Class II-positive hematopoietic cells cannot mediate positive selection of CD4+ T lymphocytes in class II-deficient mice

Selection of antigen-specific T cells by a single IEk peptide combination

In normal mice, major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins are bound to many different peptides, derived from the proteins of their host. In the thymus, the diversity of this collection of MHC + peptide ligands allows thymocytes bearing many different T cell receptors (TCRs) to mature by low avidity reactions between the MHC + peptide ligands and the thymocyte TCRs. To investigate this problem, the selection of T cells specific for a well-studied combination of MHC + peptide, IEk + moth cytochrome c 88-103 (MCC), was investigated. Mice were created that expressed IEk bound to a single peptide, either a variant of MCC in which a critical TCR contact residue, 99K, was changed to A, or a variant of a mouse hemoglobin 64-76 (Hb) peptide, 72A. IEk bound to the MCC variant caused the clonal deletion of some T cells specific for the IEk + MCC ligand; nevertheless, it also positively selected many T cells that could react with this ligand. Some of the TCRs on the selected T cells were related to those on cells from normal mice and some were not. IEk bound to the Hb variant, on the other hand, did not select any T cells which could react with IEk + MCC. These results demonstrate that although positive selection is a partially degenerate event, the sequence of the peptide involved in positive selection controls the selected repertoire.

Survival of mature CD4 T lymphocytes is dependent on major histocompatibility complex class II-expressing dendritic cells

Thymic T cell development is controlled by T cell receptor (TCR)-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) interactions, whereas a further dependence of peripheral mature T cells on TCR-MHC contact has not been described so far. To study this question, CD4 T cell survival was surveyed in mice lacking MHC class II expression and in mice expressing MHC class II exclusively on dendritic cells. Since neither of these mice positively select CD4 T cells in the thymus, they were grafted with MHC class II-positive embryonic thymic tissue, which had been depleted of bone marrow derived cells. Although the thymus grafts in both hosts were repopulated with host origin thymocytes of identical phenotype and numbers, an accumulation of CD4+ T cells in peripheral lymphoid organs could only be observed in mice expressing MHC class II on dendritic cells, but not in mice that were completely MHC class II deficient. As assessed by histology, the accumulating peripheral CD4 T cells were found to be in close contact with MHC class II+ dendritic cells, suggesting that CD4 T cells need peripheral MHC class II expression for survival and that class II+ dendritic cells might play an important role for the longevity of CD4 T cells.

CD8+ effector cells responding to residual class I antigens, with help from CD4+ cells stimulated indirectly, cause rejection of "major histocompatibility complex-deficient" skin grafts

BACKGROUND

Skin grafts from mice that are deficient in the expression of both class I and class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) antigens are rejected rapidly by normal recipients.

METHODS

To determine the mechanism of this rejection, MHC-deficient skin grafts were placed on recipients with different degrees of antigenic disparity and on recipients depleted of selected T cell subpopulations. In addition, the recipient's T cells were examined in vitro for their responses before and after graft rejection.

RESULTS

The results indicate that (1) CD4+ cells provide help for this rejection by recognizing donor antigens presented by recipient class II antigens, and (2) CD8+ cells can participate as effector cells, recognizing residual class I antigens expressed by the MHC-deficient grafts.

CONCLUSIONS

The primary conclusion from these studies is that the supposedly MHC-deficient mice actually do have sufficient class I antigen expression to cause skin graft rejection. This finding prevents the use of these mice to answer definitively the question of whether grafts entirely lacking MHC antigens would be rejected. However, these studies do illustrate two important (although previously recognized) features of allogeneic skin graft rejection: (1) that rejection can be initiated by help provided entirely through the indirect pathway, and (2) that help provided through the indirect pathway is available for effector T cells sensitized directly by donor cells. However, the results from these and other studies suggest that indirect effector mechanisms would probably be able to destroy truly MHC-deficient grafts under some circumstances.

