Glu204. These two residues seal the internal protonated water cluster from the bulk water and the protein surface. During the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin, a transient protonation of Glu204 leads to a breaking of this hydrogen bond. This breaking opens the gate to the extracellular bulk water, leading to a subsequent proton release from the protonated water cluster. We show in detail how the protein achieves vectorial proton transfer via protonated water clusters in contrast to random proton transfer in liquid water.

Bi-stable neural state switches

Here we describe bi-stable channelrhodopsins that convert a brief pulse of light into a stable step in membrane potential. These molecularly engineered probes nevertheless retain millisecond-scale temporal precision. Photocurrents can be precisely initiated and terminated with different colors of light, but operate at vastly longer time scales than conventional channelrhodopsins as a result of modification at the C128 position that extends the lifetime of the open state. Because of their enhanced kinetic stability, these step-function tools are also effectively responsive to light at orders of magnitude lower intensity than wild-type channelrhodopsins. These molecules therefore offer important new capabilities for a broad range of in vivo applications.

Crystallographic structure of xanthorhodopsin, the light-driven proton pump with a dual chromophore

Homologous to bacteriorhodopsin and even more to proteorhodopsin, xanthorhodopsin is a light-driven proton pump that, in addition to retinal, contains a noncovalently bound carotenoid with a function of a light-harvesting antenna. We determined the structure of this eubacterial membrane protein-carotenoid complex by X-ray diffraction, to 1.9-A resolution. Although it contains 7 transmembrane helices like bacteriorhodopsin and archaerhodopsin, the structure of xanthorhodopsin is considerably different from the 2 archaeal proteins. The crystallographic model for this rhodopsin introduces structural motifs for proton transfer during the reaction cycle, particularly for proton release, that are dramatically different from those in other retinal-based transmembrane pumps. Further, it contains a histidine-aspartate complex for regulating the pK(a) of the primary proton acceptor not present in archaeal pumps but apparently conserved in eubacterial pumps. In addition to aiding elucidation of a more general proton transfer mechanism for light-driven energy transducers, the structure defines also the geometry of the carotenoid and the retinal. The close approach of the 2 polyenes at their ring ends explains why the efficiency of the excited-state energy transfer is as high as approximately 45%, and the 46 degrees angle between them suggests that the chromophore location is a compromise between optimal capture of light of all polarization angles and excited-state energy transfer.

A role for internal water molecules in proton affinity changes in the Schiff base and Asp85 for one-way proton transfer in bacteriorhodopsin

Light-induced proton pumping in bacteriorhodospin is carried out through five proton transfer steps. We propose that the proton transfer to Asp85 from the Schiff base in the L-to-M transition is accompanied by the relocation of a water cluster on the cytoplasmic side of the Schiff base from a site close to the Schiff base in L to the Phe219-Thr46 region in M. The water cluster present in L, formed at 170 K, is more rigid than that at room temperature. This may be responsible for blocking the conversion of L to M at 170 K. In the photocycle at room temperature, this water cluster returns to the site close to the Schiff base in N, with a rigid structure similar to that of L at 170 K. The increase in the proton affinity of Asp85, which is a prerequisite for the one-way proton transfer in the M-to-N transition, is suggested to be facilitated by a structural change which disrupts interactions between Asp212 and the Schiff base, and between Asp212 and Arg82. We propose that this liberation of Asp212 is accompanied by a rearrangement of the structure of water molecules between Asp85 and Asp212, stabilizing the protonated Asp85 in M.

The energetics of the primary proton transfer in bacteriorhodopsin revisited: it is a sequential light-induced charge separation after all

