Selective roles of thymus-derived lymphocytes in the antibody response. I. Differential suppressive effect of carrier-primed T cells on hapten-specific IgM and IgG antibody responses

Evidence for suppressor cells in Lewis rats' experimental allergic encephalomyelitis

In this work we demonstrate a suppressive activity on the induction of experimental allergic encephalomyelitis (EAE) in Lewis rats, transferable to syngeneic animals, challenged with encephalitogenic mixture (myelin basic protein, complete Freud's adjuvant plus Bordetella pertussis organisms) 24 h later. This activity is probably effected by T cells and not by (an) inhibitory serum factor(s). The induction of this specific protection could be due to the penetration of the myelin basic protein antigen into the thymus where we first found suppressive cells. From the thymus, suppressor cells could then emigrate to spleen (on day 15) and to nondraining lymph nodes (on day 17). In the course of normal EAE in Lewis rats and especially at the time of self cure, this suppression is not demonstrated, but possible.

Regulation of anti-hapten antibody response by chemically modified carrier antigen preferentially provoking delayed-type hypersensitivity. I. Possible T-T cell interaction in the suppression of antibody response

The i.p. immunization with chemically modified antigen (dodecanoyl-bovine serum albumin, d-BSA) emulsified in Freund's incomplete adjuvant (FIA) of CBA mice provoked delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH), but not any detectable formation of antibody to the original antigen (BSA). Furthermore, it was found that immunization with d-BSA could generate T cells capable of inhibiting the antibody response to hapten on BSA, and the immunosuppressive effects of these T cells were presumably not due to direct action on hapten-primed and antibody producing B cells. These results were obtained from the following experiments: (1) anti-hapten antibody response to dinitrophenylated-BSA (DNP-BSA) was inhibited when the mice had been primed previously with d-BSA in FIA. This inhibition was regulated by the specificity of the carrier, since the mice treated with d-BSA did not inhibit the anti-DNP antibody response after the immunization with DNP-heterologous carrier, i.e. DNP-keyhole limpet haemocyanin (DNP-KLH). (2) The passive transfer of spleen cells, which had been obtained from donors primed with d-BSA in FIA, inhibited the primary anti-DNP antibody response of syngeneic mice after immunization with DNP BSA. (3) Injection of d-BSA-primed spleen cells suppressed an adoptive anti-DNP antibody response in mice which had been irradiated and had previously had their immunocompetence reconstituted by the cell transfers with both DNP-primed and BSA-primed spleen cells. This in vivo immunosuppressive effect of d-BSA-primed spleen cells did not act on hapten-primed B cells, since d-BSA-primed spleen cells could not suppress the adoptive secondary antibody response reconstituted by DNP-primed cells and bacterial alpha-amylase (BαA)-primed cells. This finding suggests that a T—T cell interaction exists for the suppression of the anti-DNP antibody response to DNP-BSA by d-BSA-primed cells.

A study of the increased serum level of IgG1 in 'lethargic' mice combined with a depressed thymus-dependent lymphoid system

In a series of recent studies on 'lethargic' mice, a neurological mutation of the mouse, significant abnormalities were discovered in the thymus and its dependent regions in the lymph nodes and spleen. The present study was made as an approach toward finding the possible causes for these abnormalities. Serum IgG1 levels were stldied in 'lethargic' mutants at the age when severe deficiency of the thymus-dependent lymphoid system is known to occur in the animal. Using the radial immunodiffusion method, it was found that serum IgG1 levels are always significantly higher in 'lethargic' mice than in their normal littermates. Possible causes of the higher IgG1 in the serum of 'lethargic' mice are discussed. The authors note the similarities of other mouse mutations to that of the 'lethargic' mouse and propose the possibility that a common mechanism may account for immunologic deficiencies in several types of mutant mice.