Targeted expression of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II molecules demonstrates that dendritic cells can induce negative but not positive selection of thymocytes in vivo

It is well established that lymphoid dendritic cells (DC) play an important role in the immune system. Beside their role as potent inducers of primary T cell responses, DC seem to play a crucial part as major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II+ "interdigitating cells" in the thymus during thymocyte development. Thymic DC have been implicated in tolerance induction and also by some authors in inducing major histocompatibility complex restriction of thymocytes. Most of our knowledge about thymic DC was obtained using highly invasive and manipulatory experimental protocols such as thymus reaggregation cultures, suspension cultures, thymus grafting, and bone marrow reconstitution experiments. The DC used in those studies had to go through extensive isolation procedures or were cultured with recombinant growth factors. Since the functions of DC after these in vitro manipulations have been reported to be not identical to those of DC in vivo, we intended to establish a system that would allow us to investigate DC function avoiding artificial interferences due to handling. Here we present a transgenic mouse model in which we targeted gene expression specifically to DC. Using the CD 11c promoter we expressed MHC class II I-E molecules specifically on DC of all tissues, but not on other cell types. We report that I-E expression on thymic DC is sufficient to negatively select I-E reactive CD4+ T cells, and to a less complete extent, CD8+ T cells. In contrast, it only DC expressed I-E in a class II-deficient background, positive selection of CD4+ T cells could not be observed. Thus negative, but not positive, selection events can be induced by DC in vivo.

Quantitative impact of thymic clonal deletion on the T cell repertoire

Interactions between major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules expressed on stromal cells and antigen-specific receptors on T cells shape the repertoire of mature T lymphocytes emerging from the thymus. Some thymocytes with appropriate receptors are stimulated to undergo differentiation to the fully mature state (positive selection), whereas others with strongly autoreactive receptors are triggered to undergo programmed cell death before completing this differentiation process (negative selection). The quantitative impact of negative selection on the potentially available repertoire is currently unknown. To address this issue, we have constructed radiation bone marrow chimeras in which MHC molecules are present on radioresistant thymic epithelial cells (to allow positive selection) but absent from radiosensitive hematopoietic elements responsible for negative selection. In such chimeras, the number of mature thymocytes was increased by twofold as compared with appropriate control chimeras This increase in steady-state numbers of mature thymocytes was not related to proliferation, increased retention, or recirculation and was accompanied by a similar two- to threefold increase in the de novo rate of generation of mature cells. Taken together, our data indicate that half to two-thirds of the thymocytes able to undergo positive selection die before full maturation due to negative selection.

Intrathymic maturation of CD4+ T-lymphocytes in an MHC class II deficient transplant model

Major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II knockout (class II-) mice fail to generate CD4+ CD8- T-lymphocytes. We were interested in determining whether these class II- mice could be reconstituted with CD4+ CD8- T-lymphocytes following marrow transplantation from normal (class II+) donors. Transplantation of class II+ marrow into lethally irradiated class II- recipients failed to generate peripheral CD4+ CD8- T-lymphocytes. Unexpectedly, however, transplantation of class II marrow into class II+ recipients also resulted in a deficiency of CD4+ CD8- cells. Analysis of intrathymic T cells showed normal distribution of CD4 and CD8 single and double positive or negative thymocytes in normal recipients, while class II- recipients always lacked CD4+ CD8- T cells intrathymically. These results suggest, therefore, that T-cell maturation in mice requires the presence of MHC class II antigens not only in the thymus but also on immature, marrow-derived pre-thymocytes.

An activated form of Notch influences the choice between CD4 and CD8 T cell lineages

Notch is a transmembrane receptor that controls cell fate decisions in Drosophila and whose role in mammalian cell fate decisions is beginning to be explored. We are investigating the role of Notch in a well-studied mammalian cell fate decision: the choice between the CD8 and CD4 T cell lineages. Here we report that expression of an activated form of Notch1 in developing T cells of the mouse leads to both an increase in CD8 lineage T cells and a decrease in CD4 lineage T cells. Expression of activated Notch permits the development of mature CD8 lineage thymocytes even in the absence of class I major histocompatability complex (MHC) proteins, ligands that are normally required for the development of these cells. However, activated Notch is not sufficient to promote CD8 cell development when both class I and class II MHC are absent. These results implicate Notch as a participant in the CD4 versus CD8 lineage decision.

