Ribozymes: recent advances in the development of RNA tools

LNA nucleotides improve cleavage efficiency of singular and binary hammerhead ribozymes

Variants of trans-acting hammerhead ribozymes were modified with Locked Nucleic Acid (LNA) nucleotides to reduce their size, to improve access to their RNA target and to explore combinational properties of binary constructs. Using low Mg(2+) concentrations and low substrate and ribozyme concentrations, it was found that insertion of LNA monomers into the substrate binding arms allowed these to be shortened and results in a very active enzyme under both single and multiple turnover conditions. Incorporation of a mix of LNA and DNA residues further increased the multiple turnover cleavage activity. At high Mg(2+) concentrations or high substrate and ribozyme concentrations, the enhancing effect of LNA incorporation was even more prominent. Using LNA in the stem of Helix II diminished cleavage activity, but allowed deletion of the tetra-loop and thus separating the ribozyme into two molecules with each half binding to the substrate. Efficient, binary hammerhead ribozymes were pursued in a combinatorial approach using a 6-times 5 library, which was analysed concerning the best combinations, buffer conditions and fragment ratios.

Tricyclo-DNA containing oligonucleotides as steric block inhibitors of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 tat-dependent trans-activation and HIV-1 infectivity

Replication of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) is controlled by a variety of viral and host proteins. The viral protein Tat acts in concert with host cellular factors to stimulate transcriptional elongation from the viral long terminal repeat (LTR) through a specific interaction with a 59-residue stem-loop RNA known as the trans-activation responsive element (TAR). Inhibitors of Tat-TAR recognition are expected to block transcription and suppress HIV-1 replication. In previous studies, we showed that 2'-O-methyl (OMe) oligonucleotide mixmers containing locked nucleic acid (LNA) residues are powerful steric block inhibitors of Tat-dependent trans-activation in a HeLa cell reporter system. Here we compare OMe/LNA mixmer oligonucleotides with oligonucleotides containing tricyclo-DNAs and their mixmers with OMe residues in four different assays: (1) binding to the target TAR RNA, (2) Tat-dependent in vitro transcription from an HIV-1 DNA template directed by HeLa cell nuclear extract, (3) trans-activation inhibition in HeLa cells containing a stably integrated firefly luciferase reporter gene under HIV-1 LTR control, and (4) an anti-HIV beta-galactosidase reporter assay of viral infection. Although tricyclo-DNA oligonucleotides bound TAR RNA more weakly, they were as good as OMe/LNA oligonucleotides in suppressing in vitro transcription and trans-activation in HeLa cells when delivered by cationic lipid. No inhibition of in vitro transcription and trans-activation in HeLa cells was observed for tricyclo-DNA/OMe mixmers, even though their affinities to TAR RNA were strong and their cell distributions did not differ from oligonucleotides containing all or predominantly tricyclo-DNA residues. Tricyclo-DNA 16-mer showed sequence-specific inhibition of beta-galactosidase expression in an anti-HIV HeLa cell reporter assay.

Recombinant RNA technology: the tRNA scaffold

RNA has emerged as a major player in most cellular processes. Understanding these processes at the molecular level requires homogeneous RNA samples for structural, biochemical and pharmacological studies. So far, this has been a bottleneck, as the only methods for producing such pure RNA have been in vitro syntheses. Here we describe a generic approach for expressing and purifying structured RNA in Escherichia coli, using tools that parallel those available for recombinant proteins. Our system is based on a camouflage strategy, the 'tRNA scaffold', in which the recombinant RNA is disguised as a natural RNA and thus hijacks the host machinery, escaping cellular RNases. This opens the way to large-scale structural and molecular investigations of RNA function.