Regulatory functions of hapten-reactive helper and suppressor T lymphocytes. I. Detection and characterization of hapten-reactive suppressor T-cell activity in mice immunized with hapten-isologous protein conjugate

Helper and suppressor T-cell activities were detected simultaneously in the spleen cells of mice immunized with para-azobenzoate (PAB)-mouse gammaglobulin (MGG). Dinitrophenyl (DNP)-specific B cells were raised by immunization with DNP-keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) and used as the indicator B-cell population. The helper and suppressor T-cell activities were determined after adoptively transferring spleen cells from PAB-MGG- primed donors and DNP-KLH-primed donors into X-irradiated recipients. Stimulation of these recipients with DNP-MGG-PAB detected helper T-cell activity, which was measured in terms of increased anti-DNP antibody responses of DNP-KLH-primed cells over these responses in the presence of unprimed cells. On the other hand, when DNP-KLH-primed cells were stimulated with DNP-KLH-PAB in the presence of PAB-MGG-primed cells, anti-DNP antibody responses were substantially lower than in unprimed normal cells. This suppressor cell population was (a) hapten-reactive, (b) present in B-cell-depleted spleen cells, (c) Thy-1 positive, (d) detectable earlier than the helper T-cell activities after priming (e) more radiosensitive than helper cells, and (f) found in the spleen but not the lymph nodes in contrast to helper T cells. These data indicate that these suppressor T cells are distinct from the helper T cells. PAB-reactive T cells clearly suppressed the antibody response by inhibiting KLH-reactive helper T-cell functions. The hapten-reactive T-lymphocyte system described here should be useful for analyzing and manipulating the immune response and for studying regulatory interactions of helper and suppressor T cells in the induction of antibody responses.

Suppression of IgE antibody production in SJL mice. III. Characterization of a suppressor substance extracted from normal SJL spleen cells

SJL mice were immunized with 1 microng dinitrophenylated keyhole limpet hemocyanin in 1 mg Al(OH)3. The mice were infected 21 days later with 750 third stage larvae of Nippostrongylus brasiliensis. On day 35, 14 days after infection, they were injected with 1 microng DNP-N, brasiliensis extract (Nb) in 1 mg Al(OH)3. In order to obtain high titer and persistent anti-DNP IgE antibody the mice were irradiated (540 R) 1 day after injection of DNP-Nb. Suppression of anti-DNP IgE antibody production was induced by spleen cells from normal SJL mice. Suppression of IgE antibody response is also obtained by an extract from normal SJL spleen cells. The suppressor substance from normal SJL spleen cell extract is a heat-labile protein, and is not absorbed by anti-mouse immunoglobulin. The mol wt of this substance is larger than 300,000 daltons as determined by gel filtration on Sephadex G-200, but after ultracentifugation, the supernate still has suppressive activity on IgE antibody production.

The induction of carrier-specific helper cell tolerance in presensitized rats

Lewis rats rendered tolerant to sheep IgG (SGG) show a markedly reduced antibody response to the 2,4,6-trinitrophenyl (TNP) hapten when later challenged with TNP-SGG. We have previously shown that this effect is due to functional unresponsiveness in the carrier SGG-specific helper T cell population. In this paper we demonstrate that induced helper cell tolerance is also maintained through a secondary immunogenic challenge. Furthermore, rats which are primed to the carrier SGG prior to tolerance induction also show a markedly reduced anti-TNP response upon secondary immunogenic challenge with TNP-SGG. The ability to specifically suppress a secondary response in this manner was found to be relatively long lasting, since rats showed reduced responsiveness when the secondary challenge was delayed for up to 4 weeks after tolerance induction. In addition, rats primed to the hapten (TNP) prior to carrier (SGG) tolerance induction also showed a marked reduction in anti-TNP antibody following challenge with TNP-SGG. These findings imply that helper cell tolerance can be induced in rats even after priming of carrier-specific (SGG) helper cells, or hapten-specific (TNP) B cells. These results parallel our other published findings that IgE responses in presensitized rats can be overcome by helper cell tolerance.

Studies on delayed hypersensitivity in mice. III. Evidence for suppressive regulatory T1-cell population in delayed hypersensitivity

T-T-cell interactions involved in delayed hypersensitivity (DH) response have been studied by employing delayed foot pad assay to methylated human serum albumin in C57BL/6J mice. The DH response, one of the T-cell manifestations of cell-mediated immune response is suppressively regulated by T cells and such observation was based on studies of age-associated kinetics of foot pad reaction and effects of cell transfer and adult thymectomy on developing DH response. These suppressively regulatory T cells in DH have a life span of less than 4 wk and a constant derivation from the thymus is required. Such cells are numerous in the young mouse thymus and few in the spleen and thymus of old mice. On the one hand, the presence of a long-lived effector T-cell population was suggested in DH. These cells are numerous in the spleen and are low responders to phytohemagglutinin in vitro. It is assumed that these suppressive T cells interact with antigen-reactive cells at their proliferating stage by recognition of the iodiotypic difference through surface receptors. As in the case of graft-vs.-host and humoral response in vivo, three different subsets of immune competent cells participate in the DH response. These cells consist of one specifically antigen-reactive T cell, one suppressive regulatory T cell, and one bone marrow-derived cell, a macrophage that responds to a chemical mediator from sensitized effector T cells and that develops a DH skin lesion nonspecifically.

