Self-tolerance alters T-cell receptor expression in an antigen-specific MHC restricted immune response

Clonal deletion versus clonal anergy: the role of the thymus in inducing self tolerance

During development in the thymus, T cells are rendered tolerant to self antigens. It is now apparent that thymocytes bearing self-reactive T cell receptors can be tolerized by processes that result in physical elimination (clonal deletion) or functional inactivation (clonal anergy). As these mechanisms have important clinical implications for transplantation and autoimmunity, current investigations are focused on understanding the cellular and molecular interactions that generate these forms of tolerance.

Flexibility of the T cell repertoire. Self tolerance causes a shift of T cell receptor gene usage in response to insulin

Bovine insulin(BI)-specific I-Ab-restricted T cell clones have been characterized for fine specificity and TCR gene usage. We have demonstrated that mouse strains carrying H-2b on three different genetic backgrounds (C57BL, BALB, and 129) rearrange and express the V beta 6 gene in a large proportion (36%) of insulin-specific clones. In these strains, the non-MHC background did not seem to influence TCR gene usage in response to BI. The V beta 6+ clones appeared to be selected by the antigen. In contrast, no V beta 6+ clones could be isolated from (B6 x DBA/2)F1 mice, where V beta 6+ (and V beta 8.1+) T cells are deleted by self tolerance to Mls-1a. Thus, although a small proportion of residual V beta 6+ cells had been demonstrated in Mls-1a mice, these cells could not be retrieved in a response that uses V beta 6 predominantly. In functional terms, therefore, the deletion of V beta 6 by self tolerance appears to be complete. Instead of V beta 6, the majority (up to 60%) of I-Ab- as well as I-Ad-restricted insulin-specific clones from the (B6 x DBA/2)F1 mice expressed V beta 8.2 and V beta 8.3. This shift of gene usage was not accompanied by any detectable change in the fine specificity pattern of response. Thus, in the insulin-specific response, the flexibility of T cell repertoire fully compensates for deletions caused by self tolerance.

Novel origin of lpr and gld cells and possible implications in autoimmunity

The lpr and gld mutations are prime examples of single-gene defects associated with expansion of a unique double-negative (CD4-8-), T-cell receptor alpha:beta + cell population and heightened polyclonal and autoimmune responses. The exact origin of these autoimmunity-inducing/enhancing T cells remains controversial. Here, we review the characteristics of the lpr and gld mutations, and speculate on the possible relationship of these cells to normal thymic differentiation pathways. We argue that mounting evidence now supports the existence of a CD4/CD8-loss pathway of late thymic differentiation, responsible for the origin of both normal and lpr/gld double-negative alpha:beta + cells. We further speculate that downregulation of CD4 and CD8 accessory molecules on thymocytes with moderately autoreactive T-cell receptors is involved in selecting cells, including lpr/gld precursors for this pathway. Escape of a large number of such autoreactive cells from thymic elimination might be an important contributory factor to the pathogenesis of autoimmunity.

Response of mature unprimed CD8+ T cells to Mlsa determinants

Contrary to existing dogma, evidence is presented that proliferative responses of mature unprimed T cells to Mlsa antigens involve CD8+ cells as well as CD4+ cells. The response of CD8+ cells to Mlsa antigens proved to be heavily dependent on help from CD4+ cells, and responses were stronger in three I-E+ strain combinations than in an I-E- combination. In I-E+ combinations, CD8+ blast cells accounted for 20-25% of the blasts generated from unseparated T cells responding to Mlsa-bearing stimulator cells in vitro; similar findings applied to blast cells generated in vivo. The observation that the majority (greater than or equal to 50%) of Mlsa-stimulated CD8+ cells (and CD4+ cells) were V beta 6+ indicated that CD8+ cells respond to Mlsa antigens, per se, rather than to nonspecific stimuli. Whether CD4+ and CD8+ cells use the same or different H-2-restricting elements to respond to Mlsa antigens has yet to be resolved.

