Follicle selection in cattle: dynamics of follicular fluid factors during development of follicle dominance

Molecular mechanisms regulating bovine ovarian follicular selection

Transcription profiling of ovarian follicles. Understanding the mechanisms by which a single follicle is selected for further ovulation is important to control fertility in mammals. However, development of new treatments is limited by our poor understanding of molecular mechanisms regulating follicular selection. Our hypothesis is that genes involved in the control of cell proliferation and apoptosis are differentially regulated during follicular selection. Our objective was to identify these new genes. Bovine follicles were collected and gene expression levels were measured using microarrays. First, follicles were allocated to three groups, according to the time spent from the initiation of follicular wave to surgery (24 H, 36 H, and 48-60 H). Fifty-seven genes are differentially expressed at a false discovery rate of 5%. These genes are involved in the control of lipid metabolism (P-value = 0.0005), cell proliferation (0.007), cell death (0.003), cell morphology (0.003), and immune response (0.003). Follicles were also grouped into four categories, according to the expected time of deviation (early deviation; 8 mm, mid-deviation; 8.5 mm, late deviation; 9 mm, dominant follicles; >or=10 mm). One hundred and twenty eight genes are differentially expressed between these four groups, including genes involved in cell proliferation (0.00002), cell death (0.0006), cell-to-cell signaling (0.003), cell morphology (0.003), lipid metabolism (0.0004), and immune response (0.00007). The expression levels of 10 genes were confirmed using quantitative real time PCR. As expected, we identified new differentially regulated genes involved in the control of cell growth and apoptosis. We also discovered a potential role for immune cells, and in particular macrophages, in follicular selection.

Differentiation of the bovine dominant follicle from the cohort upregulates mRNA expression for new tissue development genes

This study was designed to identify genes that regulate the transition from FSH- to LH-dependent development in the bovine dominant follicle (DF). Serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE) was used to compare the transcriptome of granulosa cells isolated from the most oestrogenic growing cohort follicle (COH), the newly selected DF and its largest subordinate follicle (SF) which is destined for atresia. Follicle diameter, follicular fluid oestradiol (E) and E:progesterone ratio confirmed follicle identity. Results show that there are 93 transcript species differentially expressed in DF granulosa cells, but only 8 of these encode proteins known to be involved in DF development. Most characterised transcripts upregulated in the DF are from tissue development genes that regulate cell differentiation, proliferation, apoptosis, signalling and tissue remodelling. Semiquantitative real-time PCR analysis confirmed seven genes with upregulated (P≤0.05) mRNA expression in DF compared with both COH and SF granulosa cells. Thus, the new genes identified by SAGE and real-time PCR, which show enhanced mRNA expression in the DF, may regulate proliferation (cyclin D2;CCND2), prevention of apoptosis or DNA damage (growth arrest and DNA damage-inducible, β;GADD45B), RNA synthesis (splicing factor, arginine/serine rich 9;SFRS9) and unknown processes associated with enhanced steroidogenesis (ovary-specific acidic protein; DQ004742) in granulosa cells of DF at the onset of LH-dependent development. Further studies are required to show whether the expression of identified genes is dysregulated when abnormalities occur during DF selection or subsequent development.

Vascularity and expression of angiogenic factors in bovine dominant follicles of the first follicular wave1

To determine the relationships among vascularity, expression of angiogenic factors, and selected intrafollicular factors in dominant and nondominant follicles of the first follicular wave, ovaries were obtained on d 3 of the estrous cycle from mature cross-bred beef heifers (n = 8) after a synchronized estrus. Follicular fluid (FF) was collected from all follicles > or = 3 mm for determination of estradiol-17beta (E), progesterone (P4), vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), and IGFBP concentrations. The ovaries were then perfusion-fixed and used for histochemical detection of lectin BS-1 (a marker of endothelial cells and thus vascularization) binding, and immunolocalization of VEGF, endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS), and proliferating cell nuclear antigen, followed by image analysis of selected follicles. Follicles were classified, based on E and P4 concentrations in FF, as dominant, estrogen-active (EA; E:P4 > or = 1) or nondominant, estrogen-inactive (EI; E:P4 <1). Concentrations of E and VEGF in FF, the area of positive staining for lectin BS-1, VEGF, and eNOS, and the labeling index (an index of the percentage of cells proliferating) in granulosa and theca layers were greater (P < 0.05) in the EA than in the EI follicles, but concentrations of P4 and IGFBP in FF were less (P < 0.05) in EA than in EI follicles. In addition, vascularity was positively correlated (P < 0.05) with VEGF and eNOS protein expression, and tended (P < 0.1) to be positively correlated with the E:P4 ratio in FF but tended (P < 0.1) to be negatively correlated with IGFBP and P4 concentrations in FF. These data highlight the importance of vascularity, angiogenic factors, and IGFBP in the health of the dominant follicle in heifers, and indicate that the FF concentrations of E, VEGF, IGFBP, and P4, and the E:P4 ratio can be used as markers of dominant follicles.