The light-induced proton transport in bacteriorhodopsin has been considered as a model for other light-induced proton pumps. However, the exact nature of this process is still unclear. For example, it is not entirely clear what the driving force of the initial proton transfer is and, in particular, whether it reflects electrostatic forces or other effects. The present work simulates the primary proton transfer (PT) by a specialized combination of the EVB and the QCFF/PI methods. This combination allows us to obtain sufficient sampling and a quantitative free energy profile for the PT at different protein configurations. The calculated profiles provide new insight about energetics of the primary PT and its coupling to the protein conformational changes. Our finding confirms the tentative analysis of an earlier work (A. Warshel, Conversion of light energy to electrostatic energy in the proton pump of Halobacterium halobium, Photochem. Photobiol. 30 (1979) 285-290) and determines that the overall PT process is driven by the energetics of the charge separation between the Schiff base and its counterion Asp85. Apparently, the light-induced relaxation of the steric energy of the chromophore leads to an increase in the ion-pair distance, and this drives the PT process. Our use of the linear response approximation allows us to estimate the change in the protein conformational energy and provides the first computational description of the coupling between the protein structural changes and the PT process. It is also found that the PT is not driven by twist-modulated changes of the Schiff base's pKa, changes in the hydrogen bond directionality, or other non-electrostatic effects. Overall, based on a consistent use of structural information as the starting point for converging free energy calculations, we conclude that the primary event should be described as a light-induced formation of an unstable ground state, whose relaxation leads to charge separation and to the destabilization of the ion-pair state. This provides the driving force for the subsequent PT steps.

The lifetimes of Pharaonis phoborhodopsin signaling states depend on the rates of proton transfers--effects of hydrostatic pressure and stopped flow experiments

Pharaonis phoborhodopsin (ppR), a negative phototaxis receptor of Natronomonas pharaonis, undergoes photocycle similar to the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin (BR), but the turnover rate is much slower due to much longer lifetimes of the M and O intermediates. The M decay was shown to become as fast as it is in BR in the L40T/F86D mutant. We examined the effects of hydrostatic pressure on the decay of these intermediates. For BR, pressure decelerated M decay but slightly affected O decay. In contrast, with ppR and with its L40T/F86D mutant, pressure slightly affected M decay but accelerated O decay. Clearly, the pressure-dependent factors for M and O decay are different in BR and ppR. In order to examine the deprotonation of Asp75 in unphotolyzed ppR we performed stopped flow experiments. The pH jump-induced deprotonation of Asp75 occurred with 60 ms, which is at least 20 times slower than deprotonation of the equivalent Asp85 in BR and about 10-fold faster than the O decay of ppR. These data suggest that proton transfer is slowed not only in the cytoplasmic channel but also in the extracellular channel of ppR and that the light-induced structural changes in the O intermediate of ppR additionally decrease this rate.

Microbial rhodopsins: scaffolds for ion pumps, channels, and sensors

Microbial rhodopsins have been intensively researched for the last three decades. Since the discovery of bacteriorhodopsin, the scope of microbial rhodopsins has been considerably extended, not only in view of the large number of family members, but also their functional properties as pumps, sensors, and channels. In this review, we give a short overview of old and newly discovered microbial rhodopsins, the mechanism of signal transfer and ion transfer, and we discuss structural and mechanistic aspects of phototaxis.

Probes for narcotic receptor mediated phenomena. 34. Synthesis and structure-activity relationships of a potent mu-agonist delta-antagonist and an exceedingly potent antinociceptive in the enantiomeric C9-substituted 5-(3-hydroxyphenyl)-N-phenylethylmorphan series

Both of the enantiomers of 5-(3-hydroxyphenyl)-N-phenylethylmorphan with C9alpha-methyl, C9-methylene, C9-keto, and C9alpha- and C9beta-hydroxy substituents were synthesized and pharmacologically evaluated. Three of the 10 compounds, (1R,5R,9S)-(-)-9-hydroxy-5-(3-hydroxyphenyl-2-phenylethyl-2-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane ((1R,5R,9S)-(-)-10), (1R,5S)-(+)-5-(3-hydroxyphenyl)-9-methylene-2-phenethyl-2-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane ((1R,5S)-(+)-14), and (1R,5S,9R)-(-)-5-(3-hydroxyphenyl)-9-methyl-2-phenethyl-2-azabicyclo[3.3.1]nonane ((1R,5S,9R)-(+)-15) had subnanomolar affinity at mu-opioid receptors (Ki = 0.19, 0.19, and 0.63 nM, respectively). The (1R,5S)-(+)-14 was found to be a mu-opioid agonist and a mu-, delta-, and kappa-antagonist in [35S]GTP-gamma-S assays and was approximately 50 times more potent than morphine in a number of acute and subchronic pain assays, including thermal and visceral models of nociception. The (1R,5R,9S)-(-)-10 compound with a C9-hydroxy substituent axially oriented to the piperidine ring (C9beta-hydroxy) was a mu-agonist about 500 times more potent than morphine. In the single-dose suppression assay, it was greater than 1000 times more potent than morphine. It is the most potent known phenylmorphan antinociceptive. The molecular structures of these compounds were energy minimized with density functional theory at the B3LYP/6-31G* level and then overlaid onto (1R,5R,9S)-(-)-10 using the heavy atoms in the morphan moiety as a common docking point. Based on modeling, the spatial arrangement of the protonated nitrogen atom and the 9beta-OH substituent in (1R,5R,9S)-(-)-10 may facilitate the alignment of a putative water chain enabling proton transfer to a nearby proton acceptor group in the mu-opioid receptor.

