Acute single photon emission computed tomographic study of vagus nerve stimulation in refractory epilepsy

Acute vagus nerve stimulation using different pulse widths produces varying brain effects

BACKGROUND

Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) is an approved treatment for epilepsy and has been investigated in clinical trials of depression. Little is known about the relationship of VNS parameters to brain function. Using the interleaved VNS /functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) technique, we tested whether variations of VNS pulse width (PW) would produce different immediate brain activation in a manner consistent with single neuron PW studies.

METHODS

Twelve adult patients with major depression, treated with VNS, underwent three consecutive VNS/fMRI scans, each randomly using one of three PWs (130 micros, 250 micros, or 500 micros). The data were analyzed with SPM2.

RESULTS

Global activations induced by PWs 250 and 500 were both significantly greater than that induced by PW 130 but not significantly different from each other. For global deactivation, PWs 130 and 250 were both significantly greater than PW 500 but not significantly different from each other. Regional similarities and differences were also seen with the various PWs.

CONCLUSIONS

The data confirm our hypothesis that VNS at PW 500 globally produces no more activation than does PW 250, and PW 130 is insufficient for activation of some regions. These data suggest that PW is an important variable in producing VNS brain effects.

Brain stimulation for epilepsy

Neural stimulation is a promising new technology for the treatment of medically-intractable seizures. Vagus-nerve stimulation (VNS) is licensed in several countries as an adjunctive therapy. VNS is as effective as antiepileptic drug therapy, and serious complications are rare. Transcranial magnetic stimulation is simple, non-invasive, and widely used in neurophysiology. Therapeutic results in a few studies are equivocal at best. Deep brain stimulation, although experimental, has been applied to the cerebellum, caudate nucleus, centromedian thalamus, anterior thalamus, subthalamus, hippocampus, and neocortical seizure foci. Preliminary results are encouraging, but not conclusive. Electrode implantation in the brain for indications other than seizures has been associated with a 5% risk for intracranial haemorrhage and 5% for infection. A controlled study of anterior thalamic stimulation in patients with intractable partial and secondarily generalised seizures has been started. Future investigations are likely to study extrathalamic sites of stimulation, and effects of stimulation contingent upon detection of or prediction of EEG patterns of epileptiform activity.

Vagus nerve stimulation: mood and cognitive effects

Many antiepileptic medications modulate affective and cognitive functions. In keeping with these observations, a growing body of literature suggests that vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) may have similar effects. This review evaluates the published evidence for VNS-associated changes in mood and cognition in patients with neuropsychiatric disorders.

A review of functional neuroimaging studies of vagus nerve stimulation (VNS)

Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) is a new method for preventing and treating seizures, and shows promise as a potential new antidepressant. The mechanisms of action of VNS are still unknown, although the afferent direct and secondary connections of the vagus nerve are well established and are the most likely route of VNS brain effects. Over the past several years, many groups have used functional brain imaging to better understand VNS effects on the brain. Since these studies differ somewhat in their methodologies, findings and conclusions, at first glance, this literature may appear inconsistent. Although disagreement exists regarding the specific locations and the direction of brain activation, the differences across studies are largely due to different methods, and the results are not entirely inconsistent. We provide an overview of these functional imaging studies of VNS. PET (positron emission tomography) and SPECT (single photon emission computed tomography) studies have implicated several brain areas affected by VNS, without being able to define the key structures consistently and immediately activated by VNS. BOLD (blood oxygen level dependent) fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imaging), with its relatively high spatio-temporal resolution, performed during VNS, can reveal the location and level of the brain's immediate response to VNS. As a whole, these studies demonstrate that VNS causes immediate and longer-term changes in brain regions with vagus innervations and which have been implicated in neuropsychiatric disorders. These include the thalamus, cerebellum, orbitofrontal cortex, limbic system, hypothalamus, and medulla. Functional neuroimaging studies have the potential to provide greater insight into the brain circuitry behind the activity of VNS.