Expression of activin pathway genes in granulosa cells of dominant and subordinate bovine follicles

We examined the association between the expression profiles of genes of the activin signalling pathway and ovarian follicular dominance in cattle. In monovular species such as cattle, one ovarian follicle of a cohort is selected to become dominant, whereas all others (i.e. the subordinate follicles) eventually succumb to apoptosis. We showed that Inhibin-betaA, coding for the betaA chain found in the A isoforms of activin, Inh-alpha coding for the inhibin-specific alpha chain, and the activin antagonist follistatin were expressed at higher levels in dominant follicle granulosa cells from Day 3.5 (ovulation=Day 0). Before selection, Inh-betaA but not Inh-alpha was significantly correlated with potential dominant follicles, as defined by high aromatase expression and follicular fluid estrogen concentrations. Follistatin expression marked the largest follicles at Day 1.5, but displayed large variation in levels among cows. The third inhibin gene, Inh-betaB, could only be detected at very low levels from Day 7 and thus was unlikely to play a prominent role in activin/inhibin signalling in cattle during these stages. There was a decrease in activin tone (P=0.07) specifically in the aromatase-high/dominant follicles, as measured by the ratio of Inh-betaA to Inh-alpha plus follistatin transcripts between Days 1.5 and 7. Messenger RNA for both activin type II receptors and the nuclear effector Smad2 were detected in granulosa cells, consistent with an autocrine role for activin signalling. Additionally, expression of the putative activin target genes Smad2 and FSHreceptor were, respectively, either strongly (P<0.001) or weakly (P=0.09) associated with dominant follicles.

Follicle selection in cattle and horses: role of intrafollicular factors

The eminent event in follicle selection during a follicular wave in monovular species is diameter deviation, wherein one follicle continues to grow (developing dominant) and other follicles (subordinates) begin to regress. In cattle, the IGF system, oestradiol and LH receptors are involved in the intrafollicular events initiating deviation as indicated by the following: (1) concentrations of free IGF-I and oestradiol in the follicular fluid and number of LH receptors in the follicular wall increase more dramatically in the future dominant follicle than in the future subordinate follicles before the beginning of deviation and (2) ablation of the largest follicle (LF) or injection of recombinant human IGF (rhIGF)-I into the second LF at the expected beginning of deviation increases the concentrations of oestradiol in second LF before the expected beginning of deviation between second LF and third LF. In horses, an increase in free IGF-I, oestradiol, inhibin-A and activin-A is greater in the future dominant follicle than in other follicles before the beginning of deviation. However, free IGF-I is the only one of these four factors needed for the initiation of deviation in horses as indicated by the following: (1) ablation of LF at the expected beginning of deviation increases the concentrations of free IGF-I in second LF before the beginning of deviation between second LF and third LF but does not increase the other factors; (2) injection of rhIGF-I into second LF at the expected beginning of deviation causes second LF to continue to grow and become a codominant follicle and (3) injection of IGF-binding protein-3 into LF at the expected beginning of deviation causes LF to regress and second LF to become dominant. Thus, the dramatic changes in the IGF system in LF compared to other follicles before the beginning of deviation play a crucial role in the events that lead to the beginning of diameter deviation in both cattle and horses. Oestradiol and LH receptors also play a role in cattle. These intrafollicular events prepare the selected follicle for the decreasing availability of FSH and increasing availability of LH. The other follicles of the wave have the same future capability but do not have adequate time to attain a similar preparatory stage.

Evidence of a local negative role for cocaine and amphetamine regulated transcript (CART), inhibins and low molecular weight insulin like growth factor binding proteins in regulation of granulosa cell estradiol production during follicular waves in cattle

The ability of ovarian follicles to produce large amounts of estradiol is a hallmark of follicle health status. Estradiol producing capacity is lost in ovarian follicles before morphological signs of atresia. A prominent wave like pattern of growth of antral follicles is characteristic of monotocous species such as cattle, horses and humans. While our knowledge of the role of pituitary gonadotropins in support of antral follicle growth and development is well established, the intrinsic factors that suppress estradiol production and may help promote atresia during follicular waves are not well understood. Numerous growth factors and cytokines have been reported to suppress granulosa cell estradiol production in vitro, but the association of expression of many such factors in vivo with follicle health status and their physiological significance are not clear. The purpose of this review is to discuss the in vivo and in vitro evidence supporting a local physiological role for cocaine and amphetamine regulated transcript, inhibins and low molecular weight insulin like growth factor binding proteins in negative regulation of granulosa cell estradiol production, with emphasis on evidence from the bovine model system.

Histological Characteristics and Steroid Concentration of Ovarian Follicles at Different Stages of Development in Pregnant and Non-pregnant Dairy Cows

The aim of the study was to investigate the histological characteristics and steroid concentrations in follicular fluid of different populations of follicles at different stages of development, during pregnancy and the oestrous cycle in cows. Follicles from ovaries collected at a slaughterhouse were allocated into three size categories (small, 2-5.9 mm; medium, 6-13.9 mm; and large, 14-20 mm) in pregnant and non-pregnant cows. Slices were stained with HE and PAS for histological analysis. Follicular fluid was pooled according to size and pregnancy status and estradiol, testosterone and progesterone concentrations in follicular fluid were determined by RIA. Characteristics of healthy follicles did not differ, regardless of follicle size or pregnancy status. Total histological atresia was significantly higher in pregnant cows than in non-pregnant cows (p < 0.05). Estradiol increased and testosterone decreased significantly, while follicles increased in size, in both non-pregnant and pregnant cows (p < 0.05). Nonpregnant cows had the highest estradiol values in follicles of all sizes. Medium and large follicles from pregnant cows showed the lowest testosterone concentration (p < 0.05). Progesterone levels increased with follicle size only in non-pregnant animals. In large follicles, progesterone concentration was significantly higher in non-pregnant cows than in pregnant cows (p < 0.05). Considering steroid concentration and histological findings, most large follicles might be atretic during pregnancy in cattle.

