Purkinje cell death: differences between developmental cell death and neurodegenerative death in mutant mice

Glial cells promote dendrite formation and the reception of synaptic input in Purkinje cells from postnatal mice

Previous studies suggest that glial cells contribute to synaptogenesis in specific neurons from the postnatal CNS. Here, we studied whether this is true for Purkinje cells (PCs), which represent a unique neuronal cell type due to their large size, massive synaptic input, and high vulnerability. Using new glia-free cultures enriched in PCs from postnatal mice we show that these neurons survived and grew, but displayed only low levels of excitatory and inhibitory synaptic activity. Coculture with glial cells strongly enhanced the frequency and size of spontaneous and miniature excitatory synaptic currents as well as neurite growth and branching. Immunocytochemical staining for microtubule-associated protein 2- (MAP2-) positive neurites revealed impaired dendrite formation in PCs under glia-free conditions, which can explain the absence of synaptic activity. Glial signals strongly enhanced dendritogenesis in PCs and thus their ability to receive excitatory synaptic input from granule cells (GCs). The enhancement of dendrite formation was mimicked by glia-conditioned medium (GCM), whereas the increase in synaptic activity required physical presence of glia. This indicated that dendrite development is necessary but not sufficient for PCs to receive excitatory synaptic input and that synaptogenesis requires additional signals. The level of inhibitory synaptic activity was low even in cocultures due to a low incidence of inhibitory interneurons. Taken together, our results reinforce the idea that glial cells promote synaptogenesis in specific neuronal cell types.

Behavioral characteristics, associative learning capabilities, and dynamic association mapping in an animal model of cerebellar degeneration

Young adult heterozygous Lurcher mice constitute an excellent model for studying the role of the cerebellar cortex in motor performance-including the acquisition of new motor abilities-because of the early postnatal degeneration of almost all of their Purkinje and granular cells. Wild-type and Lurcher mice were classically conditioned for eyelid responses using a delay paradigm with or without an electrolytic lesion in the interpositus nucleus. Although the late component of electrically evoked blink reflexes was smaller in amplitude and had a longer latency in Lurcher mice than that in controls, the two groups of animals presented similar acquisition curves for eyeblink conditioning. The lesion of the interpositus nucleus affected both groups of animals equally for the generation of reflex and conditioned eyelid responses. Furthermore, we recorded the multiunitary activity at the red and interpositus nuclei during the same type of associative learning. In both nuclei, the neural firing activity lagged the beginning of the conditioned response (determined by orbicularis oculi muscle response). Although red nucleus neurons and muscle activities presented a clear functional coupling (strong correlation and low asymmetry) across conditioning, the coupling between interpositus neurons and either red nucleus neurons or muscle activities was slightly significant (weak correlation and high asymmetry). Lurcher mice presented a nonlinear coupling (high asymmetry) between red nucleus neurons and muscle activities, with an evident compensatory adjustment in the correlation of firing between interpositus and red nuclei neurons (a coupling with low asymmetry), aimed probably at compensating the absence of cerebellar cortical neurons.

Reevaluation of neurodegeneration in lurcher mice: constitutive ion fluxes cause cell death with, not by, autophagy

The lurcher (Lc) mice have served as a valuable model for neurodegeneration for decades. Although the responsible mutation was identified in genes encoding delta2 glutamate receptors (GluD2s), which are predominantly expressed in cerebellar Purkinje cells, how the mutant receptor (GluD2(Lc)) triggers cell death has remained elusive. Here, taking advantage of recent knowledge about the domain structure of GluD2, we reinvestigated Lc-mediated cell death, focusing on the "autophagic cell death" hypothesis. Although autophagy and cell death were induced by the expression of GluD2(Lc) in heterologous cells and cultured neurons, they were blocked by the introduction of mutations in the channel pore domain of GluD2(Lc) or by removal of extracellular Na(+). In addition, although GluD2(Lc) is reported to directly activate autophagy, mutant channels that are not associated with n-PIST (neuronal isoform of protein-interacting specifically with TC10)-Beclin1 still caused autophagy and cell death. Furthermore, cells expressing GluD2(Lc) showed decreased ATP levels and increased AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) activities in a manner dependent on extracellular Na(+). Thus, constitutive currents were likely necessary and sufficient to induce autophagy via AMPK activation, regardless of the n-PIST-Beclin1 pathway in vitro. Interestingly, the expression of dominant-negative AMPK suppressed GluD2(Lc)-induced autophagy but did not prevent cell death in heterologous cells. Similarly, the disruption of Atg5, a gene crucial for autophagy, did not prevent but rather aggravated Purkinje-cell death in Lc mice. Furthermore, calpains were specifically activated in Lc Purkinje cells. Together, these results suggest that Lc-mediated cell death was not caused by autophagy but necrosis with autophagic features both in vivo and in vitro.