Programmed death of autoreactive thymocytes

T lymphocytes bearing high-affinity T-cell receptors (TCR) for self-antigens are clonally deleted during thymus development. Several recent studies have identified variable domains of the beta-chain of the TCR that are specifically deleted in vivo in mouse strains that express major histocompatibility complex class II molecules in addition to poorly defined self-antigens, including those encoded by the Mls-1a and Mls-2a loci. Deletion of autoreactive cells in these systems occurs in the thymus, and antibody blocking experiments in vivo have implicated the phenotypically immature CD4+CD8+ 'cortical' subset as the target population for clonal deletion. Similarly, studies with transgenic mice bearing autoreactive TCR have provided independent evidence that clonal deletion occurs at the CD4+CD8+ stage of development. But none of these studies directly identified dying autoreactive cells, and the circumstances leading to deletion remain unclear. Here we report that neonatal thymus contains a significant population of phenotypically mature CD4+CD8- cells bearing autoreactive TCR. When placed in short-term culture, a large proportion (60%) of these autoreactive cells die selectively. Furthermore, their death can be prevented by inhibitors of macromolecule (RNA and protein) synthesis, as is the case for glucocorticoid-induced death of thymocytes. These data indicate that physiological clonal deletion of autoreactive cells involves 'programmed' cell death, and that it can occur in cells with a mature (CD4+CD8-) surface phenotype.

Intrathymic clonal deletion of V beta 6+ T cells in cyclophosphamide-induced tolerance to H-2-compatible, Mls-disparate antigens

When C3H (H-2k, Mls-1b) mice were primed intravenously with 10(8) viable spleen cells from AKR (H-2k, Mls-1a) and treated intraperitoneally with 200 mg/kg of cyclophosphamide (CP) 2 d later, not only a long-lasting skin allograft tolerance but also a tolerance in mixed lymphocyte reaction to Mls-1a-encoded antigens was established. The cellular mechanisms of CP-induced tolerance were examined by assessing the V beta 6-bearing T cells that are strongly correlated with reactivity to Mls-1a-encoded antigens bound to MHC class II molecules. At the relatively early stage (2 or 5 wk) after the CP treatment, CD4+-V beta 6+ T cells of C3H origin were preferentially eliminated in the lymph nodes of the tolerant mice, whereas CD8+-V beta 6+ T cells remained. On the other hand, neither CD4+CD8- nor CD4-CD8+ thymocytes bearing a high density of V beta 6 was detected in the chimeric thymus. Namely, in the thymus of the tolerant C3H mice, neither mixed chimerism nor the clonal deletion of the V beta 6-bearing T cells was observed on day 14, whereas both of them were observed on day 35. The clonal deletion and mixed chimerism in the thymus were lasting for greater than 10 wk after the CP treatment. Expression of V beta 6 on the peripheral T cells in the tolerant C3H mice gradually reduced in the process of time. These results strongly suggested that the clonal deletion in the thymus was one of the essential mechanisms in the CP-induced tolerance system.

Minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mls) gene products in mice influence their genetic resistance or susceptibility to induction of autoimmune encephalomyelitis

The role of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene products in the genetics of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) is well established. Here we demonstrate how non-MHC gene products, stimulatory to T cells specific to myelin basic protein (MBP), can affect the MHC control in determining genetic susceptibility or resistance to induction of EAE. I-As-restricted MBP-specific T cells derived from SJL/J mice are shown to cross-react with Mls-2a gene products. The Mls-2a gene product expressed by (SJL/J X BALB/c)F1 mice tolerize T cells recognizing I-As/MBP and favor the development of I-Es/d-restricted MBP-specific T cells mediating EAE in the (SJL/J x BALB/c)F1 mice. These I-Es/d/MBP-specific T cells, cross-reactive with Mls-1a, and the I-As/MBP-specific T cells, cross-reactive with Mls-2a gene products, are both eliminated by self tolerance mechanisms in the H-2-matched (SJL/J X DBA/2)F1 mice, expressing Mls-1a2a gene products, and thereby confer genetic resistance to EAE on the (SJL/J X DBA/2)F1 mice bearing EAE-permissive MHC alleles. These results reflect a developmental selection of a T cell repertoire to the self antigen MBP, imposed by self tolerance to self Mls gene products, which affect the genetic susceptibility to EAE. These studies also demonstrate that self tolerance to Mls gene products can strengthen the tolerance to organ-specific self antigens such as MBP, which may not be expressed or which are absent in the thymus at the time of thymic selection.