Studies of the Bacteriorhodopsin Photocycle without the Use of Light: Clues to Proton Transfer Coupled Reactions

In the photochemical cycle of bacteriorhodopsin, the light-driven proton pump of halobacteria, only the first step, the isomerization of the all-trans retinal to 13-cis, is dependent on illumination. Because the steps that accomplish the translocation of a proton during the ensuing reaction sequence of intermediate states are thermal reactions, they have direct analogies with such steps in other ion pumps. In a surprisingly large number of cases, the reactions of the photocycle could be studied without using light. This review recounts experiments of this kind, and what they contribute to understanding the transport mechanism of this pump, and perhaps indirectly other ion pumps as well.

Hydration of a hydrophobic cavity and its functional role: a simulation study of human interleukin-1beta

Molecular dynamics simulations reveal that the hydrophobic cavity in human cytokine Interleukin-1beta is hydrated and can dynamically accommodate between one and four water molecules. These waters have residence times >> 500 ps and can give rise to detectable NOEs, in agreement with NMR observations of Ernst et al. (Science 1995; 267:1813-1817). The waters also display high positional disorder within the cavity, which explains why they have not been resolved crystallographically. The average distribution of water molecules over time within the cavity matches well the low resolution electron density extracted by Yu et al. (Proc Natl Acad Sci 1999; 96:103-108). The water molecules hydrate the hydrophobic cavity preferentially as complex clusters. These clusters result from a combination of hydrogen bonds between the waters and stabilizing interactions between the waters and aromatic rings forming the cavity. Free energy estimates suggest that it takes 4-waters to hydrate the cavity in a thermodynamically stable manner leading to a gain in free energy of transfer from bulk of approximately approximately 3.6 kcal/mol. This arises from the existence of the water clusters in multiple hydrogen bonded states. In addition, the waters are found to migrate either individually or as clusters out of the cavity through several pathways. The upper limit for one-dimensional diffusion of the waters within the protein matrix is 4 A/ps (relative to 6 A/ps for bulk). Simulations reveal pathways in addition to those identified crystallographically, with motions controlled by the rotations of sidechains. We find that only when the hydrophobic cavity is hydrated, do correlated motions couple distant sites with the sites that make contact with the receptor and this data partly offers an explanation of experimental mutagenesis data. Simulations, together with recent observations based on mutagenesis by Heidary et al. (J Mol Biol 2005; 353:1187-1198) that hydrogen bond networks couple motions across long distances in interleukin-1beta, lead us to hypothesize that the hydration of the cavity (conserved across mammals) can thermodynamically enhance hydrogen bond networks to enable coupling across long distances by acting as a plug and this in turn enables a kinetic control of the rate of transmission of signals.

Water as a cofactor in the unidirectional light-driven proton transfer steps in bacteriorhodopsin

Recent evidence for involvement of internal water molecules in the mechanism of bacteriorhodopsin is reviewed. Water O-H stretching vibration bands in the Fourier transform IR difference spectra of the L, M and N intermediates of bacteriorhodopsin were analyzed by photoreactions at cryogenic temperatures. A broad vibrational band in L was shown to be due to formation of a structure of water molecules connecting the Schiff base to the Thr46-Asp96 region. This structure disappears in the M intermediate, suggesting that it is involved in transient stabilization of the L intermediate prior to proton transfer from the Schiff base to Asp85. The interaction of the Schiff base with a water molecule is restored in the N intermediate. We propose that water is a critical mobile component of bacteriorhodopsin, forming organized structures in the transient intermediates during the photocycle and, to a large extent, determining the chemical behavior of these transient states.