Follicular fluid concentration of transforming growth factor-beta1 is negatively correlated with estradiol and follicle size at the early stage of development of the first-wave cohort of bovine ovarian follicles

The objectives of this study were to characterize the relationship between estradiol and transforming growth factor-beta1(TGF-beta1) concentrations in follicular fluid of growing bovine ovarian follicles, and to examine the effect of TGF-beta1 on FSH-stimulated estradiol secretion in cultured bovine granulosa cells. Follicular fluid was collected from individual follicles >5 mm in diameter by ultrasound-guided transvaginal puncture (n = 12 heifers). Follicles were sampled at four different stages of development of the first post-ovulatory wave during selection of the single dominant follicle. Estradiol, progesterone and total TGF-beta1 were measured in follicular fluid of the three or four largest follicles sampled when the largest follicle (F1) had reached either 6.5, 7.5, 8.5 or 9.5+/-0.5 mm stage of development. There was a significant negative relationship between follicular fluid TGF-beta1 and estradiol concentrations (R2 = 0.44; p < 0.002), and between TGF-beta1 concentrations and follicle diameter (R2 = 0.23; p < 0.01) in cohort follicles at the 6.5 mm stage, but not at any later stage of development of the follicle wave. There was no correlation between progesterone and TGF-beta1 concentrations at any stage. To assess the causal relationship between TGF-beta1 and estradiol, granulosa cells from follicles measuring 2-5 mm at dissection were placed in serum-free culture. TGF-beta1 caused a dose-dependent decrease in FSH-stimulated estradiol secretion (P < 0.001). These findings suggest that TGF-beta1 has an inhibitory effect on estradiol secretion in FSH-stimulated follicles and that a reduction in TGF-beta1 inhibition may be part of the mechanism of selection of a single dominant follicle.

Follicular fluid concentrations of free insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-I during follicular development in mares

The objective of the present study was to evaluate changes in concentrations of free insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-I in follicular fluid (FFL) during follicle development in the mare. Mares (n = 14) were classified as either in the follicular phase (n = 8) or luteal phase (n = 6). Follicles (n = 92) were categorized as small (6-15 mm; n = 54), medium (16-25 mm; n = 23) or large (>25 mm; n = 15) and FFL was collected. Free IGF-I levels in FFL in large follicles of follicular phase mares were greater (P < 0.05) than in large follicles of luteal phase mares and small or medium follicles of luteal and follicular phase mares. Free IGF-I concentrations were greater (P < 0.05) in large follicles of luteal phase mares than small but not medium follicles of luteal phase mares. FFL ratio of estradiol:progesterone paralleled changes in free IGF-I. Free IGF-I concentrations were negatively correlated (P < 0.05) with insulin-like growth factor binding protein (IGFBP)-2, -4 and -5 but not IGFBP-3 levels. In addition, free IGF-I concentrations in FFL were positively correlated (P < 0.01) with FFL estradiol, progesterone, androstenedione, estradiol:progesterone ratio, total IGF-I and total IGF-II. We conclude that increases in intrafollicular levels of bioavailable (free) IGF-I are associated with increased steroidogenesis in developing mare follicles.

Comparison of leptin levels in serum and follicular fluid during the oestrous cycle in cows

Leptin is mainly synthesised in white adipose tissue. Besides its effects on body weight and metabolic homeostasis, leptin also has effects on puberty, sexual maturation and reproduction. In this study the relationship between leptin, IGF-1, oestradiol (E2) and progesterone levels were investigated in serum and follicular fluid from cows. This study included 72 healthy, Brown Swiss cows aged 4-5 years. Samples from the jugular vein and follicular fluids were collected. Phases of the oestrus cycle of cows were classified according to their serum progesterone levels (< 3.18 nmol/l, follicular phase and the others as luteal phase). Follicles were grouped as large (> or = 8 mm) or small (< 8 mm). Leptin, IGF-1, oestradiol and progesterone levels were measured from serum and follicular fluid. Leptin concentrations were found to be significantly higher in luteal-phase follicular fluid of small follicles (P < 0.05). These were classified as atretic follicles. There was a positive correlation between serum and follicular fluid leptin levels in the luteal phase. Serum leptin was found to have a positive correlation with follicular fluid progesterone level (P = 0.01) in the preovulatory follicles. The present study shows that there is a relationship between the concentration of leptin in follicular fluid and atresia in small follicles.

Alterations in follicular IGFBP mRNA expression and follicular fluid IGFBP concentrations during the first follicle wave in beef heifers

The objective was to determine the pattern of IGFBP-2, -3 and -4 gene expression and follicular fluid concentrations of IGFBP-2, -3, -4 and -5 during emergence, selection and dominance of the first follicle wave of the estrous cycle in cattle and during exogenous steroid treatment. Heifers (n = 35) were ovariectomized at 36 (n = 7), 66 (n = 8), 84 (n = 12) and 108 (n = 8) h after the onset of estrus. Heifers in the 84 h ovariectomy group were sub-divided to receive either no treatment (n = 6) or were treated with a progesterone-releasing intravaginal device (n = 6, PRID) and 0.75 mg estradiol benzoate i.m. at the approximate time of ovulation, 30 h post estrus until ovariectomy. Within heifers the four largest follicles recovered following ovariectomy were ranked on size (F1, F2, F3 and F4). At 36 h IGFBP gene expression and follicular fluid IGFBP concentrations were similar in all follicles (F1-F4). Mean diameter of the F1 follicle increased (P < 0.05) between 36 and 84 h with no difference between 84 and 108 h. The F1 follicle had the highest (P < 0.05) concentration of estradiol compared with the F2, F3 and F4 at 84 and 108 h. There was no granulosa cell IGFBP-2 mRNA in F1 follicles at 84 or 108 h. Intrafolliclar IGFBP-2 concentrations were lower (P < 0.05) in the F1 compared with F3 and F4 follicles at 108 h. There was no difference in theca cell IGFBP-4 mRNA expression at 108h, but amounts of follicular fluid IGFBP-4 were lower (P < 0.05) in F1 follicles compared with F3 and F4 follicles at 108 h. IGFBP-3 mRNA was localized in the theca layer of all follicles examined with no difference in expression or follicular fluid concentrations during emergence, selection and dominance of the first follicle wave. IGFBP-5 concentrations were higher (P < 0.05) in follicular fluid of F3 follicles at 108 h compared with the F3 at 36 h. In conclusion follicular dominance was associated with low or decreased follicular fluid concentrations of IGFBP-4 and -5, increased estradiol and differential regulation of IGFBP production.