Therapeutics in pediatric epilepsy, Part 2: Epilepsy surgery and vagus nerve stimulation

When antiepileptic drugs fail to relieve seizures adequately in children and adolescents, more invasive therapies such as epilepsy surgery and an implanted device to stimulate the vagus nerve should be considered. Temporal lobectomy is an effective treatment of complex partial and secondarily generalized tonic-clonic seizures arising in the mesial structures or lateral temporal neocortex. Excellent outcomes (seizure free or rare, nondisabling seizures) are achieved in at least 70% of children. The most common adverse effect is a superior quadrant field cut that is usually asymptomatic. Transient and more long-lasting language difficulties have been reported when the surgery involves the dominant temporal lobe. The excellent outcome rate for extratemporal surgery ranges from approximately 20% to 80%, with better results seen in patients with an identifiable lesion. Potential morbidity is related to the region of resected neocortex. Corpus callosotomy is an excellent procedure for palliation but is not a cure for seizures that cause falls, with substantial improvement seen in more than 80% of patients. Potential adverse effects include more intense focal seizures and dysphasia, depending on the developmental level of the individual. Hemispherectomy provides seizure relief in 60% to 80% of patients with hemispherical pathologies such as Sturge-Weber or Rasmussen syndromes. Operative mortality has been reported in the range of 0% to 6%; other morbidities include infection and hydrocephalus. Stimulation of the vagus nerve has reduced partial seizures by 50% or more in approximately one third of patients. No adverse cognitive or systemic effects are associated with use of the implanted vagus nerve stimulator.

Effect of vagal nerve stimulation on patients with bitemporal epilepsy

Patients with bitemporal epilepsy are characterized by the existence of independent bitemporal seizure onset zones. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of chronic vagal nerve stimulation (VNS) on eight patients with bitemporal epilepsy. We demonstrated the gradually increased effect of VNS on the reduction of seizures as compared with baseline seizure frequency in patients with bitemporal epilepsy. The average seizure reduction increased from 4.2% at the 3-month follow-up visit to 18.2, 34.4 and 42.2% at the 6, 12 and 18-month follow-up visits. Similarly, a >or=50% reduction of complex partial seizures was reported at the 3-month follow-up visit in no patients (0%); at the 6-month follow-up visit in one patient (12.5%); at the 12-month follow-up visit in three patients (37.5%); and at the 18-month follow-up visit in five patients (62.5%). These data demonstrate the positive and long-lasting effect of VNS on seizure reduction in patients with intractable bitemporal epilepsy. The main mechanism of this chronic effect is not fully understood.

Vagus nerve stimulation in awake rats reduces formalin-induced nociceptive behaviour and fos-immunoreactivity in trigeminal nucleus caudalis

Besides its well-established efficacy in epilepsy, vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) may be of potential interest in pain treatment. It has, however, not yet been assessed in animal pain models with the devices and stimulation protocols used in humans. We have therefore studied in awake rats the effects of left cervical VNS on trigeminal nociception using an implantable electrode and stimulator (NCP-Cyberonics). VNS was applied for 24h at 2 mA intensity, 20 Hz frequency, 0.5 ms pulse width and a duty cycle of 20s ON/18s OFF. As a nociceptive stimulus, we injected formalin into the left mystacial vibrissae, assessed behaviour for 45 min and sacrificed the animals 45 min later. Fos-immunoreactive (Fos-Ir) neurons were counted in laminae I-II of trigeminal nucleus caudalis (TNC) on both sides. We used three groups of control animals: VNS without formalin, formalin without VNS and sham VNS (implanted without stimulation or formalin). Whereas sham VNS had no significant effect, VNS alone increased Fos expression in ipsilateral TNC in addition to the expected increase in nucleus tractus solitarius. It also significantly attenuated the increase of Fos-Ir neurons observed in ipsilateral TNC laminae I-II after formalin injection. If the proper VNS effect on Fos-expression was subtracted, the reduction of formalin-induced nociceptor activation was 55%. VNS also reduced nociceptive behaviour on average by 96.1% during the early phase (0-6 min) and by 60.7% during the late phase (6-45 min) after the formalin injection. These results suggest that VNS applied with a device used in human therapy may have in awake rats a significant antinociceptive effect in a model of trigeminal pain.

Effect of vagal nerve stimulation on interictal epileptiform discharges: a scalp EEG study

PURPOSE

To investigate the effects of acute vagal nerve stimulation (VNS) on interictal epileptiform discharges (IEDs).

METHODS

Fifteen epilepsy patients, all of whom had been treated with VNS for > or =6 months, entered the study. In each subject, the absolute number of IEDs was counted at the baseline period (BP), the stimulation period (SP), six interstimulation periods (IPs), and the prestimulation period (PP), by using an original paradigm. The number of IEDs at the BP and the PP was compared with the number of IEDs at the SP and IPs. The results were correlated with other variables (the duration of VNS, the value of the output current, the duration of epilepsy, the type of epilepsy, the effect of VNS, and the effect of extrastimulation).