Unique folding of precursor microRNAs: quantitative evidence and implications for de novo identification

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) participate in diverse cellular and physiological processes through the post-transcriptional gene regulatory pathway. Hairpin is a crucial structural feature for the computational identification of precursor miRNAs (pre-miRs), as its formation is critically associated with the early stages of the mature miRNA biogenesis. Our incomplete knowledge about the number of miRNAs present in the genomes of vertebrates, worms, plants, and even viruses necessitates thorough understanding of their sequence motifs, hairpin structural characteristics, and topological descriptors. In this in-depth study, we investigate a comprehensive and heterogeneous collection of 2241 published (nonredundant) pre-miRs across 41 species (miRBase 8.2), 8494 pseudohairpins extracted from the human RefSeq genes, 12,387 (nonredundant) ncRNAs spanning 457 types (Rfam 7.0), 31 full-length mRNAs randomly selected from GenBank, and four sets of synthetically generated genomic background corresponding to each of the native RNA sequence. Our large-scale characterization analysis reveals that pre-miRs are significantly different from other types of ncRNAs, pseudohairpins, mRNAs, and genomic background according to the nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis ANOVA (p<0.001). We examine the intrinsic and global features at the sequence, structural, and topological levels including %G+C content, normalized base-pairing propensity P(S), normalized minimum free energy of folding MFE(s), normalized Shannon entropy Q(s), normalized base-pair distance D(s), and degree of compactness F(S), as well as their corresponding Z scores of P(S), MFE(s), Q(s), D(s), and F(S). The findings will promote more accurate guidelines and distinctive criteria for the prediction of novel pre-miRs with improved performance.

Computational RNA secondary structure design: empirical complexity and improved methods

Background

We investigate the empirical complexity of the RNA secondary structure design problem, that is, the scaling of the typical difficulty of the design task for various classes of RNA structures as the size of the target structure is increased. The purpose of this work is to understand better the factors that make RNA structures hard to design for existing, high-performance algorithms. Such understanding provides the basis for improving the performance of one of the best algorithms for this problem, RNA-SSD, and for characterising its limitations.

Results

To gain insights into the practical complexity of the problem, we present a scaling analysis on random and biologically motivated structures using an improved version of the RNA-SSD algorithm, and also the RNAinverse algorithm from the Vienna package. Since primary structure constraints are relevant for designing RNA structures, we also investigate the correlation between the number and the location of the primary structure constraints when designing structures and the performance of the RNA-SSD algorithm. The scaling analysis on random and biologically motivated structures supports the hypothesis that the running time of both algorithms scales polynomially with the size of the structure. We also found that the algorithms are in general faster when constraints are placed only on paired bases in the structure. Furthermore, we prove that, according to the standard thermodynamic model, for some structures that the RNA-SSD algorithm was unable to design, there exists no sequence whose minimum free energy structure is the target structure.

Conclusion

Our analysis helps to better understand the strengths and limitations of both the RNA-SSD and RNAinverse algorithms, and suggests ways in which the performance of these algorithms can be further improved.

Modular evolution and increase of functional complexity in replicating RNA molecules

At early stages of biochemical evolution, the complexity of replicating molecules was limited by unavoidably high mutation rates. In an RNA world, prior to the appearance of cellular life, an increase in molecular length, and thus in functional complexity, could have been mediated by modular evolution. We describe here a scenario in which short, replicating RNA sequences are selected to perform a simple function. Molecular function is represented through the secondary structure corresponding to each sequence, and a given target secondary structure yields the optimal function in the environment where the population evolves. The combination of independently evolved populations may have facilitated the emergence of larger molecules able to perform more complex functions (including RNA replication) that could arise as a combination of simpler ones. We quantitatively show that modular evolution has relevant advantages with respect to the direct evolution of large functional molecules, among them the allowance of higher mutation rates, the shortening of evolutionary times, and the very possibility of finding complex structures that could not be otherwise directly selected.

Leadzyme formed in vivo interferes with tobacco mosaic virus infection in Nicotiana tabacum

We developed a new method for inhibiting tobacco mosaic virus infection in tobacco plants based on specific RNA hydrolysis induced by a leadzyme. We identified a leadzyme substrate target sequence in genomic tobacco mosaic virus RNA and designed a 16-mer oligoribonucleotide capable of forming a specific leadzyme motif with a five-nucleotide catalytic loop. The synthetic 16-mer RNA was applied with nontoxic, catalytic amount of lead to infected tobacco leaves. We observed inhibition of tobacco mosaic virus infection in tobacco leaves in vivo due to specific tobacco mosaic virus RNA cleavage effected by leadzyme. A significant reduction in tobacco mosaic virus accumulation was observed even when the leadzyme was applied up to 2 h after inoculation of leaves with tobacco mosaic virus. This process, called leadzyme interference, is determined by specific recognition and cleavage of the target site by the RNA catalytic strand in the presence of Pb(2+).