Deletion of the Chd6 exon 12 affects motor coordination

Members of the CHD protein family play key roles in gene regulation through ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling. This is facilitated by chromodomains that bind histone tails, and by the SWI2/SNF2-like ATPase/helicase domain that remodels chromatin by moving histones. Chd6 is ubiquitously expressed in both mouse and human, with the highest levels of expression in the brain. The Chd6 gene contains 37 exons, of which exons 12-19 encode the highly conserved ATPase domain. To determine the biological role of Chd6, we generated mouse lines with a deletion of exon 12. Chd6 without exon 12 is expressed at normal levels in mice, and Chd6 Exon 12 −/− mice are viable, fertile, and exhibit no obvious morphological or pathological phenotype. Chd6 Exon 12 −/− mice lack coordination as revealed by sensorimotor analysis. Further behavioral testing revealed that the coordination impairment was not due to muscle weakness or bradykinesia. Histological analysis of brain morphology revealed no differences between Chd6 Exon 12 −/− mice and wild-type (WT) controls. The location of CHD6 on human chromosome 20q12 is overlapped by the linkage map regions of several human ataxias, including autosomal recessive infantile cerebellar ataxia (SCAR6), a nonprogressive cerebrospinal ataxia. The genomic location, expression pattern, and ataxic phenotype of Chd6 Exon 12 −/− mice indicate that mutations within CHD6 may be responsible for one of these ataxias.

Progressive Purkinje cell degeneration in tambaleante mutant mice is a consequence of a missense mutation in HERC1 E3 ubiquitin ligase

The HERC gene family encodes proteins with two characteristic domains: HECT and RCC1-like. Proteins with HECT domains have been described to function as ubiquitin ligases, and those that contain RCC1-like domains have been reported to function as GTPases regulators. These two activities are essential in a number of important cellular processes such as cell cycle, cell signaling, and membrane trafficking. Mutations affecting these domains have been found associated with retinitis pigmentosa, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, and cancer. In humans, six HERC genes have been reported which encode two subgroups of HERC proteins: large (HERC1-2) and small (HERC3-6). The giant HERC1 protein was the first to be identified. It has been involved in membrane trafficking and cell proliferation/growth through its interactions with clathrin, M2-pyruvate kinase, and TSC2 proteins. Mutations affecting other members of the HERC family have been found to be associated with sterility and growth retardation. Here, we report the characterization of a recessive mutation named tambaleante, which causes progressive Purkinje cell degeneration leading to severe ataxia with reduced growth and lifespan in homozygous mice aged over two months. We mapped this mutation in mouse chromosome 9 and then performed positional cloning. We found a G⇔A transition at position 1448, causing a Gly to Glu substitution (Gly483Glu) in the highly conserved N-terminal RCC1-like domain of the HERC1 protein. Successful transgenic rescue, with either a mouse BAC containing the normal copy of Herc1 or with the human HERC1 cDNA, validated our findings. Histological and biochemical studies revealed extensive autophagy associated with an increase of the mutant protein level and a decrease of mTOR activity. Our observations concerning this first mutation in the Herc1 gene contribute to the functional annotation of the encoded E3 ubiquitin ligase and underline the crucial and unexpected role of this protein in Purkinje cell physiology.

The cerebellum is a coordination center whose function is to fine-tune vertebrates' gait and balance; and for this reason, alterations or damage affecting this structure result in a complex syndrome, called ataxia, with neurological signs that are easily recognized. In the mouse, many mutations producing ataxia have been identified and characterized. They have contributed to a better understanding of the genetics of cerebellum development, physiology, and pathology. The present study identifies the recessive allele responsible for the progressive and massive degeneration of the Purkinje cells observed in mutant mice previously named tambaleante. The mutation leads to a single amino acid substitution in a highly conserved domain (RCC1-like) of the giant protein HERC1. This protein belongs to the families HECT (E3 ubiquitin ligases) and RCC1 (GTPases regulators). While a variety of mutations have been reported in several members of these families, leading to sterility, growth retardation, retinitis pigmentosa, amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, or cancer, no mutation had ever been reported so far in the mouse Herc1 gene. This report demonstrates the crucial and unexpected role of HERC1 in Purkinje cell physiology that could be considered helpful in the development of new therapeutic strategies for neurodegenerative disorders.