Cellular interactions in thymocyte development

Interactions between stromal cells and thymocytes play a crucial role in T cell development. The thymic stroma is complex and consists of epithelial cells derived from the pharyngeal region during development, together with macrophages and dendritic cells of bone marrow origin. In addition, fibroblasts and matrix molecules permeate the whole framework. It is now apparent that these individual stromal components play specialized roles at different stages of T cell differentiation. Thus, at the early CD4-8- stage of development, T cell precursors require fibroblast as well as epithelial cell interactions. Later, at the CD4+8+ stage, as well as providing low avidity TCR/MHC-peptide interactions, thymic epithelial cells have been shown to possess unique properties essential for positive selection. Dendritic cells, on the other hand, are probably efficient mediators of negative selection, but they may not be solely responsible for this activity. Alongside the functional roles of stromal cells, considerable progress is being made in unraveling the nature of the signaling pathways involved in T cell development. Identification of the pre-T cell receptor (pre-TCR) and associated signaling molecules marks an important advance in understanding the mechanisms that control gene rearrangement and allelic exclusion. In addition, a better understanding of the signaling pathways that lead to positive selection on the one hand and negative selection on the other is beginning to emerge. Many issues remain unresolved, and some are discussed in this review. What, for example, is the nature of the chemotactic factor(s) that attract stem cells to the thymus? What is the molecular basis of the essential interactions between early thymocytes and fibroblasts, and early thymocytes and epithelial cells? What is special about cortical epithelial cells in supporting positive selection? These and other issues are ripe for analysis and can now be approached using a combination of modern molecular and cellular techniques.

Bone marrow-derived cells fail to induce positive selection in thymus reaggregation cultures

The requirements for inducing positive selection of T cells were examined in thymus reaggregation cultures, a system in which dispersed populations of immature CD4+8+ cells and purified thymic epithelial cells (TEC) are reaggregated in tissue culture. Studies with TEC from mice selectively lacking major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I (I-II+), class II (I+II-), or both class I and II (I-II-) molecules showed that class II expression was essential for the differentiation of CD4+8+ cells into CD4+8- cells. Unexpectedly, the generation of TCRhi CD4-8+ cells from CD4+8+ cells was apparent with I-II+ TEC but not with I-II- TEC, perhaps reflecting cross-reactive specificity of CD4-8+ cells for class II molecules. Significantly, the failure of I-II- TEC to generate TCRhi CD4+8- or CD4-8+ cells could not be overcome by adding MHC+ bone marrow-derived cells. These findings, together with experiments on purified subsets of TEC, suggest that positive selection in thymus reaggregation cultures is an exclusive property of cortical TEC.

Immune CD4+ T cells promote the clearance of influenza virus from major histocompatibility complex class II -/- respiratory epithelium

The experiments described establish that CD4+ T-cell-dependent effector mechanisms can eliminate an H3N2 influenza A virus from lung cells that are unable to express class II major histocompatibility complex (MHC) glycoproteins. Radiation chimeras were made by using CD4+ T cells and bone marrow from CD8-depleted, MHC class II +/+ mice and irradiated (950 rads) MHC class II -/- recipients. The influenza virus-specific CD4+ T-cell responses in these +/+-->-/- mice were not obviously different from those in the +/+-->+/+ controls: the cytokine profiles, the spectra of plasma cells producing the various immunoglobulin isotypes, and the frequencies of virus-specific CD4+ T cells were similar for the two groups. Expression of class II MHC glycoproteins on stimulator cells, B lymphocytes, and monocytes/macrophages is apparently sufficient for CD4+ T cells to terminate influenza virus infection of MHC class II -/- respiratory epithelium. A possible explanation is that the local spread of this lytic virus in the lung is limited by cytokines and/or antibody.

Pax1 is expressed during development of the thymus epithelium and is required for normal T-cell maturation

Pax1 is a transcriptional regulatory protein expressed during mouse embryogenesis and has been shown to have an important function in vertebral column development. Expression of Pax1 mRNA in the embryonic thymus has been reported previously. Here we show that Pax1 protein expression in thymic epithelial cells can be detected throughout thymic development and in the adult. Expression starts in the early endodermal epithelium lining the foregut region and includes the epithelium of the third pharyngeal pouch, a structure giving rise to part of the thymus epithelium. In early stages of thymus development a large proportion of thymus cells expresses Pax1. With increasing age, the proportion of Pax1-expressing cells is reduced and in the adult mouse only a small fraction of cortical thymic stromal cells retains strong Pax1 expression. Expression of Pax1 in thymus epithelium is necessary for establishing the thymus microenvironment required for normal T cell maturation. Mutations in the Pax-1 gene in undulated mice affect not only the total size of the thymus but also the maturation of thymocytes. The number of thymocytes is reduced about 2- to 5-fold, affecting mainly the CD4+8+ immature and CD4+ mature thymocyte subsets. The expression levels of major thymocyte surface markers remains unchanged with the exception of Thy-1 which was found to be expressed at 3- to 4-fold higher levels.