Engineering RNA-based circuits

Nucleic acids can modulate gene function by base-pairing, via the molecular recognition of proteins and metabolites, and by catalysis. This diversity of functions can be combined with the ability to engineer nucleic acids based on Watson-Crick base-pairing rules to create a modular set of molecular "tools" for biotechnological and medical interventions in cellular metabolism. However, these individual RNA-based tools are most powerful when combined into rational logical or regulatory circuits, and the circuits can in turn be evolved for optimal function. Examples of genetic circuits that control translation and transcription are herein detailed, and more complex circuits with medical applications are anticipated.

QCRNA 1.0: a database of quantum calculations for RNA catalysis

This work outlines a new on-line database of quantum calculations for RNA catalysis (QCRNA) available via the worldwide web at http://theory.chem.umn.edu/QCRNA. The database contains high-level density functional calculations for a large range of molecules, complexes and chemical mechanisms important to phosphoryl transfer reactions and RNA catalysis. Calculations are performed using a strict, consistent protocol such that a wealth of cross-comparisons can be made to elucidate meaningful trends in biological phosphate reactivity. Currently, around 2000 molecules have been collected in varying charge states in the gas phase and in solution. Solvation was treated with both the PCM and COSMO continuum solvation models. The data can be used to study important trends in reactivity of biological phosphates, or used as benchmark data for the design of new semiempirical quantum models for hybrid quantum mechanical/molecular mechanical simulations.

The first cell

The First Cell arose in the previously pre-biotic world with the coming together of several entities that gave a single vesicle the unique chance to carry out three essential and quite different life processes. These were: (a) to copy informational macromolecules, (b) to carry out specific catalytic functions, and (c) to couple energy from the environment into usable chemical forms. These would foster subsequent cellular evolution and metabolism. Each of these three essential processes probably originated and was lost many times prior to The First Cell, but only when these three occurred together was life jump-started and Darwinian evolution of organisms began. The replication of informational molecules that made only occasional mistakes allowed evolution to form all the basic components of cellular life. Ribozymes, the first informational molecules, were also catalytic. Energy coupling required the formation of a closed lipid surface to generate and maintain an ion-motive gradient. The closed vesicle partitioned components and avoided dilution within the primordial sea. Closed membranes were essential for the first self-reproducing cell to arise and for its descendants to disperse. Subsequent cellular development after the origin of The First Cell led to the beginnings of intermediary metabolism and membrane transport processes. This long process, subject to strong evolutionary selection, developed the cellular biology that is now shared by all extant organisms.

Efficient RNA ligation by reverse-joined hairpin ribozymes and engineering of twin ribozymes consisting of conventional and reverse-joined hairpin ribozyme units

In recent years major progress has been made in elucidating the mechanism and structure of catalytic RNA molecules, and we are now beginning to understand ribozymes well enough to turn them into useful tools. Work in our laboratory has focused on the development of twin ribozymes for site-specific RNA sequence alteration. To this end, we followed a strategy that relies on the combination of two ribozyme units into one molecule (hence dubbed twin ribozyme). Here, we present reverse-joined hairpin ribozymes that are structurally optimized and which, in addition to cleavage, catalyse efficient RNA ligation. The most efficient variant ligated its appropriate RNA substrate with a single turnover rate constant of 1.1 min(-1) and a final yield of 70%. We combined a reverse-joined hairpin ribozyme with a conventional hairpin ribozyme to create a twin ribozyme that mediates the insertion of four additional nucleotides into a predetermined position of a substrate RNA, and thus mimics, at the RNA level, the repair of a short deletion mutation; 17% of the initial substrate was converted to the insertion product.

Interfering with hepatitis C virus IRES activity using RNA molecules identified by a novel in vitro selection method

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection is one of the world's major health problems, and the identification of efficient HCV inhibitors is a major goal. Here we report the isolation of efficient anti-HCV internal ribosome entry site (IRES) RNA molecules identified by a new in vitro selection method. The newly developed procedure consists of two sequential steps that use distinct criteria for selection: selection for binding and selection for cleaving. The selection protocol was applied to a population of more than 10(15) variants of an anti-hepatitis C virus ribozyme covalently linked to an aptamer motif. The ribozyme was directed against positions 357 to 369 of the HCV IRES, and the cleavage substrate was a 691-nucleotide-long RNA fragment that comprises the entire HCV IRES domain. After six selection cycles, seven groups of RNA variants were identified. A representative of each group was tested for its capacity to inhibit IRES activity using in vitro translation assays. All selected RNAs promoted significant inhibition, some by as much as 95%.