The ataxic Syrian hamster: an animal model homologous to the pcd mutant mouse?

A spontaneous model of cerebellar ataxia in the Syrian hamster is described. Breeding data indicate that the condition is hereditary and that the mode of inheritance is autosomal recessive. Homozygotes are smaller in size than the wild-type but have a normal appearance. Mutants show a moderate ataxia beginning at 7 weeks of age. Although affected adults exhibit significant atrophy in the cerebellum, other parts of the brain appear relatively normal by light microscopy. Mutants lose almost all Purkinje cells by 18 months of age and exhibit a moderate reduction in granule cell density, probably as a consequence of the primary loss of Purkinje cells. In the homozygous hamster brain, Nna1 expression is suppressed, similar to that previously observed in Purkinje cell degeneration (pcd) mutant mice. A phenotypic comparison of ataxic hamsters with the pcd mutant mice suggests that the influence of the causal allele in ataxic hamsters is considerably milder than most of the alleles found in the mutant mice.

Close homologue of adhesion molecule L1 promotes survival of Purkinje and granule cells and granule cell migration during murine cerebellar development

Several L1-related adhesion molecules, expressed in a well-coordinated temporospatial pattern during development, are important for fine tuning of specific cerebellar circuitries. We tested the hypothesis that CHL1, the close homologue of L1, abundantly expressed in the developing and adult cerebellum, is also required for normal cerebellar histogenesis. We found that constitutive ablation of CHL1 in mice caused significant loss (20-23%) of Purkinje and granule cells in the mature 2-month-old cerebellum. The ratio of stellate/basket interneurons to Purkinje cells was abnormally high (+38%) in CHL1-deficient (CHL1-/-) mice compared with wild-type (CHL1+/+) littermates, but the gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA)ergic synaptic inputs to Purkinje cell bodies and dendrites were normal, as were numbers of Golgi interneurons, microglia, astrocytes, and Bergmann glia. Purkinje cell loss occurred before the first postnatal week and was associated with enhanced apoptosis, presumably as a consequence of CHL1 deficiency in afferent axons. In contrast, generation of granule cells, as indicated by in vivo analyses of cell proliferation and death, was unaffected in 1-week-old CHL1-/- mice, but numbers of migrating granule cells in the molecular layer were increased. This increase was likely related to retarded cell migration because CHL1-/- granule cells migrated more slowly than CHL1+/+ cells in vitro, and Bergmann glial processes guiding migration in vivo expressed CHL1 in wild-type mice. Granule cell deficiency in adult CHL1-/- mice appeared to result from decreased precursor cell proliferation after the first postnatal week. Our results indicate that CHL1 promotes Purkinje and granule cell survival and granule cell migration during cerebellar development.

The Vps33a gene regulates behavior and cerebellar Purkinje cell number

A mutation in the Vps33a gene causes Hermansky-Pudlak Syndrome (HPS)-like-symptoms in the buff (bf) mouse mutant. The encoded product, Vps33a, is a member of the Sec1 and Class C multi-protein complex that regulates vesicle trafficking to specialized lysosome-related organelles. As Sec1 signaling pathways have been implicated in pre-synaptic function, we examined brain size, cerebellar cell number and the behavioral phenotype of bf mutants. Standardized behavioral tests (SHIRPA protocols) demonstrated significant motor deficits (e.g., grip strength, righting reflex and touch escape) in bf mutants, worsening with age. Histological examination of brain revealed significant Purkinje cell loss that was confirmed with staining for calbindin, a calcium binding protein enriched in Purkinje cells. This pathologic finding was progressive, as older bf mutants (13-14 months) showed a greater attrition of neurons, with their cerebella appearing to be particularly reduced (approximately 30%) in size relative to those of age-matched-control cohorts. These studies suggest that loss of Purkinje neurons is the most obvious neurological atrophy in the bf mutant, a structural change that generates motor coordination deficits and impaired postural phenotypes. It is conceivable therefore that death of cerebellar cells may also be a clinical feature of HPS patients, a pathological event which has not been reported in the literature. In general, the bf mutant may be a potentially new and useful model for understanding Purkinje cell development and function.