Dynamic Holography in Bacteriorhodopsin/Gelatin Films: Effects of Light-Dark Adaptation at Different Humidity†

This work examines the kinetics of dynamic holography responses in light-adapted and dark-adapted bacteriorhodopsin (BR) films at different humidity. We have demonstrated that the kinetics of the diffraction efficiency in wild type BR films is quite different in dark-adapted and light-adapted samples. The holographic recording kinetics, which depends on the duration of incubation in the dark after light adaptation at different humidity values, was studied in depth. A specially designed miniature cell containing a BR film was mounted inside the holographic set up to allow controlled humidity changes over a broad range. The diffraction efficiency kinetics at humidity values of 96-99% were quite different from the kinetics at 60-93% humidity. We found that humidity values of 90-93% were most optimal for dynamic holography recording using a gelatin film containing BR. In agreement with a calculation of the wavelength-dependent changes of the refractive index for dark-adapted and light-adapted BR samples using the Kramers-Kronig relation, the maximum difference in the refractive index and thus in the diffraction efficiency for dark-adapted and light-adapted BR films takes place at 630 nm, close to the wavelength of the He-Ne laser used.

Development of Bacteriorhodopsin Analogues and Studies of Charge Separated Excited States in the Photoprocesses of Linear Polyenes†

Development of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) analogues employing chromophore substitution technique for the purpose of characterizing the binding site of bR and generating bR analogues with novel opto-electronic properties for applications as photoactive element in nanotechnical devices are described. Additionally, the photophysical and photochemical properties of variously substituted diarylpolyenes as models of photobiologically relevant linear polyenes are discussed. The role of charge separated dipolar excited states in the photoprocesses of linear polyenes is highlighted.

Water structural changes in the L and M photocycle intermediates of bacteriorhodopsin as revealed by time-resolved step-scan Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy

In previous Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) studies of the photocycle intermediates of bacteriorhodopsin at cryogenic temperatures, water molecules were observed in the L intermediate, in the region surrounded by protein residues between the Schiff base and Asp96. In the M intermediate, the water molecules had moved away toward the Phe219-Thr46 region. To evaluate the relevance of this scheme at room temperature, time-resolved FTIR difference spectra of bacteriorhodopsin, including the water O-H stretching vibration frequency regions, were recorded in the micro- and millisecond time ranges. Vibrational changes of weakly hydrogen-bonded water molecules were observed in L, M, and N. In each of these intermediates, the depletion of a water O-H stretching vibration at 3645 cm-1, originating from the initial unphotolyzed bacteriorhodopsin, was observed as a trough in the difference spectrum. This vibration is due to the dangling O-H group of a water molecule, which interacts with Asp85, and its absence in each of these intermediates indicates that there is perturbation of this O-H group. The formation of M is accompanied by the appearance of water O-H stretching vibrations at 3670 and 3657 cm-1, the latter of which persists to N. The 3670 cm-1 band of M is due to water molecules present in the region surrounded by Thr46, Asp96, and Phe219. The formation of L at 298 K is accompanied by the perturbations of Asp96 and the Schiff base, although in different ways from what is observed at 170 K. Changes in a broad water vibrational feature, centered around 3610 cm-1, are kinetically correlated with the L-M transition. These results imply that, even at room temperature, water molecules interact with Asp96 and the Schiff base in L, although with a less rigid structure than at cryogenic temperatures.

Energy transduction: proton transfer through the respiratory complexes

A series of metalloprotein complexes embedded in a mitochondrial or bacterial membrane utilize electron transfer reactions to pump protons across the membrane and create an electrochemical potential (DeltamuH+). Current understanding of the principles of electron-driven proton transfer is discussed, mainly with respect to the wealth of knowledge available from studies of cytochrome c oxidase. Structural, experimental, and theoretical evidence supports the model of long-distance proton transfer via hydrogen-bonded water chains in proteins as well as the basic concept that proton uptake and release in a redox-driven pump are driven by charge changes at the membrane-embedded centers. Key elements in the pumping mechanism may include bound water, carboxylates, and the heme propionates, arginines, and associated water above the hemes. There is evidence for an important role of subunit III and proton backflow, but the number and nature of gating mechanisms remain elusive, as does the mechanism of physiological control of efficiency.