Influence of different doses of progesterone treatments on ovarian follicle status in beef cows

To determine a dose of progesterone (P4) that allow ovarian follicular wave control, Aberdeen Angus cows were randomly assigned into four groups: T600 (n=5), 600 mg of P4/day; T400 (n=5), 400 mg of P4/day; T200 (n=4), 200mg of P4/day and Control (n=4) (excipient only). Progesterone was injected from day 3 to 9 of estrous cycle. Ultrasonographies and blood sample collections were performed daily from day 2 to 10 and on day 15 of the estrous cycle. Additionally, an ultrasonographic study was conducted on day 13. Progesterone concentrations were different among all groups (P<0.01). The diameter of the dominant follicle was greater for control than for T200, T400 and T600 groups (P<0.01); there was no difference between T200 and T400 (P>0.05), but they had a greater diameter follicle than the T600 group (P<0.01). The growth rate of the dominant follicle between day 3 and 7 of estrous cycle was greater for control group (1.63+/-0.3 mmday(-1)) than for T200 (0.56+/-0.19 mmday(-1), P<0.05), T400 (0.6+/-0.23 mmday(-1), P<0.05) and T600 (0.11+/-0.13 mmday(-1), P<0.01) groups. The mean number of class I follicles (3-4mm) per day for the entire experimental period was less for the control group than for T200 (P<0.05), T400 and T600 (P<0.01) groups (3.7+/-1.3; 5.3+/-1.3; 6.6+/-1.8 and 8.1+/-1.9, respectively). The mean number for the T200 group was less than for T600 (P<0.05) and similar for T400 and T600 groups (P>0.05). The number of class III follicles was greater for control group than for the other groups (P<0.01). T200 and T400 groups had similar numbers of class III follicles (P>0.05) and both had greater numbers of follicles than the T600 group (P<0.05). The diameter of the corpus luteum of the T600 group (15.8+/-1.6 mm) was less than for control (21.0+/-2.5 mm, P<0.01), T200 (19.3+/-2.7 mm, P<0.01) and T400 (20.0+/-2.2 mm) groups (P<0.05). The mean diameter of corpus luteum of T200 was similar to T400 (P>0.05), but different from the control group (P<0.05). In conclusion, the daily intramuscular administration of 200mg or more of progesterone from day 3 to 9 of the estrous cycle indicates that plasma concentrations of progesterone can be used to modify the pattern of follicular development during the follicular wave. From day 5 of the estrous cycle, progesterone concentrations greater than 15 ng/ml (T600 group: 600 mg/day of progesterone from day 3 to 9 of the estrous cycle) inhibit dominant follicle development, increase the class I follicle populations (3-4 mm) and diminish the development of the corpus luteum.

In vivo effects of pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A, activin-A and vascular endothelial growth factor on other follicular-fluid factors during follicle deviation in mares

During a follicular wave in mares, the two largest follicles (F1 and F2) begin to deviate in diameter when F1 is a mean of 22.5 mm. The intrafollicular effects of pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A), IGF-I, activin-A and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) on other follicular-fluid factors during deviation were studied. In four treated groups (n= 7/group), a single dose of one of the four factors was injected into F2 when F1 was ≥20.0 mm (expected beginning of deviation). In a control group (n= 7), F2 was injected with vehicle. One day after treatment, a sample of follicular fluid was taken from F1 and F2 of the control group and from F2 of the treated groups and was assayed for free IGF-I, oestradiol, androstenedione, activin-A, inhibin-A, follistatin and VEGF. In the control group, the means for all end points were significantly greater in F1 than in F2, except that concentrations of androstenedione were lower in F1 than in F2. The treatment effects for F2 were significant as follows: PAPP-A increased the concentrations of free IGF-I, inhibin-A, follistatin and VEGF and decreased the concentrations of androstenedione; IGF-I increased the concentration of inhibin-A and decreased the concentration of androstenedione; activin-A decreased the concentrations of follistatin and androstenedione and increased the diameter of F2; and VEGF increased the concentration of IGF-I and decreased the concentration of androstenedione. These results support the hypotheses that during deviation in mares PAPP-A increases the follicular-fluid concentrations of free IGF-I, follistatin responds to changes in follicular-fluid concentrations of activin-A, and VEGF affects the concentrations of other follicular-fluid factors.

Pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A and insulin-like growth factor binding protein mRNAs in granulosa cells of dominant and subordinate follicles of preovulatory cattle

To determine if (1) levels of pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A) mRNA and insulin-like growth factor binding protein (IGFBP) (-2, -3, -4 and -5) mRNAs differ between the dominant and subordinate follicles during the follicular phase of an estrous cycle, and (2) these differences are associated with differences in follicular fluid (FFL) concentrations of steroids (estradiol, androstenedione, and progesterone), total and free IGF-I, or IGFBPs, estrous cycles of non-lactating Holstein dairy cows (n = 16) were synchronized with two injections of prostaglandin (PGF2 alpha) 11 days apart. Granulosa cells and FFL were collected either 24 h or 48 h after the second injection of PGF2 alpha. FFL from dominant follicles had lower concentrations of progesterone (P < 0.08) and higher concentrations of estradiol (P < 0.05), androstenedione (P < 0.0001), estradiol:progesterone ratio (P < 0.0001), free IGF-I (P < 0.0001), and calculated percentage free IGF-I (P < 0.01) than large subordinate follicles. Levels of IGFBP-2, -4, and -5 in FFL were 3.0- (P < 0.05), 2.4- (P < 0.06), and 3.4-fold (P < 0.05) greater, respectively, in subordinate than in dominant follicles. IGFBP-3, IGFBP-4 and PAPP-A mRNA expression and IGF-II concentration did not differ (P > 0.10) between dominant or subordinate follicles. Levels of IGFBP-2 and -5 mRNA were severalfold greater (P < 0.05) in subordinate than dominant follicles. IGFBP-5 mRNA in granulosa cells decreased (P < 0.05) 62% to 92%, between 24h and 48 h post-PGF2 alpha. We conclude that decreased levels of IGFBP-2 and -5 mRNA in granulosa cells may contribute to the decrease in FFL IGFBP-2 and -5 protein levels of preovulatory dominant follicles, and that changes in granulosa cell IGFBP-3 and -4 mRNA and PAPP-A mRNA levels do not occur during final preovulatory follicular development in cattle.

Differential Blood Flow Changes Between the Future Dominant and Subordinate Follicles Precede Diameter Changes During Follicle Selection in Mares1

Diameter deviation during a follicular wave is characterized by the continued growth of the developing dominant follicle and reduced growth and regression of the subordinate follicles. This study considered the hypothesis that reduced blood flow in the future largest subordinate follicle precedes the beginning of diameter deviation. The hypothesis was tested by quantifying the daily changes in blood-flow velocities and blood-flow area within the wall of follicles before and during diameter deviation in mares (n = 7). The blood-flow end points were quantified daily by transrectal color Doppler ultrasonography. Follicles were identified retrospectively by rank as F1 (largest) and F2 according to the maximum attained diameter. Follicles were grouped into nine F1 diameter ranges of 3.0 mm each (equivalent to 1 day's growth) centered on 6.5, 9.5, 12.5, 15.5, 18.5, 21.5, 24.5, 27.5, and 30.5 mm. Diameter deviation began in the 24.5-mm group, as indicated by a smaller (P < 0.05) difference between F1 and F2 in the 24.5-mm group than in the 27.5-mm group. Based on a similar approach, peak systolic velocity and time-averaged maximum velocity of blood flow began to deviate between F1 and F2 in the 18.5-mm group (P < 0.04) and blood flow area began to deviate in the 21.5-mm group (P < 0.009). Thus, differential blood flow area between F1 and F2 began an average of 3.0 mm (equivalent to 1 day) and differential blood-flow velocities began an average of 6.0 mm before the beginning of diameter deviation. The results demonstrated that deviation between F1 and F2 in the blood flow of the follicle walls occurred 1 or 2 days before deviation in follicle diameter during follicle selection in mares.

Follicular development: the role of the follicular microenvironment in selection of the dominant follicle

The importance of endocrine signals in the regulation of follicular development has long been recognized. However, the follicular microenvironment also plays a critical role in determining follicular fate. This review summarizes our studies on the role of the intrafollicular IGF system in selection of the dominant follicle (DF) in cattle. During the bovine estrous cycle, the largest antral follicles develop in two or three successive waves of follicular recruitment and selection of a DF. High concentrations of estradiol in the follicular fluid are the hallmark of dominant and preovulatory follicles and are associated with lower concentrations of low molecular weight (MW) insulin-like growth factor binding proteins (IGFBP-2, -4, and -5), which can prevent binding of IGF to its receptor. Our studies have shown that dominant and preovulatory follicles also have much higher levels of an IGFBP-4/-5 protease activity, which is the bovine equivalent of the human IGFBP-4 protease, pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A). Studies of follicles isolated just after the emergence of the DF showed that PAPP-A is present in the follicular fluid of the DF as soon as it can be detected as morphologically dominant. To examine whether higher levels of PAPP-A in one follicle of the cohort (the future DF) precedes morphological dominance, the four largest follicles were isolated from pairs of bovine ovaries obtained before one follicle of the cohort was significantly larger the others, around the time that one follicle was first detected as morphologically dominant and after dominance was well established. Analysis of the temporal sequence of changes in estradiol, low MW IGFBPs, free IGF, and PAPP-A in the follicular fluid suggested that an increase in PAPP-A is the earliest biochemical difference yet detected in the future DF and that follicular selection is the result of a progressive series of changes beginning with the acquisition of PAPP-A, which leads to a decrease in IGFBP-4 and -5 and an increase in free IGF, which synergizes with FSH to increase estradiol production. Co-dominant follicles, induced by injection of small doses of recombinant bovine (rb) FSH, both had levels of PAPP-A similar to the single DF of control heifers, supporting the hypothesized role of FSH in the induction of PAPP-A in the DF. Taken together, these results suggest a critical role for FSH-induced PAPP-A, and thus for free IGF, in the selection of the DF. In contrast, other experiments provided evidence for a deleterious effect of IGF on the initiation of bovine follicular growth and the survival of primordial and primary follicles in vitro. These results underscore the importance of the follicular microenvironment in determining follicular fate and indicate that its effects can be stage-specific.