Suppressor T cells in low zone tolerance. I. Mode of action of suppressor cells

Low zone tolerance (LZT) to bacteriophage fd seems to be a type of tolerance which is primarily caused by suppressor T cells. The aim of this paper is to analyze their mode of action. For the induction of antigen-specific suppressor cells in hydrocortisone pretreated CBA mice, we use tolerogenic and immunogenic doses of antigen. Suppressor activity can be demonstrated upon transfer of spleen cells into normal syngeneic mice. After immunization these animals are unable to produce IgG antibody against phage fd, whereas the IgM response is not suppressed; The half-life of transferred suppressor cells in nonimmunized animals is 5--6 weeks. The target of suppression are unprimed T helper cells, whereas primed helper cells cannot be blocked. T helper cells become "resistant" to suppression 18--36 h after contact with antigen. Differentiation from unprimed B into B memory cells is unaffected, yet under suppression conditions persisting B memory cells are blocked in IgG production. The experimental data are incorporated into a model of LZT.

Suppressor function of peripheral blood mononuclear cells in normal individuals and in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus

Normal peripheral blood mononuclear cells demonstrated increased DNA synthesis and secretion of newly synthesized protein when suboptimal concentrations of Concanavalin A (Con A) were added to the cultures after 24-h incubation in vitro. Cells stimulated by Con A, 1 mug/ml, after 24-h incubation demonstrated 3.0 times more tritiated thymidine incorporation, and 4.4 times more 14C-amino acid incorporation into newly synthesized secreted protein, than cells stimulated at 0 h (P less than 0.001). The acquisition of increased responsiveness was not abrogated by washing and resuspending the cells in fresh medium. Since the increased responsiveness could be inhibited by the addition to the cultures of small numbers of cells previously activated by Con A it is suggested that the enhanced reactivity acquired in culture represents the loss of a subpopulation of suppressor cells that modulate the T-lymphocyte response. Cells from nine patients with active, untreated systemic lupus erythematosus demonstrated normal responses to optimal concentrations of Con A added at 0 h, but an impaired response to Con A, 1 mug/ml. When these cells were incubated for 24 h, a significant increased response to Con A was not observed. This observation suggests that patients with active SLE lack circulating suppressor cells. When seven SLE patients were again studied after corticosteroid therapy had led to clinical improvement, the response to Con A, 1 mug/ml, added after 24-h incubation was similar to that observed in normal controls, suggesting that suppressor function in SLE returns as disease activity declines.

Genetic regulation of the antibody response to H-2Db alloantigens in mice. III. Inhibition of the IgG Response to noncongenic cells by preimmunization with congenic cells

When B10.A (5R) mice (H-12i5) are immunized with spleen cells from congenic B10 mice (H-12b), they respond to alloantigens of the H-2Db region by producing antibodies of only IgM type. In contrast, they produce both IgM and IgG antibodies when immunized with A.BY cells (H-2b) that carry other foreign cell surface antigens (non-H-2) in addition to H-2Db. Preimmunization of 5R mice with two injections of congenic cells leads to an H-2Db specific inhibition of the IgG response to a subsequent immunization with A.BY cells. It is concluded that congenic B10 cells fail to activate helper T cells which are necessary to induce the switch from IgM to IgG production. Instead T- or B-cell tolerance may be induced with prohibits the subsequent IgG response to A.BY cells, possibly by way of suppressor T cells which may act either on B cells directly or via helper T cells.