Triggering and Monitoring Light‐Sensing Reactions in Protein Crystals

Many bacterial photoreceptors signal via histidine kinases. The light-activated nature of these proteins provides unique experimental opportunities to study their molecular mechanisms of signal transduction. One of these opportunities is the combined application of X-ray crystallography and optical spectroscopy in protein crystals. By combining these two methods it is possible to correlate protein structure to protein function in a way that is exceedingly difficult or impossible to achieve in most other experimental systems. This chapter is divided into two parts. The first part provides a brief overview of light-regulated histidine kinases and the most important techniques for studying the structure of photocycle intermediates by crystallography. The second part of the chapter is dedicated to practical advice on how to select, mount, activate, and monitor the structural and spectroscopic responses of photoreceptor crystals. This chapter is intended for readers who want to start using these experimental tools themselves or who wish to understand enough about the techniques to critically evaluate the work of others.

Electron paramagnetic resonance study of structural changes in the O photointermediate of bacteriorhodopsin

The structural changes of bacteriorhodopsin during its photochemical cycle, as revealed by crystal structures of trapped intermediates, have provided insights to the proton translocation mechanism. Because accumulation of the last photointermediate, O, appears to be hindered by lattice forces in the crystals, the only information about the structure of this state is from suggested analogies with the determined structures of the non-illuminated D85S mutant and wild-type bacteriorhodopsin at low pH. We used electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy of site-directed spin labels at the extracellular protein surface in membranes to test these models. Spin-spin dipolar interactions in the authentic O state compared to the non-illuminated state revealed that the distance between helices C and F increases by ca 4 Angstroms, there is no distance change between helices D and F, and the distance between helix D and helix B of the adjacent monomer increases. Further, the mobility changes of single labels indicate that helices E and F move outward from the proton channel at the center of the protein, and helix D tilts inward. The overall pattern of movements suggests that the model at acid pH is a better representation of the O state than D85S. However, the mobility analysis of spin-labels on the B-C interhelical loop indicates that the antiparallel beta-sheet maintains its ordered secondary structure in O, instead of the predicted disorder in the two structural models. During decay of the O state, the last step of the photocycle, a proton is transferred from Asp85 to proton release complex in the extracellular proton channel. The structural changes in O suggest the need of large conformational changes to drive the Arg82 side-chain back to its initial orientation towards Asp85, and to rearrange the numerous water molecules in this region in order to conduct the proton away from Asp85.

Model for Proton Transport Coupled to Protein Conformational Change: Application to Proton Pumping in the Bacteriorhodopsin Photocycle

A modeling method is presented for protein systems in which proton transport is coupled to conformational change, as in proton pumps and in motors driven by the proton-motive force. Previously developed methods for calculating pKa values in proteins using a macroscopic dielectric model are extended beyond the equilibrium case to a master-equation model for the time evolution of the system through states defined by ionization microstate and a discrete set of conformers. The macroscopic dielectric model supplies free energy changes for changes of protonation microstate, while the method for obtaining the energetics of conformational change and the relaxation rates, the other ingredients needed for the master equation, are system dependent. The method is applied to the photoactivated proton pump, bacteriorhodopsin, using conformational free energy differences from experiment and treating relaxation rates through three adjustable parameters. The model is found to pump protons with an efficiency relatively insensitive to parameter choice over a wide range of parameter values, and most of the main features of the known photocycle from very early M to the return to the resting state are reproduced. The boundaries of these parameter ranges are such that short-range proton transfers are faster than longer-range ones, which in turn are faster than conformational changes. No relaxation rates depend on conformation. The results suggest that an "accessibility switch", while not ruled out, is not required and that vectorial proton transport can be achieved through the coupling of the energetics of ionization and conformational states.

Structural changes in the L photointermediate of bacteriorhodopsin

The L to M reaction of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle includes the crucial proton transfer from the retinal Schiff base to Asp85. In spite of the importance of the L state in deciding central issues of the transport mechanism in this pump, the serious disagreements among the three published crystallographic structures of L have remained unresolved. Here, we report on the X-ray diffraction structure of the L state, to 1.53-1.73 A resolutions, from replicate data sets collected from six independent crystals. Unlike earlier studies, the partial occupancy refinement uses diffraction intensities from the same crystals before and after the illumination to produce the trapped L state. The high reproducibility of inter-atomic distances, and bond angles and torsions of the retinal, lends credibility to the structural model. The photoisomerized 13-cis retinal in L is twisted at the C(13)=C(14) and C(15)=NZ double-bonds, and the Schiff base does not lose its connection to Wat402 and, therefore, to the proton acceptor Asp85. The protonation of Asp85 by the Schiff base in the L-->M reaction is likely to occur, therefore, via Wat402. It is evident from the structure of the L state that various conformational changes involving hydrogen-bonding residues and bound water molecules begin to propagate from the retinal to the protein at this stage already, and in both extracellular and cytoplasmic directions. Their rationales in the transport can be deduced from the way their amplitudes increase in the intermediates that follow L in the reaction cycle, and from the proton transfer reactions with which they are associated.