Inhibition of HIV-1 replication by RNA targeted against the LTR region

OBJECTIVE

The use of small RNA molecules able to effect gene inactivation has emerged as a powerful method of gene therapy. These small inhibitory RNAs are widely used for silencing malignant cellular and viral genes. We have assayed a series of inhibitory RNAs named catalytic antisense RNAs, consisting of a catalytic domain, hairpin or hammerhead ribozyme, and an antisense domain. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of these inhibitory RNAs on HIV-1 replication.

METHODS

A series of expression vectors has been constructed for the intracellular synthesis of inhibitory RNAs, differing in the promoter that drives their synthesis. These inhibitory RNAs were designed to act at two possible cleavage sites in the long terminal repeat (LTR) region and the TAR domain was chosen as a target for the antisense domain. We have evaluated the effects of different inhibitory RNAs in HIV replication via changes in p24 antigen levels. Mobility shift assays have been used to check the binding capacity of inhibitory RNAs.

RESULTS

Catalytic antisense RNA designed to target the LTR region of HIV-1 inhibited viral replication in an eukaryotic cell environment by more than 90%. The conventional hairpin and hammerhead ribozymes, however, failed to inhibit viral replication.

CONCLUSIONS

The data provide preliminary evidence of a new class of inhibitory RNAs that can be used to block HIV replication. The results clearly show the importance of the ex vivo antisense effect in the inhibition achieved. A good correlation was found between the in vitro binding efficiency of the inhibitor RNA to the HIV-1 LTR and the inhibition of viral replication.

In vivo excision of a single targeted nucleotide from an mRNA by a trans excision-splicing ribozyme

We have previously reported the development of a group I intron-derived ribozyme that can bind an exogenous RNA substrate and excise from that substrate an internal segment in vitro, which allows for sequence-specific modification of RNA molecules. In this report, the activity of this trans excision-splicing ribozyme in a cellular environment, specifically Escherichia coli, was investigated. The ribozyme was re-engineered to target for excision a single-base insertion in the transcript of a green fluorescent protein, and fluorescence was exploited as a reporter for trans excision-splicing. We show that the ribozyme is able to catalyze the trans excision-splicing reaction in vivo and can repair the mutant transcripts. On average, 12% correction is observed as measured by fluorescence and at least 0.6% correction as confirmed through sequence analysis. This represents the first report of a biomolecule (in this case a ribozyme) that can selectively excise a targeted nucleotide from within an mRNA transcript in vivo. This new class of biochemical tools makes possible a wide variety of new experimental strategies, perhaps including a new approach to molecular-based therapeutics.

RNA silencing: A remarkable parallel to protein-based immune systems in vertebrates?

Sequence-specific gene silencing by double-strand RNA has been observed in many eukaryotes. Accumulating data suggest that it is the major antiviral defense mechanism in plants and invertebrates. The discovery that this cellular mechanism is also highly conserved though somewhat impaired in mammals has stimulated debate about the evolution of antiviral systems. Here we suggest that the existence of the interferon response as an evolutionary intermediate could account for both the relative decline of RNA silencing and the development of protein-based immune systems in vertebrates. In addition, we emphasize the opportunities presented by RNA silencing and the deeper understanding of vertebrate antiviral systems that is needed.

Gene therapy for proliferative ocular diseases

Proliferative ocular diseases encompass a wide variety of pathological processes with adverse cellular differentiation, proliferation and migration as common features. Pathologies may involve neovascular responses associated with diabetic retinopathy, retinopathy of prematurity or age-related macular degeneration. These diseases are quite prevalent and account for substantial visual impairment and blindness worldwide. Although treatment strategies are largely surgical, advances in our understanding of the proteins crucial to cell transdifferentiation, proliferation and migration, along with better gene transfer techniques, have greatly increased the potential for biological treatment options. In this report, the most common proliferative ocular vascular diseases and existing therapeutic modalities will be reviewed and an overview of possible gene therapy options will be discussed, along with potential candidate genes.