Intrinsic versus extrinsic determinants during the development of Purkinje cell dendrites

The peculiar shape and disposition of Purkinje cell (PC) dendrites, planar and highly branched, offers an optimal model to analyze cellular and molecular regulators for the acquisition of neuronal dendritic trees. During the first 2 weeks after the end of the proliferation period, PCs undergo a 2-phase remodeling process of their dendrites. The first phase consists in the complete retraction of the primitive but extensive dendritic tree, together with the formation of multiple filopodia-like processes arising from the cell body. In the second phase, there is a progressive disappearance of the somatic processes along with rapid growth and branching of the mature dendrite. Mature Purkinje cell dendrites bear two types of spiny protrusions, named spine and thorn. The spines are numerous, elongated, located at the distal dendritic compartment and form synapses with parallel fibers, whereas the thorns are shorter, rounded, emerge from the proximal compartment and synapse with climbing fibers. Different culture models and mutant mice analyses suggest the identification of intrinsic versus extrinsic determinants of the Purkinje cell dendritic development. The early phase of dendritic remodeling might be cell autonomous and regulated by specific transcription factors such as retinoid-related orphan receptor alpha (RORalpha). Afferent fibers, trophic factors and hormones regulate the orientation and growth of the mature dendritic tree contributing, with still unknown intrinsic factors, to sculpt its general architecture. The formation of spines appears as an intrinsic phenomenon independent of their presynaptic partner, the parallel fibers, and confined to the distal compartment by inhibitory influences of the climbing fibers along the proximal compartment.

p73 regulates neurodegeneration and phospho-tau accumulation during aging and Alzheimer's disease

The genetic mechanisms that regulate neurodegeneration are only poorly understood. We show that the loss of one allele of the p53 family member, p73, makes mice susceptible to neurodegeneration as a consequence of aging or Alzheimer's disease (AD). Behavioral analyses demonstrated that old, but not young, p73+/- mice displayed reduced motor and cognitive function, CNS atrophy, and neuronal degeneration. Unexpectedly, brains of aged p73+/- mice demonstrated dramatic accumulations of phospho-tau (P-tau)-positive filaments. Moreover, when crossed to a mouse model of AD expressing a mutant amyloid precursor protein, brains of these mice showed neuronal degeneration and early and robust formation of tangle-like structures containing P-tau. The increase in P-tau was likely mediated by JNK; in p73+/- neurons, the activity of the p73 target JNK was enhanced, and JNK regulated P-tau levels. Thus, p73 is essential for preventing neurodegeneration, and haploinsufficiency for p73 may be a susceptibility factor for AD and other neurodegenerative disorders.

Expression of X-chromosome linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein in mature Purkinje cells and in retinal bipolar cells in transgenic mice induces neurodegeneration

Transgenic mice with overexpression of the caspase-inhibitor, X-chromosome-linked inhibitor of apoptosis protein (XIAP) in Purkinje cell (PC) and in retinal bipolar cells (RBCs) were produced to study the regulation of cell death. Unexpectedly, an increased neurodegeneration was observed in the PCs in these L7-XIAP mice after the third postnatal week with the mice exhibiting severe ataxia. The loss of PCs was independent of Bax as shown by crossing the L7-XIAP mice with Bax gene-deleted mice. Electron microscopy revealed intact organelles in PCs but with the stacking of ER cisterns indicative of cell stress. Immunostaining for cell death proteins showed an increased phosphorylation of c-Jun in the PCs, suggesting an involvement in cell degeneration. Apart from PCs, the number of RBCs was decreased in adult retina in line with the expression pattern for the L7 promoter. The data show that overexpression of the anti-apoptotic protein XIAP in vulnerable neurons leads to enhanced cell death. The mechanisms underlying this neurodegeneration can be related to the effects of XIAP on cell stress and altered cell signaling.