RESULTS

We observed a significantly higher reduction in the number of IEDs in the SP and all the IPs as compared with the BP. We noticed a significantly higher reduction in the number of IEDs in the SP and in the first IP as compared with the PP. The reduction of IEDs was greater in patients who responded to VNS (>50% reduction of all seizures) and in patients who responded positively to magnetic extrastimulation. There were no other significant results in the reduction of IEDs when comparing other variables.

CONCLUSIONS

Short-term VNS reduces IEDs significantly. The reduction is most prominent during the SP (i.e., when the pulse generator is active). The value of reduction of IEDs is higher in patients who respond to VNS and in patients with positive experiences with magnetic extrastimulation. These results can be useful in predicting the effect of VNS.

Novel physical treatments for the management of neuropsychiatric disorders

OBJECTIVE

To briefly describe the novel non-drug physical interventions currently in use in the investigation and treatment of neuropsychiatric disorders regarding their efficacy and potential future applications.

METHODS

A systematic review of the literature concerning transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), deep brain stimulation (DBS), vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) and neurosurgery for mental disorders (NMD) was conducted using Medline and literature known to the authors.

RESULTS

A summary of each procedure is provided giving a succinct overview of efficacy, current applications and possible future indications.

CONCLUSION

Novel and innovative physical interventions are currently being used to study brain function in health and disease. In particular, TMS has quickly established itself as a useful investigational tool and is emerging as a possible antidepressant therapy. Similarly, VNS has been applied successfully in the management of intractable epilepsy and is undergoing evaluation in the management of patients with treatment-resistant depression. DBS has shown significant promise in the treatment of Parkinson's disease and may have use in the management of obsessive-compulsive disorder. Finally, neurosurgical procedures for the treatment of mental disorders have been sufficiently refined to stage a comeback, although rigorous scientific study of their efficacy and indications is still necessary.

Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) synchronized BOLD fMRI suggests that VNS in depressed adults has frequency/dose dependent effects

Stimulation of the vagus nerve in the neck can reduce seizures in epilepsy patients, and may be helpful in treating depression. PET studies have shown that vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) in epilepsy patients causes acute dose (intensity) dependent changes in regional cerebral blood flow. We sought to use the newly developed VNS synchronized fMRI technique to examine whether VNS BOLD signal changes depend on the frequency of stimulation. Six adults with recurrent depression were scanned inside a 1.5 T MR scanner. Data were acquired at rest, with the VNS device on for 7 s, and also, for comparison, while the patient listened to a tone for 7 s. In two separate back-to-back sessions, the VNS stimulation frequency was set to either 5 or 20 Hz. Data were transformed into Talairach space and then compared by condition. Compared to 5 Hz, 20 Hz VNS produced more acute activity changes from rest in regions similar to our initial VNS synchronized fMRI feasibility study in depression. Brain regions activated by hearing a tone were also greater when VNS was intermittently being applied at 20 Hz than at 5 Hz. In depressed adults, left cervical VNS causes regional brain activity changes that depend on the frequency of stimulation or total dose, or both. In addition to the acute immediate effects of VNS on regional brain activity, this study suggests further that VNS at different frequencies likely has frequency or dose dependent modulatory effects on other brain activities (e.g. hearing a tone).

fMRI in patients implanted with a vagal nerve stimulator

OBJECTIVE

To demonstrate the feasibility and safety of using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to determine the blood oxygen level dependent changes (BOLD) in patients undergoing vagal nerve stimulation (VNS) for the treatment of epilepsy.

METHODS

Four patients with an implanted vagus nerve stimulator had fMRI images acquired during several cycles of intermittent VNS. Blood oxygen level dependent changes were detected. These regions were then superimposed upon the patients' structural MR images.

RESULTS

Patients undergoing VNS tolerated fMRI without difficulty. No complications with the implanted stimulators were encountered. Areas of activation were noted in several cortical regions, including frontal, temporal, parietal, and occipital cortices.

CONCLUSION

Our study in four patients shows fMRI can be performed safely in patients with an implanted vagal nerve stimulator. The successful use of fMRI during VNS offers potential advantages over PET imaging by allowing rapid image acquisition and the ability to repeatedly study patients over time. Our preliminary results differ from previous PET or SPECT studies in failing to detect changes in subcortical areas. This finding could be due to the smaller n in this study compared with the other studies.

Vagus nerve stimulation: where are we?