Evidence for a single-niche model of positive selection

Thymocyte maturation depends on interactions with thymic stromal elements expressing major histocompatibility complex (MHC) molecules. Mutant mouse strains lacking MHC class I (beta 2-microglobulin-null) or class II (A beta-null) expression fail to generate normal CD8 or CD4 T-cell populations and provide model systems for reconstitution experiments. We have constructed in vitro chimeras between normal and MHC-deficient thymi to evaluate the efficiency of positive selection. Unexpectedly, the generation of mature single-positive thymocytes was proportional to the fraction of wild-type (i.e., MHC-expressing) stroma over a wide range of chimerism. Similar results were obtained for the development of T-cell receptor-transgenic thymocytes in graded chimeras expressing selecting and nonselecting MHC alleles. These findings are best explained by hypothesizing that positive selection involves a rate-limiting step at which each thymocyte can interact with only one stromal cell niche.

Murine AIDS is an antigen-driven disease: requirements for major histocompatibility complex class II expression and CD4+ T cells

Murine AIDS (MAIDS) is a complex syndrome of lymphoproliferation and immunodeficiency induced by a replication-defective murine leukemia virus (BM5def) that encodes Pr60gag as its only product. It has been suggested that the gag polyprotein is responsible for vigorous antigenic stimulation of CD4+ T cells and generalized secondary activation of the immune system. This model was tested first by infecting mice (C2K/O) that lack class II major histocompatibility complex molecules required for presentation of antigens to CD4+ T cells. C2K/O mice expressed BM5def at high levels but did not develop MAIDS either when unmanipulated or following transfer of CD4+ T cells. Second, B6 mice reconstituted with C2K/O bone marrow cells had normal frequencies of B cells (class II negative) and CD4+ cells and expressed high levels of BM5def transcripts but did not develop MAIDS; however, MAIDS developed in class II-competent nu/nu mice reconstituted with CD4+ T cells and in C2K/O mice reconstituted with B6 bone marrow to give class II-positive B cells and with purified CD4+ T cells. These results indicate that induction of MAIDS by BM5def is antigen driven and is dependent on expression of major histocompatibility complex class II molecules on antigen-presenting cells and the presence of CD4+ T cells.

Thymic epithelial cells provide unique signals for positive selection of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes in vitro

Using a novel system that supports positive selection in vitro, we have investigated the cellular requirements for this process by testing the ability of individual thymic and nonthymic stromal cell types to support the maturation of CD4+CD8+ thymocytes into CD4+ or CD8+ T cells. We show that thymic cortical epithelial cells are unique in their ability to mediate this maturation, and suggest that in addition to TCR ligation, these cells supply specific signals for positive selection. Moreover, by demonstrating positive selection on ECDI (1-ethyl-3-[3'dimethyl-aminopropyl]-carbodiimide)-fixed epithelial cells in this system, we provide direct evidence that the provision of these signals involves interactions with epithelial cell surface molecules rather than the release of soluble factors.

Toxicity of staphylococcal enterotoxins potentiated by lipopolysaccharide: major histocompatibility complex class II molecule dependency and cytokine release

The biological effects of staphylococcal enterotoxins (SE), potentiated by bacterial lipopolysaccharide (LPS), were studied with mice. Control animals survived the maximum dose of either SE or LPS, while mice receiving both agents died. SEA was 43-fold more potent than SEB and 20-fold more potent than SEC1. The mechanism of toxicity was further examined with transgenic mice deficient in major histocompatibility complex class I or II expression. Class II-deficient mice were resistant to SEA or SEB. However, class I-deficient animals were less susceptible to SEA (30% lethality) than wild-type mice (93% lethality). In vitro stimulation of T cells from the three mouse phenotypes by SEA correlated well with toxicity. T cells from transgenic or wild-type mice were similarly responsive to SEA when presented by irradiated, wild-type mononuclear cells. These data confirmed that the toxicity of SE was mainly exerted through a mechanism dependent on the expression of major histocompatibility complex class II molecules. Toxicity was also linked to stimulated cytokine release. Levels in serum of tumor necrosis factor alpha, interleukin-6, and gamma interferon peaked 2 to 4 h after the potentiating dose of LPS but returned to normal within 10 h. Concentrations of interleukin-1 alpha were also maximal after 2 h but remained above the background for up to 22 h. Relative to the levels in mice given only SEA or LPS, the levels in serum of tumor necrosis factor alpha, interleukin-6, and gamma interferon increased 5-, 10-, and 15-fold, respectively, after injections of SEA plus LPS. There was only an additive effect of SEA and LPS on interleukin-1 alpha concentrations.