Propagating structural perturbation inside bacteriorhodopsin: crystal structures of the M state and the D96A and T46V mutants

The X-ray diffraction structure of the non-illuminated D96A bacteriorhodopsin mutant reveals structural changes as far away as 15 A from residue 96, at the retinal, Trp-182, Ala-215, and waters 501, 402, and 401. The Asp-to-Ala side-chain replacement breaks its hydrogen bond with Thr-46, and the resulting separation of the cytoplasmic ends of helices B and C is communicated to the retinal region through a chain of covalent and hydrogen bonds. The unexpected long-range consequences of the D96A mutation include breaking the hydrogen bond between O of Ala-215 and water 501 and the formation of a new hydrogen bond between water molecules 401 and 402 in the extracellular region. Because in the T46V mutant a new water molecule appears at Asp-96 and its hydrogen-bond to Ile-45 replaces Thr-46 as its link to helix B, the separation of helices B and C is smaller than that in D96A, and there are no atomic displacements elsewhere in the protein. Propagation of conformational changes along the chain between the retinal and Thr-46 had been observed earlier in the crystal structures of the D96N and E204Q mutants but in the trapped M state. Consistent with the perturbation of the retinal region in D96A, little change of the Thr-46 region occurs between the non-illuminated and M states of this mutant. It appears that a local perturbation can propagate along a track in both directions between the retinal and the Asp-96/Thr-46 pair, either from photoisomerization of the retinal in the wild-type protein in one case or from the D96A mutation in the other.

Computational Analysis of the Proton Translocation from Asp96 to Schiff Base in Bacteriorhodopsin

The potential energy change during the M --> N process in bacteriorhodopsin has been evaluated by ab initio quantum chemical and advanced quantum chemical calculations following molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Many previous experimental studies have suggested that the proton transfer from Asp96 to the Schiff base occurs under the following two conditions: (1) the hydrogen bond between Thr46 and Asp96 breaks and Thr46 is detached from Asp96 and (2) a stable chain of four water molecules spans an area from Asp96 --> Schiff base. In this work, we successfully reproduced the proton-transfer process occurring under these two conditions by molecular dynamics and quantum chemical calculations. The quantum chemical computation revealed that the proton transfer from Asp96 to Shiff base occurs in two-step reactions via an intermediate in which an H(3)O(+) appears around Ala215. The activation energy for the proton transfer in the first reaction was calculated to be 9.7 kcal/mol, which enables fast and efficient proton pump action. Further QM/MM (quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical) and FMO (fragment molecular orbital) calculations revealed that the potential energy change during the proton transfer is tightly regulated by the composition and the geometry of the surrounding amino acid residues of bacteriorhodopsin. Here, we report in detail the Asp96 --> Schiff base proton translocation mechanism of bacteriorhodopsin. Additionally, we discuss the effectiveness of combining quantum chemical calculations with truncated cluster models followed by advanced quantum chemical calculations applied to a whole protein to elucidate its reaction mechanism.

Proton transfers in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

The steps in the mechanism of proton transport in bacteriorhodopsin include examples for most kinds of proton transfer reactions that might occur in a transmembrane pump: proton transfer via a bridging water molecule, coupled protonation/deprotonation of two buried groups separated by a considerable distance, long-range proton migration over a hydrogen-bonded aqueous chain, and capture as well as release of protons at the membrane-water interface. The conceptual and technical advantages of this system have allowed close examination of many of these model reactions, some at an atomic level.

Design principles of proton-pumping haem-copper oxidases

Transmembrane electrochemical proton gradients are used to store free energy in biological systems, and to drive the synthesis of biomolecules and transmembrane transport. These gradients are maintained by membrane-bound proton transporters that employ free energy provided by, for example, electron transfer or light. In recent years, the structures of several membrane proteins involved in proton translocation have been determined, and indicate that both protein-bound water molecules and protonatable amino acid residues play central roles in transmembrane proton conduction. From these structures, in combination with functional studies, have emerged general principles of proton transfer across membranes and control mechanisms for such reactions, in particular with regard to the electron-transfer-driven proton pump cytochrome c oxidase.