Heterogeneity of murine regulatory T cells. I. Subpopulations of amplifier and suppressor T cells

Immunization of C3H/HeJ mice with 4 X 10(9) SRBC yields a whole splenic T-cell population which can, upon transfer, specifically suppress recipient direct and indirect plaque-forming cells (PFC) responses to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC). Discontinuous bovine serum albumin density gradient fractionation of these T cells demonstrated a population of low density T cells which augmented and a population of high density T cells which suppressed recipient responses irrespective of the number of T cells transferred. Moreover, infusion of admixtures of low and high density cells resulted in intermediate regulatory functions which could be predicted by knowing the regulatory capacity of each population alone. In addition to heterogeneity existing among regulatory T cells as regards amplification and suppression, it appeared that heterogeneity existed within the suppressor T population. Thus, T cells capable of inhibiting direct PFC could be distinguished from those suppressing indirect PFC by their differential localization in peripheral lymphoid tissue, differences in the dissipation of suppressive influences during incubation at 37 degrees C, and by differences in the possible requirement for adherent cell populations. While the relative frequency of both low density amplifier and high density suppressor cells increased with the dose of SRBC used for their induction, it appeared that suppressor cells might be generated in response to feedback signals from amplifier cells. These studies indicate that further delineation of heterogeneity existing within suppressor populations may be helpful in defining mechanisms required for the induction and manifestation of suppressive regulatory forces.

Persisting T cells in rats tolerant of human serum albumin. The significance of tolerant and nonimmune T cells which preferentially restrict high affinity antibody synthesis

The adoptive response of primed rat thoracic duct lymphocytes ('TDL) following specific antigen challenge (soluble human serum albumin, s-HSA) was restricted when cells were transferred into syngeneic, adult (AS2 X AS)F1 hybrid recipients in comparison with irradiated hosts. This adoptive memory response was also inhibited in irradiated recipients by transferring nonimmune TDL along with 'TDL. Recirculating B cells (B-TDL) did not inhibit the 'TDL response, indicating that the adoptive secondary response was regulated by T cells. Antibody synthesis was preferentially restricted in the high affinity memory cell precursor population, demonstrating a role for T cells in regulating the maturation of antibody affinity. The adoptive memory response was liberated from this T regulatory effect in adult recipients when hosts were challenged with the alum-precipitated adjuvant form (HSA-adj) rather than the soluble form of HSA. Since the adoptive memory response was sensitive to the presence or absence of T cells, this experimental model was used to determine whether or not T cells were eliminated from HSA-tolerant rats. Antibody synthesis by 'TDL was reduced approximately 10-fold compared with controls when transferred into tolerant recipients and challenged with either s-HSA or HSA-adj; a similar reduction was not observed by substituting bovine serum albumin (BSA) 'TDL and challenging with s-BSA. The tolerance-induced inhibition of HSA 'TDL was destroyed by irradiation and TDL from HSA-tolerant donors were more effective than normal nonimmune TDL in reducing the adoptive HSA 'TDL response. HSA-tolerant TDL did not inhibit the BSA 'TDL response significantly. The results indicate that T cells are not eliminated by tolerance induction in this model and after interaction with tolerogen may exert an active (or competitive) role in restricting antibody synthesis by high affinity B memory cell precursors. However, the fact that tolerant T cells are not able to prevent a primary response suggests that unresponsiveness to HSA in the T compartment represents a functional deficiency and not an active suppression at this level. Nevertheless, the presence of these tolerant cells probably accounts for the failure of antibody affinity to mature in partially tolerant rats.

In vitro tolerance induction of neonatal murine B cells

The susceptibility of neonatal and adult B lymphocytes to tolerance induction was analyzed by a modification of the in vitro splenic focus technique. This technique permits stimulation of individual hapten-specific clonal precursor cells from both neonatal and adult donors. Neonatal or adult BALB/c spleen cells were adoptively transferred into irradiated, syngeneic, adult recipients which had been carrier-primed to hemocyanin (Hy), thus maximizing stimulation to the hapten 2,4-dinitrophenyl coupled by Hy (DNP-Hy). Cultures were initially treated with DNP on several heterologous (non-Hy) carriers and subsequently stimulated with DNP-Hy. Whereas the responsiveness of adult B cells was not diminished by pretreatment with any DNP conjugate, the majority of the neonatal B-cell response was abolished by in vitro culture with all of the DNP-protein conjugates. During the 1st wk of life, the ability to tolerize neonatal splenic B cells progressively decreased. Thus, tolerance in this system is: (a) restricted to B cells early in development; (b) established by both tolerogens and immunogens; (c) achieved at low (10(-9) M determinant) antigen concentrations; and (d) highly specific, discriminating between DNP- and TNP-specific B cells. We conclude that: (a) B lymphocytes, during their development, mature through a stage in which they are extremely susceptible to tolerogenesis; (b) the specific interaction of B-cell antigen receptors with multivalent antigens, while irrelevant to mature B cells, is tolerogenic to neonatal (immature) B cells unless antigen is concomitantly recognized by primed T cells; and (c) differences in the susceptibility of immature and mature B lymphocytes to tolerance induction suggest intrinsic differences between neonatal and adult B cells and may provide a physiologically relevant model for the study of tolerance to self-antigens.