Tolerance-related V beta clonal deletions in normal CD4-8-, TCR-alpha/beta + and abnormal lpr and gld cell populations

We have analyzed tolerance-related clonal deletion of Mls-and I-E-reactive thymocytes at the RNA level using a multi-V beta probe RNAse protection assay, and used this phenomenon to identify the maturation stage of the abnormally expanded CD4-8-, TCR-alpha/beta + subset in lpr and gld homozygous mice, and of the phenotypically similar minor thymocyte subset found in normal mice. Essentially complete V beta clonal deletions were detected in lpr and gld cells of all appropriate background strains. Substantial, but not complete, V beta clonal deletions were also detected in the CD4-8- TCR-alpha/beta + subset of normal mice. Since expression of CD4/CD8 is required for V beta clonal deletions to occur, we conclude that lpr and gld cells, and at least a portion of CD4-8- TCR-alpha/beta + thymocytes in normal mice, are derived by secondary loss of CD4/CD8 accessory molecules from more mature CD4+8+ precursors. One possible interpretation of these findings is that such CD4/CD8 loss may affect a class of self-reactive thymocytes that have escaped direct clonal deletion. Exportation and expansion of such cells in the periphery may be an important contributory factor in the induction of systemic autoimmunity.

Failure of T cell receptor V beta negative selection in an athymic environment

The mature T cell receptor (TCR) repertoire is the result of selection events during T cell development. Previous assessment of TCR beta-chain selection with serologic and molecular probes demonstrated both positive and negative selection. Although this work suggested a critical role for the thymus, no direct assessment has been made of the requirement for a thymus in TCR V beta selection. A comparison of TCR V beta expression in four different congenic pairs of normal and nu/nu (athymic) mice indicated that the normal V beta deletions associated with tolerance to self minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mlsc) antigens or to self major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-encoded E alpha E beta products did not occur in most athymic mice. Thus, the thymus has a critical role in mediating self tolerance by negative selection.

Thymic requirement for clonal deletion during T cell development

During T cell differentiation, self tolerance is established in part by the deletion of self-reactive T cells within the thymus (negative selection). The presence of T cell receptor (TCR)-alpha beta + T cells in older athymic (nu/nu) mice indicates that some T cells can also mature without thymic influence. Therefore, to determine whether the thymus is required for negative selection, TCR V beta expression was compared in athymic nu/nu mice and their congenic normal littermates. T cells expressing V beta 3 proteins are specific for minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mlsc) determinants and are deleted intrathymically due to self tolerance in Mlsc+ mouse strains. Here it is shown that V beta 3+ T cells are deleted in Mlsc+ BALB/c nu/+ mice, but not in their BALB/c nu/nu littermates. Thus, the thymus is required for clonal deletion during T cell development.

Analysis of Mlsc genetics. A novel instance of genetic redundancy

The identity of the self determinants involved in the selection of the T cell repertoire has been a matter of considerable interest. In addition to the apparent critical role of MHC gene products, accumulated experimental results indicate the importance of non-MHC gene products in T cell repertoire selection. In particular, murine Mlsa and Mlsc determinants have been shown to be highly stimulatory to allogeneic T cells and to be involved in the negative selection (elimination) of self-reactive T cells expressing selected TCR V beta segments. In this work, a unique phenomenon of genetic redundancy is described in the control of Mlsc expression: Mlsc appears to be controlled by at least two unlinked loci, and the product of either one of these loci is sufficient to evoke Mlsc-specific T cell response and to act as a ligand in the deletion of self Mlsc-reactive V beta 3+ T cells. Based on these findings, we propose a possible explanation for the fact that Mls-like genes or gene products have not been identified in other species such as man.