Proteolytic Degradation of Insulin-Like Growth Factor Binding Proteins by Ovarian Follicles: A Control Mechanism for Selection of Dominant Follicles1

This review summarizes evidence for the role of proteolytic enzymes that degrade and inactivate insulin-like growth factor binding proteins (IGFBP) during follicular development in mammals. In some species (e.g., bovine), evidence indicates that decreases in IGFBP-4 and -5 levels in estrogen-dominant preovulatory follicles are likely due, in part, to increased protease activity, whereas lower levels of IGFBP-2 are not due to increased proteolysis. Increased IGFBP-4 and -5 protease along with lower amounts of IGFBP-4 binding activity and greater amounts of free IGF-I are some of the earliest developmental changes documented in bovine growing antral follicles. This protease activity has recently been ascribed to serine metalloprotease(s), including pregnancy-associated plasma protein-A (PAPP-A), which was first detected in human follicular fluid nearly 20 yr ago. Other recent studies verified the presence of PAPP-A mRNA in granulosa cells of humans, monkeys, cattle, mice, and pigs. Increases in the amount of PAPP-A mRNA in granulosa cells during follicular development occurs in some but not all species, indicating that other proteases or protease inhibitors may be involved in IGFBP degradation. Whether the hormonal control of PAPP-A production/activity by the ovary differs between monotocous and polytocous animals will require further study. These protease-induced decreases in IGFBP-4 and -5 likely cause increased levels of bioavailable (or free) IGFs that stimulate steroidogenesis and mitogenesis in developing dominant follicles, which ultimately prepare the follicle(s) and oocyte(s) for successful ovulation and fertilization.

In vivo effects of an intrafollicular injection of insulin-like growth factor 1 on the mechanism of follicle deviation in heifers and mares

In cattle and mares, free insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1) is higher in the future dominant follicle (F1) than in the future largest subordinate follicle (F2) before deviation in diameter or selection is manifested between the two follicles. The effect of IGF-1 on other follicular-fluid factors and on the destiny of F2 were studied in two experiments in each species, using a total of 40 heifers and 42 mares. An injection of IGF-1 was made into F2 at the expected beginning of deviation (heifers, F1 >or= 8.5 mm; mares, F1 >or= 20.0 mm; Hour 0). In heifers, follicular fluid was taken from F2 at Hours 3, 6, 12, or 24; each heifer was sampled only once. In mares, sequential F2 samples were taken from each mare at Hours 0, 6, and 24 or at Hours 12 and 24. Transvaginal ultrasound guidance was used for treatment and sample collection. In heifers, IGF-1 treatment of F2 stimulated the secretion of estradiol (P < 0.05) between Hours 3 and 6 and androstenedione (P < 0.05) between Hours 3 and 12. In F2 of control heifers, estradiol decreased (P < 0.05) and androstenedione did not change significantly. In mares, IGF-1 treatment of F2 did not affect the concentrations of estradiol during the 24-h posttreatment period; androstenedione decreased (P < 0.04) in the IGF-1 group and increased (P < 0.006) in the controls. Compared with control mares, the IGF-1 group had higher (P < 0.04) activin-A at Hours 12 and 24 and higher (P < 0.0006) inhibin-A at Hour 24. After ablating F1 at Hour 24 in mares, F2 became dominant and ovulated in more mares (P < 0.0002) in the IGF-1 group (12/14) than in the control group (2/14). These results are consistent with reported temporal relationships among follicular factors during deviation in both species and indicate that IGF-1 plays a key role in controlling the temporal relationships; however, no indication was found that IGF-1 stimulated estradiol production in mares during the 24 h after treatment.

Mechanism of follicle deviation in monovular farm species

Diameter deviation is a distinctive change in growth rates among the follicles of a wave, heralding the formation of a dominant follicle and subordinate follicles. When the follicles are about 5mm in cattle and 13 mm in horses, the wave-stimulating FSH surge reaches peak concentrations. Follicle and FSH manipulation studies in both species have shown that the declining portion of the surge before the beginning of deviation is a function of multiple growing follicles that require the decreasing FSH. During this time, all follicles of the wave have the potential for future dominance. Deviation begins when the two largest follicles on average are 8.5 and 7.7 mm in cattle and 22.5 and 19.0 mm in horses or about 3 days after the FSH peak in both species. The FSH/follicle relationship is close so that a change in one event soon causes a detectable change in the other. Thus, the difference in diameter between the two largest follicles at the beginning of deviation is compatible with rapid establishment of the destiny of the two follicles before the second-largest follicle can also show dominance. The deviation mechanism is initiated when FSH concentrations are low and the most advanced follicle reaches a specific developmental stage. In cattle, the future dominant follicle develops greater LH-receptor expression than the other follicles about 8 h before the beginning of diameter deviation. Estradiol and free IGF-1 begin to establish higher concentrations in the future dominant follicle than in other follicles and activin-A is transiently elevated in both follicles a few hours before the beginning of diameter deviation. In horses, estradiol, free IGF-1, activin-A, and inhibin-A begin to increase differentially in the future dominant follicle about 1 day before deviation. These changes underlie a greater responsiveness to LH and FSH by the developing dominant follicle than for other follicles, thereby accounting for deviation. Results of in vitro studies, although frequently done in other species, support this conclusion.