Altering cellular signaling pathways enhance gene silencing activity of shRNA, shRNA.ribozyme, and shRNA.antisense in neuroblastoma cells

1. RNA interference (RNAi) is a multicomponent machinery that operates in a sequence-specific manner to repress the expression of genes in most eukaryotic cells. 2. Here we wanted to investigate in a murine neuroblastoma cell line (NBP2) (a) if replacement of the loop of the short hairpin RNA (shRNA) with a hammerhead ribozyme (shRNA.RZ) or an antisense oligonucleotide (shRNA. AS) would affect the efficacy of gene suppression, and (b) if activation or inhibition of signaling pathways would enhance the efficacy of shRNA, shRNA.RZ, and shRNA. AS complex in gene silencing. 3. We used U6-driven expression of these shRNAs to target either a short-lived green fluorescent protein (d2EGFP) or an endogenous cyclophilin A (CyP-A) gene in a d2EGFP expressing NBP2 cell line (NBP2-PN25). 4. Activation of the cAMP signaling pathway or inhibition of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K) enhanced the efficacy of shRNA and shRNA.RZ complex in reducing the expression of d2EGFP shRNA.RZ complex was as efficacious as shRNA in reducing the expression of d2EGFP and CyP-A shRNA. AS complex showed a slightly lower efficacy than shRNA alone in decreasing d2EGFP expression. In contrast, the U6-driven hammerhead ribozyme targeted to d2EGFP showed no gene silencing activity. 5. This report describes novel strategies of modifying shRNA and altering signaling pathways to affect siRNA-mediated gene silencing in a neuronal cell line.

Toxicology of antisense therapeutics

Targeting unique mRNA molecules using antisense approaches, based on sequence specificity of double-stranded nucleic acid interactions should, in theory, allow for design of drugs with high specificity for intended targets. Antisense-induced degradation or inhibition of translation of a target mRNA is potentially capable of inhibiting the expression of any target protein. In fact, a large number of proteins of widely varied character have been successfully downregulated using an assortment of antisense-based approaches. The most prevalent approach has been to use antisense oligonucleotides (ASOs), which have progressed through the preclinical development stages including pharmacokinetics and toxicological studies. A small number of ASOs are currently in human clinical trials. These trials have highlighted several toxicities that are attributable to the chemical structure of the ASOs, and not to the particular ASO or target mRNA sequence. These include mild thrombocytopenia and hyperglycemia, activation of the complement and coagulation cascades, and hypotension. Dose-limiting toxicities have been related to hepatocellular degeneration leading to decreased levels of albumin and cholesterol. Despite these toxicities, which are generally mild and readily treatable with available standard medications, the clinical trials have clearly shown that ASOs can be safely administered to patients. Alternative chemistries of ASOs are also being pursued by many investigators to improve specificity and antisense efficacy and to reduce toxicity. In the design of ASOs for anticancer therapeutics in particular, the goal is often to enhance the cytotoxicity of traditional drugs toward cancer cells or to reduce the toxicity to normal cells to improve the therapeutic index of existing clinically relevant cancer chemotherapy drugs. We predict that use of antisense ASOs in combination with small molecule therapeutics against the target protein encoded by the antisense-targeted mRNA, or an alternate target in the same or a connected biological pathway, will likely be the most beneficial application of this emerging class of therapeutic agent.

Hybrid QM/MM study of thio effects in transphosphorylation reactions: the role of solvation

Transphosphorylation thio effects in solution are studied using hybrid QM/MM calculations with a d-orbital semiempirical Hamiltonian. Activated dynamics simulations were performed for a 3' ribose-phosphate model in an explicit 20 A sphere of TIP3P water surrounded by a solvent boundary potential, and free energy analysis was performed using the weighted histogram analysis method. Single thio-substitutions at all of the phosphoryl oxygen positions and a double thio-substitution at the nonbridging positions were considered. The reaction free energy profiles are compared with available experimental data, and the role of solvation on the barrier heights and reaction coordinate is discussed. These results provide an important step in the characterization of thio effects in reactions of biological phosphates that may aid in the interpretation of kinetic data and ultimately help to unravel the catalytic mechanisms of ribozymes.