Neonatal thymectomy results in a repertoire enriched in T cells deleted in adult thymus

In B6AF1 mice, T lymphocytes that use the V beta 11-positive (and not V beta 6-positive or V beta 8-positive) segment in their receptor for antigen are greatly reduced in the thymus and peripheral lymphoid tissues, most likely as a result of clonal deletion. The relative number of V beta 11-positive cells in adult lymph nodes was ten times as high in B6AF1 mice thymectomized 1 to 4 days after birth as in normal mice. Moreover, for the first 10 days of life of B6AF1 mice, mature V beta 11-positive T cells were readily detected in the thymus and spleen. Thus neonatal thymectomy results in the maintenance of the receptor repertoire of early postnatal life, and this correlates with the subsequent development of organ-specific autoimmune diseases.

Phenotypic differences between alpha beta versus beta T-cell receptor transgenic mice undergoing negative selection

T-cell differentiation in the thymus is thought to involve a progression from the CD4-CD8- phenotype through CD4+CD8+ intermediates to mature CD4+ or CD8+ cells. There is evidence that during this process T cells bearing receptors potentially reactive to 'self' are deleted by a process termed 'negative selection' One example of this process occurs in mice carrying polymorphic Mls antigens, against which a detectable proportion of T cells are autoreactive. These mice show clonal deletion of thymic and peripheral T-cell subsets that express the autoreactive V beta 3 segment of the T-cell antigen receptor, but at most a two-fold depletion of thymic cells at the CD4+CD8+ stage. By contrast, transgenic mice bearing both alpha and beta chain genes encoding autoreactive receptors recognizing other ligands, show severe depletion of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes as well, suggesting that negative selection occurs much earlier. We report here the Mls 2a/3a mediated elimination of T cells expressing a transgene encoded V beta 3-segment, in T-cell receptor alpha/beta and beta-transgenic mice. Severe depletion of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes is seen only in the alpha/beta chain transgenic mice, whereas both strains delete mature V beta 3 bearing CD4+ and CD8+ T cells efficiently. We conclude that severe CD4+CD8+ thymocyte deletion in alpha/beta transgenic mice results from the premature expression of both receptor chains, and does not reflect a difference in the timing or mechanism of negative selection for Mls antigens as against the allo- and MHC class 1-restricted antigens used in the other studies.

Deletion of Mls-reactive T cells in H-2-compatible but Mls-incompatible bone marrow chimeras

The cellular basis of tolerance induction to Mls-encoded antigens in radiation bone marrow (BM) chimeras has been investigated in two H-2-compatible strain combinations of AKR/J (H-2k, Thy-1.1, Mls-Ia) and C3H/He (H-2k, Thy-1.2, Mls-IIa). Sequential appearance of host- and donor-derived T cell subsets and T cell receptor gene messages occurred in the peripheral lymphoid organs of both irradiated AKR/J mice reconstituted with C3H/He BM cells (C3H/He-AKR/J chimera) and irradiated C3H/He mice reconstituted with AKR/J BM cells (AKR/J-C3H/He chimera). A large number of cells expressing T cell receptor gamma genes were detected in spleen on day 21 after reconstitution, while the normal level of alloreactivity was first detected in the spleen on day 56 after reconstitution in correlation with the appearance of appreciable levels of Thy-1 high cells and T cell receptor alpha and beta gene transcripts. T cells bearing V beta 6, that is strongly correlated with reactivity to antigens encoded by the Mls-Ia genetic locus, were virtually abolished in spleen on day 56 in both C3H/He-AKR/J chimera and AKR/J-C3H/He chimera. Furthermore, expression of V beta 3 gene transcripts, that are important for recognizing Mls-IIa, was undetected either in the peripheral lymphoid cells of AKR/J-C3H/He chimera or in those of C3H/He-AKR/J chimera. These results suggested that clonal elimination of self-reactive T cells bearing V beta 3 or V beta 6 was induced by both host-derived radioresistant cells and donor-derived repopulating cells in the thymus of radiation BM chimeras.