Fibroblasts can induce thymocyte positive selection in vivo

During development in the thymus, thymocytes bearing alpha beta T-cell receptors are selected to mature if the receptors they bear are able to interact in some way with major histocompatibility complex (MHC) proteins expressed on thymic stromal cells. It has been shown that thymus cortical epithelial cells are usually the cells presenting the MHC molecules involved in this process of so-called positive selection. Here we tested the ability of fibroblasts to mediate positive selection in vivo. Fibroblasts transfected with the genes for the MHC I-Ab proteins were injected intrathymically into irradiated H-2k animals reconstituted with H-2bxk F1 fetal liver cells. Eight weeks later, the recipient mice were immunized and shown to contain peptide-specific I-Ab-restricted T cells. This demonstrates the ability of I-Ab-transfected fibroblasts to participate in positive selection. Thus a cell type that is not specialized to process and present antigens in the context of MHC class II molecules can mediate positive selection when transfected with an appropriate MHC molecule. The data also support the idea that the ability to mediate positive selection may not be limited to thymic cortical epithelium.

The effect of bone marrow and thymus chimerism between non-obese diabetic (NOD) and NOD-E transgenic mice, on the expression and prevention of diabetes

The non-obese diabetic (NOD) mouse is an established animal model of the autoimmune disease, insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). The NOD-E mouse is a transgenic mouse which expresses the I-E molecule (absent in NOD mice). Expression of I-E protects these mice from both insulitis and IDDM. We have investigated the possible mechanisms of this protection by constructing bone marrow, and combined bone marrow and thymus chimeras between NOD and NOD-E mice. Our data suggest that thymic epithelium may play no direct role in either protection against, or promotion of, IDDM. Protection from diabetes is provided either by NOD-E donor bone marrow or NOD-E recipient non-thymic radioresistant cells. The means by which protection may be achieved in this system are discussed.

MHC class I-deficient mice

A great deal has already been learned from the analysis of beta 2m-mutant mice, but it is clear that a great deal remains to be learned. A significant (though unanticipated) problem with this model system is that it is functionally leaky: residual functional class I expression can be detected in beta 2m- mice, and small numbers of functional CD8+ lymphocytes are present in the animals. In many cases, this has frustrated the initial attempts at obtaining immediate definitive resolution of important questions regarding the function of class I molecules. This has occurred primarily in instances in which the class I-deficient mice fail to express an expected phenotype--for example, in studies showing that beta 2m- mice make adequate protective immune responses against certain intracellular pathogens, and are able to reject some allogeneic tissues with a relatively normal pace. On the other hand, it appears that combining the use of beta 2m- mice with other methods (for example, antibody-mediated depletion of CD8+ T cells) is usually adequate to circumvent these difficulties. It remains to be seen whether other better class I deficiencies can be engineered--for example, large deletions of class I genes or mutations in transcription factors essential for class I gene expression. The extent of immunocompetence of beta 2m- mice was somewhat surprising. It was widely expected that class I-deficient mice would be exquisitely sensitive to many viral infections, though the results indicate that sensitivity varies dramatically with the virus and conditions of infection. However, it appears that in lieu of one major arm of the immune system, compensatory immune mechanisms are in many cases able to deal with infection. Similar conclusions are developing from the analysis of several other recently generated mutant mice. Nevertheless, the results indicate a very important role for class I-directed responses in clearing infections mediated by various viral and parasitic agents, particularly in the case of more severe conditions of infection. Although the class I-deficient mice were initially considered primarily a vehicle for analysis of the role of CD8+ T cells, evidence is accumulating that they manifest deficiencies in several other types of lymphocytes, including NK cells, TCR alpha beta+CD4-CD8- cells, and a subset of TCR gamma delta+ cells. This has been a boon for analysis of the development of these cells, but at the same time it has created difficulties in assigning a biological effect of the mutation to a specific lymphocyte deficiency.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)