Separation of helper and suppressor T lymphocytes on a ficoll velocity sedimentation gradient

A 5-20% Ficoll velocity sedimentation gradient has been successfully applied to separate concanavalin A (Con A)-induced helper; and suppressor T cells. When titrated into a constant number of fresh normal spleen cells responding to sheep erythrocytes, cells from the top pool show stimulatory effects while those from the bottom pool show inhibitory activity. Both activities are found to be Con A dependent and anti-theta sensitive. We conclude that Con A-induced helper and suppressor T cells are distinct subpopulations and such separation will allow further characterization of these cell types.

Liver disease--a prominent cause of serum IgE elevation

Serum IgE concentrations were elevated in thirty-seven out of sixty-seven patients (55%) with acute or chronic liver disease of widely differing aetiology. The mean IgE concentrations in these patients showed an eight-fold increase above that observed in control subjects. Increased IgE levels in patients with liver disease occurred in the absence of eosinophilia, clinical evidence of atopy or other known causes of IgE elevation. No IgE-containing plasma cells were detected in the liver biopsies from thirty-two of the sixty-seven patients tested. Peripheral blood T cells were significantly decreased from normal in the patients with liver disease, but no correlation emerged between serum IgE levels and absolute peripheral blood T-cell numbers. These findings emphasize the importance of liver disease as a significant cause of serum IgE elevation.

Hapten and carrier specificities of cellular and humoral responses to highly substituted dinitrophenyl-human gamma-globulins in guinea-pigs

Delayed hypersensitivity (DH) and antibody reactions to the carrier and to the hapten have been studied in guinea-pigs immunized with different doses of highly substituted dinitrophenyl-human gamma-globulins (DNP56-HGG) in Freund's complete adjuvant (FCA). The results confirm that DH reactions are specific for the carrier while antibody-mediated reactions are specific for the hapten in the early stages of the immune response. Later in the response, however, DH reactions to the hapten as well as a transient humoral reaction to the carrier could be observed. T cells specific for the hapten and B cells specific for the carrier are therefore triggered after a single infection of a highly substituted hapten-carrier conjugate in FCA. Their regulatory functions in the immune response to hapten-carrier conjugates are discussed.

Properties of antigen-specific suppressive T-cell factor in the regulation of antibody response of the mouse. I. In vivo activity and immunochemical characterization

An antigen-specific suppressive T-cell factor was extracted from physically disrupted thymocytes and spleen cells of mice that had been immunized with soluble protein antigens. The factor, when inoculated into syngeneic normal mice, could induce a significant suppression of IgG antibody response against a hapten coupled to the carrier protein by which the donor of the suppressor factor was immunized. The suppressor factor was found only effective in suppressing the antibody response of syngeneic or H-2 histocompatible recipients. The suppressive T-cell factor was removed by absorption with immunoadsorbent composed of the relevant antigen, but not with any of those of anti-immunoglobulin antibodies. The factor was successfully removed by alloantibodies with specificity for the K end (H-2K, I-A and I-B) of the H-2 complex of the donor strain, but not by those for the D end (I-C, SsSlp, and H-2D). The activity was removed by absorption with a heterologous antithymocyte serum. The mol wt of the suppression T-cell factor was between 35,000 and 60,000 as determined by Sephadex G-200 gel filtration. The suppressive T-cell factor was found to be a heat-liable protein.