Postnatal disappearance of self-reactive (V beta 6+) cells from the thymus of Mlsa mice. Implications for T cell development and autoimmunity

The postnatal ontogeny of potentially autoreactive T cells has been studied in a model system where a particular TCR beta chain variable domain (V beta 6) is correlated with reactivity to a minor antigen encoded by the Mlsa locus. Although absent among mature (CD4+ or CD8+) T cells in adult mice expressing Mlsa, brightly staining V beta 6+ cells were readily detectable in the thymus of neonatal animals, reaching a maximum after 4 d and decreasing rapidly thereafter. These V beta 6+ thymocytes were predominantly of the CD4+ phenotype and were localized in the medulla of the developing thymus. Furthermore, the intensity of TCR expression by these CD4+ cells was significantly (twofold) reduced as compared with age-matched Mlsb controls. A rapid disappearance of CD4+V beta 6+ cells (and corresponding decrease in TCR density) could also be observed in the thymus of Mlsb mice that had been injected neonatally with Mlsa spleen cells. Taken together, these results raise the possibility that some autoreactive T cells may persist after birth and that TCR downregulation may occur as a physiological response to tolerogenic signals in vivo.

Two monoclonal antibodies specific for the T cell receptor V alpha 8

Two monoclonal antibodies, KT50 and KT65, specific for V alpha 8 have been established. This was determined as follows: (a) 4 T cell clones, C6, R1, G22 and I9, out of 43 T cell clones with various antigen specificities, major histocompatibility complex restrictions and V beta usages not only bound KT50 and KT65 but also expressed V alpha 8 mRNA, (b) KT50 and KT65 precipitated molecules from the clone C6 similar to the T cell receptor molecules precipitated in C6 cells by KT11 (anti-V beta 11) or KTL2 (anti-Ti) and (c) KT50 and KT65 were mitogenic and induced cytotoxicity. All strains of mice so far examined have populations of KT50+ and KT65+ T cells of 1.4%-3.6% and 0.9%-2.6%, respectively. Different H-2 haplotypes were not observed to affect the number of cells expressing KT50 or KT65. In addition KT15 (anti-CD8), without cross-linking to KT50 or KT65, augmented proliferation triggered by KT50 or KT65.

Relative V beta transcript levels in thymus and peripheral lymphoid tissues from various mouse strains. Inverse correlation of I-E and Mls expression with relative abundance of several V beta transcripts in peripheral lymphoid tissues

We have measured the relative levels of transcripts for 15 of the 22 known V beta gene segments. The level of transcripts for the highest and lowest expressed V beta gene segment differed by greater than 20-fold in the thymus and an even larger difference was observed in the periphery. The levels of expressions were unrelated to the order of the V beta genes on the chromosome. For most of the V beta gene segments, the relative transcript levels were the same in the thymus and periphery, suggesting that thymic selection in general does not act solely upon the V beta gene segment. One V beta gene segment in the BALB and B10 mice strains was an exception to this rule. V beta 5.2 expression in the periphery of BALB and B10 mice inversely correlated with the expression of the MHC class II molecule I-E. Five V beta gene segments had reduced transcript levels in the periphery of Mls-1a mice compared with their thymic levels or to the levels found in Mls-1b mice. The peripheral level of V beta 3 transcripts vary with MHC and Mls-2 haplotypes. The observation that certain V beta transcript levels are reduced in the periphery when compared with the thymus favors the hypothesis that self tolerance at the T cell level results in the elimination of self-reactive T cells, rather than paralysis by a block at some post-transcriptional step. Finally, the wide variability of V beta gene segment expression in the thymus suggests mechanisms exist to import an early bias to the repertoire. Whether this bias results from differential V beta segment rearrangement rates, differential V beta expression rates, or events occurring after TCR-alpha/beta expression on immature/nonmature thymocyte cell surfaces is yet to be determined.