Use of ribozymes in validation of targets involved in tumor progression

The discovery over 20 years ago that RNA molecules called ribozymes are able to catalyze chemical reactions was a breakthrough in biology. Because of their high specificity, wide range of target selection and action before protein translation, ribozymes, mainly hammerhead ribozymes, have been largely used as specific suppressors of gene functions with the additional aim of validating disease-related genes as potential targets for new therapeutic interventions. However, the lack of suitable delivery systems still hampers the clinical development of ribozyme-based therapeutics. In this review, examples of ribozyme-based strategies to validate targets involved in tumor progression are reported together with a comparison of the advantages and disadvantages of ribozymes with respect to RNA interference technology.:

Inhibition of MDR1 gene expression by chimeric HNA antisense oligonucleotides

Hexitol nucleic acids (HNAs) are nuclease resistant and provide strong hybridization to RNA. However, there is relatively little information on the biological properties of HNA antisense oligonucleotides. In this study, we compared the antisense effects of a chimeric HNA 'gapmer' oligonucleotide comprising a phosphorothioate central sequence flanked by 5' and 3' HNA sequences to conventional phosphorothioate oligonucleotides and to a 2'-O-methoxyethyl (2'-O-ME) phosphorothioate 'gapmer'. The antisense oligomers each targeted a sequence bracketing the start codon of the message of MDR1, a gene involved in multi-drug resistance in cancer cells. Antisense and control oligonucleotides were delivered to MDR1-expressing cells using transfection with the cationic lipid Lipofectamine 2000. The anti-MDR1 HNA gapmer was substantially more potent than a phosphorothioate oligonucleotide of the same sequence in reducing expression of P-glycoprotein, the MDR1 gene product. HNA and 2'-O-ME gapmers displayed similar potency, but a pure HNA antisense oligonucleotide (lacking the phosphorothioate 'gap') was ineffective, indicating that RNase H activity was likely required. Treatment with anti-MDR1 HNA gapmer resulted in increased cellular accumulation of the drug surrogate Rhodamine 123 that correlated well with the reduced cell surface expression of P-glycoprotein. Thus, HNA gapmers may provide a valuable additional tool for antisense-based investigations and therapeutic approaches.

Emerging Technologies: Trendy RNA Tools for Aging Research

Aging is an inevitable biological phenomenon. Attempts to understand its mechanisms and, consequently, to therapeutically decelerate or even reverse the process are limited by its daunting complexity. Rapid and robust functional genomic tools suited to a wide array of experimental model systems are needed to dissect the interplay of individual genes during aging. In this article, we review principles that transcend the view of RNA, from a molecule merely mediating the flow of genetic information, into a unique molecular tool. In the form of catalytic molecular scissors (ribozymes), antibody-like antagonists (aptamers) and gene silencers (interfering RNAs, RNAi) can be effectively used to dissect biofunctions conserved throughout the evolution. In this review, application of recent RNA tools in aging research is discussed.

Interference of mRNA function by sequence-specific endoribonuclease PemK

In Escherichia coli, programmed cell death is mediated through the system called "addiction module," which consists of a pair of genes encoding a stable toxin and a labile antitoxin. The pemI-pemK system is an addiction module present on plasmid R100. It helps to maintain the plasmid by post-segregational killing in E. coli population. Here we demonstrate that purified PemK, the toxin encoded by the pemI-pemK addiction module, inhibits protein synthesis in an E. coli cell-free system, whereas the addition of PemI, the antitoxin against PemK, resumes the protein synthesis. Further studies reveal that PemK is a sequence-specific endoribonuclease that cleaves mRNAs to inhibit protein synthesis, whereas PemI blocks the endoribonuclease activity of PemK. PemK cleaves only single-stranded RNA preferentially at the 5' or 3' side of the A residue in the "UAH" sequences (where H is C, A, or U). Upon induction, PemK cleaves cellular mRNAs to effectively block protein synthesis in E. coli. The pemK homologue genes have been identified on the genomes of a wide range of bacteria. We propose that PemK and its homologues form a novel endoribonuclease family that interferes with mRNA function by cleaving cellular mRNAs in a sequence-specific manner.