Calculated follicle deviation using segmented regression for modeling diameter differences in cattle

Segmented linear regression alone or in combination with simple linear regression was evaluated as an objective method to calculate the beginning of follicle deviation by modeling the sequential (Experiment 1) and non-sequential or single-point (Experiment 2) differences in diameter between the future dominant (F1) and largest subordinate (F2) follicles of Wave 1 in cattle. The segmented regression consisted of Segment 1 representing the common growth phase, Segment 2 representing the period of dominance, and a Join Point connecting the two segments and representing the end of the common growth phase and the beginning of deviation. The model was fit to the diameter differences for each heifer in Experiment 1 (n=15) and the group of heifers in Experiment 2 (n=40). The optimal Join Point value that corresponded to the maximum R(2) was designated the calculated hour (Experiment 1) or diameter of F1 (Experiment 2) at the beginning of deviation. In Experiment 1, simple linear regression was used to calculate the corresponding diameter of F1 at the beginning of deviation. Observed deviation was determined by inspection of the diameter profiles of F1 and F2 for comparison to calculated deviation. In Experiment 1, the observed method determined the beginning of deviation in 80% of the heifers, whereas, the regression method calculated deviation in 93% of the heifers including two of the three heifers in which observed deviation was not discernable (no significant difference between methods). The mean hours of deviation after wave emergence (Hour 0) and diameters of F1 at the corresponding hours were not significantly different between the observed (62 h and 8.4 mm) and calculated (61 h and 8.8 mm) methods. In Experiment 2, the diameter of F1 at the beginning of calculated deviation was 8.2 mm. The results indicated that the segmented regression model can provide an objective and more accurate alternative to estimate follicle deviation, especially when observed deviation is obscured by the complexity of follicle development in some waves.

Plasma concentrations of inhibin a and follicle-stimulating hormone differ between cows with two or three waves of ovarian follicular development in a single estrous cycle

Patterns of ovarian follicle development were monitored daily in Holstein-Friesian cows that had two (n = 4) or three (n = 4) waves of ovarian follicle development during a single estrous cycle. The plasma from daily blood samples was used in assays for inhibin A, FSH, progesterone, and estradiol-17beta. Mean cycle lengths for cows with two and three waves were 21.8 and 25.3 days, respectively (P < 0.02). Although the average number of follicles >3-mm diameter on each pair of ovaries was similar for two- and three-wave cows on Days 2, 3, and 4 (Day 0 = day of ovulation; 8.6 vs. 9.6 follicles), there were more follicles >6-mm diameter on the ovaries of cows with two waves on Days 3 and 4. This difference was associated with a shorter interval from wave emergence to peak concentrations of inhibin A during the first wave in two-wave cows (2.0 vs. 3.8 days; P = 0.03) and with higher peak concentrations (474 vs. 332 pg/ml; P = 0.03). Differences in peak FSH concentrations were not significant (1.7 vs. 1.3 ng/ml; P = 0.10) and were inversely related to inhibin A concentrations. The peak concentrations of inhibin A and FSH in the second nonovulatory wave in the three-wave cows were similar to the low concentrations measured in the first wave (292 vs. 332 pg/ml of inhibin A, 1.3 vs. 1.3 ng/ml of FSH; P > 0.20). Average peak concentrations of inhibin A and FSH were similar during the ovulatory wave for cows with either two or three waves in a cycle (432 vs. 464 pg/ml of inhibin A, 2.3 vs. 2.1 ng/ml of FSH; P > 0.3). The lower concentrations of FSH during the emergence of the first follicular wave in cows with three-wave cycles may have reduced the rate of development of some of the follicles and reduced the concentrations of inhibin A. This pattern of lower concentrations of FSH and inhibin A was repeated in the second nonovulatory wave but not in the ovulatory wave. Subtle differences in the concentrations of these two hormones may underlie the mechanism that influences the number of waves of ovarian follicle development that occur during the bovine estrous cycle.

Associated and independent comparisons between the two largest follicles preceding follicle deviation in cattle

Follicle diameters and concentrations of follicular fluid factors were studied in the two largest follicles (F1 and F2) using F1 diameters in increments of 0.2 mm (equivalent to 4 h intervals) and extending from 7.4 to 8.4 mm (12 heifers in each of 6 groups). Changes were compared between follicles using the F2 associated with each F1-diameter group. Diameter deviation began in the 8.2-mm group as indicated by a greater (P < 0.05) diameter difference between F1 and F2 in the 8.4-mm group than in the 8.2-mm group. In the 8.0-mm group, estradiol concentrations began to increase (P < 0.05) differentially in F1 versus F2, and free insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) began to decrease differentially in F2 (P < 0.06). Combined for F1 and the associated F2, activin-A concentrations increased (P < 0.05) between the 7.6- and 8.2-mm groups and then decreased (P < 0.05). Results supported the hypothesis that estradiol and free IGF-1 concentrations simultaneously become higher in F1 than in the associated F2 by the beginning of diameter deviation. Results did not support the hypothesis that a transient elevation in activin-A is present in F1 but not in the associated F2 at the beginning of the estradiol and IGF-1 changes; instead, a mean transient elevation in activin-A occurred at this time only when data for the two follicles were combined. Comparisons between F1 and F2 also were made by independently grouping F2 and using diameter groups at 0.2-mm increments for F2 as well as for F1. In the diameter groups common to F1 and F2 (7.4, 7.6, 7.8, and 8.0 mm) there was a group effect (P < 0.003) for estradiol involving an increase (P < 0.05) beginning at the 7.6-mm group averaged over F1 and F2. For free IGF-1 concentrations, a fluctuation (a significant increase followed by a significant decrease) occurred independently in F1 between the 7.4- to 7.8-mm groups and independently in F2 between the 7.0- to 7.4-mm groups.