The Fc receptor on thymus-derived lymphocytes. I. Detection of a subpopulation of murine T lymphocytes bearing the Fc receptor

Utilizing the fluorescence-activated cell sorter (FACS) and washed murine antibody-antigen complexes formed in antibody excess, we have demonstrated the presence of the Fc receptor on the surface of a distinct subpopulation of murine T lymphocytes. No differences in intensity of labeling with the complexes was observed when the Fc+ T lymphocytes were compared with Fc+ B lymphocytes. The majority of Fc+ T lymphocytes are small lymphocytes determined by light-scattering characteristics on the FACS. Separating Fc+ from Fc- T lymphocytes from spleens of mice primed 1 wk or 1 mo previously with keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) revealed that the T cells capable of cooperating with DNP-KLH primed B cells to give an adoptive anti-DNP PFC response do not bear the Fc receptor.

A disquisition on suppressor T cells

The main points that I have put forth are that: (1) suppressor T cell activity cannot be explained as simply being too much help; (2) feedback signals from target cells are of crucial importance in determining and maintaining the activity of suppressor T cells; (3) whenever T cells are triggered by antigen, suppression occurs. Immune responses only occur when countermanding signals are also generated. Both intrinsic and extrinsic adjuvanticity is the operational production of countermanding signals; (4) memory T cells are qualitatively different from normal T cells in their sensitivity to feedback signals and also in their susceptibility to suppression; (5) mature thymus dependent B cells cannot be rendered tolerant by the direct action of antigen, while immature and thymus independent B cells can; (6) the mechanism of suppression induced by exogenously administered antigens and that by normal differentiation products (i.e.: GVH; allotypes), is different; (7) generation of suppressor cells requires or results from complex interactions between subpopulations of cells, making it impossible under present conditions to determine which cell is doing what and to which; (8) further work is required before a full understanding of the importance, mechanism of action and other aspects of suppressor T cell function can be fully understood.

Feedback induction of suppressor T-cell activity

Adoptively transferred carrier immune T cells interact with nonimmune T cells in recipients in a fashion which generates specific immunosuppression although both the immune and normal cells function quite well as helper cells when not admixed.

Idiotype suppression. II. Amplification of a suppressor T cell with anti-idiotypic activity

Guinea pig IgG2 anti-idiotypic antibody (aId2) against the strain A/J antibody A5A has a suppressive effect on the expression of the A5A idiotype in adult A/J mice immunized with Group A streptococci. High doses of aId2 cause an immediate but transient suppression, whereas low doses of aId2 result in a delayed but chronic suppression which lasted for more than 1 year without any indication of recovery. Chronic suppression is transferred by as few as 10(5) spleen cells, but an interval of 6 weeks after transfer is required for completion of suppression. The suppressive capacity of aId2-induced suppressor cells was virtually inexhaustable in 4 consecutive transfers spaced at 3 month intervals. The suppressor cell is a T cell which adheres to histamine-rabbit serum albumin-Sepharose 2B columns.

Clonal dominance. I. Restricted nature of the IgM antibody response to group A streptococcal carbohydrate in mice

The IgM antibody response of mice to the streptococcal group A carbohydrate (GAC) was measured. With most strains tested, large amounts of IgM antibody were produced; in AKR mice, over 1% of the total nucleated spleen cells secreted IgM anti-GAC antibody after hyperimmunization. The relative avidity of the antibody was extimated by a modification of the Jerne plaque assay where spleen cells from individual mice were tested against erythrocytes with varying GAC epitope densitymthese studies showed that the earliest, as well as latest, IgM antibodies produced were highly restricted in avidity heterogeneity. No evidence of affinity maturation was seen upon hyperimmunization. These data favor the conclusion that the restricted IgG response seen in mice hyperimmunized to GAC is not the result of affinity driven competition for antigen among precursor cells.

Genetic control of immune response. The dose of antigen given in aqueous solution is critical in determining which mouse strain is high responder to poly(LTyr, LGlu)-poly(LPro)--poly(LLys)