Now nearly 5 years post-approval, vagus nerve stimulation has emerged as a major non-pharmacological treatment for epilepsy. The place of vagus nerve stimulation among antiepileptic drugs and other surgical therapies is still evolving. This review evaluates the role of vagus nerve stimulation in light of recently published research of its mechanism(s) of action, long-term efficacy, safety and tolerability, and application to other disorders besides epilepsy.

Vagus nerve stimulation in pediatric epilepsy: a review

Therapeutic options for intractable epilepsy include new and investigational antiepileptic drugs, ketogenic diet, epilepsy surgery, and, now, vagus nerve stimulation, which is approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration for the treatment of refractory partial seizures in adolescents and adults. The exact mechanisms of action are unknown. Although the use of vagus nerve stimulation in children has increased, including those younger than 12 years of age or those with generalized epilepsy, there has been no large controlled pediatric study to date. The identification of favorable prognostic indicators, especially in children, would be useful. Preliminary results suggest that children with Lennox-Gastaut syndrome may have a favorable response, with improvement in both seizure control and global evaluation scores. Improved global evaluation scores have occurred even without an associated improvement in seizure control.

Vagus nerve stimulation for refractory epilepsy

Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) is a neurophysiological treatment for patients with medically or surgically refractory epilepsy. Since the first human implant in 1989, more than 10 000 patients have been treated with VNS. Two randomized controlled studies have shown a statistically significant decrease in seizure frequency during a 12-week treatment period versus a baseline period when 'high stimulation' mode was compared with 'low stimulation' mode. The efficacy appears to increase over time. In general, one third of the patients show a >50% reduction of seizure frequency; one third show a 30-50% seizure reduction, and one third of patients show no response. Few patients become seizure-free. Side effects during stimulation are mainly voice alteration, coughing, throat paraesthesia and discomfort. When studied on a long-term basis, VNS is an efficacious, safe and cost-effective treatment not only in adults but also in children and the elderly. The precise mechanism of action remains to be elucidated. In recent years much progress has been made through neurophysiological, neuroanatomical, neurochemical and cerebral blood flow studies in animals and patients treated with VNS. Further elucidation of the mechanism of action of VNS may increase its clinical efficacy and our general understanding of some physiopathological aspects of epilepsy. Finally, VNS may become an alternative treatment for other conditions such as depression and pain.

The mechanism of action of vagus nerve stimulation for refractory epilepsy: the current status

Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) is a neurophysiologic treatment for patients with medically or surgically refractory epilepsy. Since the first human implant in 1989, more than 10,000 patients have been treated with VNS. The precise mechanism of action remains to be elucidated. Animal experiments with VNS were initially performed to demonstrate efficacy and safety preceding the clinical trials in human patients. Mechanism of action research involving animal experiments can provide essential clues. Animal experiments are often labor-intensive even in the hands of experienced researchers, however, and the results remain only a reflection of the complicated pathophysiologic systems of the human brain. Mechanism of action research in human patients treated with VNS is particularly challenging because of safety concerns, the large number of patients required, and the heterogeneous nature of various small patient series. This study provides an overview of the progress that has been made in the past 10 years through neurophysiologic, neuroanatomic, neurochemical, and cerebral blood flow studies in animals and patients treated with VNS. Further elucidation of the mechanism of action of VNS may increase its clinical efficacy. It may also provide inspiration for the development of new therapeutic modalities for refractory epilepsy.

Feasibility of vagus nerve stimulation-synchronized blood oxygenation level-dependent functional MRI

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Left cervical vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) by use of an implanted neurocybernetic prosthesis (NCP) system is effective in treating epilepsy, with open data suggesting effectiveness in depression, yet the mechanisms of action are unknown. Our objective was to develop a methodology for performing VNS-synchronized functional magnetic resonance imaging (VNS-fMRI) and then to demonstrate its feasibility for studying VNS effects.

METHODS

In nine patients implanted for treatment of intractable depression, a Macintosh computer was used to detect the signal from the implanted VNS stimulator and then to synchronize fMRI image acquisition with its regular firing.

RESULTS

With our VNS-fMRI methodology, the blood oxygenation level-dependent response to VNS was shown in brain regions regulated by the vagus nerve: orbitofrontal and parieto-occipital cortex bilaterally, left temporal cortex, the hypothalamus, and the left amygdala.

CONCLUSIONS

Vagus nerve stimulation pulses from an NCP system can be detected externally to determine its firing pattern, thus allowing VNS-fMRI studies of VNS-induced brain activity.