Positive selection of CD4-CD8+ T cells in the thymus of normal mice

The diversification of the repertoire of T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) specificities is influenced by at least two selection processes which occur in the thymus. One of these, termed 'negative selection', is required to install a state of tolerance to self-antigens in the T-cell repertoire and is often achieved by clonal deletion. The second type of selection operating in the thymus results in preferential differentiation of T cells that have restriction specificity for thymic major histocompatibility complex glycoproteins, but the mechanisms leading to this selective process are not yet clear. One model used to describe this 'positive selection' proposes that only those T cells with sufficient avidity for the MHC glycoproteins expressed in the thymus are allowed to acquire functional competence. Here we directly investigate the generation of TCR specificities by following the fate of developing V beta 17+ CD4-CD8+ T cells under conditions where one of the main class I-MHC molecules, either H-2K or H-2D, was specifically blocked by in vitro monoclonal antibody treatment. The results show that development of V beta 17+ CD4-CD8+ T cells in the SJL H-2s mouse strain is selectively abrogated by blocking class I-Ks molecules but is unaffected by blocking class I-Ds molecules. These data directly demonstrate that generation of CD4-CD8+ T cells expressing a particular TCR V beta segment can be correlated with the expression of a particular class I-MHC molecule, thereby providing evidence for positive selection.

Alternative T cell receptor gene usage induced by self tolerance

Ab-restricted, H-Y-specific T cell clones from C57BL/6 mice were found to use predominantly V beta 6 T cell receptor genes, conferring Mls-1a reactivity. However, the expression of Mls-1a as a self antigen in (DBA/2 x C57BL/6)F1 mice did not turn these mice into nonresponders to H-Y. Instead of V beta 6, they used other T cell receptor genes in this response. Thus, self tolerance appears to bias the repertoire of T cell receptor genes used in response to foreign antigens, without necessarily impairing the immune responsiveness to these antigens.

Analysis of specificity for antigen, Mls, and allogenic MHC by transfer of T-cell receptor alpha- and beta-chain genes

The majority of peripheral T lymphocytes bear cell-surface antigen receptors comprised of a disulphide-linked alpha beta dimer. In an immune response, this receptor endows T cells with specificities for foreign antigenic protein fragments bound to cell surface glycoproteins encoded in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). At a high frequency (greater than 1%), the same population of T lymphocytes responds to allogeneic MHC glycoproteins, or to differences at other genetic loci termed Mls, in conjunction with MHC. The alpha beta-antigen receptor has been implicated in alloreactivity and Mls reactivity. In fact, many monoclonal T-cell lines recognize a foreign protein fragment bound to self-MHC molecules and, in addition, recognize allogeneic MHC glycoproteins, an Mls-encoded determinant, or both. For at least one T-cell clone, a monoclonal antibody directed against the alpha beta antigen receptor has been shown to block activation induced by either antigen-bound self-MHC or by allogeneic MHC. However, it remains to be demonstrated directly that a single alpha beta receptor can mediate antigen specificity, alloreactivity and Mls reactivity, a prerequisite to understanding the structural basis of these high-frequency cross-reactivities. To address this issue we have performed transfers of receptor chain genes from a multiple-reactive T-cell clone into an unrelated host T lymphocyte. We now demonstrate definitively that the genes encoding a single alpha beta-receptor chain pair can transfer the recognition of self-MHC molecules complexed with fragments of antigen, allogeneic MHC molecules, and an Mls-encoded determinant (presumably in conjunction with MHC). In this case the transfer of antigen specificity and alloreactivity requires a specific alpha beta-receptor chain combination, whereas Mls reactivity can be transferred with the beta-chain gene alone into a recipient expressing a randomly selected alpha-chain.

Preferential expression of the T-cell receptor V beta 3 gene by Mlsc reactive T cells

The precursor frequency of T cells specific for any given foreign antigen is, in general, extremely low. Prominent exceptions to this rule are the T cells that are specific for foreign major histocompatibility complex (MHC) products or for products of the minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) genes in the mouse which are present at high frequencies. Here, we report a striking overlap or cross-reactivity between the T cells specific for the protein antigen pigeon cytochrome c in association with Ek alpha Ek beta and the set of T cells specific for Mlsc products. In addition, we demonstrate that the basis for this overlap is the predominant expression of one T-cell receptor (TCR) V beta gene, V beta 3, by T cells that recognize Mlsc products. These results indicate the importance of specific TCR alpha beta dimers in the recognition of Mlsc products and that positive or negative selection of T cells specific for Mls self-determinants may selectively alter the repertoire of T cells available for MHC-restricted recognition of foreign antigens.