Antibody response to different doses of (T,G)-Pro--L, given in aqueous solution, was investigated in the high responder SJL and low responder DBA/1 strains by measuring hemolytic plaque-forming cells (PFC) in the spleens as well as hemagglutination titers in the sera. The gene responsible for the difference between the two strains in the response to this antigen, given in complete Freund's adjuvant, has been previously denoted Ir-3. This gene is not linked to the major histocompatibility locus. In the response to the optimal dose (1 mug) of antigen, no difference could be shown between the strains. The peak of the response and the numbers of direct and indirect PFC were similar in both strains in the primary and secondary response. After injection of higher doses (10-100 mug) of antigen, both the direct and indirect PFC responses were lower in the low responder than in the high responder strain. Moreover, the peak of the response occurred earlier in the high responder strain in the primary response to the 10 mu dose of antigen. After administration of a suboptimal dose (0.02 mug) of antigen, the low responder strain produced in the primary response 4-20 times more indirect plaques than the high responder strain. Also the number of direct plaques was higher in the low responder than in the high responder strain. The serum antibody responses to the optimal and higher doses of antigen were parallel to the PFC responses. From inhibition of PFC with free antigen, it was concluded that a similar proportion of cells was producing high and low affinity antibodies to (T,G)-Pro--L in both strains. High and low zone tolerance could be induced in the two strains with (T,G)-Pro--L, but no difference could be shown between the strains. It is suggested that the Ir-3 gene plays a role in the regulation of the balance stimulation and suppression according to the dose of antigen given.

Evidence for specific suppression in the maintenance of immunologic tolerance

Specific suppressor cells have been demonstrated in mice tolerant to the thymus-dependent antigen HGG. Transfer of normal thymocytes, normal spleen cells, or immune spleen cells into these tolerant mice did not restore immunocompetence to HGG. Furthermore, the transfer of tolerant spleen cells into normal recipients abrogated the response of these recipients to subsequent challenge with immunogenic HGG. Spleen cells removed from mice 5, 8, or 11 wk after the induction of tolerance specifically suppressed the response of normal spleen cells in an adoptive cell transfer system. The extent of suppression appears to be dependent upon how long after the induction of tolerance the cells were removed from the tolerant donors and how soon after transfer the recipients were challenged.

Genetic control of immune responses in vitro. V. Stimulation of suppressor T cells in nonresponder mice by the terpolymer L-glutamic acid 60-L-alanine 30-L-tyrosine 10 (GAT)

In recent studies we have found that GAT not only fails to elicit a GAT-specific response in nonresponder mice but also specifically decreases the ability of nonresponder mice to develop a GAT-specific PFC response to a subsequent challenge with GAT bound to the immunogenic carrier, MBSA. Studies presented in this paper demonstrate that B cells from nonresponder, DBA/1 mice rendered unresponsive by GAT in vivo can respond in vitro to GAT-MBSA if exogenous, carrier-primed T cells are added to the cultures. The unresponsiveness was shown to be the result of impaired carrier-specific helper T-cell function in the spleen cells of GAT-primed mice. Spleen cells from GAT-primed mice specifically suppressed the GAT-specific PFC response of spleen cells from normal DBA/1 mice incubated with GAT-MBSA. This suppression was prevented by pretreatment of GAT-primed spleen cells with anti-theta serum plus C or X irradiation. Identification of the suppressor cells as T cells was confirmed by the demonstration that suppressor cells were confined to the fraction of the column-purified lymphocytes which contained theta-positive cells and a few non-Ig-bearing cells. The significance of these data to our understanding of Ir-gene regulation of the immune response is discussed.

Selective roles of thymus-derived lymphocytes in the antibody response. II. Preferential suppression of high-affinity antibody-forming cells by carrier-primed suppressor T cells

Passive transfer of thymocytes and spleen cells from donors primed with keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) caused significant decrease in the average avidity of anti-DNP antibodies produced by direct and indirect PFC in the recipients in both primary and adoptive secondary antibody responses against DNP-KLH. The analysis of the avidity distribution of antibodies produced by plaque-forming cells (PFC) indicated that the observed decrease in the average avidity is primarily due to the selective loss of high avidity subpopulation of PFC leaving low avidity subpopulation relatively unaffected. The degree of suppression in antibody avidity did not correlate with the reduction in the number of PFC, and thus causing the "shift" of avidity distribution of PFC to the low avidity end. These results indicate that the "maturation" of antibody in the T-cell-dependent antibody response is influenced by the carrier-specific suppressor T cells with respect to the emergence and selection of B cells having high affinity receptors for hapten. It is suggested that B cells binding antigen with high affinity receptors would be more easily affected than those with low affinity receptors by specific suppressor T cells which are capable of reacting the carrier portion of the same antigen.