Reinstating the ability of the motor cortex to modulate cutaneomuscular reflexes in hemicerebellectomized rats

The pathways passing through the cerebellum calibrate cutaneomuscular responses. Indeed, the enhancement of cutaneomuscular responses associated with subthreshold high-frequency trains of stimulation applied on motor cortex following a period of peripheral repetitive stimulation (PRS) is prevented by hemicerebellectomy. We analysed the effects of low-frequency repetitive stimulation of motor cortex (LFRSM1) on interhemispheric inhibition (IHI) and on the modulation of cutaneomuscular reflexes in rats with left hemicerebellar ablation. IHI was assessed by paired-pulse method with a conditioning stimulus (CS) to M1 followed by a test stimulus (TS) to the opposite M1. LFRSM1 reduced IHI. Combination of LFRSM1 with PRS increased significantly the magnitudes of cutaneomuscular responses evoked ipsilaterally to the hemicerebellar ablation. The increase of the intensity of cutaneomuscular responses was correlated with the reduction of IHI. Excitability of anterior horn motoneurons pool, assessed by F-wave, remained unchanged. Conjunction of LFRSM1 with PRS can be used to restore the ability of the motor cortex to modulate the intensity of cutaneomuscular responses in case of extensive unilateral cerebellar lesion. This study underlines for the first time the potential role of callosal pathways in the deficits of corticomotor tuning of cutaneomuscular responses contralaterally to acute extensive cerebellar lesion.

Morphological and biochemical signs of age-related neurodegenerative changes in klotho mutant mice

Klotho mutant mice, defective in the klotho gene, develop multiple age-related disorders with very short lifespans. Introduction of the exogenous klotho gene into these mutant mice leads to an improvement in their phenotypes, while overexpression of this gene in wild-type mice significantly extends their lifespan. These observations suggest that the klotho gene/protein has an anti-aging function. Since there have been only a few reports with some disagreement about results on the CNS of the mutant mice, we tried to clarify whether the CNS neurons generate aging-like features, even in premature stages, using biochemical and morphological approaches. Results obtained from the mutant mice, when compared with wild-type mice, were as follows. Neurofilaments (NFs) were increased significantly in axons, with the subunit proteins showing a significant enhancement in phosphorylation or expression of NF-H or NF-L, respectively. Microtubules in Purkinje cell dendrites were closer to each other, and in the CNS tissue tubulin was unaltered, but microtubule-associated protein (MAP) 2 was significantly reduced in expression. Neuronal cellular organelles were morphologically disordered. Lysosomes, cathepsin D and light chain 3 of MAP1A/B (LC3) were augmented with the appearance of putative autophagy-related structures. Antiapoptotic Bcl-xL and proapoptotic Bax were reduced and enhanced, respectively, and mitogen-activated protein kinase was reduced. Synapse-related proteins and structures were decreased. Neuronal degeneration was evident in hippocampal pyramidal cells, and possibly in Purkinje cells. Astrocytic glial filaments and glial fibrillary acidic protein were increased in density and expression, respectively. Together, the CNS neuronal alterations in klotho mutant mice were quite similar to those found in aged animals, including even premature death, so this mouse should be a more appropriate animal model for CNS aging than those previously reported.

Doppel induces degeneration of cerebellar Purkinje cells independently of Bax

Doppel (Dpl) is a prion protein paralog that causes neurodegeneration when expressed ectopically in the brain. To investigate the cellular mechanism underlying this effect, we analyzed Dpl-expressing transgenic mice in which the gene for the proapoptotic protein Bax had been deleted. We found that Bax deletion does not alter either clinical symptoms or Purkinje cell degeneration in Dpl transgenic mice. In addition, we observed that degenerating Purkinje cells in these animals do not display DNA fragmentation or caspase-3 activation. Our results suggest that non-Bax-dependent pathways mediate the toxic effects of Dpl in Purkinje cells, highlighting a possible role for nonapoptotic mechanisms in the death of these neurons.

The strange case of Purkinje axon regeneration and plasticity

In the last few years Purkinje cells have become a most interesting model to investigate cellular/molecular mechanisms of axon regeneration and plasticity. Adult Purkinje cells are most peculiar for their weak cell body response to axotomy, which is accompanied by a strong resistance to injury and a virtually absolute inability to regenerate severed neurites, even in the presence of favourable environmental conditions. The same neurons show a vigorous intrinsic inclination toward axonal sprouting and structural plasticity, which can be elicited by removing extrinsic growth-inhibitory cues. These features gradually develop during early postnatal life, but the underlying mechanisms and biological significance remain unclear. This article reviews recent studies aimed at addressing these questions with respect to the general issue of brain repair. Indeed, understanding the reasons for the extremely poor regenerative capacity of Purkinje cells will be most important to elucidate basic biological mechanisms of axon regeneration and plasticity, and to promote circuit rewiring in the adult CNS.