Follicle and endocrine dynamics during experimental follicle deviation in mares

Deviation during a follicular wave in mares begins when the largest follicle (F1) reaches a mean diameter of 22.5 mm and is characterized by continued growth of F1 to become the dominant follicle and regression of F2 to become the largest subordinate follicle. In the present study, F1 was ablated at the expected beginning of deviation (Hour 0) to provide a reference point for characterizing the intrafollicular changes preceding experimental deviation between F2 and F3. Diameters and concentrations of follicular fluid factors in F2 and F3 were determined in F1-ablated mares at Hours 0, 12, 24, 48, or 72 (n = 8 mares/group). Circulating FSH concentrations were greater (P < 0.05) in the Hour 72 ablation group than in controls 12 h after ablation and then progressively decreased. The diameters of F2 and F3 increased (P < 0.05) during Hours 0 to 24. Thereafter, F2 continued to increase but F3 did not, indicating that experimental deviation began at Hour 24. The diameter of F2 and circulating FSH concentration at Hour 24 were similar (P > 0.1) to the diameter of F1 and FSH concentration at Hour 0, respectively. A differential change between F2 and F3 was not detected in follicular fluid concentrations of estradiol, inhibin-A, and activin-A by the beginning of experimental deviation. However, estradiol was higher in F2 at Hours 0 and 12 and inhibin-A was higher in F2 throughout the experiment, and both factors could have been involved in experimental deviation. Free insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) increased (P < 0.05) in F2 beginning at Hour 12 and was higher (P < 0.05) in F2 than in F3 by the beginning of experimental deviation. Temporally, this result indicated that intrafollicular IGF-1 was involved in conversion of F2 from a destined subordinate follicle to a dominant follicle.

Activin A, estradiol, and free insulin-like growth factor I in follicular fluid preceding the experimental assumption of follicle dominance in cattle

In cattle, the two largest follicles of a wave (F1, F2) begin to deviate into a dominant follicle and a subordinate follicle when F1 is a mean of 8.5 mm in diameter. After the beginning of deviation, F1 and F2 are diameter-defined dominant and subordinate follicles. Changes associated with the conversion of F2 into a future dominant follicle were studied by ablating F1 at the expected beginning of deviation (F1, 8.5 mm; Hour 0) and assessing the follicular-fluid factors in F2. Follicles were designated F1C and F2C in controls and F2A in F1-ablated heifers. Follicular-fluid collections were made at Hours 0, 4, 8, or 12 (n = 7 heifers per hour; fluid from F1C, F2C, and F2A; experiment 1) or at Hours 4, 6, 8, 10, or 12 (n = 9 heifers per hour; fluid from F2A; experiment 2). Postablation concentrations of circulating FSH increased (P < 0.05) between Hours 2 and 6. Diameter of F2A increased (P < 0.05) after Hour 8 in both experiments so that the diameter of F2A at Hours 10 or 12 was not different (P > 0.1) from the diameter of F1 at Hour 0. A transient elevation (P < 0.05) in follicular-fluid activin A occurred in F2A at Hour 8 in both experiments. Concentrations of estradiol (P < 0.05) and insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I; P < 0.1) decreased in F2C by Hour 8. In F2A, the concentrations of both factors began to increase (P < 0.05) after Hours 4 or 8 so that there was no difference (P > 0.1) between F1C and F2A at Hour 12. Concentrations of IGF-I and IGF binding protein 2 (IGFBP-2) in F2A changed in opposite directions at the same hours. No differences between follicles were found for concentrations of progesterone, androstenedione, inhibin A, and inhibin B. The order of events in the conversion of a future subordinate follicle to a future dominant follicle was an increase in systemic FSH, a transient elevation in follicular-fluid activin A, and a simultaneous increase in follicular-fluid estradiol and restoration of an apparent growth-compatible balance of free IGF-I and IGFBP-2.

Changes in concentrations of follicular fluid factors during follicle selection in mares

The temporal relationships in the changes in concentrations of follicular fluid factors during follicle selection were characterized in mares. All follicles > or =5 mm were ablated 10 days after ovulation, followed by follicular fluid collection from the three largest follicles (F1, F2, and F3) when F1 of the new wave reached a diameter of 8.0-11.9, 12.0-15.9, 16.0-19.9, 20.0-23.9, 24.0-27.9, or 28.0-31.9 mm (n = 4-8 mares/range). Diameter deviation between F1 and F2 began during the 20.0- to 23.9-mm range, as indicated by a greater difference in diameter between the two follicles at the 24.0- to 27.9-mm range than at the 20.0- to 23.9-mm range. Androstenedione concentrations increased in F1, F2, and F3 between the 16.0- to 19.9- and 20.0- to 23.9-mm ranges. In contrast, estradiol, free insulin-like growth factor (IGF)-1, activin-A, and inhibin-A concentrations increased only in F1 beginning at the 16.0- to 19.9-mm range. As a result, the concentrations of all four factors were higher in F1 than in F2 and F3 at all the later ranges, including the 20.0- to 23.9-mm range (beginning of diameter deviation). Concentrations of progesterone differentially increased in F1, concentrations of androstenedione and IGF-binding protein (IGFBP)-2 increased only in F2 and F3, and concentrations of inhibin-B differentially decreased in F2 and F3 simultaneous with the beginning of deviation. Concentrations of FSH, LH, pro-alphaC inhibin, and total inhibin did not change differentially among follicles. Results indicated that, on a temporal basis, estradiol, free IGF-1, activin-A, and inhibin-A may have played a role in the initiation of follicle deviation. In addition, these four factors as well as progesterone, androstenedione, IGFBP-2, and inhibin-B may have been involved in the subsequent differential development of the follicles.