Factors influencing the energetics of electron and proton transfers in proteins. What can be learned from calculations

A protein structure should provide the information needed to understand its observed properties. Significant progress has been made in developing accurate calculations of acid/base and oxidation/reduction reactions in proteins. Current methods and their strengths and weaknesses are discussed. The distribution and calculated ionization states in a survey of proteins is described, showing that a significant minority of acidic and basic residues are buried in the protein and that most of these remain ionized. The electrochemistry of heme and quinones are considered. Proton transfers in bacteriorhodopsin and coupled electron and proton transfers in photosynthetic reaction centers, 5-coordinate heme binding proteins and cytochrome c oxidase are highlighted as systems where calculations have provided insight into the reaction mechanism.

Time-resolved microspectroscopy on a single crystal of bacteriorhodopsin reveals lattice-induced differences in the photocycle kinetics

The determination of the intermediate state structures of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle has lead to an unprecedented level of understanding of the catalytic process exerted by a membrane protein. However, the crystallographic structures of the intermediate states are only relevant if the working cycle is not impaired by the crystal lattice. Therefore, we applied visible and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) microspectroscopy with microsecond time resolution to compare the photoreaction of a single bacteriorhodopsin crystal to that of bacteriorhodopsin residing in the native purple membrane. The analysis of the FTIR difference spectra of the resolved intermediate states reveals great similarity in structural changes taking place in the crystal and in PM. However, the kinetics of the photocycle are significantly altered in the three-dimensional crystal as compared to PM. Strikingly, the L state decay is accelerated in the crystal, whereas the M decay is delayed. The physical origin of this deviation and the implications for trapping of intermediate states are discussed. As a methodological advance, time-resolved step-scan FTIR spectroscopy on a single protein crystal is demonstrated for the first time which may be used in the future to gauge the functionality of other crystallized proteins with the molecular resolution of vibrational spectroscopy.

Water dynamics simulation as a tool for probing proton transfer pathways in a heptahelical membrane protein

The proton transfer pathway in a heptahelical membrane protein, the light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin (BR), is probed by a combined approach of structural analysis of recent X-ray models and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations that provide the diffusion pathways of internal and external water molecules. Analyzing the hydrogen-bond contact frequencies of the water molecules with protein groups, the complete proton pathway through the protein is probed. Beside the well-known proton binding sites in the protein interior-the protonated Schiff base, Asp85 and Asp96, and the H(5)O(2) (+) complex stabilized by Glu204 and Glu194-the proton release and uptake pathways to the protein surfaces are described in great detail. Further residues were identified, by mutation of which the proposed pathways can be verified. In addition the diffusion pathway of water 502 from Lys216 to Asp96 is shown to cover the positions of the intruding waters 503 and 504 in the N-intermediate. The transiently established water chain in the N-state provides a proton pathway from Asp96 to the Schiff base in the M- to N-transition in a Grotthus-like mechanism, as concluded earlier from time-resolved Fourier transform infrared experiments [le Coutre et al., Proc Nat Acad Sci USA 1995;92:4962-4966].

Cytoplasmic Shuttling of Protons in Anabaena Sensory Rhodopsin: Implications for Signaling Mechanism

It was found recently that Anabaena sensory rhodopsin (ASR), which possibly serves as a photoreceptor for chromatic adaptation, interacts with a soluble cytoplasmic transducer. The X-ray structure of the transducer-free protein revealed an extensive hydrogen-bonded network of amino acid residues and water molecules in the cytoplasmic half of ASR, in high contrast to its haloarchaeal counterparts. Using time-resolved spectroscopy of the wild-type and mutant ASR in the visible and infrared ranges, we tried to determine whether this hydrogen-bonded network is used to translocate protons and whether those proton transfers are important for interaction with the transducer. We found that the retinal Schiff base deprotonation, which occurs in the M intermediate of the photocycle of all-trans-ASR, results in protonation of Asp217 on the cytoplasmic side of the protein. The deprotonation of the Schiff base induces a conformational change of ASR observed through the perturbation of associated lipids. We suggest that the cytoplasmic shuttling of protons in the photocycle of all-trans-ASR and the ensuing conformational changes might activate the transducer. Consequently, the M intermediate may be the signaling state of ASR.